18 ms·
To tell someone they're wrong, first tell them how they're right
- tmptmp 10y agoGood article and great advice. But I wish to make a qualification to the statement: To tell "someone" they're wrong, first tell them how they're right and make sure that the "someone" is not a psychopath or sociopath or a brainwashed person. Still as a liberal, I would start with an open mind (null hypothesis) but I will keep my analysis running and will keep on adjusting the hypothesis accordingly. Also depending on what is at stake, I will cut the analysis shorter and come to conclusion faster (and potentially wrong) so that I can take some action that is needed in time. Unfortunately, there are enough people in the world who are completely convinced of their superiority or of the superiority of their views/beliefs and if you tell them they are right they just use your statement as a testament to their advantage and if you later even try to tell them they are wrong then they will not hesitate to kill you. Some examples that come to mind are Hitler (blinded by Nazism) [1], prophet Muhammad (blinded by Islamism) [2], Stalin (blinded by communism) [3]. Because with such people it doesn't matter what you tell first or later. Sadly, that's the main reason why we need (have to face) wars. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_Hitler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_Hitler [2] http://www.faithfreedom.org/understanding-muhammad-free-download/ http://www.faithfreedom.org/understanding-muhammad-free-down... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Stalin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Stalin
- helthanatos 10y agoI've always felt more persuasive when doing that. I've also felt more persuaded when I'm not flat told I'm wrong.
- whistlerbrk 10y agoit flatters the ego, which can be belittling at times.
- danharaj 10y agoI think it is that by stating how someone is right, you are demonstrating a comprehensive understanding of their views which justifies your disagreement. It grounds your points in theirs, creating a shared position which is easier to understand than two positions that are simply smashed against each other until the more solid one prevails. I think someone who flatters the ego is cargo culting persuasion. It may work when people are more invested in the power relationship than the discussion, like a discussion between a worker and their boss, but otherwise yes I think it is belittling and someone trying to have a genuine dialogue is going to find it obnoxious and insincere.
- Mendenhall 10y agoAlways start from common ground and that which can be agreed upon. Although I do disagree that there was no formal study of "persuasion" before then. Socrates was trolling sophists long before then. Rhetoric = persuasion and thats what the sophists got paid to do. Read Gorgias.
- danielam 10y agoYou're headed in the right direction, but your characterization isn't accurate. Strictly speaking, Socrates wasn't trolling the sophists so much as drawing attention to their manipulative practices. The sophists weren't infamous for employing rhetoric, but rather sophistry and eristic. Here, rhetoric is to sophistry what polemic is to eristic. Where rhetoric is an art that emphasizes logical, sound, effective and clear communication for the purpose of persuading someone of a position that the rhetor believes to be true, the sophist employs fallacies, flattery and other methods of appeal to manipulate someone into accepting a position, regardless of the truth of that position, for other ends. The highest value for the sophist was oratory excellence and skillful use of language, not the attainment of truth. Analogously, the polemicist aims to dispute a position, but he does so while maintaining the same ethos as the rhetor, i.e., by attacking what he deems to be false for the sake of the truth. The eristic, on the other hand, shares the ethos of the sophist, i.e., he is unconcerned with the truth and aims only dispute for some other end. Josef Pieper's puts it well in his essay "Abuse of Language, Abuse of Power" when he says that when language is disconnected from truth, it becomes an instrument of power. Both rhetoric and polemic are useful during intellectual exchanges. Indeed, the most successful philosophical arguments often consist of disputation of a previously stated position, followed by argumentation in favor of another position and here both rhetoric and polemic may be used. I was rather annoyed by what appears to be the author's ignorance of these ancient arts.
- danso 10y agoFrom a straightforward standpoint, having to think about how the other person is right, and then to incorporate in a rebuttal, simply takes more time. Which for me is helpful because that physical delay curbs the kinds of reflexive emotional responses that I regret later.
- mapt 10y agoIt takes more time and a lot more patience and some common-ground factual context. Which is why bomb-throwing is the game-theoretically preferred public debate tactic with a mixed audience, such as the practice of politics.
- andrewclunn 10y agoThis is a very interesting and well written piece, but I'm going to have to disagree, as (like false modesty) the tactic quickly becomes identifiable as such and turns people off.
- jskulski 10y agoI agree, insincere flattery (maybe even condescension?) will be read and figured out. To me, this is sort of inline with How to Win Friends and Influence People. Taken at face value and just following the motions will be ineffectual at best, offensive at worst. I do think there is value to be gained, like with HTWFIP, that if done sincerely I very valuable for both sides. If I actually have to understand your view, that opens my mind.
