9 ms·
Microsoft Delivers Another Broken Windows 10 Update
- arbuge 10y agoThe first time I installed Windows 10 on my Lenovo laptop I was left with a file manager which gets hopelessly spinning circle stuck every few days, requiring a reboot. About 25% of file copies also hang up for about 2 minutes before completing, in the "Calculating" phase, even if the file in question is just a few bytes. So I was looking forward to this new update. Perhaps it might fix things. No dice. It crashed during the install process. At this point I consider myself lucky to have been able to roll things back to the old version.
- f_allwein 10y agoand I consider myself lucky I managed to push back any of Microsoft's attempts to upgrade me to Windows 10...
- BoorishBears 10y agoAnd on the other hand Windows 10 has been updating without issue for me on my home machines, I've only caught glimpses of any of them restarting for updates (It schedules them for times when the PC isn't usually in use). Overall for me the benefits of Windows 10 (Especially better Xbox controller support, which was why I upgraded my first machine to Windows 10) have been nice, and there's been no downside
- lucb1e 10y agoI consider myself lucky to not be forced to use Windows: as a developer, everything I need runs on Linux. Haven't had trouble with updates or other crap from vendors ever since.
- jerf 10y agoTone note: Serious question, not just kvetching. Does anyone have a good clue as to why this update is so big and disruptive? The feature list [1] shows "biometric security for Windows apps and Edge", "Windows Ink" support, vaguely-specified Cortana improvements (I think that translates to "Cortana has plugins now"), and an Xbox improvement. I'm thinking that's not really what's in there since that just doesn't seem like a 2-3 reboot and massive disruption sort of update. [1]: https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2016/03/30/windows-10-anniversary-update-brings-new-experiences-and-developer-opportunity/ https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2016/03/30/windo...
- Rafert 10y agoSupposedly it should fix the webcam issues of the previous update: https://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/windowsdesktop/en-US/9d6a8704-764f-46df-a41c-8e9d84f7f0f3/mjpg-encoded-media-type-is-not-available-for-usbuvc-webcameras-after-windows-10-version-1607-os?forum=mediafoundationdevelopment#3547e093-2178-4e04-b652-82336a03aa53 https://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/windowsdesktop/en-U...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jpambrun 10y agoI had the same issue with a previous patch. The forced update resulted in 4-5 restarts, totalling about 30 minutes, to install and then uninstall the update every two days. Needless to say, that this is a bad user experience. In the end, I had to remove GRUB, fix the MBR with the windows CD, install the update and reinstall GRUB I can dual boot. It sucked. It should not have passed QA.
- green7ea 10y agoI had this exact same issue for two seperate updates (they didn't like a dual boot - same fix as yours). This is what convinced me to finally uninstall windows.
- e40 10y agoI really think Microsoft has built themselves a house of cards. It has so many moving parts and is so complex it's very difficult to make changes to this system without edge-case errors. It makes me appreciate the simplicity of design of Linux and macOS.
- Klathmon 10y agoMacOS I'll buy, but a desktop Linux system feels more brittle than any windows install ever did. Maybe that's just my lack of knowledge with the platform outside of servers, but if you stick to the "Main" GUI screens on macOS and Windows you are pretty foot-gun safe. On Linux this is not the case, and to me its always very difficult to tell if a change you are about to make will open a Pandora's box you can't close again.
- ekianjo 10y agoNot sure what makes you say that about Desktop Linux. I moved away from Windows because the Desktop experience was horrible in the first place. Linux desktops are not perfect but you have choice, they usually have implemented ideas earlier and better than Windows and you can bet your system is going to feel more responsive, too.
- Klathmon 10y agoBrittle is really the only way I can describe it. It's the only platform where simply installing something has rendered the system non-booting, there are hundreds or more of config files and often changing one will break another system. And I fully admit this might be self-inflicted, but its been my experience. It's by no means a bad platform, but its not for me. I want a system where I need to do as little as possible to configure it, an I just want it to work. On my windows and macOS systems, I can completely wipe the machine, and be back up and running in a few hours.
- keithpeter 10y agoGood heavens, what was it that you installed!
- jakub_g 10y agoIn case you wanted to disable automatic updates on Win10 (and for some reason didn't do it yet), set your WiFi connection as metered in advanced options. This prevents from autodownloading/installing/rebooting when you just left to make yourself a coffee. You get notified when an update is available, so you can wait a few days and see if there's no news on front page of HN about update being hopelessly broken, and then you can proceed with an update. You're welcome.
- rjsw 10y agoYou can set wired connections as metered too.
- funkyy 10y agoI am afraid Windows will "fix" this whenever this gets more popular though.
