19 ms·
Percentage of Young Americans Living with Parents Rises to 75-Year High
- _RPM 10y agoI am 26 and just graduated college 3 years behind my high school class. I have accepted a software engineering job, but will be living at home commuting 3 hours per day until I can save up enough for an emergency fund to be able to move out and afford a 12 month lease in case I get fired. I'm planning on getting my own place in the beginning of Q2, 2017. Unfortunately, I'm a little behind salary wise.
- weisser 10y agoNo judgment either way but >50% of the people I know cannot afford a full year's lease out of their savings.
- _RPM 10y agoThat's fine. I just think it's a good idea to have that fund in case I get fired, company closes (startup, series B), etc.
- closeparen 10y agoIf your parents are willing to let you live with them, why not just save the cost of exiting your lease (mine is 1 month's rent) and U-Hauling your stuff back home? Or would you not be able to go back once you left?
- _RPM 10y agoMy parents tell me I can stay at home forever. I'm not sure about this type of contract. Is it common to have a clause that allows you to "exit the lease"? If so, how would I go forward with asking the people about this without seeming high risk?
- closeparen 10y agoThe lease should specify a fee, large enough to deter you from walking away for a slightly better deal, but (generally) smaller than paying rent for the remaining months. Giving the required notice (mine is 30 days) and paying the fee lets you terminate the lease early while still fulfilling your legal obligations. It's there primarily for people who need to move because of work, and usually the employer who is relocating them would reimburse it. So, you could probably ask something like, "what if I get transferred to a different office before 12 months is up?" That will signal some risk that the landlord will have to find a new tenant. My landlord is a REIT, and I live in a large complex with 2 full-time leasing agents onsite, so finding new tenants is not a huge burden for them - they're fine with high turnover. A mom-and-pop landlord might be skittish about that possibility. But it is still better than "what if I can't pay rent because I am unemployed?" Definitely don't ask that :).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- beachstartup 10y ago> If so, how would I go forward with asking the people about this without seeming high risk? to a business owner/landlord, asking how much it costs to exit the lease does not mark you as high risk. it just means you know what you're talking about, and they are free to set that value to whatever they want in the contract.
- nicobn 10y agoI think you're doing the right thing. The first step towards financial independence is building a reasonable emergency fund. The peace of mind is liberating.
- rokhayakebe 10y agoKeep this up as long as you can if it does not affect your social life (girlfriend/boyfriend). There is nothing like money in the bank.
- morgante 10y ago3 hours a day is a huge amount of time and commute time is one of the biggest, easily changeable factors of happiness. Nobody in a software engineering job should have to live with parents for financial reasons. I appreciate OP's dedication, but they should be able to save up an emergency fund pretty quickly and move into their own (small) apartment.
- _RPM 10y ago3 hours per day is going to kill me. I did it over the summer for an internship, and just plan to save for 3 months until I have a solid base to add to my savings account. I'm targeting a solid 9-10 months of emergency fund. If I moved out right now, I could afford the first and last month of rent, but would not have that much left in my bank account. And for the record, a reason I want to move out is so I can start to build my own life with a woman in my life. I can't do this at my parents place. I love my parents, but at 26 it is time for me to be on my own.
- morgante 10y agoIt's a great plan and good luck. If you're interested in saving for the longer term, I recommend checking out r/financialindependence.
- rokhayakebe 10y ago+1 if you move in with this woman and keep saving.
- ryandrake 10y agoDon't worry. I commute 4 hours a day. You get used to it. You have to live where you can afford, man.
- notyourwork 10y agoCost of tuition continually grows, most graduates are not falling into extremely lucrative salaries and average salaries are not keeping up with inflation. This is far from surprising but is very concerning. Another avenue to pursue this discussion from is the % of income allocated to retirement savings. I have a sneaky suspicious most of my peers are saving less for retirement than the same demographic 10, 20, 30 years ago. What happens in a few decades when all these adults who lived with their parents and hardly saved for retirement due to lower salaries and student loans are too old to work? It seems our tax dollars will be supporting them and this looks like a big problem. Curious what others think or if I am looking at this problem from the wrong perspective.
