19 ms·
Signs that a startup is focused on stuff that doesn’t matter
- CalChris 10y ago#1. Meetings. Don't even get me started.
- kyriakos 10y agoVanity is the key here. If you are spending on anything that doesn't directly improve your startups potential but makes you feel good then you should rethink your strategy.
- open_nsfw 10y agoGlad vanity metrics is being given a name. I've worked for one which obsessed about user signups long before we even had a product ready. It was ridiculous
- personjerry 10y agoI was under the impression that user sign ups is a real metric?
- twoshedsmcginty 10y ago"If you’re bootstrapped and have an email list of 1,000 people and want to grow that list, you don’t need a full-time email marketing manager, a writer, a designer and a junior marketer to execute on a content marketing strategy for you...You need a motivated, scrappy content marketer who can do all of those jobs at once." I agree about the time-wasting meetings, but not about the above, since I'm directly in that situation. You could hope to find one person to fill any two of those jobs, but all you'll get out of a 'scrappy content marketer' is a vacant position and a series of burnouts. That's hard work, where you have to invest resources to reap rewards.
- joshdotsmith 10y agoTo add to your point: people often make the mistake of trying to replace former team members with people who fit the exact skill profile of the person who left. It's highly improbable you'll find the perfect match. Instead, identify the bundle of tasks that person did and find people who can take them on separately, and perhaps accomplish other tasks you didn't even realize your team could do. If you were to identify every task your business needs, then you have the flexibility to direct those tasks to the right people. Further, if you're in a high-growth environment, you can continue to scale by motivating your people to fire themselves from their worst tasks and focus on their best expertise. If your team continues to evolve in this way while your company keeps sound unit economics, then congratulations! You've solved the scaling problem.
- dibstern 10y agoDoes that not depend entirely on the size/stage of your business, the size of your customers and your industry? I don't think it's unusual for an email list to be managed by one dude at an early stage tech startup.
- smitherfield 10y agoI think the idea is that it's worth "overpaying" for a single exceptional employee in a given area, as opposed to underpaying for several. (Which seems to be a definite truism in my observation of which businesses and teams succeed and fail).
- cookiecaper 10y agoIt's hard enough to find a single semi-competent employee by "overpaying". I don't think it's as simple as increasing the salary on the job listing by 20% and watching the super qualified candidates pour in.
- coredog64 10y agoI'm not privy to what my employer is advertising for senior DevOps positions, but I can tell you it's not nearly enough: I get resumes where "installed htop" is a prominent bullet point. Literally. The last two hires have been somewhere between oxygen thief and chair warmer. TL;DR: If you are getting crappy candidates, you are likely offering too little and could tempt better candidates with a better offer.
- debt 10y agoare you meeting demand of an underserved market people have nervous breakdowns and worse from running startups so make sure you're in a good spot financially to even do it everything u do creates value. that sexy button your designer just spent two days on cost the company $2600 hope it was worth it. that bug you left unfixed for a few releases now takes a whole weekend to fix and now one of your developer burns out and quits uh oh costs you $50000. everything has very very exact price tag. add up all the missteps and the successes and get the final outcome
- cobbzilla 10y agoGood article. One quibble: $5k for a conference sponsorship is pretty cheap; try finding any space at CES in that price range! If the conference audience is a perfect fit, and you feel your company/product is far enough along to leverage the exposure, it could make total sense to pay for a booth/sponsorship. If you don't have $5k to spend on marketing, or it's too early for it to be effective, that's a different story. But if you do, then compare spending the same amount on AdWords (or other marketing/lead-gen channel X) and see if the math works out.
- joshdotsmith 10y agoI generally love Alex's writing and have learned a ton. This example, and one or two others, stuck out as a little flawed here. If conference sponsorships are a traction channel that proves to be successful for you relative to other channels, then more power to you. To your final point, do what works for your company. This isn't going to come from blog posts – although you may get ideas there. It's going to come from the hard work of developing hypotheses, running experiments, and using benchmarks to start the process anew.
- biot 10y agoThe problem is when a startup treats a conference as a branding exercise ("we got our name out there... success!"), rather than as a means to acquire highly qualified leads so they can close deals and profit from the experience ("we got a 1000% ROI by closing $50K worth of deals... success!").
- Void_ 10y agoEverybody should try going through a bootstrapped business. We've been coding for a few months now and don't even have a website. Business cards? hahaha. Product + market fit comes first, everything else next.
- buro9 10y ago> Product + market fit comes first, everything else next. I've done the bootstrapped startup. I'd change that line, simplify it. Sales comes first, everything else next.
- idlewords 10y agoBreakfast comes first.
- fairpx 10y agoSales before breakfast = productive and energized rest of the day.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- weego 10y agoBreakfast is for closers!
