13 ms·
All quiet in the IPv4 Internet?
- okket 10y agoSlides from IETF96: https://www.ietf.org/proceedings/96/slides/slides-96-maprg-1.pdf https://www.ietf.org/proceedings/96/slides/slides-96-maprg-1... Paper: http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.00360.pdf http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.00360.pdf Edit: If you have some time and like high quality networking commentary (aka 'rants'), I strongly recommend to listen to this packet pusher episode with Geoff Huston, where he plays devil's advocate for IPv4. http://packetpushers.net/podcast/podcasts/show-275-future-of-networking-geoff-huston/ http://packetpushers.net/podcast/podcasts/show-275-future-of...
- nmc 10y ago(I know this is drifting off.) Geoff Huston is a phenomenal speaker (and researcher of course). If you have even more time and want to learn more about how the address spaces and routing tables are evolving, I definitely recommend his talk on BGP at RIPE 68 (2014) which I was lucky enough to attend. Video: https://ripe68.ripe.net/archives/video/131/ https://ripe68.ripe.net/archives/video/131/ Slides: https://ripe68.ripe.net/presentations/156-2014-05-12-bgp2013.pdf https://ripe68.ripe.net/presentations/156-2014-05-12-bgp2013... [EDIT] In another talk he indicates where you can get that kind of data on the Internet address space: http://www.routeviews.org/ http://www.routeviews.org/
- okket 10y agoGreat talk, thanks for the link!
- stock_toaster 10y agoWhat a great interview. Thanks for linking to it!
- Sniffnoy 10y agoA note -- if you're linking to arXiv, it's better to link to the abstract (http://arxiv.org/abs/1606.00360 http://arxiv.org/abs/1606.00360) rather than directly to the PDF. From the abstract, one can easily click through to the PDF; not so the reverse. And the abstract allows one to do things like see different versions of the paper, search for other things by the same authors, etc. Thank you!
- jedberg 10y agoThe lack of usage in static blocks isn't entirely surprising. A lot of universities got their IP space early and utilize it poorly. I know this because it is in part my fault. When we were assigning IP addresses for the dorms at Berkeley, we gave every dorm a /24, and then reserved the first 50 IPs for "future use" and "internal use". Most of those were never used. And unless 200 people signed up per building, some of the top end was missed too. My understanding is that they have since fixed this on the wifi since many people bring three or four devices now, but the hard wired connections are still poorly utilized.
- soulnothing 10y agoIt was the same thing when I was at University of Delaware. Each hard wire got a IPv4 public address. I lived in one of two apartment towers. From what I recall there were three /24s split between the two. Much like your setup the first 25 were reserved. In addition anything past that was rate limited. I recall anything past that was ~10->25Mbs. Going into the lower range though got around 500Mbs. I know similar stories from other state employees. The times when IPs were more prevalent.
- sp00ls 10y agoSame thing at SUNY Polytechnic (previously SUNYIT). Its been a few years since I left but when I was there all hardwired devices had a public IP address.
- wtbob 10y ago> Its been a few years since I left but when I was there all hardwired devices had a public IP address. Which is, of course, how it's supposed to be. I used to host a website from my dorm room. Every device on the Internet should have a public IP address!
- Walf 10y ago> Every device that wants to be on the Internet should have a public IP address! We don't need every network-connected device, with all their flaws accessible to the world. Unfortunately, IPv6 will not help us there.
- Animats 10y agoThey're only looking at IP addresses that access a big CDN as clients. They won't see servers that way. As mobile devices migrate to IPv6, the address space problem should be less. It's too bad that most mobile devices don't have permanent IPv6 addresses - more peer to peer applications would be possible.
- korethr 10y agoI'd say it's more like most mobile devices don't have IPv6 period, at least not here in the US. Every time I've done or seen network tests on a phone on the major cell carrier networks here in the US, there's been no IPv6 to be found.
