46 ms·
German Cities Are Solving the Age-Old Public Toilet Problem
- petepete 10y agoCommon sense appears to prevail. Cheap for the council, easy to understand, no bottlenecks, companies can opt in or out. More cities should try this.
- minitoar 10y agoSanta Cruz, California has been doing this for a few years. It mostly works well but those bathrooms get trashed.
- jdavis703 10y agoYes I was wondering how this would work in San Francisco. There is a large mental illness and drug abuse problem, many who suffer from these issues find it very difficult to leave a bathroom in at least a semi-decent state. Does the city maybe wind up paying enough to the businesses so they hire someone to keep the restroom clean?
- oscardelben 10y agoI think you'll find that mentally ill people are treated differently in Europe, that would be a necessary first step of your want to do something similar in sf.
- jsemrau 10y agoThe low cost for healthcare usually helps, in addition to the social net. A social democracy surely has it's benefits. *Not to be going into a political debate here.
- jdavis703 10y agoYes I spend a couple of months every year in Europe so I'm aware. The thing is health care is better, drug abuse (not use, but abuse) seems lower and also society has less tolerance for acting out. I've got a lot of mental illness issues in my family, so I hopefully can say this without sounding rude. But a lot of people dealing with mental episodes can to some extent moderate their behaviour. Not that it's easy, but the ability is there. However particularly in SF we are very tolerant, maybe to the point of causing more harm than good. So then some people just indulge in their every impulse including engaging in poor sanitary habits.
- tomjen3 10y agoThe post toilets in Germany typically have somebody sitting there, constantly cleaning the toilets.
- discordianfish 10y agoWhile I agree that SF has a much larger drug abuse / mental illness problem, that problem exists in Berlin as well - even with the better health care system and unemployment benefits. One thing to keep in mind when comparing homelessness in Berlin and SF is the clima. I don't know how much it contributes but homeless people in Berlin risk to freeze to dead. So I could imaging homeless people prefering warmer cities.
- haffla 10y agoAs if homeless people had a choice to become homeless or not.
- eliaspro 10y agoWell, at least in Germany there's virtually no homelessness due to a lack of resources. The government has to provide sufficient housing. The reasons for homelessness around here are most of the time different ones than "can't afford to pay rent". In many cases mental health issues and bureaucratic hurdles which might be too high to tackle for those stuck in a difficult situation. It's mostly down to having Street Workers which are able to connect to those people and help them doing the first steps into the right direction.
- manarth 10y agoPeople don't usually have a choice about becoming homeless, but their environment will affect how they respond to their homelessness. It's a cliché that some homeless people in America will choose to travel to California or Florida for the warmer climate (whether that's true or not I have no idea - would be interested in seeing data on that subject). If someone becomes homeless in a place where homelessness has a significantly increased risk of death (such as freezing to death in Berlin), then either they move away, they engage with local support services, or they carry on as they are, risking death (and some of them will die as a result). Either way, the effect is a reduction in the number of homeless people at that location. Thankfully a lot of places recognise some of the risks and try to address them. In the UK, many cities have a cold-weather response: when the temperature drops below Xº, additional shelters are opened, and street-teams look for people sleeping rough and guide them towards the shelters.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoLos Angeles has a large homeless population, and, if this sounds unfair, well I apologize, but, a significant fraction of LA's homeless people smell bad. I'm not trying to criticize homeless people and I'm sure there are good reasons for that fact such as lack of bathing facilities and access to clean clothing. If LA had a program paying cafes and restaurants a monthly fee to allow the general population (which would have to include the homeless) to use their restrooms, I predict that the vast majority of businesses would not participate. A restaurant owner would simply not want a smelly person parading through their dining space to get to the restroom. In short, I don't see a way to make this work in Los Angeles.
- easychris 10y agoThe cities pay 50-150€/mo to the owners [1]. I wouldn't participate if I would own a bar/restaurant. Slightly OT: A shopping mall in germany, where paying for the use of the toilet is voluntary (50Ct / use) makes on avg. ~300€/day, during christmas season up to 8000€/day [2]. If I would own a venue at a highly frequented place I'd rather request 50Ct from the user. ;) [1] https://www.welt.de/regionales/koeln/article13794805/Nette-Toilette-steht-vor-einem-Comeback.html https://www.welt.de/regionales/koeln/article13794805/Nette-T... (german) [2] http://waz.m.derwesten.de/dw/staedte/oberhausen/gladbecker-firma-kassierte-trinkgeld-von-klofrau-id8899268.html?service=mobile http://waz.m.derwesten.de/dw/staedte/oberhausen/gladbecker-f... (german)
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoIn this case your neighbor participating in the program puts you out of (the toilet) business!
