15 ms·
One of the biggest flaws of the tech industry is the belief that being a tech expert is enough to disrupt other industries in which they don't have any expertis
by slg 10y ago
One of the biggest flaws of the tech industry is the belief that being a tech expert is enough to disrupt other industries in which they don't have any expertise. Sometimes they get lucky and it works despite something like Uber's or Airbnb's total ignorance of the law. Sometimes it fails like with numerous cryptocurrency companies relearning why the finance industry has so many dang regulations. Seems like Soylent is falling in the latter camp.
- briandear 10y agoAirBnB and Uber are as ignorant of the law as a medicinal marijuana dealer selling in Texas.
- reacweb 10y agoIMHO, Uber has accumulated enough years of practice of law circunvention and political lobbying to earn some expertise badges. Maybe they were ignorant, now they are not.
- therein 10y agoYou could say the same thing about a dealer who started dealing in high school, continued dealing, graduated college, and still not caught.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- slang800 10y agoIf ignorance gets you a 30-something billion dollar valuation, then maybe it isn't such a bad strategy after all.
- clock_tower 10y agoCheck back in 30 years. I expect Uber and Airbnb to go the way of all tech stocks...
- wott 10y agoThat's a Pablo Escobar quote?
- elcct 10y agoThere really must be a law for everything? That's a slave mentality right there.
- adamlett 10y agoNot quite. It's not that there must be a law for everything, it's that there are laws for many things, and often for good reasons. It's not that we always need to regulate new things because new means risky. It's that many new things are actually old things in new guises, and we already know (or should know) what to be concerned about.
- omnimus 10y agoParadox is that US still has no regulations concerning digital privacy, big data and user protection.
- mirekrusin 10y ago...at the same time granting patents on double clicking.
- manigandham 10y agoThe internet moves fast, progress is being made. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2016/10/27/the-fcc-just-passed-sweeping-new-rules-to-protect-your-online-privacy/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2016/10/27...
- pjc50 10y agoPeople have paid good money to make sure there aren't such laws. It only has privacy laws based on incidents that have affected people of sufficient status: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Privacy_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Privacy_Protection_Act (and note the little coda in there about Netflix)
- marincounty 10y agoWe have a law for pretty much everything. Food laws--fine. Most laws--fine. But in the United States, the fines/fees for breaking these laws are just unfair. The same old analogy comming up. A rich man get's a $500 red light ticket. He tells the wife over dinner. With the poor man gets the same ticket; it just might be the last straw. I'm getting so tired of writing that senerio, but I guarantee someone's rent is in jeopardy right now because of the excessive penalty. I don't mind laws. I don't like being overcharged for the infraction. We live in a society where the rich can do pretty much as they please. I don't think the founding fathers would approve. For awhile, I belive the 8th admendment has been grossly violated. Laws--fine, but tie fees/punishment to income. It's way overdue. I believe Sweden took the plunge?
- coleifer 10y agoYou're laying the schadenfreude on a bit thick, don't you think?
- amelius 10y ago> One of the biggest flaws of the tech industry is the belief that being a tech expert is enough to disrupt other industries in which they don't have any expertise. One of the biggest flaws of consumers is that they can't tell low tech from high tech. Writing a shiny CRUD website is not high tech.
- nicky0 10y agoWhy should a consumer care either way?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThat's not just a flaw of consumers. It seems to be a problem with lots of people in the industry, including programmers, marketers and investors... Then again, they can make money out of it, so they probably don't care either.
- kelseydh 10y agoAnd most software products are just skins around databases. What's your point? This notion that some development should be considered "high tech" while other development should be considered "low tech" is one that bothers me, both for its elitism and for its simplemindedness. Yes, the skills needed to make a pretty CRUD app may be "lower tech" than the skills needed for someone to master, say, machine learning. But there are also many University professors doing work considered "high tech" who couldn't practically architect or code a basic application to save their lives. Meanwhile you have CRUD app developers contributing to frameworks that powerfully advance productivity being looked down upon because they only work in "kiddie languages" like Ruby or Javascript. Their work, even when it produces very high value appreciated by millions, is looked down upon as little more than copy-and-paste coding -- with zero appreciation given to how long it takes to develop the heuristics to do this kind of work well. I don't think this attitude is healthy. A more healthy attitude would be to recognize that value can be created in different ways.
