10 ms·
What 2,000 Calories Looks Like (2014)
- eumoria 10y agoThe Sonic 2000 calorie single shake is pretty nuts. I can imagine someone pairing it with a 2000+ calorie meal and not thinking they're slamming nearly 5k calories into their bodies. Although I suppose someone who drinking half a gallon of milkshake with a meal probably doesn't care. Also personally I could eat 2 burgers at shake shack with fries. Such a fatty :<
- karlshea 10y agoI don't think that's really a big problem if it's occasional. Once you're doing that a couple times a week is when it adds up.
- AJ007 10y agoIf you can consume this and not feel sick afterwards, your diet is already fucked up.
- mod 10y agoMany, many animals evolved in this fashion. Any animal that hunts. I don't think you should have a digestion problem after ingesting 4k calories.
- pjc50 10y agoIndeed. There used to be a lot more people with heavy manual jobs for whom eating 4k at a sitting was a very regular event. But they've mostly been automated away.
- justin66 10y agoYeah, but the way you're getting the calories matters. There's nothing similar about metabolizing 4000 calories worth of raw meat vs. metabolizing an enormous milkshake.
- jtuente 10y agoDoing that even once a week with a regular diet the rest of the time, someone could gain 35+ pounds per year.
- swah 10y agoAgreed, 19k calories per week vs 14k calories, say. That's a 35% increase. One would have to plan and follow their daily calorie intake very well to be able to consume that milkshake regularly...
- SonicSoul 10y agoI was once addicted to venti java chip frappuccinos. i'd have them every day (sometimes 2) which is one of my low points. So just went back to compare and that's just 500 calories! https://www.caloriecount.com/calories-starbucks-coffee-java-chip-frappuccino-i57310 https://www.caloriecount.com/calories-starbucks-coffee-java-... Kudos to Sonic for squeezing 4 times more into similar size cup. That thing must taste like a pinnacle of our culinary achievement.
- bduerst 10y agoCinnabon rolls used to have ~1,800 calories, though I think they've dialed it back to 900 now. The smell is 0 calories at least.
- madamelic 10y agoShakes are very good for exactly that. When I was recovering from anorexia, I got a large milkshake every night. Milkshakes are really, really easy ways to get enormous amounts of calories into yourself.
- komali2 10y agoTo be fair, avoiding the fries and shake (or chips and coke or what have you) seems to cut 50% or more of the calories. 760 calories on a burger is a fine portion. Then again, the macro ratio is probably not where you want it if you're counting that sort of thing.
- ng12 10y agoThe macros on a burger are actually pretty good. Lots of protein, lots of fat, 30-40 carbs. In-n-Out was one of my post workout go-to's when I was really paying attention to my diet.
- croon 10y agoThe McDouble has been touted as well as a !/$ macro comp [1]. [1]: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/foodanddrink/10210327/McDouble-is-cheapest-and-most-nutritious-food-in-human-history.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/foodanddrink/10210327/McDouble-is...
