17 ms·
Microsoft aren't forcing Lenovo to block free operating systems
- hermitdev 10y agoFor what it's worth, I've had issues with Intel RST under Windows as well in mixed-mode configs. My boot device is an SSD configured for AHCI and I've a 3 drive RAID array. On a soft reset of my PC, the BIOS won't see the SSD. The completely nonobvious solution? Make the SSD hot swappable. Not a Lenovo PC, either. Been going on for years. Had to do a hard reset every time I had to restart for years before I found a solution to this.
- christogreeff 10y agoAlso have this on an older Lenovo. I use it as a small server now.
- rukuu001 10y agoI'm surprised at the incredulity expressed here, given MS's history of dealing with OEMs. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundling_of_Microsoft_Windows https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundling_of_Microsoft_Window...
- tumbas 10y agodidn't microsoft recently tried to pull off some patent thing on linux while at the same time launching media campaign how it hearts linux online. and didn't microsoft include feature on windows 10 to automatically collect screenshots while you work while not giving option to turn it off and not telling about it to anyone and didn't they made people to upgrade by tricks... don't they buy people to argue online like other hardware manufacturers isn't bill gates free mason communist? inside conspiracy or pure dose of cash also netscape
- raesene9 10y agoAlso worth noting Lenovo's official statment on the matter http://www.techrepublic.com/article/lenovo-denies-deliberately-blocking-linux-on-windows-10-pcs/ http://www.techrepublic.com/article/lenovo-denies-deliberate... confirming that they have not blocked the installation of alternate operating systems. It was a shame to see the initial posts this morning hit the top of the page without any more evidence than a single customer support rep. who was unlikely to realistically have inside knowledge of some kind of "secret conspiracy" to block linux installs by Microsoft.
- christogreeff 10y agoIt was fascinating how quickly people condemned Microsoft without applying any critical thinking to the issue. I tend to not read commments on articles anymore, where Microsoft is blamed for something. Reminds me of Slahdot.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoMoment I saw it this morning I was like "probably one of those SSDs with a really weird driver setup". My Surface Pro 4 has one too, and Acronis didn't initially work with it either.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoExcept that's an inaccurate assumption. If you actually read the specifics about the situation, you'll learn that the SSD is set up in RAID mode, and the Intel hardware also supports AHCI mode. Acronis and all other OSes do not have driver-level support for this new experimental RAID hardware at all; they do support AHCI, of course, like they have for years. The BIOS normally has an option to revert the hardware back to normal AHCI mode, but Lenovo intentionally restricted the Advanced page in the BIOS containing this option (which is available and unrestricted by default in the BIOS code they received from the manufacturer) by adding a goto statement to the BIOS's code.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoMy understanding is that experimental support for the new RAID mode in Linux already exists. AFAIK, Acronis boots a Linux-based OS, and they were able to get it to support the Surface Pro 4 when it's using that mode, so presumably, they figured it out. As far as why Lenovo restricted it, it's likely for the same reason Lenovo was prohibited from preinstalling software. Signature PCs claim to have the "best" performance settings, mandated by Microsoft. If NVMe is superior to AHCI, Microsoft would sensibly mandate NVMe.
- 10y ago
- facorreia 10y ago> Rather than be angry at Lenovo, let's put pressure on Intel to provide support for their hardware.
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoWhich won't work.
- dandelion_lover 10y agoLike a petition? https://puri.sm/posts/petition-for-intel-to-release-an-me-less-cpu-design/ https://puri.sm/posts/petition-for-intel-to-release-an-me-le...
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoThe moral of the story is that you shouldn't trust a low-level support engineer as a source for official company policy.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoOr the uncritical tech press or the rubes on reddit, etc. Its obvious to me that we're living in a time where rumors, falsehoods, and purposeful misdirection are easily monetized and that's what our tech press has degenerated into. Critical voices just get downvoted away for being "shills" or somesuch. We live in a time where likes and upvotes control what we see and informed criticism being censored away by downvotes and flagging. As someone who often goes against the grain, its god damn obvious our communication infrastructure has degenerated into something horrible where only echo chambers and groupthink rule. Stuff like this will continue to rise to the top until there's some kind of reform. I don't see reddit, HN, or Facebook changing how they rank items up to encourage dissenting opinions, because ultimately dissenting opinions aren't as profitable or 'community minded.'
