61 ms·
White House urges ban on non-compete agreements for many workers
- dmourati 10y agoMassachusetts has realized that its current legislation allowing for non-competes sniffles innovation. https://techcrunch.com/2016/02/18/silicon-valley-keeps-winning-because-non-competes-limit-innovation/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/02/18/silicon-valley-keeps-winni... http://news.wgbh.org/2016/06/29/politics-government/deleo-pleases-both-sides-business-approved-noncompete-bill http://news.wgbh.org/2016/06/29/politics-government/deleo-pl...
- oxide 10y agoI'm glad that non-competes are being looked at with a stink-eye, I feel it's bullshit to ask someone to sign away their right to use their skills to make a living in exchange for...using their skills to make a living. "If I can't have you, nobody can" is the long and short of a non-compete IMO, I don't feel that's an acceptable condition in any relationship. Maybe I misunderstand what a non-compete is, but it seems relatively straightforward. I don't think an employer is entitled to that kind of benefit, especially considering loyalty to an employer is usually rewarded with indifference at best.
- pinot 10y agoIn 2013 I turned down a job in Philadelphia, with a company who was headquartered in Boston. They wanted me to sign a 1yr non-compete with the stipulation that I wouldn't work for a company sold similar products within a +/- 30% wholesale cost of their product. After two trans-continental flights, interviews etc, I said no because of the NC. The recruiter flipped over it. He basically yelled at me "you're going to come work with us, we'll train you, then you'll go somewhere else?" No. I'm mid-career. I have skills you want. You're not training me. Your company is not an engineering school. I'll leave because I might not like working for you, or living where your company's office is. It's my life, not yours. Decided to stay in California where this wouldn't ever even be a question that would come up.
- antisthenes 10y agoThat's almost as ridiculous as parents asking their kids for a lifelong non-compete in the same field as them.
- dmourati 10y agoI'm glad you did that. It shows principle. You may have been able to negotiate it out but the fact that they wanted it shows you a good deal about the company character.
- pinot 10y agoIt was a privilege I had and exercised. I later found out that the company was notorious for pursing violators of their NC, and sort of well-known about it in my industry- which has companies from 1-person shops to multinationals, all operating within the same price point (food and beverage). So the NC was absolutely insane.
- agottem 10y agoThe Great Recession happened 8 years ago and they're just now discussing changes to protect workers?
- hak8or 10y agoThis seems to explicitly not include workers who are privvy to trade secrets based on a quick skim, so I guess all of us tech workers wouldn't have anything changed sadly.
- tedmiston 10y ago^ My thoughts exactly. > The Obama administration on Tuesday also urged states to ban non-compete agreements that are not proposed before a job offer or promotion is accepted and said employers should not be able to enforce the agreements when workers are laid off. It's unclear to me if the empathized part was meant to be a general statement, so that could affect tech workers.
- DominikR 10y agoA business owner could claim that trade secrets are involved in almost every sector. I've seen companies treating their (very basic) plans for Facebook ads as if it was classified information, putting a guy with a USB stick on a plane to transmit the "trade secret" from one office to another safely.
- Animats 10y agoNote that this is being proposed as something states should do. Federal legislation is not being proposed. Worst case would be Federal legislation which was weak and pre-empted state legislation, weakening California's ban. California employment law prohibits non-compete agreements for employees, and has since 1872. California also prohibits any employee agreement which claims employer ownership of intellectual property developed on the employee's own time.[1] This is one reason Silicon Valley is so successful. [1] http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=lab&group=02001-03000&file=2870-2872 http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=lab&gr...
- tedmiston 10y agoThese two points are awesome. Every state could use that. Both are not prohibited in Ohio.
- ekianjo 10y ago> California also prohibits any employee agreement which claims employer ownership of intellectual property developed on the employee's own time I have always wondered how could such a claim on ownership could exist in the first place. This reduces the employee to a mere company slave.
