12 ms·
Why Twitter Must Be Saved
- sergiotapia 10y agoSaudi Money assured it's destruction - Twitter will die and become the "AOL Keyword" of the twenty-tens.
- largote 10y agoTwitter's not going to go under. It just won't grow to FB/GOOG/AMZN/MSFT size (at least not under their current strategy), and that's not necessarily a bad thing.
- astrodust 10y agoThe problem with wild success but not insanely wild success is investors that were promised insanely wild feel cheated.
- Retra 10y agoI don't know many people who are actually concerned about that. Sounds like complaining about a win-win situation. More to the point: investors with irrational expectations are not the kind of investors who deserve to have their expectations met.
- user5994461 10y agoI wish we'd consider a multi-billion dollars company as "a wild success".
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoThere isn't some natural law that states "Twitter is with $12bn." It'a valued as such in expectation of future profits. Massive future profits. If it can't sustainably materialise those profits, it loses its valuation (and some of its investors lose their shirts).
- gozur88 10y agoIs it really a multi-billion dollars company, though? Twitter has never made money, and it's not clear they ever will make money. A company that can't make money isn't worth more than its assets minus debt.
- user5994461 10y agoThey have multi billions in revenue. That definitely qualify it as a multi-billion dollars company.
- st3v3r 10y agoWhy do I care about them? They still most likely made more money than I'll see in my lifetime for not doing anything other than having money.
- ProAm 10y agoIt is for share holders.
- flukus 10y agoProfitable companies aren't bad for shareholders.
- guelo 10y agoHype > profits if you're trying to find the next sucker to sell your shares to. Especially for companies that don't pay dividends.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Profitable companies aren't bad for shareholders They are if the profits were greatly overestimated. Paying a billion for a dollar of profits isn't smart. Not to mention, Twitter isn't profitable. (They lose half a billion dollars a year.) About a month ago I said I'd find Twitter a possibly reasonable buy at a third its current valuation [1]. To make that work, a lot would need to change. And Twitter's current investors would surely lose. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12710784 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12710784
- metaphorm 10y agoI mean, how could it possibly grow into a Google type of company? it's product is just not that valuable. it could disappear tomorrow and nobody would have to change their plans for the day.
- duaneb 10y ago> it could disappear tomorrow and nobody would have to change their plans for the day. Unless you're in an industry that depends on it for PR, like entertainment.
- gkya 10y agoI have a twitter account that follows 9-10 theatres (and only those) in my city created so that I could follow the newest shows and stuff, but all I got was repetitive broadcasting of the same stuff multiple times a day by all the accounts I follow, so overwhelmingly many times that the actual new stuff that I was looking for got buried somewhere in the useless flux of yesterday's news. And overall most entertainment sources on Twitter behive similarly. I just follow the RSS feeds of local theatre magazines nowadays, it's easier, period. Finding info on twitter is a needle-haystack situation and unfortunately I'm incapable of making a binary search as a human.
- metaphorm 10y agodoes any industry really depend on it? Even if you're in the entertainment industry, if Twitter disappeared you would still just go on using every other form of media that's around. TV, radio, magazines, websites, etc. There is nothing special or indispensable about Twitter. It's a totally replaceable product. In fact, it can even be replaced with nothing at all. Nobody needs it.
- intoverflow2 10y agoIt doesn't depend on it, they'd move straight over to Insta or whatever by the afternoon. It honestly makes no difference. I've actually worked on these sort of campaigns, you never just rely on a single platform and pray for traction.
- Mz 10y ago"Rumors of my death have been greatly exaggerated."
- saintwind 10y agoOr, you know, let it suck for awhile and we get some competition.
- Nadya 10y ago>The payoff, though, is the capability of spreading information more widely and more quickly than has ever before been possible; the societal benefit is an externality that needs to be preserved. So let it die and use GNU Social [0]. Non-techies don't need to know how to run their own instance and join the federation, but they gain all the benefits of Twitter, better control of their own data, and don't need to rely on a company known for censoring views it dislikes. "Social" can move. See the migration from Digg to Reddit or MySpace to Facebook. Twitter to GNU Social would be grand. ;) [0] https://gnu.io/social/ https://gnu.io/social/
- _audakel 10y agoNot that I like GNU social (get all my news from twitter) but why the down votes? It is a legitimate idea and project, and he gives examples of similar undertakings.
- catdog 10y agoAlso pointing out existing alternatives which can work without some single big for profit company behind is a very valid counter argument to a claim that Twitter has to be saved.
- striking 10y agoHave you ever tried it? It's not very good. Like, yes, it's workable and usable. It's okay. But the user experience is absolutely awful, especially on mobile. Maybe if HN started its own GNU Social server and started using it, we'd see some interesting stuff happen.
