18 ms·
Something I've been wondering about: We're seeing this pattern where the coasts of many countries are cosmopolitan and well-integrated into the world economy,
by nostrademons 10y ago
Something I've been wondering about:
We're seeing this pattern where the coasts of many countries are cosmopolitan and well-integrated into the world economy, but the interiors are very conservative and nationalistic. Scotland & London vs. Wales & the rest of Britain. The U.S. West Coast & Northeast vs. the Farm Belt, Rust Belt, and Mountain states. Croatia & Slovenia vs. the rest of Yugoslavia. The Baltic Republics vs. the rest of the USSR. Even in a Red State like Texas, Houston (on the coast) has gone democratic.
What happens if economic ties between coastal regions of major trading partners become greater than cultural ties within nations?
Here in California, some of the proposals about sending all the immigrants back to where they came from seem absurd. The economy would cease to function. On one of my teams of 10 people at Google, we had immigrants from Iceland, England, Vietnam, China, Taiwan, and India, and I was the only native-born American citizen. California would sooner secede than deport all of its immigrants.
What if it actually came to that? If push came to shove and the interior decided to push a nativist, nationalist agenda, what if the coastal regions that benefit significantly from trade were to say "Okay, you guys can play with yourself, we're going to play with the rest of the world." Scotland has threatened to do exactly that, and is planning on holding another referendum on independence if Britain actually follows through on Brexit.
What sort of organizing principle would the world have then? I haven't seen anything historically like that - the closest would be the Roman Empire that rimmed the Mediterranean. For most of recorded history, the primary means of production has been land and so fights have been over land, but over the last 150 years or so (contemporaneous with the nation-state as a social organizing principle, BTW), the primary means of production shifted to capital, and now it's shifting to information. What kind of social organizing principle does that imply?
- s_kilk 10y ago> What sort of organizing principle would the world have then? I haven't seen anything historically like that Basically City-States
- nostrademons 10y agoActually, yeah, it has a lot in common with city states. It differs from historical city-states in that the primary factor of production in the classical/medieval era was land, and so city states negotiated from a position of weakness and remained confined to the city because they lacked the resources to capture more territory. Now, food is abundant, and actually requires fossil fuels and genetic engineering for its production. That changes the negotiating position of a port city without a lot of land significantly. (It does make me wonder what would happen if we got a nationalist heartland ringed by a number of small city states, and then the heartland would refuse to sell food. Massive famine and political collapse? Peaceful trade with overseas nations to supply an alternate source? A large army streaming out of the city states to capture the heartland by force? Mutually assured destruction where everyone dies, since modern crops don't actually grow by themselves without fresh inputs of chemical fertilizers, pesticides, antibiotics, and genetically-modified seeds?)
- zigzigzag 10y agoFood is abundant but still grows outside of cities. There's no particular reason to assume that genetic engineering companies are all based in cities. A city state arrangement is one I was thinking about a lot lately but it seems very hard to make it stable.
- morgante 10y agoYup. I actually think the world is ripe for the return of city-states. The advantages of nation-states have fallen in importance, while their disadvantages have become increasingly clear. Just look at the success of Singapore to see how effective a modern city-state can be. London, New York, San Francisco, etc. would all be better off as independent self-governing city-states.
- noobermin 10y agoWhat will happen to the interiors when they realize their tax subsidies won't exist anymore?
- flukus 10y agoWhat will happen to the cities when the realize they need food and other items from the interiors?
- noobermin 10y agoI guess it will become a sort of inefficient, hyper-federalist system.
- leurfete 10y agoSeems like having the interior pay its own way by selling food and other resources would be quite a lot more efficient. It would also allow people to govern themselves how they see fit. It's a more humane solution IMO.
- sbmassey 10y agoWhy inefficient? Easing the burden of centralised government on all interstate trade should be more efficient, I would think
- eitally 10y agoIf this actually happened, people in the interior wouldn't be able to afford the food they were selling.