- throwaway_exer 10y ago> This reduces the employee to a mere company slave. Generally law enforcement will treat an employee as a slave if a company files any kind of complaint statement against the employee, regardless of how small the company is. Also, former employees have been convicted of violating employee handbooks. So slave is an apt description.
- GavinMcG 10y agoCan you please point to some examples of where employees were convicted of a crime simply for violating the private policies of their employer?
- throw_away_777 10y agoWhy can't congress do something about this? Non-competes are clearly terrible for workers, and should at the least be illegal without a severance agreement. If a company wants to keep me from working they should pay for the privilege. Workers also need to start refusing to sign egregiously bad non-compete agreements.
- jomamaxx 10y ago"If a company wants to keep me from working they should pay for the privilege." They are paying you. You join the company on those terms. If you don't want to join, then don't join. What they don't want you dong is taking all their IP, walking off and passing it onto a competitor. It would be extremely naive to not understand that this happens all the time. It's a tricky and nuanced problem, but it's real.
- aikah 10y ago> What they don't want you dong is taking all their IP, walking off and passing it onto a competitor. Bullshit, that's what NDAs are for.
- jomamaxx 10y ago"Bullshit, that's what NDAs are for." Totally false and completely naive. Most knowledge and know-how is not explicit - they are often learned. For example - suppose you worked at Nuance, and helped develop their new AI/Neural Network speech recognition system. Everything you know about Speech + AI you learned from them, in that language specific setting. If you went to work on Google's new Speech Recognition, which is AI-based - it would basically be impossible not to pass on know how and relevant knowledge. The application-specific skills are basically IP.
- aikah 10y ago> For example - suppose you worked at Nuance, and helped develop their new AI/Neural Network speech recognition system. Everything you know about Speech + AI you learned from them, in that language specific setting. And the knowledge and experience you got from your previous job before Nuance ? where does it come from ? why would the buck stop at Nuance ? or the former company ? or the company before it ? your point is ridiculous. The knowledge I acquire, if it doesn't involve a company's secret is my own and no company owns it. There is no such thing as intellectual slavery which you basically promote. If you don't pay me I owe nothing more than the respect of your patents and other corporate secrets and those are covered by NDA.
- solotronics 10y agoIANAL but my understanding is that non-competes are essentially unenforceable in Texas.
- enraged_camel 10y agoI live in Texas and I'm interested to know if this is actually true. Asking for a friend.
- ahlatimer 10y agoI also live in Texas and recently signed a non-compete after talking to my attorney. The general gist is that, yes, they are enforceable. The legislature keeps pushing for them, and the courts have, at various times, pushed back against them. There are limitations on them, but you'd have to talk to an attorney to figure out what they are -- I don't remember exactly what my attorney said. I do know that my attorney said my fairly typical non-compete probably would hold up in court. While I signed this one, I've just flat out refused to sign them in the past. People seem to have the idea that the employment agreement is set in stone. For some companies it might be, but I've had some success pushing back against clauses I didn't like.
- driverdan 10y agoWhy did you sign it? Why didn't you refuse this time?
- ahlatimer 10y agoBecause it was for a position where I felt it was more justified (cofounder), as compared to a run of the mill developer or team lead position, which is what I've been in the past and where I've refused to sign them.
- laichzeit0 10y agoI just signed one of these ridiculous clauses because pretty much everyone is just slapping this into their contracts now. Law needs to catch up on this one and fast. I like the idea of making non-compete enforceable only if you can prove malicious intent. Similar to how tax works. If onus is on the tax payer to prove that if you buy something and sell it at profit you must prove that the _intention_ was not to turn a profit if you want to pay capital gains tax and not income tax on the profit. Except the burden on proof must be skewed in favor of the employee and the proof of intent needs to sit with the employer if they want to enforce. E.g. If I go to market and get an offer (say at some competitor), you have first right of refusal to give me a counter. If you refuse to counter you cannot enforce your non-compete. This is fair imho. Lots of problems regarding "trade secrets" etc. but the law should be highly weighted towards the idea of "innocent by until proven guilty" for the employee.
