26 ms·
Twitter may receive formal bid, suitors said to include Salesforce and Google
- WA 10y agoStock is through the roof right now. About +19%
- kelukelugames 10y agoOh good. Just 30% off from when I first bought in.
- the_duke 10y agoUnclear is what kind of "deal" they are talking about. A considerable buy in? A full acquisition? And, assuming a full acquisition... what would be the gain? Google has a bad story with attempts at social media, apart from YouTube. (Bought Orkut, killed it, tried Google Plus, went nowhere). Twitter is hard to make profitable without alienating the users with too many ads. For Google, it would probably be an acquisition like YouTube. With the knowledge that it might never be profitable, but intended to get control over a significant asset. But sharing Google infrastructure and resources could probably bring down operating costs in the medium term. We'll see.
- andybak 10y agoIf it's Google then cue endless jokes about shutting it down. I'm not saying they don't have some issues with their corporate attention span but I do get sick of that one being wheeled out without any real insight or cause.
- koolba 10y ago> If it's Google then cue endless jokes about shutting it down. Haha. That'd be the world's funniest acquihire.
- gdulli 10y agoGoogle wasn't given that reputation randomly or casually. They earned it through their actions and they deserve the consequences. People who don't know the pattern deserve to be educated about it. I weaned myself from Twitter when they added the algorithmic timeline but if I hadn't, I'd begin doing it now and I would be better off for starting it now at my own pace than later, forced to abruptly.
- andybak 10y agoThe point is everyone knows the pattern and it's not adding anything further to the conversation to keep repeating it. It's no better than parroting "Embrace Extend Extinguish" every single time Microsoft are mentioned.
- gdulli 10y agoEveryone knows because it gets pointed out and discussed, like this. It's myopic to assume that everyone is as old as you are and has been paying attention for as long as you have. There are people who are younger or newer to the Google ecosystem for whom it's not common knowledge.
- wlesieutre 10y agoBought Orkut, killed it, tried Google Plus, went nowhere > Don't forget Buzz! That time when they default opted-in Gmail users into publishing a list of frequently contacted users on their google profile. Auto-follow was a terrible terrible idea.
- giarc 10y agoAnd Wave.
- pmalynin 10y agoWave was too ahead of its time. Bots in channels that could translate and issue arbitrary actions? In 2009? Nonsense.
- wlesieutre 10y agoI really liked Wave. It came out when I was in college and moving into an off-campus apartment with two other guys. We used it to coordinate who was bringing what (to not end up with 50 pots and three sets of chairs), and being able to have reply threads in the middle of a previous post was a great format for that sort of small group discussion.
- abz10 10y agoIt was not ahead of its time, it was poorly executed. People didn't know what to make of it. That is the designers fault. They needed to relate it to existing ideas and beat those ideas at their own game, even if that mean restricting what it can do to familiar domains. Then over time they can evolve it while taking the users along with them. Instead people bounced off it and decided to wait it out to see if they really needed it and it turns out they didn't. Spereately, I think it's hilarious that many websites pester hard for emails, making them effectively pamphlets for their email content. If only there was a way that I could subscribe (and unsubscribe) to a stream of short notifications from content creators and be confident that I see all of them in a timeline order. Like what Twitter used to be before they screwed with the timeline. They're going to lose to email, and not for being ahead of their time.
- joobus 10y agoHow is a company which "might never be profitable" considered a "significant asset"?!
- brazzledazzle 10y agoI assume it's because another company is in a position to capitalize on it in ways Twitter alone could not.
- dpflan 10y agoAs a social network, this is probably valuable to Google's Ad business - gives more dimensions to a Google user if you link your Twitter account with Google account...just guessing ATM.
- falcolas 10y agoThere's a lot of signal to be had in Twitter, signal which can be (and has been) turned into revenue not directly gained from it's users or advertisers. Remember the story about Dataminr and its Government contracts?
- adventured 10y agoThe same thing was said about YouTube because of its immense costs of operations and the fact that few/nobody had figured out how to do a good job monetizing video advertising at that point. Google being the ad monster that it is, could significantly boost Twitter's business and they could slash the operating costs very considerably. Twitter should be solidly profitable at $3-$4 billion in sales (which Google could deliver).
- the_duke 10y agoMoney isn't everything. YouTube is a hugely popular service, driving lots of data, traffic and brand image towards Google. Could be the same for Twitter.
