29 ms·
Elementary OS
- pjmlp 10y agoKind of interesting overview, but it doesn't support XCode nor the Objective-C and Swift frameworks I care about.
- kylec 10y agoXcode will never work on a non-Apple OS. It's just too tightly integrated.
- ant6n 10y agoIf you will only ever do macos, then why read and then comment (dismissively) on another OS..
- pjmlp 10y agoBecause I think people are overreacting. UNIX support was never a goal for macOS, neither for NeXT, rather a nice way to bring developers from Sun and SGI into their platforms. The business value for developers was always the Objective-C libraries, which is quite clear from most presentations done by Jobs, some of them available on YouTube. It is as if some people needed this week's presentation to wake up for the real Apple culture, that goes back to the days when they kind of toyed around with A/UX.
- rcarmo 10y agoI used A/UX. For real, because at the time we had VAXen and Suns, and it was a good way to make use of the 68030 Macs we had (I think it never ran on the IIfx, which had a 68040) I have no delusions about Apple culture. But apparently you're forgetting that Apple heavily marketed OSX's association with UNIX after the merge with NeXT, and that it made a lot of noise about how the Mac would be the best UNIX workstation ever. I lived through those years and saw the same presentations you mentioned - some on VHS tapes that were shipped to us after the events. There was no toying about OSX as a workstation, it was even on the sales pitch guides.
- pjmlp 10y agoI was at CERN when they visited us with the same type of sales pitch, but I always saw it as an attempt to get people to buy Macs than anything else, specially after how things went with Copland. The real Apple culture was Object Pascal, Common Lisp, Hypercard, Dylan, Newton, MacApp, PowerPlant, QuickDraw,... Now they have money and they actually need is macOS, iOS, tvOS and watchOS developers, not UNIX developers deploying code on GNU/Linux servers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- curiousgal 10y agoThat's like complaining that Linux can't run Adobe software, well duh.
- rcarmo 10y agoOf course not. I never meant to suggest this would be a macOS replacement - and as a former dabbler in GNUStep, let me tell you that that way wouldn't work either.
- pjmlp 10y agoI am ok with the Mac as it is, I don't see an issue with it, and actually am looking forward to eventually being able to play with the magic toolbar from Swift in a future acquisition.
- rcarmo 10y agoWell, I've been waiting for a suitable desktop Mac for the latter part of six years. I'm certainly not OK with the disrepair their product line is in, nor with the value for money of the "Pro" (or, as I prefer to call them, the "Air SE") range.
- pjmlp 10y agoI don't use desktops since 2006, only laptops with docking stations. Many of our customers follow similar patterns, I hardly see new desktops being deployed, so I have some sympathy for Apple thinking that it might not be worthwhile to keep doing them.
- gurkendoktor 10y agoCould GNUStep at least help in porting macOS apps to Linux? (In the very, very long term.)
- Jade_Jet 10y agoDidn't they make it so swift can run on any OS now? Also it sounds like you want the ability to develop for osx on a non-osx device. That seems counterintuitive.
- davidcollantes 10y agoCould you post the steps to get Elementary OS working on a Chromebook? Interesting post, thanks!
- rcarmo 10y agoErm. I just installed from an SD card, because I had already removed ChromeOS previously (in case you haven't read that bit). Unlocking your Chromebook is highly dependent on the specific hardware, so I suggest you Google around.
- izacus 10y agoI really like elementaryOS - not for myself (need to use macOS for dev), but pretty much all of my family was migrated to it. It has proven to be significantly more stable and simple to use than Windows and the default applications really nicely hit the simplicity and usability for a user that primarily needs web, email, photos and minor document editing. I'd even argue it's better than macOS for that user profile (especially since it's not localized to my local language, which eOS and most of major Linux apps are). The fact that it actually looks good by default is nice as well. Known downsides: - It's based on Ubuntu LTS (which is great!), but the new versions tend to lag after Ubuntu LTS releases by months at a time. - No upgrade path between versions. - Releases tend to be buggy on some hardware after release.
- gravypod 10y agoI would move to an Elementary OS if it's UI/UX was moved over an Arch based distribution. I mean Elementary OS simply looks beautiful and is stable(-ish). On top of Manjaro or something that holds back updates I wouldn't be able to figure out a more perfect development/daily driver system.
- rcarmo 10y agoThere were people trying to get Pantheon onto AUR. No idea how that's going.
- gravypod 10y agoJust like everything in the AUR I presume. It probably works, but when it stops doing that you're never going to get it working again.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- voltagex_ 10y agoHave you got an example of something on the AUR "never working again"? I'm assuming you mean some kind of dependency problem?
- adamors 10y agoLast time I tried Elementary OS it _looked_ very nice but basic stuff like adding an HTML signature in the email client was missing. Did they improve on this front?
- rcarmo 10y agoOP here - Yes and no. Mail can now cope much better with some HTML email, but there still isn't an obvious way to add a signature (I allude to that in the post).
- insertnickname 10y agoWhy would you want an HTML signature?
- adamors 10y agoIt's a common use case that's why.
- gnarbarian 10y agoBecause he's tacky.
- ikurei 10y agoSome companies will require you to use a signature with an image and particular formatting. Also, tackiness is in the eye of the beholder.
- flavor8 10y agoYou can install any email client available on ubuntu, e.g. thunderbird. No need to use Elementary's stock apps.
- matzipan 10y agoMail used to use webkitgtk (the old api), but has been since ported to use webkit2gtk (the new, multi-process api), you might wanna give it a second look. EDIT: I stand corrected. This has not happened yet. I confused this with some other changes.
- mavelikara 10y agoMy mini Ask HN: After over a decade of using Mac OS X, I am considering switching to Linux for my dev laptop. The tools I worry about are those that interact with audio and webcam - Go To Meeting, Google Hangout etc. My work involves me having to teleconf with others often. Does anyone here have experience using Linux well in such scenarios. If so, what hardware are you using? Also, does sleep-on-closing-lid work well?
