10 ms·
Y Combinator's Hardware Guy Leaves After 14 Months
- sethbannon 10y agoTL;DR -- Luke Iseman, YC's hardware focused Partner founded a hardware startup, which he's now taking through YC as a founder, after having set up a bunch of deals and processes to help hardware startups as a YC Partner. Seems like pretty good evidence YC is now great at helping hardware startups that he's choosing to go through the program himself.
- cellularmitosis 10y agoOh cool, Luke was a Maker personality in Austin for a while. I remember when he was making his own pedicabs. http://austinpedicab.org/2008/10/06/austin-cronicle-interviews-luke-iseman/ http://austinpedicab.org/2008/10/06/austin-cronicle-intervie...
- patcon 10y agoAustin, eh? I wonder if he's friend or foe with the Kasita guy (ie. Professor Dumpster)...
- covercash 10y agoIt's also a pretty good way to see how those deals and processes actually work from the founder perspective and give valuable feedback to the YC team.
- jeremy_wiebe 10y agoSounds like dogfooding, to me.
- elmar 10y agoLuke is a great person, I love the container houses project, and it's a statement to YC quality that he decided to go trough the program. On the other side, "a full quarter of the current batch are making physical products" and no Hardware focused partners, isn't that a litle strange.
- jabbanobodder 10y agoIs it just me or does that picture make him look like a zombie on TWD?
- pen2l 10y agoThat's... not even him, that's not Luke, that's Sam. For a second they had me thinking Sam had stepped down from his position at yc. Sam wouldn't do that to us.
- kenferry 10y ago"Iseman says his departure was purely about his desire to get back into the founder's role and build something new. He's already been accepted into the winter 2017 YC cohort with his new housing startup." Doesn't sound very acrimonious.
- Cyph0n 10y agoIsn't that the definition of a conflict of interest? Or am I reading this wrong?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hawkice 10y agoAn allegation that there is favoritism among the closed off society of YC elites? I'm astonished, astonished, I say!
- mej10 10y agoFavoritism? It is a lot easier to vet someone you have worked with extensively, or if someone you trust gives a recommendation. It isn't like there is some secret society -- it is simply the way the world works. Those are extra bits of information that go into the equation and they happen to count for a lot. I don't really see a problem with it. Why wouldn't they give extra weight to those bits of information? Also, this happens all of the time with positions across the board in startups/companies. If I am a senior engineer somewhere, and we are hiring and the company thinks I have good judgement... of course they are going to take my recommendations of candidates more seriously than someone off the street.
- Mango_Diesel 10y agoWhat is the conflict of interest? Being a partner at YC is certainly a unique qualifier that would basically guarantee acceptance. There is nothing wrong with that. It is awesome, in fact.
- sushid 10y ago"Sam Altman, president and co-founder of Y Combinator." Uhh, they clearly didn't do their homework if they thought Altman co-founded YC.
- birken 10y agoHaving read basically every news article ever about the startup I was involved in, they get the most basic, easily checkable facts like: What year was it founded? What does the company do? Who is the CEO? wrong at least half of the time. And they get the more complicated facts wrong much more often, but that is because they generally directly printing either what the founder tells them or something they think that is more interesting than what the founder tells them without any sort of verification. Basically, almost all articles about startups (and frankly most things in general) are written to be interesting, not factually correct.
- WalterBright 10y agoI learned that when there was a natural gas explosion in the building I worked in in the 80s (nobody was hurt). I recorded several TV news broadcasts on it, and every one got the basic facts wrong in different ways. Things like one called the building a warehouse (it was an office building). There were no political issues nor agendas nor money at stake, the news reporters just didn't make any effort to be correct. I've often wondered what we know about history that is dead wrong.
- zubat 10y agoI'm increasingly convinced that looking and thinking too deeply on people matters(news, history, organizations, relationships) is like staring at the sun. There's nothing much to see by focusing your gaze on it, it blocks out stuff more nearby, and you go blind in the process. Which isn't to say that being a numb automaton is ideal, either, but there is a degree of balance and good taste required to avoid converting the information into dangerous thoughts, and it's simpler to restrict quantity of exposure.
- rezashirazian 10y agoStill, hardware is, well, hard. Silicon Valley has produced a raft of world-changing software startups, from Airbnb (a YC veteran) to Facebook. But it's a whole lot easier to beta-test an app than to prototype and then manufacture a gadget with a bunch of moving parts. Then you have to market the thing to the masses, who are already enamored of their Apple and Samsung products. Exhibits A and B: Fitbit, the fitness tracking company, and GoPro, maker of rugged little cameras. This week, both cut their sales forecasts for the crucial holiday quarter and watched their shares plunge. (Neither started life at YC.) Fitbit and GoPro's downturn is mostly fueled by mismanagement and poor decisions than hardware being intrinsically hard. The hard part of hardware is building something that works well enough and is in demand. When you have your device on people's wrist or mounted on their helmet, you have overcome the "hardware is hard" part. (for the most part). After that it's building on your original success, expanding your market and creating value for your customers; all of which are true for any other business, not strictly hardware. For fitbit and GoPro, the latter has proven more difficult.