- malandrew 10y agoThe problem already goes beyond millennials. Increasing automation is going to make unskilled labor a huge liability for countries. This is one reason I don't think some of the anti-immigrant position of many Americans (and Europeans) is unwarranted. Every country should want highly skilled labor to help improve their current account, but unskilled labor is huge future liability. There is already a huge surplus of domestic unskilled labor in developed countries. Allowing unskilled labor to increase through immigration is only going to exacerbate the problem.
- maxerickson 10y agoIf there's literally no work to do, you can meet the material demands of the problem by turning more machines on. (meanwhile lots of the US runs on cheap labor)
- jquery 10y agoThere is work to do, though. Doctors, lawyers, engineering, etc. Lots of work for skilled labor. You can't just "turn on more machines" to placate unemployed unskilled labor.
- astronautjones 10y ago
- danm07 10y agoI think one of the other reasons is that parents this day and age are more liberal minded than previous generations. I remember talking to my mom and dad about this. When they left the nest, their parents held very strict conservative view, and were often very opinionated in how their sons and daughters should conduct their lives. Nowadays there's not much to rebel against, especially among the educated class.
- Fraterkes 10y agoThis seems like a pretty big deal, parents and kids listening to a lot of the same music, watching the same kind of television/series. Its interesting, many parents actually expect their kids to rebel nowadays, because they themselves did, but this expectation is of course counter to the whole idea of rebelling.
- analog31 10y agoI've got two kids in high school. Among all of the ways to support them after college if necessary, having them live at home may be the most economical. Fortunately, they're pleasant to hang around with.
- hn_user2 10y agoRising rents and harder to get home loans do sound like the primary cause. That being said, I also believe there is not quite the same urgency to leave home for current young adults. Just from personal observation they don't necessarily see increasing their expenses just to be more independent as worthwhile. Same goes with getting a driver license and a car. I don't think it's necessarily being lazy, I think they might rightly see that building up all these expenses just to be independent is a bit overkill. Mix this with people in general getting married later and I find it quite natural that more people are living at home.
- YokoZar 10y agoAnd the cause of rising rents and harder to get loans is a rise in home prices. Yet when we hear news reports about rising housing costs, we say that the housing market is "recovering" as though it's somehow a good thing. Perhaps we should rethink our nationwide policies of raising housing costs.
- jackcosgrove 10y agoWe have policies that favor home owners because, 1) older people are more likely to own homes and they vote at higher rates, and 2) politicians love property tax revenue. If you don't vote and you don't fill their coffers, you're invisible to politicians.
- taurath 10y agoAnd there is a generation of people ready with hammers to knock down that wall of equity so they can afford to live. Right now we're in the negotiating phase. Wait for the right politician.
- codingmyway 10y agoThe occupy movement should have occupied all vacant buildings, a lot of which were effectively owned by banks, and demanded the return of squatters rights. Next time, get it right
- white-flame 10y agoI'm not a millennial, but it makes a heck of a lot of financial sense to live with family. I'm glad that with these shifts, the stigma is falling away. My immediate family has lived through rough times, with lots of "creative" living arrangements. Of course, we should still train general life autonomy, and not promote being able-but-incapable shut-ins, but being able to venture into housing (or back out of it if things go really pear-shaped) should be done flexibly. The family unit as a reciprocating life cushion is a very positive thing to maintain. If you're on the receiving end of this cushion, make sure you're doing your part for your parents and/or extended household, too. I don't care that economists and real estate investors bemoan the shrinking population of those able to buy houses. When times are financially tough, people need to pool together, not overextend themselves. Overall statistics about economic recovery also don't evenly represent all families.
- hkmurakami 10y agoI've heard that in (at least some regions of) Spain, it's perfectly common and acceptable to continue living with their parents well into adulthood. I remember reading that José María Olazábal (one of the best professional golfers in the 90's, with millions of dollars in earnings) was still living with his parents into his early 40's (though to be fair, he was traveling for half the year on tour). I often think that the "move out from home" pressure is a ploy by the real estate industry. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Mar%C3%ADa_Olaz%C3%A1bal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Mar%C3%ADa_Olaz%C3%A...
- niftich 10y agoCulturally, many contemporary societies in Southern Europe -- including places like Italy's boot, Spain, and Greece -- place a strong emphasis on family and don't subscribe as much to the brand of fiercely self-reliant individualism manifested in America that evolved from the 'protestant work ethic'.