- catdog 10y ago> Like, yes, it's workable and usable. It's okay. But the user experience is absolutely awful Sure it needs a bit more love on the UI side but it's not that bad. The Twitter Website is btw. not that great, too. > especially on mobile. I use Twidere [1] for both Twitter and GS, works well. [1] https://github.com/mariotaku/twidere https://github.com/mariotaku/twidere
- aaron-lebo 10y agoPeople have a rose-tinted view of Twitter. And yet it is Twitter that has reaffirmed itself as the most powerful antidote to Facebook’s algorithm: misinformation certainly spreads via a tweet, but truth follows unusually quickly; thanks to the power of retweets and quoted tweets, both are far more inescapable than they are on Facebook. What is the evidence of this? Even if "truth" follows misinformation on Twitter, there's so much noise, how do you find it? that the greatest menace to freedom is an inert people; that public discussion is a political duty, Twitter isn't public discussion, unless you consider the following examples of discussion: Every time I speak of the haters and losers I do so with great love and affection. They cannot help the fact that they were born fucked up! - Trump Delete your account. - Clinton Riveting. Don't tell me that Twitter is a vital part of discussion when public discussion has gotten worse over the past 9 years. This is a long blog post and only the last few paragraphs even begin to touch on "why Twitter must be saved", but there's not arguments beyond the sentimental. Twitter has existed for less than a decade and society got along just fine without it. It's not as important as people think it is. The author is also absolutely wrong if they believe that Twitter isn't censored similarly to FB.
- vvanders 10y agoIt's not just wide public discussion, when there's some large local event(weather, tornado, etc) I usually find the most up to date and accurate information on twitter 2-3 hours before any news site. It's the CB radio of social media and I find huge value in that.
- komali2 10y agoDoes it function better for you than a google search or a news.google.com search?
- vvanders 10y agoYes, much better. All it takes is someone and their phone. Take for instance the recent tornado we had off the Oregon coast. I had video/pictures/reports showing up even ahead of the local NOAA site or google news.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sintaxi 10y agoI'd argue Twitter is being saved from itself right now. Hard to say what will emerge out of this but twitter has not been on the right path ever since it killed its developer program and closed its API. Twitter badly needed this shakeup.
- tdb7893 10y agoI find the whole Twitter thing kinda strange. If Twitter had kept this sort of API the comments now probably would just be "of course they are losing money, how did they expect to monetize that API"
- reitanqild 10y ago> "of course they are losing money, how did they expect to monetize that API" By selling posting increased posting quotas to news organisations? Extra integrations (webhooks etc) to companies?
- tdb7893 10y agoI think that would definitely work some but I'm sceptical there are enough companies that will pay. My personal opinion is that they would run into the same problem they are having now, they are making money but just not nearly enough of it.
- reitanqild 10y agoThanks! I'd say they make enough money to keep twitter running, just not as much as shareholders hoped.
- M_Grey 10y agoOh please. Twitter is not fundamental to discourse, it's mostly an open sewer along with the vast majority of social media.
- yabatopia 10y agoTwitter as a network and format is replaceable and replicatable, Just let it crash and burn. From the ashes can rise a new and better Twitter-like service. The current Twitter carries too much nostalgia, undecisivenes and other toxic dead weight to change course.
- st3v3r 10y agoThey're gonna have to have a solution for harassment out of the gate, otherwise they'll suffer the same fate.
- KODeKarnage 10y agoThey're gonna have to have safe spaces and unashamedly be an echo-chamber out of the gate, otherwise they'll suffer the same fate. FYP
- st3v3r 10y agoNo, you didn't. You completely ignored one of the reasons why Twitter is tanking. Tell me, why would I want to use Twitter 2 if every time I make a post I have a dozen people calling for my family to be raped and murdered?
- r3bl 10y ago> ...if every time I make a post I have a dozen people calling for my family to be raped and murdered Try using it for a month and make the same argument. I have posted ~5000 tweets in the last couple of years. I can guarantee you that neither me nor my family ever got threatened with rape and murder. This is an issue, but those affected are exceptions, not the rule.
- st3v3r 10y agoNo. You just handwaved away the experiences of thousands of users. You said that because YOU don't have a problem, that there isn't one. That is not an answer.
- sean_patel 10y agoTwitter was doomed from the day it started, when it imposed the 140 character limit on what you got to say to the "world". I mean how can anyone have a meaningful conversation or make a point in 140 characters or less? The only person capable of doing the latter ("making a point") is the Republican Candidate for President - Donald J Trump i.e. @RealDonaldTrump - and what does that tell you? ( * = Unpleasant side-effects of the 140 character limit include 1) "longer tweet" sites and services that would link a 140+ character statement to their site, so you go elsewhere to read it and 2) celebs and influencers sending a series of tweets 1 after another, and the media and others have to piece them together painfully in order to make any sense of the tweets.
