19 ms·
Why I Majored in Philosophy Despite Everyone Telling Me Not To (2013)
- oldmanjay 10y ago> For some of us philosophy majors, we are just genuinely curious about some notions in life that are often taken for granted. For instance, is our ability to have rational thought just a product of our brainwaves, the interaction of different neurotransmitters? Or is there something more going on, something "supernatural" that allowed humans the capacity for rational dialogue? What a shame a philosophy education confers no ability to address such a question meaningfully.
- pmoriarty 10y agoWhether it does or it doesn't is itself a philosophical question. If you are interested in that question, you are interested in philosophy. The same goes for a lot of other questions that people might not at first blush consider philosophical questions, such as most any questions containing the word "should". I've found it interesting to see what extreme negative reactions a lot of people have to the very idea of studying philosophy or even being interested in philosophical questions. They're really outraged and think it's a complete waste of time, usually not realizing how much of what they believe and of the world around them has been and continues to be shaped by philosophy and philosophers.
- Gracana 10y agoI think that was intended to be a jab at the author/article.
- panic 10y agoIt's possible to be interested in philosophy while criticizing the field as it is taught. If you want to know how and whether the workings of the brain can produce rational thought, you'd be better off pursuing a neuroscience education.
- pmoriarty 10y ago> It's possible to be interested in philosophy while criticizing the field as it is taught. Absolutely. Criticism of philosophy is itself usually a philosophical undertaking. > If you want to know how and whether the workings of the brain can produce rational thought, you'd be better off pursuing a neuroscience education. That's a philosophical position, and very open to debate.
- parennoob 10y agoWell, I think some part of the negative reactions stem from the fact that the scope of philosophy is incredibly narrow these days, and largely limited to speculative analyses. For example, experiments that detect electro-chemical impulses in the brain and compare them during various moods would classically have been squarely in the center of a philosopher's work. But today, they are part of biology, or psychology, or some other science that has split away from what was once philosophy. As a result, (referring to the original example), literally "Whether it does or it doesn't" is the only problem that is under the aegis of philosophy -- everything else has been delegated to some science or the other.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hosh 10y agoI've been enjoying these comments, particularly the ones by pmoriarty. I'm not really adding anything meaningful here: I used to have a negative reaction to philosophy. Somewhere in the past few years as I was getting into my mid-30s, I've been finding myself studying it more. I will say though, I'm approaching philosophy from Eastern studies. It's my understanding that a philosophy degree in an American university is heavily focused on Western philosophy. I know nearly nothing about Western philosophy (that is, nothing more than the average Joe on the street). However, whenever I read something written by people who are trained in philosophy, I marvel at the clarity of the writing, even if I don't always agree with them.
- pmoriarty 10y agoThank you for your kind words. I have a great interest in Eastern philosophy, and think it undeservedly gets very short shrift in Western universities. That seems to be getting somewhat better in modern times, however, as common ground is discovered between Eastern and Western philosophy, and it's beginning to be recognized how much the former has influenced the latter and how much more there is to learn.
- aidenn0 10y agoA lot of philosophy departments are very poor[1] (nothing surprising here, a lot of CS departments are also very poor). On top of that, it seems to me that, at least outside the most prestigious schools (e.g. Ivy's), philosophy departments at schools with respected CS programs, are even less likely to be high quality. This is exacerbated when you compare the quality of the CS program to the quality of the philosophy program, since we are already talking about schools with quality CS programs. This means that the average HNer likely went to a school where the quality of the philosophy department is much lower than the CS department. So when an HNer says "A philosophy education sucks" they really mean "A poor philosophy education is worse than a quality CS education" This is exacerbated by the fact that the first several philosophy courses one might take typically focus on gaining a groundwork in philosophy. It's not unlike someone finishing elementary school thinking math is just boring arithmetic. At the school I went to, the smartest student in a philosophy class was typically an engineering dropout, and the intellectual rigor of the classes was poor because they weren't allowed to fail 50% of the students (unlike engineering, where that fraction would be high, but not eyebrow raising). For most of the time I was an undergrad, I thought that all philosophy majors were less intelligent than STEM majors and philosophy was not at all intellectually rigorous. 1: When I say "poor" I am being a bit vague, but consider it a qualitative mix of the faculty, curriculum, and students. Of course these 3 things are very closely interrelated as curriculum difficulty is adjusted to the level of the students, faculty has some control over the curriculum, and having quality faculty and curriculum will attract better students.