- icebraining 10y agoI'd say it's mostly because we're fucking poor. France isn't protestant either, yet they leave the home much earlier. Looking at the map, it seems to correlate pretty strongly with income: http://i.imgur.com/KIPcRbM.png http://i.imgur.com/KIPcRbM.png
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jprzybyl 10y agoYoung Canadian here. Personally, it's just hard to find work, and there's no cheaper place than mom's house. My girlfriend lives with her parents. She has a job, but her family is having a hard time finding work themselves. I'm doing it because it's free, and it's a chance to find a job. If I had a steady job, I'd be out in no time. But goings are tough. I'm saying job a lot. Live in rural Canada and you'll find that job is the magic word. Lots of people do contracting work up here, for welding and scaffolding and that sort of thing. Lots of people have known the experience of working for a month and never seeing the paycheck as the company goes under. There's a lot of fuss about the Cite C dam in British Columbia. I think it will be built, no matter the problems, because it means work for the people building it, and those people are people I know. Jobs jobs jobs. I know this isn't about Canada, and I didn't even read the paywalled article, but I think we're staying home because the economy sucks and there are no jobs.
- aianus 10y agoI've lived at home and I've lived on my own and I'd rather live at home even if the cost was the same. Going home to an empty apartment or roommates that don't care about you is lonely af.
- tayo42 10y agoCant read the article since im not subscribed. Why were so many people living with their parents in 1940 and why did it stop? Does the article explain that?
- vinhboy 10y agoClick on "web" under the article title (in HN). Then you can click on the link in google. It's a built in HN hack...
- tayo42 10y agoheh good to know. thanks
- ProAm 10y agoProbably the great depression and then war.
- tayo42 10y agoNow thanks to the other guy I can read the article. The graph makes it look like were only slightly higher then that the early 1900s where it was consistently higher then the last 70 years and also steady.
- akulbe 10y agoI'm curious... why is this such a bad thing? As a society (an American society, as this isn't true in many other places) we place a rather negative stigma on a person who doesn't leave home at the age of majority (usually 18). This is a norm that I think we should do away with. And by that, I mean we should stop making turning that age the time that we flip the switch and the kids move out. What I would suggest in its place... encourage them to go when they're ready. This places more responsibility on the parents in assisting with all the types of preparation that make one ready for leaving home. There's a LOT more to this conversation, but I figure this is a good starter. :)
- throawaybay 10y agoWell it is an economic thing. It means that jobs and wages don't support independent living. It means that young people don't (or can't) migrate for jobs. It may mean that there aren't enough jobs or they are otherwise unqualified.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- q-base 10y agoFrom a corporate economic standpoint there is a lot to be gained by keeping that stigma. Moving out and starting your own household means buying a lot of stuff. You can't really target the opposite in any meaningful way that gives revenue. And a whole lot of our norms and stigmas are somehow rooted in popular culture and the institutions that benefit from set values.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoIt might surprise people but there is no stigma around adults living with their parents in other places. As if giving a stranger $1.5k+ every month is an indicator of adulthood. Save that money and put it into a retirement or savings account. Unless your job or life situation truly demands having your own space I see no reason to move out.
- kayman 10y agoMoved out to college after highschool, never lived home since. Not everyone who lives at home with their parents are the same and in some cases it does make sense, but from my observations of people who live at home: - No skills on managing self: relies on parents to manage - No financial management skills: using all your money for play money and not contributing to the household. - Can't take a date home: unless you want to introduce your parents right away - ManChild Syndrome: grown kids playing video games and watching tv. - No drive: as long as you have parents, why try. Everything is already provided for you.
- gruez 10y ago>- ManChild Syndrome: grown kids playing video games and watching tv. As opposed to playing golf and watching football games?
- flukus 10y agoI lived at home until my late 20's and your way off on most of those. > No skills on managing self: This was the worst part for me, I wanted and had been self reliant before, but it's hard to do in a shared house. >No financial management skills: using all your money for play money and not contributing to the household. I was paying minimal board (when I was able) and saving for a deposit on a house (which are insanely expensive here), is that irresponsible? >Can't take a date home: unless you want to introduce your parents right away It's not the 1950's anymore. Meeting someones parents is not a big deal. >ManChild Syndrome: grown kids playing video games and watching tv. Problem being? >No drive: as long as you have parents, why try. Everything is already provided for you. Another expense to try and minimize.