- spicytunacone 10y agoI'd be careful with that claim. Looking at the nutritional info on the In-N-Out website[0], I wouldn't say the macros are pretty good at all. Let's take the Double Double which clocks in at 670 total calories, a decently sized meal as the parent comment would suggest. Double Double Total Calories: 670 [520 Protein® Style (lettuce for bun)] Fats: 41g (18g from saturated fats) * 9 = 369 calories, ~55% [~68%] Carbs: 39g * 4 = 156 calories, ~23% [~7%] Protein: 37g * 4 = 148 calories, ~22% [~25%] For comparison, Cheeseburger Total Calories: 480 [330 Protein® Style] Fats: 27g (10g from saturated fats) * 9 = 243 calories, ~50% [~68%] Carbs: 39g * 4 = 156 calories, ~32% [~13%] Protein: 22g (a normal Hamburger is only 16g) * 4 = 88 calories, ~18% [~22%, total calories using my crude calculations adds up to 341] Now, I realize arguing about ratios is about as good as arguing about editors, but, for bulking, I'd rather scarf down some milk and I still think that's a tad extreme (its ratios come to about 30% fat/45% carbs/25% protein even at a quarter gallon for a comparable 632 calories)[1][2]. As for cutting to preserve lean mass, it's definitely not something you can easily put into your day without some prior planning or fallback options. Personally a Double Double would put me at only slightly north of 1kcal allowance on a cut, and I'd need to get another >~100g protein to come near my goals. Obviously I'm not saying someone can't enjoy a burger every so often, but I wouldn't suggest they compose model macros for most purposes. 0: http://www.in-n-out.com/nutrition.aspx http://www.in-n-out.com/nutrition.aspx 1: https://fitness.stackexchange.com/questions/3967/weight-gained-using-gomad-strategy https://fitness.stackexchange.com/questions/3967/weight-gain... 2: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1/4+gallon+milk http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1/4+gallon+milk tldr: amateur bodybuilder (me) doesn't think fast-food burgers are particularly great on their own, even for gaining mass. If you're a non-bodybuilder/don't care about macros, just watch the sodium and saturated fats if anything.
- hasenj 10y agoWhy isn't there an outcry to regulate the fast food industry to prevent this kind of thing from happening? This is one of the biggest issues in North America.
- DanBC 10y agoThe easy and obvious first target would be a sugar tax on large serving sodas. That doesn't seem to be so popular in the US for some reason.
- mars4rp 10y agonot only on large serving sodas, there is sugar in %80 of stuff you can buy in supermarkets !!!!
- DanBC 10y agoBut if we can't even tax large serving sodas there's no hope of taxing anything else. They're the best example of empty pointless calories, and safe alternatives (water, sugar free sodas) already exist.
- mason240 10y agoIt would be more effective and efficient to just put a tax right on sugar commodities. Add something like a 30% tax with the intention of driving the price up.
- tormeh 10y agoYep. Just tax the sugar and most of the problems go away. It sounds too simple to be true, but I think it could be true.
- logfromblammo 10y agoImposing any tax (or subsidy) with a primary purpose of changing public behavior is not acceptable to me. It's arrogant and patronizing, and turns what would otherwise be objective facts into topics for lobbying and political debate. If you want to sway people, do it with information, not by charging them extra for doing what is wrong in your opinion. While I would never support a "sugary foods" consumer tax, I might support a uniform tax on the purchase price of all restaurant foods, that would specifically support objective dietary and nutrition science, public education campaigns on how to obtain nutritious meals at any income level, publicly queryable tracking of food items from farms to tables, random testing of restaurant foods as served to the end-consumer, and more effective nutrition labels for prepackaged foods and restaurant menu items. If you fund objective research on what people should eat (and why) by taxing what they do eat, the information alone should be sufficient to help people choose healthier meals on their own, rather than by twisting their arms with existing biases and assumptions. I personally believe (without objective data to back it up) that excessive dietary sugars, particularly those containing fructose, are the most blameworthy single factor for American obesity, and that this is due in part to steep import tariffs on foreign-produced crystalline sucrose, farming subsidies and favors to domestic corn, beet, and cane producers, the price differential between high-fructose corn syrup and crystalline sucrose, the weakly-supported demonization of dietary fats, and the slow decline of real median-household purchasing power since the 1970s. In other words, we got to where we are now by pushing people around with overly-specific taxation and politically-influenced dietary recommendations.
- pashapiro 10y agoOne of the things I wonder about is how many calories your body can actually metabolize into fat and glycogen in a given day. For example, if you eat 15,000 calories, how many of those calories will your body just pass right through your digestive tract? I could see liquid calories like pop or juice being metabolized easily, but do all the beans in a Chipotle burrito end up clinging on your thighs and gut also?
- jlebrech 10y agoyour body's ability to metabolize will increase too as you eat more. that's why skinny people who eat massively for a single meal once a week don't really gain weight, it's the regular over eating that does it.
