18 ms·
LinkedIn is now officially blocked in Russia
- 0xmohit 10y agoGiven how LinkedIn works [0], it doesn't appear too bad. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11063178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11063178
- ivan_gammel 10y agoThat was quick - it's already not accessible from Megafon cellular networks. LinkedIn is quite popular among international HRs hiring software developers in Russia. HRs may still have access, but the workforce now does not. What was the point not to comply with regulatory requirements? Too small market? Too hard to throw some user data to a server in some Moscow datacenter for persistent storage?
- lisivka 10y agoRisk of leaking of databases, which are vital for their business, is too high, IMHO. Did you remember closed government databases, with private information, written on CD and sold at Gorbushka for pennies?
- ivan_gammel 10y agoThat risk isn't bigger than anywhere else since we are talking about private company really concerned about security. How many leaks were there through government channels from Mail.ru Group or Yandex? None, and the reason is that, given all necessary security measures taken, you cannot just copy such a database to CD. The access will be limited to few well-paid people in IT Ops, the database can be secured using a solution certified by FSB (and even if FSB will hack it, these guys do not expose themselves by selling CDs on Gorbushka).
- lisivka 10y agoAFAIK, you can buy mail.ru databases[1]. Quote: «A vendor going by the online handle of “saul_berenson” is selling 57 million Mail.ru accounts on darknet in BTC 1.0000 (628.78 US Dollar). The sold data includes emails and MD5 passwords of Mail.ru users. According to the seller, “these passwords are very easy to crack.” Remember Mail.ru was hacked twice, one in July and August 2016 when 27 million accounts were stolen and before that in May 2016 when 57 million accounts were stolen. We suspect that the stolen data is from May 2016 breach. Yandex is another Russian Internet giant serving as the country’s largest search engine and like Mail.ru the corporation has been under attack by hackers numerous times. However, now, a vendor is selling 6.5 million Yandex accounts containing emails and passwords. The total number of sold accounts is 659,5756 with both hashed and clear-text passwords.» The whole idea of an government operation, like that, is to put finger first, then whole hand. When data will be in Russia, government will demand 24x7 access to it. Then data will be copied somewhere, then sold. [1] https://www.hackread.com/utorrent-forum-mailru-yandex-data-darknet/ https://www.hackread.com/utorrent-forum-mailru-yandex-data-d...
- twelve40 10y ago> selling 57 million Mail.ru accounts Seriously? I can give you free access to credentials from 164,611,595 LinkedIn accounts right now. This data has been copied and sold many times over with zero help from any government.
- baybal2 10y agowell, allegedly somebody sold Putin's own bank accounts in Cyprus on blackhack a year ago
- QUFB 10y agoLinkedIn doesn't seem to mind if their Chinese databases are leaked; they complied with similar requirements there. If the market in Russia were as large as China, I'm certain they would make a compromise too.
- tobltobs 10y agoI didn't know about this crazy new regulatory requirements until now. Quoting from an article [1] describing the new law: > “When collecting personal data, including through information and the internet telecommunications network, the operator is required to provide a record that the systematization, accumulation, storage, updating and retrieval of personal data of citizens of the Russian Federation, is held on databases located in the territory of the Russian Federation.” I could imagine that complying to this regulation wont be worthwhile for most companies. Edit: The interesting thing is, that the law seems not to forbid to store the data outside of Russia, it "just" dictates that the data has to be stored in Russia also. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2014/07/02/russia-moves-to-ban-online-services-that-dont-store-personal-data-in-russia/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/07/02/russia-moves-to-ban-online...
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI wonder what sort of onus is on the operators to determine the citizenship of its users. How do I know that Andrey Zhukov is a citizen of the Russian Federation? Does a Russian name and a home address of Saint Petersburg suffice?
- baybal2 10y agoThey don't. That's the trick
- devoply 10y agoAt the end of the day, creating many of these services is trivial. Creating a LinkedIn clone is trivial, and one will pop up in Russia giving some Russian owners profit and creating jobs for Russians. So how it's bad for the Russian economy, or the economy of any country to do this, is beyond me. On the other hand, dictatorships and capitalist democracies love to gather as much information as they can on their citizens, so it will allow Russians to get more information on their citizens. Which may be bad for some of them.
- frozenport 10y agoBecause a large part of the Russian software market is overseas.and many developers work on contract. Further, this helps the Kremlin's agenda which has lead to economic stagnation, and the average gdp of Russians dropping below that of China.