- serge2k 10y ago> grown kids playing video games and watching tv. Yeah, those fucking losers! NERRRRRRRRRRRDS.
- stuxnet79 10y ago(1) and (2) make sense to me. They are pretty much the reason why I decided to move out. (3) is irrelevant. Nobody should intentionally hemorrhage themselves financially just to get the opportunity to take dates home without being hassled. Chances are your date probably lives at home too anyway. (4) is uncalled for and completely irrelevant. I game, I watch TV, have a healthy social life and I take care of business. (5) is a very likely outcome as well. Moved out for this reason as well. Could feel the malaise / indifference coming on.
- castratikron 10y agoFor me, the main reason I don't have a house is because I wouldn't have anyone to share it with; finding a partner outside of college while being employed in a field comprised of 97% men is impossible.
- kLeeIsDead 10y agoThis is a pretty bad attitude to have.
- flycaliguy 10y agoThen this might be a great chance to choose one that you like, with the features you prefer, before have to make a compromise with a partner! Keep it nice and cozy and you'll be able to invite women to your house. Seems like a solid game plan.
- kbart 10y ago"finding a partner outside of college while being employed in a field comprised of 97% men is impossible." What? How is that related? I (and most of readers here, I presume) also work in the same field, but I've never dated a girl who I've had any business with or who could write a single line of code. Just go out more often, get some hobbies, travel -- work is not your whole life. Unless you work in China sweatshop 16h/d, 6d/w work-life balance is achievable, it's mostly a mindset.
- siliconc0w 10y agoI'm a millennial - Living with my parents after college allowed me to save a boat load of money which I then invested and now I'm in a comfortable place finally - even looking at early retirement.
- PebblesHD 10y agoNot sure if Australia's current housing situation is analogous to America's one, but one of the primary motivators on our side of the pond is financial. Rents within 60km/35mi of the main Sydney CBD have crossed well over 50% of the average persons wage, at around $700/week. I currently live 45km from Sydney and pay $800/wk for a detached house primarily because I don't want to live in a 1 bedroom box in the city. Unfortunately, for that $800, I get next to no public transport and a local government that doesn't actually do anything useful. If I had the option I would gladly have stayed at home for a few years to start saving for a deposit on a house, which is no easy feat since the national average price is creeping closer to the $1m mark, and the average around major cities is already well over that mark.
- taurath 10y agoI don't understand how politicians don't consider that a crisis. Too many fat happy landlords I suppose.
- girvo 10y agoIt disproportionately affects young people, and they don't really care about young people. So I'm not surprised.
- forthefuture 10y agoIt's more that it only affects poor people, regardless of age, and they really don't care about poor people. Young rich people are doing just fine.
- PebblesHD 10y agoI'd certainly like to believe I'm above the 50th percentile of incomes for my age, and I'm struggling to bring the costs of living to under 75-80% of my take home income. Given many young people aren't as fortunate as even I am I feel like there's a very large portion of the coming generation for whom owning a home will never be a reality.
- trendoid 10y agoAny way to read the article without signing in? Can someone paste useful paragraphs from the article here?
- grzm 10y agoThe "web" link beneath the submission title will bring you to a search page with a link to the actual article, which should get you around the paywall.