- bendykstra 10y ago"Besides, as the vilest Writer has his Readers, so the greatest Liar has his Believers; and it often happens, that if a Lie be believ’d only for an Hour, it has done its Work, and there is no farther occasion for it. Falsehood flies, and the Truth comes limping after it; so that when Men come to be undeceiv’d, it is too late; the Jest is over, and the Tale has had its Effect…" Jonathan Swift (1710)
- keyboardwarrior 10y agoYou just have no idea how logic works, If you dissent against people who think they are dissenting against a idea, then what you are actually doing is agreeing to whatever those people were desenting against in the first place. Its double negation law in action. So you cannot really dissent against a dissentor without very clearly sitting in the middle and stating so.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y ago
- NikolaeVarius 10y agoStandard culture of outrage before actually taking more than 5 seconds to think about something and consider other possibilities.
- huhtenberg 10y agoYeah, sure, Microsoft is now all white and fluffy. Best friends forever. How about we pay some attention to the second part of: Lenovo's firmware defaults to "RAID" mode and ** doesn't allow you to change that ** Power savings or not, but locking down storage controller to a mode that just happens to be supported by exactly one OS has NO obvious rational explanation. Either Lenovo does that or Windows does. This has nothing to do with Intel.
- 13of40 10y agoWhy doesn't Linux support it? Is "RAID" mode based on some spec that was only provided to Microsoft and kept secret from everyone else?
- detaro 10y agoI doubt Microsoft knows the spec to it, all they care about is that the manufacturer provides a working driver.
- mjg59 10y agoWindows only supports it if you use the Intel storage driver - even Microsoft don't ship a driver that supports it.
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoYay, so supporting completely non-standard and inevitably more buggy drivers is the correct option?
- farcical_tinpot 10y ago> even Microsoft don't ship a driver that supports it. .....and why do you suppose that is? Fake RAID drivers and hardware are shit that's why. It's an option that is hardly used, if ever, and I never thought I'd see the day when a system had it as its default.
- mcpherrinm 10y ago> "RAID" mode is typically just changing the PCI IDs so that the normal drivers won't bind, ensuring that drivers that support the software RAID mode are used. It sounds like the kernel just needs to learn about the new PCI ID.
- simbalion 10y agoedit: the truth has been censored because I spoke harshly of those looking to perpetuate evil.
- Sanddancer 10y agoIt isn't hard to figure out what's happening if you read everything that went on. Windows itself doesn't install on these computers unless you have special drivers in the boot medium that aren't included with Windows 10. Why would Microsoft sabotage their own OS like that if this were something done to stymie other OSes?
- huhtenberg 10y agoNo idea who are the dolts^H^H^H^H^H kind people who have downvoted you into light gray, but you are bloody right. Just look at their complete and utter disregard to everyone's privacy demonstrated by Windows 10. Remember all the shady shit Microsoft pulled to shovel W10 down everyone's throat, including "x", the cancel, being treated as "Yes, upgrade". How short and selective of a memory you should have to then claim with a straight face that NOT assuming that Lenovo lockdown is benign is the lack of critical thinking. WTH is wrong with you, people, really.
- christogreeff 10y agoSelective memory is disregarding all other areas where MS is actually encouring or trying to make their products work on Linux. The future of Microsoft is not Windows. I am also not disregarding the fact that I might be wrong, but as a Windows and Linux user, it seems strange to possibly alienate potential users with a Linux blocking move.
- guelo 10y agoWithout any comment from Lenovo or Microsoft this guy is speculating the same as everybody else.
- jsmthrowaway 10y ago"This guy" is relatively known for hacking on Linux laptop drivers and a long relationship with Intel hardware and power management in particular, so I'll stop short of appealing to authority and just say I value his speculation even if it is that. (Which I don't think it is.)
- guelo 10y agoThis guy is so knowledgable that he says > Why not offer the option to disable it? A user who does would end up with a machine that doesn't boot But the modder that flashed the custom BIOS was able to boot linux on the first attempt.
- teraflop 10y agoThat comment was clearly referring to the common case of ordinary Windows users, who could easily render their existing systems unbootable by changing the driver mode after Windows was already installed.
- michaelmrose 10y agoRandom joe user should probably not be messing around with his bios or should at least be smart enough to know what he changed or at worst reset his bios to default. If not use the tech support you pay for.
