21 ms·
Just to be clear: This service is offered by Amazon/AWS themselves, it isn't a third party. That's a question I had when I first clicked, which is why I am answ
by Someone1234 10y ago
Just to be clear: This service is offered by Amazon/AWS themselves, it isn't a third party. That's a question I had when I first clicked, which is why I am answering it here.
One big "gotcha" for AWS newbies which I cannot tell if this addresses: Does this set or allow the user to set a cost ceiling?
AWS have offered billing alerts since forever. They'll also occasionally refund unexpected expenses (one time thing). But they've never offered a hard "suspend my account" ceiling that a lot of people with limited budgets have asked for.
They claim this is a competitor for Digital Ocean, but with DO what they say they charge is what they actually charge. I'm already seeing looking through the FAQ various ways for this to exceed the supposed monthly charges listed on the homepage (and no way to stop that).
Why even offer a service like this if you cannot GUARANTEE that the $5 they say they charge is all you'll ever get charged? How is this different from AWS if a $5 VPS can cost $50, or $500?
That's what Amazon is missing. People want ironclad guarantees about how much this can cost under any and all circumstances. I'd welcome an account suspend instead of bill shock.
- elevensies 10y agoOn the landing page they say there will be overages for excess data transfer. In terms of how it is different, I think a lot of people here have probably been using AWS for 5+ years and the jargon etc. is familiar, and we can calculate the price and understand what it is, but for people who are just getting started this will be a product that is directly comparable to i.e. Digital Ocean and can serve as a gateway drug to AWS.
- AtheistOfFail 10y agoThat's how they get people on Glacier storage. The storage is cheap as balls but the transfer can fuck you.
- bradyd 10y agoThey changed the way Glacier retrieval costs work a little over a week ago to help address this. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10230937 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10230937
- jknoepfler 10y agoThe whole point is to service customers with massive storage needs who seldom need to retrieve the data. For example, many companies are compelled by regulation to archive records for decades, but only need to access data in response to lawsuits/etc. no one with frequent high volume retrieval needs would be advised to use glacier.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wildpeaks 10y agoExactly, the lack of cost ceiling is the #1 reason I can't pick AWS.
- cpollard0 10y agoThe cost ceiling are the initial resource limits. Maybe you can ask them to lower the limits?
- vacri 10y agoNot for bandwidth, though. That's where AWS gets you. All the complaining of server costs are the AWS of yesteryear - servers are pretty similar in costs to competitors now. But traffic doesn't have any caps that I'm aware of.
- akerl_ 10y agoI don't think that actually holds up. There are certainly some people that want "ironclad guarantees", but the reality of cost here is pretty close: you pay $5/mo max for the server. The things that can cost more are either overages on bandwidth/dns (and here, 1TB of bandwidth on the low end is included, eliminating a lot of the flux from EC2), or things you choose to initiate, like snapshots. It feels like the larger thing they're trying to solve, that I expect actually stops the majority of people who don't choose AWS, is the complexity around setting up VPCs/SecurityGroups/Subnets/etc. Most providers in the VPS space already charge overages for bandwidth, and most of them don't support suspending the account vs just billing you.
- ffk 10y agoI personally don't use AWS for personal projects because of the lack of a cap. I would rather see my system suspended rather than continue to pay beyond my budget.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoThis. I got excited about this until I came to HN and started reading the comments. I _have_ to have a cap. I don't want to do something stupid that puts me on the hook for $$$.
- MustardTiger 10y agoSo who are you using then? I don't see anyone that has a cap. Everyone charges you if you go over your allotted bandwidth.
- ffk 10y agoNot sure if this is still the case. Digital ocean had a pricing structure for bandwidth, but was not charging for that used bandwidth because they did not have a way to show how much bandwidth has been used in a billing cycle. Best to ask them if this is still the case.
- 10y ago
- johnqpub 10y ago>I'd welcome an account suspend instead of bill shock. The big question here is what to do with stateful data. Would you accept an immediate deletion of all of your S3 data? RDS instances and snapshots?
- ceejayoz 10y agoPer the AWS TOS, once Amazon suspends your account for non-payment your data's kept for at least 30 days. No reason they couldn't do the same here.
