18 ms·
Global warming: The state of the climate in 2016
- buckbova 10y ago> According to research published last year, spending a day in Beijing is currently akin to smoking almost 40 cigarettes. Decoupling emissions from economic growth thus helps both people and planet. Convincing Mr Trump of this fact is now an urgent and daunting challenge. How is convincing Trump here the answer? Isn't convincing China more important? How about convincing the American people? Do this and politicians will follow. Perhaps if Trump can bring back more industry to the US, he is on his way to helping already.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoI think all of the above are part of the answer. Convincing Trump not to try to prop up coal as he's promised.
- Delmania 10y agoThe Republican leadership has already said there's not much that can be done because coal is private and that government money shouldn't be spent on it. They know, and have known for some time, that coal is a dying industry, but you have to appeal to voters.
- papercrane 10y agoChina is convinced.[1] The American public is convinced, although not as much as they probably should be.[2][3][4] The problem here is to convince world leaders to actually do something. [1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-16/china-tells-trump-that-climate-change-is-no-hoax-it-invented http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-16/china-tell... [2] http://climatepublicopinion.stanford.edu/sample-page/opinions-in-the-states/ http://climatepublicopinion.stanford.edu/sample-page/opinion... [3] https://environment.yale.edu/poe/v2014/ https://environment.yale.edu/poe/v2014/ [4] http://www.gallup.com/poll/190010/concern-global-warming-eight-year-high.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/190010/concern-global-warming-eig...
- strictnein 10y agoChina is convinced? Then China should tell China to stop building coal power plants. They burn slightly more coal than the rest of the world combined. http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/26/business/energy-environment/china-coal.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/26/business/energy-environmen...
- papercrane 10y ago> China is convinced? Then China should tell China to stop building coal power plants. You realise you're source says they're doing exactly that? "In guidelines released on Monday, China halted plans for new coal-fired power stations in many parts of the country, and construction of some approved plants will be postponed until at least 2018." They've also gone all in on solar, having more installed capacity than any other nation. They're far from perfect, but they've started to acknowledge the problem at least.
- problems 10y agoNot only that, but they've taken all these steps while they're bringing hundreds of millions of people out of abject poverty doing sustenance farming and into cities. Cities where they want things like electricity and cars. Look at the history of the world, development like that is usually fueled by burning as many hydrocarbons as possible. It's very good to see a country able now to at least start to break away from that. The rapidly dropping price of solar, thanks in large part to China plays a big role in that.
- yellow_postit 10y agoDespite setbacks China is also actively building up more nuclear capacity, something I wish was taken more seriously in the US http://energypost.eu/china-2016-year-nuclear-power/ http://energypost.eu/china-2016-year-nuclear-power/
- hayavuk 10y agoChina also has a sizable population to match.
- jameskilton 10y agoI'm confused with this statement but I'll try to clear up something you seem to be missing. 1) China is already convinced. It's in the article. They are the world-leading user of solar power and are pushing harder than anyone to get away from dirty power. 2) Trump wants to push and invest in dirty power. He wants to significantly increase the production of coal and gas. The very stuff that causes global warming. Convincing Trump is about saving the world from itself. If Trump has his way, the last 20 years of progress towards renewable energy will be wiped out, with a strong possibility of making life very difficult for humanity in the next 50 - 100 years.
- strictnein 10y ago> are pushing harder than anyone to get away from dirty power. Where do you gather that from? They use more coal than the entirety of the rest of the world combined. Their coal usage has more than doubled over the past ~15 years. http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/26/business/energy-environment/china-coal.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/26/business/energy-environmen...
- leereeves 10y agoThis is from your link: > Now Beijing is trying to slow things down. > In guidelines released on Monday, China halted plans for new coal-fired power stations in many parts of the country, and construction of some approved plants will be postponed until at least 2018. Whether this will amount to anything, who can say?
- derrickdirge 10y agoIt seems like for it to amount to anything, they would also have to close down currently operational plants.
- nyolfen 10y agochina's coal use peaked by 2014: http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/press/releases/2015/China-coal-data-indicates-consumption-fell-in-2014-shows-peak-coal-achievable/ http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/press/releases/20...