- digi_owl 10y agoHe also seems to have a severe hardon for EFI...
- seba_dos1 10y agoThen obviously Intel providing the drivers is what he'd like to see happening, regardless of what and why Lenovo did here. With the driver, it doesn't matter if Lenovo did it to lock out older Windows versions, Linux users or just to screw with their customers for fun - because it would work. However, it's still Lenovo who's playing bad here. Intel provides a mode in their controller that works with everything. It's Lenovo who deliberatelly made it almost impossible to access.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoTheir spin that it is "our super advanced Intel RAID chipset" really plays in their favor, given that their BIOS uses a single goto statement to intentionally block access to the ability to set this chipset into the AHCI compatible mode that the hardware so readily supports, as evidenced by the REing work and the fact that other OSes detect the drive after the AHCI fix using the custom-flashed BIOS. So, why are they reluctant to just issue their band-aid patch to the BIOS -- after all, it's really the path of least resistance here? Yes, there has been some deflection of blame here. The argument that every single OS except Windows 10 is at fault for not supporting this CRAZY new super advanced hardware doesn't make much sense. "Linux (and all other operating systems) don't support X on Z because of Y" doesn't really apply when "Z modified Y in a way that does not allow support for X." To state it more plainly, this "CRAZY new super advanced hardware" has a trivial backwards compatible mode that works with everything just fine, but it is blocked by Lenovo's BIOS.
- zanny 10y agoIts actually no problem not to be backwards compatible with your "crazy new super advanced hardware". Except when that CNSAH is holistically proprietary and black box, with no documentation, no announcement of it, no schematics or free drivers or anything. "We made this black box that you aren't allowed to know how it works but you aren't supporting it so you are in the wrong".
- Hydraulix989 10y agoI'm confused. Lenovo is claiming that the problem is Linux's fault because Linux isn't "forwards compatible"with the CNSAH -- except the CNSAH is actually backwards compatible with Linux, except Intel's usually enabled/unrestricted backwards compatible functionality is intentionally blocked by Lenovo by two lines of code in their BIOS. The fact that Intel's hardware is "CNSAH" (or even black box/proprietary/etc) is completely irrelevant to the issue at hand. I'm not saying that it is Lenovo's onus to ensure that Linux is forwards compatible at CNSAH at all -- it's actually their responsibility to make sure they don't break existing backwards compatible functionality; you're misrepresenting my actual argument. I'm also _liberally_ and very generously using "backwards compatible" to describe AHCI, when I should be calling it "modus operandi."
- hetfeld 10y agoSo why i can't install Ubuntu on my Lenovo laptop?
- 0x006A 10y agoHave you opened up a bug with the new new PCI ID so they can be added to the kernel?
- rbanffy 10y agoWasn't Lenovo the company that shipped unremovable malware with laptops? Considering the almost impossible to disable Intel management stuff is also there, I can only imagine the kind of parasite living on these machines. Why would anyone buy their stuff?
- Sanddancer 10y agoOne of the parts of the MS Signature Series agreement is that there is no crapware, that what you get is pretty much the same if you installed a direct from microsoft copy of Windows. The signature series is probably the only line I would get from lenovo, because it's guaranteed not to need hours of futzing to get it working decently.
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoSo get a vanilla install disk from Microsoft's site, install and reuse the license.
- pdkl95 10y agoThere has been a disturbing level of contempt for the people that were concerned about the future of Free Software. There has been a major shift towards more locked down platforms for years ever since iOS was accepted by the developer community. With Microsoft locking down Secure Boot on ARM and requiring it for Windows 10, it is prudent to be extra vigilant about anything strange that happens in the boot process. The alternative is to ignore potential problems until they grow into much larger problems that are harder to deal with. Obviously vigilance implies some amount of false positives. It is easy to dismiss a problem once better information is available. It's great that this Lenovo situation is simply a misunderstanding about drivers, but that doesn't invalidate the initial concern about a suspicious situation.
- youdontknowtho 10y agoWow. Man, come on. The disturbing level of contempt is almost the sole property of the "Linux == Freedom" crowd. I mean seriously, the level of outrage about systemd alone is off the rails. Bring up Microsoft and I'm somehow complicit in oppressing people because I use their software? (But somehow the rare earth minerals in devices and the contributions to modern electronics of the defense budget don't somehow make us all culpable of far more. I mean, yeah the GPS in my phone was built for the military but how dare you not give me a compiler!) I used to be such a hard core Linux fan when I was younger. Man I hope I wasn't as breathlessly shrill as the people I'm seeing today. There is so much wrong with the world that people complaining about this really make me think that we are all so isolated in our little worlds...
