11 ms·
Google's CFO Ruth Porat is pushing “creatives” to bring costs under control
- paulddraper 10y ago> In short, the hoodie honeymoon phase is over. I've used Ruth's favorite search engine to find "hoodie honeymoon phase" ... but I get nothing. What does this mean?
- Gigablah 10y agoSurround it with quotes. You'll get the article.
- paulddraper 10y agoHm, true. Thanks :D
- SolarNet 10y agoIt's based off of an earlier paragraph about her trading business suits for hoodies. It's self referential to a running metaphor.
- rectang 10y agoIt's Fortune magazine -- consider the audience. This is capital convincing itself that it is morally superior to labor.
- dgnnmdhn 10y agoUh oh, it looks like the cult of shareholder value is about to claim another victim. I wonder how long it will take for Google to IBM itself.
- nl 10y agoExcept Google doesn't need to care about shareholder value for anyone except the class 1 shareholders, is the founders.
- paulddraper 10y agoSo? A rising tide raises all ships.
- mcguire 10y agoJudging by my experiences with IBM, within 5 years, Google will be "focusing on its core competencies" of advertising and will be cutting everything else loose.
- protomyth 10y agoIt's especially painful when the company management misjudges their core competency and cuts the wrong thing.
- h4nkoslo 10y agoBesides the "cult of shareholder value", there is also an opposite fallacy where the more difficult to measure a division's payoff, the more leeway they have in blowing through cash. Many of the "moonshots" seem like the kind of thing that sure, might have some kind of long-term payoff, but not necessarily one captured by Google, or that justifies arbitrary levels of investment. A company can survive such a tax even if it's negative payoff, especially if other divisions are crapping gold bricks, but at some point you have to figure out what your long-term expectation is and calibrate expenditures to that level.
- jjoonathan 10y agoAbsolutely. Thanks for saying what nobody likes to hear. Markets consistently undervalue research in the utilitarian sense, but I'm pretty sure they don't undervalue it in the economic sense. To be clear, I think this is a shortcoming in the economic notion of value, not in research. > sure, might have some kind of long-term payoff, but not necessarily one captured by Google That's the crux of it. It's not about unwillingness of companies to "think big" and "take risks", it's not about a shrinking horizon of shareholder ROI expectations, it's about the difficulty of capturing the value that gets created. Economic value that can't be captured isn't economic value. Maybe (probably, in this case) it's utilitarian value, but it's not economic value. The notion of intellectual property was a valiant attempt to turn things around, but it introduces so much friction and so many routes of exploitation that it really hasn't changed the fact that on some level markets are fundamentally incompatible with basic research -- which is why fighting to fund it through the government is so important.
- crucifiction 10y agoI think this is a key problem for google. I am not sure there are many who believe that the Google R&D/moonshots are actually going to turn into businesses or executed products for Google sold by Google. Their "heart" never seems to be in any of the other areas that they entertain, even at huge amounts of funding (like GCE) they seem to still be hobbies. In contrast, I doubt there is any shareholder that would not believe that if Apple's r&d stumbles on something they wouldn't be able to execute on product and turn it into a $xx billion segment.
- RandomOpinion 10y agoIt was inevitable. These monopolies / near-monopolies seem to follow a pattern: -IBM was at its peak in the '80s before losing its direction and beginning layoffs and a long slow collapse, reducing it to its current state as a shadow of its former self. -Microsoft was at its peak in the '90s before losing its direction and is now starting its collapse with major layoffs a couple of years ago. -Google was at its peak in the '00s and is starting to lose its direction. -Amazon is at its peak now in the '10s.
- asdfologist 10y agoWhere do you get the idea that Google peaked in the '00s? Their net income has been rising dramatically every year (2015 more than doubled 2009): http://www.statista.com/statistics/266472/googles-net-income/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/266472/googles-net-income... I think people are conflating "a company at its peak" with "shiny new company that is the center of media hype", which are completely different things.
- RandomOpinion 10y agoMicrosoft's income kept rising steadily through the '00s too and look at where they are.