- bambax 10y agoIt's an interesting question. But doesn't the fact that coastal regions are pro-trade and interior lands are against it tell us that people are pro-trade when they engage in it and against it when they don't? So a response may be to get more people engage in trade and globalization instead of only seeing the bad sides, the closed factories, etc. How does one do that I don't know. Maybe Google should move its campus to Iowa.
- nostrademons 10y agoI think that's both an accurate assessment and a useful prescription. I don't know how to get more people to engage in trade either. Better education, probably. Even though I live in the Bay Area, used to work for a multinational corporation, know plenty of immigrants (including a parent), and have entrepreneurial friends that basically employ an army of international contractors through UpWork, I still find myself reluctant to take the plunge and take advantage of globalization.
- taurath 10y agoSorry if you're employing an army of international contractors through upwork you're taking advantage of globalization.
- nostrademons 10y agoI'm not, but I have a number of friends who are.
- taurath 10y agoAh wow, I completely misread. I'll take my downvote and move on then!
- throwaway911911 10y agoGoogle is hiring in Iowa: https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/inside/locations/council-bluffs/working-here.html https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/inside/locations/co...
- r00fus 10y agoThe US civil war was fought in part because the southern states threatened to secede. Do you think the US would let California leave? Can CA defend her own borders (especially against the rest of the US)?
- int_19h 10y ago> Do you think the US would let California leave? It actually might now. The Right is in full control of the country, and it had been generally very sympathetic to the idea of just splitting up the country and each going their own way lately. It was never really seriously looked at by the Left - sure, there are semi-joking proposals like Cascadia, but nothing as serious as, say, Texas secessionists. But right now Cascadia might sound like a very good idea for a lot of people.
- bobjordan 10y agoThe better more workable suggestion for these times is for the Federal Government to give the states back more of their individual powers. The Republican party is certainly more open to that vs. the Democrats.
- int_19h 10y agoIt would have been workable, if not for one thing that Republicans have consistently promised their electorate for a long time now: a federal abortion ban. Liberals will not see anything including that as a legitimate "states rights" solution for themselves. Secession resolves this issue, and can even score points with the electorate on the right.
- nostrademons 10y agoCA has the advantage of geography - any invading army would have to cross the steep side of the Sierras. These have relatively few passes, most at high altitude and all easily defended against an invading army. It's actually easier to invade CA via Tijuana than overland through the U.S. They also have the advantage of being exceptionally technically advanced - perhaps moreso than the U.S. military, given that Lockheed has a large presence in the Bay Area and all the Predator drones are made in San Diego. And they're a nuclear power - Livermore is one of two sites that actually develops atomic bombs. This'd be fun to wargame out as a board game or computer simulation, although the subject matter is a little macabre.
- zigzigzag 10y agoLondon isn't on the coast. What you're looking at here is not coasts vs non-coasts even if American maps might make it look that way. It's cities vs everywhere else. It just so happens that in America most of the biggest/best known cities are on the coasts.
- pjc50 10y agoLondon is a port with at least four international airports. It's the most outward-facing internationalist city in the UK.
- wfunction 10y agoBut I think the point was that it's a (large) city.
- joosters 10y agoLondon is a port Have you visited London's "docklands"?
- pjc50 10y agoYes, that's where the airport is :) Should probably have said "was" a port, but the point was that it doesn't really count as "inland".
- michaelt 10y agofour international airports If the London city-state's boundaries are determined by the Brexit vote, remember that Hillingdon (Heathrow), Uttlesford (Stanstead), Crawley (Gatwick) all voted to leave. Only Newham (London City Airport) was majority Remain.
- the_duke 10y agoExcellent observation. It definitely is big cities versus rural areas rather than coast vs not coast. It just so happens that most big cities are on or closer to the coast (or along large rivers in earlier history). It made travel and trade much easier.