- brian-armstrong 10y agoWe (the US) are in a good position to lead the renewables industry, and part of that is dogfooding what we make. But that dogfooding is harder if our domestic nonrenewable prices are low. Yes that means that, for now, those products aren't fully competitive. But they could get there with scale, and we get that scale by rolling them out domestically. It helps us build this industry in the long term. China is also jumping on this opportunity, by the way. I saw an article recently that competitive solar will be a big focus point for its electronics industry.
- maxxxxx 10y agoThe US would be in great position to take the lead here. For example, I don't understand why not every house in Southern California is covered with solar panels. Instead Trump's program seems to be to burn as much coal and oil as possible.
- malnourish 10y agoThis is exactly what I think we should be doing (as a nation). We should be pushing innovation and becoming a leader in R&D for green energy. It seems like a fantastic way of creating jobs and I have a hard time comprehending why people are so resistant to it.
- brian-armstrong 10y agoI hate to beat this drum, but it comes down to money. Oil and coal spend so much money spreading false information about the issues, so it's hard for people to be informed about what our options actually are.
- indlebe 10y agoNot to mention that Oil and Coal are sources of energy where western corporations directly profit. Not so much with solar and nuclear.
- Delmania 10y agoFear. Put yourself in the shoes of a 50-year-old coal miner who's had the same job since he was age 18. You lose your job, and the town in which you live is starting to decline because the major source of money is gone. You have no idea how your going to pay for your bills and food. Do you really think such a person is going to be enthusiastic for retraining for a new, competing with younger people, and moving? Or do you think this person would rather support politicians who promise to restore the coal mining industry?
- the8472 10y agoAs far as building renewables is concerned both countries are currently doing their share. But that trend needs to accelerate and at the same time fossil sources need to be scaled back. Trump's statements on energy policy are mostly contrary to the latter part. http://www.ren21.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/REN12-GSR2015_Onlinebook_low1.pdf http://www.ren21.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/REN12-GSR201... (page 20)
- jamesblonde 10y agoThe canary in the coalmine for global warming is Arctic sea ice. It is melting at an alarming rate, and we can expect an ice-free (>1m sq km of sea ice) Arctic in the summer within a decade or two (or 3-4 years if recent trends continue!). There's a small active community who follow this. We tend to hang out here - a HN level of polite discussion goes on: http://neven1.typepad.com/ http://neven1.typepad.com/
- mugdho 10y agoSo what happens to the indigenous population of animals (polar bears are the first that come to my mind) when this happens? Do they just die out or are there groups trying to get them to safety?
- yellow_postit 10y agoOutside of captivity, where would it be safe for arctic animals?
- mugdho 10y agoProbably nowhere. But the alternative to captivity is that we will just see entire species of animals go extinct.
- Silfen 10y agoWe have already seen many, many species go extinct. The exact figures are not well understood, but there's a lot more at stake than just the polar bear. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction
- shoo 10y agoThere's a 2009 paper "Planetary Boundaries: Exploring the Safe Operating Space for Humanity" that may be of interest. > The planetary boundary (PB) concept, introduced in 2009, aimed to define the environmental limits within which humanity can safely operate. This approach has proved influential in global sustainability policy development. Steffen et al. provide an updated and extended analysis of the PB framework. Of the original nine proposed boundaries, they identify three (including climate change) that might push the Earth system into a new state if crossed and that also have a pervasive influence on the remaining boundaries. They also develop the PB framework so that it can be applied usefully in a regional context. [1] http://science.sciencemag.org/content/347/6223/1259855 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/347/6223/1259855 [2] http://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1063&context=iss_pub http://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?articl... edit: and the indicator that is off the charts relative to its corresponding "safe operating space" boundary is biodiversity loss - measured in species extinction/(millions of species * year). Climate change looks practically controlled compared to that. (ha).
- clumsysmurf 10y ago"Convincing Mr Trump of this fact is now an urgent and daunting challenge." By appointing Myron Ebell to lead the transition at the EPA, Mr Trump has made it clear he's made up his mind. Personnel is policy.
- joering2 10y agoFor those who want to ask obvious follow up question, based on Wikipedia article on Mr. Ebell: Through CEI, Ebell has stated his belief that global warming is a hoax, that most of the data predicting climate change is false, and that the scientific consensus was "phony". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myron_Ebell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myron_Ebell
- blondie9x 10y agoIt's too bad Americans cannot vote for some of the most prominent cabinet members the way they vote for President/Vice-President. Many of these appointees will have a more direct impact on people's lives but yet they have no say in who will represent them. Democracy?
