7 ms·
Who's to Blame for the 16 GB RAM Limit on the New MacBook Pros: Apple or Intel?
- brentis 10y agoApple is so deeply in Gruber he can barely say anything that would off be Apple. Very old - his site would be dead if Apple didn't give him the occasional morsel of inside knowledge. Move along.
- wlesieutre 10y agoSo do you have a criticism of the argument he's making or what?
- coldtea 10y agoNotice how your comment is both content-less and just an ad-hominem. You know you don't like Gruber because he's so into Apple, but not any actual complaint with anything specific you have, or what makes you think "his site would be dead if Apple didn't give him the occasional morsel of inside knowledge" (since he rarely if ever breaks news stories -- he usually posts his analysis after the fact).
- kubatyszko 10y agoFirst gen of Intel Mac's had 2GB limit (even though the chipset could address 3 or 4 GB), this got fixed later. My bet it that revision 2 in 6-12 months with whatever next Intel CPU generation will take 32GB with no issues.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- legohead 10y agoAfter hearing people complain about the new Macbook limit on 16gb RAM, I went to check out what the Surface Book offers -- which is, also, a max of 16gb RAM.
- coldtea 10y agoAnd which nobody even thought of raising as an issue...
- dlss 10y agoBecause in the windows market, surface isn't a laptop targeting video editors, game programmers, etc. It's a thin and light entry. Contrast with lenovo portable workstations which got 64gb over a year ago: http://www.theverge.com/2015/8/11/9129681/lenovo-skylake-xeon-notebooks-p50-p70 http://www.theverge.com/2015/8/11/9129681/lenovo-skylake-xeo... Apple produces every osx compatible device. This means it needs to produce at least one device that can meet the needs of power users.
- codepope2014 10y agoHave you not watched MIcrosofts "can't do that in a Mac" campaign? 3D modelling, video editing, lots of heavy lift graphics apps...
- coldtea 10y agoAnd yet most video editors I know use Macs, same for "heavy lift graphics apps". Nobody (ie very few) run around with a 8lbs/4hour battery "desktop replacement" PC to do such things on the go.
- dorfsmay 10y agoI don't know about the surface, but I've bee putting off my 6 year old Thinkpad x220 because the current replacement, the x260 has a 16gb limit.
- pritambaral 10y agoThe X series of ThinkPads are designed to be slim and light. If you want 32GB in a ThinkPad, there are other series available with 32GB units. Unfortunately, if you want a 32GB macOS laptop, you're out of luck with Apple.
- ppurka 10y agoIf I am not mistaken, the chipsets on the Intel NUC models are laptop chipsets. I have the Skylake Core i3 version and that supports up to 32G of LPDDR4 RAM (dual channel). Since the thin laptops typically have only one RAM slot, it makes sense why they are limited to only 16G. With this in mind, my understanding is that it is perhaps a limitation of the current Intel chips for single RAM slots, combined with the reluctance of the laptop manufacturer to include dual channel memory in their (thin) laptops.
- rayiner 10y agoEven the Macbook has dual-channel memory. They don't have RAM slots--they solder memory chips directly to the motherboard.
- ppurka 10y agoHaving RAM slots that are user serviceable and having them soldered directly into the motherboard is besides the point. If there is only one RAM slot (whether soldered-on or otherwise), then the total memory that can be supported is at most 16G.
- rayiner 10y agoThere are no DIMM slots at all on an MB or MBP motherboard. There are bare memory chips soldered in a dual channel configuration.
- S_A_P 10y agoI overrammed my previous MacBook. It was a max of 4 or 8 Gb can't remember but I ended up going 8/16. It worked fine until the keyboard failed. I'm going to replace it eventually.
- revelation 10y agoBattery is a pure smoke screen. They had no qualms cutting battery life to make it that little bit thinner and put in a watch with horizontal striped OLED display.
- grzm 10y ago"They had no qualms cutting battery life" I haven't seen where Apple cut battery life in the MacBook Pro. Here's what's reported now (granted, it's from Apple's website): 15" MacBook Pro 2015 - Up to 9 hours wireless web http://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs-2015/ http://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs-2015/ 2016 - Up to 10 hours wireless web http://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs/ http://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs/ If there are other references out there (particularly if they're independent of Apple), please share! Or perhaps you're referring to something besides last week's MacBook Pro updates?
- givinguflac 10y agoYep, battery life is improved but hey don't let that get in the way of Apple hate lol.
- rayiner 10y agoIt sucks they didn't use the opportunity to make battery life better, but at least on the 13" non-touchbar it seems like they didn't make it worse: http://www.laptopmag.com/reviews/laptops/macbook-pro-13-inch http://www.laptopmag.com/reviews/laptops/macbook-pro-13-inch. 12 hours is the same as the 2015 13" rMBP on that test.