- adamors 10y agoIf you rely on Skype in any way, avoid Linux. The Linux version was killed years ago and basic stuff like screen sharing isn't working as expected. Last time I tried (2+ years ago, it might be different now) Go To Meeting also wasn't working on Linux. I've used Linux on the desktop between 2009-2014 and basically anything multimedia related was a chore.
- Ianvdl 10y agoLinux is getting a new Skype version: https://blogs.skype.com/2016/07/13/skype-for-linux-alpha-and-calling-on-chrome-and-chromebooks/ https://blogs.skype.com/2016/07/13/skype-for-linux-alpha-and...
- AhtiK 10y agoUnfortunately this seems to be just a wrapper around their web app. Meaning there is zero chance for a significant native linux skype client update.
- t0mislav 10y agoFor me, only showstopper to migrate from Mac to Linux is alternative for iMovie and Lightroom. Any progress on this alternatives for Linux in last year or two? What programs do I need to check? Elementary is nice, it is also my backup OS, and I also donated some money to them 1 year ago.
- amlib 10y agoTry kdenlive for a competent but still simple video editor.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoAs an alternative to Lightroom, try Darktable: https://www.darktable.org/ https://www.darktable.org/ . Several people I know seem quite happy with it, and LWN has positive reviews of it.
- rcarmo 10y agoOP here. I actually installed that this morning, am still fiddling with it. Other folk report trouble importing their Lightroom XMP metadata on some versions, can't say much about that.
- edcastro 10y agoPlenty of options there. iMovie: Pitivi, OpenShot, KDEnlive and even Lightworks for something more advanced. Lightroom: Darktable, Rawtherapee and Corel Aftershot Pro.
- SwellJoe 10y agoVideo editors on Linux are strikingly crappy in my experience. KDEnlive is the one I settled on and have been using for my tutorial videos for a couple of years, but it still has random crashes and some of its UI choices are questionable. But, it's the one I recommend when people ask.
- PuffinBlue 10y agoThe truth is though - there is no replacement for Lightroom. Digikam has the file management capabilities but the editor experience is clunky (pop out editor, edit modules require opening, no apparent easy sync of settings across images, poor noise control) and it's not the fastest app I've used. Digikam 5 is a big improvement is some ways but the editor is still very clunky to use. ASP is just buggy. I tried it on Debian Jessie and Ubuntu 16.04 and on both it lasted a few days before simply refusing to open, even after install. It's also slow, even though they claim it's faster. And it does annoying stuff like paint its own window borders to look like a Windows app. Darktable is the best RAW editor I've used, but it's got essentially zero file management. Batch output requires a new mental abstraction with the 'queue'. For volume work (hundreds of images at a time) it seems ill equipped as you have to create a style or copy the history stack (which doesn't seem to have an easy keyboard shortcut). I'm still working on this one as it has so much power and control it could be fantastic, but more work needs to be done on the process of the edit or you can get stuck in the editors rabbit hole of fine detail. RAWtherapee - that's the next one to test for me. My initial feature check showed it suffers some of the complaints of Darktable like no file management (as far as I can see) and an involved edit process. If you pair any of the above applications with gThumb you can get some of the file management back in the most LR style I have found, but (infuriatingly) gThumb doesn't seem to display images in subfolders for whatever reason. My conclusions so far (as a former pro photographer) is that there is potential in the linux world to equal and even do better that LR but it's definitely not there yet and definitely not in one programme. And let's not start talking about Photoshop/GIMP - which of course ISN'T photoshop, as they keep telling us.
- antouank 10y agoI actually did the same after the Macbook pro presentation. Got Elementary OS on my desktop to try it. Works fine so far, better UI/UX than Ubuntu for sure. But I have some problems with the Nvidia support. https://elementaryos.stackexchange.com/questions/8952/artifacts-in-background https://elementaryos.stackexchange.com/questions/8952/artifa... Also v-sync doesn't really work, I get lots of tearing. The terminal is nice and the window manager is good as well. ( elementarty-tweaks should be in there by default )
- throwaway13337 10y agoA desktop linux could really grab an audience right now with the current state of windows and the agnosticism that is common in today's applications. The problem with desktop linux has always been that polish isn't quite there. Things like handling gracefully video card/dual monitor, audio switching, and sleep mode recovery end up being headaches that use up a lot of time googling around and generally learning about stuff you shouldn't have to know. It would be nice to see a company that specializes in a linux flavor sell a machine that is specifically built for that OS and with high build quality. Chromebooks are the closest thing to that but pushing a web-only interface is a major drawback. Are there any serious projects in this direction?
- jdoliner 10y agoSystem76 might be what you're looking for here.
- creshal 10y agoOne of many, many resellers of generic China OEM laptops with zero development capacities by themselves.
- peller 10y agoDo you happen to know if they use Clevo, or somebody else? I'd be curious to know which China OEMs are at least marginally Linux friendly.
- bwat48 10y agoafaik they mainly use clevo
- emidln 10y agoThey do offer apt repos with some light configuration, firmware installation, etc. I referenced their source code when setting up my equivalent Clevo from pro-star.
- 10y ago
- jroseattle 10y agoI've been looking for a replacement OS to try over macOS for a while, so I just tried this on for size. 2-year old MBP. Created a boot disk with the Elementary ISO and started up. Fairly snappy, connected over a USB 3 connection to a 500GB SSD. First thing I tried to install was Google Chrome. DEBian package. Fail. Google search for others who have tried. Found recent article, followed step-by-step. Failed. :-(
- rcarmo 10y agoI just downloaded the official Chrome .deb and did a sudo dpkg -i foo.deb. Can't understand how that would fail, really. One thing you might try is doing an apt-get install -f, since there might be implicit dependencies depending on the build, and this forces apt to figure them out.