- Void_ 10y agoMy boss used to say breakfast/eating/sleep/sports/anything that's not work is for wimps... Ah Silicon Valley.
- q-base 10y agoHe should have been a foot-soldier in the trenches of WWI - or more likely - just wants to appear as a badass.
- 10y ago
- vecter 10y agoThis is great advice. YC hammers home hard the point about not "playing" startup. You should be spending most of your time building your product, talking to users, and selling (or some variation thereof depending on your market). If you're not doing one of those three things, you're probably wasting your time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Animats 10y agoFrom the article: "SalesForce, and even much smaller companies, can comfortably spend $5,000 on a trade show booth because it’s a small part of their larger marketing strategy. It makes sense for them, because they can afford to buy booths at every relevant conference and get consistent face-time with their market over the long-term." SalesForce spent $250K on a party pre-IPO, back in 2000.[1] Four floors of the Regency and the B-52s. Playing startup was much bigger in the first dot-com boom. This time around, everybody is working very hard. Not necessarily on the right stuff, but working hard. [1] http://www.sfgirl.com/webtrash.html http://www.sfgirl.com/webtrash.html
- _pmf_ 10y ago> SalesForce, and even much smaller companies, can comfortably spend $5,000 on a trade show booth 5000 for a booth is a bargain even for really obscure trade shows, and it makes absolute sense for a B2B entity to be present at trade shows.
- ssharp 10y ago> it makes absolute sense for a B2B entity to be present at trade shows It may make sense for some B2B entities to be present at trade shows but the article is talking about early-stage companies buying trade show sponsorships. Depending on how you interpret "early-stage", I'd argue that this article is wholly accurate -- there likely is a smarter way to spend that $5,000. However, at some point you cross a line where your product is ready for the next growth stage and that $5,000 is well spent at $X Conference. At that point, $X Conference is part of your larger marketing strategy, also pointed out in the article.
- gsylvie 10y agoThe original article is completely wrong on this point. Maybe some startups sponsor but don't attend? That would be foolish. Alternatively, spending any money on marketing before you have anything customers can actually buy or use or trial would be foolish. But if you've got something even a little bit useful that's ready for people to try, and you plan to attend the conference, that $5,000 is a smoking deal!!!
- apatters 10y agoHello, founder of a bootstrapped WordPress theme & plugin development business reporting in. Been running a profitable "startup" for 5-7 years (depending on whether you count my first two years as a solo freelancer). Can confirm that not all startups are like this! 1) Meetings We have one per week and sometimes cancel that because we feel it's overkill 2) Hiring tons of people If anything we don't hire enough because we never spend money we haven't yet earned 3) Vanity benchmarks One benchmark - cash in the bank (if it's too little, tighten the belt, if it's too much, spend it to grow) 4) Meetups I'm terrible at networking and should do more of these! 5) Sponsoring conferences HA! 6) Office, business cards and so on Don't have either... 100% remote has worked since day one... OK, just got an office (sort of, it's shared) in Bangkok but no one works there! 7) Having more conversations with people outside of your market than people in it I am totally guilty of that one! Please don't take any of this as a claim that we are better... I can and have leveled a thousand criticisms at how I run things... just saying, "startups" that exist way, way outside of this mold are definitely out there :)
- zdkl 10y agoOn the other hand, what you describe doesn't sound like a start up from the high-growth/external investment required point of view. Sure startup is a sexier way to describe a young, small business but semantics aside, this feels like "traditional" business looking for glamour. Of which I am equally guilty, donnt take this as criticism.
- apatters 10y agoIf I was looking for glamour I would have raised money, started the type of business described in the blog post, and probably gone on to make many more of the mistakes it lists. I guess the point I'm trying to make is if you're an aspiring business owner you don't have to go for this high-growth/external investment model. It encourages lax fiscal discipline which is the cause of these mistakes. I sometimes feel people I know who have gone through this could have learned more and earned more by bootstrapping.
- 10y ago
- myf01d 10y ago8) "We are doing it for passion, creating value, vision, future, entrepreneurship, making clients' lives easier, etc.. and NOT FOR THE MONEY OR POWER AT ALL"
- elkos 10y agoI really cringe on statement like this. Since startups are not non-profit organizations I tend to cringe when I hear all this "making the world a better place" mantra. I understand that many startup founders have values and vision but as soon as funding comes I think it gets more complicated that.