- daveguy 10y agoI'm not sure if brand image is something YouTube gives Google. I honestly don't think the general public knows that YouTube is a part of Google. YouTube seems like its own separate thing to the casual user. It would be interesting to see a poll of the general public. But the data. The data is key. They have rocked image recognition and video is a huge data source for their ML efforts.
- berns 10y ago> Bought Orkut, killed it, tried Google Plus, went nowhere Add Jaiku.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaiku https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaiku
- muse900 10y agoSorry I don't think youtube is profitable by itself and sustainable. Although its the biggest video platform in the world attracting 1/3 of the worlds population to it. I think the data itself that can be gathered via youtube are profitable for google and google's purpose really (AI). If they buy twitter it won't be because they can turn it into being sustainable itself but because they can make it profitable for them and not in money. Personally I don't think that google has a money issue and I think for them its easier to value data more as a currency.
- the_duke 10y agoI said that they probably bought it with the assumption that it might never be profitable. As far as public information goes, Youtube is most likely not.
- dvdcxn 10y ago>Twitter is hard to make profitable without alienating the users with too many ads. TBH I don't think google would buy Twitter with the expectation of making money off of it. Its value is its continued data gathering, which would inform other google products.
- bdcravens 10y agoThis, and perhaps a deeper integration in Android.
- mzw_mzw 10y agoIf Google buys Twitter and then kills it, we should mint them a freaking medal for services to humanity.
- fideloper 10y agoI wouldn't blame Jack one bit for wanting to get back to Square full-time (not that it's necessarily fully his decision to sell).
- MollyR 10y agoI really can't see salesforce buying twitter. I think a social media giant would gain something from twitter, but not much else.
- calpaterson 10y agoI think it would be stupid too but the article does contain an executive being fairly direct about wanting it and why.
- MollyR 10y agoYea I read that, but I don't see how it really benefits Salesforce. I can see why the executive likes it.
- mattwg 10y agoI think it makes a bit of sense. For a lot of companies Twitter is already a major point of customer interaction and retention. Maybe Salesforce feels like they could monetize that aspect of Twitter, with the advantage that a ton of consumers are already there and using it.
- abz10 10y agoIt will introduce a conflict of interest, where the side that has is paying Twitter. The perception alone of a conflict means people will 'find' it all over the place and those examples to their bias until slowly and gradually no one will trust the service anymore. Even if Twitter never changes anything.
- dennyabraham 10y agoIt could enhance and supersede Salesforce's already existing Chatter product (an internal social newsfeed).
- EternalBeginner 10y agoWhat if the social media giant is wondering about its own shelf life?
- nvk 10y agoTwitter should be a public utility.
- overcast 10y agoIt is a public utility.
- nvk 10y agoit's a "private" utility. But I take your point. If they remove all the fat making a tweet page 5mb it could be hosted for nearly nothing by some FOSS org.
- Jtsummers 10y agoExcept for all the backend connecting each user's messages to their followers. That's no mean feat. And certainly would cost more than "nearly nothing".
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoYes, Twitter's backend is actually quite sophisticated. It's one thing to build a very small Twitter clone for you and your friends, it's quite another to scale that up to hundreds of millions of users and keep everything running smoothly.
- overcast 10y agoBut that's exactly what is what as the beginning. Twitter spent a significant amount of its early days sitting on the Fail Whale screen. Sure, now it's stable, when you throw a complete rewrite, and millions of dollars at it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- hornbaker 10y agoMy bet is GOOG. They need a streaming newsfeed product in which to insert ads.
- asendra 10y agoAlso, better youtube commenting system?
- hood_syntax 10y ago> better youtube Two words that probably won't be said about any feature Google creates. They seemed determined to kill the platform.
- 0x37 10y agoWhat is this inane trend here on HN of referring to companies with the names they are registered to stock exhange?
- hornbaker 10y agoMy bet is GOOG. They need a streaming newsfeed product in which to insert ads, especially on mobile where FB is killing it.
- rrggrr 10y agoGOOG has to buy TWTR or its real-time web ambitions are dead. FB has to buy TWTR to prevent GOOG real-time entry. AAPL has to buy TWTR or be cut out from social media. MSFT too. The bidding war that is going on behind the scenes must be unreal. This acquistion may be the biggest ever.
- lcnmrn 10y agoThere are better alternatives to Twitter out there. It’s time for everybody to move on.
- mikeycgto 10y agoSuch as?