- Someone1234 10y agoI said suspend, not removal. They could easily cut off public access to those resources while charging you storage fees. Obviously with any kind of ceiling there are certain details that need to be ironed out (i.e. most people wouldn't want configuration information or data to be lost, but they likely would want VPS to be taken offline and other services to be suspended). Ultimately for most startups, small businesses, and individual developers being able to say "My AWS bill cannot exceed $1000, period" is a powerful tool. Right now if a billing alert fires at 1am, you may not see it until 9am and by then you're already in huge trouble.
- dsmithatx 10y agoSNS topics and lambda jobs. Just use the API to add a firewall rule to block traffic when it gets a billing SNS alert. Should be pretty simple to get working.
- gknoy 10y agoThat's still a very striking omission of a feature. Lambda isn't available in all zones, and not everyone has the time/ability/knowledge to set up such a thing. I'm sure I could do it, but only if I were to spend a few hours researching it, and probably a few nights working on such a solution. I'd also have to trust that I didn't mess it up -- I'd hate to have a bunch of traffic and NOT properly prevent the traffic. This is the kind of thing that Amazon surely could provide easily if they wanted to. It's like if your phone company didn't give you an option to limit your spending (prepaid), but said that you could use their arcane API to tell them each month to start/stop service. That's great, but not really very nice to customers.
- prashnts 10y agoAlso, if you have a Static IP attached to the VPS and you first Stop, and then Destroy your instance, you will need to make sure you "free" the IP as well to avoid _small_ 0.005/hr price. From FAQ: > What do Lightsail static IPs cost? > They're free in Lightsail, as long as you are using them! You don't pay for a static IP if it is attached to an instance. Public IPs are a scarce resource and Lightsail is committed to helping to use them efficiently, so we charge a small $0.005/hour fee for static IPs not attached to an instance for more than 1 hour.
- geerlingguy 10y ago> $0.005/hour That's $3.60/month... seems similar to mail-in rebates—many people forget, and accidentally give Amazon some (mostly) free money. Also, from later in this thread: > FWIW, bandwidth overages at Linode and DO are $0.02 per GB, LightSail is $0.09. It's these seemingly-tiny (but not-so-tiny when I'm running 60-70 VPSes) costs that kill when you get your first bill after a large traffic event.
- CaveTech 10y agoIt's not exactly free money because Amazon will surely reserve that IP for your use at any time. By sitting on Static IPs you are using AWS resources. Yes, operationally it costs them nothing, but there is an opportunity cost.
- Domenic_S 10y ago> but there is an opportunity cost Is there?
- lucasmullens 10y agoYes. They could sell the IP address to someone else.
- Domenic_S 10y ago
- DenisM 10y agoIt would be nice if they offered an option of adaptive bandwidth throttling, so that once you're past 75% of your allotment it starts slowing you down such that you never reach your entire quota, and never get charged for overages. The Zeno's paradox in action - once you reach half your limit, the speed is cut in half. "Zeno" throttling if you will. :)
- 0xmohit 10y agoIsn't $80 for a 2-core processor a bit high especially if they are competing with Digital Ocean?
- kuschku 10y agoAnd DO is already immensely expensive compared to VPS at OVH, or actual dedicated hardware at Hetzner, OVH, Online.net, Scaleways, KimSufi, however they are all called.
- voltagex_ 10y agoI'm in Australia so I either pay a premium (100x) for an Australian VPS, or deal with 150 (US) to 400ms (EU) latency. I'm "locked out" of Hetzner et al due to that - and yes, I know there's nothing you can do about the speed of light. I just wish Australian/New Zealand/Singaporean/Hong Kong offerings were more competitive (all of those are <200ms)
- snowl 10y agoHave you checked out vultr? I host my VPS there with no issues and extremely good ping.
- voltagex_ 10y agoOther comments regarding Vultr's billing in this thread have put me off it completely.
- e2021 10y agoDigital ocean have servers in Singapore for the same price as all their other ones. The latency from Perth is about 40ms from memory.
- voltagex_ 10y ago167ms from Canberra, on the NBN. Terrible routing though - I wonder what it would have been pre-TPG takeover, though.