- known 10y agoSounds like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikikomori https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikikomori
- blazespin 10y agoCould be a demographic thing. Increasing Asian and Mexican population have stronger cultural ties to family and saving habits? They should Plot it by race. Honestly though, video games and vr. Who needs your own place
- lonesword 10y ago23 year old Indian developer here. The concept of 'moving out' of your parents home is baffling for most of us. I now live in a different city and I share a decent apartment with friends. I can afford to live alone in the apartment I now live in - the rent is 30% of my monthly income and the apartment is 15 minutes away from where I work - but living alone would be just awful. So I'm now paying 11% of my income for rent(electricity, water and a maid included) because I stay with friends. Eventually, most of us would want to move back to our hometowns if we can get a job with similar pay - and live with our parents. Not because it would be cheaper and mom would cook yummy food - but it is just the way it is. In our society, NOT living with your parents when you can is frowned upon. "These are people who raised you and know you well and care for you, why would you want to move out?" is how the society thinks. Also, in a way it is nice. You are NEVER alone. You ALWAYS have people waiting for you when you come back from work. 'Being alone' is seldom a reason for a depressed Indian - the family is always there. However, compared to the west, we have little to no privacy. We are raised to not expect much privacy in the first place so we don't really miss it. Kids do NOT get a room of their own - never ever - they bunk with siblings. I was around 15 when I got a room of my 'own'. There's no pressure to move out once you grow up - parents would do their best to KEEP you home in fact. I would not have had to 'move out' if my college was not 200 km away. There's one big trade off with the whole set up though - no sex till you get married ;)
- ieatkittens 10y ago> Also, in a way it is nice. You are NEVER alone. You ALWAYS have people waiting for you when you come back from work. Glad it works for you, but that has got to be the third circle of my personal hell. > 'Being alone' is seldom a reason for a depressed Indian - the family is always there. That's nice. Some European countries are exactly the opposite. It's my hypothesis that this is the cause for many suicides, despite otherwise stellar living standards.
- gexla 10y ago> Glad it works for you, but that has got to be the third circle of my personal hell. Here, here. Not only do I not live with parents, friends or anyone else. The slowly but steadily losing side of a current raging personal debate in my head is that one day I should share my life with a significant other and perhaps have a family of my own. That idea is on the ropes but I'm not quite ready to close that door completely, but I'm real close to calling the fight and declaring a winner. Further, I have been going longer between replies to messages from friends. If they need to find me, they will know where to go. We can only maintain X number of relationships. I would rather that list include people in my pro network and an inner circle of friends and family. If you can handle being alone. I feel that's a superpower. Though there are many benefits to for sharing your life with an SO. I suppose it's a trade-off.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoThe most natural state is to remain with your family until you form your own family. I have never understood the stigma attached to adult children living at home. Admittedly, this might very well be because I have lived in multiple cultures, most of which don't have this antagonistic "kick them out of the house" relationship between parents and adult kids. The other side of that story is that, yes, if an adult kid has opportunities that might take the kid away from the family home it could make total sense to move out. One example is getting into a really good university on the other side of the country. I personally believe that the family connection is crucially important and it must remain as intact as possible until the adult children are ready to form their own families. There is no better incubator for future good people than a good family life.
- rhapsodic 10y ago> personally believe that the family connection is crucially important and it must remain as intact as possible until the adult children are ready to form their own families. There is no better incubator for future good people than a good family life. I think there's something to be said for living on your own, cooking your own meals, doing your own laundry and housework, paying your own living expenses, and managing your own finances, before taking the plunge into a situation where it's non-optional. (E.g. a marriage.)
- rebootthesystem 10y agoThe things you mention are incompatible with adult children staying at home longer. The secret is to have some of those things be part of normal life from when they are little. Bring the laundry to the washing machine. Help fold it. Help cook Help clean, etc. Not that difficult. The financial side can be introduced initially through games and later on in different ways. It just takes forethought and consistency. And it doesn't have to be punishment but rather part of normal life.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoDamn iOS auto-correct...that was suppose to say "compatible".
- babyrainbow 10y agoGreat. Now let us push it even more.
- ktRolster 10y agoIf there aren't enough houses for everyone, then the people who can't afford to pay as much will be the ones pushed out of the market.