- wanda 10y agoParent post's product, Sublevel, would make for a nice public communication utility. Unfortunately, while I like it, it's definitely not going in the same direction as Twitter and is not likely to match everybody's idea of a social network. While its current members, myself included, like it for its simplicity and lack of embellishment, it is precisely because it comes with fewer features and deliberate design choices against janky embedded media, it does not and likely will not represent a Twitter alternative for the vast majority of Twitter users. Sublevel could however be made into an interesting, social-first alternative to Pinboard. If Sublevel were for sale, that's likely what I'd do with it, offering an archive utility to save HTML where duplicate content is only saved once and blindly shared among users to conserve space. Then stick an incrementally increasing price tag on membership like Pinboard. Maybe membership tiers. I remember as well numerous decentralised alternatives to Twitter like Diaspora and Twister IIRC. Twitter is horrible to use and would benefit from a complete rethink in terms of UI, maybe something along the lines of Opera Coast.
- daveid 10y agoGNU social [1], Mastodon* [2] There is a set of standartized web protocols called Webfinger, ActivityStreams, Salmon and PubSubHubbub which allow websites to interact with each other as a sort of decentralized/federated Twitter (this is called the "fediverse"). [1]: https://gnu.io/social https://gnu.io/social [2]: https://github.com/Gargron/mastodon https://github.com/Gargron/mastodon Disclaimer: I'm working on Mastodon, it's a new open source implementation, I'm trying to make it more approachable to people who value UX and maintainability
- 10y ago
- yalogin 10y agoIt doesn't matter it would still not cover my losses in the stock. Talk about crappy decisions.
- owenwil 10y agoGoogle acquiring Twitter is actually the best end result here. Salesforce is probably the worst. Lots of people hate the idea of a Google acquisition, but I think it's well suited because: - Google learnt from its mistakes with Google+ and is eager to not repeat them - The company is a very different one now from years ago - Google doesn't want to mess up identity again, so that wouldn't be an issue - Google mostly just wants a social graph - Twitter is a bad public company that makes irrational decisions - Merging Google engineering/leadership with Twitter might actually give direction and ease the financial pressure that seems to drive the company's poor engineering decisions
- taeric 10y agoGoogle learned from Google+? Where is the evidence? Also, Twitter is unprofitable, but my understanding was that they were heavily trusted by the public.
- refulgentis 10y agoThere's copious evidence that's public, look for how it's talked about externally. I think you're substituting a particular group of Twitter users for the public - the general perception is Twitter is full of hateful trolls and management can't be bothered to control them.
- exergy 10y agoI would have said that the de-integration of Google+ from YouTube was a good example of them learning from their mistakes, except fucking Allo shows that they're still rather clueless about a lot of things related to people communicating online.
- lmm 10y agoI still get prompted to "upgrade" to Google+ every time I launch a game on my phone.
- taeric 10y ago
- dcgudeman 10y agoBy Salesforce?? RIP twitter.
- ceejayoz 10y agoC'mon, no one knows how to run indefinitely at a loss than Salesforce...
- staticautomatic 10y agoIndeed. They've never turned a profit either, right? I still can't fathom how/why they're sinking half a billion dollars into that new building in downtown SF.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rch 10y agoWhy no mention of Oracle? That's a more likely acquirer than Salesforce. Other Oracle acquisitions: Datastax, push.io, Collective Intellect, etc.
- nkassis 10y agoHas Oracle shown an interest? But like Salesforce, why would Oracle they be interested? I may be missing something but it is not at all obvious how twitter is related to the type of thing those two companies are currently doing.
- wslh 10y agoIs it logical to buy Twitter at $ 16B? I think it is too expensive considering a lot of their actual users are bots.
- draw_down 10y agoA lot of everyone's users are bots.
- aikah 10y agoAmazon or Facebook . It would make sense for the latter as it is its only real competitor.
- jbverschoor 10y agoFacebookgot big by copying the twitter timeline. They won't buy them. Not for the product, not for the team
- alex_hitchins 10y agoMight sound strange, but I think this would be a great purchase for Apple. They have the cash, they certainly have the engineers and UI skills it desperately needs. iMessage working brilliantly, but closer integration with a Twitter style feed makes real sense to me.
- __abc 10y agoActually, with the new iMessages app platform I wish all my Twitter conversations moved to iMessages. If Apple buys Twitter, that would be personally awesome.
- protomyth 10y agoI can only imagine what Apple will do with censorship given their app guidelines and general attitude towards editing their own user forums. Ping wasn't such a hit either.
- deepfriedbits 10y agoTwitter's real value to Google is real-time search, in my opinion. They already license results from Twitter for search results, but having access to all of that sweet, sweet real-time data is nice. The social graph is nice, but between Chrome and Gmail, Google already knows quite a bit about everyone.