- ubernostrum 10y agoWhat a shame a philosophy education confers no ability to address such a question meaningfully. The counterpoint, of course, is that over the course of human history, philosophy has a better track record than anything else at producing fruitful inquiry and results. It's just that the results always end up branded as entirely new fields of study, meaning that what's left in the "philosophy" bucket is the stuff which hasn't yet been productive enough to spawn an entire separate field.
- dghf 10y agoThis kind of speculation is hardly the preserve of philosophy students, either. It has to be one of the top 10 topics of drunken (and stoned) conversations among undergraduates of all disciplines.
- pmoriarty 10y agoAn interesting list of some famous people with philosophy degrees: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1k1qSRoDpuOeDVkYm10bTg3V3lCUGEtRGJoVDRaOU1fSWx3/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1k1qSRoDpuOeDVkYm10bTg3V3l...
- dmerrick 10y agoThe one that stood out to me most was Jean-Paul Sartre. Wouldn't it make sense for a philosopher to have a philosophy degree?
- jimbokun 10y agoHaha, of course Phil Jackson is on there! His nickname was the "Zen Master" and used to give his players books for gifts to influence their thinking.
- c3534l 10y agoAll of those people are in careers infamous for being oversaturated and almost impossible to make a living off of or went on to get graduate degrees in law.
- saintzozo 10y agoI'm going to reproduce a reddit post I made recently that I think is relevant: Analytic philosophy has made my mind a razor. It forged in me the confidence and mental discipline to learn anything, and I'm now dominating the tech scene despite having little in the way of formal coursework. I was lucky to choose one of the few disciplines that can be fruitfully studied at Brown. As any student of a rigorous discipline, I was ultimately responsible for my own intellectual growth; everything I ever truly learned has been in solitude. The less-than-brilliant technical faculty, weak course offerings, and charlatan arts professors had little negative impact on me. In fact, being forced to retreat within myself was necessary for my success, because it allowed me to look at reality more critically, unmired by the prejudices and preoccupations of the misguided or less thoughtful around me. I have nearly everything I want in life, but I was lucky to (1) pursue rigorous scholarship and (2) be born with the abilities and personality that made such a pursuit feasible at Brown. The less intelligent[^] or more impressionable will be made failures at Brown. Those are the people I'm trying to warn. [^] For example, those who were not invited to attend a better Ivy League university. It's very tempting for someone in this position to choose Brown over a better option simply because it is wrongfully perceived as prestigious for technically being an Ivy.
- rublev 10y agoComments like that are lost on Reddit. Reddit isn't about discourse, it's about upvotes. The whole "just find good small subreddits" also doesn't work unless you subscribe to their specific early-stage cults mentality. And each sub has one.
- saintzozo 10y agoThat has been my experience, unfortunately.
- hkmurakami 10y agoQuestion -- you say that you are a person who is able to learn in solitude. Would you have been able to pursue your dive into Philosophy without the environment that Brown offered you? I ask this for a few reasons. 1) I have a fairly strong interest in the discipline, but have found rigorous self guided study to be a challenge, beyond cursory readings of the classics and a smattering of modern theorists like Singer. 2) I feel that a fortunate circumstance today that the fastest growing, lucrative profession is programming, which now has a wealth of online resources for new entrants to get started and become proficient. Many other technical disciplines require prohibitively expensive lab equipment to learn the craft. I wonder if philosophy is a discipline within the humanities that is more difficult to cultivate in a self-directed fashion than others.
- huac 10y ago> Grant studies at Wake Forest, where he majors in philosophy and economics.
- fennecfoxen 10y agoAh, a double-major. Good times, lots of fun. I minored in studio art at Wake Forest myself: impractical for money, but helps keeps you sane, and it's nice to do something that's very Physical after you've been on computers all day.
- catuskoti 10y agoWell, to the tune of $60,000 dollars/year, I wonder how much longer people are going to "become a more whole human being". There are cheap conjectures and ideologies, and then there are the really expensive ones! What about pulling your own weight and produce something that other people would be willing to pay for? That may make sense too, no?