- jacques_chester 10y agoI'd trade places with Microsoft. Earning $16.7 billion on $85.3 billion in the 12 months to June 2016 sounds like a pretty sweet deal.
- btian 10y agoMost CEOs will do anything to trade places with Microsoft.
- sgnelson 10y agoI don't know what the original poster meant, but I may (I'm not sure I would) argue that he may mean things other than simple income/profit. Such things as core competencies/competitiveness/managerial and employee talent and motivation/corporate "cohesiveness"/ability to create successful products/other, maybe more difficult to measure criteria and so forth. I wouldn't say all (or even most) of the above applies to Google, but I do believe that for large corporate systems in general, these sorts of things become a major issue when you have half a million employees and hundreds of subsidiaries/divisions. Just trying to make things clearer.
- the_duke 10y agoInteresting article, interesting person. I'm never quite comfortable with portraits that just sing endless praise and are devoid of any kind of critical reflection, though (apart from the subtle hint that her work takes precendence over her son). BTW, I tried to look up Alphabets and Googles revenue/earnings by segment, but the information out there is relatively sparse. Anybody have a good link? (Apart from [1]). [1] https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ:GOOGL&fstype=ii https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ:GOOGL&fstype=ii
- theDoug 10y agohttps://abc.xyz/investor/ https://abc.xyz/investor/ May be of some help.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe word you're looking for is "hagiography".
- aaron-lebo 10y agoAt Morgan Stanley from 1996 through 2010 and an executive during the banking crisis. I feel like that's gotta be simplistic and/or wrong because that's nothing but red flags for me. Could someone correct me? Why should this not be concerning? Those were some of the most predatory and poorly run companies in America at the time.
- refulgentis 10y agoThe Big Short gets into why it's misplaced to blame the big banks for the crisis, and calling them "predatory and poorly run" goes several unjustified steps beyond that.
- iaw 10y agoWhere do you believe 'The Big Short' places the blame?
- refulgentis 10y agoMortgage lenders, like Countrywide, who were selling predatory crap to banks that weren't questioning Countrywide enough, and had an unyielding faith in house prices always increasing. More doofus behavior than knowing malfeasance, at least, that's what I got out of the book? Clearly that's a minority viewpoint, perhaps I should re-read it...:X
- nl 10y agoI think the the more common impression from the book was that mortgage lenders were incentived not to ask questions, and banks were more than happy to take their offerings, repackage them, and resell them to dumb money. Many at the banks seemed to know what was happening: remember how the price wasn't dropping as fast as they expected? That was Goldman covering their position and refusing to make the market at a reasonable price until they were safe. The dumb banks for burnt of course.
- friendlygrammar 10y ago
- blackbagboys 10y ago> Instead of going under the knife, she went to her office, arm in a sling. Porat refused painkillers, saying they would impair her > judgment, and put in two long workdays before the Tuesday morning call. > “Ruth is the only person who can deliver bad news to me, and I’ll still like her,” says Jeff Immelt, CEO > of GE These people are insane. Keep personalities like this far away from your life.
- wtbob 10y ago> These people are insane. No, not really. An earnings call for an enterprise that large is worth many human lives (at the standard rate of about $2 million, which is itself derived from both people's own insurance choices as well as court-case awards); part of what someone at that level is paid to do is to put her company (and the well-being of the millions of people with a stake in it) above herself, and Mrs. Porat did that.
- lfam 10y ago$2 million (or whatever number) may be the standard rate used to compensate others for a lost life, but does anyone willingly sell their life for $2 million? I think there is a difference between how we try to compensate for the loss of something irreplaceable (a life) or disincentive negligence, and the price of something bought and sold.
- sa46 10y agoIsn't life insurance fraud by suicide selling your life for a chance at money, usually much less than $2 million?
- jonathankoren 10y agoObviously not, because you're not dead.