- mordocai 10y agoRepresentative Democracy yeah. The people voted in Trump who now gets to appoint those positions.
- tnecniv 10y agoWell they need to be let in by congress, who the public also voted for...
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>The people voted in Trump Well no. The people voted in Clinton, and the Electoral College upweighted some votes and downweighted others in a way that favors Trump. The EC once had a distinct purpose, but right now just seems to give Republicans a structural advantage, to the ultimate detriment of Democrats and Democrat-leaners in small or rural states.
- anon1253 10y agoMy worry is that Trump doesn't deny it (well he does publicly), but rather privately realizes that it's already far too late. There's nothing we can do, collapse of global civilization before mid-century is probably inevitable. So what can you do, well ramp up every dirty trick you can think off … because it doesn't really matter and it makes you look good with the public (sorry to say, it does, climate change is still not popular in public discourse). To stay within the 1.5 to 2ºC bounds, the IPCC already includes massive carbon sequestering technologies in even its most simple recommendations. This is technology that does not exist. We're betting life on Earth (and truly, it is that dire) on tech that might be impossible to build and scale. Even if we reduce our carbon emissions to 0 today the delayed effects and non-linear dynamics are so poorly understood, that it could very well be that nothing truly can be done to avoid our mass extinction. And, this too goes for carbon sequestering; even if we magically suck the last 5 decades of carbon out of the air, some stuff that is broken can't be fixed. Thresholds, catastrophes, oscillations, bifurcations, etc are real. We really have to think in non-linear systems when dealing with climate, and that is something we're very bad at. Especially when it comes to the media-voter complex. But picture this, you are driving your car down some road, and everything is fine. You're minding your own business. There's nobody else there, so what the heck, let's ramp up some of the speed. And you go faster and faster. Until bam, unexpected steep corner, your car flies off the road and you die. At that point going back a couple of miles is never going to fix you. It's too late.
- sqeaky 10y agoCarbon sequestering is not as hard as it would seem. We have several technologies, but we can also just plant trees.
- anon1253 10y agoYes trees are a perfect solution. They've optimized this process through millions of years of evolution. However, we're still removing more trees than adding them per year. Quite impressively so, even. It takes time for forests to grow. A lot of its carbon sink properties are because of soil succession, which takes decades to mature.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dharma1 10y agoThis graph of global sea ice area is kind of alarming: https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-JX41K2UK6Io/WCvyXQ6CFvI/AAAAAAAAWBs/1KITPEgbPlgvKjGPLMoXfHfqnnQ84EZXACLcB/s1600/nsidc_global_area_byyear_b-Nov-14-2016.png https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-JX41K2UK6Io/WCvyXQ6CFvI/AAAAAAAAW... More info: http://arctic-news.blogspot.co.uk/ http://arctic-news.blogspot.co.uk/
- spacehacker 10y agoFortunately, sea ice does not contribute much to the sea level because it displaces about the same volume it will add when melted.
- dharma1 10y agoYep, but it does have other negative effects. https://www.carbonbrief.org/five-reasons-why-the-speed-of-arctic-sea-ice-loss-matters https://www.carbonbrief.org/five-reasons-why-the-speed-of-ar...
- saosebastiao 10y agoAlbedo is a measure of how well the earth’s surface reflects sunlight. Snow-covered sea ice has a high albedo and reflects 85 per cent of sunlight. But the open water revealed as ice melts is darker and absorbs more – reflecting just seven per cent. Yep, that's terrifying.
- wiredfool 10y agoBut sea ice has an albedo affect. Dark seas absorb more heat.
- flukus 10y agoDepends on where it's coming from. Some of those increases are because of on land glaciers thinning and spreading over the ocean.