- nvarsj 10y ago> What if it actually came to that? If push came to shove and the interior decided to push a nativist, nationalist agenda, what if the coastal regions that benefit significantly from trade were to say "Okay, you guys can play with yourself, we're going to play with the rest of the world." I think if it actually came to that, it would eventually mean war. The interior economy falls apart, coastal regions secede, the poor countries would inevitably be driven to war against the coastal regions out of desperation. Extreme nationalism would just make this more likely. No one should think this is a good idea. Also, saying coasts are "well-integrated into the world economy", implying the rest of the country is not, is just a horribly myopic view of the world. They are only "well-integrated" because the government chose and planned that explicitly - globalization and free trade as an economic policy, removal of protectionism (e.g. NAFTA, etc) and heavy subsidies of the industries involved (especially tech, via military spending). It didn't have to be that way - it isn't because tech, finance, whatever is more meritocratic or anything. With more sensible protectionism you could have international trade while still preserving your country's manufacturing base, allowing the rest of the country's economy to also be "well-integrated". But labor is expensive in developed countries, corporations want more profit, and our government doesn't particularly prioritize the working class.
- berserkpi 10y agoHere is an opinion of a Mexican guy. I remember back in the day when Mexican president Carlos Salinas promoted the NAFTA deal as a solution to our problems. I started to disagree when reason came to me (I was too young when it happened), few reasons: - I believed in a more protectionist system that encouraged internal growth. I still do to a point. - Trading is good as long as you don't compromise internal production and employment. NAFTA is way too aggressive in this sense. - It will triggered this bad "us-american?" behavior of consumerism and materialism. Well, here we are 22 years after and it's evident the system got exhausted, even for US-Americans who were supposed to be the strong link in this chain. Is killing NAFTA a good idea? maybe. I don't know. We are so deep into these waters that it has to be a small "chunk by chunk" change, and even so, it'll be chaos. What I am sure we need, is to find a new balance, going all protectionist will be a huge mistake, just like this crazy aggressive neoliberalism that allowed companies behave irresponsible. Believe me, the consequences of this 20+ years trade system in Mexico are massive. Wait, I'm not a pro-Trump crazy Mexican, keep reading. As I said, we need a new balance. To my eyes, Trump is an extremist and a dangerous man, he doesn't sound or act like a guy that could bring this balance. I think USA voters made a huge mistake on electing him. But, at the same time, they had 2 very poor choices. They just chose the worst one. The years to come will be interesting ones... that is given.
- shams93 10y agoThey will leave the US before they start a war or try to force a california sucession. Ireland could become the next Silicon Valley it may change from Silicon Valley to Technology Island. It would be cheaper for them to pay for their diverse workforce to move to a different country rather than go to war for sucession.
- makomk 10y agoIt's basically urban vs rural, the cities are just on the coasts for historical reasons related to trade and shipping I think. Global trade means that the economy has centred more and more around highly-skilled jobs that require the network effects of being in a major city. Rural residents can't afford to move there and probably wouldn't be able to get jobs anyway. Also, being dependent on imports to feed the population would have major national security implications.
- oska 10y ago> What sort of organizing principle would the world have then? I haven't seen anything historically like that The Hanseatic League was a federation of free-trading market towns along the North Sea and Baltic Sea coastlines. [1] A number of people have suggested that cities (and federations of cities) may become more of a focus as a political unit in the medium term over the nation state. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_League https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_League
- oselhn 10y ago"The Baltic Republics vs. the rest of the USSR." Not good example. They were not voluntarily part of USSR (see Molotov-Ribentrop pact), Stalin sent a lot of them to Siberia. They have huge Russian minority too (remember Putin's policy for "protecting" russians in foreign countries). It it not easy for them to survive, they have to be as independent on russia as possible, so they have no other choice than integrate into international organizations.
- dglass 10y agoYou're misunderstanding the proposal about immigrants. The proposal is to send all immigrants that are here illegally back to where they came from. Yes, I agree it would hurt the California economy if that happened. But are you saying that on your team of 10 people at Google, all of them were here illegally? I can't comprehend the fact that Google would hire immigrants without proper visas or background checks. If they're legal immigrants or they have the required visas, they would be just fine. edit: the proposal is also just that...a proposal. It's not guaranteed this will happen.