- easychris 10y agoI think the toilet business is only a good one on a large scale anyway: mostly due to fixed costs for paying the cleaning staff no matter if you operate a restroom with 1 or 20 seats. BTW: I'm not sure about the neighbor. As I would only ask for a voluntary 50 Ct. there's no reason to prefer the other guys toilet. I assume my toilet would be preferred because it's cleaner (cause I'd pay more to my cleaning staff).
- merb 10y ago> (cause I'd pay more to my cleaning staff). cleaning staff never gets a lot of money and if you need 50 ct to use your toilet it will probably not be the preferred one because people who pay direct money mostly think they can do whatever they want (they paid for it) so every use is more problematic than somebody who can use the toilet for free (exceptions confirm the rule).
- y4mi 10y agodepends. the 50c toilets are often significantly cleaner with automated washing between uses and similar stuff.
- adrianN 10y agoIn Japan public toilets are ubiquitous, free, and fairly clean. I wonder how they do it? Is it because Japanese people generally take better care of public spaces and keeping the toilets clean and operational is thus cheaper?
- rwmj 10y agoThey have a huge army of (mainly old people) cleaning them, so I think it's a sort of public works program to keep people employed -- and one I approve of.
- thro32 10y agoGermany has a huge army of unemployed immigrants.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- beachstartup 10y agoi'm guessing those people aren't going to be real happy with the toilet cleaning job.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWork is work. While I've never enjoyed cleaning toilets in jobs where my duties included that I've never especially objected to it either. I much prefer it to, say, cleaning out the grease traps in a commercial kitchen.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- qznc 10y agoI found the public toilets in Singapur amazing. I'm not sure about cheap labor, but they certainly have draconian penalties for making a mess.
- jamiecurle 10y agoNewcastle Upon Tyne is also doing something similar. [0] https://www.newcastle.gov.uk/environment-and-waste/street-care-and-cleaning/public-toilets https://www.newcastle.gov.uk/environment-and-waste/street-ca... [1] https://www.getintonewcastle.co.uk/city-info/use-our-loos https://www.getintonewcastle.co.uk/city-info/use-our-loos
- Theodores 10y agoIn the cynical British context I see the stickers on windows regarding the scheme and assume that it just means there are no public toilets any more. I would not go in to the cafe etc. for a quick visit to the lavatory, I would still feel odd about not buying anything. It is a cultural thing and I expect most British people would expect their council to maintain public toilets rather than not bother and have some community business scheme. It reeks of privatisation and down sizing the local council.
- zuzun 10y agoBerlin licenses all its advertising space to private companies and lets them build and maintain public toilets as part of the deal. The toilets are usually barrier free and fully automated, i.e. they do a full cleaning after every use. They are in fairly good conditions and I thought this was a great idea, but the senate has issued a request for tender in 2018 so the future is a bit unclear at the moment. http://img.morgenpost.de/img/berlin/crop207814885/0722602716-w820-cv16_9-q85/42418011-621b782d-d10e-4ebe-adc6-58422ca66696.jpg http://img.morgenpost.de/img/berlin/crop207814885/0722602716...
- maelito 10y agoSame in Paris (JCDecaux). But I wonder the cost for just 400 toilets in a city center with 2 million inhabitants and lots of tourists.
- acqq 10y ago"The Germans have figured out a cheap way to provide the public with bathrooms." Aren't the bathrooms the places where somebody can bathe?
- chrisseaton 10y agoIt's a euphemism.
- manarth 10y agoEnglish seems to have an extraordinary number of euphemisms for "that room": Bathroom. Restroom. Water Closet. Loo. Bog. Khazi. John. Privy. I wonder if other languages have such an array of words for a toilet, and how much confusion they cause for foreigners.
- Symbiote 10y ago"Bathroom" and "restroom" are only used in American English. In other English-speaking countries, a bathroom contains a bath, and a restroom sounds like somewhere to go if you're tired. "Toilet" is also a euphemism, it's Middle French for a type of cloth. So is "lavatory", it means wash room. I can't think of a word that isn't vulgar or a euphemism.