- unlimit 10y agoThere is another way - disable windows update service. I use this and every month or so I enable it to update.
- fwn 10y agoI do this since Windows XP and it always worked. I don't know why so many were writing that updates can't be disabled anymore.
- vonmoltke 10y agoThe control panel setting was removed. Disabling the service entirely is an advanced and somewhat non-obvious (if you don't know update is a service to begin with) solution.
- taspeotis 10y agoI got done in by the Anniversary Update. It didn't handle certain combinations of SSDs and non-SSDs. How did not testing the "SSD for OS, mechanical for data" configuration get past QA... http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/windows_10-performance/windows-10-may-freeze-after-installing-the/5a60d75d-120a-4502-873c-8bfec65c82d0?auth=1 http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/windows_10-...
- diryawish 10y agoThank you for this, explains my issue. I wasn't sure if it was just dual boot or something else.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoAs far as I know the bug didn't hit most systems with a SSD+HDD setup, just ones where certain default paths were changed to point to the second drive (which is frequently done through unsupported registry hacks).
- taspeotis 10y agoI had Gears of War (from the Windows Store) on my HDD. This should be fully supported since changing the default locations for apps is ... built into Windows. http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/windows_10-files/cannot-change-install-location-of-apps-in-windows/fd9efca0-1b34-45de-bed9-e9b42b24aaae http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/windows_10-...
- rafaelm 10y agoI've kinda liked Windows 10 but the updates have been introducing small problems for me now. First, some update introduced a bug for me where file Explorer will sometimes not update the files when changed. For example, if I paste a file in a folder, the folder view will not show the new file until I press F5 to refresh the view. This sometimes causes Explorer yo crash. Now, after having to download the the Anniversary update three times over my crappy 1mbps connection, it's stuck in an endless reboot loop. Windows tells me to reboot to finish installing I'll reboot, it gets stuck on "Configuring update ", I have to do a hard reset and the loop starts again. Very frustrating.
- conradfr 10y agoAbout the Explorer bug, I've had it for years in Windows 7. It's inconvenient, especially when coding. The (very) short workaround is to rebuild the indexation. I'm sad to hear it is (seemingly) still present in Windows 10.
- adrianlmm 10y agoInstalled in two of my laptops w/o problems two days ago.
- AlexeyBrin 10y agoYou are confusing a fresh install, which almost always works, with upgrading a system.
- adrianlmm 10y agoThe system was upgraded,it was not a fresh install.
- AlexeyBrin 10y agoI guess you are lucky to have a hardware that is well supported by the OS.
- adrianlmm 10y agoI suppose, both of my laptops are HP.
- lucb1e 10y agoOh yeah, HP is totally in Microsoft's circle of friends. When they violated the EULA on Windows, Microsoft was like "oh but that's just a minor thing, we don't mind."
- JadeNB 10y ago> When they violated the EULA on Windows, Microsoft was like "oh but that's just a minor thing, we don't mind." When did this happen? What was the violation?
- blitzd 10y agoI'm not sure that makes a difference here, since a lot of the issues reported are with Surface devices. At my org we found that Surface+WSUS+ Anniversary Update=dead Surface... And this is just 2 weeks after they fixed the issue where the batteries would stop charging.
- AlexeyBrin 10y agoOK, so now every time Windows 10 decides it is time to force an update it becomes a kind of Sci-Fi thriller ... you watch it and watch it and hope the hero doesn't die at the end. I know people that simply disabled the Windows Update service to avoid this hassle, with the risk of ending up with a non secure system in the long run.
- 0xmohit 10y ago> it becomes a kind of Sci-Fi thriller So Windows 10 users can now have entertainment for free. Imagine the possibilities with Windows. I can only wonder what it would be like.
- ourmandave 10y agoOr watch and root for the hero to die at the end.
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoIt worked fine for me! I've had MacOS updates bork my machine and it was never News.
- oldmanhorton 10y agoI have updated three computers -- a Lenovo laptop, a surface book, and a custom desktop -- all without any issues. Its important to remember that everyone with a problem will make sure to say something, but everyone without a problem usually moves on and doesn't talk about it. Its extraordinarily easy to assume that everything is broken just because only people whom it broke for are talking about it.
- xg15 10y agoThe problem is that - as a user - there is no other way to know whether a faulty update affects a significant number of users (or even just a small group of users that you happen to be a part of) The only one with telemetry to obtain unbiased numbers is microsoft, and they might refuse to publish that data for PR reasons - or simply organisational ones. So what's a user to do?
- kyriakos 10y agoSame here I'm surprised with all these posts describing issues I never experience, either we're exceptions or people facing problems are indeed louder.