- nitwit005 10y ago> But hey, is it really worth it to spend upwards of $60,000 a year to read books that will still be around after graduating? Well, for some with eyes for graduate school it may be. > Rock on fellow baristas, rock on Finally, my dream of being a graduate student working at a coffee shop...
- ycombinatorMan 10y agoPhilosophy is for delusional people.
- unit91 10y agoI hope you realize that your statement is absolutely loaded with philosophical undertones. A few examples: - Is being deluded bad? If so, what is it that makes being deluded bad? You might say "Oh come on! Of course it's bad! We can all see that!" But is that just your opinion, or is it objectively bad? If it's objectively true that I ought to have an accurately informed view of reality instead of being deluded, what is this ought-making property? What grounds it? Is it a moral duty (e.g., I ought not murder), or an intellectual duty (e.g., I ought to think Austin is the capital of Texas)? Is there a difference between moral and intellectual duties? - Why is philosophy for delusional people, instead of rational people? Surely you recognize that "philosophy is for delusional people" is itself a philosophical statement! - Being deluded assumes a theory of truth, and an epistemological theory (how we come to know what we know). You seem to know that philosophy is for delusional people -- on what grounds do you know it? What counts as justification for this belief, and how would you account for Gettier counterexamples to warrant? - I imagine you don't count all fields of study as being reserved for the delusional. What about math or science? If it is the case that math and science are legitimate sources of knowledge, but philosophy is not, how do you justify this claim? You can't prove it mathematically, or verify it in a laboratory. Thus, this scientistic view is self-refuting -- and surely that's for really delusional people!
- sctb 10y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly violating the HN guidelines after we asked you to stop. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- andrewguy9 10y agoBecause I'm really stubborn.
- xupybd 10y agoSounds great if you can afford to avoid a more marketable degree. In better economic times this might seem more sensible to me but if you want to learn how to be a better human there are cheaper ways.
- HarrietTubgirl 10y agoCONGRATULATIONS
- sebringj 10y agoAfter taking some in college, philosophy to me was more like a stepping stone in critical thinking to embracing the light of science. I've noticed on so many youtube forums for example, people postulate things without external verification in nature, "if this then that" where tautologies and vin diagrams and the like are held as absolute truths. It never was sold on that as there are more dimensions to reality than our simple minds can grasp within a cleverly worded statement. The main point being is observing nature always trumps anything philosophy will ever invent on its own. Philosophy is a nice way to help frame hypothesis if you keep in mind that's all it can ever do and not take it too seriously. I do give philosophy the proper respect it deserves for starting the fire of thinking deeper so I could grasp what quality information actually was, but then you must step off of it as something unreliable unto itself.
- pmoriarty 10y agoScience can certainly be an interesting pastime, can provide lots of interesting and intellectually stimulating results, is arguably responsible for the technical advances we see around us, and you're likely to make more money and get more respect as a scientist than as a professional philosopher, but how much we're learning about the wold through science is very much open to debate. For one, the scientific study of perception itself (not to mention the study of chemistry and physics) brings in to question how much of what we perceive is real. The solid-seeming table not really being at all as solid as it seems, or the small trees in the distance not really being small being some of the commonest and simplest examples. There are plenty of other examples, from optical illusions to a wide variety of phenomena detected through experimental aparatus but not usually available to our senses, such as x-rays, viruses, and so on. Such phenomena and the stories scientists use to explain them have lead to the widespread questioning of the reality of the world as we commonly experience it, and even to questioning if the world itself is a simulation -- questions from physicists, no less. These are philosophical questions, but ones I'm not convinced that science is equipped to answer. I'm not sure what experiments could ever be performed to determine whether ultimately, deep down, whatever scientific instruments detect or theories postulate is "really real" or just illusion. At the most basic level, it's questionable whether science ever even "gets closer to" some kind of ultimate "truth", or whether they're always just attempts to explain mere apperances. There are many other objections to the claim that science is the only true, valid, or legitimate way of acquiring knowledge, and to the claim that scientific results are either true or approaching truth. But I'll spare you in the interest of not making this post in to a book or boring you any more than I already have. I'll just point to you these articles on Skepticism[1], Epistemology[2], and Scientism[3] and move on to pointing out that even were we to grant that the practice of science gives us access to truth, there are still some realms off-limits to it, such as (more specifically) ethical questions, and more generally telling us how we should act when given a choice. There are no experiments which can be performed that can show us which is the "right", "moral" or "ethical" choice in any given situation. One could certainly survey some population, but that would only tell you what some people think is right, moral, or ethical, not what actually is (unless you think what the majority believe must be true, which is yet another philosophical position and up for debate). So this is yet another example where science just stands mute, and I don't see any way it'll ever be able to speak on these subjects. I think most well educated scientists realize these limits of science, and consequently don't make grand claims for the Truth of what they're discovering or the superiority of science over other fields. In fact, those subjects and such claims are off-limits in most if not all scientific journals. It's outside scientific journals, and one could say outside of science proper that such claims are heard, and they're often made either by science fans who are not scientists, or by scientists who really haven't studied the philosophy of science much and get a little too carried away with the popular view of science. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skepticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skepticism [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemology [3] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism
- tomlock 10y agoI majored in Philosophy because I'm not optimizing my life for maximum profit.