- Goladus 10y agoYou're misunderstanding the proposal about immigrants. The proposal is to send all immigrants that are here illegally back to where they came from. For what it's worth, while I don't think Trump is likely to be even close to as draconian as his early rhetoric made it seem, it's worth noting that many of his supporters really are opposed to immigration in a much broader sense than merely legal or illegal. There's a very strong sense that the current philosophy of immigration + multiculturalism is out of control. Too many immigrants are coming in who do not share traditional American values and then are being encouraged NOT to assimilate by the progressive left; but to instead complain about oppression and racism. My impression is that people just want this insane trend to STOP. Most don't want to see mass deportations. Most don't care about the finer points of what's illegal and what's not. They want someone to address the obvious threat to their culture and values.
- nostrademons 10y agoI am (somewhat deliberately, since this thread was initially about Brexit + Trump being part of a more general trend) conflating what Trump said about immigration with what his supporters have said about immigration. Trump's proposal was about illegal immigration. I actually think that as president he's going to be a lot more moderate than many on the left fear. I'm also pretty sure that there are supporters of his that actually want to send all immigrants back to where they came from. "America for Americans", right? And most of the hypotheticals in this thread are about what happens if that wing of the party gets its way and pushes through rather extremist legislation.
- majewsky 10y ago> For most of recorded history, the primary means of production has been land and so fights have been over land, but over the last 150 years or so (contemporaneous with the nation-state as a social organizing principle, BTW), the primary means of production shifted to capital, and now it's shifting to information. I don't expect wars over land to be done anytime soon. We might be doing most of our work on computers rather than on land, but the resources for these computers gotta come from somewhere. This is why esp. China has been going around and buying huge troves of land in Africa: not only to feed their growing population, but also to call dibs on the minerals in the ground. That doesn't mean that information wars are not happening as well. (Though not nearly as prominent since these need way less personnel and happen less openly.)
- tehwalrus 10y ago> these need way less personnel and happen less openly. (Nationalistic media and propaganda are just as much an information war as attacks on computer systems. Even if it does sound more like a "misinformation war".)
- saint_fiasco 10y agoThat's just more capital, though. They aren't invading the land itself by force because they need to be able to sell their stuff to other countries and an invasion can cause trade sanctions.
- saiya-jin 10y agoone of main reasons of Turkey intervening anywhere ISIS is (and stepping back from their former covert support) is to grab more land, in case Iraq or Syria will stay in turmoil. Both valid representatives of the states expressed that Turkey is not welcomed on their territory and should move back, but they couldn't care less. Land is apparently good, even if arid desert or useless very high mountains (ie Chinese invasion of India and land grab for 0 purposes)
- devdas 10y agoThe Himalayas? That's water. Those mountains aren't useless.
- BjoernKW 10y agoCity states and some sort of 'neo-medieval' organisation principle with lots of overlapping allegiances and identities. There was an interesting article on this some time ago that broached some of these ideas: https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg22329850-600-end-of-nations-is-there-an-alternative-to-countries/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg22329850-600-end-of-n...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lgieron 10y ago> Scotland & London vs. Wales & the rest of Britain How is Wales less coastal than Scotland?
- literallycancer 10y agoEven before the Roman Empire, there were trade focused sea faring groups with significant influence, as seen on a map of Greek & Phoenician colonies[1]. The Carthaginians even sailed around West Africa and reached as far as Gulf of Guinea to search for precious metals[2]. I would expect the largest, most successful cities to be located on the coast, or in extremely fertile regions like the Nile Delta or Mesopotamia. Couldn't find any pretty visualisations that would show that though, so I might be wrong. 1 https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a9/Griechischen_und_ph%C3%B6nizischen_Kolonien.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a9/Griechis... 2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanno_the_Navigator#Modern_analysis_of_the_route https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanno_the_Navigator#Modern_ana...
- angry_octet 10y agoIn Heinlien's Friday the US has split up into competing and fractious rival states, like a late 19th century Europe. The heroine is from a persecuted minority (namely genetically engineered people).
