11 ms·
Why Haters Hate: Kierkegaard Explains the Psychology of Trolling in 1847
- PeterWhittaker 10y agotl;dr: It is the only way the troll can participate in the greatness/fame/notoriety (as the case may be) of the trollee. FWIW, YMMV.
- PeterWhittaker 10y agoHuh. Why the downvote? Is my summary inaccurate? If so, please, by all means, do better! Downvoting is so lazy....
- DanBC 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7789350#7790022 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7789350#7790022 > All: please don't use "tl;dr" on Hacker News. It's fine, of course, to point out relevant details from an article. But it should be part of a considered comment of your own. > HN values intellectual substance. Good reading, writing, and thinking take time. If we're to have high-quality discussion, we need to inhibit the reflex to snap judgment and give the slower and quieter reflective process a chance to function. > Since memes like "tl;dr" are emblems of that shallow reflex, we should heed the broken windows theory and not have them here. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12667459 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12667459 > It's important for HN to keep its distance from tldr culture. Longer articles are ok, even if many of us won't read them. It's true of any post that most people won't read it. > Snap summaries make for reflexive reactions. That's the shallow kind of discussion we're hoping to avoid here. What we want is reflection, which is slower, takes more energy, and leads to more considered exchanges. etc etc.
- PeterWhittaker 10y agoAnd you'll see that the top comment on Dang's comment is a "profound disagreement". We none of us have time to read all articles. I've found and continue to find tl;dr's useful - and judging by upvotes and comments I've received on other pure tl;dr's I've made, this view is widely held. dang and others may wish a certain "intellectual climate" but, for better or for worse, many HN discussions fail to live up to whatever standard he may hope for. Targeting tl;dr's - considered a useful feature by many - is both petty and unhelpful. But thanks for the extensive quote.
- M_Grey 10y agoThat explains very little of the most common form of trolling, in which the target of the abuse is every bit as obscure as the abuser.
- whack 10y agoKeep your friends close, and your enemies closer. The idea of constantly surrounding myself with enemies sounds nightmarish, but I can understand why it works.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoIf you have many friends and few enemies, it's not so bad.
- wott 10y agoIt ain't bad if you can take a breath sometimes. Enemies do not betray you, unlike friends.
- Swizec 10y agoThere is also another form of trolling, common on the internet: the person is bored and looking for entertainment. Or my favorite form of trolling where I merely use the thing I am commenting on as a sort of plot device, a writing and thought prompt even, that helps me think through a thing. Like right now. This comment is more for me than it is for anyone else, it lightly disagrees with the OP, perhaps even trolls, but it's not for OP, it's for me. The upvotes and downvotes then help tune me to the community and/or society. Yes, I troll like this IRL as well. Just say something outrageous, see what happens. The resulting debates are often great fun and tell you a lot about the people around you.
- bsenftner 10y agoThe writer needs to know Kierkegaard better to be writing such articles. That was a puff of air. Whereas Kierkegaard is more like a rock against your head, smarting with pain.
- M_Grey 10y agoI'm curious, what aspect of this do you think missed the points which Kierkegaard tried to make? I'm not sure that I understand your metaphor and analogy.
- mangeletti 10y agoIt actually seems that Søren may have been tripping over his own ego while falling prey to a false consensus of his own shortcomings. Perhaps, he was just socially awkward. That's not such a bad thing, once you admit it to yourself. He referred to his community as "petty". This is much like somebody who disagrees with what other are saying (e.g., in an online forum like this), and thus dismisses the community as a group of idiots, rather than using the disagreement as an opportunity for introspection.
- trestles 10y agohonestly, since this is in translation, a word like "petty" raises numerous issues for negative connotations that might not be in original.
- ythl 10y agoI troll a lot, and this doesn't describe me at all. For me, it's simple - I like eliciting reactions out of people. I like saying controversial things to see if someone will get upset or offended. It's fun. Same reason I liked to tease my siblings when I was younger. For some reason manipulating people into losing control of their emotions is very entertaining.
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agoyou're an idiot.
- legodt 10y agoPerhaps it is time to seek professional help so you can hopefully mend that energy into something less anti-social. Good luck
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoHave you ever met your match?
- ythl 10y agoAs in, has anyone successfully trolled me? Or have my "victims" defeated my attempts? If the latter, all the time. The people that defeat me are the ones that just ignore me. Once I can get people to engage with me, I'll try to string them along as long as possible.
- Pica_soO 10y agoIts the certainty with which some people express there opinion as absolute reality, dogmatism and fanaticism, that attracts the trolls. If you would take a look at the "victims" you often discover that a meaningful exchange of arguments wouldn't have been possible in the first place. If someone runs with the -ism crowd, has his eyes opened by using the ideologys inherent errors or has otherwise encapsulated himself in his own little information cyst, any disturbance from the outside will be a troll. If you dislike the troll, you just can starve him, by being reasonable, emotionless and calm. If you demand special protection rights for your opinions, and are unwilling to rebut attacks with good arguments you disserve to be trolled else you could damage the public.