- pdkl95 10y ago> The disturbing level of contempt is almost the sole property of the "Linux == Freedom" crowd. That's patently incorrect and you know it. FYI: You're showing that kind of contempt right now. My point isn't even related strongly to Free Software; it was an observation that a lot of people don't like early warning systems, which is bad for security. Shooting the messenger when they bring a warning of a possible threat is a terrible idea if you want to continue to receive warning messages. Deciding if that was the goal for some people is left as an exercise to the reader. > I mean seriously, the level of outrage about systemd alone is off the rails. Off topic and irrelevant, though if you actually read the real, substantive complaints against systemd they tend to focus on forced upgrades from unnecessary tight integration between components and disruption of working code. The contempt in these arguments is usually from the people that try to shut down any discussion that isn't blindly accepting systemd. > Bring up Microsoft and I'm somehow complicit in oppressing people because I use their software? I never said anything of the sort. Pretending to be a victim is unbecoming. > [stuff about rare earth minerals, the defense budget, GPS] If there is a point to this word salad, I am not parsing it. It seems off topic? > I used to be such a hard core Linux fan when I was younger. Some of us still believe it's a bad idea to sacrifice your principles for convenience and a few shiny baubles. > people complaining about this really make me think that we are all so isolated in our little worlds The future will be shaped by those that control computation and the internet. This means defending computation and communication that isn't controlled by one entity is one of the most important tasks of this generation. In the future, everything is a computer. Some of us think it's important to fight for freedom now, before that happens, because the problem is only going to get harder. If you've given up that fight, that's fine. Just please stand aside because other people are still trying to fight for a free and open future.
- intopieces 10y agoFTA: "For a consumer device, why would you want to? The number of people buying these laptops to run anything other than Windows is miniscule." This is a really poor argument, and slightly disingenuous. Sometimes, people change their use for a device. Maybe they want to explore linux in the future, maybe they want to sell the laptop to someone who wants to use it for linux... That the blame is being possibly misdirected ought not to detract from the fact that blame is necessary. If users don't vocally oppose measures like this, the industry will assume that this kind of restriction is reasonable. It's not. Yes, power management is important, but anyone who puts linux on their laptop will quickly learn there are limitations to the features of that device that were originally tailored to the OS the device shipped with. That's a good lesson, and a good opportunity for a community to develop around the device (if it's good enough) to mitigate those deficiencies and adapt them for the particular linux distro. In short, Lenovo is at fault for not being up front about this limitation, for not explaining it, and for not devoting at least some resources to mitigating for their potential linux-inclined users. Then again, perhaps a linux-inclined user might also be one of the many that don't trust Lenovo after their self-signed certificate scandal.
- richardwhiuk 10y agoI think you are missing that the 'you' in that argument is Lenovo, not the consumer. Lenovo doesn't have an interest in how people's use of a device changes, unless it changes they up front purchasing decision. They do have a very strong interest in making sure that reviews and writeups don't say that the battery life is rubbish because the laptop has been switched to AHCI mode. As such, they have a strong incentive to prevent this happening. Given that the operating which 99.9% of their install base will use supports this, it's almost certainly a net win. They don't support running Linux on it - that's at the customers risk. Why would they devote any resource to this?
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoCorrection, they only support on version of that OS - which is the point here. To claim you're going to get better battery life with a fake RAID driver is also one of the funniest things I've ever heard.
- StreamBright 10y agoSomebody should notify the guys who went really deep condemning Microsoft of cutting shady deals. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12545878 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12545878
- savagej 10y agoWhy would anyone ever buy Lenovo? It's malware, spyware, and harmful to users. I buy HP or Samsung laptops to run Fedora. Just accept that Lenovo is not IBM hardware, and that it is lost to us.
- sndean 10y ago> I buy HP or Samsung laptops to run Fedora. Recently, which models? (I was thinking of getting a new Thinkpad... but maybe I should look at HP or Samsung)
- savagej 10y agoCurrently, I run on a pair of Samsung Ativ Book 9 Plus with 8G mem. It looks like they've moved on from the Ativ line. The 3200 x 1800 display works well with awesome+gnome. It also drives an external 1440p display simultaneously (at 30fps).