- greglindahl 10y agoMove to California, or draw a line through it and see what happens.
- driverdan 10y agoYou should have refused to sign it.
- drawkbox 10y agoNon-competes, the most anti-innovation, anti-skilled worker, anti-free market, anti-business and anti-American thing in working today. Non-competes are protectionism for larger businesses over small/medium businesses. As a freelancer, contractor and self-employed business owner/worker, please make these illegal, tired of these. The worst part about non-competes is they are blanket protectionism usually and up to 2+ years of non-compete, this sometimes happens on a job that is only 1-3 months. You have to laugh at those types of situations. Usually the client will push them aside or lower the time to the job plus some time, but both non-competes and arbitration agreements are horrible for workers in today's economy where people change jobs frequently and many are self-employed/freelancing/contracting. The non-compete should not exist, at the core removing competition from skilled workers in our economy is bad all around, unless you are one of the current big fish.
- jomamaxx 10y agoFrom your comments I gather you might not understand the problem. Were Soft Engs simply to do 'work' then you would be absolutely right. But in a world of IP ... it's a different story. Company ABC brings you in, trains you on their know-how and core IP, which took a lot of struggle, $, and R&D to create - then you leave, go to a competitor, and effectively communicate and give away ABC Corps. most valuable asset. Non-competes can certainly applied far too aggressively, esp. in situations where there is not merit ... but there are definitely cases wherein I think it does make sense. I'm thinking companies like DWAVE in Vancouver that built the 'first' qubit/quantum computer. The guy spent his whole life developing that tech. It's feasible that Google just grabs up some of the team and internalizes all that work and effort for the price of a few headcount. It's a real problem in some cases, but worse - very difficult to parameterize.
- bsder 10y ago> Company ABC brings you in, trains you on their know-how and core IP, which took a lot of struggle, $, and R&D to create - then you leave, go to a competitor, and effectively communicate and give away ABC Corps. most valuable asset. Um, that's covered by an NDA--Non-Disclosure Agreement. Those are generally QUITE enforceable, even in California and often last for 3 to 5 years. Non-compete is quite different.
- aikah 10y agoI don't understand how these clauses are even legal at first place. It violates the basic right of freedom of work. You can't have on one end freedom of enterprise but on the other hand no freedom of work for employees. the worst thing is the fact that these agreements usually come with 0 compensation.
- telefonica 10y agoCompletely agree. In the UK it's called garden leave: the employer pays you to drink tea in your garden. It's too easy for companies to claim losses from competing employees. They need to put their $$$ where their mouth is
- greglindahl 10y agoI believe that this is basically allowed in California, too, but the employee can still quit.
- yomly 10y agoIn the UK you're usually paid full salary though and garden leave is rarely longer than 3 months iirc.
- tajen 10y ago> with 0 compensation I don't agree compensation would be any useful. In France non-compete agreements must be compensated proportionnaly. Example: My company prohibited me from working with the customers on the whole territory of France for a duration of 3 months, paid at 1/3 of the salary per month. The real mean clause is that they can decide whether to apply it or not, and they can tell you on the day you leave. Therefore: They save, except when the employee gets hired by the customer, in which case they only have to spend 33% of the salary for 3 months to prevent you from working. Last point, in France, Company-to-Employee non-competes are restricted, but Company-to-Company are not. Which makes things hard for consultants. So don't fall in that trap: Asking for a compensation will only seem fair on the surface. Require your government to drop non-competes altogether, and both for employees and B2B contracts.
- joshAg 10y agosimple solution: all workers must be paid full salary and benefits for the entire term of the non-compete agreement.