- marichards 10y agoIt was annoying, a few years ago, trying to find a non-Apple laptop with better specifications. Now it's too easy, as a developer, I rarely find CPU limits my speed (typing is a limitation) but ram does limit how much I can do at once, or at least how many vms and containers I can run whilst developing, testing and searching stackoverflow. However, I use Linux laptops, but my graphic designing partner who loves to have lots of elements of work open at once as she works out how to aggregate them, is going to find it harder to cope, especially as graphics resolutions keep getting better and needing more memory.
- pcurve 10y agoI'm a little bit surprised at this outrage considering there are very few PC laptops that offer 32GB+ DDR4. XPS15 offers 32GB but its battery life is rather poor. Thinkpad P50 offers 64gb with tested battery life of over 8 hours, but it clocks in at 5.8lbs. I'm a pretty heavy duty user and I have 3 machines that each has 8GB. (PC, PC, Mac). What the hell are people doing on their 13.3 - 15inch laptop that requires 32GB?
- PostOnce 10y agoI assume people who have a macbook pro that they dock and connect to a big display, and don't really own a desktop. You can plow a field with a honda civic, but it's not really the "right" tool for the job. The same applies to insisting on a 64GB laptop as your main workstation.
- rayiner 10y agoIf you spend all your time docked, why do you care about a 15" screen? I've got a 15" MBP precisely because I do a lot of work out of conference rooms, hotel rooms, etc. Traditional "road warrior" stuff. Battery life is a huge premium there.
- hibikir 10y agoI do a lot of work outside of an office too, but I don't care about the battery life advantages. For my workloads, battery life is already terrible in a modern MBP, because all those great battery gains from the last 10 years are really about idle performance, not flattening the processor. My MBP is rarely quiet: Too often it has to do enough processing to sound like an airplane about to take off. If you actually tax it, it lasts about two hours before it runs out of juice. I'd much rather have more power and less battery life than to just give up, buy a tablet with a keyboard, since then the computer is nothing more than a modernized VT100 terminal, and do all real computing in the cloud.
- pcurve 10y agoI see. I guess time will tell if apple made the right call to sacrifice ports and memory in exchange for thin and light. I have a feeling that Apple's bigger screw up is the new pricing. Cost of getting 15" laptop is now $2,400, which is colossally more expensive than before. Some people just need bigger screen, and not high end specs.
- tbrock 10y agoWhat 13" laptop of this form factor and size has 32gb of ram as an option? Answer: none
- yetiii 10y ago14" but 32gb of memory - thinkpad t460
- dorfsmay 10y agoBut 14 inches (too big for me).
- douche 10y agoWhat are these, laptops for ants?
- dorfsmay 10y agoTry to use a 14 inch in a packet commuter train or in an airplane. 12.5 are small enough that they can be used anywhere, the whole point of a laptop for me. If I need more screen space when at home I can plug an external monitor.
- douche 10y ago12.5" is tiny. I would not be able to fit both hands on the keyboard. That's almost at the point of the eeePC I once had that I had to balance on one hand, and type with the other. It worked for screwing around and pecking away a few notes, but I was some glad to pull out my 17" laptop if I had to actually do anything.
- sliken 10y agoThe extra 0.7 inches is a deal killer? More important than double the ram?
- 10y ago
- plinkplonk 10y agoI've been checking his site the last few days just to get the pro Apple spin. This is awesome. Can Apple ever make a serious mistake in Gruber's eyes?
- grzm 10y agoI think it would be a useful project to compile a list of times Gruber has been critical of Apple. One topic he has called out Apple on been the amount of memory in entry-level iPhones and iPads. http://daringfireball.net/2014/10/ipad_air_2 http://daringfireball.net/2014/10/ipad_air_2 I don't know if this meets your criteria for "serious", and it's just a single example. Just a little push-back against "ever" :)
- plinkplonk 10y agothat specific article has a pinch of criticism in a gallon of praise ;-) That said, I'm fine with Gruber being such a fanboy. He fills a niche, makes a great living, and his readers are happy. All good. I personally find his writing amusing is all.
- grzm 10y ago"that specific article has a pinch of criticism in a gallon of praise " No disagreement here :) Like I said, just a little push back :)
- themodelplumber 10y agoThat post is as close to a "WTF is going on" as you'll probably get from Gruber. I was pretty surprised to read it.
- snowwrestler 10y agoThe flip side to this is all the times people thought Apple was making a huge mistake but it turned out great. The initial Slashdot review of the iPod is a pretty famous example.
- cannonball 10y agoMy entire company was waiting on 32G, we run a simulation that chokes on 16G. Now everyone is trying to figure out what is the best non-Mac to do the job.
- Volt 10y agoWhy not use a desktop?
- robUx4 10y agoThe i5-7200U and i7-7500U both have DDR4 and a limit of 32GB. What kind of U CPU does the MacBook Pro has?