- Dowwie 10y agoThis article is part of a broader spotlight casted upon declining economic opportunities. Raj Chetty and company released a great deal of research about this, which journalists have been slowly summarizing for the public: http://www.equality-of-opportunity.org/ http://www.equality-of-opportunity.org/
- cryoshon 10y agoit's the economy, stupid. americans of generations X and Y got raped out of their money by the looter economy comprised of high-interest big-sum debt, decreasing wages, increasing rent, increasing cost of living, and few jobs. this story gets rehashed every few months (starting from around 2010) as though it's new. it's not new that capitalism has scarred the young. it took me a while to leave my parents after college-- and it was a miserable period that couldn't have elapsed quickly enough. suffice it to say that young americans stay at home due to not being able to afford any alternatives. even living with roommates is expensive if you're in an area that has jobs-- and most areas do not have any jobs, or any well paying jobs. we can't save money to move out, nor buy a house, nor save for retirement, etc, etc. it's been this way for nearly ten years. things have actually gotten worse economically, and we're now overdue for another recession. the "main street" economy is completely divorced from any successes of the "wall st" or finance center economy, yet it suffers their failures even more violently. millenials can't afford to take care of their dying boomer parents... it seems as though they'll grow even poorer while trying, however. millenials can also expect no real return from their investment, as their parents have themselves been hollowed out of wealth by the process of aging. here is a radical statement: seizing the means of production or forcing the downward redistribution of capital is now justified and overdue... the time wasted waiting for a handout from the business owners or the government would be better spent organizing the young to eat the rich.
- cableshaft 10y ago"When the people shall have nothing more to eat, they will eat the rich." ~Jean-Jacques Rousseau "Eat the rich, there's only one thing that they're good for, eat the rich, take one bite now, come back for more." ~Aerosmith
- jgalt212 10y agoZIRP is the reason. Once we get away from ZIRP, interest rate sensitive assets will go down in price, and people will be able to afford housing. They may not be able to afford bread (inflation), but housing will be cheaper.
- pdimitar 10y agoDisclaimer: this is a somewhat personal-nuanced and anecdotal essay, so skip it if you prefer colder facts. You've been warned. ;) Eastern European (Bulgarian) 36-year old programmer here, still living in Sofia (the capital). We don't miss communism and socialism. At all. A good chunk of us around here are competitive and want to demonstrate skills for better money. There are frauds and freeloaders but hell, is there a community where there isn't? I've witnessed the fall of our regime (1989) when I was 9. Later on the fall of the USSR followed. I didn't quite appreciate these events back then but the effect on the standard of living on the other hand was VERY visible. It has been a very gradual process, but our country is bleeding brains, skills and money -- badly, and all the time. Quite frankly I don't think that the EU countries are so much better; what good is a triple salary if your rent and bills are triple the amount as well? The only real benefit I guess is to get a citizenship several years down the line and not be afraid that yet another shady government will appropriate all retirement funds and you'll be left with peanuts when you eventually grow old. My mother lives with me and my girlfriend. Her pension is 60 euros. You read that correctly, it's not a typo. If it wasn't for me, she'd be yet another old woman with eyes full of tears, struggling not to die of cold on the street, and to have a few mouthfuls of bread a day. (Father died a long time ago, back in 2002) We at Eastern Europe are diverse people. We don't frown upon at either situation -- living with or without parents, but for many people living in a bigger flat/house with the family is simply more convenient (my mother's cooking is absolutely fantastic and is easily worth €30 a meal, I am pretty sure of it!) and makes much more sense financially. It is what it is, we can't do much about it. Long story short: I am now in ~ €20,000 debt and the thought of getting a mortgage is making me grind my teeth. As other posters said, we're not even close! My mother and father were working governmental jobs and they had an apartment fully paid for when they were at their ages of 40-42. Had two cars. And that was a backwater communistic/socialistic country, a mere satelite of the USSR. I can't imagine how much better many others had it really. (The fact that I should probably look for a higher paid job since I am in demand is an irony that doesn't escape me, but that's a personal struggle interwoven with many other factors which I won't touch upon here.) The article has struck many nerves in me. It's true not only in the USA.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ihaveahadron 10y agoThe youth today suck. Sorry it's true. This is, partly, a joke. Explanation: The joke is that I am one of the youth. It's only partly a joke, though, because "the youth" besides me and I guess "a few others", really do suck because they are hao 老 and still livings with their parents -- according to the article.
