19 ms·
Bruce Schneier: 'The Internet Era of Fun and Games Is Over'
- eveningcoffee 10y agoI can propose a quite straightforward solution for this mess: do not connect things into the Internet. Your thermostat maybe wants to talk with your alarm clock. I can get that. But it does not have to happen over the Internet. Let them talk locally.
- wwwigham 10y agoThat's actually what Bruce wants - and he figures the only way to enforce it is through regulation. He's given up on the sensibilities of individual companies and programmers, and would instead like to rely on regulations to make some basic guarantees. You and I know the basics of computer security. We can take a crack at designing a secure system and maybe do okay. But the argument goes like this: Yes there are security conscous programmers, but there are also many which are not. And those people work on products which make it to market. How do we stop those products from making it to market? Government intervention. He's given up on education and relying on the informed developer, and would rather rely on public policy. I find it a bit sad.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoIt also won't work. The only solution to ignorance is education. Having "smart people" make all the decisions will only get you so far.
- jlj 10y agoThe free market crowd would argue that the surviving companies will bake in the right security if consumers demand it. If companies don't take it seriously, either their customers aren't demanding it, or they will be replaced by companies that do a good job at it. The government has a proven conflict of interest and disincentive to harden the infrastructure. Vulnerabilities are valuable for espionage. And there are already regulations like HIPPA, PCI, etc, yet there are still breaches. Regulation will add complexity to business and will protect market share for the entrenched players who can afford to follow it. That will lead to further consolidation and reduced competition while I feel that the opposite is needed. The fiefdoms described in another post wouldn't be such a bad thing. At the nation state level, competition will also make for better security. Isolationism doesn't work out well in world history. Movement of goods and ideas does a better job at bringing countries together. I feel there's a pendulum swinging back towards isolationism but it goes back and forth over time.
- alexqgb 10y agoWhat the free-market crowd can never account for - here, or anywhere - is how the market is supposed to resolve issues that are not of direct, immediate interest to self-serving buyers or sellers, but which are of massive and justifiable interest to third parties outside the transaction. Case in point: If a seller in one country can lower the costs of a good shipped to another country by scrapping responsible waste management in favor of polluting the commons (i.e., places where individual property rights claims are difficult to press), then "the magic of the market" is likely to increase - not decrease - the amount of pollution generated by the trade. What libertarians don't like to admit is that they see free markets as more than ideal mechanisms for preserving efficient economies. They also see them as efficient sources of good and just governance. Like all belief systems, faith in the quality of governance supplied by free markets, while rational and well-supported to a point, can be taken to counter productive extremes where it maintenance stops operating like empiricism, and starts to function is ways indistinguishable from fundamentalists religions. Not sure how many sensible knowledgeable people want this to be the dominant force in guiding global network security.
- CuriousSkeptic 10y agoAs a nuance though. one could agree with the notion of negative externalities naturally occurring in a free market economy (perhaps in a total laissez faire environment the affected third parties could retaliate in kind though) but disagree with the form of policy to address it. In principle the market should be able to select appropriate fixes if the costs are internalized, but governments have a tendency to focus less on the internalize costs part, and more on selecting fixes. Pragmatically it might be the best way forward, but in principle it goes against free market resource optimizations and instead becomes a gamble that whatever fix is made policy actually do have an impact on the problem, and doesn't make things worse.
- alexqgb 10y agoPragmatically it might be the best way forward, but in principle it goes against free market resource optimizations This is a pretty good argument the absolute value of principle, tbh For what it's worth, I tend to see principles like map; useful - even indispensable - in many situations, that are nevertheless abstractions and therefor imperfect guides to actual reality. Use maps, yes, but avoid mistaking them - or any system of symbols - for the things they represent (i.e., the map is not the territory). Indeed, principle is a form of proxy wisdom for the young and inexperienced. It's better than nothing, but probably not enough to save you from at least a few episodes of hard reckoning. Assuming these don't get you killed, the places where principle doesn't serve are the ones where mature judgement develops. Granted, there's a point where this doesn't serve either, but that's okay too since mortality always wins in the end.
- hash-set 10y agoHe's nuts. Elected officials don't get technology. Hillary Clinton had no idea what she was doing with a simple e-mail server. They. Don't. Get. It.