- nostrademons 10y agoCurious why you make the distinction between for-profit and non-profit organizations. All organizations face the challenge of their vision of "making the world a better place" not necessarily lining up with the vision of the folks for whom they want to make it better. For-profit companies at least have the signal of "someone is willing to pay me for this" as a concrete guide to whether they align with anyone. Watsi's founder talked a fair bit about this in his Startup School presentation (which is excellent, BTW): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WlT3UhC7NwQ#t=490 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WlT3UhC7NwQ#t=490
- Flenser 10y agoFor-profit companies at least have the signal of "someone is willing to pay me for this" as a concrete guide to whether they align with anyone. and non-profit companies have the signal of "someone is willing to donate money to pay me to do this for someone else"
- myf01d 10y agoEntrepreneurship is just a goal for the sake of itself, if you're engineer/tech and you are aware you are just a "slave" who does all the work for almost nothing/a little while the so called "entrepreneurs" do almost nothing and get everything, why don't you become a master (i.e. entrepreneur) yourself, and employ another fool to do the real work for you while you grow a fortune doing almost nothing. Sorry for my English.
- idlewords 10y agoIt seems like the culprit here is easy money. We've had twelve years now of ample funding for startups, and a whole generation of coders who have not seen lean times in their entire career. In such circumstances, you would expect people to get profligate.
- nostrademons 10y agoHas it really been 12 years of ample funding? My recollection is that the downturn in 08-09 was really steep, with Sequoia sending out warnings to all their portfolio companies, mass layoffs at most Bay Area tech companies (my roommate when I moved out here went through 4 rounds at EMC, and was doing the work of 3 people by the end of it), dramatic rent decreases, and the almost total extinction of the Web 2.0 startup craze (remember that?). It recovered in late 2010 with the mobile boom - that's when companies like Uber, Instagram, SnapChat, Parse, etc. were founded. And those companies that managed to survive the downturn (DropBox, AirBnB, KickStarter, Whatsapp, Evernote) emerged quite strong, and were ready to take on massive amounts of funding afterwards.
- idlewords 10y agoI was out of the US then, so I may well be wrong. My recollection (working remotely as a consultant) was that people panicked for a month or two, and after that working in tech was like a magical oasis from the chaos. What was other people's experience like?
- Naritai 10y agoExperiences varied wildly. For employees, it was a terrible time. Large companies were laying off left and right, and Sequoia did indeed advise all CEOs to fire their devs if their product was already on the market. However, since the stock market was doing so badly, it was the beginning of the moment where a _lot_ of money started looking for somewhere else to go. So if you were of the wherewithal to go out and make a startup, it was a great time to be looking for funding. So it depends a lot on who you ask. I will say, though, that real estate started taking off in ~2011, so it was more than a month of panic, but I would guess that in 2011-2013 or so SF was far and away the strongest local economy in the US.
- markatkinson 10y agoGosh this hits close to home. I tried to start a business with a friend beginning of the year. Too many meetings... Too much money on business cards and logos... Too much travelling... I definitely learned a hell of a lot, but I did have this nagging feeling the whole while like "wait, why do I have a business card, I don't even know what I am supposed to be selling here".
- dj-wonk 10y ago> "the unimaginably high likelihood of failure" What? I can imagine the rate might be as high as 100%. That's hardly "unimaginable". I am not trying to be merely annoying or pedantic here. I simply want authors to tighten up their writing and exaggerate less. With an exaggeration like that, I stop reading.
- babuskov 10y agoThanks for this comment. I think you just saved me time reading the article and further HN comments. In fact, I feel so much time was saved, I used some of it to write this. I'm serious.
- dj-wonk 10y ago> More often than not, meetings are a waste of time, leaned on by people who don’t want to make a difficult decision and would rather punt it to a group. I have a different experience. Meetings aren't the problem. Getting 2+ people together is important. The problem is how the interaction happens and the costs and benefits involved. No one said that leadership or communication is easy. Building collective will is both an art and a science. I say this: don't blame meetings. They are necessary. Learn to run better meetings.
- sankyo 10y agoA meeting that does not result in 1) a decision 2) action items or 3) information distribution is a waste of time. As a team, meetings are necessary to get "on the same page". It is true, sometimes in a meeting we think, "This could have been done with email". And other times when there is an email thread with 20+ responses, we think "A meeting would have solved this faster" It is not always easy to plumb the depths of a topic to decide beforehand.
- dschiptsov 10y agoWhy, cosplay is much more easier and pleasant than the actual thing, especially in the age of social media and role governed behavior - the age of cosplay. You wouldn't believe how many idiots are cosplaying scientists, leave alone all these hipsters cosplaying intelligence.. In general, it boils down to the social advantage of displaying "success" and "competence" - socially constructed markers. But there is a beautiful principle in biology - the "signals" must be honest and costly, impossible to cheat - one cannot cosplay parasite resistance, superior foraging ability, or good genes in general. One cannot cosplay youth and health. All these celebrities are ridiculous. Hipsterism is cheap cosplay of intelligence. Founders cosplay special talents and abilities they does not possess. Nothing to see here.