- robUx4 10y agoFrom https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacBook_Pro https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacBook_Pro the lowest spec CPU is an i5-6360U which supports DDR4 and 32GB of RAM: http://ark.intel.com/m/products/91156/Intel-Core-i5-6360U-Processor-4M-Cache-up-to-3_10-GHz#@product/specifications http://ark.intel.com/m/products/91156/Intel-Core-i5-6360U-Pr...
- ac29 10y agoAnd the highest spec is a i7-6920HQ, which supports 64GB DDR4... but Apple declined to use DDR4.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- feelix 10y agoI would say that, strangely enough, the Federal Aviation Administration is to blame for the 16GB RAM limit. I posted an explanation why here hours ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12841293 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12841293
- dlss 10y agoIf the FFA is to blame, how have windows laptops had 64gb of ram for over a year? http://www.theverge.com/2015/8/11/9129681/lenovo-skylake-xeon-notebooks-p50-p70 http://www.theverge.com/2015/8/11/9129681/lenovo-skylake-xeo...
- feelix 10y agoIf you RTA you'll see that it's a forced compromise between battery life and FFA restrictions
- dlss 10y agoI did. The FAA power limit is a red herring. Perhaps an example will help: High res screens require more power to run, and more power to render for... which means you could also blame the FAA for Apple not using high res screens... except Apple does use high resolution screens. So the situation is not one of forced compromise so much as Apple having different priorities from its users... which is where we thought we were before you brought up the FAA.
- TheLilHipster 10y agoJobs is not a fan of softkeys: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yL7X3DTyS2Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yL7X3DTyS2Q This is pretty much directly relevant to the state of apple right now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-AxZofbMGpM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-AxZofbMGpM It's quite eery.
- segmondy 10y agoI have an intel laptop (w520) from 5yrs that can supports more than 16gig of ram and currently has 20gb of ram (16+4). Yes spec says max is 16gb but that's not true. I don't know the max. i7 quad core. 5 years old.
- chillacy 10y agoAnyone know why Intel isn't able to support > 16GB of LPDDR4? Is it a limitation of address bus width in the design?
- yuhong 10y agoThey don't have support for LPDDR4 at all at this point.
- pritambaral 10y ago> I don't know the max. Running `dmidecode -t 16` as root on Linux might tell you.
- SamReidHughes 10y agoMax there is 32GB if you have a quad core CPU (and you do, because 16 is the max for dual core). I have one with 32, it works.
- fgpwd 10y agoI have a 4gb 2012 MacBook air that works fine. I don't face much performance related issues with it and can compile apps, use VMs(one at a time) fine with it. It can get slightly laggy at times, but most of it isn't noticeable. I usually restart when that starts to happen and it gets fine that way. I am thinking of saving some money and upgrading to the base 1499 model and donating my air to a friend who really needs it. But it has got only 8GB of RAM. Ideally I would have gone for the 1799 model with 16gb ram which makes it $1999. But don't have that much money right now. However, since even the 4GBs of RAM have seemed satisfactory to me so far, I am thinking of making the jump. Non-apple is anyways not an option as I use sketch and need to compile iOS apps. With my present air I always regret getting 128GB hard disk as it is too less, and I need to format my laptop every year to get rid of the junk occupying hard disk space. I hope I don't end up regretting the 8GB for the next few years.
- sliken 10y agoSeems like apple's just blowing smoke. The entry level macbook pro has a 10% (5kwh) larger battery. Seems rather implausible that an extra 5kwh is not enough to run 16GB ram for 10 hours.
- pwinnski 10y agoI am currently using a MacBook Pro (Retina, 15-inch, Mid 2014), and am running: a Docker VM, IntelliJ IDEA (two instances, one large and one medium Java project), Slack, Safari, Chrome, iTerm configured with unlimited screen buffer, a VPN, Dropbox, Fantastical, Backblaze, 1Password, and a few other things. For memory, I've got 16 GB 1600 MHz DDR3 Activity Monitor is happily green, and shows me that 11.57GB of my 16.00 GB of memory is used, with 3.18 GB of cache. I used to run into trouble with "memory pressure," but switching to Safari instead of Chrome eliminated all of that. I have 21 tabs open in Safari, only Gmail open in Chrome. I'm sure I could come up with some combination of things that would strain the 16 GB I currently have. I might have to work at it a bit, though, and I think by most of the definitions I've seen in this thread, I should be screaming about the limitation. If I ever hit the yellow zone with memory again, I'll just quit Chrome.
- narrowrail 10y agoI think the tech bloggers/ industry have had their fill on the latest Apple PC lineup. We need to stop this madness of giving them attention. We are being trolled. My non-scientific estimate is that I've seen ~20 threads in some way related/ essentially having the same discussion in the last 24hrs. Build your own desktop behemoth that you can use remotely (Xeon+dedicated GPU(s) and all), and buy an Apple laptop or Dell XPS with what you need. Done. If you develop for iOS, the choice is clear.