- atria 10y agoI'm sure this has nothing to do with recent articles detailing how Russian FSB agents successfully use LinkedIn to find, contact, groom, and network with potential sources and agents on Wall Street.
- LeonidBugaev 10y agoWorth noticing that court blocked only HTTP version "http://www.linkedin.com/" http://www.linkedin.com/", HTTPS works just fine :) However some providers, who had no smart hardware, may block by IP instead of URL, and https version will be blocked as well (not my case).
- degorov 10y agoAlready not true as of 2016-11-18 10:50 MSK. All protocols/ports should be blocked by ISP's for both www and apex.
- pfarnsworth 10y agoHonestly, if LinkedIn disappeared today worldwide, I wouldn't miss it one second. It's really more of a chore than anything else. When you're looking for a job, or looking to recruit, it's helpful, but they haven't made the case of general everyday use, and I doubt they ever will.
- Raphmedia 10y agoJoins groups on it. I am in a few web dev. groups and we have discussions, people share links, ask questions, etc.
- secfirstmd 10y agoDitto, it seems most to mostly be stories of: "10 years ago I was a alcoholic leprechaun but today I finally got that job working as a chimney sweep" "Here's a picture of me with a homeless person I spoke to on my way to work today. It turns out they are people too." "Don't you just love our military personnel/democracy/babies? One like to show you love these things. One share to show you don't hate them." "Here's a pointless meme about mindfullness" "Hey look at my dog wearing a santa costume" (actually that would be kind of cool)
- julianozen 10y agoI feel like LinkedIn will find a way in. They're the terminator of social networks
- EugeneOZ 10y agoPlease block as many services as possible in Russia, it will motivate our people to change government (by force, maybe) faster.
- jwtadvice 10y agoSimilarly, please continue to leak as many illegal activities of the United States government as possible, it will motivate our people to change government (by force, maybe) faster.
- homakov 10y agoFrom Russia, can confirm. Finally roscomnadzor is preventing spam!
- AlfeG 10y agoUnfortunatly, I still receieve emails from linkedin...
- mlvljr 10y agoThis pal is right fellas, gmail still has their spam :)
- degorov 10y agoActually, you probably will still get emails from them, but won't be able to open unsubscribe links.
- meshr 10y agoRoscomnadzor will prevent using Internet one day with applauding russians. For what to herds are the gifts of freedom? Pushkin
- Taylor_OD 10y agoIt still blows my mind that people are on linkedin. If you are not a recruiter/hiring manager it's only real purpose (that I can see) is to be a boasting board for achievements and a easy to ignore place to receive recruiting emails. Does anyone get any other value out of it?
- geoka9 10y agoGot a dream job out of the blue through LinkedIn. Was skeptical when the cold call came in, but decided to talk to the recruiter and ended up accepting the offer. YMMV, but you never know.
- dekhn 10y agosure, I use it to manage connections to people who meet me at conferences.
- afterburner 10y ago"receive recruiting emails" That's pretty much it, right? That, and very easy job applications. Nowhere have I had an easier time applying for a job.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoThink of it as a recruiters database. Works pretty well that way. Need a new job? Just message everyone. It's not social media. That's Facebook, etc. At least that's how I see it.
- sdm 10y agoIt's great for lead gen, researching competitors, networking, etc. It doesn't apply much to a developer's day to day, but there are more than just developers out there. Recruiting is a very small part of Linkedin.
- Scea91 10y agoI got lots of interesting offers from linkedin. Also I didn't have to bother to write my CV in years, because I can just link anyone to my up to date linkedin profile.
- 10y ago
- dz0ny 10y agoIt should be blocked everywhere :)
- hal9000xp 10y agoAs a Russian citizen, I used LinkedIn heavily to find jobs in Europe (along with stackoverflow.com/jobs). I keep a lot of contacts there (e.g. former colleagues and European recruiters, some of them are very helpful). I found it's alarming that LinkedIn is blocked in Russia. Blocking LinkedIn significantly reduces chances to find a job in Europe. But I expected that since I watched closely on new laws restricting internet freedom in Russia. Official motivation behind this law is to prevent US spying on Russian citizens (this law was proposed after Snowden's scandal). Of course, this motivation was a lie as everything else which came out of dirty rotten mouths of nasty Kremlin bastards. The real motivation is that the Kremlin loves to spy on its own citizens. And they already did that for a long time. The problem is that these anti-freedom laws do bother only very small percentage of Russians. The rest of Russia won't even notice if Kremlin completely shuts down access to the global internet. Heck, the majority of Russians doesn't even bother to learn elementary English! Stupid people buy everything Kremlin tells them, including version about protecting Russian citizens from US NSA. The general principle is that any government is constantly trying to expand itself and limit citizen's freedoms. The only force which can prevent government from endlessly limiting citizen's freedoms is the majority of citizens (definitely not a minority of non-rich citizens). Every freedom above what masses asking for is only at mercy of the government's bueracrats. It means that in absolutely any country masses fully deserve their government. I wrote more details about this principle here: https://www.quora.com/Why-do-people-living-in-totalitarian-states-love-their-dictators-1/answer/Eldar-Gaynetdinov?srid=xsEM https://www.quora.com/Why-do-people-living-in-totalitarian-s... So I consider myself as a part of absolute tiny minority of Russian citizens which has no voice at all (thanks to backward masses). That's why I left Russia and I hope forever! I think LinkedIn could be unblocked if LinkedIn agrees to meet these crazy requirements. Even if LinkedIn would be unblocked, it won't change sad state of freedoms in Russia. P.S. I hope to get rid of toxic Russian citizenship in the future.