- smallnamespace 10y agoThe key is to honestly want to find common ground with the other person, just like the antidote to false modesty is to actually be modest.
- Mendenhall 10y agoI think you may be misunderstanding in that there is nothing false about it. You are actually finding that which you agree upon.
- haxel 10y agoThis seems to underscore the need for criticisms to seem credible in order to be accepted. For example, if I write an article and I get a drive-by critical comment that offers no substantial detail drawn from the article itself, I have no idea whether or not the critique is based on a misunderstanding of what I wrote. I'm likely to dismiss the critique because it lacks credibility. I achieve nothing by reacting to a random person's hallucination of what I wrote. But when there's a clear indication of understanding (or misunderstanding) in the critique, which to me also indicates respect, I'm happy to receive the criticism, respond to it, and perhaps adapt to it. Because then it's a real thing from a real person who cares at least a little bit about both the ideas I've expressed and me as a person.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- RachelF 10y ago“The Relativity of Wrong”[1] by Isaac Asimov is a great read. In it, he states that it’s possible to be mostly right, and partly wrong. Or mostly wrong, and partly right. Someone's argument or design can have components which are absolutely wrong while still ending up being right enough for all practical purposes. [1] http://chem.tufts.edu/answersinscience/relativityofwrong.htm http://chem.tufts.edu/answersinscience/relativityofwrong.htm
- orblivion 10y agoI don't see how that's a trick. It just seems considerate to me. That's how I would prefer to be persuaded. First validate my thinking, and convince me that you understand it. Then your new perspective will be credible. I also think Pascal made the point better in his quote than the rest of the article did.
- orsenthil 10y agoI had this failure to make a family member see a particular point of view. The person had taken a stance, that would be harmful to the family, but yet rational arguments did not work out. The person had something to gain, I don't know what, by causing this harm, the person went ahead with that. Have you ever encountered this? If yes, does rational argument and persuation work with people who don't care?
- munchbunny 10y agoIf they're trying to get something and are willing to screw others over for it, then you have to give them an easier way to get what they want. Maybe they actually want something else? Or maybe they can get the thing some less damaging way? If that all fails then you have to find other strings to pull. Figure out what currencies they care about (think social pressure) and see how you might be able to use them to help you make your case.
- AstralStorm 10y agoHow Machiavelian. We're talking about people, not things. People are often inconsistent. You cannot reduce them to a simple stratagem without a risk of total mistake.
- munchbunny 10y agoI didn't suggest a simple strategem, I suggested a way of thinking about how to dissuade someone who is willing to burn you or things or people you care about to gain something. How you implement what I said will vary from person to person. It can be Machiavellian if you're a student of the Jack Bauer school of persuasion, but for normal people it's just negotiation. Everybody has that ledger in their head when they make a decision but what's on that ledger can vary dramatically. If you want to both dissuade an irrational actor and keeping things civil, then you need to figure out what's on that ledger and whether you have a way of adjusting those items, maybe by offering a more palatable (to you) alternative, or by changing the perception of the costs/benefits, or by actually changing the costs/benefits, and so on.
- EGreg 10y agoDaniel Dennett is a curious character. A philosopher at Tufts, he wrote this: How to compose a successful critical commentary: You should attempt to re-express your target’s position so clearly, vividly, and fairly that your target says, “Thanks, I wish I’d thought of putting it that way. You should list any points of agreement (especially if they are not matters of general or widespread agreement). You should mention anything you have learned from your target. Only then are you permitted to say so much as a word of rebuttal or criticism.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 10y agoLearning how to do this is an essential skill. Most people are not idiots. If they disagree with you, it's probably not because they are being irrational, but because they're starting from a different premise, making different assumptions, or assigning different values to different aspects of the problem. Only when you understand their argument well enough to articulate it in your own words can you effectively present a counter-argument that has a chance of being persuasive.
- teen 10y agoi would argue that most people are in fact idiots
- pavanky 10y agoI would argue that most people simple love to argue.
- dogles 10y agoWell I would argue that I'm rubber, and you're glue.
- Artoemius 10y agoThat depends on how you define an idiot. It's true that one half of people literally has less-than-average intelligence...
- regularfry 10y agoDepends on the distribution. And which average.
- umanwizard 10y agoIQ is distributed normally.