- izacus 10y agoHe tried to install an app on a live system running off of a read-only medium. :)
- rpeden 10y agoJust a quick question to make sure I understand properly: do you mean you tried to install an application while running the ElementaryOS live USB? If so, perhaps that's why it failed? Depending on how the live boot OS is set up, installing new applications may not work at all. Some live USB creator apps I've used give the option of setting aside some space for a writable filesystem that will with with Ubuntu live images (and possibly others). In either case, the best way to get a real sense of how much you like the OS is to do a proper install of it in a VM. The live ISO will mostly just show you if the OS supports your hardware and everything (WiFi, etc.) works.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ant6n 10y agoThis may sound silly, but I'm mostly concerned about losing the three-finger side-swipe to the other desktops. Is this possible with elementary OS?
- rcarmo 10y agoOP here. No settings for that on my trackpad. It's doable in Linux, but I don't see any prebuilt hooks for that in Elementary other than a hotkey combo.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- matzipan 10y agoIt's certainly on the to-do list, but some features related to swipe were implemented in the GTK version after than the one Ubuntu 16.04 LTS currently ships, so it'll take a bit more time. I personally want that feature too.
- insertnickname 10y agoLoading this page with JS disabled, all the images are blurred. Loading it with JS, there's a fancy fade-in animation on the images. What is the point of this? Why would you intentionally distort the images for people who browse with JS disabled?
- jbicha 10y agobecause almost everyone has JavaScript enabled because websites are broken with it disabled…
- insertnickname 10y agoBecause web developers deliberately break websites...
- rcarmo 10y agoIt's a simple approach to lazy loading, so that you only download the images you actually want to view on a phone as you scroll to them. (I also pick the right kind of image depending on your display DPI, and resize them on the back-end, but that's beside the point here) I get a _lot_ of mobile visitors, and mobile bandwidth is expensive, so I'm considerate to them - folk with JavaScript disabled know how to re-enable it to view the images, and are a very minute percentage of my page views. Sorry! :)
- abrowne 10y agoFYI I also get the blurry images in Firefox's reader mode. (I had to go back to the original to see if that was intentional when I saw the first screenshot ;-)
- rcarmo 10y agoYeah, well, that's actually JavaScript that (go figure) strips away all the event handlers :)
- matt_kantor 10y ago
- lingben 10y agothere is a linux OS built specifically for chromebooks called gallium OS https://galliumos.org/ https://galliumos.org/
- rcarmo 10y agoOP here. It does not add anything that I wanted, and I had already ditched XFCE in favor of LXDE in the past. The point of the post was not to get Elementary running on a Chromebook, it was to see if I, coming from a Mac, could use it on a future desktop without issues and the usual ugly UIs Linux DEs have.
- mercurysmessage 10y agoGo to Reddit.com/r/unixporn, with some minor tweaking it's very easy to make Linux look nice.
- rcarmo 10y agoRiiiight. I don't want to spend hours tweaking my desktop. It's hard enough to pick a decent wallpaper, and since I've been using X desktops since the SunOS era, believe me when I tell you that I have no interest in wrestling with multiple X toolkits to achieve the kiddie look of the day...
- mercurysmessage 10y agoMy experience tweaking my Linux desktop didn't take nearly that long. It depends I suppose on how in detail you want to get, but a much nicer look than the standard is fairly easy to achieve.
- r3bl 10y agoMinor tweaking? /r/unixporn crowd is always interested in posts that customize their Linux setups to the max: use Window Managers almost exclusively, have a unified color scheme all over the system etc. That's not minor tweaking.
- nemo1618 10y agoI've been using elementaryOS for a few years now and just upgraded to Loki. On the whole it has been great, but there are just a few buggy elements that occasionally make me want to wipe the thing and start fresh with Ubuntu, which at least I can trust to not break. Hoping that eOS continues to become more polished.
- flavor8 10y agoI really wish that they'd narrow their ambition and just ship a really great desktop environment that could be installable in stock Ubuntu. I guess that's harder to monetize.
- Brakenshire 10y agoAgreed about the few buggy elements. The last version had a bug with the cursor for about 6 months. Freya's still got the window focus bug that Ubuntu has had for years (haven't tried Loki yet). They're waiting for upstream fixes, but it does undermine the fundamental usability message of the distribution. If they do manage to grow to a major distribution, they really need to set aside a significant amount of money to sponsor upstream developers to fix these problems in weeks rather than months.
- altern8 10y agoI've actually done the same thing. Your life is not as easy as when using macOS, but it's well worth it to refuse to be ripped off by Apple. The keynote really sucked. I bet there are a lot of people who are switching.
- achikin 10y agoWhat about power management? I've heard that elementary is not as good as MacOSX at that.
- izacus 10y agoThat depends on hardware (and amount of proprietary firmwares) really. On newer Macs where a lot of things are non-standard and controlled via EFI, it's going to be tough - same as BootCamp where Apple doesn't provide drivers for powersaving. On things like ThinkPads, XPS Developer Editions, etc. the battery is rather comparable to their Windows counterparts for most cases.
- achikin 10y agoSurprised to hear that Apple does not provide power management for other operating systems. Are there any recent benchmarks for macOS versus Windows in terms of power saving?
- rcarmo 10y agoOn this chromebook, it's OK. I get 6-8 hours coding, same as under Lubuntu. But I intend to use this on a beefy desktop crammed with VMs and Docker containers, so that's not a problem for me.
- bangonkeyboard 10y agoThe Mac UI ripoff issue may not matter to you, but it does to me. It's gross and slavish, like using a KIRF Chinese knockoff phone with stolen icons.
- overgard 10y agoYeah, to me it's kind of the broken-windows theory. When I see something that tasteless upfront, it makes me question the quality of the thing from the top down. It's like if you went to buy a used car and it had flame stickers all over it. Sure, it's just surface level tacky, but it would lead you to question how well the owner took care of it. When I see a bad macOS knockoff, all I can think is, if the best their ux design can do is rip off apple, then I'm not sure I want to commit long term to the thing (especially since I think that many of apple's UX decisions have actually been really bad form-over-function calls)
- reitanqild 10y agoGreat artists something something
- SwellJoe 10y agoI agree. Every time Elementary OS comes up, people are like, "Finally a nice looking Linux desktop!", and I'm over here thinking, "meh...regular old Gnome 3, as shipped with recent Fedora versions, looks nicer and more cohesive, to me."