- mod 10y agoI don't think that's why. Those people would gain weight, but it's hard to "massively overeat" for one week to the tune of "noticeable amount." You're talking 1 lb, maybe 2 if you really go overboard.
- mikeash 10y agoA pound of fat is about 3,500 calories of overeating. Real hard to do that much in one sitting for someone who doesn't do it constantly.
- DanBC 10y agoI'd be interested to see the results of independent lab testing to see what the actual calorie values are. Some companies consistently under-report calories.
- mod 10y agoAt home we picked diet soda and water to drink? Why didn't we do that when we were out?
- projektir 10y agoIndeed. I do sometimes get a milkshake or an alcoholic drink, but most of the time I just drink water at restaurants.
- logfromblammo 10y agoAt home I make beverages with stevia and erythritol sweeteners. When I go out, about everything non-caloric is sweetened with aspartame, sucralose, and acesulfame-potassium. Also, I don't like kola-flavored or caffeinated beverages, and very often the only "diet" option is a cola. Because of that, I either drink water or the HFCS-sweetened beverages when I'm out. Some restaurants get snotty when you order water. That's probably because fountain drinks are a huge profit center, and corporate accounting leans on managers, who in turn lean on line employees, whenever the break-even or loss-leading entrees outnumber fountain-drink cups by too wide a margin.
- ashark 10y agoYeah, drinkable desserts (soda, milk/ice cream drinks) seemed to be best intersection between "easy to address" and "removing would cause a major calorie reduction" in their fast food picks. The food portions wouldn't have looked quite so small if they'd bumped those up to account for cutting that crap. Then again maybe they were going for the typical order, which I'm sure does include a giant soda or shake.
- jlebrech 10y agoif you eat like this 3 meals a day is probably too much. your BMR is covered by a single meal.
- jlebrech 10y agosubway does look like 2.5 meals tho.
- jonathanberger 10y agoYes. We all know (and the article starts out saying) most adults need 2000 calories a day. But then we see pictures of what most would consider one meal, and since we have 2 - 3 meals a day, eating any of these actually leaves you with 4000 - 6000 calories a day. Wouldn't it have been more instructive if this article showed pictures of meals that were 700 - 1000 calories?
- kowdermeister 10y ago2000 calories is a lot, I try to limit myself around 1000 / day. This is no way a golden rule, I just figured it out a few years ago. I'm pretty much done with eating for the day with a tactical kebab from the turkish guys. Off: why is this on the front page? Anyone else hungry? :)
- jlebrech 10y ago1000 calories of what? are you sure you're not counting 1000 and getting the rest in hidden calories?
- kowdermeister 10y agoEnergy :) I know not all calories are made equal, but I really don't care, I mix meat + vegetables + various carbon hydrates. I get most of the extra calories via alcohol, beer mostly.
- jlebrech 10y agooh, I see. the "make room for alcohol" diet :)
- projektir 10y agoUnless you are female and tiny and engage in no physical activity whatsoever that's a dangerously low calorie intake. You're probably not counting your calories right...
- kowdermeister 10y agoMale, ~85kg, and yes, little physical activity other than typing :) 1000 is fine, really. I had two coffees today, and some pasta + pesto, I think I'm still below 1000. http://imgur.com/a/ayFgF http://imgur.com/a/ayFgF
- projektir 10y ago
- jimmytidey 10y agoBe interested to see the same article for the UK. How a fry up measure up? 5 pints and a kebab?
- arethuza 10y agoI hate to think what some of our culinary "specialities" here in Scotland would come out as? Deep fried battered pizza? Deep fried battered white puddings? [NB A white pudding is pretty much a savoury porridge sausage]. Butteries - which are basically 140% fat. (And delicious). I'm now wondering if anyone has tried deep fried battered butteries....
- robin_reala 10y agoNot a buttery, but there is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep-fried_butter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep-fried_butter
- jimmytidey 10y agoAll washed down with larger and fags. Isn't there a part of Glasgow where life expectancy is 54?