- mreiland 10y agoI disagree with the idea that the problem has to do with "non-security minded programmers". Certainly they exist, but the issue more often than not is that security is more expensive than non-security, so companies don't give their developers enough time to actually do security.
- rspeer 10y agoSo what's the solution? When other people keep making and buying products that communicate over the Internet, because it's easier, what do you do about it?
- mtgx 10y agoIf you don't like the "regulations to prevent bad stuff" approach, then use the "we'll let you do whatever you want, but if you screw up you're going to pay dearly to fix it" approach. Then companies can balance the cost of adding a secure enclave and a Grsec kernel (just an example) to their smart coffee maker against having to recall all of their infected products from the market when a botnet takes over them. Besides that stick, I would throw a couple of carrots in there, too, like the companies being able to brag that their products are A+ security rated, etc, in their promotional materials and on their packages.
- ridgeguy 10y agoBut the ease of creating companies and abandoning them or otherwise obfuscating their liabilities says that they won't be the ones paying dearly. In short, I think regulations will prevent more damage than post-hoc legal retribution.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"In short, I think regulations will prevent more damage than post-hoc legal retribution." Time has proven that wrong so far. We got a lot of highly-secure products after DOD's Computer Security Initiative giving clear guidance plus financial incentive. DO-178B and other safety-critical markets are cranking out lots of them on safety side. So is segment of smartcard industry focused on high-security. Regulation works so long as it has effective standards, they're clear, evaluated against product, and must be followed to sell the product. As in TCSEC era and DO-178B, reusable components for common cases show up to reduce the evaluation cost or risk. Open-source security would likely get a boost, too, as companies sponsoring it would sponsor certifiable versions with the higher QA.
- trentlott 10y agoSo some hardware maker should propose and publish an open intranetworking guide, ideally. There could be an interesting market for Apple clocks and Apple thermostats, but to increase the likelihood of something like that becoming popular (vs just using the easy Wi-Fi route), wouldn't it taken an unlikely push like that? It will be a long time before manufacturers decide whether or not to put everything online, I think.
- btgeekboy 10y agoBut why make things compatible with open standards (regardless of who writes them) when you can build an ecosystem?! I say that sarcastically, but it seems to be where the world goes.
- shostack 10y agoAre there any devices that do this? I'd be very much a fan of a local IoT I control, perhaps with an encrypted data file on Dropbox or something it can accees. I have no need for cloud storage from the vendor...I can bring my own.
- robterrell 10y agoIsn't this what ZigBee and Z-Wave are for? Local-only wireless network for your things, just bridge out to the internet for services as needed? Instead of making dropbox the nervous system of everything?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eveningcoffee 10y agoThe whole EIB/KNX standard works like this and has been around for more than 20 years and there are hundreds of devices to choose from. It is designed around local low bound (9600 bps) network where you can connect KNX devices (thermostats, actuators, sensors etc) or gateways/routers to other networks. Only problem it has is that the communication is not encrypted, but being local and isolated, it is not a very big concern. Every other home/building automation systems worked like this recently until some marketing geniuses came up with the IoT campaign.
- agumonkey 10y agoAre there technologies that aim at physical scoping of networks ? Sometimes I joke to myself that IR remotes will be the next privacy graal. Can't hack my RCA TV unless you've been granted access on my couch.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agodo not connect things into the Internet...Let them talk locally. Too simplistic. If devices talk then there will be a way to listen and scale that talking/listening.
- boramalper 10y ago> Let them talk locally. Although I agree, what if one the devices that they communicate locally is connected to the Internet? Then it becomes just another level of indirection...
- pessimizer 10y agoThis site's ssl is broken.
- ursus_bonum 10y agoOr you're using Chrome.
- whyagaindavid 10y agoI too get an ssl error with firefox 50
- Futurebot 10y agoI'd love to see what a detailed version of security policies and infrastructure look like in a world of backdoor-less strong encryption from Schneier, the EFF, the Hopkins crew, etc. Something that can be used to persuade, or at least influence policymakers by allowing them to see that another way is possible, one that allows security services to do their job in a way that allows them to feel that their work isn't futile, while simultaneously respecting privacy rights. I think the need for strong encryption and no backdoors (which as Schneier himself has explained in the past, are always a double-edged sword) are very important and I support them, but that those on the side of it who also have in-depth knowledge about the finer details don't deign to articulate just what exactly the policy looks like without resorting to just a list of what we shouldn't do and vague allusions to "just go old-school" or "utilize human assets more." A coherently articulated, normative counterfactual security platform would be a better place to argue from. It's a cousin to the negative liberty arguments: they only list what not to do to in order to avoid hurting people, rather than what we can do to help them (positive liberty.) Maybe we could frame the question as "If we let the EFF and Bruce Schneier redesign the United States security apparatus from scratch, what would it look like?" We already have excellent critiques, and are good at articulating "what's bad," but far too little on "what would a good system look like that strikes the 'right' balance?"