- Mendenhall 10y agoDime store philosophy. Some just want to be seen as philosophers and regurgitate what others told them about anothers work. I always had a passion for philosophy, I read massive amounts before even going to college. I would read the ancient greek books that had english on one page greek on the other then use a concordance to basically teach myself ancient greek while making sure I had the context correct and not miss anything in translation. Just for fun, All of Plato, Platonist, Gracian, the Gita, Miyamoto, Zen koans, I Ching, Aurelius and many more before even stepping foot in college. I find there is a huge difference between a philospher and someone who studied philosphy. You can always tell by their copy and pasted thoughts and the disconnect between their mostly modern definitions and what was actually the definition when the terms "started". Those who regurgitate others words in the wish to appear worldly and wise are such a bore compared to those who are actual philosophers. Dime store philosophers give the real ones a bad name.
- meric 10y agoI suppose that is a good reason to wear a rough cloak and hide the jade in your heart.
- Mendenhall 10y ago:) Till it is time to take the cloak off.
- usgroup 10y agoI'd say philosophers study philosophers... Not sure when that wasn't true? Aristotle being the most famous academic philosopher ... The thing that annoyed me was the number of philosophers that don't study anything else but proceed to talk about it. Stuff that hinges on politics or psychology for example where philosophers just assume that something is human or social nature . Or when we assume that justice is somehow primary in ethics . Etc
- Mendenhall 10y agoI would disagree and say philosophers study philosophy and I use study in a loose sense meaning "look into". I dont think you can read your way or study your way into philosophy. To me that is studying someone elses work not philosophy. Oddly enough I find aristotle a bore, he was too myopic and clinical when philosophy is no such thing. He was firmly rooted in the shadow cast on the wall and not what was casting the shadow for my taste. I would fall in the same camp as you and be annoyed by the "philosophers" that dont study anything else and proceed talk about it. I find most "philosophers" to not even be philosophers, they just like to be considered so.
- nurettin 10y agoFalse: philosophy majors don't/can't have any marketable skills - they can write books and make a living on controversial subjects. True: Philosophy is a way towards impeccable logic and humanity - thanks for saving us technically oriented purists from destroying ourselves and eating eachother alive.
- dasil003 10y agoProbably a good idea to take advantage of that last freedom to pursue what really interests you before you have to go get a fucking job.
- sunstone 10y agoAs my friend said of narcotics, they're ok just don't make them a career.
- GoToRO 10y agoIt's the difference between common people education, and really reach people education: common people need to learn things that will help them make a living, like programming; reach people already have the money so they get the best education, the one that really opens your mind, like philosophy, history, arts etc., plus some to help them keep power. It's just how things are.
- johan_larson 10y agoI studied some philosophy in college, and found the experience pretty disappointing. The field addresses some really fascinating problems, but I'm not too impressed with their answers. A typical assignment in philosophy consists of thinking about a really hard problem with no good solutions, picking one, and arguing for it. And since there are so few fixed points, almost anything is arguable. Really, it's a debater's paradise. If I were to do undergrad all over again, with an emphasis on mental calisthenics rather than job skills, I'd study physics and history. Physics is rigorous and really builds your analytical skills. History is deep and builds your research and writing skills. But both are ultimately grounded in reality. There are none of those oh so precious arguments about whether reality is even there.
- jraedisch 10y agoThe rules of logic should be applied in philosophy as in physics. If you don't do that, or there is no competent judge (e.g. teacher) things tend to get out of hand, especially with people studying philosophy because they "can't do math".