- mvid 10y ago
- ben_jones 10y agoTheirs a scene in Mr Robot where a junior executive at E-Corp bragged about getting a blow job from an executive recruiter on a tennis court on one of the Google campuses. That scene resonated pretty deeply with me. All large corporations have much more in common then they do apart, including for the most part the same needs, desires, objectives, tactics, etc. They all pull from the same pool of Harvard, Stanford, Yale, whose pedigree of professors-to-influential-people would be incredibly fascinating in its own right. That said I've longed learned it's pointless to try to predict the doom of companies. Just try not to get burned by the inevitable fall out in whatever form it may take...
- cs702 10y agoReading this reminds me of "The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free," by Steve Blank.[1] Here's the key passage: "...the new CFO got up to give her presentation – all kind of expected; Sarbanes Oxley compliance, a new accounting system, beef up IT and security, Section 409A (valuation) compliance, etc. Then she dropped the other shoe. “Do you know how much our company is spending on free sodas and snacks?” And to answer her own question she presented the spreadsheet totaling it all up. There were some experienced VC’s in the room and I was waiting for them to “educate” her about startup culture. But my jaw dropped when the board agreed that the “free stuff” had to go. “We’re too big for that now” was the shared opinion. But we’ll sell them soda “cheap.” ... One day the engineering team was clustered in the snack room looking at the soda machine. The sign said, “Soda now 50 cents.” The uproar began. Engineers started complaining about the price of the soda. Someone noticed that instead of the informal reimbursement system for dinners when they were working late, there was now a formal expense report system. Some had already been irritated when “professional” managers had been hired over their teams with reportedly more stock than the early engineers had. Lots of email was exchanged about “how things were changing for the worse.” A few engineers went to the see the CEO. But the damage had been done. The most talented and senior engineers looked up from their desks and noticed the company was no longer the one they loved. It had changed. And not in a way they were happy with. The best engineers quietly put the word out that they were available, and in less than month the best and the brightest began to drift away." [1] https://steveblank.com/2009/12/21/the-elves-leave-middle-earth-%E2%80%93-soda%E2%80%99s-are-no-longer-free/ https://steveblank.com/2009/12/21/the-elves-leave-middle-ear...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI remember getting into a long discussion with an engineering director at Google about "the entitled attitude" that engineers had. Their argument was that money spent on "lifestyle perqs" was money not spent on better computers or improved networking, or heaven forbid higher salaries where the engineers could spend the money on something for themselves. They weren't wrong. But at the same time, they really weren't looking at it from the employee's perspective. Being a bit cheeky I mentioned that Google could save lots of money if they stopped heating and cooling the buildings. With the obvious counter argument that if the place was uncomfortable "everyone" would leave. But that is just as wrong. Not everyone would leave, only the people for whom working for Google wasn't as important as being comfortable at work. There were plenty of people who would sit there sweltering just to be "working at Google." And many of those people would do great work and build great things. But the really good people, the people who constantly invent new things and have the skills to communicate their ideas and get them implemented, those people can work literally anywhere and if they can do what they want to do anywhere else, they will leave. So this "tax" of free soda and snacks is just a cost of doing business. And if you look at the revenue per employee, you do yourself no favor trying to maximize that number beyond the value that meets your net income numbers. The other thing that a number of middle managers miss is that once you are paying a person more than their "wants" level, you get more loyalty and commitment spending additional dollars on snacks and sodas etc than you do on cash.
- throwaway12522 10y ago[using a throwaway here to avoid offending anyone] I actually think there's a LOT of fat that could be cut at Google without affecting innovation. One person I know - I've literally never seen him wearing a shirt that he didn't get for free at Google. I've seen people get new Mac power adapters because the tech stop was closer than their desk. These things are pretty small compared to salaries - and they do serve a purpose - having to buy your own t-shirts and pay for your own gym membership is a pretty good reason never to quit, but I wonder how much they foster a culture of just throwing money at problems instead of innovating? I wonder how much they make Googlers soft and entitled.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoThat seems like a funny place to start cutting costs. You can run Google's datacenters for about 1 second on the same money as all those shirts. When these people talk about cost they are talking about headcount.
- throwaway12522 10y agoMy point is less about the t-shirts specifically (as I said, it's a minimal cost) and more about the company culture as a whole. If you can make a silly request for an office fire pole and the company will give you a fire pole, does that foster an attitude where you'll just throw more servers at a problem instead of thinking hard about your systems, or an attitude where a cool project will stay in development for a long time, even when the business case for it stops making sense.