- kuschku 10y agoRegular old Gnome3 is horrible to use with multiple screens. Good luck running a program in full screen on your main monitor, while also doing stuff on a secondary monitor, where you have to switch windows, open new ones, etc. Gnome3 is only useful on non-touch laptops, not on any other usecase.
- SwellJoe 10y agoHuh...I don't think I know what you're talking about. What specific problems have you had with multiple screens? I don't currently have my system setup for multiple displays (I live in an RV and don't have room for that kind of setup), but did use Gnome 3 with a second display for quite a long time. I don't remember any problems with switching windows and such. It seemed to work pretty much the same as Windows or macOS. The only multi-monitor complaint I had about Gnome 3 was that opening the Activities bar or changing apps led to both displays dimming. This makes Gnome 3 horrible for presentations, screening films, or pretty much anything you'd want to use a projector for. I'm hopeful that problem has been fixed, as I've rarely felt so annoyed at a piece of software. Notifications were also problematic, in that they would pop up over full screen applications (which is, IMHO, never the right behavior...full screen apps should really be treated as sacred, by default). But, at least notifications can be disabled. The misfeature of screen dimming and shrinking app windows across displays could not be disabled last time I messed with it (admittedly, a year or two ago). "Gnome3 is only useful on non-touch laptops" Which touch features do you think are missing? Mine seems to work fine, though I so rarely use the touchscreen that I may be missing something important. I find touchscreens hard to use for anything more than basic scrolling, so it's not a feature I even wanted, but it came with my laptop, and I was surprised to see it worked fine out-of-the-box with Linux. I didn't even tweak it.
- fiatjaf 10y agoHow do I install this thing? Will it work well on relatively old computers?
- Brakenshire 10y agoIt works really well on old computers in my experience. I first ran it because Ubuntu was so slow to be unusuable on an old Core2Duo, and on that hardware Elementary was very fast.
- matzipan 10y agoThe AppCenter is the hottest development area, so there are new features and fixes landing every day. But in the not very distant future you're going to see the result of a lot of work: https://houston.elementary.io/ https://houston.elementary.io/ There is a problem with Epiphany, namely that the webkit version that ships with Ubuntu is long outdated, hopefully that's going to get fixed: https://blogs.gnome.org/mcatanzaro/2016/02/01/on-webkit-security-updates/ https://blogs.gnome.org/mcatanzaro/2016/02/01/on-webkit-secu...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- phs318u 10y agoAs a slight aside. Can anyone point me to any recent work being done to get working Linux drivers for the various Mac hardware bits that have been problematic in the past? I'm only finding old howtos for Linux on Mac which usually end up with some hardware or other not working. I'm specifically interested in Linux on MacBook Air. Thanks.
- cooper12 10y agoMaybe this: https://help.ubuntu.com/community/MacBookAir https://help.ubuntu.com/community/MacBookAir?
- phs318u 10y agoThank you. A great start.
- AsyncAwait 10y agoArch (or Antrgos[1] if you want an out-of-the-box experience), work very well on my MBP, can recommend. [1] - https://antergos.com https://antergos.com
- usaphp 10y agoFunny how everyone here in comments and author is saying "I really like Elementary OS" but nobody really wants/is ready to use it.
- happy-go-lucky 10y agoYou're right. I played with multiple distros before settling on Ubuntu because it gives me the least headaches.
- Brakenshire 10y agoI've been using it for the last 2/3 years. Started using it because my computer was old, and it was a lot faster than Ubuntu, and much more polished (in my opinion) than XFCE or LFCE, and have used it ever since. Has worked really well. Definitely has one or two persistent bugs, though. There was a really annoying cursor one for a long time, and then one with window focus which Ubuntu also suffered from. It's also annoying not to be able to do updates in place. To be fair, I think they are often upstream issues, Ubuntu also was waiting for that upstream focus fix for a long time. But it does mean they're not yet fulfilling the promise of a completely seamless, polished, Linux distribution. For the moment, for my use case it's the best distribution, but it's not quite at the stage where I'd want to put it on a relative's computer, and I think given their stated aims that's the litmus test.
- phaedryx 10y agoI paid for it and put it on both of my kids' computers. They like it a lot.
- xaduha 10y agoNot interested in Elementary OS at all, but I do keep an eye on Solus https://solus-project.com https://solus-project.com (Well, there's also http://papyros.io http://papyros.io, but I'm not confident that it will amount to anything) BTW, that practice of making keywords (which often repeat throughout the text) into links (often to your own damn blog) is abhorrent.
- rcarmo 10y agoIt's not a blog, it's a Wiki (https://github.com/rcarmo/sushy https://github.com/rcarmo/sushy), and the blog just hangs off it. I see no damning in that - you can always either not visit or not click :)
- cooper12 10y agoThen you gotta warn us in the title that you link everything :). Just kidding, but on a more serious note I also found it very distracting. Sure, link the first occurrence of the word, but I see no reason macOS needs to be linked every time it's mentioned. Even the big daddy of wikis, Wikipedia, recommends against linking things that have already been linked and very common terms [0]: > An overlinked article contains an excessive number of links, making it difficult to identify links likely to aid the reader's understanding significantly. A 2015 study of log data found that "in the English Wikipedia, of all the 800,000 links added ... in February 2015, the majority (66%) were not clicked even a single time in March 2015, and among the rest, most links were clicked only very rarely", and that "simply adding more links does not increase the overall number of clicks taken from a page. Instead, links compete with each other for user attention." When I, an internet user see a link, it's visual distinctiveness cues to me that it might lead me to more information that emphasizes something. It's fine for websites to link to their own tags, but there's also overdoing it. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Linking#What_generally_should_not_be_linked https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Link...
- rcarmo 10y agoI'm testing out a little JS to hide all but the first link of each kind (it makes sense for the anchors to stick around to do internal reference counting). Will be up soon.
