9 ms·
It's easy to forget on HN, but there is far from universal buy-in for the notion that having or collecting data on people is unethical. Some may even consider i
by closeparen 10y ago
It's easy to forget on HN, but there is far from universal buy-in for the notion that having or collecting data on people is unethical. Some may even consider it noble to optimize and perfect the world and its institutions (including commerce, via efficient advertising) using large-scale personal data.
The impulse to make something better by applying a database engine that you might feel for business processes, can just as easily be felt for customer interactions or the world at large.
For an interesting (and very critical) look at this philosophy I recommend The Circle by Dave Eggers.
- api 10y agoSurveillance could indeed have many beneficial uses in a benevolent, voluntarist sort of society. Unfortunately we don't live there. The world is still largely run by warlords, narcissists, and sociopaths.
- closeparen 10y agoThe "standard" counterargument here is that warlords, narcissists, and sociopaths can only operate effectively in private, and their capabilities would be severely limited in a world where secrets are hard to keep.
- playeren 10y agoI understand you don't necessarily buy into that argument, but allow me to offer a counter-counter. That argument relies on the collected data being closer to the truth, than the absence of it. I think that may be true for (statistically) normal people. But for narcissists and sociopaths, it may also be a helpful tool for someone creating a fake alter ego of benevolence and 'harmlessness'.
- scalio 10y agoWhy would the warlords, narcissists and sociopaths get rid of their own privacy? Zuckerberg seems very keen on preserving his...
- ForrestN 10y agoThe problem is misleading the public about the nature of the information gathered and the shady ways that the information is sometimes used. If Facebook were only gathering information necessary to improve the experience of its users, and were not selling that information or lying about it, I don't think you'd see the same backlash.
- onewaystreet 10y ago> If Facebook were only gathering information necessary to improve the experience of its users, and were not selling that information or lying about it, I don't think you'd see the same backlash. Facebook doesn't sell information, it sells ads. That's not the same thing.
- underdown 10y agoThey sell ads by offering this information in the form of targeting.
- majormajor 10y agoI've worked at an ad-serving company. Clients couldn't get our data out, it's behind the scenes to them. Business-wise, it would be undermining our own product to offer anyone's personal information. There are other companies that do this focusing just on the collection side, which sounds like what FB is buying - but for FB to protect their position they're going to try to keep lids on that. The companies that try to sell those types of profiles, by IP or cookie syncing or whatever, seemed to get it wildly, wildly wrong - but the role of accuracy/auditing in the ads business is another discussion. FB seems to be buying a different sort of data than we were, since they know so much more (first/last/birthdate, etc). Anyway, this is a problem that doesn't start or stop with FB, and the brokers are the dangerous part.
- Fnoord 10y agoStarting a database with personal information on a large amount of personae. Without them knowing about it. Refusing to share the gathered information. All of this is legal in the US? In the EU???
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoThe problem I have with it is that Facebook decides what "improve" means -- it tries to groom me like cattle rather than ask me how I want to experience it or who I want to be "optimized" in to being. And that's okay, so far as they're open about it. But I don't think they are, especially the sophistication of their psychology research (and experimentation).
- maverick_iceman 10y agoIf you don't like Facebook, don't use Facebook.
- csydas 10y agoI think the problem rests more on the fact that as it stands Facebook profits regardless as to whether or not you use it. The same collection happens across numerous non-Facebook sites and apps, from data other people reveal about you, from apps and companies that are bought up by Facebook, and so on. The idea of "if you don't like it just don't use Facebook" becomes very difficult to implement when modern existence feeds into Facebook it seems. It's the involuntary participation in facebook's arrangement that people are bothered by.
- harry8 10y agoNot an option. They have a shadow profile about you anyway. Aside from that this is as silly as "If you don't like organized crime don't buy stuff from the mafia and there's no problem."
- nihonde 10y agoActually, if you don't like Facebook, litter it with disinformation until it becomes an unreliable and undesirable source.
- FabHK 10y ago> If you don't like Facebook, don't use Facebook. And don't use any site with the Facebook "Like" thumbs-up thingy, which is tracking what sites you visit.