- jarrettlenox 10y ago"...and he’s a sought-after advisor for young companies looking to break through the noise." That article and these comments were written by a bot. It's all spam.
- jarrettlenox 10y ago"I started to fall in love with feeling like I had a successful business." - Donald J Trump
- jarrettlenox 10y ago"If you want to play startup, and have the money to do so, go for it." - Donald J Trump
- glenndebacker 10y agoThe company I working for is more then 6 years old but we are still calling ourself a startup. Sometimes I think it's because of marketing reasons or as an alibi for certain decisions because "that is how they do it in startups". Although we only do the meetings stuff, the benefits we don't have. So when exactly is a company not a startup anymore ?
- elcapitan 10y agoI thought that startups are there to try out new business models? So by that definition at some point you're either a business (proven) or a failure (disproven). OR you're sitting on a big bag of other people's money (startup forever, yay).
- jarrettlenox 10y ago"The bigger your team is, the more serious your company feels." - Donald J Trump
- jarrettlenox 10y ago"Look, I get that it’s nice to have stuff with your company’s name on it…" - Donald J Trump
- sctb 10y agoPlease stop posting such off-topic comments or we'll ban the account.
- a3_nm 10y agoI would add three others: 1. Spending too much time designing an "About" page, a "Who we are" page, an "FAQ" page, to present the startup and what the product will be, rather than actually developing the product. 2. Being very secretive about your very great (but generally vague) startup idea, instead of working on execution. 3. Having a product that is perpetually "almost ready" to launch but never getting around to taking care of that last 80%.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ssharp 10y agoI'd argue point #1 isn't that terrible if you're a B2B company. Having some veil of being a legitimate company isn't the worst thing if you're trying to get a business to commit to using and paying for your product. That isn't to say those pages need to be grandiose but knowing that the product is supported by more than one person is something you probably want to convey if you're looking for growth.
- wpietri 10y agoSure. Everything on these lists is something that's valuable to some extent. But it shifts into "playing startup" the moment you're doing it because it makes you feel more important, because it makes you look better in the eyes of somebody besides the customers you need to acquire in the next few months.
- saddestcatever 10y agoThanks for these. Way more direct than the article.
- nom 10y agoto 1: The About page is not always targeted towards the customer but it's important for investors and other businesses. You just have to look good, the first impression counts. It also doesn't take a lot of effort to create it, so why not? But I get what you are saying. If the website, videos, and social media posts look awesome and the startup has more swag to offer than real progress, they obviously spend their money and time at the wrong end.
- DonHopkins 10y ago>Soon, you’ll begin spending more time sharing stories with other founders to learn about their journeys than you spend talking to your customers and your prospects to learn about their needs. Is it even still possible to use the word "journey" in this context without it dripping with snarky ironic reference to "Our Incredible Journey" [1], with the obvious implication that a start-up is doomed to sell out and shut down and screw all their customers? That the actual "journey" being taken is the wild goose chase of the unwitting customers being led down the garden path? [2] [1] https://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com https://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com [2] http://www.gyford.com/phil/writing/2013/02/27/our-incredible-journey.php http://www.gyford.com/phil/writing/2013/02/27/our-incredible...
- wingerlang 10y agoI am pretty sure that's how he intended to use it, considering he is giving an example of what the founders (the ones who are "playing startup") are, or will be, doing (talking about their journeys).
- DonHopkins 10y agoThanks for the confirmation of my suspicions. For some reason, I didn't think he was allegorically referring to the incredible 250 mile journey through the Canadian wilderness of Luath the Labrador Retriever, Bodger the Bull Terrier, and Tao the Siamese cat. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Incredible_Journey_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Incredible_Journey_(film)
- mpoloton 10y agoI admit I was guilty of this. After failing in my first startup I realized that I was playing the startup game rather than creating true value.
- elcct 10y agoAs some other people wrote as well - everyone should try to work in a start up at least once. You can learn a lot, especially how not to do things. It will be useful when the day comes of having your own start up :)
- chiefalchemist 10y agoThey all seem to sum up to: Too much money, not enough urgency.
- Klockan 10y agoI think the worst offender is writing blog posts about startups rather than running them.
- toomanybeersies 10y agoWow, this pretty much sums up to a tee a new company that's moved into my coworking space. They haven't even launched yet, and they have 9 people, and more working remotely. They also all have branded team swag. The company I work for is mostly bootstrapped, we've been around for about 3 years now and we still don't have swag, and have only 7 employees (most of whom are sales and support, because we're in a market that requires a lot of human interaction for sales).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ihaveahadron 10y agoSwag
- mseebach 10y agoSo the other company has (a) funding and (b) a different strategy than you. This tell us nothing about the quality of either business.