- bkor 10y agoLaw in Belgium allows an anti competition clause only in certain cases. When it does apply, the employer still has to pay half of the salary for the length of anti compete clause. There's still a limit on the length (12 months), various limitations on when it applies, etc. See http://nl.workpocket.be/2/3/het-concurrentiebeding/ http://nl.workpocket.be/2/3/het-concurrentiebeding/ Netherlands also has various limitations on anti compete clauses. Generally, they're not valid: http://www.lbv.nl/actueel/wet-en-regelgeving/146-het-concurrentiebeding http://www.lbv.nl/actueel/wet-en-regelgeving/146-het-concurr.... Since 2015 they only apply to full time employees and there should be a very good business reason. Meaning: it should not apply to everyone, at most a limited amount of people.
- gok 10y agoGreat! ...as long as this doesn't just mean nonsensically narrow rules like the new Illinois law, which only applies to low wage workers (< $13/hour).
- greglindahl 10y agoMost laws are a reaction to something stupid, and in this particular case it's a reaction against sandwich shops requiring low-wage workers to sign non-competes.
- kalms 10y agoReally? Those sandwiches must be something special for sure. It actually seems borderline malicious and evil to me. Modern day slavery.
- didgeoridoo 10y agoA ban seems heavy-handed. Since a noncompete essentially ties up an employee for a period, I'd prefer to see that tie-up treated by law as a continuation of employment at the existing salary. Surely companies must value their precious IP more than a single employee's salary for a year or two — and if they don't, perhaps it isn't that valuable after all.
- flukus 10y ago> The Obama administration on Tuesday also urged states to ban non-compete agreements that are not proposed before a job offer or promotion is accepted and said employers should not be able to enforce the agreements when workers are laid off. Won't this just move the non-compete to be included in the job offer instead of the formal employment contract? That's a slight improvement at best.
- DominikR 10y agoI wonder what a principled position on this matter would be. On one hand everyone is free to trade freedoms for gains (usually monetary - every contract restricts both parties freedom), but on the other hand you can't trade certain freedoms away that we view as fundamental. Even though I am certainly no proponent of non-compete agreements I cautiously tend towards viewing such contracts as acceptable and valid. You usually do limit selling your services already the moment you accept a position as an employee, at least for the time you stay employed there. Contractually expanding it for a mutually agreed upon period doesn't strike me as that much different, at least as long as there was no coercion involved and both sides fully understood the consequences.
- flukus 10y agoThe coercion is usually that you don't know about the non-compete until you walk in and sign your employment contract on day 1. >Contractually expanding it for a mutually agreed upon period doesn't strike me as that much different As long as I'm compensated for that period (a normal wage) then I think it's fair.
- DominikR 10y ago> The coercion is usually that you don't know about the non-compete until you walk in and sign your employment contract on day 1. Okay this is really bad, in the EU country where I live you usually first negotiate and sign the contract, then start working. But the drawback is that it is really just done this way because the government requires that the business notifies it about your employment before you start working, which is a privacy issue. I think I'd still prefer it the US way. I'd ask about this before starting to work. (if this isn't a no go)
- cableshaft 10y agoYep, they spring it on you by giving you your 'Employee Handbook' or something on your first day, after you accepted the offer and relocated and whatever else you wanted to do, then sit down to sign paperwork on your first day and.... yep, there it is, that sneaky little non-compete. You ask HR about it and they'll probably just say "It's standard legalese, everyone here signed it, it's no big deal, just sign the damn thing, or you can walk." You have to bring it up in the interview if you don't want to be bound by one. But even just asking could spook out the interviewees and get them to pass on you "Is this guy a Snowden? Is he going to steal and leak all our preeeeecious 'secrets'?"
- Steeeve 10y agoI've heard of two or three people in my lifetime that had a company try to enforce a non-compete. Two were during a Microsoft/Google fight, and one was in the late 60s with a scientist. Has anybody around here been sued after leaving a company due to a non-compete clause?
- throw_away_777 10y agoNon-competes are usually enforced indirectly. Most companies will ask if you have a non-compete, and a lot of them will just refuse to hire you if you do.
- MrMullen 10y agoI have a good story on non-compete agreement! I worked for a company based in New Mexico while I lived in California. When we both got sick of each other, at the exit interview the HR personnel on the phone from New Mexico told me I could not work in IT for the next 2 years as I signed a non-compete agreement. I just started laughing at them and told them I lived in California and good luck with enforcing that contract. End of conversation and I was out in the parking lot 5 minutes later, still laughing.