- tremon 10y agoWhat happens if economic ties between coastal regions of major trading partners become greater than cultural ties within nations? Then those regions might form their own government, see for example the Hanseatic League [1]. These cities answered directly to the Emperor, instead of some local nobility or government. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_league https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_league
- MandieD 10y agoKind of reminds me of the medieval Hanseatic League - city-states and merchant guilds around the Baltic Sea trading goods and culture (and providing for the defence of all that shipping) while the interior regions were more isolated. Are we really all part of New Hansa?
- aangjie 10y ago> so (contemporaneous with the nation-state as a social organizing principle, BTW), the primary means of production shifted to capital, and now it's shifting to information. What kind of social organizing principle does that imply? Agggressive, negotiators with awareness of cognitive biases like base-rate fallacy, asymmetry of information advantage, etc.... will form or create the organizing principles most likely.. I think of it and it becomes a pain thinking about the asymmentry of information. Hopefully, if it happens, we'll build a better deterrant against withholding information.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>Here in California, some of the proposals about sending all the immigrants back to where they came from seem absurd. The economy would cease to function. On one of my teams of 10 people at Google, we had immigrants from Iceland, England, Vietnam, China, Taiwan, and India, and I was the only native-born American citizen. California would sooner secede than deport all of its immigrants. >What if it actually came to that? If push came to shove and the interior decided to push a nativist, nationalist agenda, what if the coastal regions that benefit significantly from trade were to say "Okay, you guys can play with yourself, we're going to play with the rest of the world." Scotland has threatened to do exactly that, and is planning on holding another referendum on independence if Britain actually follows through on Brexit. It's a decent idea for large parts of America to be devolved into separate nation-states. Texas, California, and Massachusetts are looking not to be governable as a unified country.
- Taek 10y agoDifferent cultures have such dramatically different ideas about what laws they should be governed under, throwing them all into one set of rules is tyranny of the majority. California gets to feel that strongly right now, with Republicans owning 2/3, and soon 3/3 branches of the government. More people get what they want when you have a larger number of smaller countries. California could have a democratic president and Texas could have a republican one. They don't need to hate how the other votes.
- crusso 10y agoIf the concept of States' Rights had been more faithfully adhered to, more states would enjoy a greater feeling of autonomy. Instead, collectivism was embraced. California Democrats were loving it when Obama and the Democrats were in control in 2008. Couldn't they realize that sooner or later the pendulum would swing the other way? We're about to witness an object lesson on why you enforce the rules even on your own party - even when the ends seem to justify the means. Think about the overreach of executive orders and the suspension of the filibuster as tools in the hands of the opposing party.
- throwaway911911 10y ago> some of the proposals about sending all the immigrants back to where they came from seem absurd Oh come on. Nobody is calling for sending all immigrants back. Trump's wife is an immigrant... The questions are: * Big one: What to do about illegal immigration. * Smaller one: What to do about the widespread abuse of the h1b program. For example, FY 2015, Infosys [outsourcing Indian company] leads the h1b pack with 23k visas, whereas Google has 3k visas. http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/11/06/us/outsourcing-companies-dominate-h1b-visas.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/11/06/us/outsourcing... http://www.myvisajobs.com/Reports/2015-H1B-Visa-Sponsor.aspx http://www.myvisajobs.com/Reports/2015-H1B-Visa-Sponsor.aspx
- arcticbull 10y agoRepealing NAFTA sends back all Canadians and Mexicans on TN status.
- arcticbull 10y agoI'm kind of curious why the down-votes so let me explain a bit further. Free trade isn't just about free movement of goods, it's also about free movement of labor. They're not the same thing but they are often lumped together, certainly for the purposes of Trump rhetoric and often in trade agreements. One of Trump's signature campaign promises was to repeal NAFTA, which defines a class of skilled laborer status called TN status, which allows Canadians to show up at the border with $50, an offer letter and a diploma (in a skilled labor category) and work in the US. Mexican nationals are afforded similar status though require consular processing. This is cheap, flexible and un-capped. I'd wager the bulk of legal Canadians and Mexicans are in the US on TN status, so they would have to go were NAFTA repealed. I have a hard time seeing a world where isolationist/protectionist policies increase free movement of labor so almost by definitions legal immigration will be restricted, IMO.