- musha68k 10y agoDear founders: 1: identify/invent __problem__ 2: create! solution 3: sell! solution 4: save __profits__ 5: goto 1
- Kiro 10y agoAnother dangerous thing is that you get a sort of false validation from the startup bubble. You mingle with other startup founders and "everyone" is talking about your idea. You get the feeling you're onto something big but in reality the hype never spreads outside the bubble and the idea may not even have a market fit at all.
- gchokov 10y agoYou'd be surprised, but enterprises like to play the startup game nowadays too! There're whole divisions spinning off as startups all the time... :)
- amelius 10y agoYes, it started around the time when Google put the tag "beta" on all of their products.
- mhurron 10y agoAlong with the 'open office work like a startup looks like' disease.
- noxToken 10y agoPlease! Stop! It's like you're kicking me in the teeth! I'm with an international corporation. This week alone, I'm averaging about 2 hours of meetings per day. I was expected to attend an "optional" networking event last week. Since it was "optional", I didn't go. If and when that negatively affects me, I'll know it's time to go job hunting. I can see from one end of this floor to the other, because open office floor plan is best office floor plan.
- lr4444lr 10y agoThere’s a good chance that one or more of these resonated with you. And that’s okay; it doesn’t mean that you’re going to fail in business Yes it does, and you deserve it so that someone more capable can come along. </rant>
- amelius 10y agoI guess there is also anxiety involved: if you actually start to build something, there's a big chance you will run into at least some problems. "Playing startup" is a good way to avoid those problems.
- noir_lord 10y agoI have two products I want to build (one more than the other) but I'm raising the capital (which is pretty small, mostly it's time I need) needed to do the initial development by running a small dev-shop with my business partner, client work pays the bills and leaves enough free time to work on the product, it'll take longer to build and there is a slight risk of someone building something similar (though I've not seen anything remotely like it yet which means a) good idea b) it's a terrible idea). I've no interest in the "startup" model, We work out of a very cheap office in a council (local gov) building and we run cheap!, total business costs (inc rent, internet and phone) run around £450 a month for both businesses (the dev shop and business partners design business), We have a local startup hub that would cost that for a couple of hotdesks, it's crazy.
- tome 10y ago> We work out of a very cheap office in a council How did you arrange that?
- noir_lord 10y agoThat should have been council owned building, typing on a phone is still painful. Lots of councils here in the UK own office buildings and rent them out, We get two big rooms as a single office for ~340 a month which includes 24/7 access everything but phone/internet basically. You can see the size of my side http://imgur.com/a/H7fxb http://imgur.com/a/H7fxb in the bottom image, that desk is 8ft long, the other side is even bigger (maybe 60% bigger) but I didn't want it because it's too bright.
- tome 10y agoVery nice! I'm not sure whether I'm surprised that the council has offices that are so much cheaper than privately available. Would you mind saying which council this is?
- noir_lord 10y agoNot at all, Hull City Council. They are managed by the NPS group one of those, privatise the public sector deals. Though out building lease was just taken over by a non-profit setup to help younger people get started in business, so far they've been amazing at getting an old building up to spec :). Hull is a bit of a basket case economically but its on the up and would be a good place to run a startup if you want cheap good offices and insane broadband, I have 250Mbps at home!
- caseysoftware 10y ago> he points out that a one-hour meeting with eight people isn’t really a one-hour meeting at all; it’s a meeting that just consumed eight hours of productive time from your team I still think this is an underestimate. Odds are people were working on something before the meeting and stopped just a bit early to get their notes together or read that email chain or whatever. Count on at least 5 minutes but assume more like 15. And then after the meeting people collect their notes, head back to their desks, and then to read the recap after. Another 15 minutes is likely. So that 1 hour meeting just became 1.5+ hours times 8 people. What a waste.
- matwood 10y agoI think a better point is to simply say cut all the bullshit. Bullshit work is just as bad if not worse than bullshit meetings. Programmers hate bullshit meetings but many will happily do bullshit work and change over the whole project to a new, flavor of the week js framework. Sometimes meetings are required, just like sometimes changing frameworks is required. The skill is separating the required from the bullshit.
- caseysoftware 10y agoMy rule: No agenda, no attenda. (I didn't come up with it.)
- bmm6o 10y agoUgh, yes. To be fair, running a meeting well is an acquired skill. It's just that it's never taught and nobody realizes that they run shitty, inefficient meetings.
- acedinlowball 10y agoMy rule: Call going to take longer than 2 minutes? Send me an email. I don't waste my time talking to people when I could be working. Personal preference, I know not everyone will agree with it.