- nate 10y agoA very similar effect is the "backfire effect" http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Backfire_effect http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Backfire_effect I've been spending a lot of time focusing on this with customer support. When a customer is hot about a problem it doesn't help at all to show facts about anything. It really helps though to begin with a place of empathy of how you understand how they feel if you were in a similar situation. For example, had a great experience with Indinero recently when I was hot about a problem. Their customer service rep though approached it exactly from how he would feel the same way as me in such a place and here's how they'll fix it. If he just started with the "here's how we'll do better" I don't think he have gotten through to me in the situation. I've been using this a ton with problems ranging from dealing with my 2 year old to hot topics for customer support, and it's really impressive how well it works. Yes, in many ways it's simply practicing empathy. But for some reason without thinking about the tactic folks who want to be practicing empathy don't seem to get to that point. FWIW: I talk about this topic more in depth in video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzGOdE92z9I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzGOdE92z9I
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TW80000 10y agoI took a course this summer called "Design Thinking," which is about a methodology that emphasizes empathizing with the users of a product or service to improve that product or service. Empathy is an extremely powerful tool for communication between people, which is so fundamental to almost everything we do in life.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe simpering sympathising and apologising thing can go much too far as well. My reaction to that is "stop apologising and fix the damned problem". Experience teaches that it's almost always a sign of someone who's not empowered, or worse, not capable, of actually improving the situation. At worst their role is to actively impede the process, a circumstance far too frequently encountered.
- 10y ago
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agoyou're wrong. you need to know that. now, tell me how i'm right.
- espeed 10y agoEmpathy and perspective. Empathy [1] (cognitive empathy) is the ability to put yourself in someone's shoes and see things from their perspective. Not everyone has the ability to empathize -- we often believe our level of empathy is like that of everyone else, but this is not the case. Cluster B personality types [2], those with Asperger's [3] or on the autistic spectrum, and some with ADHD lack the ability to empathize. Recent research out of Berkeley has show than medication can help those with ADHD access their Executive Function and gain their ability to empathize [4]. In one of the comments on [4], Dr Charles Parker describes empathy as a "two-step process": "Empathy is a higher order function, more evolved with effective PFC [prefrontal cortex] activity than sympathy. Why? Sympathy indicates a certain subjective, feeling level, ability to emotionally reach across the room and identify with the pain of another. The only problem for those practicing sympathy is that, more often than not, they only take that first identification step, and too often get stuck in the other person’s pain. They can’t leave, and become emotionally lost over there. Empathy, on the other hand, requires good PFC Executive Function, with a metacognitively active two step process: 1. Trial identification with the other, and 2. Return to one’s full self for objective management of the other’s challenges. Good next-step advice doesn’t often arise from sympathy, but does often arise from empathetic considerations more objectively managed outside of a purely emotional reaction." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathy [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cluster_B_personality_disorders https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cluster_B_personality_disorder... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asperger_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asperger_syndrome [4] http://adhdrollercoaster.org/adhd-and-relationships/adhd-impaired-empathy-and-dopamine/ http://adhdrollercoaster.org/adhd-and-relationships/adhd-imp...
- morbidhawk 10y agoMy wife is literally the DSM definition of borderline personality disorder (one of the cluster b personality types) and she does have empathy, a lot of it actually. I'm not sure about the other cluster-B types though. Everything is about feelings for her, because her emotions are extreme and hard to regulate. She's the friend that gets called when their life is falling apart because she knows what that feels like almost 100% of the time. Her decisions are always based on emotions. Naturally, because of her lack of emotional health she has unrealistic expectations of me but it's not because she can't empathize with me, it's because she has the emotional health of a child and is afraid of abandonment.
- cyphar 10y agoThere is a modification of this idea which forms a teaching technique that my parents used with me, and I use with everyone I teach or tutor. Essentially you ask them to make predictions (what will happen here). You then try to figure out their process of coming to that conclusion (why do you say that). It's important that you ask them this question even if they're correct. Then you emphasise the parts of their reasoning which make sense, and focus on the parts that were mistaken. You then ask them to make the prediction again with what they've learned. Bonus points if you give a third, different example to reinforce the concepts. Rinse and repeat. While some people (especially children who aren't used to this method) might not enjoy it at first because it seems to be harder and takes longer than "just giving the answer", it actually helps people learn how to reason about things (which is something that is lacking in a lot of people these days IMO).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- M_Grey 10y agoIt's the complete opposite of what seems to be the increasingly reigning trend online at least, and all too often offline. That is to say this is good advice, but a really shocking number of people seem to unaware that the least effective teacher is the one who informs you that you're a pointless moron before trying to correct you. I'm constantly amazed at people who think their genius is so valuable that anyone would put up with their rancid personality. It can get even worse when there is no genius in play, just power or money and a good social/professional bubble.