- okket 10y ago"Major Mobile US Networks Pass 50% IPv6 Threshold for IPv6-Enabled Hosts" http://www.worldipv6launch.org/major-mobile-us-networks-pass-50-ipv6-threshold/ http://www.worldipv6launch.org/major-mobile-us-networks-pass... Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12338993 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12338993
- cmurf 10y agotmobile, ipv6 on lte everywhere I've been in the U.S. in the paste year with a Moto G (2015).
- daenney 10y agoThat site barely loads for me and I can't find an archive/cached link. I would expect a RIR to be able to handle this internet thing a bit better.
- madsushi 10y agoPublic IPs are about $10/each on the market. If you're running a serious service, $10 is a fairly small cost, so you just buy whatever you need. IPv4 exhaustion has mostly affected people that were getting addresses for "free".
- blowski 10y agoThis has confused me too. All this talk of IPv4 exhaustion, and yet I get a free one with every $5 Digital Ocean box.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoBecause DigitalOcean fought, and possibly paid, for their blocks for you. I don't do it any more but even in 2010-2011 getting blocks from ARIN took real work (ask for /18, get /19, lots of justification and explanation, etc). Now everybody's pretty much out. So I don't know DO's blocks, but very likely if they're running out they're having to buy more. Depending on how they cut it up a /16 -- I know they have at least one /16, because it came up here yesterday -- can serve at least 60,000 droplets or so.
- alexforster 10y agoThe main justification for getting more space is to show projected usage based on past usage. So if I get a /19 and use it in one month instead of three, I'll get an /18 next time, because that's about how much I'll need to sustain my growth. Rinse and repeat. Speaking on DO, it's likely that they grew so fast in the beginning they were able to acquire an awful lot of space.
- slyall 10y agoA couple of months ago I sold two networks (a /22 and a /24 ) that I had accumulated over the years. I got closer to $5/ip but a fairly small volume. A little bit of paperwork but not too bad. I thought it was interested that only a couple of years ago paying for IPs was very much against policy and now they even have pointers to brokers on the APNIC website.
- nvarsj 10y agoI'm happy that my ISP gives me a /29 ipv4 block :). An example of a real world effect is one of the largest fibre ISPs in the U.K. They are the only provider afaik to assign users internal IPs, which is then NAT'd. This then gets NAT'd on the router again - double NAT, woohoo! :) I know they desperately tried to get enough public space for all their customers, but were unable to buy a large enough space for it, so were forced into this position. Interestingly, the U.K. has at least two /8 ranges that aren't even advertised on the public internet, owned by MoD (25/8) and Department of Work & Pensions (51/8). That's 32 million addresses unused as far as anyone can tell from the outside.
- nmc 10y agoSeriously? They assign internal addresses (10/8, 172.16/12, 192.168/16) to all customers? Are you able to name the ISP?
- knorker 10y agoIs it rare? I think BT's cheaper broadbands do this, for one.
- tokenizerrr 10y agoI certainly have never encountered this, and would be really unhappy if my ISP pulled this stunt.
- j3097736 10y agoOnly the early players get the luxury of large IP pools, everyone else has had to resort to carrier-grade NAT. Fortunately some of those can un-NAT you if you ask politely.
- vertex-four 10y agoBT does this unless you either have an Unlimited package or opt out through their website.