- thesmallestcat 10y ago
- SFJulie 10y agoYou can know easily know if a startup will fail: try to make them easily state how they expect to make money. Most self named startup that are as much a startup the new baker around the corner feel self entitled to be fuzzy about earning money. A baker is like a startup, it requires freaking investment, it requires innovation, it requires to adapt to a market where distributions bake frozen «high value» (frozen) bread at 50% of the costs. But a baker will always know how he/she makes money, how much investments are needed, that they must have a plan to reimburse debts, a point of equilibrium, a knowledge of operational costs and a clear position on the market in front of competition. That is why I am trying to get hired by the baker around the corner, I feel more entrepreneurship in this guy than most MBA in suits and tie that plays with others money and lives without a real sense of responsibility or professionalism.
- dkhenry 10y agoI don't get the meetings bulletpoint. There is no way a startup can compare to the meetings load of a "Big Boy" company. I have always marked the transition from "Start-up" to "Enterprise" by how much time the company spends in meetings. Smaller companies make more decisions by force of persona, and larger ones have endless meetings to make sure no one feels left out of a minute decision. We have even codified it into a named activity in the software development process, bike shedding
- mwfunk 10y agoAnother way to look at it is that the activity being done in the big company is usually going to be much larger scale and affect many more people than the activity being done at the startup- those small groups of startup people pushing through ideas by force of personality/lack of resistance can easily be engaging in just as much bikeshedding, it's just that in a smaller org there's fewer people and lower stakes. Smaller orgs are by definition going to be more agile than larger orgs, but that doesn't grant them more wisdom, just the ability to execute bad decisions more quickly. The only way to avoid bad organizations is to stay out of them, regardless of size IME.
- nathanvanfleet 10y agoMost of these points are "too much of X" on things that are not necessarily obvious. Don't have "too many" meetings, or buy "too much" schwag. There's an arbitrary value in there where apparently you've passed the invisible marker, and you're not a real business anymore to this guy. It really reeks of someone looking in retrospect and saying "oh, you spent too much time in meetings maybe?" Why can't this just be real businesses who are making mistakes, which could or could not be fatal?
- wpietri 10y agoIt could be, but I've seen the problem as well. One obvious reason it's different is the number of people who now have the explicit goal of doing a startup. They don't know what they want to do, but gosh golly they're sure they want to be startup founders. This is different than, say, 2003. Or 1995. Then, basically nobody wanted to "do a startup". Starting a company was not generally seen positively. It was hard to do, it took many years to get anywhere, it was likely to fail, and you could end up broke. So the people doing it really wanted to launch a particular product, solve a particular problem. They were people with a specific burning vision that they wanted to make real. But now you'll talk to people who see it as just another career choice. They're going to go to grad school or do a startup. They'll join an investment bank or do a startup. Their idea, their burning passion? They don't have one. But they want to be a founder! Maybe! What that means, of course, is they want to appear a founder. It's basically like playing dress-up. Except at $1m+ per year of other people's money. That's why the failure mode involves things that look like business but are anathema to serious founders: lots of meetings (where, yay, everybody listens to you because you're the founder), lots of headcount (because that's what grown-up businesses have), vanity metrics, fancy office space, etc, etc. To people really in business, "too many" has a pretty clear baseline: the absolute minimum you need to get shit done, to make and sell your product. That's why HP started in a garage. Every dollar you spend on vanity is a dollar you you aren't spending on something that matters to your customers.
- morgante 10y agoThe meetup advice is highly contextual. If the people at the meetups/events are your target customers, it can be very valuable time (both in terms of getting feedback and closing actual customers).
- djyaz1200 10y agoCompletely agree with the premise here. I think some of the causes of this are worth exploring/understanding. I believe part of it is just about getting laid. Startups are cool right now, they are like the modern band. You can create a sense of "...maybe this guy is the next Zuck?" with girls fairly easily. Another part of it is that there are a lot of people in the startup community that prey on others and/or have no clue. I wasted a shameful amount of time on what I've heard YC folks refers to as "playing house" because that's what people in my community were encouraging, and I didn't know any better. Only when I stopped going to meetups and searching for validation elsewhere was I able to truly begin building a business by focusing exclusively on solving problems for clients.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zebraflask 10y agoI'm probably drawing from a limited sample, and might not be articulating it well, but I would add: Developing a business plan that depends on a web-based product to succeed, then, instead of focusing on developing the product, hiring a bunch of assistants and reps to do the product's job by hand. You hear the words "concierge," "curated," and - worse - "bespoke" thrown around a lot when this is going on. The actual product development ends up getting bogged down in a lot of the things that article discusses. My impression is also that there's often an overly-ambitious tech stack for what amounts to a CRUD app with a few feature tweaks.
- driverdan 10y agoDoing something manually is a great way to test an idea. It shouldn't interfere with building the automated product though.