- nickpsecurity 10y agoA combo of per-customer authentication at packet-level, DDOS monitoring, and rate limiting (or termination) of specific connection upon DDOS or malicious activity. That by itself would stop a lot of these right at the Tier 3 ISP level. Trickle those suckers down to dialup speeds with a notice telling them their computer is being used in a crime with a link to helpful ways on dealing with it (or support number). Far as design, they could put cheap knockoff of an INFOSEC guard in their modems with CPU's resistant to code injection. Include accelerators for networking functions and/or some DDOS detection (esp low-layer flooding) right at that device. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guard_(information_security) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guard_(information_security)
- wwwigham 10y ago> When it didn’t matter—when it was Facebook, when it was Twitter, when it was email—it was OK to let programmers, to give them the special right to code the world as they saw fit. We were able to do that. But now that it’s the world of dangerous things—and it’s cars and planes and medical devices and everything else—maybe we can’t do that anymore. Mark this mindset as the beginning of the end of the open, inclusive programming world as we know it. Schnier visited RIT (my alma mater) last spring, and his presentation revolved around the threat presented by IoT and the growing need for national legislation to encumber it. I asked him a pointed question about how this scaled to the _international_ level, which he decided mostly not to answer (focus on domestic policy first, and such). Because the answer is simple: _it doesn't_. Without global collaboration, this philosophy is the beginning of national internet feifdoms - moreso than what exists today - and the beginning of the end of the global collaboration we freely enjoy today. I value this freedom a lot. I respect Mr. Schneier for his poignant responses to popular security issues and his ability to be a public face for computer security, but I strongly disagree with where he's lobbying we take the future to. Maybe I just can't accept the hard reality that "security isn't easy" and that government regulation is the only way to force security on people.
- mej10 10y agoDISCLAIMER: I don't necessarily think the types of regulations proposed are the answer, but at the very least there should be some responsibility on people using high-bandwidth connections. It would probably have to be legally mandated. Even if his proposal doesn't fix the rest of the world it would set an example for other countries. It would also give other countries more that they can do themselves. Like with the DNS DDoS, the traffic originated in the US -- even if the perpetrator was in another country. Getting the US locked down means that those countries can start taking responsibility (and I mean that in a positive way) for their own piece of the internet. Right now there isn't even a place for them to start.
- cesarb 10y ago> Without global collaboration, this philosophy is the beginning of national internet feifdoms - moreso than what exists today - and the beginning of the end of the global collaboration we freely enjoy today. You mean like a national network? I believe something like that existed in several countries. And the Internet of old grew over them, as a way to interconnect nodes within disparate networks (thus the name Internet). Give it enough time, and the national networks will merge into a single global network again.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoYep. Keep IoT on the LAN, or give it the same respect you would any other networked computer. However, the day the the Internet Era of Fun And Games is over is the day that the internet keels over dead. The Internet was (almost literally) built on fun and games.
- 0xCMP 10y agoBut the problem has been people haven't done that. So here we are. Maybe some stick (vs carrot) for unwittingly contributing to a DDoS to make people care will work? Not sure. I'm not really liking any of these solutions, but the problem is that it'll get worse.
- gooberdoober 10y agoI don't know, do they have to run on the same network as everything else? Maybe a first step is just to have an address range for these demonic things, which isn't publicly routable (unless you deliberating NAT it). The "home network" range (steal back some of that loopback space!).
- patcheudor 10y ago"Any sufficiently advanced technology controlled by a miscreant is indistinguishable from a possessed object in a Stephen King Novel." http://thefutureisastephenkingnovel.com/assets/player/KeynoteDHTMLPlayer.html#2 http://thefutureisastephenkingnovel.com/assets/player/Keynot...