- snowwrestler 10y agoI don't actually believe this, but it occurred to me the other day as a funny way to look at a very sad situation: What if Trump does believe global warming is real, but recognizes that we're too late to stop its worst effects? What if he expects the world to go to hell over the next 50 years and is focused on protecting the U.S. specifically? What would he do? He'd build a wall across the lower border of the U.S. to keep out southern populations fleeing extreme heat. But he'd keep the border with Canada open, so Americans can flee there if they need to. The oceans will protect us from the rest of the world. He'd disentangle us from overseas treaty obligations that might draw us into wars we wouldn't otherwise want to fight. And he'd focus international relations on the few biggest countries who are most likely to secure and defend their own societies. He'd incentivize U.S. companies to manufacture domestically: long supply chains are a risk. He'd ramp up infrastructure spending--particularly on the coasts--to be ready to build sea walls and other mitigating structures. He'd strengthen law enforcement to deal with internal unrest. Like I said, I don't actually believe this... EDIT: Another (and perhaps more likely) way to look at this is that Trump and his posse are just paranoid nuts, but by ignoring global warming, they will inadvertently bring about the global calamity that they fear.
- zelon88 10y agoI like that the theory has to assume that Canada is just naturally expected to take in American refugees while Mexico can go screw itself. With such ignorant American exceptionalism it's no wonder why we haven't fixed global warming yet.
- jdavis703 10y agoYou do realize a plurality of American voters voted for Hillary Clinton? She's leading by margins larger than Kennedy and Nixon. Edited to use correct terminology.
- grzm 10y agoI understand your point, but plurality ≠ majority. Plurality is more votes than any other candidate. Majority means more than 50% of the vote. This doesn't detract from the point you're trying to make, but it is inaccurate. You strengthen your argument by using the appropriate word.
- intrasight 10y agoI believe that it is already too late. Here's my proposed solution. Send a robot into space. Pickup an asteroid and bring it to Lagrangian L1. Have it begin weaving a solar curtain.
- anon1253 10y agodoesn't fix the ocean acidification
- intrasight 10y agoyou got me there
- CptJamesCook 10y agoThe conclusion of this article is not that global warming is dangerous but that local air pollution is bad for public health: "According to research published last year, spending a day in Beijing is currently akin to smoking almost 40 cigarettes. Decoupling emissions from economic growth thus helps both people and planet. Convincing Mr. Trump of this fact is now an urgent and daunting challenge." Why should Donald Trump worry about local air pollution in Beijing? This has nothing to do with climate change. I highly doubt Donald Trump thinks thick smog is a good thing.
- acqq 10y agoIt's mentioned at the end of the article but it's not the main message. The reason it's mentioned is to give the argument why China will have to reduce their own emissions, no matter what other countries do. Then it concludes that Trump should understand the same that China has to understand: "Decoupling emissions from economic growth thus helps both people and planet."
- dcgudeman 10y ago"According to research published last year, spending a day in Beijing is currently akin to smoking almost 40 cigarettes." Wow
- greeneggs 10y agoThere have been a number of studies on how many deaths can be attributed to air pollution. It seems to be ~1 million deaths a year in China. Here's a typical source (a press release with good graphs, the original paper is linked in it): https://www.healtheffects.org/system/files/HEI-GBD-MAPS-China-Press-Release.pdf https://www.healtheffects.org/system/files/HEI-GBD-MAPS-Chin...
- meganvito 10y agoIf it is truely a big problem, it will be more strengthful to let the denying end to fully deploy their defense. The hope may the system resilient enough not on an irreversable track which has a penalty not bailable.
- pmarreck 10y agoCan someone point me to a URL with an arguably good prediction of how these increasing temperatures would negatively effect the ecosystem specifically? Are we talking mass extinctions? More powerful storms/more extreme weather events? And/or something else?
- cbennett 10y agohttp://climate.nasa.gov/effects/ http://climate.nasa.gov/effects/
- codecamper 10y agoWhat about the Elon Musk <-> Peter Thiel <-> Trump connection? Trump respects Peter. He's young & rich. Peter is an engineer. He must believe in global warming. He wants to live forever, so he'll need a good planet for that. Musk is a firm believer in green tech. Peter respects Musk? The future of the planet depends on how Peter Thiel explains the role of clean tech to Trump! (I'm starting to be very happy about that $1 million Peter handed over to Trump)
- grzm 10y ago"He must believe in global warming." While I understand what motivates your thinking so, I don't think you can assume this. I haven't looked for anything that addresses Thiel's opinion on this btw, so I'm agnostic on the issue.