- brianmcc 10y agos/larger/buckie/
- DonaldFisk 10y agoCalton: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calton,_Glasgow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calton,_Glasgow
- logfromblammo 10y agoI thought Scots were supposed to drink Irn Bru or whisky with everything.
- pjc50 10y agoI'm fond of a "munchy box", eaten over the course of two days. The buttery is lovely, it's basically an all butter croissant that someone couldn't be bothered to roll up.
- tbabb 10y agoThe results at starbucks really make me think that we should mandate visible calorie counts for food establishments. No need to regulate calories directly, just inform people about what they're eating and let behavior follow.
- trisomy21 10y agoI fully agree. I've found this to be quite common in NYC now which has already had positive impacts for me. For example, just yesterday a friend wanted to grab a smoothie and after looking at the caloric values, I ended up making a selection that had at least half the calories I would have consumed had I just gone by ingredient listing alone. Smoothies can be deceptive!
- DanBC 10y agoThey'd need to be accurate labels though. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hE2lna5Wxuo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hE2lna5Wxuo
- Fricken 10y agoMost overweight people I know are keenly aware of how many calories they're consuming, they just can't help themselves. I don't know how someone can drink a extra large milkshake without feeling like they just dropped a bomb on their digestive system. When it comes down to it, you need to be in tune with your body. If you need a nutrition label to know whether or not you're feeding yourself right, you're already in trouble.
- nsxwolf 10y agoWe're already doing it in many places, it's mandated by the FDA for certain establishments like McDonald's. And all we hear about is Americans getting fatter and fatter. So maybe we could chill with the paternalism? When I moved out of the house I was done with having parents tell me what to do.
- sgift 10y agoIf a piece of information is telling you what to do that's your own problem. Other people may actually prefer it when they have are able to make informed decisions.
- anotherarray 10y agoThis is a fairly biased article. It is possible to have a healthy calorie consumption with fast food. During college, I was able to compete in a natural bodybuilding competition by mostly eating like this. It's all about what you choose to eat. No matter where you are.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoYeah, the fact that they included a zero-calorie soda and black coffee in the "home" meal is so heavy handed. They could've included a diet soda in any of the other meals, but they didn't. How insulting. The author has neither respect for their readers, nor apparently belief that their editorial thesis stands on its own merits.
- adrr 10y agoMost things on the dollar menu are 300 to 400 calories. 3 meals with 2 items and you're hitting around 2k calories while only spending $6 a day. Just need to give up the soda and the snacks.
- rayiner 10y agoSeriously. I don't think I could even eat a whole Chipotle burrito and also guacamole and chips. Chipotle has a lot of filling lunches under 500 calories. My go tos when I was young was a salad with chicken, guacamole, cheese, and salsa. The soft tacos with just meat, veggies, and cheese also keep you under 500.
- kj01a 10y agoIt looks like the really had to try hard to get that Chipotle burrito to fit into the 2000 cal. I've never seen a Chipotle burrito that small.
- fu9ar 10y agoRiiiiiight, a splash of coke in a cup full of ice is 400 calories? I commute by bike every day and lift weights a couple times a week. 2000 calories would be a starvation diet. Fucking Puritans.
- pugio 10y agoI've been using variations on the following smoothie recipe for years. Works great for nutrition, energy, and is really easy to make. As an added bonus, for focused work, it's really easy to sip while coding and doesn't require those flow-busting lunch or snack breaks. 1 can coconut milk/cream (thick) - 920 calories 1 c plain coconut milk - 45 calories 1 banana - 105 calories 1 c blueberries - 85 calories 2 c plain yogurt - 300 calories 2x scoop whey protein - 220 calories 2x serving 100% baking chocolate - 160 calories 2c spinach - 14 calories 2-3 tomato - ~60 calories Total: 1909 calories
- exhilaration 10y agoSo that (and probably water) is all you'd eat and drink in a single day?