- Mathnerd314 10y ago> the terminal emits a desktop notification whenever it detects that a long-running process has finished. Does anyone know how this is implemented? Edit: pretty simple: http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~elementary-apps/pantheon-terminal/trunk/view/head:/src/PantheonTerminal.vala#L106 http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~elementary-apps/pantheon-termin... http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~elementary-apps/pantheon-terminal/trunk/view/head:/src/TerminalWidget.vala#L259 http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~elementary-apps/pantheon-termin...
- pritambaral 10y agoThat can be achieved in any terminal emulator that visually shows the occurrence of an ASCII bell. For instance, all I had to do was include `\a` in my `$PS1` and now whenever a command finishes running and bash is ready for a new command, my terminal emulator gets a bell. Konsole (and any Konsole based terminal emulators, like Yakuake) shows a notification if a bell happens in a non-foreground session. Konsole also has explicit tab-specific settings for "Monitor for Silence" and "Monitor for Activity".
- Mathnerd314 10y agoWouldn't that beep every time you run a command? And/or interfere with any programs that use the beep for their own purposes?
- pritambaral 10y ago> Wouldn't that beep every time you run a command? It's up to the terminal emulator to do what it wants with the beep character. Technically, it's up to whoever has to display the character; if you're running bash at a tty — an actual terminal — then the kernel gets to decide what to do, so it beeps, since there is little else it could choose to do. Terminal emulators, on the other hand, know they aren't actually in a limited environment and can do a lot more than playing a sound. That's why there's such a thing as "visual bell" among terminal emulators. Some highlight the tab title upon visual bell, Konsole merely sends a notification if a bell occurs. ---- > And/or interfere with any programs that use the beep for their own purposes? I don't quite understand what you mean here. There isn't any way for arbitrary programs to listen for / wait for / register callbacks for the beep. If you're thinking about the `\a` in `$PS1` ... well, PS1 is shown only when bash runs as an interactive process. Also, the beep control in ALSA is muted by default.
- bajsejohannes 10y ago> the Screenshot app knows how to obfuscate text Wow, that's a pretty great idea. Enough people do this wrong manually that it seems like something that could be better solved by the OS. One example I've seen of doing it wrong is adding black opaque rectangles as layers and then sending out all layers including the original. Another is pixelating it in a way where it's possible to revert the pixelation since the font is known (e.g. parts of a facebook post)
- pmlnr 10y agoI've been an elementaryOS user for years and I ended up dropping the whole thing in favour of xfwm4 + synapse + tint2. eOS is a really nice looking thing, but it's buggy, release after release it's losing features, like [1] - this specific one was never fixed in the previous release. The built-on music app collapses under a reasonable amount of music, same as banshee or quod libet can easily handle. Geary, the mail app looks nice, but lacks basic features and has a tendency to corrupt IMAP folders. The window manager of eOS, Gala, is indeed impressive, but lack options to tweak. In the previous release, it was impossible to disable the ALT+TAB effect, even if all the other effects were set to none. So overally: it's looks nice, the window manager is fast, and if you're fine with the defaults, you're probably going to be a happy user - until you find something you miss, and there is no way to fix that. https://bugs.launchpad.net/switchboard-plug-power/+bug/1359054 https://bugs.launchpad.net/switchboard-plug-power/+bug/13590...
- Brakenshire 10y ago> Geary, the mail app looks nice, but lacks basic features and has a tendency to corrupt IMAP folders. Geary was forked after Yorba wound down, and Elementary are moving it over to the Evolution backend, incidentally.
- ShinyCyril 10y agoForgive my ignorance - what implications does this have? Would Evolution run as some kind of daemon, and Geary just add the presentation layer on top?
- Brakenshire 10y agoYes, I think so. It means the Geary developers don't have to maintain IMAP etc support, they can concentrate on the other parts of the app.
- MadWombat 10y agoLooking at the bug you mentioned, the status is "Fix released", so yeah, it too them a while to make a GUI option for lid closing, but they did.
- rkv 10y agoAre there any differences between this and Debian + Pantheon?
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoA couple: - eOS is built on top of Ubuntu rather than Debian - The team doesn't officially support Pantheon outside of eOS, so you've probably got it from an unofficial PPA that could break with the next version. - I don't think the Pantheon DE would get you eOS's included apps like Geary.
- rkv 10y agoIs there any difference between this and Debian+Pantheon?
- goodells 10y agoI've used elementary OS for a few months now as my primary development environment. It's great to have set up in VirtualBox on 2/3 monitors, and the fact that it's based on Ubuntu makes finding support online pretty easy for someone not as experienced with Linux. My biggest complaint is actually that the OS file selection interface (like what I get opening things in Sublime Text) is not same as the fancy finder application, but the default Ubuntu one that doesn't look consistent.
- Kenji 10y agoI love how it's called Elementary OS but it's just a Ubuntu Linux with some sugars. I already got excited about another operating system but it's same old, same old.
- endgame 10y ago> It has polish and care that the stereotypical raging neckbeards who espouse the mantra of Linux on the desktop are unable to appreciate (or, apparently, build), and it has to exist, even if merely as a counterpoint to all the ugliness. Please be nice :(. Some of those so-called "neckbeards" probably helped build the stack upon which things like elementaryOS rest.
- Yhippa 10y agoIs there a difference between "graybeards" and "neckbeards"? I think culturally there is a difference and he possibly meant to use greybeard here.
- chongli 10y agoYes. "Neckbeard" has connotations of sexism and other ugliness. "Graybeard" merely connotes old age and anachronism.