- epalmer 10y agoI have two girls, 24 and 18 years old. Both live at home right now. The 24 year old graduated from a selective private liberal arts college in 2015 and is working part time in a library. She does not qualify for health insurance or many other benefits. She does not make enough to live on her own. She is also in graduate school online for a Master of Library Science (MLS). She wants to be a librarian and you pretty much need an MLS to become a librarian. Her part time income mostly goes just to pay for graduate school. Her sister graduated high school 2016 and is taking a gap year as an AmeriCorp Vista employee working with center city schools on after school STEM programs from FIRST Robotics. She will go to college fall 2017 at Olin College of Engineering. We suspect that the oldest will live with us for many years and her mom and I are fine with that. Expensive liberal arts degrees don't often pay well. I think that situation is going to catch up with liberal arts colleges very soon. I like having her around. She does some chores and provides some company to us. But mostly she stays to herself studying or reading. If you had told me 10 years ago that she would be living with us after college and that we would be okay with that, I would have thought you crazy. Her younger sister will get an engineering degree and we will only see here once and awhile after that. We are okay with that also, though we will miss her so much. We mostly have younger friends so they are not yet at a place where their older children can be living at home.
- FussyZeus 10y agoI don't understand this situation with your daughter: - Wanted to be a librarian - Studied to be a librarian - Graduated school to be a librarian - Got a job as a librarian - Doesn't make enough to live on her own and pay the cost of her education to be a librarian And this isn't isolated to librarians, it's just a very instructive example. How is it we now have entire classes of jobs where the education they require for that job now puts you in such a degree of debt that you have to live off of your parents? We need librarians, no? We want to make sure we still have those? We have to be willing to pay for them.
- knz 10y agoI don't understand why a librarian needs a master's degree? Is it just due to competition for a limited number of positions? Or are there skills gained from post graduate study that are essential to being a librarian?
- chiefalchemist 10y agoI'm going to say a simple X Y plot probably oversimplifies the picture. 1) Parents have been having kids later in life. How many of these are because the child (read: adult offspring) is home to help care of an ill or older parent? 2) As the divorce rate increases homes that were was the right size for a traditional family are now too big for one parent or the other on their own. The kids move back because it's practical for all. 3) Related to 2, the housing market has sucked. Selling for many hasn't been an option. This "enables" yas to stay home longer. The point is, this isn't a YA issue per se. There are plenty of broader social changes that a helping to redefine the American family unit.
- DudeNet 10y agoPlus unlike most guys there is a backup life plan for her. You are lucky that it's not a librarian son!
- pavel_lishin 10y agoWhat's the backup life plan that a librarian son would be ineligible for?
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13236745 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13236745 and marked it off-topic.
- msimpson 10y agoFirst of all, housing in America is a dual income trap. So unless you are comfortable with roommates, have a significant other, or can attain a lucrative salary, you have limited options. Second, renting is for chumps; as you will simply throw money away to the tune of a monthly mortgage payment. Therefore, you should stay where you are (if possible) and save until that down payment can make a worthwhile home affordable with only a single income. It is the only fiscally responsible choice.
- q-base 10y agoRenting also equals freedom. YES you may throw away money in the light of the ability to sell a property at equal or higher price than you payed. BUT you may also end up losing a lot of money or being bound to a property if market changes and prices drop. Renting is a transparent way of knowing the cost of living where you do. In a liquid somewhat stable housing market you probably are better off buying - but just to say that saying renting is for chumps is bit of a simplification in my opinion. P.S. I know the above probably is a bit of topic as even having the ability to choose somewhat implies that you aren't totally struggling financially.
- msimpson 10y ago"Renting also equals freedom." Only if you plan to relocate often. "...you may also end up losing a lot of money or being bound to a property if market changes and prices drop." Which is why making good investments and leveraging refinancing is very important. "...saying renting is for chumps is bit of a simplification..." Yet in most cases, it isn't. Just like leasing a car.
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoThe nuclear family concept was always odd to me anyway. Myself, my wife, and my daughter are building a house with my parents right now. If you can find a good job in the same city, I have trouble understanding why someone wouldn't want to live together. The economies of scale and the benefits of having extra helpers around with our daughter (and 2nd one on the way!), more than outweigh any downsides to us. The psychological impacts to our children of having our grandparents around as positive continual influences seem pretty valuable to us?