- wruza 10y agoAnd you buy everything various conspiracy theorists and layman politicians sell to you. We have some issues, right, but your generalizing 'stupid' attitude is really better off this land, no matter who's in power.
- 10y ago
- kimshibal 10y agoMy friend. We use ВКонтакте for everything.
- sakopov 10y agoI'm not in Russia but I can pretty much confirm this. It feels like the number of reposts on VK containing videos from small companies asking for referrals to fill positions has almost quadrupled in last several months. I guess it's working out quite well.
- w8rbt 10y agoIt seems like a reasonable requirement. If you want to do business there, then setup a data center and store data there.
- meshr 10y agoInternet ends when every country will start to force everyone else to do what they think is good. In digital world physical geo-location doesn’t matter unless you want to fool someone. You can store data in Russia but give access to it to CIA. You can store data in USA but make it impossible to access by CIA.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dima_medvedev 10y ago"We wanted as good as possible, but it turned out as always" Viktor Chernomyrdin, Russian politician The law itself is more or less reasonable, but very poorly done and applied, like almost all recent Russian internet laws.
- pc2g4d 10y agoIsn't this basically a protectionism move designed to strengthen local social networks?
- Pica_soO 10y agoCareer has arrived? You must construct additional Tor-Nodes!
- treebeard901 10y agoWe require more vespene cash.
- cynoclast 10y ago>'It’s not clear why LinkedIn — which has out of its 467 million users, only 5 million registered in Russia — was targeted in this case. ' Probably because they keep getting fucking hacked: http://www.wired.co.uk/article/linkedin-data-breach-find-out-included http://www.wired.co.uk/article/linkedin-data-breach-find-out... And Russia is tired of Russians getting fucked by shitty American software engineers.
- camboyero1992 10y agoTotalitarianism all over... 1984 monitoring voted in UK (right after Brexit), Trump win in the US, Putin and Erdogan on the east, China and its big walls imprisoning billions... I am honestly giving up hope on the human race.
- bayesian_horse 10y agoRussia likes to copy EU strategies and uses them for other purposes. For example, the EU and its members really like to go after US companies for privacy protection. This is usually a good thing for the consumers, but can feel like a targeted attack to the US companies in question. However, when the Russian Federation does - on the surface - almost the same thing, it suddenly has a very different impact...
- supergirl 10y agoso you say if Europe does something, it's good. If Russia does the same thing, it's bad, because it's Russia. OK.
- bayesian_horse 10y agoPutin likes to make it look that way, yes. And on the surface it does. Beneath the surface, there are lots of important differences. The EU doesn't block websites. It doesn't control the media. It ensures freedom of speech. It makes it possible even for US companies to do business in the EU, without the fear that their servers are seized whenever some corrupt regime decides to. The EU doesn't go after dissidents... and the list goes on and on...
- degorov 10y agoWhy does then wikipedia have articles with lists of websites blocked in different EU countries?