- nikatwork 10y agoPleasant side-effects include forcing a clear cogent point by eschewing excess verbiage. I personally find the 140 limit a useful antidote to the waffling academia trained me to employ in my writing.
- sean_patel 10y agosays the guy who made his point with 199 characters.
- nikatwork 10y agoHN is neither twitter nor a blog.
- inopinatus 10y agoI knew a serial entrepreneur (three paydirt IPOs and still going) whose formula for building basic infrastructure was this: 1. Find some capital to fund it 2. Build it 3. Attempt to sell services across it 4. The prices will be set to recoup investment + return. These prices will be too high for the market. 5. Go bust 6. Get bought for a song 7. New owner sells services at market-friendly rates. It merely remains to find VCs to sucker into step (1). More than one internet backbone got built this way. I leave unanswered the question of whether Twitter can be treated as infrastructure, and in particular do not mean to suggest their investors are this naive.
- herge 10y agoI think the intercontinental rail system in the US was built the same way too.
- arethuza 10y agoAnd the UK-France Channel Tunnel - which didn't go bankrupt but did have a significant financial "restructuring" along the way.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"More than one internet backbone got built this way" Can you elaborate? Which ones?
- xiaoma 10y agoWhat does a "paydirt" IPO mean?
- sethhochberg 10y agoSlang term for "profit" (a reference to digging in the dirt and finding oil or ores)
- xiaoma 10y agothanks!
- mentat2737 10y agoTwitter will be absorbed by a big one (possibly Google), so no need for this kind of posts. And if it dies, let it be. Another one will come up.
- hackaflocka 10y agoVia Twitter I have asked clarificatory questions to some of the top authors (Taleb was one), journalists and programmers in the world. Most of them responded.
- detaro 10y agoYes, that's something Twitter is pretty good at. E-mailing random people feels more intrusive to me, and blog comments or similar channels aren't always available or appropriate (although Twitter certainly is to blame for at least some of that)
- matwood 10y agoTwitter has been the best way to deal with Comcast that I have found.
- MustardTiger 10y agoTwitter is 100% opposed to free speech, and have stated policy that they censor views they do not like. There is nothing there to save for the sake of free speech. If you want some form of "social media" with free speech, you'll have to make it (and make it popular).
- ChrisNorstrom 10y agoThis is true, they've censored Milo Yainnapolis (gay jewish conservative for Trump), Azealia Banks (female rapper who insulted middle easterners), Blaire White (transgender anti-islamic trans-woman). Whom twitter chooses to censor is strange...
- a_imho 10y agoYou are right, but I don't think free speech is considered a pro feature in making services popular right now.
- MustardTiger 10y agoI don't think it is either. But the post is under the misconception that twitter should be saved because it offers a free speech alternative to the other social media outlets.
- shmerl 10y agoRegarding Facebook. Monstrous, centralized entity which knows everything about everyone? That's an anti-utopian example, not utopian one. I'd prefer something like diaspora* to gain more traction. Open, decentralized social network without pointless limitations on post length.
- nof 10y agoHaving played around with diaspora* (awful name), I don't think it can replace Facebook, unfortunately. Like Twitter it doesn't rely on people's real names nor are there good options for chat or making private or public groups or events. However, it could potentially be a good replacement for twitter. We need a good decentralized social network that has good design all around, code, gui, ux etc. which is hard to find atm. Ello is also quite nice, but not free, open and decentralized as diaspora which is a deal breaker for me when discussing new social media services. Btw, could anyone enlighten me on why jabber (xmmp?) never took off in any major way? It seems nice?
- shmerl 10y agodiaspora* doesn't prevent you from using real names, as well as it doesn't force you to use them. That's exactly the point! XMPP was sabotaged by major IM participants not using it. Especially Google. They first were pushing XMPP a lot, but later betrayed the whole effort.
- nof 10y agoYes I like that you can choose whatever name you want, but ask your family members or old friends from school how they use Facebook. Being enable to find old friends and connect with far relatives is a huge reason for why Facebook is so popular. I am having a hard time time figuring out how to solve this problem if there aren't any constraints, culture or expectations for using real names. Maybe it's just a matter if time. Online aliases is more second nature to the coming generations. And still, the group and chat thing is very important imho. That's why I asked about XMPP. Would love if we could get a modern chat system as widely and universally used as email.
- ramblenode 10y agoThis article is a criticism of Facebook, not a defense of Twitter. The idea that Twitter, by virtue of not being Facebook, is a public square fit for deliberation of ideas that are key to the health of democracy is fairly absurd. Tweets are just about as imperfect a medium for dialogue as any that has existed in the time of the internet. Both Twitter and Facebook in their current states are fatally flawed as public forums. Let's at least acknowledge that before exploring solutions.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoPeople in general are prone to looking for messianic saviors. I think it is wired into the generic brain circuitry. Good things in general require consistent hard work and effort and just general humanity. Neither twitter nor facebook embody any of those things. Both are machines for turning clicks peppered by "original content" into money. The author should look elsewhere for the messiah.