- lap42 10y agoTrump will deport ILEGAL immigrants. Four paragraphs based on a false premise.
- throw_away_777 10y agoNo one is proposing sending all the immigrants back to where they came from, and if they did the economy would not cease to function. Maybe part of the problem is that companies like Google hire teams of 90% immigrants while Americans can't find good jobs.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoI'm not sure it's "coastal vs interior" as much as "urban vs rural". I think we're past the time period where water transport was hugely superior to land transport (and air didn't yet exist). It's not that much harder or more expensive to get a plane ticket or UPS package to the Midwest compared to California. I think the election results by county support this. Even in red states, urban centers are blue, and in blue states, rural areas are red. I'm not sure there's a sufficient segregating force to change this. Aside from election time and resulting legal frameworks that apply to both areas, the ease of transportation and also of moving information mean that there's little friction in being next door to or embedded within the other groups.
- ceejay 10y agoI think the rural vs urban dichotomy definitely needs to be talked about. In reality these are 2 completely different worlds. This is a little hyperbolic, but by the time the rural factory worker has finished killing the chicken and plucking its feathers for dinner, the attorney at New York's finest law firm has just settled a class action lawsuit for $100,000,000.00 There is no question rural areas are getting the short end of the stick, but I have a hard time believing it's primarily because of any intervention on the part of special interests (though they almost certainly are not innocent). It's because on a global scale the smartest, most connected people in the world can literally move mountains relative to their blue collar counter parts.
- ams6110 10y agoIs your team of immigrants here illegally? Nobody is talking about deporting legal immigrants.
- pacomerh 10y agoNo, but way too many people are now using this as an excuse to express their xenophobia, and it really sucks because this country's good qualities are enriched by immigrants.
- magic_beans 10y ago"On one of my teams of 10 people at Google" You're so far from the average Trump voter that they would never see your point.
- Coding_Cat 10y agoHonestly, I'd quite like to have a world with a few large 'nation-states' in charge of 'the global scene'. I am not an economic liberal by any means, but I am a proponent of forming ties between nations and having democracy applied to smaller communities.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"We're seeing this pattern where the coasts of many countries are cosmopolitan and well-integrated into the world economy, but the interiors are very conservative and nationalistic. Scotland & London vs. Wales & the rest of Britain" London is the interior, it is not on the coast. Wales and and Scotland are both coastal. >"Croatia & Slovenia vs. the rest of Yugoslavia." I assume you mean the former Yugoslavia? Bosnia and Herzegovina and Montenegro are also on the coast. So what does that leave for non-coastal fomer Yugoslavia? Macedonia? >"The Baltic Republics vs. the rest of the USSR" There hasn't been a USSR since 1991. Do you mean the former USSR?
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoI think the situation in Wales is that the South and East are more cosmopolitan, lots of immigrants going back many years. The West and North less so. Similarly in Scotland I think the major urban areas dominate, where populations are more diverse. But rural populations away from communications and conurbations seem far less accepting of [large groups of] migrants. Similarly in the UK poorer populations that might feel threatened by incomers seeking low-skilled jobs (eg due to poor language skills) seem less welcoming of migrants. Personally I think the whole "culture" aspect is a red herring and what people really care about is their own wealth. I mean the UK's history is epitomised by outside influences either due to invasion of Britain or British invasion and Empire. Personally I think to survive and meet the needs of everyone the West will need give up some of its luxuries, get rid of our need to own everything we use, move away from the disposable lifestyle. In short my analysis is it's liberal just greed that drives this whole thing - 'I deserve wealth but other people don't'. Does that idea fit in other geographies or not?
- rullelito 10y ago> On one of my teams of 10 people at Google, we had immigrants from Iceland, England, Vietnam, China, Taiwan, and India, and I was the only native-born American citizen. How is this an argument? I'm not from the US and I'm not very well read on the issue, but isn't it illegal immigrants they want to deport? Who said that people from those countries couldn't be well educated and be fully functional Americans? Also, I live in Malmö Sweden (coastal city) and the right-wing party here is strong, and we have lots of problem with immigrants, both legal and illegal.