- yurty 10y agoI know someone who was threatened with a lawsuit over a non-compete contract by a web development contracting company. He consulted with a lawyer in the state the contract was signed, and ended up settling with his original employer for a series of cash payments. It led some people (including myself) to quit the company that sued, but it has also resulted in a number of employees deciding that looking for new employment was too risky. I'm posting under a throwaway for obvious reasons.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tristor 10y agoI don't understand why there's so many people in the comments defending non-competes. They have literally no value to society, or to individual employees. They are a tool of restrictive coercion to stifle an employees freedom of movement in the job market. Trade secrets, IP, secret sauce: covered by NDA and IP assignment agreements Client lists, contract terms, sales strategies, reported metrics, financials: covered by NDA and in some cases SEC regulations about insider trading. Etc. The only thing a non-compete does is say that Employee A cannot work in their chosen field for some period of time after they are fired or quit. In doing so it offers no consideration or compensation typically in the contract. So your employer underpays you by 40% and treats you badly? You want to leave for greener pastures at that hip new startup that offered you a Senior Engineer gig? Well, sorry to say you have a mortgage, a wife, and 2 kids and that non-compete says you are only legally allowed to be a burger flipper for two years after quitting, that software engineering is verboten. Totally fair right? If you don't sit on the board of a Fortune 500 company, you have literally no incentive to support non-competes. There is no rational basis to argue in their favor. Please learn the difference between NDAs, IP assignment agreements, and non-competes before lending non-competes some mystical powers they don't have.
- masklinn 10y ago> The only thing a non-compete does is say that Employee A cannot work in their chosen field for some period of time after they are fired or quit. In doing so it offers no consideration or compensation typically in the contract. Many (if not most) EU countries require compensation for non-competes to be valid (usually at least 30% gross), and the non-compete can still be challenged in court if e.g. it applies to too large a geographical area (e.g. the entire state/country) or if it's broad enough to prevent the employee from finding work in the field.
- Fiahil 10y agoYes, and it's rarely enforced. Most of the time its activation is at the employer's discretion.
- 10y ago
- npezolano 10y agoCalifornia is one of the few states that doesn't honor out of state non-competes.
- tjpnz 10y agoAnyone know how these work in practice in Japan? The constitution here guarantees the right to work where you want yet I've witnessed people being asked to sign them upon leaving a job.
- bahularora 10y agoToday, after completing almost a month of my trial at a new job, HR asked me to sign a document on Stamp paper with a very vague 1 year non-compete clause. All my objections to the same were casually shrugged of by her, by saying they don't use it until I would directly hurt the revenue of the employer. When I refused to sign it she said that it might be hard to offer me a job in the case I don't sign it. Which very much sounded like a threat to me. If they insist I would most probably sign it, as without the salary I wouldn't be able to afford rent next month. According to her all the other employees have signed it and none questioned her on it. Notably non-competes are mostly illegal in India, still almost all agreements I have come across have the clause mentioned in them. I don't understand the point in having a clause like this, when its non-enforceable. Many other points of the agreement were as egregious as the non-compete clause. Also the whole agreement was extremely one sided. It also said all the IP/Products/patents I develop, even in my own time, during my tenure would belong by the employer.
- falcolas 10y ago> It also said all the IP/Products/patents I develop, even in my own time, during my tenure would belong by the employer. These clauses are getting worse too, claiming what you develop up to a year after you leave the company. I had to sign one of these or not take the job, non-negotiable. Not taking the job wasn't a choice at that time, sadly.
- CaptSpify 10y agoThis, to me, is the shadiest part of non-competes. I've only gotten one, but it was after I had quit my previous job, and moved across the country. Am I supposed to say no, now that I've already moved and have no other current source of income for my family? Shame on me for not asking up-front what I would have to sign, but also, how is it legal to start throwing new contracts at someone, when they weren't part of the original agreement in the first place.