- majani 10y agoBad idea. I think the social networks who's main purpose is to feed into people's vanity will not stand the test of time since they're not solving a real problem and are merely novelties.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoCan someone actually explain to me how the situation came to this point where it practically looks as if Twitter's fate is being decided and played out in the media via endless speculation? It is not like Twitter is a tiny company with an unknown brand, few users and no possibility of improving its profit margins. I am not aware of what they are trying to do, but at the same time it is not as if they could have exhausted all the possibilities. Remember Facebook's beacon? That failed, but FB still managed to repackage the same crap into something more lucrative didn't it? Is this just impatience from stockholders? For example, let us just say, hypothetically, something really damaging comes out about FB (e.g. the news about the fake video view metrics) and advertisers start fleeing from it. Wouldn't Twitter be the beneficiary of at least some of that exodus? Do they really have no option of an end game?
- poopsintub 10y agoFacebook was due to flop after going public also, but they have managed quarter after quarter of user growth and profits. Twitter has been public about a year less and investors (3 years) are getting antsy because it can't turn a profit, user growth has dropped to very little, people are tweeting far less, and they don't have any glimpse of monetizing what they have. The main thing is that people invest in a companies growth and betting on future profits, but there isn't any. Hence the stock price, and bringing back Dorsey to try and save the company. Facebook tanking into MySpace wouldn't impact Twitter when they can't turn a profit on the hundreds of millions of users they already have.
- jldugger 10y ago> Can someone actually explain to me how the situation came to this point where it practically looks as if ... Is this just impatience from stockholders? Money doesn't grow on trees, and Facebook has lost a half billion dollars every year. They have maybe four years left at that rate before they run out of cash on hand. The numbers are improving by about 20 percent a year, which, if projected forward, means they'll stop losing money in ... four years. I don't think it's impatience to question if your investment will go bankrupt or not. Impatience was taking the company public before it was profitable. > For example, let us just say, hypothetically, something really damaging comes out about FB (e.g. the news about the fake video view metrics) and advertisers start fleeing from it. Wouldn't Twitter be the beneficiary of at least some of that exodus? Do they really have no option of an end game? Why would you invest in Twitter if the only reason to expect a positive outcome was if Facebook horribly fucked up?
- imagist 10y agoIMO, Twitter is the poster child for the tech bubble. They have users, which is their only claim to viability, but notably, they have never made a profit. Currently valued at around $10 billion with 350 million active users, that's about $29 per user. You'd be hard-pressed to find an investor so foolish that they would invest $29 in each of their users and hope to make it back if it were stated in those terms, but people have rushed to invest in a company which only has users, and whose attempts to monetize users through advertising have correlated strongly with loss of users. There can be little argument that Twitter's price has become entirely detached from its value. That doesn't of course, mean you couldn't make money by investing in Twitter. You can make money by investing in overvalued companies as long as you don't hold onto your share until it busts. One profitable route would be if Twitter does get bought by a larger company. The market as a whole will lose on Twitter, but local maxima can be more profitable than the whole. But at a personal level, don't be naive about this. A lot of people are investing, not just money, but time and energy, in Twitter or startups like Twitter. If you find yourself thinking that Twitter is a company with any real value, you should take a step back and evaluate whether you're being wise, or whether you've fallen prey to the unbridled optimism of the tech bubble. Twitter's position as poster child for the tech bubble makes it a good litmus test for people's understanding of the industry, and I suspect it will correlate very strongly with who loses everything when the tech bubble collapses.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoYour comment actually sort of explains the question I asked. Would you still maintain this view if either a) advertisers reduce their spend on FB because of poor results and the usual problem with saturation of any advertising channel and start looking at other options, or b) more events play out in the future where Twitter's place as the "other social network that people actually care about" becomes more important/relevant - e.g. one more mass hysteria event surrounding some censorship from FB, or c) anything happens to block FB from being able to show ads inside WhatsApp?
- imagist 10y agoIn the long run, I don't think that Twitter's problem is one of competition from FB or any other competitor. They have enough users that they could turn a profit even if they could monetize those users, regardless of competition. But they haven't turned a profit, which after 10 years is a strong indicator that they can't turn a profit. If Twitter is able to time an addition of ads with a major event that damages FB's user base, the influx of users from FB might cancel out the loss of users from the addition of ads, and Twitter might be able to turn a profit. But that effect is a) temporary, and b) fairly unlikely. Even if they managed to eat into their competitors' user bases, they have failed to monetize their existing hundreds of millions of users, so there's no reason to believe they'd be able to monetize future hypothetical users.