- Chris2048 10y agoCan you use one of those top-up VISA cards? That you put so much money on, Do you need to be tied to a bank account?
- rlpb 10y agoAmazon usually bill in arrears (no idea about Lightsail). In the general case even, it doesn't matter. What you owe Amazon is independent of whether your card allows the charge or not. You can run out of top-up VISA card credit but you may still end up owing Amazon money. This applies to any other provider, too. What you owe the provider is what you contracted to pay the provider (eg. by consuming services, or clicking the "upgrade" button in a web interface). It is independent of them actually taking the money.
- blibble 10y agothis is why people set up companies, which in the UK costs 13 pounds/year to keep operational limited liability, can't really beat it
- biot 10y agoIntentionally doing that in order to avoid paying sounds a lot like fraud, something your limited liability won't protect you from.
- blibble 10y agoshifting risk to the creditors is the entire point of limited liability; the risk of deadbeats abusing it is always there, and the ability to pay is something almost every business will take into account when arranging a line of credit amazon could completely negate this risk by requiring pre-payment for small/unknown operators, which is something a lot of people (myself included) desperately want them to provide. I'm sure they've done their sums here, and have figured out the increased revenue from customers not being able to set a budget is more than their potential losses from deadbeats the variable costs are basically zero, after all ( bandwidth and CPU time are worthless if not utilised)
- stupidcar 10y agoWhat are these "various" ways you're talking about? The only overage charge I see is for data transfer. This isn't ideal, I'll grant you, but it's not the same as "various".
- Someone1234 10y agoDNS, IP Address Reservation, Plan Upgrades, Bandwidth, and so on. We've seen AWS accounts get broken into with stolen tokens, additional VPS's started, VPS upgraded, bandwidth consumed, etc. And while Amazon has been good with refunding the FIRST time, nobody wants to wake up to a 10K bill because your gitignore had a typo. A ceiling or cap may even stop plan upgrades without an email confirmation. That would be hugely welcome, particularly in a world where bad guys are actively seeking out VPS to break into.
- Whitestrake 10y agoGenuinely curious to hear if that "gitignore had a typo" 10k bill has a story behind it!
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agohttps://wptavern.com/ryan-hellyers-aws-nightmare-leaked-access-keys-result-in-a-6000-bill-overnight https://wptavern.com/ryan-hellyers-aws-nightmare-leaked-acce...
- creullin 10y agoThey say on the FAQ: >For every Lightsail plan you use, we charge you the fixed hourly price, up to the maximum monthly plan cost. Wording implies the monthly pricing is a 'maximum' price.
- fabian2k 10y agoTraffic is the big item that can add additional charges: > Data transfer overages above the free allowance are charged at $0.09/GB. On the $5 instance the second TB (at $90) is 18 times as expensive as the instance itself with the first TB included.
- bendbro 10y agoI'm pretty sure AWS only charges on traffic out. Edit: just did some research, there are many cases this isn't true
- creullin 10y agoI get that, but that's after the first TB. For a $5 VPS I'd expect most customers wouldn't go over that.
- Someone1234 10y agoI'd agree. But it would be nice to have an option in the account settings so you literally cannot accidentally spend $90 on a $5 account.
- user5994461 10y agoIt's not expected... until your site get unexpectedly featured on HN, reddit or any news site.
- kuschku 10y agoWow. That traffic is almost 50 times more expensive than at hosters of dedicated servers, or when you buy it directly from Tier 1 or Tier 2 networks. Hetzner charges 1.36€ per Terabyte of traffic, and with most servers, gives you 10-20TB included. I’ve heard people talk about the ridiculous traffic costs of AWS, but this is an entirely new dimension of expensive.
- blhack 10y agoThis is exactly it. 5-6 years ago (I think), I signed up for an aws account under the "free" or educational or something tier. AWS was newish at the time, and I wanted to learn about it. Via some accidental clicking in the control panel (trying to get an IP address for the instance, I think?) I ended up getting a bill from them for over $100. Which, to me at the time, was a huge amount of money. It put me off of AWS forever. I don't ever want something that tells me how much they're going to charge me after I have already given them my credit card information. edit: they did credit me back when I complained, but that doesn't matter. The risk to me wasn't/isn't worth it.