- rburhum 10y agoWhat is crazy to me is that Lenovo is usually the brand that people recommend for Linux laptops. They are shooting themselves in the foot here. They may think that the number of people on Linux is too small, but I bet it is bigger than they think. It is just that there is no easy way to accurately census the amount of Linux users on their HW.
- captainmuon 10y agoI used to recommend Lenovo (and before that, IBM) unconditionally for both Windows and Linux use. We called them the "Volvo of computers" because of their longevity, their performance, and their repairability. Now I'm writing this on a Yoga Pro 2, which is nice in principle, but it's slowly starting to get wobbly, screws are falling out, the color is peeling off the keys, and I can't use Linux because the color yellow is replaced with fricking MUSTARD if you don't load a specific Windows only driver. I actually poked a bit around in the drivers, and Lenovo fixes the problem by sending a few bytes to the Embedded Controller (a microcontroller on the motherboard). Lenovo doesn't give out the neccessary information, but I could reverse engineer it by kernel-debugging Windows. But the only way to do that on this Laptop would be via a special crossover USB3 debugger cable, which is out of sale. Before I soldered my own, I just gave up, and am now using Windows... My next PC is going to be an Asus or a Dell (who would have thought a few years ago...).
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI have heard nothing but rave reviews for the XPS laptops which come officially supported with Ubuntu out of the box.
- rburhum 10y agooh wow. That sounds horrible. I am sorry man!
- wpietri 10y agoI was thinking that too. I write this on a Lenovo Thinkpad, and was just looking at buying a new machine from them. I've been using Thinkpads for more than decade. I guess if they want me to look elsewhere, I'm willing. Anybody have recommendations?
- guelo 10y ago> Why not offer the option to disable it? A user who does would end up with a machine that doesn't boot The modder that flashed the custom BIOS was able to boot linux on his first try.
- mjg59 10y agoBut which wouldn't have run the pre-installed OS any more
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoIt would run Windows though ;-).
- WhitneyLand 10y agoThere was way too much rush to judgement here. Suspicion and skepticism are great, let those fires burn. But let's not condemn or blame until the issue has been aired out from all parties. - MS shouldn't be blamed based on what the CEO of Lenovo says, let alone what a tech or BB rep says. - MS shouldn't be blamed for new crimes based on past behavior Why care about MS or any other megacorp? Because this salem witch trial shit is toxic and should not be condoned against anyone. Rush to suspicion and demanding answers is great. There is no downside to saving blame for after the facts are in.
- youdontknowtho 10y agoOf course they aren't but how can I feel morally superior with that fact?
- youdontknowtho 10y agoIts amazing that Linux can so thoroughly have won in the device world and yet MS is still every fan boys favorite boogeyman. This is such a non event.
- colemickens 10y agoOh it's funny to see the comments in this thread talking down about people on reddit when the misplaced outrage was just as loud here. In fact, I got buried here for pointing out that the claim was BS and unrelated to SecureBoot where at least Reddit took it thoughtfully and realized it was probably just a bullshit statement from a nobody rep that got blown out of proportion. Sorry to be that guy, but the elitism is pretty misplaced anymore...
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoIt's not Secure Boot - yet. But this is what you're going to find - obsolescence depending on built-in hardware driver support. Not only are you not getting Linux installed on here but Windows 7, or any future version of Windows that does not have this driver built for it. You'll then have to throw the hardware away. No, it wasn't a bullshit statement from a rep - it was a very clear statement from a rep, in black and white, that has not been retracted or clarified by Lenovo in any way. It's always funny when people choose not to believe verbatim statements and explanations put right in front of them.
- colemickens 10y ago>No, it wasn't a bullshit statement from a rep - it was a very clear statement from a rep, in black and white, that has not been retracted or clarified by Lenovo in any way. It's always funny when people choose not to believe verbatim statements and explanations put right in front of them. Literally nothing about this sentence is correct. Support reps know nothing, and nameless support reps that throw out statements like that with no explanation or link to company policies are even less likely to have a clue what they're talking about. I can't believe I'm having to explain this on Hacker News. It's like people on /r/xboxone that post the dumbest crap from support reps and claim it as Microsoft canon. And yes, Lenovo has clarified that... as everyone who is paying any attention already knows... no, it's not some bullshit conspiracy, and it is in fact the result of switching to faster storage technology that simply isn't supported by Linux today. http://news.softpedia.com/news/lenovo-says-linux-is-not-blocked-on-its-windows-10-pcs-508509.shtml http://news.softpedia.com/news/lenovo-says-linux-is-not-bloc... (this includes the statement from Lenovo) Plus, you know, you could read Matthew's blog post (the HN link that we're commenting on...) that explains this as well.