- popmystack 10y ago>I'm constantly amazed at people who think their genius is so valuable that anyone would put up with their rancid personality. My opinion has been that if you really value truth, leave your ego at the door. Emotional intelligence is key to discovering things you don't know, from sources that may be less than friendly. I am not advocating being needlessly toxic. This goes for both parties. But people would do well to learn when to A) Not expect respect B) Know how deal with someone who is disrespectful, but is correct in the current subject matter being discussed.
- M_Grey 10y agoI agree, but we're all just human, and most of the time it's not truth that comes with rudeness, it's just more rudeness and a lot of opinions. Worse, people seem to think that being rude is a way to broadcast your important or genius, when it really does nothing of the sort. I'm also not talking about "expecting respect", I'm talking about people who cross basic lines of conduct. "I don't feel I'm being treated as well as I should," is not in this, and yes, people who expect that need to ground themselves in reality a bit.
- popmystack 10y agoI definitely see what you're saying. I guess all I can really say is it's such a gray area for me personally, given the people I've worked with. There are people who demand respect for absolutely no reason, and then there are generally arrogant, toxic people like you're describing. It's an emotional minefield!
- Hydraulix989 10y agoI noticed I receive far fewer downvotes whenever I do this on HN.
- SimeVidas 10y ago“…since the perceptions of our senses are always true” Like we all saw all 12 black dots in that image yesterday, right?
- arkj 10y agoUnless the person has serious emotional issues this kind of approach only makes conversations too tedious and artificial. A simpler approach could be, accept the fact that you are wrong (may do great good) or learn to ignore the bully (some bullies get a thrill to tell everyone they are wrong)
- Xcelerate 10y agoIt would be incredibly difficult, but I've always wished we could develop a (formal) axiomatic system of morality, such that with independent axioms that each person takes as true by default, all of that person's positions on the major issues would be immediately derivable from the axioms and would essentially be indisputable. Heated emotional debates that last for hours would instead turn into each party running a short computer program to determine whether their views are compatible. For example, one such axiom (not being rigorous here) may be "human life is valuable". If someone else takes "human life has no inherent worth", then you're kind of at an impasse, as each statement forms the basis of entirely different systems of morality.
- xupybd 10y agoAnother example is the abortion debate, every one is quick to show the evils of the other side of the debate. But often they simply disagree on when human life starts and fail to ever identify that as the issue. Because of this most discussions on this topic become far more vitriolic than productive.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoOne interesting observation was, that human life is continuous and has been for a million years. Don't know how that changes the discussion but its interesting.
- tomjen3 10y agoEven then the argument can actually be solved by the "famous violinist" argument (http://www.patheos.com/blogs/hallq/2012/02/the-under-rated-famous-violinist-defense-of-abortion/ http://www.patheos.com/blogs/hallq/2012/02/the-under-rated-f...) and by pointing out that humans are not forced to donate a kidney, even though doing so has a great chance of saving the life of the recepient, and a live-donation results in a much higher quality of life for the receiver. In this case we value the body integrity of the first person more than the life of the second - even though both are undeniably human.
- 10y ago
- h4nkoslo 10y agoThis is also known as the "shit sandwich" (when leavened with another helping of praise on the other end), and is instantly recognizable once you see the pattern. The risk is that your initial praise is seen as disingenuous by its recipients, or that it goes too far and reifies their underlying value system when it actually is contradictory to yours. Incidentally, Barack Obama was particularly good at this construction in his first term, but fell victim to the first trap. Pre-Trump Republicans in general fall victim to the second, when they have any effective rhetoric at all. Like most rhetorical devices, it works better in person than in print.
- douche 10y agoI hate this pattern. If something is fucked up, tell me, so I can fix it. Don't waste my time buttering me up first and patting me on the back afterwards, just get to the point. It's one thing I do kind of miss about working shitty, dangerous construction and logging jobs summers in college. There's no time for pussyfooting around when a miscommunication means somebody gets crushed or mangled by heavy equipment. Brusque, unambiguous, often profanity-laced communication is more effective getting the point across rapidly...