- bahularora 10y agoI am gonna try to change the management's mind about these policies. I am hopeful that they would accept my request especially since these are not enforceable in court and this would makes the whole agreement void. Is it legal to have a extremely one sided agreement? Also if it is signed under threat(no job/no livelihood) isn't it void, as its signed under duress?
- dsr_ 10y agoI'm perfectly OK with a non-compete agreement... as long as it pays me for my downtime. You think the information in my head is so valuable that you don't want me working for a competitor for three years after I leave? OK, pay me for three years. It's not worth that much to you? Well, how much is it worth?
- pzh 10y agoHow would you determine the cost of your downtime? If you're assuming that all you're going to do after you leave a company is become a wage slave at another one, then getting paid the same wage for a few years might be enough to compensate you. However, if you really aspire to start your own company that might become hugely successful (e.g. the next Facebook or Google), how would you be compensated for that? The point is that even if you're paid for the time when the NDA is in force, you are still being harmed, because your freedom to invest your time is restricted.
- biztos 10y agoNot to mention the opportunity cost for wage slaves. If you're a programmer and are prevented from getting a new job right now, when it's a seller's market for talent, then you might be in a much worse situation in a year if the market changes. Even getting 100% of your wage for that year could be a terrible deal.
- hammock 10y agoThis comes one week after - and in contrast to - Donald Trump promising in his first 100 days in office a five-year ban on White House officials and Congressman from becoming lobbyists, and a lifetime ban on White House lobbyists from lobbying on behalf of foreign governments. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/news/powerpost/wp/2016/10/17/trump-proposes-five-year-ban-on-executive-branch-officials-and-lawmakers-who-want-to-become-lobbyists/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/...
- Cabal 10y agoWhich is a good idea. If you showed someone from 30 years ago how lobbying worked today, they'd declare it was straight-up bribery.
- MrMullen 10y agoThis, yet again, demonstrates that Trump does not understand how the US Government works. The President does not make laws, Congress does. You think the very people who signed up for a job so they can get rich later are really going to pass a law that limits their ability to get rich later?
- 0xffff2 10y agoa) How is this article in any way related to lobbying? b) Even if we assume Trump somehow managed to implement his plan, how is it not going to be struck down immediately as a violation of the first amendment? Campaign finance and lobbying are incredibly broken right now, but they currently exist because of a legal framework that can only be changed by a constitutional amendment that (partially) exempts political speech from the promises of the first amendment.
- neogodless 10y agoI'm not sure if you came here for anecdotes, but my very first full time web developer position had a non-compete clause. After 2.5 years, I moved to a new company about 15 miles away for a roughly 20% raise. Some time into this job, I ended up doing some work for a client that had left my previous employer. I reached out to the previous employer because I needed something changed on the server (they still managed hosting) - this tipped them off that I was (gasp) doing work for one of their previous clients. They ended up attempting to sue me and my new employer based on the non-compete! We went to a disposition, but then the lawyers huddled, and the end result was that the non-compete was reduced from 5 Years (!!) to just 1 year, and that we agreed I wouldn't do work on that specific client for the duration. Otherwise, there was no penalty or fallout. I consider it a big dramatic show with no benefit to the previous employer; they stomped their feet and pouted, the end. Depending on the phrasing of the non-compete, I tend to cross that section out, initial them, and then include a note when I submit them to my employer. Most are fine with that change.
- aaronchall 10y agoYeah, I think that's what I'm going to do going forward. If there's a non-compete in an otherwise viable contract, I'm going to strike it, sign, and if it's of real value to them and they still want me, they can pay me to agree to it.
- shadowban_me 10y agoI like how anyone even mentioning IP is downvoted to hell. It really shows you what market Ycombinator is really in. Every single comment is either someone's personal narrative, or a ridiculous troll where "OMG WHY" is the only thing they say in each sentence. Wow, I wonder how this ever became law when YCombinator commentators are so opposed to it?