- phantom_oracle 10y agoI think I live in a bubble... But... Who buys these products? Why does a toaster need to be connected to the internet and synced with your "smart"phone? What exactly can you achieve having this feature?
- imaginology 10y agoNot sure about a toster, but there are benefits to having some household appliances connected to the internet. For example, a washing machine may be able to determine what hour it should operate for maximum energy savings, and ping you when finished. I guess a toaster could be similar; pre-loaded with bread so you could ask it to start toasting before getting up from the sofa. > Consumers may find it totally cool to design images for toast using a smartphone. Meantime, the resulting data would help food companies understand how people approach breakfast, design new products and market to consumers more effectively. http://blog.rackspace.com/internet-of-things-why-connected-toasters-and-other-smart-home-devices-matter http://blog.rackspace.com/internet-of-things-why-connected-t...
- rglover 10y ago> [...] pre-loaded with bread so you could ask it to start toasting before getting up from the sofa. But how did the bread get in the toaster?!
- mreiland 10y agoyou preload it the night before so it goes stale while you sleep, duh.
- tdkl 10y agoNot really. Those benefits that are marketed are mostly just enablers for laziness, but not actually solving anything. It caters to the self repeating lie of "saving precious time" but actually harms responsibility and security at scale.
- woofyman 10y ago>Thanks to the Internet of Things, the ability to collect massive amounts of data and use it in new and profoundly different ways also enters the picture. http://blog.rackspace.com/internet-of-things-why-connected-toasters-and-other-smart-home-devices-matter http://blog.rackspace.com/internet-of-things-why-connected-t... No thank you very much.
- kordless 10y agoWe're going to need to integrate cryptocurrencies with APIs. Encrypted pay to play is the only way.
- nixos 10y agoThe problem is that software engineering is hard. Immensely so. On a scale of engineering "hardness" (meaning, we can predict all side affects of action), software engineering is closer to medicine than to, say, civil engineering. We know stresses, materials, and how they interact. We can predict what will happen, and how to avoid edge cases. Software? Is there any commonly used secure software? Forget about Windows and Linux. What about OpenBSD? Did it ever have a security hole? And that's just the OS. What about software? There are just too many variables. So what will happen? There will become "best practices" enshrined by law. Most will be security theater. Most will remove our rights, and most will actually make things less safe. Right now, the number one problem of IoT security is fragmentation. Samsung puts out an S6, three years later stops updating it, a hole is found, too bad. Game over. The problem is that "locking firmware" is common "security theater", which, if there'll ever be a legal security requirement on IoT, it'll require locked bootloader and firmware. And you can't make a requirement to "keep code secure", because then the question will be for "how long"? Five years? 10 years?
- dustingetz 10y agosoftware itself isn't intractable, it's that the field is young, and we are stuck with choices made when nothing was understood, and its gonna take a while to turn the ship. but i think we have a pretty good idea of where we are trying to go wrt writing secure software.
- nixos 10y ago> it's that the field is young The opposite. When the field was in its infancy, one was able to keep whole stacks in his head. How complicated were CPUs in the 1960s? How many lines of assembler was in the LM? How many lines is Linux or FreeBSD kernel? Now add libc. Now you have a 1970s C compiler. Now take into account all the optimizations any modern C compiler does. Now make sure there's no bugs _there_. Now add a Python stack. Now you can have decent, "safe" code. Most hacks don't target this part. The low hanging fruit is lower. You need a math library. OK, import that. You need some other library. OK, import that. Oops, there's a bug in one module. Or the admin setup wasn't done right. Or something blew. Bam. You have the keys to the kingdom. And this is all deterministic. Someone _could_ verify that there are no bugs here. But what about Neural Networks? The whole point of training is that the programmers _can't_ write a deterministic algorithm to self drive, and have to have a huge NN do the heavy lifting. And that's not verifiable. _This_ is what's going to be running your self-driving car. That's why I compared software engineering to biology, where we "test" a lot, hope for the best, and have it blow up in our face a generation later.
- zzzcpan 10y agoIt feels like they are using dyn ddos incident as a 9/11 of the internet. So much fear mongering and push for government involvement, disgusting. Next thing you know you'll need a license to write software for appliances and mandated to put a surveillance API into everything.