- simondedalus 10y agonot to mention that i've yet to have as bug-free an experience on elementary as i have on vanilla ubuntu, or opensuse with kde, or a really basic arch + i3 install, or kali with gnome 3, or (the list goes on). the unearned appreciation of elementary has always baffled me. i mean, the developers are not hacks or anything. i quite liked geary, and i'm fine with distros multiplying (why not? just use what you want, it doesn't matter). but elementary is barely any more mac-ish than ubuntu with unity, and it's always felt like the beta version of someone's side project. to sum up, i'm happy that they have interest in their project, and i respect the effort they put into it. however, most of the praise for elementary seems to come from and for the wrong places; it's not particularly polished or user friendly (they have a history of "i'll choose for you," but not in as an intuitive way as Apple), its thematically unified design does not last unless you either use a vanilla install forever or put in just as much linux-y work in maintaining your install as you would w/ arch or debian or ubuntu (and you cared about how everything looks). to me, elementary is a nice little niche distro like bodhi linux. it's bizarre to me that people can use it as a main system unless they're very advanced (read: they play with config files like a sysadmin and code decently in at least bash), and it's outright unthinkable that people use it for anything beyond checking email if they're keeping a vanilla install. this stuff keeps the ecosystem healthy, but the articles and comments i read about it look like they're coming from people who simply don't use linux that much (and aren't aware that all the good things they see in elementary are done better in other distros).
- drcross 10y agoHas anyone found an alternative to OSX that can still compete to it's battery life?
- 72deluxe 10y agoNo, not for me. Running Windows 10 on the exact same macbook (just a reboot to bootcamp) and I get an hour less battery. Probably something to do with Apple's aggressive app nap?
- butterm 10y agoI am using elementary OS for the past one and a half years, and honestly speaking, I am in love with it. I am a long time Linux user, and whenever I get a chance, I tell people about all the great things about Linux and why it's better than Windows and the MacOS. But there was always one aspect of Linux that I always felt a bit uneasy about, and this was design/UI/UX/accessibility of the many popular distributions. I liked ubuntu the most in this regards, but after they moved to Unity, I had to ditch it. But then I found Elementary, and have never looked back. Elementary combines the freedom and transparency of open source with beautiful design. I have never seen an OS that scores high on so many different factors. There's a lot of discussion here about the stock apps in elementary. However, since I am an experienced Linux user, I don't really care about stock apps. The Linux app ecosystem is extremely diverse, and over the years, I have found my best solution for each task. For example, Clementine for music, Atom for text editing etc. So these apps get installed immediately after every installation of elementary and then I never look back at the stock apps again.
- Brakenshire 10y agoAgreed about the stock apps. I think actually they are being too ambitious. They want to have certain interface guidelines which operate across all apps (things like autosaving state so they can be closed and opened seamlessly), and that's why they're so keen on developing a full suite of their own programs. But independently developing so many apps all at the same time is a massive, massive task. In my opinion they would be better off focusing for the moment on areas where there are gaps, for instance making Shotwell / Pantheon Photos or Geary / Pantheon Mail really excellent. It's making the perfect the enemy of the good to redirect their effort to reimplementing their own music app and their own text editor etc, when there are good alternatives. Agree about the general sentiment, also. In general it's an excellent project.
- Sir_Cmpwn 10y agoReally the best strategy would be to take existing Linux desktop staples and send patches that allow them to be reskinned enough to get the consistent L+F they want.
- maratc 10y agoNow I need a decent terminal (iTerm2-like quality) and a sane set of shortcuts (like a shortcut for "Copy" that doesn't stop processes in terminal) and I'd be all set...
- CGamesPlay 10y agoThis is probably the #1 reason why I still want to use mac OS every day. Emacs-style editing shortcuts and not having to press Ctrl-Shift-C to copy when I'm in my terminal window (alternatively, not having to remember to press Ctrl-Shift-C to copy but only when I'm in my terminal window).
- pritambaral 10y agoAs a long-time user of the terminal, I just don't get this complaint. I haven't had to "remember" to press the right keys, my muscle memory understands the context I'm in and simply takes care of it. Is this really that big a deal? I am genuinely curious.
- maratc 10y agoOn macOS, we don't need context because many shortcuts work the same everywhere. That might be a reason why our muscle memory hasn't been developed to "understand the context". Erasing all of your muscle memory and starting anew is a big deal, yes.
- Gracana 10y agoYep, I really like this about Mac OS X. The fact that I can c-w to kill a word anywhere or c-u to kill a line is pretty nice. And OS-level copy/paste has the same shortcut everywhere, like you say. I think it was a mistake for Windows and linux to use control as the default meta-character for gui operations. I always switch it to super if I can.
- kps 10y agoIt is unfortunate that the ‘desktop Linux’ groups all came from Windows backgrounds and ignored all the previous Unix windowing systems, most of which knew better than to screw up terminal emulation. Qt has a flag to use the GUI key for shortcuts, but it's hard-wired to the platform. I keep hoping there will be enough OS X refugees to make it a user-configurable setting.
- djhworld 10y agoI bought a 2015 MBP back in January, so I'm all set for a few years at least. Whether OSX goes down the pan even more, I don't know. Moving to Linux seems like a romantic idea, but I can forsee there being a number of problems that would make it unfeasible for me 1. I use 1Password, no Linux client 2. Spotify client is no longer being developed for Linux 3. YouNeedABudget software is not Linux compatible - I have 2+ years of financial transactions in there... 4. Google Drive, no (official) Linux client 5. I have a number of Alfred workflows, and enjoy using Alfred in general. Yes, there are a number of open source alternatives, but I've built up enough inertia on OSX it's going to be very difficult for me to switch. There are things about OSX that couldn't care less about like iTunes, Apple Maps etc, but overall it's not so bad
- tylerflick 10y agoI can't testify to the rest of your issues, but the Windows client of 1Password runs reasonably well under Wine.
- jkelsey 10y agoBut does it integrate well with Firefox or Chrome on Linux?
- tylerflick 10y agoHonestly I haven't tried to set that up yet, I just assumed it wouldn't.
- LukasSkywalker 10y agoIt does actually. You have to disable web browser code signature checking and start some program (Agile1pAgent.exe iirc) which then runs in the background. Full instructions: http://eduardosanchez.me/2015/01/25/1password-on-ubuntu-linux-14-10/ http://eduardosanchez.me/2015/01/25/1password-on-ubuntu-linu...