- tedmiston 10y agoI got my first bit of AWS credit in a cloud class and something like this was common. From what I've heard they will null out the bill if they can see you didn't use it.
- arcticfox 10y ago100%. I can't stand it. It's unlimited liability for anyone that uses their service with no way to limit it. If you were able to set hard caps, you could have set yours at like $5 or even $0 (free tier) and never run into that. One of my services had a Google BigQuery "budget" set at $100. One of our test machines went haywire and continuously submitted a bunch of jobs. The "budget" turned out only to be an alarm, and even that they sent us 8 hours late, after $1600 of charges had been racked up. I responded in 20 minutes and shut it down. Google insisted we pay the full bill. After I wrote up a blog post on the situation and had the "publish" button warmed up, they finally relented and refunded us for the amount of time their alarm was delayed. Absolutely ridiculous that's not their policy to begin with...
- zwischenzug 10y agoMe too. I want protection against my own stupidity, as well as sheer ignorance of the charges. This put me off AWS for years, and I was deeply shocked there was no one-click 'suspend at x$'. For a company that supposedly puts the customer first, this is appalling.
- spdustin 10y agoCloudwatch alarms can stop running EC2 instances. We do this to prevent accidentally leaving expensive instances running. If that helps a little.
- fgpwd 10y agoAfaik the data is delayed and the damage might already be done by the time the alarm fires
- spdustin 10y agoFor just running instances, that's not true. You set up a metric that checks if the instance is alive every minute, ten minutes, whatever, and set it's alarm condition to trigger once the metric is true for six samples, 600 samples, whatever you need. The alarm action: stop instance.
- dsmithatx 10y agoI use budgets in AWS to send me a text when I get to a certain limit. You could potentially use an SNS topic to take action and shutdown resources I suppose. I guess if you are always traveling or can't get to a computer this could be an issue for you. I can't imagine there are that many people seriously using AWS who could suddenly run up a huge bill that can't respond to a txt or have an friend, coworker, employee or automated task do so.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shostack 10y agoIt's like they saw all these consumers being screwed by ISP and cell provider data caps and astronomical accidental overage fees and went "how do we get in on that action?!"
- thecrazyone 10y agoHehe, sounds pretty much like what they've been doing. Really wish they bring some of that customer centric-ness they talk about to this aspect
- vacri 10y agoThey frequently refund mistaken overages.
- bayofpigs 10y agoI pre-paid for 3 years of service but 1 year in they sent notification that the server farm would moved and I had 30 days to relocate my servers. Was pretty busy at the time so was an inconvenience to move everything, but I did. Then I get the next months invoice and it's not using my pre-paid services but instead is billing for full CPU usage - no reserved instances. After emailing support several times they say it's my own fault for not using the correct instance type, even though it's identical to the one I pre-paid for. It may well be my error but it was caused by them since I never asked for my servers to be moved. It's been an expensive and time-wasting experience -- will never use them again. Am currently evaluating GKE (even more expensive) and DigitalOcean.
- danesparza 10y agoDoes this set or allow the user to set a cost ceiling? Probably not. Just based on transfer (network) costs, Amazon Lightsail includes this caveat: Some types of data transfer in excess of data transfer included in your plan is subject to overage charges. Please see the FAQ for details.
- ericdidier1 10y agoThat's exactly what we do: www.onekloud.com happy to chat (eric@onekloud.com)
- ericdidier1 10y agoThat's exactly what we do: www.onekloud.com. You can contact me at eric@onekloud.com
- metafunctor 10y agoThe AWS cost structure is one reasons we switched to a different provider. I feel Amazon has taken metered pricing too far with AWS, especially when the prices aren't really that low. Everything seems to cost extra with AWS, and it's quite hard to estimate beforehand how much a thing will actually cost in practice.
- chj 10y agoIt's so confusing that I switched to DO. Not that DO is cheaper but it's pricing is way simpler.