- c0nfused 10y agoThe Trump campaign has only promised to enforce the existing US law. However, the tenor of the campaign in the american press and social media has such that the left is convinced that they are going to be sent to robot death camps constructed for people who vote democrat. The right was concerned about the opposite until they won. For many of the young and educated democrats this is the first time they have lost an election. The hysteria will pass. And then we will see where it all goes
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- defen 10y ago> On one of my teams of 10 people at Google, we had immigrants from Iceland, England, Vietnam, China, Taiwan, and India, and I was the only native-born American citizen. California would sooner secede than deport all of its immigrants. If you think the immigration debate is about Google employees, I think you don't understand the immigration debate. > If push came to shove and the interior decided to push a nativist, nationalist agenda, what if the coastal regions that benefit significantly from trade were to say "Okay, you guys can play with yourself, we're going to play with the rest of the world." The interior (culturally and geographically) is massively over-represented in the security forces and military. So good luck with that.
- zaphar 10y agoHe didn't say that the debate was about Google employees. He said that Google is affected by the debate. This is a big difference and is increasingly relevant.
- chrishacken 10y agoAnd what defen is saying is that the actual debate is about "illegal" immigrants. Not all immigrants. I have absolutely no idea where the idea that Trump doesn't want legal immigrants in the country came from; as that's certainly not true.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gotchange 10y agoAnn Coulter is the defacto Trump advisor on immigration and she can't hide her preference for either only or predominantly white immigration and if that untenable for some reason, just limit it to absolute minimum. So, it is not just about illegal immigration, this is just a red herring for what it really is at stake here.
- chrishacken 10y ago
- malcol 10y agoWhat if, people vote with their feet? Would it be possible that sites like https://teleport.org https://teleport.org or others, make moving as simple as booking a holiday trip? People will find their likeminded peers in the cloud and meet up physically at a place that fits best their needs? Not just to meet up for conferences but for longterm stays? Countries, cities, governments would have to compete for talent? Would this change the dynamic how governments act overall? Being in competition for people, for talent on a complete new level?
- cicero 10y agoSurely your immigrant coworkers are here legally. I don't think legal immigration is a problem for anyone except for a small extreme fringe.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TheGirondin 10y ago> On one of my teams of 10 people at Google, we had immigrants from Iceland, England, Vietnam, China, Taiwan, and India, and I was the only native-born American citizen. California would sooner secede than deport all of its immigrants. No one wants to send legal immigrants on your team back their countries of origin. Blue collar, unskilled laborers want to stop the influx of unskilled laborers and illegal immigrants who 1) take their jobs and depress their wages and 2) take up resources from social programs.
- jackmaney 10y ago> No one wants to send legal immigrants on your team back their countries of origin. What about legal immigrants who are also Muslim?
- TheGirondin 10y agoIf they want to come in legally and can be properly vetted for ties with Islamic terrorist groups there's no issue and they can come in legally like everyone else.
- jackmaney 10y agoYour President-Elect disagrees with you, and has called for the deportation of all Muslims--full stop.
- TheGirondin 10y agoNo, he has not.