- mcv 10y agoIt's still tech though. Actually, I'd say anything involving computers is still high tech, even when it's not innovative. Shiny CRUD website is not innovative, but it's still on the internet. Well, maybe it's more that it relies on high tech than actually being it.
- errow 10y agoAnd then there are the real elephants in the room - YouTube and Facebook. Basically saying well our platforms allow for infinite content sure, but we can't police all that. Sorry! These are actual arguments made in court. And then behind the scenes they are running around scared shitless trying to police content - http://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-content-insight-idUSKCN12S0D3 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-content-insight-i... The whole thing reminds me of Samuel L Jackson's character in Jurassic Park. Yes the dino's are breeding when they shouldn't, the kids are missing, the fences are broken, the T Rex can't be found but hey as soon as power is back up I can monitor everything from this one magic console. Isn't that amazing? Micheal Crichton had a good term for it. He called these people thintelligent.
- bitJericho 10y agoYouTube is the leader in protecting digital content. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-GTAVsMqa-U https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-GTAVsMqa-U
- n72 10y agoThe founder of Soylent clearly believes he's an expert in many, many fields: http://robrhinehart.com/?p=1331 http://robrhinehart.com/?p=1331 BTW, anyone know a good word for this attitude? I wouldn't call it hybris, though it's closely related. It's a mix of arrogance, over confidence, ignorance, plus more and very prevalent in SV.
- LouisSayers 10y agoSeems to work for Donald Trump
- ekianjo 10y agoMaybe thats the kind of attitude that makes founders good at taking risks, while more careful people would rationalize themselves out of trying new things ?
- Chrisjay 10y agoI would call it mania. If I wanted a pejorative, I'd call him euphoric.
- djur 10y agoAs someone who struggled with bipolar for years, his writing reminds me a lot of the shit I used to write in notebooks when manic. I was always convinced I had figured out a way to live a purer, better life without the bullshit everyone else always managed to slog through. And I never even had to sleep, except on the occasional bench in the middle of the day!
- Artoemius 10y agoThis was a fun read, and I found myself agreeing with him on most of the points. I would call his attitude "confidence in his own ability to reason clearly".
- arvinjoar 10y agoIt's not a bad attitude though. Experts with authority granted to them in the form of titles have failed us, and keep failing us in so many areas. Ranging from nutrition to psychology, we really shouldn't put their work on a pedestal. Techies are a smart bunch on average and can stomach a lot more complexity than the average joe. It makes sense for them to try to pick up stuff outside of their line of work. Take Elon Musk as the most successful example. Deferring to experts is a poor substitute for thinking for yourself.
- FLUX-YOU 10y agoThis thread seems like it's out to crucify someone and validate some belief that tech CEOs are masters-of-the-universe types instead of assuming Rob hired people to validate his ideas and tweak them which would be the sensible assumption. If someone has proof that Soylent employs zero nutritionists/food scientists, please enlighten us, because if that's the case, the product never should have gone to market and I'll throw my supply out immediately and go get a refund.
- r2dnb 10y ago>One of the biggest flaws of the tech industry is the belief that being a tech expert is enough to disrupt other industries in which they don't have any expertise. Here's an article elaborating on this sentiment : https://read.reddy.today/read/5/new-entrepreneurs-are-no-longer-wise https://read.reddy.today/read/5/new-entrepreneurs-are-no-lon...