- pugio 10y agoSometimes. I usually have 3-4 eggs in butter along with some more veggies. If I'm active, then a handful of nuts or two. Occasionally (due to cost) some grass fed ground beef stir fried in avocado oil. The smoothie counts for breakfast and lunch. The eggs, for dinner, take ~5 minutes to make. All simple, easy, healthy foods.
- mathgeek 10y ago1909 calories is going to be a caloric deficit for most people in the West
- jlebrech 10y agobut what about flow busting toilet breaks?
- pugio 10y agoYMMV. One could argue that's just compounded flow ;) My body conveniently schedules those breaks at the very ends of the day. Rarely an issue.
- deleted 10y ago
- projektir 10y agoI don't know if fast food is really a problem per se. Getting a lot of calories from a restaurant visit is quite expected. That's why you do it occasionally and it's often your entire meal for the day. Like the article says, whether it's a fancy steakhouse or Burger King doesn't really matter. And fancy steakhouses existed for a while, though. I do, though, think that the US has a problem with portion sizes. A lot of the time, any given meal is just way too large for me. I just don't really like to eat that much per sitting and sometimes I can get filled up on appetizers and I really wish there were smaller portion options in addition to the larger portion options at more places and I wouldn't waste money by plain not being able to finish the food. Especially if I would have been perfectly happy being able to have a small plate, then a small desert, and a drink, instead of one giant plate that leaves room for nothing else. Having a somewhat warped portion size may mess with peoples' heads, especially those who want to get the most for their money. It doesn't help that the bigger portions are often only marginally more expensive. Even worse for women and children, who should be eating less in general. That being said, I'm not really convinced the obesity epidemic is not a consequence of the average human syndrome and mental health issues and that the fast food industry isn't simply capitalizing on that as opposed to causing it. I think counting calories and lamenting how people are not doing this or that is missing the point.
- dpark 10y ago> and it's often your entire meal for the day. I don't know anyone who only eats one meal on days they go to restaurants. For most people, going to a restaurant for a meal simply means they eat more in total that day. > I do, though, think that the US has a problem with portion sizes. ... I really wish there were smaller portion options in addition to the larger portion options at more places and I wouldn't waste money by plain not being able to finish the food. The problem is that it's not much cheaper to serve smaller portions. That's why when restaurants have half portions they still cost 75+% of the bigger portion. As you noted, people want to "get their money's worth", so restaurants give them absurdly large portions rather than charge 20% less for half as much food and have patrons complain about getting so little food.
- projektir 10y ago
- dropit_sphere 10y agoMan, as someone trying to gain weight, this article was kind of depressing. Sure you can get a ton of calories if you add a bunch of carbs or fat, but do you know how much stuff you have to eat to get a caloric surplus on a protein-based diet, without the addictiveness of carbs? Pretty much any time you think of it, it's time for some milk/peanut butter sandwich/hard-boiled egg/spinach. I know, I know, first-world problems. But the corollary to "it's so easy to get fat eating junk" is "it's surprisingly hard to get big eating well."
- morley 10y agoSeveral people have mentioned trying to follow Dwayne Johnson's diet, and they end up spending all their time (and a substantial amount of their money) preparing chicken and cod. http://www.muscleandfitness.com/nutrition/meal-plans/smell-what-rock-cooking http://www.muscleandfitness.com/nutrition/meal-plans/smell-w...
- harveywi 10y agoThe trick is to cook all the food en masse, in one fell swoop, maybe once or twice per week.
- gthtjtkt 10y agoThe trick is to be a millionaire and hire a personal chef. Not to mention a plethora of PEDs so you can grow enough muscle to burn all those calories.
- another_account 10y agoAnd the consistent hours and hours of hard work in the gym. Day in, day out. A lot of which was before he was a millionaire. Im also pretty sure he does most of his own cooking. The current Mr Olympia, Phil Heath, certainly does. Diet > Training > Meal timing / cycling etc > Drugs.