- fdsaaf 10y agoThat fire pole costs a lot less than the salary increase you'd need in order to achieve the same level of employee retention. Google has quite a bit of engineering talent; you don't want that talent to evaporate for the sake of some short-term cost savings. Your scheme will absolutely affect innovation: it will cause innovators to leave. If you want to cut datacenter costs, reward engineers for impact, and include cost savings under your definition of impact. Engineers are pretty rational people and will respond to incentives.
- honkhonkpants 10y ago"her hiring package to almost $70 million." Everything you need to know about cost cutting under Ruth Porat.
- compiler-guy 10y agoThe value of the company jumped sixty-billion dollars after her first earnings report. So, roughly, in her first quarter at the company, she paid her entire compensation package back to the shareholders almost 900x over. Anyone with any stock in Google at that point would have been thrilled even if she never accomplished anything else. Seventy million was a steal.
- adrenalinelol 10y agoAttributing that gain solely to senior management in ridiculous.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- honkhonkpants 10y agoThat's pretty ridiculous. The company's leverage is not any individual's leverage for compensation purposes. We don't all expect to get paid for the net present value of our contributions to the company.
- olalonde 10y agoThat's assuming no one else could have accomplished that for 69M$ though :)
- compiler-guy 10y agoThe point isn't that no one else could have. The point is that no one else did. And I don't attribute it solely to her. Certainly the company's performance was the major factor. But the market was largely reacting to the change in certainty around Google's financial discipline.
- js8 10y agoAh, a "deletionist". A person who uses its own intelligence to justify what other people can't do, rather than trying to be (IMHO) actually helpful and using intelligence to figure out how to do stuff. Every human institution seems to get overrun by those, eventually.
- protomyth 10y agoI am more and more convinced that software developers need people who used to run tv shows (show runners) rather than people who worked for banks as managers. Also, what demented message does it send to your team that you trust them so little that you need to delay surgery rather than let them handle something? I regard this as a failure to lead or paranoia of others getting noticed.
- JamesBarney 10y agoI'm always very suspicious when a company saves easy to count money but pays with hard to count costs. For instance Google just got a little less cool. Everyone and their mother wants to work at Google, and the people who work there love it, and believe in Google's mission. But as it turns into a more standard profit-oriented company they will lose a lot of their kool-aid, and the Google kool-aid is an asset they have worth many billions. Unfortunately that asset isn't written down anywhere, and the books won't mark down the capital loss from this depreciation. If they did, a lot of these cost cutting measures probably wouldn't look so great.
- centicosm 10y agoI think something like that might be accounted for as Business Goodwill on a valuation (http://www.valuadder.com/glossary/business-goodwill.html http://www.valuadder.com/glossary/business-goodwill.html). It would definitely be interesting to know if it is actually included in some internal or public accounting valuation and if the accountants actually adjust the values in some way as it surely has some impact.
- JamesBarney 10y agoI think business goodwill is usually measured on the consumer side. And it's usually something like brand recognition like Coca-Cola. I've never seen it used to measure employee good-feelings/koolaid etc..
- mark_l_watson 10y agoI totally enjoyed that article. I am a Google fan, worked there as a contractor for a while and really enjoyed the way the company was run, infrastructure, and work. But, but, but... Google does have long term problems having a one-pony business. They really do have to win big on at least one 'Other Bets.' I am not a Finance person, but I think I understand how Facebook earns a lot of money long term, but in contrast Google's ad business does not look as good in the future of 'mostly mobile devices.'
- cbanek 10y agoThis reminds me of some of the cost cutting at Microsoft in the late 00's. One of the classic anger points was the free towel service. There were showers in some of the buildings, and towels were provided for free for employees to use (and leave there in a bin). Management said they could save a huge amount of money by getting rid of the benefit, and that most people don't use it. The amount of time spent on backlash emails was probably more than that. But it does seem inevitable that companies will go down this way as they age.