- dredmorbius 10y agoI'm with you on most of that (the sandwich), but (the shit) it requires a community of trust, and some healthy functioning people, at least within that specific context. I've had a recent online experience in a community in which all interaction is anonymous -- but the anonymity isn't persistent, rather, identities are created and assigned for each discussion. This almost perfectly destroys any and all sense of community. It also interacts poorly with several other site dynamics, but the result is phenomenally toxic. I do know online communities, usually smallish (5-50 people, occasionally more, but rarely >150) where that kind of banter can develop. I've seen it in workplaces, but rarely, and even then often only between a few people. Like you I've seen it in jobs involving physical work, close quarters, and danger, and those were some of the most awesome times of my life. There's a strong sense of missing that in much technology and online interaction. I've also seen places which are almost the antithesis of this. Where there's no trust, or camarderie, or sense of shared purpose. Financial industry and political environments seem to be the epitome of this. In banking, the culture permeates inside organisations, in politics, it's usually confined to rivalries across party lines, though not always. In either case, though, you find that there's an excessive need for formality, protocol, and ego-buttering which isn't so necessary elsewhere. And which apparently you and I both find tedious.
- WWKong 10y agoHere is a method to get the other person on your side of the issue: ask them the reasons the counter point could be reasonable. "Could you think of some reasons why one would vote for Trump? Seriously." Use responsibly.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThe way you phrased it makes the question sound like a trap. It presumes one couldn't think of any reason. Try "What are some reasons one would vote for Trump?" Neutral tone of voice included.
- WWKong 10y agoAgreed. That is what I was aiming for. You worded it better.
- guscost 10y agoA few more tips for arguing on the Internet: 1) Be polite. Nobody wants to listen to or learn from a rude person. 2) Avoid signaling your values, knowledge, or status. Write for the person you are addressing, not other members of your in-group. Proofread your writing and delete anything that does not serve this purpose. 3) Don't value winning more than understanding.
- tedmiston 10y ago> Don't value winning more than understanding. Over time I've learned that when arguing, some people are convinced they must win, and they value that over correctness or logic. With those types, I simply back off with a neutral stance and save myself the time of arguing with someone not interested in changing their position.
- Klockan 10y agoOn the other hand, the fastest way to get people to teach you about their views is to be rude in an argument.
- PakG1 10y agoWhile this is an important skill to have, I've also learned over time that there are certain types of people where it's easier to let them "be right" and accommodate the consequences. I didn't always think this way. In the past, I would say that people are reasonable, it's always possible to figure out what the truth is, especially if I acknowledge the possibility that I am often wrong. But now I realize that some people have a very skewed view of the world around them, either built up from a lifetime of emotional trauma, undesirable upbringing, or something else. edit: it is unfortunate when their own skewed perspective causes self-infliction of additional emotional trauma, it's a very negative and constant feedback loop. And that skewed perspective causes any and all disagreements to be perceived as personal attacks or worse. Every time I feel like I make progress with these people to earn their trust enough to get them to talk with me, it's back to square 1 when a new issue crops up, and then it's once again obviously because the world is out to get them, and there is no possible other explanation. Eventually, I get to a crossroad: either I accept what these people are saying as right (even when it's wrong and would require some absurd actions on my part), or I navigate to exit that situation so I can minimize my future interactions with those people. If neither are possible, it's perhaps time to find new work. Of course, I'd love to get onto the same page as them. But I think we have to acknowledge that sometimes it's not possible. I say this as someone who believes that he has gotten pretty good at this skill after years of experience. As would probably be expected, these types of people are lifers at organizations where they have used political means to entrench themselves, and would likely not survive on the open market if they ever needed to look for new employment.
- jaywunder 10y ago> While this is an important skill to have, I've also learned over time that there are certain types of people where it's easier to let them "be right" and accommodate the consequences Generally when that happens to me I've come across what I like to call a "fundamental argument." Where neither party is correct and neither party is wrong. A good example of this is "do you believe in religion" because nobody can prove or disprove the existence of a higher being or a religion. But some people will fundamentally be okay with believing in a higher power though. So whatever side of the debate I'm on, when the conversation comes down to a fundamental argument I let both parties be right.
- NumberCruncher 10y agoPascal was using this method: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socratic_method https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socratic_method Really Bad article by the way.
- morbidhawk 10y agoI was just about to point this same thing out. Asking good questions works so much better than trying to tell them how they are wrong, so after validating them start questioning their logic (or lack of logic). I actually learned about this in therapy to assist in communicating better with my wife (who has a personality disorder) and then later realized it's the Socratic method. Validating the things you agree with is still important too, but this article is missing the second part where you question their claims.