- zebraflask 10y agoI think that's what I'm getting at, it does in this scenario. A crude but working MVP could be knocked out in a month or two using any of a number of frameworks. Instead, a year or two later, the app is still half-built and most of the client base is coming from the manual work done by assistants, who prop up the illusion that the tech part of the company is on track.
- vinchuco 10y agothis describes graduate school quite well
- exabrial 10y agoThis is my opinion, and I know it won't be popular, so give me some slack for admitting that and posting it anyway. You can tell a startup is focusing on the wrong thing when: They're using the 'newest', most obscure, programming language or frameworks available because it's the 'best' for some unscientific reason. Instantly I hear the argument "Yah, but if we need to scale, we don't want to re-write." Ok, you're going to rewrite anyway. Right now your problem is producing quality code that additional people can onboard themselves with. Chances are you can produce something very practical using plain GET/POST operations and gradually add more interactivity on the client side if you prove your product out. The stem of my rant is this: Recently I was thinking about picking up some side work for extra $. The company I was interviewing with described their front end team as struggling to keep pace and needed some temporary help. The product is under NDA, so let's just say it's a shared calendar. Their stack was insane: 18 different javascript frameworks, required a certain version of Node.js to "compile" to ES6, then another to run it in your browser, and the stylesheets were written in some other obscure language. In the second interview, I told the product manager I think he's been had: the reason your front end team is struggling is because they're not being practical, they're busy with shiny toys. He said he had a feeling, but given his situation he didn't have much of a choice but to continue. He thanked me for being honest and said he understood if I wasn't interested anymore. Anyway, there's a lot of really "cool" stuff to get distracted by as developers. I think a lot of us need to sober up and really meditate on the phrase "do the simplest thing that could possibly work".
- tonyplee 10y agoThe more I look at the latest frameworks, the happier I got with just JQuery + bootstrap.
- savanaly 10y agoTo some people, jQuery and bootstrap are overkill (motherfuckingwebsite.com, etc). The rule of thumb is if someone is using a more complicated stack than me then they're foolishly overengineering their app and if they're using a simpler stack than me then they're unsophisticated novices.
- 10y ago
- Dwolb 10y agoIt's super easy to discount people who have these habits but I think we should also look at why these habits develop. Part of what makes a start-up hard is there aren't any processes in place nor a true north for what the company should do nor how they should do it. Coupled with people who might be new to start-ups and lack the ability to optimize which tasks they work on, I'd bet some of these bad habits develop. Another time when these bad habits may develop is when people are fighting fires all day. They don't always have the time to reasses how and when to fix what's broken to set up the company for future success. The rule of thumb I try to think about is "what activities have high leverage" and "will talking about or doing this change what we do or how we do it?". These two checks often help me figure out if the activity is worth doing or if it's "bullshit".
- ak39 10y agoAgreed about identifying the real reasons why, habit wise, startup owners do things the way they do. I am talking psychologically, blind spots. Many of us can only introspect effectively when we're afforded sufficient space to think clearly. I've been through almost all 7 items that Alex Turnbull lists in the article. In the end we had to lay off our single employee (prematurely hired), close office (prematurely leased) and put in storage most of our furniture. We were forced to reconsider all we did through the new lens of this criteria: is there a paying client? It was a bitter and, memory wise, a cringe-worthy part of my recent history. I'm in my 40s (started our startup when I was 39 - three years ago) and only really had partial experience doing independent consulting. My experience and practical references have only ever been informed from the perspective of an employee and through the paradigm of that working ethic. This, the employee thinking, was the weakest heritage I took into the startup world. As a technical software developer I am sufficiently competent, but only ever lived in an employee (sheltered) worldview. This was a fatal disposition to take into the world of startup. I learnt a few things in the months after we restarted (circa 2015 Jan): 1. Startup owners run scared 24/7 2. Fear drives most, if not all, decisions 3. The single most import source of fear is the quitting of a secure job 4. Fear affects your technical abilities 5. Hope is the ointment for the fear 6. Subconscious drive to drown out the fear usually means propping up hope, which is usually accomplished by spending, hiring and "growing" - and by spending time with people or groups considered "safe" (out of your field to give you objective feedback!) 7. Rejection feeds fear and affects momentum of progress. So opportunities are avoided because rejection is more likely than success is. It takes courage and an endocrine balance that favours decisions made without influence of fear. This can only happen when you lose your blind spots.
- pinaceae 10y agogiven the current pace of insights, by 2025 the tech scene will slowly realize how to actually run a profitable business rather than a "startup". books will be written, talks will be held. and anyone outside tech will continue to look in bewilderment as to what the fuck is going on here.
- btbuildem 10y ago8) Writing blog posts.
- Kiro 10y agoWhy was the title changed from the original one? Bad decision IMO.