- vladimir-y 10y agoI still do use RSS and it works well for me.
- nof 10y agoIndeed. Feedly does a nice job of presenting rss items. I actually feel lucky that websites are still using rss.
- r3bl 10y agoI believe that this has more has to do with it being built into almost all CMS's than it being a conscious decision. I remember creating a couple of years back a simple script where you input a subdomain or a top level domain and it would try loading the most common feed locations (like /rss, /feed etc.) and returns the location of the feed if it gets 200 as a response. All I had to do was to check for like 10 different locations (think: one or two for every major CMS) and it worked in like 98% of the time.
- aikah 10y agoYep, it's so simple yet too complicated for twitter evangelists like the OP.Also big tech companies try to push people into their walled gardens since data is wealth and they don't want to share it. In the end I believe open tech will prevail.
- st3v3r 10y agoEven if Twitter itself is not saved, whatever springs up in it's place is likely going to have similar problems with harassment.
- m0llusk 10y agoThis is contemptible garbage. The author implies engineers do not improve the world, but he is not about to go without cars or washing machines or credit. This current election was going to be difficult even for a moderate Republican to win, but this guy got emotional over the coverage therefore it was poignant to him and relevant to his argument. Twitter has so little to contribute that much of what he says is an apology for the unavoidable abuse that saturates the medium. This kind of article is why so little is lost in flushing traditional journalism down the toilet.
- sanderjd 10y ago> This kind of article is why so little is lost in flushing traditional journalism down the toilet. This seems like a non-sequitur. What does this article have to do with traditional journalism?
- minimuffins 10y ago> The tech industry is now producing its own magnates, who are following the Rockefeller playbook. See Mark Zuckerberg giving $100 million to the Newark school district, or Chris Hughes buying the New Republic It might be worth noting that both were notorious as abject failures.
- whywhywhywhy 10y agoSomeone with nearly 30K followers would feel this way. Can't say I see that much that needs saving as an average user of the service. I'd actually rather it crumble and see what someone more competent can do in the space.
- mobiletest 10y agoTest
- muad 10y agoToo big to fail.
- kuhidarwin 10y agoDon't worry, even if Twitter die, there will be another better product to take over.
- MrFurious 10y agoTwitter must not be saved. If its gone, other services more efficient (probably) replace it, how facebook replace myspace and other services.
- retrogradeorbit 10y agoThere's nothing new, or inherently tech about any of this. It started long before the Internet was widespread. I recommend the author reads "Flat Earth News" by Nick Davies.
- tn13 10y agoTwitter has been pretty rubbish curation policies and also engages in censorship of worst kind. The activists I know and follow already are looking for alternatives.
- SixSigma 10y agoSaudi Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal, no thanks.
- cinquemb 10y agoOne thing I find really great about twitter as a platform is the data they have available from devs/users who check in their oauth keys on public repos which one can use to get very accurate detailed information from accounts and tweets/retweets like getting the gps coords/conducting sentiment/graph analysis without being rate limited or having to sign onto any of their terms coupled with the "public" nature of twitter which just isn't there anymore with facebook.
- gavinpc 10y agoTonight is not the night to apologize for this sewer.
- rkv 10y ago>What is the evidence of this? Even if "truth" follows misinformation on Twitter, there's so much noise, how do you find it? Do you use twitter? I see a lot of misinformation and rumors started by "journalists" which gain a lot of popularity but seemingly disapear once the true source confirms or denies said claims. And it is easy to navigate this on twitter. I'm mainly talking about sports or entertainment news. With other forms of media the turnaround time is no where near as fast to (1) notify the source and (2) have the original poster edit their article.
- visarga 10y agoI tried reading the replies to a post on Twitter recently. It was a medium-long list. The UI was atrocious, unstable and plain inferior to putting plain text on an empty page. It's just frustrating. What are they on?
- drivingmenuts 10y agoThat's great, but if Twitter can't pay it's own way, then bin it. The argument hasn't really been strongly focused on whether or not Twitter is useful (it's not useful for me, but YMMV). The major problem has been "How does Twitter make money to stay in business?" You can't ask investors to keep tossing money down the Tweet-hole without getting something for their money.
- debacle 10y agoA-thing-like-Twitter must be saved, but Twitter probably isn't it, unless someone like Google buys it and gives it to the world for free.
- throwaway23421 10y agoads
- throwaway23421 10y agoremember digg? the internet will move on.
- Macsenour 10y agoradical idea: save it by focusing on what people use it for, ignoring the trolling that you want to go away anyway. Question is, is there a business model for that? Fast news, breaking news events, what else?