- gooberdoober 10y agoYeah it feels very much like that to me too. Taking that a step further, it wouldn't surprise me if it were orchestrated by the people that will be at the helm on this sort of shit if it's implemented. When we have TLA's subverting security, megacorps sucking up information and leaving it open to attack, manufacturers baking in backdoors etc... I would run an absolute mile from being a developer in this new world.
- gioele 10y agoSchneier point of view is that government involvement will happen and it is better to shape this involvement before the US government is forced to intervene after a large-scale disaster. > Nothing motivates the U.S. government like fear. Remember 2001? A small-government Republican president created the Department of Homeland Security in the wake of the 9/11 terrorist attacks: a rushed and ill-thought-out decision that we've been trying to fix for more than a decade. > A fatal IoT disaster will similarly spur our government into action, and it's unlikely to be well-considered and thoughtful action. > Our choice isn't between government involvement and no government involvement. Our choice is between smarter government involvement and stupider government involvement. We have to start thinking about this now. Regulations are necessary, important and complex — and they're coming. We can't afford to ignore these issues until it's too late. https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/11/regulation_of_t.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/11/regulation_of...
- bArray 10y agoThe governments want to get involved - the simple fact is I don't think they can. Software can be much more complex than humans. There are systems out there that are already so complex, no one human can reason about the entire system. I don't think law could even keep up with the space it wants to govern. They would be better trying to govern the application space as they have already been doing, such as vehicles, nuclear, etc.
- Mithaldu 10y agoIn the video he makes an excellent point, that i think is valuable to highlight and repeat here again: Device insecurity is in aggregate very similar to environmental pollution of devices. It is a latent danger that in some cases can stick around for many decades, it is caused by many people invidicually adding a tiny bit to the problem, it is created because right now accepting insecurity makes the product cheaper without directly hurting either the manufacturer or the buyer.
- MichaelMoser123 10y agoDid Bruce Schneier call for regulations that should prevent ddos attacks? What kind of regulation/law does he propose? In other articles Schneier called to solve other problems by regulation - for example to limit data retention by internet companies. are laws the answer? Is these no way to solve security related problems be better technology? Will microkernel os solve embeded device security or will it be regulation?
- porkloin 10y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but I believe he's calling for a specific organ of government to take on regulation of the internet and connected devices in a general sense, not calling for some specific regulation or law. I suspect what he's getting at is having some set of "safety standards" to be put in place, especially for IoT tech. The whole quote of >Our computers are secure for a bunch of reasons. The engineers at Google, Apple, Microsoft spent a lot of time on this. But that doesn’t happen for these cheaper devices. … These devices are a lower price margin, they’re offshore, there’s no teams. And a lot of them cannot be patched. sums up that point pretty well. I honestly don't know how you would really enforce something like this, but the proposal seems to be less about the specifics of regulation and more about the need for new regulation. The FCC really isn't equipped to handle this kind of thing.
- MichaelMoser123 10y ago% honestly don't know how you would really enforce something like this Probably like with automotive code - they don't have code audits but have mandated test scenarios. The problem is that you need large organizations to work these out i guess Schneier has a point, if consumers do not demand secure systems then it can only be done through regulation. that would be a very German approach - they have strong consumer advocacy organisations like Stiftung Warentest and the Adac, these then push for more consumer protecting regulation. [1] Once upon a time these requirements were also used as protectionist barriers. In our days that would mean: you did not bother to update your toolchain and have no firmware updates for this smart light bulb of yours? gone is your import license. [1] http://americastradepolicy.com/german-customer-protection-or-protectionism/#.WDaqd7J96M8 http://americastradepolicy.com/german-customer-protection-or...
- willholloway 10y agoCould we not solve the problem of DDOS through collaboration between hosts and ISP's? 1) DDOS attack is detected 2) Attacking IP addresses are sent automated DDOS abuse notifications 3) ISP, like your credit card company when it's machine learning algos detect fraud ask for human back channel verification like SMS. 4) ISP notifies user of suspected bot on one of their devices. The onus is put on the user to run a secure network and remove or fix offending devices. This system could work well for residential connections at least. It could be implemented similarly to the way spam is handled by the internet, bad neighborhoods and networks that don't self police are treated as second class citizens.