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoI wondered when Matthew Garrett would pipe up and deepthroat Microsoft again. He duly obliges. When I first heard this I thought this was what I always thought would eventually happen with Secure Boot, but we haven't quite arrived at that point yet. Give it time when we eventually end up with critical mass. What seems to be happening is similar to Kaby Lake in reverse. You restrict hardware and drivers needed to no only exclude other operating systems, which is a side-effect, but build in hardware obsolescence so you'll find yourself without any drivers or means to upgrade in future Windows versions. You don't lock any chipset into an idiotic RAID mode in a laptop with a single disk. To claim this is done for power management reasons over perfectly standard AHCI is so stupid it isn't even funny, but Matthew likes defending stupid. He swears blind that Secure Boot will always be in a position where it can be turned off and Microsoft will not try anything on with key access. Because, you know, Microsoft's word and all that. Be in no doubt, Microsoft and OEMs together want us all to throw away hardware and upgrade more regularly.
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoI haven't looked but I also very much doubt there is a Windows 7 driver for this.......... ;-).
- farcical_tinpot 10y ago....and indeed, there are only Windows 10 drivers. http://support.lenovo.com/gb/en/products/Laptops-and-netbooks/Yoga-Series/yoga-900-13isk2?query=&Shallow=1&Type=&OperatingSystems=&Component=&Symptom=&tabName=Downloads&linkTrack=Mast:SubNav:Support:Drivers%20and%20Software%7CDrivers%20and%20Software&beta=false http://support.lenovo.com/gb/en/products/Laptops-and-netbook... WTF is that URL by the way? Many Skylake systems are like this today. You can boot Windows 7 but there are no USB 2.0 ports so you have no keyboard or mouse. You have to go through an incredibly tedious procedure of slipstreaming USB 3 drivers into the installation, and you don't always know whether you have the right ones from Intel's site. Restricting disk access seems like a much more foolproof way of closing this off ;-). Businesses can't buy this laptop and use their volume license of Windows 7, which is entirely the point. They can also build in obsolescence in the future by removing driver support. You might be able to get an OS they're not keen on installed, but if you can't see the disk you've got no chance of getting it installed ;-).
- johansch 10y agoIt's so sad to see this. (This entire thread, and its comments are down-voted.) Let me try again. New Microsoft is awesome! Old Microsoft never happened. Double plus good!
- johansch 10y agoFor the love of any god you worship: Will the Microsoft-ecosystem developers please stop downvoting this just out of spite? This is so pathetic. You guys have truly proven yourself to be civil today, haven't you? F*ng pathetic. You guys are so insecure it's funny.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments. Also, please don't post comments complaining about downvotes; that's explicitly against the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). People often feel that their pro/anti MS views are being suppressed by the anti/pro members of the community, but really it's just that the community is divided. Accusations of abuse without evidence aren't allowed here, and someone merely holding an opposing view isn't evidence. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12551876 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12551876 and marked it off-topic.
- throw2016 10y agoSome commentators seem to be more keen on labelling others conspiracy theorists than consider the possibility that MS and Lenovo could be up to no good. The only way to convince these folks it seems would be a smoking gun or even better a signed confession from satya and lenovo admitting to shady behavior. Since that's not how shady behavior works in the real world presumably many here are supporters of the camel in the sand approach with a zero tolerance policy towards non conforming camels.
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoSeeing a manufacturer use fake RAID, by default, on a single disk system, then unfathomably hardwiring this into the firmware so it can't be changed, then have a Lenovo rep actually admit the reason with the forum thread censored and then see this kind of defence is downright hilarious. Garrett should be condemning Lenovo for not making a perfectly configurable chipset feature....configurable and defending Linux and freedom of choice on hardware that has always traditionally been that way. But, no, he doesn't. He defends stupidity as he always does.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoYes, I wholly disagree with Garrett's attempts to redirect (or should I say, deflect) blame to Intel instead of Lenovo in this case. I've succinctly outlined my argument in most of my other posts in this thread.