- wheelerwj 10y agoBut just to be clear, hardware IS hard.
- samstave 10y agoAside: Shoot - this wants me to make a "front fell off" joke... but HN hates jokes.
- exolymph 10y agoAs evidenced by you getting downvoted. Oh, HN, I would say "never change" but I already don't expect you to.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoPersonally I don't mind some jokes here but I can't see what the joke is you're trying to make. If it was a clearly funny comment it perhaps wouldn't fair as badly.
- dmix 10y agoEverything must be a controversy these days in the news world. Including all of the times they're really not. Like this time.
- anondon 10y agoFrom the title to the tone of the article, I felt like they were going to drop a bombshell, something like "Luke was fired" or "Luke hates how YC is being run". Very poor journalism, Bloomberg.
- samstave 10y agoWRT goPro... (I do not know if they already do this); Should it not be a sound idea to work with companies that make the THINGS that your users would be on to bundle a device with the things... Rosignol branded gopro when you buy a pair of skis [SkateBoard] branded gopro bundle, or a tony hawk edition Water-proof versions bundled with every [insert water product] Specialized/Brooks branded versions... Try to get the companies already selling the transport mechanisms the users of go-pro would be using to boost sales. Lower margins, higher(???) volume?
- analog31 10y agoA potential issue is that if someone wants a branded helmet-cam, they can apply their brand label to a knock-off model for a lot less coin. For the bundle to be attractive to the consumer, it has to be cheaper than the parts bought separately. These days, folks do extensive price research before spending more than a few bucks on anything.
- Animats 10y agoHardware may be a bad fit for YC, with its low initial funding and short deadlines. If you're doing some me-too product, others can do it too, probably better. If you're doing something hard that takes R&D, it may take more time and resources than YC provides.
- the_watcher 10y agoI met Luke while he was working on Edyn (pre-YC). He was really interesting, and clearly enjoys hacking and tinkering with hardware and physical things more than anything. It's not surprising to me that he'd get bored after a working process for supporting hardware startups was established. Interested to see what he's doing around housing, and somewhat hopeful it won't just be tiny homes (since while I think they're cool, living in one isn't for everyone).
- dnprock 10y agoThis shows being YC founder is more fun than YC partner.
- Steeeve 10y agoThat's a brilliant photo.
- Jugurtha 10y agoThere's "silicon" in Silicon Valley. The reason it exists is hardware, yet they seem oblivious to that fact and make it seem that, somehow, SV's pursuit of hardware is a new path.
- sama 10y agoI counted at least 5 factual errors in the photo caption and first 3 paragraphs. We also heard that this reporter was 'encouraged' to write this by someone from a competing accelerator with an obvious agenda. Seems like manufactured controversy otherwise. All that said, we like hardware and we like Luke, and we're excited he's in the new batch! And we're thankful for the work he did to get our hardware program set up.
- danso 10y agoHeh, impressive that a lede photo caption as short and simple as, "Sam Altman, president and co-founder of Y Combinator", has an error.
- sama 10y agotwo errors!
- titanomachy 10y agoWhat's the second, is that a picture of some other person?
- dcposch 10y ago* Not a cofounder. YC was created by PG, Jessica Livingstone, and two other ppl who aren't Sam * Recently changed roles. Michael Siebel runs YC now, while Sam runs the parent organization YC Group
- Tomte 10y agoAt least you can use it as a source for his Wikipedia article. In a few short years everybody will agree that sama co-founded YC. ;-)
- ak39 10y agoI had to google your word "lede" in order to understand what you were saying. I found this: http://howardowens.com/lede-vs-lead/ http://howardowens.com/lede-vs-lead/
- louprado 10y agoI don't know Luke Iseman's vision for Boxouse. But if the goal is to produce structures like the ones shown in the link below then I am really glad he made the decision to focus full time on his company. http://www.architecturendesign.net/22-most-beautiful-houses-made-from-shipping-containers/ http://www.architecturendesign.net/22-most-beautiful-houses-...
- debt 10y agothe position is probably pointless and is why he left. it's cool that yc experiments with shit like this but didn't work out and now he's doing something else. hardware is hard.
- nom 10y agoHardware development requires a lot of spare resources, it doesn't pair well with startups. The development cycles are much less predictable compared to software, you never know how many prototypes you have to burn through until you reach the production stage. Small changes become hugely expensive once you've finalized the designs, and even a minuscule error like a tolerance mismatch can cause hundreds of thousands in damage and ruin a startup almost instantly. I'm always wary of a HW startup, unless the lead engineer is well known and has experience.
- cdibona 10y agoI don want to sound like a jerk, but Trevor Blackwell has always filled the ycombinatoe hardware 'slot' from my perspective.
- patcon 10y agoAs someone who saw Luke & Heather's Boxouse talk at HOPE conf with some friends, and were inspired to go at it stealth, I've gotta say I'm so so glad they're focussing on the housing project. I just got my rental shipping container dropped off last week, and am working to quickly and non-destructively insulate it for Canadian winter :)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]