- supergirl 10y agoThat's so naive, to think that any country isn't simply pursuing its own interests. I'll argue some of your points for fun. > The EU doesn't block websites Really? What about all the torrent sites being blocked? Same as Russia, EU has their own agenda for blocking websites. It doesn't need to be for the same reasons or the same websites. > It doesn't control the media. Really? Pretty sure any newspaper/tv station has an affiliation/bias with one party/view or another. Also, same as Russia having state owned media, other countries in Europe have that too, for example the public national televisions and radios. Then there is the social media. Try posting something illegal on facebook and see if it is controlled or not. Try calling for a protest against something. You might get a visit from the police [1]. > It ensures freedom of speech What exactly is freedom of speech? No country has 100% freedom of speech. How much does Russia have? How much do other countries have? How do you measure it? Let's say in Russia I can't insult Putin (although probably you can), in UK I can't insult the queen, in US I can't insult the FBI. Is there a difference? Insulting can mean different things in different countries. > It makes it possible even for US companies to do business in the EU Of course they do, EU is almost like another part of the US. In collaboration with the US they also use these tech companies to spy. But still, not all US business is welcomed. Some countries protect their own interests. That is why this EU-US free trade treaty is hard to get signed. > without the fear that their servers are seized whenever some corrupt regime decides to Yeah, US companies definitely do not fear their servers being seized because the US is doing all the seizing. In any case, this is a mutual benefit deal. But recently there is a shift against big US companies and their tax practices. So far, there was no seizing, but let's see what happens next. > The EU doesn't go after dissidents What about Snowden, what about Assange? Pretty sure Assange would go to Russia if he could. Of course, EU encourages and protects dissidents of countries such as China and Russia. In turn these countries do the same. But nobody is better. [1] http://www.dw.com/en/online-anti-refugee-posts-lead-to-offline-visits-by-dutch-police/a-19005888 http://www.dw.com/en/online-anti-refugee-posts-lead-to-offli...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- duaneb 10y agoLucky bastards. /s
- odbol_ 10y agoGreat! Maybe now I'll stop getting spam connect requests from all these Russians I don't even know...
- rdiddly 10y agoLinkedIn didn't just "get blocked" out of the blue. They got blocked after many warnings and plenty of time during which they refused to take basic steps to comply with the laws of a sovereign nation. Just set up some servers in a Russian datacenter and be done with it! But instead they blew it off, or created the impression of blowing it off, by going running to the Russian bureaucrats on the last day -- as if the whole thing were a big surprise! If you wanted to insult them, show them you didn't take them seriously and didn't make a plan to comply with their laws, I can't think of a better way to do it than going to them on the last day to ask for more time. If I were those bureaucrats I would take especial relish in cutting them off. (And that's aside from the fact that it's a worthless site in the first place.) Sometimes when you get Tased it's because of crooked cops, but most of the time it's because you're being an ass, disregarding the laws of the people, despite many warnings, and not taking simple steps to comply.
- meshr 10y agoLinkedIn denied to play by rules of idiots. Shame on Google etc who supports and promotes censorship by accepting the rules of censorship. Internet ends when every country will start to force everyone else to do what they think is good.
- technion 10y agoWell I went to see if there was any news on this for an Australian, and all I found when I logged into LinkedIn was this advice regarding "restricting" my account from use: http://imgur.com/a/VOBQV http://imgur.com/a/VOBQV I haven't sent out a direct message or "added" anyone in months, and the only recently posted content was this blog: https://lolware.net/2016/11/17/requesting_bank_login.html https://lolware.net/2016/11/17/requesting_bank_login.html Despite not being able to log in, I've received two separate emails from them. I have a feeling I'll be letting LinkedIn go.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bikamonki 10y agoA similar law is about to pass in my country and we are 15 weeks away from elections. I believe the targets are FB and Twitter. So what is my best bet to rollout a Twitter clone fast and host it in-house? Impossible?
- btgeekboy 10y agoThe magic of Facebook, Twitter, etc are not the technologies. Sure, as they grow, they need more elegant than off-the-shelf solutions. But hacking together a Twitter clone in a week is the easy part - getting people to use it, building a community, etc, is the hard part.
- gumernatorial 10y agoThe hardest part is that once your Twitter clone functions well enough to replace Twitter it will be banned just the same.
- tmptmp 10y agoI wonder, where is Snowden now? What has he to say about it? Has he ever spoken anything against the oppression done by the Russian govt? We should be asking him tough questions, not just joining in praising him to be some sort of hero, who is cozying up with criminals in Kremlin.
- icebraining 10y agoHas he ever spoken anything against the oppression done by the Russian govt? If you'd bothered to look up, you'd know he has.
- Mikeb85 10y ago> Amid a tense stand-off and attempt at negotiations, Russia’s communications regulator Roskomnadzor has started to enforce a proposed block of LinkedIn in the country, after the social network failed to transfer Russian user data to servers located in the country, violating a law instituted in Russia requiring all online sites to store personal data on national servers. Not the worst rationale. Keep in mind that countries such as Canada and EU countries also have different privacy laws that US corporations have ran afoul of from time to time.