- 10y ago
- dkarapetyan 10y agoI really don't understand why developers use macs at all. They're not good dev machines. All production systems I work with are some flavor of linux (mostly ubuntu). There is actually a real impedance mismatch when I'm using my mac for work purposes. All those cores and RAM become meaningless when I have to do everything in a VM anyway. My personal dev machine is a project sputnik running ubuntu 16.04. I can understand why designers would use them but programmers never made any sense.
- toefraz 10y ago> It has polish and care that the stereotypical raging neckbeards who espouse the mantra of Linux on the desktop are unable to appreciate (or, apparently, build), and it has to exist, even if merely as a counterpoint to all the ugliness.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoThat's the part I don't get I guess. I'm either in Chrome, Vim, some IDE, or experimenting in some REPL. There isn't much room for improving ergonomics in any of those instances by adding extra "polish". I prefer my technical aesthetics to be compositional instead of pretty and the dell machine I have with ubuntu delivers on that front very nicely.
- numerlo 10y agoIn short, they provide a good enough Unix experience in a machine that just works™. Or used to, depending who you ask.
- tigershark 10y agoMaybe because after decades I'm frankly pissed of all the infinite glitches in windows and Linux and I want something that just works? Every hour spent in fighting those problems is real money that I lose, but above all I want to write code, not to fight with a machine. I'm not 16 anymore (when I had all the time of this world and when I even enjoyed the fight), now I just want to use my time to write code instead of wasting it. Simply as that.
- partycoder 10y agoWell, many decisions behind macOS UX are certainly based on usability testing and research, which is costly. By incorporating these features Elementary OS is profiting for all that, so it seems to be crossing a line. GNOME in a sense also takes a lot of inspiration on macOS but it is different. I personally use GNOME. Elementary OS seems great, though, don't get me wrong. I hope it helps bringing more people into Linux.
- hackerkid 10y agoI am computer science student who have been using elementary as the primary os for almost three years now. It's beautiful and you would never think of switching to another linux desktop environment once you start using it. The only major problem you would be facing would be release upgrades. You have to do a fresh install for upgrading to a newer elementary version.
- pippy 10y agoThe quality of MacOS releases have been dropping since Snow Leopard. With Sierra, they dropped the accessibility setting for disabling scroll inertia. This is serious for someone who's getting RSI. I use Elementary OS as a secondary OS, and I have to say I'm loving it more and more while the quality of MacOS continues to drop.
- jawngee 10y agoThat setting is still there. System Preferences > Accessibility > Mouse & Trackpad > Trackpad Options > Scrolling > Without Inertia System Preferences > Accessibility > Mouse & Trackpad > Mouse Options > Scrolling > Without Inertia
- mrmondo 10y agoIt is indeed quite pretty and build with UX in mind, does it have SELinux enforcing by default now?
- ThomPete 10y agoCan this be run on the mac just like windows parallels? Would love to try it out for some design experiments I am doing.
- mrmondo 10y agoJust gave it a shot, great UX experience! But: for some reason it formats /boot to ext2 which is a bad idea as it has no journaling and you're likely to end up with a corrupt boot partition that won't boot. It's also a shame to see it's based on ubuntu and not Debian or Fedora which both test their packages a lot better than the ubuntu team has proven over the years.
- jasoncchild 10y agoI've used elementary before, never encountered any major issues and quite enjoyed the UX clone factor ;)
- deecewan 10y agoDoes Elementary handle mutli-resolution displays better than stock GNOME? That was a major reason for me leaving Linux. I love gnome, but I couldn't deal with not being able to use (in a stable way) a 1080p external monitor with a 4K laptop screen.
- shard972 10y agoI moved from windows 10 to ElementryOS 3 weeks ago and I haven't had the urge to go back at all.
- felipebueno 10y agoInteresting reading. Since 2012, I've tried Elementary several times but I always come back to whatever other (Debian based) distro with LXDE because there's one thing, really JUST ONE THING, on Elementary I can't stand: the Application Switcher (alt+tab) animation. It's slow and distracting and, even switching any and every UI animation off, I couldn't speed it up. I still like the project and I really want to use it as my main OS some day (at least for 1 year or so. I'm always switching OSes)... I'll give it a try again next month to see how things are going.
- pmlnr 10y agoThis, besides the no detailed window tiling, was one of my main issues as well.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cpfohl 10y agoI really wanted to use Elementary, but couldn't get my Lenovo laptop to connect to WiFi... Someday maybe
- mr337 10y agoLenovo and Dell sometimes have broadcom wifi which are utter crap. If you do go down that route just order an intel wifi and replace it, normally a 5 minutes job and save hours worth of headaches.
- bootload 10y ago"in what I can only call a tremendously good example of how not to copy Apple‘s mistakes, the built-in Music app looks a lot like iTunes, but without any of the bloat." Not a bad writeup. For me music is via XTools->mplayer
- greggman 10y agoI am really intruigued when people say they do most of their computer usage on an iPad. I get massively frustrated anytime I try to do almost anything other than consome on an iPad. As just one example trying to copy snd paste almost anything makes me want to tear my hair out it's so frustrsting. Moving the cursor or trying to fight with the os about what I really want to select as it keeps trying to expand my selection, or the fact tbat I can't copy the text of a link, only the link itself. That's just one of many frustrstions I run into anytime I try to use ios (or Android) for anything other than consuming and so I'd really like to know am I doing it wrong? Is there some magic to work around these issue? Do others just never need to do the things I need do regularly? It's so bad I recently bought a headmountable camera to document the frustrations in the hopes of generating some awareness of the issues because I'd love to be able to get by with just a tablet.
- rasengan 10y agoDefinitely agree with you about selecting/copy paste.
- spraak 10y agoI definitely agree with your sentiment. I too get very frustrated with those things, and had a terrible time just formatting this comment! > or the fact tbat I can't copy the text of a link, only the link itself. I wanted to share a tip in regard to this: select some text before or after the link text, then use the markers to adjust/refine down to just the link text that you want.