- cr0sh 10y agoWhile it wouldn't be as easy as what you want, and this certainly wouldn't be the best solution, they say they offer an API. So in theory (I haven't checked what the API gives you control over - so this may be worthless), you could monitor your instance (bandwidth, time up, disk usage, etc), and if things get out of hand, or approach your limit (whatever it is), you could use the API to say shut down or delete the instance, or throttle the bandwidth (maybe via firewall rules or something?). Again - this would assume the API allows you to do this (and ideally from within the instance itself - which shouldn't be an issue, I wouldn't think). And again, it shouldn't take this much work (you're right, it should just be a simple control panel setting). But maybe it's an option for those who have the skills to implement it?
- cr0sh 10y agoEDIT: I just took a quick look at the API docs - and while it doesn't look like you can mess with the firewall rules settings, everything else should be possible (get metric data, start/stop/reboot/delete instance, etc).
- swamp40 10y ago>> But they've never offered a hard "suspend my account" ceiling that a lot of people with limited budgets have asked for. That's probably where most of their profit comes from. That option was most likely squashed from the highest authority.
- robot 10y ago"Just to be clear: This service is offered by Amazon/AWS themselves, it isn't a third party. " says Someone1234. Should we believe it?
- carlosdp 10y agoIt's an official AWS announcement, so yea...
- neurotech1 10y agoThese are going to be insanely expensive. Each FPGA chip costs $50k retail, and unlikely to be cheaper than $10k in volume, so I can't imagine the per hour cost being particularly cheap. https://octopart.com/search?q=VU9P https://octopart.com/search?q=VU9P
- morganvachon 10y agoThanks, that's exactly what I was wondering. This makes LightSail a non-starter for little guys like me; I'll stick with Vultr for similar service that charges the actual price listed with no gotchas.
- 20years 10y ago"Why even offer a service like this if you cannot GUARANTEE that the $5 they say they charge is all you'll ever get charged?" Exactly! We have used AWS and DO a lot this past year. DO is great for smaller sites/api's and super easy to use. Their support is also outstanding. AWS has tons of tools but many come at a cost. We are in the process of moving a couple of sites off of AWS and onto a LiquidWeb dedicated box. We will be paying much less and the LW dedicated server is more than enough for what we need. AWS is great for spinning up and scaling instances quickly and comes with a ton of other tools. At the end of the day however it is not always the most cost effective or even best offering for most sites/apps.
- joe563323 10y agoLinode provides 2 gb for $10. AWS provides 1GB for the same thing. Also, AWS does not support ipv6 which means you can not launch your apps in istore if you use AWS servers.
- lucb1e 10y ago> AWS does not support ipv6 Wait what? That's getting ridiculous. Seven years ago they would have been on time, perhaps even considered early by some, but three years ago when looking for hosting providers I already laughed at the ones without v6 and moved on without a second thought. They weren't even the cheap ones. Currently enjoying a €3/mo VPS at Pcextreme.nl with the same specs as the $5 Lightsail VPS. But with IPv6 of course. Perhaps I've been spoiled with dual stack at home since 2009 from xs4all. Other Dutch ISPs promised it in (iirc) 2013 and every year since, but there has yet to be a second big one to offer it and other countries like Belgium surpassed us by now. Even Germany's Telekom is getting there.
- Intermernet 10y agoThere is a way to hack this up, which is probably a bit complex for a single instance, but works: - Setup a HTTPS endpoint on the server that listens for an SNS notification and performs an action (e.g. backup ephemeral data to S3 and shutdown). I wrote the service in Go and the action is just a shell script but choose your favorite language. - Setup an SNS subscription pointing to the service endpoint. - Setup an SNS topic for the message. - Set up an SNS notification in AWS billing. I use "When actual costs are equal to 100% of budgeted amount". The problem is that it's necessary to lock down the endpoint listener as it will usually need root access in order to shutdown the machine. This can be done by using authentication on the endpoint, setting up a locked down user to run the service under and granting that user the ability to run /sbin/shutdown in the sudoers file. There are probably nicer ways to do it, but this does work to limit my spend on each instance. You can also add AWS API calls to delete any other costly related resources (static IPs, load balancers etc.) I've been thinking about writing a more modular and robust app that handles multiple instances etc but most of my servers are now in GCE so I don't really have the need.
- _andromeda_ 10y agoRemarkably spot on! Everything.