- aresant 10y agoSalesforce feels like a bizarre choice, although I agree with their digital chief that "I love Twitter" personally. I use twitter every day as my primary method of content discovery. So at their core the BUSINESS should revolve around monetizing my eyeballs, eg advertising. So to me it's Facebook or Google that should grab it, w/FB at the lead considering their relatively smooth / unhurried / and successful takeovers of whatsapp / instagram
- trentmb 10y agoPerhaps there's some back end tech, talent that would be useful for tackling Salesforces problems.
- gaius 10y agoSalesforce's back end is AWS. They ran their own cloud for a while, but ditched it.
- packetized 10y agoIncorrect.
- gaius 10y agoO RLY?? http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2016/06/03/salesforce_aws_microsoft_platform_wars/ http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2016/06/03/salesforce_aws_m...
- whatthesmack 10y agoThings are in flux, but the original statement that it's in AWS now is still incorrect. The core app (and some acquired apps) is/are still on their own gear. Moving everything from their hosting environment to AWS (if that's even what is planned) would take many years.
- btym 10y ago
- crooked-v 10y agoOctober 2016: Google buys Twitter. May 2017: Google gives a one-month notice that Twitter will be shutting down.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- _kyran 10y agoJust going to leave this here (from last month): http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/downloadthisshow/swisherr/7719978 http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/downloadthissho... "Twitter will be sold in six months - Kara Swisher"
- maxander 10y agoI'd be curious to see a statistical analysis of how unlikely it is for there to be predictions of something like this on any given timeframe. Whenever Twitter got sold (or didn't), what are the odds that some vaguely recognizable name would have "predicted" it? To do this analysis we would need some kind of easily searchable corpus of simply-worded predictions, issued by a sizable fraction of public personalities. Hmm...
- erickhill 10y agoI think Twitter's recent foray into becoming a content streaming source (see: NFL) is very interesting and a natural next step, albeit a late one. The user base is already there to essentially compete with Twitch and other streaming providers.
- mbloom1915 10y agoWhy can't youtube live replicate this streaming service and give even more split ad revenue back to NFL, CBS, etc.??
- sidcool 10y agoSalesforce wud be an interesting prospect. Not sure how wud it fit in their business plan
- packetslave 10y ago"wud" is not a word. Use English. please.
- atombath 10y agoNot sure how wood it fit in their business plan
- hackaflocka 10y agoPlease use periods at the end of sentences. This is Hacker News for crying out loud.
- back_beyond 10y agoNot sure how wood it fit in their business plan. . . . . .. ..
- sidcool 10y agoPlease capitalize appropriately.
- jedisct1 10y agoPlease send a pull request.
- happy-go-lucky 10y agoIf you try to make people want what you make, you end up making something disposable, a short-lived romance.
- ben_jones 10y agoAnyone else see S20E02 of southpark? All I'm going to say is it put Twitter in a very interesting perspective.
- mandeepj 10y agoany idea why advertising is working on facebook and not on twitter?
- encoderer 10y agoAnecdotally I use twitter to advertise my SaaS monitoring product, Cronitor, with far more success than we found with AdWords. The ad platform feels easier to use, and promoting content on Twitter is less of a time investment vs selecting, culling, and optimizing sets of keywords.
- k2xl 10y agoWhy are Twitter's expenses so high? Don't get me wrong, scaling is hard... But at the same time, they don't have the issues of scaling photos or videos (like Facebook).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pbarnes_1 10y agoThey host both those things...
- samlevine 10y agoI would pay $10 a year to use Twitter. It's just that good for live news.
- edbaskerville 10y agoBy any normal metric, Twitter is a huge success. 300 million people find their service useful. But it was already huge success when it had no business model. Moreover, what is fundamentally valuable about Twitter to its users--sharing and discovering little bits of textual expression over a publicly visible social network--is not very expensive. From the perspective of the users who find it valuable, why does it need a for-profit model at all? Why can't we just subsidize it as a non-profit via grants and donations, a la Wikipedia? I'm pretty sure you could do the important thing that Twitter does--ignoring all the extras devoted to figuring out how to extract more money from the data--at a small fraction of its $2 billion in revenue. I'm not being naive here--it's quite obvious why things are the way they are. But there many examples out there of making a big impact while making a decent living (just without anyone trying to become a billionaire). Social networking is ripe for more of this approach. The attempts so far have failed not because of their business model, but because of the usual reason: poor execution.