- andai 10y agoWow, that's great to hear about the head cam. Where are you putting these recordings?
- legulere 10y agoYou can use two fingers over the keyboard for moving the cursor on an iPad (force touch on the keyboard with iphones)
- b15h0p 10y ago
- gremlinsinc 10y agoTried elementary awhile back, but I've recently gotten tired of ubuntu's kernel, and just some errors/quirks with my hardware. So when I upgraded my hdd to sdd/hybrid I said screw it and went with Antergos (arch linux) distro. The gnome build is pretty beautiful, lightdm is styled very lovely, better than ubuntu/xubuntu/lxde/kubuntu by far. My hardware performs way better with less crashes, though I think I've narrowed that down to a bad memory chip that I need to replace soon. I did pull out gnome and swap it for i3wm. I recommend if you haven't tried i3wm give it a try, there's less graphical flair, and panels -- but you gain in performance, speed, and productivity, everything is just a shortcut away, and the i3 config file makes adding more shortcuts even easier. Definitely worth the time to learn.
- mrmondo 10y agoNo intel wireless 8000 series support = show stopper for me, why they wouldn't include that in the kernel config I have no idea
- nanna 10y agoFor me a downside of Elementary OS is that, like all Ubuntu-based distros, I've found installing it on my apple hardware to be such a pain. Fedora-based distros on the other hand have worked wonderfully out of the box. If I were to advise a friend on which distro to install on their MacBook, I'd recommend the beautiful Fedora-based Korora over Elementary OS any day. https://kororaproject.org/ https://kororaproject.org/
- AsyncAwait 10y agoArch (Antergos if you want nice out of the box setup[1]) works very well on my 2015 work MBP, perhaps give it a try. [1] https://antergos.com https://antergos.com
- nanna 10y agoHuh, never heard of Antergos but it looks great. Will consider it next time I swap distros...
- gurkendoktor 10y ago> but neither would I use a plain Gnome, KDE or Unity desktop, because I find them tasteless and cluttered I've been preparing a "plan B" for my iOS developer career, and I've installed elementary and a Fedora 25 alpha to see what's going on in Linux land. To me, Fedora's GNOME 3 seems just as pretty and minimal as elementaryOS. It's way less cluttered than GNOME 2. I actually had to figure out how to clutter it up again (I want files on my desktop!).
- staticelf 10y agoI use linux on my laptop at work. It is running Red Hat. I have many issues and as always with Linux one of them is bad graphics drivers. Basically every time I've tried desktop Linux (which is many times) I have always, always struggled with graphics drivers. Even if I get it to work fine, they always suck compared with a Windows installation. Last year I ran desktop Linux and first I had Linux installed and ran CS:Go, I had some issues with frame rate and when I installed Windows on the machine I got about 10-20 more fps which made a huge difference under heavy load. I love the idea of desktop Linux but I've come to terms last year after about 8 years of trying that it will never be as polished, as good as Windows. At least for me as a gamer. I think a big part of the problem is that there is just too much choices and software out there. Either it's Gnome, Unity or KDE or 20 other window managers. Writing GUIs for Linux is hard compared to Windows/MacOS. Small issues in many appliations, errors that show up when you really try to replace programs with open source ones etc. I love open source and of course I understand why things are the way they are, it's incredible hard for a smaller open source project to compete with a company that has lots of resources to throw at the issues.
- coldpie 10y agoJust curious, what graphics hardware were you using? Intel? Nvidia? ATI? I've used Intel and Nvidia extensively and had very few, if any, issues. Intel's drivers are open source, integrated with Linux, and fantastic. Nvidia performance is indeed worse than on Windows, but not enough for me to care. ATI is a mess and has been for more than a decade. Don't use ATI if you want to use Linux.
- staticelf 10y agoMainly nvidia, I have used their linux drivers but they just aren't as good in my opinion. Last time I tried was with a couple of years old graphics card. It works with nvidia, but as soon as you have multiple monitors or do heavy gaming the faults are there and it's obvious that they don't put in the same effort as in their windows drivers.
- OOPMan 10y agoFor a second I thought this was a new OS, then I realised it was Yet Another Ubuntu Derivative and I tuned out. Also, that fact they're trying rather hard to get you to pay for it seems a little...icky. Yeah, I know, just click custom amount and enter 0 but still...
- shoover 10y agoI installed it in vmware and was surprised to see that both the installer and the OS seamlessly grabbed and released the mouse at the window border. The window also autosized when I changed the guest resolution. I don't recall those features working in Ubuntu or any other VM without manually installing vmware tools. Is that a vmware update or OS package convenience? Either, it's smooth.
- rpazyaquian 10y agoI'm seeing a whooole lot of posts about laptop hardware poorly supporting Linux distributions in this thread. I've been considering moving to a Linux-based laptop for basic computing once my old MBP inevitably dies a horrible death, but these reports about poor hardware interfacing, broken features, missing drivers, etc. is making me less interested in doing so. Is this really such a widespread problem?
- htns 10y agoIf you go for an obscure distro it is. Ubuntu has good hardware support.
- rpazyaquian 10y agoI'll likely go for Ubuntu just because it's the most accessible choice right now, and the distro I'm most used to. In my case, is there a reason why I should go to other distros? I'm mostly used to distros like Arch, CoreOS, etc. being used for production servers and other specialized hardware over personal computing.
- htns 10y agoIMHO Qubes (https://www.qubes-os.org/ https://www.qubes-os.org/) is the only desktop distro with worthwhile differentiation. Most of the other distros' gimmicks fall under "who cares" if you just want to browse the web and program.
- ceilingscorpion 10y agoI thought it was a good OS but it does not play well with the newer HP laptops. Sadly had to revert back to Windows 10 :(
- hashhar 10y agoAll of the stuff he praises about Elementary is just vanilla GNOME. I mean, he can't even recognize that Rhythmbox has looked the same for over 3 years now.