- baha_man 10y ago"Toilet" is not a euphemism: "Toilet" was by etymology a euphemism, but is no longer understood as such. As old euphemisms have become the standard term, they have been progressively replaced by newer ones, an example of the euphemism treadmill at work. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toilet#Contemporary_Use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toilet#Contemporary_Use
- chiph 10y ago"Crapper" is not a euphemism. It's the name of the man who invented the siphonic flush toilet: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Crapper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Crapper
- trengrj 10y agoThe public toilet 'problem' (in that public toilets must be bad) isn't really a thing as any mall can seem to handle this issue. When I went to Germany I was amazed at how bad their toilets were and I often had to pay to use them.
- easychris 10y agoA toilet in a mall is not considered public (= state-owned) in context of this article. The latter are usually really dirty and not nice to use.
- icebraining 10y agoI think the point is that many malls have toilets completely open to the public (no payment to keep out "undesirables") and manages to keep them nice and clean.
- manarth 10y agoI would guess that it's because the confined space of a mall makes this this efficient to staff. Firstly, there are multiple toilets within a relatively small area, so one cleaning team can service multiple toilets. Secondly, the small area of a mall minimises travel time (wastage) between toilets. Thirdly, in places where keeping the toilets clean doesn't take enough time to keep the cleaners occupied full-time, there are other general cleaning tasks to occupy them. It's also worth considering the deterrent effect of footfall and supervision: if the toilets are used frequently, and checked/cleaned frequently, people are less likely to carry out wanton acts of vandalism, for fear of getting caught. If you take the example of a city with public toilets on the streets, either each toilet has to be staffed, which would generally be expensive/inefficient, as each toilet wouldn't require a full-time cleaner, or you would need a cleaning team to travel from toilet to toilet, spending time stuck in traffic, looking for a parking space, etc.
- blackbagboys 10y agoMalls have their own private security force to keep out the undesirables.
- xg15 10y agoI like the idea, but... > If a venue took the cash and didn't display its sticker, for example, the public would soon report it to the city. How exactly would "the public" know the venue takes part in the program if they don't display the sticker?
- raphman 10y agoThere's a website (and an app) with a list of all participating venues: http://www.die-nette-toilette.de/wer-macht-bereits-mit.html http://www.die-nette-toilette.de/wer-macht-bereits-mit.html (in German)
- thro32 10y agoI love the downvotes. It is fine to force 70 years old pensioners to clean toilets, but it is not ok to do that to young healthy men ;-)
- mschuster91 10y ago> but it is not ok to do that to young healthy men It is not OK at all to force someone to work. And especially not if all you offer to refugees is menial cleaning work. That's a highly racist opinion you have, and IMO you deserve the downvotes.
- kittiepryde 10y agoIs it more or less ok to let someone starve? ( do they still get handouts if they could have a job if they wanted to work, but they just felt the work beneath them? )
- SixSigma 10y agoHaving people contribute to society that feeds and houses them is extremely racist - who knew ?
- easychris 10y ago> It is fine to force 70 year old pensioners to clean toilets No one forces these 70 years olds to work there. I honestly believe that the people who do are happy to be able to earn some money (because they may not find a "better" job). In Germany no one is really forced to accept a job because of the reasonable good-enough social benefits / welfare systems (not saying that you can live a good life with it though). Anyway, you probably didn't want to discuss a real issue but rather spread your, umh, questionable ideas about the "army" of immigrants. :-/
- thro32 10y agoRetirement age in Japan and Germany is around 65 years. Not everyone qualifies for social benefits (owns house, work history...). And regions like Bavaria are bloody expensive. So yes, some pensioners have to work even in Germany (but it was about Japan in reference to old people). I would be happy to discus my "questionable ideas". I live in Athens and I actually tried to hire some of them for manual labor. Most of them had better shoes than me, were lazy as fuck, and all want to go to Germany. To start a discussion, please post employment rates among migrants ;-)
- cowsandmilk 10y agoIn Boston, a big problem is at 2:30 AM after the bars close and people are wandering the streets to get home because public transit is also (inexplicably) closed. When everything is closed, how do you prevent people from pooping and pissing in alleys (or in broad streetlight)? Or, for the opposite type of person, runners at 5 in the morning have the same problem. Miles away from home, sudden need to go to the bathroom, everything is closed.