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoI thought people do programming because they "can't do math"?
- objectiveariel 10y agoI love this bit: "I prefer to spend my college years searching, exploring, and wondering, as opposed to training to become an "asset" in the file cabinet of a "human resource" department. Rock on fellow baristas, rock on." Translation: "I'll come out of university with no transferrable skills whatsoever. Dreadfully unintellectual dead-end jobs are where I'll be able to keep pursuing my love of knowledge". Dude. The author's bio is probably the most important part of this article: "Grant studies at Wake Forest, where he majors in philosophy and economics." Translation: "I'm passionate about half the university course I'm currently doing and have absolutely no idea how the job market will treat me when I'm done with it." Full disclosure: I myself studied philosophy at university. I'm proud of it, but I'd never boast about how poorly it prepared me for the job market.
- lagadu 10y ago> I'm proud of it, but I'd never boast about how poorly it prepared me for the job market. This is what I don't get: why is there an assumption that what you study at university has to be in any way related to the job market? You study something because you have an interest in developing it further, being able to get a job doing it is just a secondary perk.
- chestervonwinch 10y ago> why is there an assumption that what you study at university has to be in any way related to the job market? Because, like it or not, the majority of people's education is the means to obtain a job in a related field. People don't go tens of thousands of dollars into debt for some l'art pour l'art interest development; they do it because they expect the benefit from the degree (i.e., as a ticket into the job market in a field related to the degree) to outweigh the cost.
- RandomOpinion 10y ago>Because, like it or not, the majority of people's education is the means to obtain a job in a related field. The community college system is more than enough for those who view postsecondary education as a mere vocational program and doesn't require going "tens of thousands of dollars into debt".
- yodsanklai 10y agoI studied a bit of philosophy in high school, but it didn't really interest me at that time. But getting older, I realize that philosophical questions are pervasive. A lot of our contemporary debates and our disagreements are rooted in philosophical questions. Unfortunately, I find philosophy to be very arid and I'm sure it doesn't have to be that way. For one thing, a lot of philosophy books discuss past philosophers ideas. Of course, some of their thoughts are still valid, but they're very obfuscated and hard to follow for a modern reader. It's like if we were asking math students to read Euclide to learn about geometry.
- SupremumLimit 10y agoI get your point, but Euclid's books are still being sold (in translation): https://www.amazon.com/Euclids-Elements-Euclid/dp/1888009195 https://www.amazon.com/Euclids-Elements-Euclid/dp/1888009195
- yodsanklai 10y agoSeems I didn't pick the best example :) it has actually great reviews!
- yanickmartel 10y agoI think it's a degree that teaches you how to think. You don't need a degree to learn this. But one could argue that you don't need a degree to be a software engineer either.
- noir-york 10y agoI did politics, philosophy and economics (PPE) at uni. I knew I could find a job as an economist or in politics but ended up as a product manager for an IT security company. Analytical/continental philosophy is intellectual masturbation; clever scholasticism to keep (mostly) marxists in cushy jobs. On the other hand, the history of ideas and political philosophy has been much more intellectually stimulating and rewarding. It's fine to study subjects which may not have any necessarily obvious value in the job market - there is value in being a critical thinker especially if used well (say, as a public intellectual) Scientists are the most expensive: they need labs. Mathematicians are cheaper: paper, pencils and erasers. But philosophers are the cheapest: paper and pencils, they don't need the erasers.
- osullivj 10y ago"Philosophy is the discipline whose adherents kick up a load of dust, then complain they can't see". Murray Gell-Mann. Mind you, I do have a degree in Philosophy from a faculty very firmly in the analytic school. Logic, metaphysics and ontology have been helpful in thinking about software problems. For instance, you can think of Russell's On Denoting ("the king of France is bald") as being about null pointers, or dangling pointers. And Kripke's rigid designators are a solution to the bad pointer problem. One of my lecturers, Jeremy Butterfield, would always exclaim "because Quine is our hero" whenever he mentioned the great man. "No entity without identity" and "to be is to be the value of a bound variable" are useful rules for software design as well as ontology.