- pdkl95 10y ago> Its extraordinarily easy to assume that everything is broken Just like it's easy to assume that everything is fine. Both are fallacies where personal experience is projected on everyone. This is why it's important to have the choice to use or not use automatic updates. You cannot centrally manage the incredible complexity of all possible PC configurations and use cases; the decision about when to install updates needs to be made locally (which includes the option of deferring that choice to the vendor).
- kyriakos 10y agoEven if you could disable updates how would you know which will cause problems to your particular setup?
- 10y ago
- kyriakos 10y agoI must be an exception, I use Windows insider builds daily for development on 2 PCs (one desktop and a laptop,a quite old one too) and other than virtualbox breaking with some updates which is easily resolved by updating virtualbox itself I never had any issues.
- thomasrognon 10y agoI've never had any issues either. And with over 300 million computers on Windows 10, I'd bet people with issues are the exception, not us. People that have issues are just (rightly) vocal about it.
- davesque 10y agoI also never had any issues with Windows until this update.
- AmVess 10y agoMS has really gone downhill over the past few years with badly designed software and shockingly broken patches. The anniversary update set all the permissions in my registry so it couldn't be written to, and there was no way to fix it. On another machine, all the network interfaces vanished with no way of restoring them. These are complete show stoppers on machines I use to make money. I loaded Win8.1 on all machines and will never touch W10.
- tapirl 10y agoI really like win8.1. I dislike win10 so much, not only it contains so many bugs, but also I don't like the UI change.
- oneplane 10y agoI'd say: fork the old UI and use it instead of the new one. But that's something you'd do on Linux, not on Windows I guess...
- tapirl 10y agoThat is why I use mate desktop on debian now, for I also don't like the gnome3 UI.
- cmarschner 10y agoI must say it is the other way round for me. The latest Windows is the best release since Windows 7. Windows 8(.1) seemed like an alpha version of the current OS (I just say: power off button).
- bobbyi_settv 10y agoMaybe they think they can get away with because their only competition (MacOS) is heading in the same direction. Both OSs peaked somewhere around 2010. Since then, MS has focussed on using their desktop OS to collect data and Apple has been focussed on using their desktop OS to prop up their mobile OS.
- cdr 10y agoThe Anniversary Update completely hosed the Windows install on my desktop. It got stuck at 15% installing with the infamous spinning circle - I let it run 8 hours at 15% just to be sure because there is zero info given to you beyond the spinning circle. Then when I rebooted the machine it got stuck "Restoring previous version of Windows", again I gave it 8 hours. A third reboot and it failed to boot, forcing me to spend a couple hours fiddling with the command line tools in the recovery environment to repair the boot record. And I still have no idea why it failed, and Google has no answers either beyond vague suggestions like unplugging all USB devices before the install runs. Not looking forward to losing a day of work to it again, but not like I have a choice. How does Microsoft screw up Windows that badly? They've had 20 years to figure stuff like this out.
- analog31 10y agoI updated to Win10 on my little Bay Trail convertible thingy, which I use mainly as a tablet for web surfing. It's been fine, but an annoying feature is that the update apparently loaded Win10 into the recovery partition in addition to installing it as the main OS. So, when I did a "factory restore" after (admittedly) horribly screwing things up myself, it restored to Win10. Of course I had been very sloppy with not creating a recovery drive, etc., so I'm stuck with Win10, but it's just a thing to be aware of. That's why Linux is for people like me. I get as many chances as I want to screw things up, and recovery is just a matter of downloading an .iso and trying again.
- anjc 10y agoHaven't had a problem with Windows, ever, since installing 8 a few years back on multiple PCs.
- davesque 10y agoNeither had I actually... until this update.
- ourmandave 10y agoHere's a way to schedule Win10 updates on your schedule, not theirs. It uses the convenient and widely known Local Group Policy Editor. http://www.windowscentral.com/how-schedule-windows-updates-windows-10 http://www.windowscentral.com/how-schedule-windows-updates-w... It's really annoying when the update starts whenever it pleases and bogs the system. Watching a movie or gaming? Enjoy the stutter!
- jkot 10y agoAt this point anyone who says that Windows is easier to use than Linux, is a troll!
- kmfrk 10y agoI do some HTML-to-PDF conversion with Word every now and then, and all of a sudden, Word now offers two different ways to convert, and I have no idea which conforms to the former feature. I also had a Jekyll site break, because GitHub Pages updated its github-pages gem remotely. I totally get the advantage of auto-updates, but it's really hard to rely on any software to work the same way for a few years.
- wuschel 10y agoWhat finally scared me off MS Windows were the forced updates and the blatant spyware. I still run a MS OS from time to time: Windows 7, for some legacy software, well confined in a virtual box. Linux is an alternative the days, both for individuals and companies.