- mattmanser 10y agoIt's closed because between 8 and 2:30 they make no money, so why would they keep it open for 6 hours. In the UK the councils subsidise the local transport to stay open till 1/2am.
- chairleader 10y agoBoston has blue laws around the sale of alcohol. See also: no alcohol sales before noon on Sunday, no discounted liquor at restaurants, and every bar/pub that sells liquor must also sell food.
- mattmanser 10y agoI don't understand why I'm being downvoted, can you explain? Public transport loses money in the evenings, across the world they get shut down unless subsidised.
- rsync 10y agoI downvoted you because you talked about your downvotes. Don't interrupt the discussion to meta-discuss the scoring system.
- mattmanser 10y agoI might have phrased it wrong but I was literally asking what was wrong with what I said. I'm getting confused by HN these days, it's like you get random d/vs for absolutely nothing.
- heisenbit 10y agoOne aspect not mentioned is that in Germany when you sell liquid drinks AND provide seats to sit down you also have to provide a toilet for customers. I'm not sure this initiative is actually improving matters. I more believe it is trying to stem the tide of key codes at toilet doors. See this article from last year mentioning "nice toilet" initiative: http://www.faz.net/aktuell/rhein-main/wc-nur-fuer-gaeste-frankfurter-cafebetreiber-schliessen-toiletten-ab-13402228.html http://www.faz.net/aktuell/rhein-main/wc-nur-fuer-gaeste-fra... Google translate: https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=de&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.faz.net%2Faktuell%2Frhein-main%2Fwc-nur-fuer-gaeste-frankfurter-cafebetreiber-schliessen-toiletten-ab-13402228.html https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=de&tl=en&u=h...
- elecengin 10y agoMany coffee shops in downtown NYC have the code/key situation. There are similar regulations in NYC (and I think most of the US, although it is at a local level) that mandate customer bathrooms although they do not sound as strict. For example, small coffee shops (less than ~15 seats) frequently have no customer bathrooms.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nefitty 10y agoWow, that would be one of the first places I'd expect a restroom. Here in Vegas I continually find myself asking for a public restroom at convenience stores. It's usually hit or miss. Most do have seats for gamblers, so it's not the seats, most have hot prepared foods, so it's not that either. I've always thought that places that provide public facilities on their own initiative should maybe get some kind of subsidy for upkeep from the county or city government.
- paganel 10y ago> For example, small coffee shops (less than ~15 seats) frequently have no customer bathrooms. That sucks. As a person with a mild case of "what's-the-closest-toilet?"-angst I would feel quite awkward drinking a coffee and probably eating a cookie on the side knowing that there's no toilet close-by. As a matter of fact that would make me avoid those coffee shops entirely. Bonus link, here's this Seinfeld clip where George speaks for all the people like me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYVBRQ7t46g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYVBRQ7t46g
- radarsat1 10y agoShould be mentioned Paris' automatically cleaning toilets. They are definitely slow and not great when there is a lot of people needing them, but for an otherwise rather dirty city, damned if they are not cleaner and more convenient than what I've seen most other places.
- douche 10y agoThese are supremely confusing if you have never encountered one before... Thankfully, a helpful French man was able to explain the situation to me before I tried to enter one as it was starting it's wash cycle.
- known 10y ago"Diversity society will fail" --Putnam; http://www.boston.com/news/globe/ideas/articles/2007/08/05/the_downside_of_diversity/ http://www.boston.com/news/globe/ideas/articles/2007/08/05/t...
- sctb 10y agoThis account has been posting a lot of unsubstantive comments, but this one is right out of nowhere. Please stop.
- Vitaly 10y agoOr you could just mandate all toilets to be open to the public. Like, for example, in Israel.
- jupp0r 10y agoAs a German, every time I travel to any other country I am impressed how many public toilets there are and the good state they are in.
- pmoriarty 10y agoI've heard a lot of people complain about all the shit on the streets of San Francisco. For such a clearly visible and obviously unwanted problem, I'm shocked and puzzled by the lack of action to provide more public toilets. Why is it so hard? If you don't want shit on the streets, the obvious solution is public toilets, no? Instead, most of the people complaining about the shit on the streets blame it on homeless people, as if it's their fault that there's nowhere for them to shit except on the streets. What are they supposed to do? Hold it in? One group of people has the wherewithal to solve this problem, and it's not the mentally ill homeless people who can barely take care of themselves. You'd think one of the wealthiest countries on the planet would have gotten basic sanitation right by now.