- therealidiot 10y ago> It could be implemented similarly to the way spam is handled by the internet, bad neighborhoods and networks that don't self police are treated as second class citizens. Please no, the way spam is handled on the internet means that anyone who isn't already a massive internet company is usually treat as a second class citizen
- willholloway 10y agoOn second thought, agreed. I hope that is not part of the solution. I think that our routers may be the key, or are at least completely negligent at the moment. A normal consumer router is essentially a black box, but it should be a watchdog. The router should alert users when suspect outbound traffic is originating from it's network. Of course the router could be compromised, and router patch cycles are atrocious generally, but this method could notify in case of hacked IP cameras and thermostats.
- rtpg 10y agoISPs do this for bittorrent, I imagine similar things could be set up for DDOS attacks. A little message from the ISP like "hey, you were sending out some DDoS stuff, please check your devices."
- marcosdumay 10y agoThis. But with ISP procedures mandated by governments, with international synchronization of rules. This already works well for medicine, aviation, telephone systems, transit signaling, and a huge number of other things. There's no reason to believe this wouldn't work for internet security. We could start by mandating the network best practices RFC.
- sandworm101 10y ago>>> We get security [for phones] because I get a new one every 18 months. Your DVR lasts for five years, your car for 10, your refrigerator for 25. I’m going to replace my thermostat approximately never. So the market really can’t fix this. Yes it can. It is fixing the problem as we speak. I, a security aware person, would never buy a connected thermostat. I'll buy the 5$ model that does the job I want perfectly. And my connected DVR lies behind some decent protections on my local network. Should it start participating in a dos attack or talking to those it shouldn't, I'll notice and replace it with a better system. The same is true of laptops, phones and cars. Once people are burnt a couple times they will opt for the safer models. Government could perhaps accelerate this process by increasing manufacturer liability (lol, not for the next 4/8 years) or by mandating that unmaintained products self-brick (again, lol). But the market will react nevertheless.
- saint_fiasco 10y ago> It is fixing the problem as we speak. I, a security aware person... The market of devices bought by security aware people is not the market that Schneier is concerned about. It's this other much larger market of normal people buying the least expensive devices with the most convenient features. Those consumers won't notice or care if their devices participate in dos attacks, but the targets of the attacks care a lot. It's a classic example of a negative externality.
- simonlebo 10y agoCould ISP be responsible for attacks coming from some of their infected users? Shutting down someone's internet for 'abusive use' would be a good incentive of getting incriminating devices out of the market.
- sbuttgereit 10y agoI remember the last time we called on a government security solution for a problem that was perceived as too difficult and too critical for the private sector that had been, up to that time, managing the issue. That's roughly how the Department of Homeland Security was born and the TSA was given the critical task of managing airport security where the failures happen. I wonder how Mr. Schneier thought that worked out? I cannot take seriously any open-ended demand for regulation in the name of safety that doesn't spell out pretty detailed proposals which would work in practice; what such regulations should address and what is off limits. The last time we did this, we sacrificed rights and gained little (if any) additional security; I think Schneier calls it "security theater". I want to know why he thinks his call will result in ANYTHING better than that fiasco before I'm even vaguely convinced that this is the right answer. Please don't read this as my not believing that there is a real problem and threat. I'm simply dubious of Schneier's answer at this point. "Any action" here is not necessarily the right action.
- hackuser 10y ago> the last time we called on a government security solution for a problem that was perceived as too difficult and too critical for the private sector that had been, up to that time, managing the issue. / That's roughly how the Department of Homeland Security was born I'm pretty sure the U.S. government has taken on other security issues since the DHS was founded in 2002.
- sbuttgereit 10y agoAnd what's your point caller? Your statement sounds like blind trust and assumption rather than any actual knowledge. Sorry, I can't do that. So let me run the exercise a bit... DHS... Patriot Act?... All that Snowden revealed stuff?... Invasion of Iraq?... Lybia?... Syria?... the U.S. Border?... OK... a bit glib, but the point is there: where are the successes where the government protected citizens successfully without a disproportionate reduction of rights of those citizens. Off the top of my head, I can cite about as many as you did. I imagine there are some out there... but the track record isn't so good.
- ihaveahadron 10y ago"the internet" once some weird thing nobody heard of. now the medium that has the most influence over everything. shouldve seeen that one coming morons
- heheocoenev 10y agoThe fun and games are just getting started, it's just the stakes have been raised.