- farcical_tinpot 10y agoGarrett has a history of stonewalling and misdirection on these matters. It was the same with UEFI, Secure Boot and when he and Red Hat tried to casually shoehorn support for PE binaries into the Linux kernel, hoping no one would notice.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoWhy is PE binary support a bad thing? Wine gets us mostly there already. Very interesting...
- digi_owl 10y agoLeading to Torvalds making a comment about Red Hat going down on MS no less...
- seba_dos1 10y agoPushing Intel to provide the drivers or at least documentation would be the best solution - the BIOS lock would become irrelevant. However, I don't agree with conclusion that Lenovo isn't to blame. They went out of their way to ensure that even power users playing with EFI shell won't be able to switch to AHCI mode. I don't care about Microsoft here. Lenovo showed its bad side and I probably won't be buying their devices anymore - which is a pity, as I'm writing this on my Yoga 2 Pro, with my company's Yoga 900 (fortunately older, unblocked revision) nearby and I liked those devices.
- lspears 10y agoisn't
- bsder 10y agoThe setting is almost certainly because of Microsoft. It is almost certainly part of their license agreement to block installation of anything older than Windows 10. The fact that Linux got caught in it is just collateral damage.
- sqldba 10y agoClick bait. It's one interpretation masquerading as the truth while decrying the other interpretation. Until Lenovo issue a proper, detailed, official statement we need to keep the pressure on. Self aggrandising posts like this don't help.
- fenomas 10y agoMeta: It seems really odd that this has been relegated to page two, considering that "MS and Lenovo secret agreement" headlines sat on the top page most of yesterday, largely unsubstantiated. I could be crazy, but HN's algos seem much too aggressive about hiding articles due to flags. It often feels like the most interesting articles are to be found 2-3 spots into the second page.
- aruggirello 10y agoI repost here the 39th comment, which gives a possible explanation of the issue: Storm in a teacup Date: 2016-09-22 09:17 am (UTC) From: [personal profile] cowbutt "Intel have not submitted any patches to Linux to support the "RAID" mode." Such patches are unnecessary, as mdadm already supports Intel Rapid Storage Technology (RST - http://www.intel.co.uk/content/www/uk/en/architecture-and-technology/rapid-storage-technology.html http://www.intel.co.uk/content/www/uk/en/architecture-and-te... ) for simple RAID (e.g. levels 0, 1, 10) arrays, allowing them to be assembled as md or dmraid devices under Linux. However, it would appear that the version of mdadm in shipping versions of Ubuntu (at least - maybe other distros too) doesn't support the Smart Response Technology (SRT - http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/architecture-and-technology/smart-response-technology.html http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/architecture-and-tech... ) feature that's a part of RST and is used by Lenovo to build a hybrid one-stripe RAID0 device from the HDD with a cache on the SSD (I'm sure Lenovo have a good reason for not using a SSHD). Dan Williams of Intel submitted a series of patches to mdadm to support SRT back in April 2014: https://marc.info/?l=linux-raid&r=1&b=201404&w=2 https://marc.info/?l=linux-raid&r=1&b=201404&w=2 . Perhaps now there's shipping hardware that requires them, there'll be the impetus for distro vendors to get them integrated into mdadm, and their auto-detection in their installers to use the functionality provided sanely. --- I should add that mdadm is not present in Ubuntu live images by default - one has to pull it in by issuing "sudo apt[-get] install mdadm". BTW, I don't know if mdadm would detect the RAID controller/disk immediately upon installation, or it would require a reboot. In the latter case you may wish to use a USB key with enough spare room to save the system status and reboot. I'd use UNetBootin to prepare such a USB key. The main issue here is, a user who doesn't even see a disk, probably wouldn't know to go as far as installing mdadm. IMHO, given the broadening diffusion of NVMe and RAID devices, Debian, Canonical, REDHAT, Fedora etc. might wish to make mdadm part of their live images by default (and eventually strip it from the installed system if it's unnecessary). Edit: clarified
- gnode 10y agoIt sounds to me like it would be quite trivial to run Linux on this laptop, just by treating the "RAID" mode PCI ID like AHCI and employing the regular driver. I believe Linux supports forcing the use of a driver for a PCI device.