- chrisper 10y agoI think a lot of people just want problems to go away without having to pay anything. You can very much see it in the attitude in the US towards taxes. People do not like taxes. Without taxes, you can only do so much.
- TylerE 10y agoBecause when you provide public toilets, they end up being monopolized by junkies as a place to shoot up.
- ChuckMcM 10y ago..or for a someone to sleep for the night out of the wind. Lots of reasons why a small building providing nothing but toilet services gets re-purposed. I think the German system would work in San Francisco, but if the Bremen experience is correct it should be possible to pay a restaurant $500 a month for leaving their toilet open. That might help fund the additional cleaning and supplies needed.
- pmoriarty 10y agoThe German system would be a step in the right direction (if the restaurants that participated actually let homeless people use their toilets). But most restaurants in SF close pretty early, and some problem parts of the city don't even have restaurants nearby. What would one do at night, or when in one of those problem areas?
- coldcode 10y agoLast time I was in Germany (2015) I had to pay 50pf to the little emperor who ran the toilet in the Paderborn train station; I didn't see the sign about paying (it was blocked by the open door) and he basically attacked me as I walked out. Not sure how this is a wonderful solution. I also remember a European airline wanting to charge people to use the toilet on their planes.
- jagermo 10y agoGerman here. I have never heard of this programm, nor does it seem that big cities like Hamburg, Frankfurt or Munich are part of it. It looks like a nice thing, but the headline is a little misleading, its not in "all German cities", just some.
- kuschku 10y agoMunich is actually joining the program from 2017 on. Bremen already is in it. So, it's actually not that misleading.
- kaikai 10y agoThe city of Santa Cruz, California has a similar program: http://cityofsantacruz.com/departments/economic-development/business-support/visitor-restroom-program http://cityofsantacruz.com/departments/economic-development/... The main downside is that the bathrooms are only open when the businesses are open. That means folks living on the streets still don't have access to toilets for a big chunk of the day.
- broccolisoup 10y agoTo mention the Spanish and Italian way: there are public toilets, some on the street (not that many, mostly near playgrounds), most in public buildings, rail and bus stations and the like. They are always free to use. Condition can be from very good to very poor, depends on the area and who looks after the toilets, mostly. Aside from that, every place serving drinks or foods with the possibility to eat in the premises must have fully equipped toilets, and those are usually in good condition, so what most people do is walk into a bar or restaurant and use those. Some people just ask if it's OK to use the toilet, others will buy an espresso or bottle of water. Personally I ask and then pay for someone else's coffee or tip the barman, but I'm neither Spanish or Italian. Paid toilets are unknown there and would be seen with hostility. Toilets at shopping centres and motorway stops can always be used freely. Petrol stations and underground car parks also tend to have toilets that one can use, sometimes you have to ask for the key. In France, it is mostly the same except that bar/restaurant toilets tend to be, let us say, a character building experience and being a different culture, the "let me use the toilet and I'll buy a bottle of water from you" thing does not quite work (apart from the water being at least €2.-) There are, however, a lot more public toilets, often the self-cleaning type (the French are big on automation, due to their awkward labour laws), and best of all, the "pissoirs" (from "pisser": to piss). There aren't many left, but you can still see them in some villages and small towns. Some pics and history here: http://untappedcities.com/2010/07/08/i-need-to-pee-public-toilets-in-paris/ http://untappedcities.com/2010/07/08/i-need-to-pee-public-to... (also shows the newer automatic toilets), and a bit of an extreme and not completely serious example here: http://www.pwfg.de/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/open-air-pissoir-640x426.jpg http://www.pwfg.de/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/open-air-pisso...
- broccolisoup 10y ago> http://www.pwfg.de/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/open-air-pissoir-640x426.jpg http://www.pwfg.de/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/open-air-pisso... In case anyone wonders about the hose, that's for people of North African or Middle Eastern origin who in addition to or instead of toilet paper, prefer to use water and their (conventionally, left) hand to clean up after full relief--a method which in fact does a far better job than smearing it all over one's arse cheeks.