- jackmaney 10y agohttp://lmgtfy.com/?q=trump+keep+out+muslims http://lmgtfy.com/?q=trump+keep+out+muslims
- 10y ago
- jerf 10y ago"What sort of organizing principle would the world have then?" I don't know if this is what is likely to happen, but I've been pondering this: The Westphalian order for the world, which we currently live under, involves drawing borders for countries, and then basically insisting that the governments within those borders must have some sort of unity, regardless of what those borders are, do, or come from. Do you have a group of people that are geographically localized but have borders going right through the middle of them, like the Kurds? Then they are not a country, not countrymen, and regardless of their affiliations they are subject to their country's policies for dealing with each other. The split of East and West Germany was an extreme case of this, where a national border was drawn, and you had families cut in half. Do you have bunches of people that basically loathe each other with the fire of a thousand suns, but there's a border drawn around them on the world map? Then they live together, until the most pathological cases like Yugoslavia finally just blow apart. And where did these borders come from? Did some bureaucrats in Europe in the 1700s or 1800s draw some conveniently straight lines in Africa? You're a country now in the 21st century, regardless of how anyone local feels about that. Pretty much anywhere in the world you see a straight line border you see something very artificial that took no account of conditions on the ground. In the 1990s, the cyber utopians thought that technology would lead to more decentralization. With improved technology, you don't need industrial-era practices to deal with cities and counties and states and countries. You can have very sophisticated government and government services now at much smaller polities; even the small local cities take online payments now, for instance, and have online billing. Perhaps the future looks like the Westphalian system cracking up, and polities being more willing to secede, easily join together in arrangements of convenience as needed, and easily break apart again as their interests diverge. There are certainly a lot of practical issues involved in that transition, but as diversity increases all around the world, there's increasingly a lot of practical issues involved in forcibly jamming people together because of borders drawn 200+ years ago. It wouldn't solve war; that's not on the table. But it might just prevent World War III.
- pault 10y agoI don't think it will happen within my lifetime, but I think the future has to be something like the "phyles"[1] from the Diamond Age, by Neal Stephenson. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Diamond_Age#Phyles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Diamond_Age#Phyles
- shaurz 10y agoGlobal city-states need to become independent with open immigration, separate from the Nations which should enforce strong immigration controls to maintain the native population & culture.
- curiousgeorgio 10y ago> Here in California, some of the proposals about sending all the immigrants back to where they came from seem absurd. FYI, I'm not aware of anyone proposing to send all immigrants back, only undocumented (also known as "illegal") immigrants. Like it or not, the current laws are such that people in that category are not here legally, so if we truly are a nation of laws, those laws should be upheld, no? If you don't agree with the law, vote to change it rather than act as if the law just doesn't exist. To single out a certain group of people and act as if laws don't apply to them in a country that is otherwise built on laws is to deprive them (and all of us) of one of the most fundamental American virtues. Whether we agree with the laws or not, if we don't uphold them, we cease to be a free country (it's the laws that keep us free, after all). It's absurd to believe otherwise. Or, you know, we can keep going down the rabbit hole of selectively enforcing laws, and we can ignore your vote too because some people don't agree with it; the voting laws are just words on paper.
- digler999 10y ago> those laws should be upheld, no? OK, when you catch them, write them a ticket and make them show up with their Mexican ID and fill out the paperwork to be documented again. It's false to conclude that deportation is the only possible redress. There's no reason to turn one person's or a whole family's life upside down for a victimless crime of not filling out a paper form that takes 7 years to complete. The RIAA tried this with suing MP3 purveyors in the 00's, once an efficient legal market existed infringement plummeted.
- curiousgeorgio 10y agoWould that be fair to all the people playing by the rules and going through the process of legal immigration now? I do agree that the process can and should be streamlined in many ways, but it should begin with those seeking to follow the law rather than essentially giving a free pass to everyone who knowingly broke the law as their first deed on American soil. For the record, I know several Mexican families (in Mexico and in the US) affected by this, and I firmly believe that a strong border is better in the long run - both for the US and Mexico. Legal immigration should be an option and it should be a more straightforward process, but blanket amnesty doesn't really do any favors for anyone.
- roymurdock 10y ago> What happens if economic ties between coastal regions of major trading partners become greater than cultural ties within nations? Until you can fix your toilet, repair your house, teach your kids, pave your roads, and have your meals cooked for you remotely, I don't think this is a valid concern. The upper "coastal" class depends on local, blue collar labor that can't be outsourced (with current technology). Rich folk can move to the suburbs but everyone will need to coexist within contiguous geographic states for the foreseeable future.
- dacox 10y agoThose cultural ties practically already are stronger. Living on the west coast of Canada I really feel that - to the south we have Washington, Oregon, California.