- 10y ago
- kyledrake 10y agoI've pondered the IPv4 issue a lot, having recently acquired a /24 block for running an Anycast network (blog post coming soon). People have asked me my thoughts on IPv6 adoption, and I have to honestly say I'm pretty bearish on IPv6 being quickly adopted. I try to enable IPv6 on all my friends' routers, but even today, many routers, though they support 6 (notable exception being DD-WRT.. WTF), don't enable it by default, which means they don't enable the dual-stack configuration needed for transition. People then place these routers in a dusty area under their computers or behind their couches, where they sit, basically untouched, for 10+ years until they blow up and require replacement. The people I've talked to that happen to control a lot of IPv4 addresses tell me that even at the current ~$10-12/ip strike price, nobody is interested in selling because the IPs are more valuable to them for use with datacenters and leasing than for selling them at auctions. And nobody's putting pressure on the people that own huge IPv4 subnets (and I genuinely doubt use all of it) to start splitting them up and releasing them. Not to name names, but the original developers of the Internet come to mind (huge research universities like MIT). As such, I'm expecting the price of IPv4 addresses to increase substantially over the next 10 years, and I'm really not anticipating that price to drop for longer than that even. Because at the end of the day, if you want to support everybody, you need 4. And even today, dual stack is not the default option (despite ISPs like Comcast being ready for it). IMHO, If you need IPv4s for something like an Anycast network or a hosting service, the time to get them is now. As for IPv6 transition, the best way to improve this problem is to do your part to get ready for it: https://blog.apnic.net/2016/05/04/you-have-ipv6-turn-it-on/ https://blog.apnic.net/2016/05/04/you-have-ipv6-turn-it-on/
- johnbatch 10y agoSometimes last year it looks like Xerox split the 13.0.0.0/8 Selling a /11 to Microsoft (13.64.0.0/11) and a /14 to Salesforce (13.108.0.0/14)
- kyledrake 10y agoWhich means it won't be available for people that want to run their own IP subnets. I doubt they'll be splitting it into /24-/16s and reselling it anytime soon.
- byuu 10y agoOn this topic, does anyone have any advice for pressuring ISPs to move on IPv6? I've tried calling and public shaming Wide Open West to no avail. They don't seem to care at all. Time Warner Cable is the next fastest ISP (and they do support IPv6), but they want almost the same price for 1/12th the speed (600mbit/s WOW vs 50mbit/s TWC); so I begrudgingly stick with WOW anyway =(
- dreamcompiler 10y agoAssuming consumer-grade router manufacturers started fully enabling IPv6 by default (and ISPs did too), how does Grandma get the automatic firewall-ish security benefits NAT provides? Does the end of NAT mean Grandma has to start caring about firewall settings?
- sitharus 10y agoNo, consumer grade routers simply have a stateful ipv6 firewall that blocks incoming connections, just like NAT did.
- dreamcompiler 10y agoExactly the answer I was hoping to hear. Thanks.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y agoNAT does not provide any security benefits at all. A stateful packet filter does, with IPv6 just as with IPv4.
- therein 10y agoIt does provide somewhat of an isolation on the WAN side. If your grandma installs ElasticSearch on her box, she won't get pwned because it listens on 0.0.0.0 on her laptop and she didn't get the latest updates and is vulnerable to RCE.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y agoPlease explain how NAT provides isolation on the WAN side.
- dreamcompiler 10y agoNAT doesn't isolate your router, but it does isolate devices behind your router from unsolicited WAN-side connections (modulo hacking the router itself and hijacking sessions, of course). How is this not a security benefit?
- shmerl 10y agoStill waiting for any ISP in my area to start supporting IPv6. They seem to have fallen asleep about it.
- swingbridge 10y agoAs the article points out theres a big difference between addresses being allocated and addresses being used.
- nashashmi 10y agoOne thing I cannot understand about the transition to ipv6 is why weren't all ipv4 addresses converted via encoding to ipv6. This way ipv4 and ipv6 could talk to each other. And all service websites could jump on the ipv6 bandwagon without hiccups. By encoding, I mean every ipv4 segment would be encoded as a hexadecimal set and that would be merged into an ipv6 category under a special prefix.
- calumrobinson 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/6to4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/6to4
- XorNot 10y agoThat is not the problem. The problem is how does a 32 bit address represent all possible 128 bit addresses? It can't, period. Ipv4 devices cannot route to ipv6.
- wmf 10y agoThat sounds like a good idea until you try to implement it and discover all the problems: http://archive.is/eHvKF http://archive.is/eHvKF HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10854570 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10854570