- codecamper 10y agoPeter has invested in clean tech before. He's a technologist. He wants to live forever (on a stable climate planet). We can assume he believes in global warming.
- grzm 10y agoI could be cynical and view his clean tech investments as a capitalist assessing the market, independent of his beliefs in global warming. If enough people want clean tech for whatever reason (including false beliefs in climate change), investing in clean tech can be a smart move. That said, I did find a quote that indicates he cares about the environment. Thiel told the TechCrunch Disrupt crowd that "one potential route for cleantech energies is to work with something that’s slightly more environmentally friendly than current sources — natural gas. It's a cheaper form of energy that's much more ubiquitous, and has less of an environmental impact than most energy sources today, but has not been harnessed." http://www.thegreenskeptic.com/2011/09/peter-thiel-cleantech-disaster-well-not.html http://www.thegreenskeptic.com/2011/09/peter-thiel-cleantech... Concerns about the environment don't necessarily mean belief in global warming. His NYT editorial "The New Atomic Age We Need" talks about other's concerns about climate change, but never his own position on climate change, just on nuclear energy. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/28/opinion/the-new-atomic-age-we-need.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/28/opinion/the-new-atomic-age... An interview he did with Glenn Beck for the Blaze quotes him as calling climate science pseudoscience. Thiel: I do think that having a space where you can think for yourself and where it doesn't always get second-guessed is very important. We have a we have all these monolithic debates about science or pseudoscience. Like there's the climate change debate. Beck: Is that science or pseudoscience? Thiel: I think it's more pseudoscience. Whenever you can't have a debate I often think that's evidence that there's a problem. When people use the word science, it's often a tell like in poker that you're bluffing. We have social science, we have political science. We don't call it physical science or chemical science, we just call them physics and chemistry because we just know they're right and you can debate the periodic table of elements. No one will be upset if you ask questions about that. We call it climate scicence. It's a tell like in poker. It's telling you that people are exaggerating, and that they're bluffing a little bit. But I think this monolithic culture is breaking down. People are asking questions. You know the weather has not been getting warmer for the past 15 years. The hockey stick that Al Gore predicted in the early 2000s on the climate has not happened for the last decade. I think as this monolithic culture breaks down you can have more real debates and I think that would be a good thing on net. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CoxxGhLFbw4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CoxxGhLFbw4 I just did the transcript myself, so there are very likely mistakes. I also tried to clean up the language a bit. I won't quibble if people point them out. If someone feels I've misrepresented what he said, please do correct me. There's a lot of language there that sounds like that of climate change skeptics. I'm not trying to be obstinate here. I've been surprised by many of the opinions shared by HN commenters that I would think are incongruent (and I'm sure some think the same of mine). I guess I'm a "Peter Thiel Believes in Climate Change" skeptic. Happy to be shown I'm wrong. Edit: I realize I'm equating "global warming" and "climate change". I don't think that changes what I've written, but if it does, please let me know.
- lossolo 10y agoI've read interesting post couple of days ago about Global Warming on reddit: "Hey guys this research isn't really finding out anything that wasn't already known. RCP 8.5 scenario, which they assumed in their modelling, has long been known to be effectively Armageddon. Any temperature rise past 5.5 degrees is probably irrelevant because there wont be any humans left to deal with that outcome. However it's looking increasingly likely that we aren't on the RCP 8.5 pathway. RCP 8.5 calls for steady continued growth in emissions of around 3%+ per year, which is what we were on in the early part of this decade. The last three years emissions have been effectively flat in spite of ongoing economic growth, and the Paris pledges that will keep warming to about 2.8 degrees call for the emissions peak to be in 2040~ (RCP 4.5). Based on trends in renewables, the downturn in the coal industry, and emissions growth halting, it's increasingly hard to see how we could possibly get back on track to an RCP 8.5 scenario. 2.8 degrees will still be terrible for environment, the economy, and poorer nations of course, and we should really be aiming for the RCP 2.6 scenario, where emissions peak no later than 2020. It's possible emissions have peaked already, but we will need more than three years of data to determine that. Of course, than comes the hard part of taking offline the carbon intensive elements of the world economy (i.e Coal)" source: https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/5cz4a7/new_climate_change_estimate_predicts_global/da0sfad/ https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/5cz4a7/new_climate...