- rustynails 10y agoThat creates a difficult balance. I agree with everything you said (except he instead of they). Where we are let down with that approach is if businesses, media or government don't take responsibility to manage prejudice and bullying. Imagine being Jewish in Germany just before WWII. Now my argument may sound like political correctness, but it's not for a few reasons. You avoid prejudice by avoiding topics of gender, race, etc. You ensure people have the opportunity, which doesn't guarantee an outcome. You don't need equal numbers, just don't alienate. These 3 things encapsulate my beliefs and are the antithesis of political correctness. So, you are right in that individuals should have the right to their views and should expect them to be challenged. Also recognise that Facebook and co will magnetise these marginalisers to each other, giving them a collective voice which can easily turn into a mob (as it often does). If you don't have responsible leadership (and we don't), these mobs become vicious and destructive. Compound this with political correctness and you have a toxic, self righteous and highly prejudiced mob of hate and bullying! With policies of both US candidates being so openly prejudiced (eg. Trump on Mexicans, Clinton on her gender card), the future for more hate and bullying looks certain.
- wyager 10y ago> Imagine being Jewish in Germany just before WWII. Really? Getting trolled online is like the holocaust?
- rustynails 10y agoI don't think this article adequately captures the problem. I'll try to illustrate. I explained to my children about the 2 US candidates. I described both of them as bullies and said they promote a culture of bullying. We discussed how they set a bad example for the broader community and how media condones this behaviour. I was picking up my children from school when one young boy called me by my first name in a mocking tone. I approached him and asked how his day was and took a moment to ask about him. When I now see this boy, he goes out of his way to say hello. I recently went to a computer club open day. The rules were "we will only allow the same number of boys in as girls". I looked around and saw about 20 boys and 1 girl. I went to this girl and her mother and said "good on you for giving it a go, a variety of experiences is essential to helping you find your true self". The mother went on a sexist rant about patriarchal societies (the usual politically correct thinking) and I said "why would you deny any child the opportunity? Why would you force the same numbers of girls and boys? What's gone wrong in such basic thinking?" She stopped the hardcore feminist routine and apologised. She was big enough to say "no one has ever put it like that, that really makes sense". The problem with hate is that the Internet has given it a collective voice of monumental proportions. Our community leaders have let us down by selectively promoting prejudice (eg. Emma Watson is glorified for hypocrisy) while aggressively condemning others, especially passive people like Matt Taylor. What's worse is that most people don't recognise hate and bullying when they see it, or they are apathetic to it. My simple rule: if someone promotes one group over another, they are as bad as someone who excludes or vilifies a group (especially politically correct people who are huge bullies). These people who marginalise are the true haters and bullies. The article really misses the breadth of hate and bullying. Thought for the day. Do a search on breast cancer websites. How many of these sites do you think alienate men who suffer from the condition? Why do you think many of these sites quote percentages of male victims?
- plasticchris 10y agoJust curious, how does this rule affect your stance on affirmative action and similar policies?
- kingkawn 10y agoSo to combat all of this you're going around correcting people and dismissing their perspectives as, among other things, the usual PC culture? Do you not think your attitude will evolve in your children and theirs into the same mockery of kindness and it's own principles that has befallen everyone else?
- chinese_dan 10y ago'Trolling' has changed definitions over the years. It used to mean someone that intentionally stirs things up to make people angry, even though they don't actually believe what they are posting/saying. Now, it's used to classify anyone that has an opinion other than the current liberal narrative and has the purpose of silencing all opposing viewpoints. Once a person is considered a 'troll', all horrible and inhuman behavior against that person is acceptable and even encouraged. Edit: haha, I guess we aren't open to any discussions here on HN?
- qb45 10y agoNot only liberal, nowadays trolling is any behavior you dislike on the Internet. Having weird opinions, harassment and death threats, shilling, spam - I've seen each of these being called trolling by noobs.
- kordless 10y ago"Hating" is a strange thing. It's the trustless communication by an individual, or group of individuals, JUDGING another individual or group in a way that SPEAKS for the other individual or group. For example, if I was telling Alice a story about Bob, and I were to say something like "Bob doesn't know how he feels, he is sad most of the time and everyone here hates him for it" then I would be blaming Bob for not knowing how he feels, rationalizing my own thoughts about how he feels (sad) and then presenting "his" emotions as a shared truth for Alice and others that would listen. As long as I did that in a way that corroborates other's external observations of Bob nobody will know any different, other than Bob of course. Haters use simplified terms, leading questions, "thoughts of others" and visualization seeds to transmit their internal blaming views onto others. Those seeds are then propagated by those who don't know these recursive thoughts are dangerous to play with, as they lead to increasing blame, judgement and speaking for larger groups over time. I say "dangerous" here, but what I really mean is "increasingly inefficient" given everyone involved in the hate has to start rendering future realities that don't exist. ISIS, for example, does this quite well using Armageddon (a foregone conclusion) as their excuse to be involved in massive suffering. Gandhi observed that our thoughts become our words, our words become our actions, our actions become our character, our character becomes our destiny. Causality happens somewhere in there, even if we don't want to admit it. If we choose to judge and speak for others, the expectation is that others will continue to increasingly judge and speak for us. Or as Erlich put it best : "Richard, if you're not an asshole, it creates this kind of asshole vacuum, and that void is filled by other assholes, like Jared. I mean, you almost gave him shares. You need to completely change who you are, Richard. A complete Teutonic shift has to happen."