- turnersr 10y agoDo you mind please explaining rigid designators from Kripke and how they apply to pointers? That sounds like a neat insight! :D
- osullivj 10y agohttp://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rigid-designators/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rigid-designators/ A rigid designator designates the same object in all possible worlds. Translation to software terms: a safe pointer/reference refers to the same object in all possible process lifetimes. Consider Python: everything is an object, including integers. If you look into the C implementation of CPython you'll see that the runtime creates certain commonly used object up front, rather than on demand as is the case for most objects. IIRC integers 0 to 10 are created upfront. So if we exec 'i = 0' in Python and don't change i then i refers to the same object every time we execute. It's a rigid designator!
- dschiptsov 10y agoYou forgot the precision of language usage and precision and clarity of definitions, which has been the foundation of math - the way to deal with meaningful abstractions, and then so called computer science, where naming, clarity and reduced to the essence (to an optimum) abstractions (ADTs) are the most important aspects. Classification (ontology) and labeling of a human language gives us meaningful type systems (Java has nothing to do with it). Logic gave us control structures and ultimately algorithms. The philosophy of science and epistemology gave us the absolute necessity of tests and reality checks (otherwise one ends up with Hegelian abstract nonsense or what we call theoretical physics). And metaphysics is just nonsense for weak minded to boost their self-esteem, which gave us "everything must be Object Oriented, statically typed, absurdly verbose" crap.
- timwaagh 10y agoMost of the criticism i have regarding the humanities and philosophy in particular does not apply to the american situation as people there pay for their own education. if a private individual wants to spend some time developing as a human being, reading classic texts, admiring thinkers of past ages and polishing his rhetoric and is willing to pay. then i say that's a good choice and power to him. if a government pays for someone to train in something which serves no economic purpose, then the government is wasting its money. i do like philosophy. i love a good argument. i read 'philosophy magazine'. but i don't think the garbageman should have to pay for my habit.
- pitt1980 10y agowho pays for their own education? usually it's some combination of parents and government backed loans or grants even when people pay for their own education in the form of future loans, they're doing so with highly imperfect information about what it will mean to pay them back (which I don't think is necessarily an argument against studying philosophy, learning to think rigorously can be highly practical)
- throwaway729 10y agoSo how do you square that with the fact that a lot of secondary education is not remotely "useful" for most jobs? The most common argument I've heard for universal secondary education is that some amount of liberal education is necessary for a functioning democracy. Which I think is definitely true, and the only question is where to draw the line. It's clear to me that we shouldn't draw the line prior to literacy and basic numeracy, but it's not clear why the current position of the line -- right between secondary and higher education -- is more meritorious than any other position.
- dschiptsov 10y agoI would like it too if someone would pay my bills..)
- impostervt 10y agoI recently discovered an interest in philosophy, and found this book a great introduction. There's lots of different types of philosophy - maybe you're interested in what makes a government good, or maybe you're more into the whole "what is reality" part of it - and this book provides an introduction to the different types, as well as the major philosophers from the last 25000 years. https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-Book-Ideas-Simply-Explained/dp/0756668611/ref=sr_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1473944547&sr=1-3&keywords=philosophy https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-Book-Ideas-Simply-Explaine...
- anotherarray 10y agoI waited to have a established career and money to pursue a Philosophy degree just for the sake of it. Many Americans obsess about graduating in their "dream field" before they're 22. It's much better not to worry about food, roommates, books, and so forth.
- norea-armozel 10y agoI like some parts of philosophy like Whitehead, Dennett, and Rachels but beyond them I really find most philosophers to be intentionally too murky. So, I'm impressed when someone dares to slog through philosophy and come up with something of substance from it. But honestly, I think people are better served by majoring in math and only taking a minor in philosophy if they weren't hard set on any given field of study.
- bbctol 10y agoPhilosophy's got a lot of different schools, and there are plenty of people who major in it and still stick to the dry and analytic (confusing because it uses way too many numbers and greek letters) and avoid the continental style (confusing because it uses way too many made up words and rambling anecdotes.)
- danielam 10y agoAdd Derrida and other postmodernists to the list of those practicing "obscurantisme terroriste".
- norea-armozel 10y agoI can barely tolerate Foucault. And I've tried Derrida but I've always wind up giving up since he just makes no sense to me. Then there's Zizek. That's one person I just can't bother to listen to because I don't know what the hell he's on about half the time (I tried reading his essay on transgender politics and wound up giving up after the first paragraph).