- wcchandler 10y agoThis is definitely something I'm facing. I have a pretty deep interest in farming and have a bunch of approaches for "disrupting" it. But you know what my hangups are? Penetrating the culture and getting involved with the industry. Case in point -- where's the best place to buy zoysia seeds? Amazon? eBay? Some random mom and pop place with a ecommerce page? No. The best place to go is to "Bill" who is friends of friends of friends. Who won't take cold calls. Who doesn't sell wholesale. Who only finds new customers once a year at the local fair and he only shows up after 5. For the blue ribbon ceremony on prized pigs. Why is he the best? 99.999% reliability on seeds. It's 100, but he'll never claim that. Price? 1/10th of anything I can find online. What's rough is you can't just google this stuff. It takes knowledge and experience in these industries to know what's up. We believe we can do a lot with technology but we're going to make a lot of BAD decisions getting there.
- huac 10y agoSounds like there's asymmetrical information, a great place for a startup to break into. Or create a better marketplace for seeds!
- paavokoya 10y agoI'd venture to say the reason there is 100% reliability is due to the personal and "non-corporate" aspect to the way he does business. When you stop having face-to-face transactions and stop seeing your customers the interest in maintaining quality plummets. People become numbers. Also, p2p transactions work so well and are cheap because of the lack of middle-men taking unnecessary "fees".
- aalbertson 10y agoComing from the Farm culture/environment growing up, I can support this idea that it is in part the "non-corporate" aspect. It's very very much the personal, non-technological, Stay out of my business, get off my lawn, view points and feelings that drive some of this. In many cases you have a "handshake and your word is your honor" system in place that drives business forward. No one is stressing about much, beyond the weather, and they have a more peaceful perspective on life in general. That CERTAINLY has room for some technological improvement, but would have to be done in a very careful, well thought out and implemented way. Case in point, if it quits working or requires data fulltime (try getting data/cell/internet on a 10,000 acre farm in the middle of nowhere), then you will fail because even if you CAN convince a large portion of farmers to adopt the tech, once they start having enough problems with it? Out it goes, back to paper, phone calls, and a handshake.
- api 10y ago"like with numerous cryptocurrency companies relearning why the finance industry has so many dang regulations." My wife is into architecture and told me once that "every building code has a tombstone." Every building code is there because someone (or sometimes lots of people) died. Same with vehicle and road regs, etc. I had a lawyer tell me almost the same thing about equity, finance, and contract law: every standard provision in e.g. a VC deal and every financial regulation is there because somebody perpetuated a fraud or someone got screwed. Many are also there to compensate for large-scale systemic failure modes like runaway financial bubbles that occurred in the past. These systems are clunky and crufty and ugly and sometimes there is some value in "disrupting" them, but at the same time I think any would-be disrupters have to understand that the content of these laws and customs is the outcome of an evolutionary "Red Queen's race" lasting centuries or more. The code base is ugly but there's a lot of value and information captured in it.
- crpatino 10y agoJoel Spolsky's essay about never doing a full rewrite seems eerily appropriate. It should be obvious that systems that have been going and going for centuries will have quirks all over the place.
- max_ 10y agoI think Soylent's failure here wasn't that they tried to do something that they are not experts at, but rather failed to hire actual experts that could assist them in production. IMO they had a pretty good idea but tried to execute things in a rather vague way instead of consulting the actual experts in this field.
- alexandersingh 10y agoMalcolm Gladwell hosted a podcast recently called "Revisionist History". In one episode, "Generous Orthodoxy" (http://revisionisthistory.com/episodes/09-generous-orthodoxy http://revisionisthistory.com/episodes/09-generous-orthodoxy) that explored dissent, Gladwell states that we must "respect the body we're trying to heal". I haven't been able to get that statement out of my head since I heard it. It's simple, elegant and slightly profound. It (respect) is also precisely what is missing in the tech industries rallying cry around disruption. Study and learn why an industry has evolved the way it has before you criticize it as "backwards". In doing so, you may very well gain a deep sense of respect for it.