- zc75 10y agoTectonic?
- swayvil 10y agoAn extremely gentle moderately chummy word to break the ice. I'll try that. I'm assuming that I haven't tried that. I may have. I seem to recall the troll taking even that as an opportunity to lunge for my soft spots, but I could be mistaken.
- panste 10y agoThat part with the "casual remark" is something that I experienced myself. In middle school I was bullied by a neighbour of mine. The weird part was that on some days he was really nice to me and he acted like he was a good friend of mine and on some days he was a total dick. I learned that when I approached him in the morning and talked to him (about homework, video games, whatever) he was nice to me the whole day, when I had nothing to do with him he became mean and started bullying.
- ddrum001 10y agoIs this post equating trolling with bullying?
- known 10y agoRejection can dramatically reduce a person’s IQ and their ability to reason analytically, while increasing their aggression https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn2051-rejection-massively-reduces-iq/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn2051-rejection-massiv...
- nsaslideface 10y agoI feel this article tries to make plain-old masculinity interesting and complex, but it just isn't. Bullying exists on a spectrum of violence. There is no reason to assume there must be a categorical separation between verbal/text-based bullying and physical aggression. Internet bullying (trolling, whatever, we all know what is being discussed without having to argue semantics) is a manifestation of masculinity, no different from how boys/men bully in person. It's another sort of male violence, socialized in young boys by their slightly older peers and the adult world (something I observed as a boy, growing up). Young girls also bully, but the objectification of human beings is more alien to teenage girls than boys, and I think this explains why women tend to "troll" less, meaning, they tend less to see fellow human beings as toys. If learned trolling starts early in life, the most efficient strategy to defeat trolls permanently is to donate to organizations with explicit stances against the socialization of masculinity in boys (Feminist Current, Stop Patriarchy, WoLF, etc.)
- mentos 10y agoI'm pretty sure there are videos on YouTube of chimpanzees playing with tigers in the forest. Swinging down from trees just to smack them over the head and back up into cover...
- losteverything 10y agoThe pic looks like the $20 US note of Andrew Jackson.
- ythl 10y ago> I would say that's what separates trolling from just plain bullying: people know it's just a game of sorts. Not exactly. What if I go to a predominately liberal community and start saying pro-Trump things? Am I bullying anyone? No, yet people might not know it's a game (to me), either and have very emotional reactions to my trolling.
- M_Grey 10y agoFrom my perspective? You'd be declaring to anyone and everyone that you're bored and lonely, and starved for attention. If that's what you enjoy, be you, but remember that the majority of people will be, at best, pitying you.
- ythl 10y agoYes, but most people don't even realize they are being trolled. Why would they pity me? Do you pity people you disagree with online?
- M_Grey 10y agoYou might be surprised at just how often those people being trolled are just as lonely and bored as you, and just as undiscriminating in their taste in virtual company. The rest, the aforementioned "vast majority" almost certainly recognize what you're about, and steer well clear of you as a result. In all likelihood, your activities achieve little more than to restrict your potential interactions by preemptively driving away anyone who's actually worth interacting with.
- ythl 10y agoStop saying I'm lonely and bored! I'm neither lonely nor bored, and my trolling is purely for entertainment value (often to be shared with others after the fact). For example, sometimes I'll make a throwaway stackoverflow account and then ask a question in which I criticize the gcc compiler, when in reality my posted code itself is logically incorrect. The variety and types of responses I get are often hilarious... from the condescending pedant to the patient nurturer.
- throw2016 10y agoTrolls are sociopaths. As long as they can get some satisfaction or happiness for themselves they don't really care about other people who are reduced to objects of amusement. Try to impress on them the concept of other people and out will come a litany of excuses that seek to dehumanise their targets and paint themselves as self appointed arbiters of fanatism, intolerance or 'holders of valid opinions'. Are other people triggered by trolls or is it the trolls who are triggered merely by others holding opinions they don't agree with? The dissonance does not even register, because that requires self awareness, self examination and empathy. There is a context for humour, comedy, satire and deception that outside the context can quickly become cruelty and reflect some sort of sadism in taking pleasure in others pain.