- losteverything 10y agoIt is now standard for unskilled workers too as it is included in most job application / offers. A $12 / hr. part time Walmart worker can not work at another retailer or online company or Amazon warehouse. The scope is defined by the company. It is used as a threat. Besides, if someone wants to steal company secrets they will regardless of a signed paper. In the '80s worked with a Chinese C/unix contractor that ported all code to China. It was comm type work. No NDA would prevent a criminal.
- omouse 10y agoThank the lord, non-competes are a criminal waste of productivity.
- dominotw 10y agoBan-ing things is like writing explanatory code comments instead of working out why that code was confusing/hacky in the first place. Unfortunately, people would rather welcome big brother govt into their lives than work on fixing the real problem.
- ad_a 10y agoThere's a coffee shop in our town that makes barristas sign a non-compete i.e. no working at other coffee shops in town. This is beyond mind-blowingly stupid.
- zappo2938 10y agoJimmy John's the sandwich shop made their employees sign non-compete contracts too. [1] [1] http://www.cnbc.com/2016/06/22/jimmy-johns-drops-non-compete-clauses-following-settlement.html http://www.cnbc.com/2016/06/22/jimmy-johns-drops-non-compete...
- losteverything 10y agoTragic story of a business. You decide if it was stolen. Happened a few years ago to a client friend. Husband wife owns a florist. Has for decades in a county fourth highes per capita income in us. Built a nice life but it was time to retire and sell the business. They did not own their building. New landlord buys building ( shop in nice main street area.) raises rent to outrageous amount. Too much to run the business. Husband wife team can't sell florist before New lease starts and they do not sign lease. The very Next week !!!! Next week - building owner puts up new sign for a new florist. The owners lost everything. They owned some things like coolers - and got $$ for those.
- ghaff 10y agoIn other words, a landlord decided not to renew a lease and opened their own business. On the one hand, it's a bit sleazy to attempt to cash in on the previous shop's customer relationships. But I have trouble calling this "stolen." Presumably, if it were a Starbucks that were opened instead, it wouldn't be so objectionable even though the net effect on the previous store owners is largely the same.
- losteverything 10y agoThe couple is devastated. I call it sleazy. But wonder why someone didn't let them see that outcome could happen.
- ghaff 10y agoI agree the thing carries something of a smell and is unfortunate. On the other hand, I'm not sure how much salable value there is in a typical florist (or indeed in many retail businesses) even if it's throwing off a reasonable income stream for the owners that would lead someone to buy an existing business, rather than just starting fresh.
- briffle 10y agoI'm a bit confused on how this is relevant? would a employee signing a non-compete agreement have prevented this? Even if there was one with the previous lanlord, would that have applied in the case of a sale?
- dustinmr 10y agoThis seems to miss how companies will react if enacted. If there's a freer flow on the talent side, corporations will want a freer flow as well. I would expect this to accelerate the current trend of converting more and more positions to contract or temporary positions rather than employment. I think that's a good thing. I'm not sure the White House would agree.
- smokedoutraider 10y agoWhile I don't agree with non-competes, I don't understand how it's even slightly ok to allow a government to decide private business policies.
- ViViDboarder 10y agoTypically to prevent abuse of employees, who often have far less power than a company does. That is unless they are organized as a group to heighten their bargaining power.
- briffle 10y agoI agree, lets only hire heterosexual, white, Christian males under 35 years old, and exclude all other candidates if we want to! </sarcasm>
- Arcaten 10y agoWhat is most surprising to me about these stories today is how uncommon NDAs are. I read somewhere that 20% of workers in the US have signed one. I don't know if this is a common experience, but my employer recently began putting NDAs in place and, in retrospect, I feel they took advantage of the ignorance of most of the employees (including me). They insisted that the NDA was "standard," managers told us that there was no room for negotiation and pushed to have us sign immediately (eventually relented to having it signed by end of the following day).
- squozzer 10y agoIf this gets any traction, I might consider giving BHO a C+ grade for his administration.