- Avshalom 10y ago>>By any normal metric, Twitter is a huge success Revenue - Cost is perhaps the most normal metric
- edbaskerville 10y ago>> By any normal metric, Twitter is a huge success > Revenue - Cost is perhaps the most normal metric Badly chosen phrase. I'm not saying that currently Twitter is not a business failure--it is, at the moment. But from the perspective of providing value to many people, it's doing very well. Plus, the cost part of the equation is driven at this point largely by trying to figure out how to make more money, not by continuing to provide a valuable service to users. (The making-more-money thing is obviously not working yet.) The alternative model is: lower costs drastically by focusing on doing a handful of useful things well. And then you might be able to raise the money to cover those costs the way Wikipedia does.
- hackaflocka 10y agoLook up "app.net". It's been tried. It failed.
- mattjaynes 10y agoOH: "Twitter is a Friendster whose Facebook hasn't appeared yet." From Jessica Livingston yesterday: https://twitter.com/jesslivingston/status/778948962724315136 https://twitter.com/jesslivingston/status/778948962724315136
- bsparker 10y agoI wish Slack would somehow take over Twitter. Expertly adding in custom channels would save the social platform.
- sorenjan 10y agoAt the end of 2015 Twitter had 3900 employees [0]. Why would they need close to that? How many could a new owner fire without noticeably affecting the day to day operations? [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/272140/employees-of-twitter/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/272140/employees-of-twit...
- fabiandesimone 10y agoTo me Twitter has always been real time news. Why haven't they worked on a way to 'validate' tweets around a story, I can't understand it (from a biz perspective, not technically). With validation they become, instantly, the #1 news agency in the world.
- sp527 10y agoSeeing a lot of arguments about profitability that don't make sense. At Twitter scale, profit sensitivity to even minor tweaks in ad rate/targeting/placement is massive. They could also go into 'maintenance mode' tomorrow and break a massive profit (it would just be stupid). Active users is a poor metric for Twitter. It's much more about the views. A relatively smaller number of people on Twitter can command an outsized influence. It's a fundamentally different kind of network. Twitter's future will probably be more about monetizing its viewership. It's definitely not going to disappear anytime soon.
- randomestname 10y agoThey aren't investing in the present value, they are investing in the future value. Is Twitter going to be more or less relevant in 5 years? 10 years?
- plg 10y agoIf google buys twitter, I'm out
- eddiecalzone 10y agoI had to come here to read some saner comments; the comment section on the linked CNBC article is, uh, deplorable.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoWould it be a bad idea for Twitter to charge a small yearly fee for use? The reason why I think this might work is because some users are very loyal and might not mind spending $20/year for an advertisement free Twitter service. They have about 350 million users, according to a comment here, and if 50 million users would stay, that would be $100 million revenue per year, and with many fewer users, their cost of doing business would be reduced, but with reduced network effects the service would not be as valuable for users. I like Twitter and I would pay $20/year in return for no promoted tweets.
- MichaelGG 10y agoSo they'd convert 15% of all user accounts (many user have more than one account)? That seems really high - 1% might be attainable. Hardly the numbers they need to justify their valuation. Maybe if they lay off a ton of employees and start getting lean, while keeping their current revenue?
- cpsempek 10y agoIs Google the suitor, or, is Alphabet the suitor? The article says Google, but this could be out of habit. I am not sure that answering my question changes much about the news. But it might say something about how Alphabet views Twitter based on who they decide owns the acquisition and where Twitter would fit within the company (as subsidiary or under Google).
- smegel 10y agoIf there is anyone who could mess up Twitter worse than Twitter it is Google.
- susan_hall 10y agoPerhaps off-topic, but does anyone know why Twitter gave up on its effort to monetize its API? There was a moment, circa 2010, when that seemed like the obvious move. When Twitter first began to shut down access to its full firehose, it seemed clear that there were businesses willing to pay for its information. But Twitter suddenly turned away from that idea, and focused on advertising. Considering how many sites compete for advertising dollars, it seems crazy that Twitter felt that was the right way to go. But then Facebook went down the same path, first promoting its API, then largely giving up on any attempt to monetize it. And before that, way back in 2006, I tried to build a business that would rely on Technorati's API, which they briefly promoted, then gave up on. There are a lot of companies that make money by selling information via an API. And there is tremendous competition for ad dollars. These 2 facts would lead me to expect more companies might try to make money from their APIs. But what happened in Twitter's case?