- billjings 10y agoIt may be good, but it's not democratic.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoSeconded. I would gladly hand over my personal data if it means improved FB/search experience. I think there's a large number of people who share my viewpoint. If someone is concerned about protecting their online privacy they have the option of not using those services. (I know about trackers on third-party websites. It's pretty trivial to block them.)
- wheelerwj 10y agomostly agreed. i would be okay of 1) the data never left facebook, 2) i had access to all the data, and 3) conversation content and contact data was specifically excluded.
- lis 10y agoSo how do I prevent my friends from uploading my phone number when they share their contacts? What do I do when they take pictures at a party and upload them? Should I have to jump out of view every time somebody takes a phone out of their pocket? Give only "trusted people" my phone number?
- Karunamon 10y agoYou don't, and can't. Not beyond perhaps choosing better friends. Information about you is not necessarily owned by you.
- kayoone 10y agoIt's not even just unethical, it's also illegal in many places. Facebook (and Google and many others) are constantly violating European privacy laws and hide behind the Irish government who protects them against the rest of the EU. As an example, in Germany, data privacy is a basic human right and in theory things like the FB Like Button or Google Analytics just collecting data in the background without a user knowing is illegal. In theory, any site using Social Plugins/Google Analytics would need users to opt-into the data collection, but of course nobody does this and going against FB/Google for these kinds of things is near impossible right now. See http://europe-v-facebook.org/ http://europe-v-facebook.org/ for more information and examples. The current EU data privacy guideline will be replaced by a regulation in 2018 and Safe Harbor has just been replaced by Privacy Shield for EU->US data transfer, but it will probably not change much. Compared to the EU, in the US data privacy is hardly existent but people seem to accept it. edit This is not even touching on the fact that all the data these US companies mine of European citizens is also accessible by the NSA in one form or another (no, Privacy Shield does not effectively prevent this) and the implications that arise from this.
- tripzilch 10y ago> in Germany, data privacy is a basic human right This! Seriously, there's moral relativism and there's squabbling whether a human right "would be nice to have". They/we don't call it a human right lightly. It's to shine a spotlight on something very important that people otherwise don't realise. > This is not even touching on the fact that all the data these US companies mine of European citizens is also accessible by the NSA Well in a way, it does. Total surveillance by governments that openly admit you have zero rights in their eyes (as do their citizens, by the way, many times, even on HN ...) is one of the many terrible implications of the existence of these databases.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoMost likely simply don't think about it in enough depth to form a view either way. Collecting data to make the app make connections better is the "acceptable" view. The artificial bubbling is probably widely known - as it's recently hit mainstream thanks to all the fake news. The implications and other uses and data transfers are not talked, or often known about. Just like when you look into food production or global supply chains you find many inconvenient truths there too. As age is so often correlated with cynicism it's probable that many tech applicants (to FB or anywhere) are simply not adequately cynical yet. There's quite a few cases of high profile techies suddenly and surprisingly (well according to reportage anyway :) becoming rather anti. btw I thought The Circle far too gentle, and simplistic, about the criticism. Perhaps it's the "cynical Brit" perspective as I felt very much the same about Black Mirror after arrival at Netflix.
- wiz21c 10y agoIt's not because one doesn't think it's unethical that it is ethical. The very existence of the question implies that there is an ethical issue here. Moreover, in the age of information, the one who knows more about the other becomes a potential predator (every country has secret services and spies). Facebook (and others) knows a lot more about me than I do myself because their computers don't forget, because they analyze what I do in a way I don't. Moreover Facebook can be tied to other companies or institutions with my consent. So although the optimization might seem like a good idea, I think it also needs to be put in context. Is this really a good idea. Is optimizing advertisement a noble goal ? It's useful for the advertisers, true. But is it useful for their targets ?
- walterstucco 10y agoyes it's always unethical. even more if you don't ask me or hide the fact that you're doing it. it's only acceptable if it is for public research.
- lithos 10y agoThe US doesn't have the privacy parts is WWII in memory. Where govt workers had to scramble to destroy what data they could before it was seized, where fire fighters let document storage burn as long as possible because it had census data, where others where forced to go through govt. Data to sentence neighbors to death, and similar hero/horror stories. I feel that the IT world is irresponsible in its collection of data, and doesn't treat it as the liability it is. (What's the proper word for old data/information before computers)?