- pmoriarty 10y agoIt doesn't make sense to you probably because you haven't had enough education in philosophy. The thing is that philosophy rarely happens in a vacuum. Usually philosophers build on and respond to the ideas of other philosophers. So to really understand and see where they're coming from, you have to understand their predecessors and the dialogue which has been going on for thousands of years. To understand the trickier philosophers like Derrida or some other Continentals, you're probably also going to need the help of a talented teacher who understands these philosophers themselves -- someone you're unlikely to find in Analytic philosophy departments where contempt for Continentals reigns. At best, you're going to get a strongly distorted view of Derrida as Analytics see him. That will not do justice to his thought. That said, I'm not a fan of Derrida myself. I much prefer Nietzsche and Heidegger. Foucault's cool too, though, for his attempts to address power, punishment, mental illness and marginalized portions of society -- all subjects that other philosophers ever touch. I should read more of him.
- todd8 10y agoIt seems that the benefits of majoring in philosophy are confounded by the difficulty of the subject. Let me explain. There are subjects, say Philosophy or Physics, that are some of the more demanding undergraduate majors and yet have limited job markets. Simply getting through a Philosophy major signals that one is capable of deep thinking, abstract thought, the ability to read book after book of long complex argumentation and understand it in its historical context. Physics places similarly difficult (but differing) demands upon its students. A major in Philosophy signals to potential employers that this person can read, write, and think clearly; a major in Physics does the same with an emphasis on math and science. Such employees can be valuable because they are almost certainly have high intelligence, they have demonstrated discipline, and have a good work ethic. The downside is that it isn't entirely obvious of what use they are to an organization; they will require training and time to learn for many potential jobs. I would consider something like a Philosophy or Physics undergraduate degree combined with a Masters in CS to be a perfectly adequate, although drawn out, education for the job market.
- jdlyga 10y agoIn general: if everyone is telling you not to do something, then there's probably a good reason. Even if you're 100% sure that you're right and everyone is wrong.
- metaphorm 10y agothis is from 2013 and the author was an undergraduate at the time. its now 3 years later. this is his LinkedIn profile https://www.linkedin.com/in/gferowich https://www.linkedin.com/in/gferowich he appears to have done a bit of freelance writing and editing, but generally not gotten very far into a "real job" as most of us would understand it. this is not a criticism. he's very young and seems to be off to a reasonably good start for a career in writing. that said, the author seems to have strongly emphasized his social media clout (twitter account mentions "most viewed philosophy/existentialism on Quora" or some other inane thing like that) as if that was some sort of accomplishment. maybe this is just a generation gap thing. I'm > 10 years older than this fellow and I really don't relate to that at all. Damn kid's today. Get off my lawn. so what's my point? that Philosophy as a major seems roughly equivalent to ANY non-technical major you might take as an undergrad. that's to say, it doesn't fuckin matter. if you enjoy it and feel comfortable spending all that money on your degree for it, then go ahead, but as far as career goes it probably has no greater value than any other humanities major. I know I know, sample size n=1. I'm not trying to generalize from this anecdote. My previous paragraph is meant as a statement of opinion only. Still, it is readily observed and I think many others would corroborate it. In other words I disagree with the point of the linked article. There is no good reason to study Philosophy in school. I say this as a person who dropped out of a philosophy major in school, spent years living in "fun-employment" (that means poverty if you didn't get it) and then went back to school for computer science and got a real job. I never lost my interest in philosophy. If anything I've read more, learned more, and had better discussions as a non-academic amateur enthusiast than I ever did while studying this stuff in school. Studying philosophy is all well and good. In my opinion, in 2016 in America, it is probably no longer a good idea to do this in the academy. The benefits of this study (gaining deep insights that inform how we live) are available to anyone who can read and find a decent forum (online or meatspace) to participate in. The academy is no longer necessary and may now be an impediment to studying philosophy, because it's so unreasonably expensive, and our society has shifted towards expecting university education to be career/money/job skills oriented.