- 10y ago
- zackmorris 10y agoI spent so much of my life trying to make rent that some part of me read the article backwards - looking for the densest meals for the buck. Burger Kings seems like a pretty good value in a pinch. If eating out triggered the obesity epidemic, then working long hours for poverty wages (or cost of living outpacing incomes) surely exacerbated things.
- mikeash 10y agoI find that restaurants listing calories on their menus can make it harder for me to watch what I eat for just this reason. I see a 600 calorie meal for $10 and a 1000 calorie meal for $10 and I feel like I'm getting a bad deal if I don't take the second one. Intellectually I know that I have no trouble affording it either way and regulating my intake is much more important for me, but it can be tough to overcome.
- xedarius 10y agoWhat is not obvious from some of the photos (in particular the Cheesecake factory chicken) is how big the portion sizes are.
- TranceMan 10y agoOff topic - Paywall link? [Also not working for me in incognito mode - and can't remember the last time I deliberately click on a nytimes link] and the web link doesn't work?
- rayiner 10y agoThe article reminds me why I'm always pretty skeptical of the "eat good food" angle. The TV dinner generation (1950s-1980s) didn't have the same problem with obesity. My pet theory is "calorie inflation." Coffee and a donut for breakfast isn't "good food" but it's probably 250-300 calories. A Starbucks latte and pastry is easily double that.
- tomatsu 10y ago> The TV dinner generation (1950s-1980s) didn't have the same problem with obesity. Subsidizing corn -> way too much corn -> dirt cheap sugar (HFCS) is a fairly new problem. Today's processed food contains too much sugar, because it's the cheapest way to add some taste. The "low fat" and "no fat" variations, where fat is often replaced by sugar, also made things much worse.
- philfrasty 10y agoShameless plug for anyone interested: I have a (German) healthy-food channel on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/user/CookedAndShredded/videos https://www.youtube.com/user/CookedAndShredded/videos No processed foods used. No supplements. Just real food.
- pdog 10y agoI'll answer for them. None. It's just another fad diet, no less ridiculous than any other.
- ethanbond 10y agoExcept for the long, long, long history of well established medical benefits from cutting out carbs. http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/mind-guest-blog/the-fat-fueled-brain-unnatural-or-advantageous/ http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/mind-guest-blog/the-fat-... Besides the plain fact that you can't "answer for [someone else]" when the question is about their body's reaction to certain things. I personally don't deal with carbs well, which is probably related to the diabetes that runs rampant through my family despite myself not having it. You know how there are probably foods that you like that others don't? Or that others like and you don't? Some people simply don't like consuming carbohydrates. Not because they have any disease (real nor imagined), but simply because they don't like it. It seems like you take a personal affront to people eating how they prefer to eat. Could I ask why you care? Historically speaking, in fact, the uber carb-rich diets that dominate developed western culture is the real fad. Never before have humans ingested carbohydrates in the proportion that your average American does today. > Although dairy products, cereals, refined sugars, refined vegetable oils, and alcohol make up 72.1% of the total daily energy consumed by all people in the United States, these types of foods would have contributed little or none of the energy in the typical preagricultural hominin diet (20). Additionally, mixtures of foods listed in Table 1⇓ make up the ubiquitous processed foods (eg, cookies, cake, bakery foods, breakfast cereals, bagels, rolls, muffins, crackers, chips, snack foods, pizza, soft drinks, candy, ice cream, condiments, and salad dressings) that dominate the typical US diet. http://m.ajcn.nutrition.org/content/81/2/341.full http://m.ajcn.nutrition.org/content/81/2/341.full
- M_Grey 10y agoFrom that blog, "While promising, large-scale placebo-controlled clinical trials in patients with neurological disorders are still lacking." That's the opposite of "well established medical benefits", and is more in line with, "Lots of gaps to find your god in!"
- adamwong246 10y agoor you could have 5 Soylents. Problem solved.
- doodpants 10y agoI clicked the link just to see if it would be an article about Soylent, since it comes in 2000-calorie pouches.