- ChicagoBoy11 10y agoAs a foreigner living in the U.S., I have to admit this obsession with leaving your parents house kinda baffles me. I'm from Brazil, and despite nearing my thirties, back home the majority of my friends live with their parents and it is hardly seen as a big deal. I think a big driver of this shift is the fact that in the U.S. it is extremely common for one to leave for college, whereas in Brazil literally 100% of my friends who went to school in the country resided with their parents while they were in school. One of the things that most attract me about the U.S. is the fact that opportunity and mobility is so rampant, and you have people crossing the country for jobs and a different life. That is a superb thing. But what I never, ever understood is seeing young friends of mine who get jobs in their hometowns but who stubbornly "move out" even if they are barely making enough to survive. In terms of lifetime earnings, those few thousand dollars a month that go to a stranger for rent are so, so valuable. Another point this statistic does not take into account is that the current generation of "parents" are also on average better off than their parents were. The prospect of "living with the parents" would have seemed worse for my father than it did for me. I get that there are economic forces "forcing" kids to stay home, but I'm sure there is also a genuine shift in preference as well.
- ebbv 10y agoSpeaking for myself, growing up in the US I couldn't wait to move out of my parents' house and live on my own. My friends were the same way. The reasons having my own place was appealing to me really boil down to independence. Being able to choose where I live, being able to decide my own priorities, not dealing with them being around and pestering me, having peace and quiet when I want it and being able to blast my music that they don't like without being asked to turn it down. Being able to have my friends over. Being able to have girls over. Being able to move in with a girlfriend (which is what I did when I moved out.) I love my parents but I cannot live with them. They annoy me within a few hours of being around them. We don't like the same things. We don't like the same music, the same TV shows, we don't hold similar politics, they are religious and I am an atheist. We just aren't compatible.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ebbv 10y agoThe plural of anecdote is not data but just to give my own experience here; my youngest brother is of this age group and still lives with my parents for no reason other than laziness. He just has no ambition or interest in getting a steady job and moving out to his own place. No interest in finding a romantic partner. He just sits at home and plays video games as he has for his entire life. He has friends doing the same thing. I don't know if this is a real trend or just something I'm seeing but someone should probably study this phenomenon.
- m23khan 10y agoWhat I would like to see happen is for young people to stay with their aging parents even after becoming financially settled and even after marriage. The whole concept of 'moving out' is barbaric to say the least. Old folks who can't fend for themselves in many situations and their old bodies fail them in most basic of tasks such as cleaning house and cooking are then simply shoved into 'old folks house' till they breathe their last. Best if this generation can break this sh!tty concept about 'moving out' - after all, they themselves would become old one day...
- nicolas_t 10y agoI often see that point of view when I discuss with friends in Asia (where living with the parents is much more prevalent). Let me offer an anecdotical counter point. I have a grandmother, she's getting old (85 years old) and things are much harder than they used to be, she no longer can easily go shopping by herself or clean the house. We've asked her multiple times if she wanted to live with us or our aunt, every time she's refused. She wants to stay independent and instead hired a helper who comes everyday for a few hours and helps her with the basic tasks. We often come to visit her but she doesn't want us to stay too long or too often for the same reason. She values her independence. So, yes I see the point about living with aging parents but it's also good not to deny the independence of those same aging parents. The Asian model of staying at home with the parents does have a lot of tradeoffs too. Usually the wife needs to move in with her husband's parents and this is not easy at all for the wife. I've seen a few divorces that were due to conflicts with the in laws (which are much worse when you actually have to live with them). I also have a friend whose parents had a big house and lived together with all their sons and the parents decided to sell that house, buy separate houses for each of their sons and live alone because it was just too much headache for them.
- gravypod 10y agoI'm in the minority here of my generation but I'm 19 and I really would like to get out of my house. Due to some complications with my family it's just my mom and I now and we'll be moving into an apartment soon. I'd like to get out so I can learn about machining and electronics without being told to "stop bringing garbage into my house". Unfortuantly I 1) don't have enough time for a full time job since I'm wasting away my better years and credit in college, and 2) none of my friends want to move out or will be allowed to move out by their parents. Finding a room mate will be tough. I'm going to try... but it'll still be tough. This is extra worse because of how high the rent is here in NJ (even in Paterson, Franklin Lakes, and Newerk where I go to school).
- la6470 10y agoIf this generation has heartedly embraced open office spaces then they should not mind sharing space with their parents either. The corporates had you by your balls and took away many hard earned rifts. Trump is gonna squeeze you now for the last drop of juice. Then and only then you might grow up.