- Entangled 10y ago> "Schneier then laid out his argument for why the government should be a part of the solution" Now we have two problems.
- xapata 10y agoGovernment is useful to solve the tragedy of the commons. Insecure devices are a negative externality. The government should tax insecurity (or fine device manufacturers that allow an attack) and use the revenue to subsidize software security efforts.
- barnacs 10y agoIn my opinion, this is yet another example of a social problem that technology simply amplifies. Humans make mistakes. Computer systems are fragile. As humans keep developing computer systems, new attack surfaces, new vulnerabilities will be introduced. It's pointless to try and keep playing catch-up either with or without "regulations". Instead, we should consider _why_ such attacks happen in the first place. Who are the targets? States? Corporations? Maybe they're not open enough. Maybe they're too powerful. Or are we afraid that our governments, corporations, or other entities/instituions of our society invade our privacy to manipulate us? Or are we scared for our wealth or status? None of these are technological issues at their core. Our society needs to adapt and grow up to this powerful technology. Until then, the only thing we can do for our safety is refuse to use it.
- WalterBright 10y agoAdd a physical write-enable switch or jumper, so that malware cannot be installed into the firmware, and hacks cannot survive a reboot.
- debt 10y agobro imma let you finish but "the government should be part of he solution?" Hahah wtf Bro the gov't regularly "hacks" all the things(including the internet of things) legally that I literally couldn't give a shit if some random fucktard script kiddie decides to hack my router. the government literally does it on the regular legally. that's the actual problem. get a mitt bro.
- greggman 10y agoI don't understand how this regulation will work. Will all open source software have to be submitted to some government run or approved certification? OpenWRT? Linux? Random App that accesses the net? Raspberry PI python script? Sure it matters that 1 million IoT cameras are secure and can be updated but what about a million servers running some npm library? Do those need to be regulated too? I'm very concerned about the security issues but I'm not looking forward to no longer being able to write software because I need it certified every time I add a line. Are there other solutions that don't require regulation?
- RRWagner 10y agoThere are few powerful technologies invented in the last 100 years for which the government did not eventually require a license to make or even operate. I do imagine a future where to own a computer that can truly "create" will require a license to own and operate.
- z3t4 10y agoWe do not need more laws and regulations, we need less. Remember what happened if you had a security vulnerability 15 years ago ? You got hacked by some kid, then you patched your system and restored from backup and gave the kid a cookie. What will happen now ? And why ?
- sliken 10y agoseems like the answer to this is a federal standard for home firewalls. You buy a random piece of crap camera, the FCC or similar should track and publish a reasonable firewall rule for it. That way hordes of IoT devices could participate in a DoS without the FCC publishing bogus internet rules.
- woliveirajr 10y agoAnd I think that it'll be interesting when this kind of thing backfires. Like, let's say, USA government wanting that some computer made by Digital doesn't give the correct precision in all calculus done in the USSR nuclear research.
- throw2016 10y agoThere have been dozens of discussions on ddos and iot over the last few weeks here and its curious the technical consensus to solve a 'fragile network' problem is with politics and control and a political problem like surveillance with technology. The first can't be solved with politics without locking down the internet and fine frained control of billions of devices connecting globally in others words an unachievable strategy. And the second cannot be solved with technology unless anyone truly believes they can fight an organization with the law, tens of thousands of programmers working on surveillance 24/7 and near endless resources on their side. This way none of the problems get solved.
- Pica_soO 10y agoAnother approach to security - give everyone a nuke, and only prevent untraceable strikes. If everyone can denial of service the guy who started it- he wont start it? Dear god, now im pro-gun. Also then identity fraud will be the weapon of tomorrow.. I miss the old internet.. maybe if the speed is so slow, that strikes become uninteresting.. Could the servers transferring TCP-IP be adapted, in such a way, that a mass-traffic causing incident (controllserver) leads to a slowing down of the connection of the causality chain origin? No, crypto prevents that. What a nice little maze.
- cmurf 10y agoIt'll be a continuous sequence of market and government failure until it breaks. And in the meantime it'll involve a lot of finger pointing, not least of which will be at the user e.g. the user is stupid for clicking on that obvious link and deserves to be defrauded, that'll teach them; and other mind numbing nonsense. We'll see a return to walled gardens of private networks very restrictively interconnected, similar to the days of AOL, CompuServe, and Prodigy.