- dang 10y agoThe HN guidelines call for changing linkbait titles (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). Titles that use superlatives and evoke indignation are on the baity side, so we changed it to the subtitle, with "you" replaced by the more neutral "a startup".
- Kurimo 10y agoAnother one to add in is "Buzzword Chasing." I've been a part of a startup where we were growing our core product at a reasonable rate and having success. But some of our customers kept throwing certain buzzwords at us, "Millennials" being the most oft repeated one. As a result, our founder pivoted hard to a new product targeting that buzzword. The consequences have not been ideal. Another buzzword that is currently threatening to derail us again is "bots." Buzzwords or trends are something big companies can afford to waste thousands or even millions of dollars chasing aimlessly (often for no real return). A startup cannot. Startups need to have a clear vision of a single product and pursue it relentlessly until they are in the black. When our customers throw buzzwords at us they aren't expressing a need. Reacting to it as such is often self destructive.
- BrandonWatson 10y agoHow is "utilizing time contributing to comments on a post like this on HN instead of working on your product" not on the list? :)
- trymas 10y agocompletely OT: I like that HN has strong and heavy moderation for titles, the more definite - the better. On topic - IMHO articles like these should be more frequent. I dislike 'startup culture'. They should build a business first (or at least have monetization strategy) and party later.
- GCA10 10y agoThe biggest killer: pursuing the wrong customers/users. I like Groove's list, but all seven of its sins flow out of that more-fundamental problem. Get a few troublesome customers ... and you will be stuck in a lot of meetings, trying to figure out what they want, how to deal with their latest crazy requirements/deadlines, etc. The meetings are a symptom. Not the root cause. It's the same story with "vanity benchmarks." Good benchmarks reinforce smart business choices (i.e doing business with the right people.) The way you know you're worshiping vanity benchmarks is if they keep generating traffic, leads, etc. that take you ever deeper into the valley of canceled accounts and anti-profits.
- metaphorm 10y agothis is ridiculously important and deserves an entire manifesto/epic-rant to be written about it. having just recently switched jobs, the single biggest cause of pain, failure, frustration, and everything else that sucks at the company I left was pursuing the wrong customers. throwing good money after bad is a losing situation. some customers need to be allowed to quit. they're not worth keeping on.
- mancerayder 10y ago"Doesn't matter" is perhaps too bold. 'Misprioritized' better describes what I've seen. Sometimes partners have trouble seeing what's more important than something else, either because of communication issues with people below them, or because they get an idea they just can't shake. The sign that I saw most prominently was operational instability. The application would have performance and sometimes uptime issues; these issues were predictable but time and effort was spent on things other than beefing up infrastructure to make that happen. When moving off of GMail takes higher precedence than creating an Highly Available web server setup, you know that's a sign that things aren't prioritized well.
- rompic 10y agoI would add planning the 3rd relaunch of your website to the list.
- bduerst 10y agoEverything in this listicle (except #4) applies to product teams in general, ranging from a startup to an enterprise company. I don't really think attending meetups are an issue, tbh. Are there startups that force employees to repeatedly go?
- kumarski 10y agoThe one thing that solves all problems and is cheap, is lots of customer conversations.
- rdtsc 10y agoI think there is a deeper underlying problem why they are focusing on stuff that doesn't matter -- to avoid doing stuff that matters. Usually the reason is because it is hard or tedious. I have seen others do it and I've done it myself. Someone doesn't know how code so instead they become very vocal and go to all meetings or tell everyone documentation updating or benchmarking is what is crucial and they'll focus on that. There is of course nothing wrong with all the other tasks, but I think it is worth looking at why all of the sudden these new priorities are being pushed. Deep down everyone wants to seem important look busy, so people will always find busy work. Sometimes they find something is useful, but often it is just random stuff, just not appear idle. "How are you doing Steve, how is new database backend coming along? - Well I decided we should re-prioritize our customer accounts, and then I worked on updating all the documentation, and a meeting is coming along we should present there..." The point is employees engage in this avoidance busy works but CxOs, managers and owners do this as well. In their case it is even more damaging because they pull in the whole company after them. "Stop everyone, I found a cool new JS frameworks it is super reactive, we should rewrite our front end in it".
- kmote00 10y agoSounds like the folks at 18F are a poster child for this sort of mis-behavior. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2016/11/02/why-a-federal-high-tech-start-up-is-a-money-loser/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2016/11/02/...
- codingdave 10y agoI really just have one measure of whether a startup is on-track or not -- can they verbalize to you what core business transaction is going to take place wherein a customer will give them money in exchange for a product/service? If not, there is no business there.
- thecrazyone 10y agoI'd say reading Hacker news and watching startup videos in YouTube is what I feel guilty about but I don't know of a better way to learn about building companies