- drunken-serval 10y ago> I feel that the IT world is irresponsible in its collection of data, and doesn't treat it as the liability it is. A lot of that is due to a lack of training. There's two major ways new people come into programming. 1. Go to college, get a computer science or engineering degree. 2. Self taught. Neither of those prepares you to deal with the ethics of information storage. I happened to have an entire course on the topic but only because I took an Information Science minor with my Computer Science major. That course wasn't even an optional elective for me otherwise. A computer science degree trains you for thinking how to do something. It doesn't teach you how to figure if you should do something.
- pluma 10y agoYou can be lucky if a college education in CS/SE teaches you about open source licensing, even more so if it deals with privacy in any way. IMO every SE curriculum should contain a mandatory course looking into historical precedents how information was used in genocides and oppressive regimes (Nazi Germany and the German Democratic Republic are two of the most obvious examples but there are plenty others). It's ridiculous how it took Trump to get elected for the liberal techies in my Twitter stream to realise that the US government has the power to do really bad things with all the data FB & friends have been collecting.
- clydethefrog 10y agoWhat literature did the course provide? I would like to teach myself more too. The lack of any so far in my programme is making me really pessimistic.
- deliridude 10y agoIn the end, it all boils down to persons and personalities, and most important uglyness and shortcomings. Part of their surface pretends to think it's noble, their real self know how they are inside, they live with themselves 24/7, and they know it's the shriek of a ghoul scrambling away from the light. They want a glove to interact with the world, not because the world is dirty, but because they are, and cannot face themselves. So we will make them for them.
- j_s 10y agoThe Circle is due to be released as a movie in April. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4287320 http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4287320
- austinhutch 10y agolmao the mental olympics needed to arrive at the conclusion "data collection to improve advertising efficiency" is noble.
- 0xfeba 10y agoReminds me of one of the recorded AOL customer service calls from someone trying to end service. AOL: Hi, this is John at AOL. How may I help you today? Ferrari: I want to cancel my account. AOL: OK. I mean, is there a problem with the software itself? Ferrari: No. I don't use it. I don't need it. I don't want it. John disputes Ferrari's claim that he never uses the account. AOL: Last year, last month it was 545 hours of usage. Ferrari: I don't know how to make it any clearer. So I'm just gonna say it one last time. Cancel the account. AOL: Well, explain to me what is wrong. Ferrari: I'm not explaining anything to you. Cancel the account. It goes on like this for 5 minutes. Ferrari: Cancel my account. Cancel the account. Cancel the account. From: http://www.nbcnews.com/id/13447232/ns/business-cnbc_tv/t/how-hard-can-it-be-cancel-aol-account/ http://www.nbcnews.com/id/13447232/ns/business-cnbc_tv/t/how... IIRC, from the audio the AOL rep. just goes on about how he's "just there to help you". To me, this is the same. "We just want to give you the best advertising that is relevant to you!" So possibly these people just take them at face value. Which is usually a bad idea when there's a profit motive.
- amelius 10y ago> Some may even consider it noble to optimize and perfect the world and its institutions (including commerce, via efficient advertising) using large-scale personal data. That's all great, but how can I opt-out? Even without a facebook account, they are collecting my data.
- ninkendo 10y agoThe Circle was an interesting idea wrapped in a really terrible book. Every page was full of terribly-paced plot development, one dimensional characters and cliched rip-offs of 1984.
- xg15 10y ago> Some may even consider it noble to optimize and perfect the world and its institutions (including commerce, via efficient advertising) using large-scale personal data. Data they don't own. So I suppose, "noble" in the Robin Hood kind of way. Also, "efficient" in what way? What metric do they optimize that lets advertising benefit society?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fnl 10y agoAbout twenty years ago we probably surpassed Orwell's 1984. Until ten years ago, the secret services of the world's governments would have done just about anything to get this kind of personal data. Five years ago, Facebook & co (twenti in Spain, vkontake in Russia, etc.) started to convince people to hand that info over for free. Today people are saying that somehow improves their lives, or that they have "nothing to hide". What do you think will happen when, in a few decades in the future, your personal, detailed history ends up in the hands of a government that is rattled by debt, ever increasing poverty and unemployment, and political instability, in a world much like in the 1930s? Not that that scenario must happen, but it can, given today's outlook, and history tends to repeat itself...