- uxp100 10y agoI like this. It's short, and covers how influential philosophy has been. And I have no problem with snark from someone who's interest has become the butt of cheap jokes. However, when it comes to the greater conversation, I'm less generous. I think an aspect of the supposed STEM vs Humanities divide is class, which seems like a bit of a stretch now that I write it down. I chose the most fascinating, lucrative, TRADE I could. And damn, it pays well. And now people who had the freedom to go to an expensive University and 'explore themselves' can condescend to me while also feeling persecuted by me. And my coworkers condescend back, but I remain interested in the humanities, but it just was not a choice to go to college for the fun of it. I was the first in my family to go to college, and from the start it was understood that this was my ticket to the upper middle class, where your parents aren't in tears figuring out how to pay their bills. (Although we did OK, Dad found another job, etc. Never actually went broke. My mom just might be the type to cry when frustrated.) When people had the freedom to go to college to explore themselves and the humanities, and you weren't expected to justify your degree, mostly rich people went to college. As a small minded reformist Bourgeoisie, I'm OK with this. Now is better than then. Lets make college even better in the future for everyone, not just my kids, who will be free to explore themselves with post-colonial vaporwave music production. PS My father was in a real trade, I don't actually think of Software Engineering as a trade, but I do think there is a class thing here.
- uxp100 10y agoI'm out of my edit window, but I am aware Bourgeoisie is the class, I should have said I am a small minded Bourgeois. Post-colonial vaporwave music production is an associates degree. My children can get degrees in post-colonial power electronics music composition. Also, to apologize for that snark, post colonial theory is interesting, music composition is very interesting.
- aporetics 10y agoThe Athens of Plato's time was a society built on slave labor. They were a strictly patriarchal society (women weren't allowed to leave the house much), and to be a citizen meant you didn't need to work for a living. In short: a degree and a kind of classism we have difficulty imagining. None of this mitigates the lessons that Plato, Aristotle, Heraclitus, Pythagoras, etc., have left behind for us, and which await us at the local library (or liberal arts college). You're right that access to higher education is not where it should be. This is well understood, protested, discussed, etc. But the decision to pursue more or less lucrative paths is a free decision. You may well be coerced by issues attending economic inequality. You may face great sacrifice in order to devote yourself to something like philosophy[1]. And certainly the decision is inextricable from (let's not forget) your family life (oh, you want kids? you want to live in a real house, not a tenement house? you want healthcare and a minimal retirement fund?). But these are decisions about what kind of life you want to lead, and the examples above are about the comforts you may want in life. It is not a coincidence that philosophy's purview lies in asking the questions that help you understand why you value what you do, and base your decisions accordingly. And it may even turn out that, in the course of better understanding why you have found something meaningful in the past, that you no longer find it quite so meaningful. You may, in fact, have turn of heart, and start a new chapter in your life. It would be great if we had social values that translated into an economy which enabled academic pursuits instead of hampered them. (If you think this is idealism run amok, take a look at Finland[2], with the best primary education system in the world, where getting a degree in education is as competitive and prestigious as becoming a doctor; not coincidentally, those careers garner similar salaries). But we're not there yet. Maybe what's needed are more philosophy majors. [1] http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/gifted-teachers-life-of-the-mind-was-also-life-of-near-destitution/ http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/gifted-teachers-lif... [2] https://www.google.com/#q=finland+education+system https://www.google.com/#q=finland+education+system
- 6stringmerc 10y agoAnecdote: The smartest, intellectual, brilliant software developer / computer programmer I've ever come across taught Logic II as an adjunct. He had his PhD in Philosophy and could drown us with Second Order of Calculus so fast we didn't know how it happened. He was so gracious it was almost comical. He could look at the board, look at the class, and sort of attempt to explain but it was clear he could see things ways we couldn't. I don't wish to go into much detail but I will state he - single handed (which I believe) - built an entire Regional Real Estate software suite from scratch over the years and was constantly upgrading it to keep with the times. No maintenance mode junk. He was the real deal.
- drjesusphd 10y ago"First they came for the philosophers..." We techies better be careful how we treat the humanities. The fact that our skills are in high demand is an accident of history. The powers that be find us very useful now, but that can change. There can come a time when the only reason to code or study math/science is out of passion, and then we'll be in the same boat as the philosopher. Then we'll have no moral high ground to stand on because we cannibalized the humanities in universities. Of course, if you're just in STEM for the money, then by all means chase the next thing when that time comes.
- gerby 10y agoI have a great respect for philosophers, and I consider myself a philosopher too. Look at Alex Karp at Palantir (Doctorate level in Philosophy) and Stewart Butterfield at Slack.. both were trained philosophers, and ended up building very successful companies that are relatively outside of what they studied in school.