- NumberCruncher 10y agoPG had an essay about non intuitive things like skiing. IMO the socratic method is the best non intuitive solution for situations when you disagree someone.
- ollifi 10y agoI find that most of this discussion is framed through being right and needing to school someone. That is pretty easy special case. The useful thing to learn in conversation would be to actually have power to adjust your own beliefs. It's better to be in that end of learning.
- muzster 10y agoThis article is a fantastic read. However, the images are way too big and unnecessary.
- known 10y agoFirst check https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases
- khattam 10y agoIf and when I want to tell you that you're wrong, I no longer want you to agree with me or win you over. I just want to tell you to go fuck yourself. At that point, nothing you believe or stand for or identify as will be remotely right in any imaginable stable universe.
- petters 10y agoThat's only one part. Another is realizing that you may be the one who should change your mind.
- vintermann 10y agoTo tell someone how they're right, you first have to understand and accurately represent their position. That's a step that's usually skipped with ideological opponents.
- GarvielLoken 10y agoWhat did I just read? Some unheard of psychologist distorted and dumbified a perfectly understandable passage from the famous Pascal. And because he, as a psychologist, did that; the statement is now considered truth and valid "for realz". Am I getting this right? Scientist are really our times high priests.
- 98Windows 10y agoI think it resonates because we've all seen both methods in action, and the proposed one (at least for me) has always lead to a better outcome. The psychologist has also most likely seen even more examples in all the literature he has read and so can add a bit more weight to the argument. What would convince you of the hypothesis? A quantitative study?
- GarvielLoken 10y agoI think you misunderstood me 180 degrees. I was not advocating stronger evidence. I was questioning our culture need for "Now scientist have finally proven the old x is correct/incorrect". Wasn't Pascal beautiful passages already obvious true before this psychologist made his statement?
- 98Windows 10y agoBut lots of things seem obviously true but turn out to be wrong or problematic. It is nice to get more than one opinion.
- vog 10y agoWas this really confirmed just know in psychology? At least here in Germany this is ubiquitous. "Start criticism with the positive" is taught everywhere from elementary school to university, from self-help groups to management courses. This is so normal that it is usually not attributed to Pascal, but to common-sense psychology and good social behaviour in general. I alway thought this was well-established in science for decades - not something we verified just now.
- AstralStorm 10y agoIt is generally safer to start with neutral inquisitive stance. Some people take the easy positive them attempt to browbeat you because "you have agreed".
- Ind007 10y agoThere is a recent article on real life incident practicing the same. http://urbanconfessional.org/blog/howtodisagree http://urbanconfessional.org/blog/howtodisagree
- amelius 10y agoA better way is to first teach them logic. Then tell them they're wrong.
- shunyaloop 10y agoQuoting Charlie Munger on this subject - You’re not entitled to take a view, unless and until you can argue better against that view than the smartest guy who holds that opposite view. If you can argue better than the smartest person who holds the opposite view, that is when you are entitled to hold a certain view.”
- jondubois 10y agoI think it's not something you can fake. You have to genuinely understand and value the other persons's opinion. Also, for this to work in the long term, you have to allow yourself to lose the argument from time to time. Sometimes you have to fold on purpose (even if you think your idea is better). Of course you have to do so strategically - You have to fold arguments when the consequence isn't very important - That gives you the ammunition to be very firm in your stance when the decision is important. You don't want to be perceived like a 'cunning mule'. I had a boss who used this trick of agreeing first and then disagreeing but they did it for EVERY argument - After spending a few months with this person, you notice the pattern. If someone wins every argument, it becomes noticeable and the trick doesn't work anymore - The workplace environment becomes tense.
- lordnacho 10y agoA related question that I've been grappling with is how do you tell someone that they don't understand something, and that they really need to work a lot harder to do so? That an attitude change is required in order to get to where the actual experts are. - Extra points if you can do this without sounding patronising.
- lutusp 10y ago> To tell someone they're wrong, first tell them how they're right Yes, sometimes, but in many cases this only plays into the hands of narcissists. Remember that narcissists listen to you when you tell them they're right, then shut down completely and/or go on the attack when you try to offer constructive criticism. Nobody showed this behavior more dramatically than Steve Jobs, with whom I briefly tried to work in the early 1980s. A classic malignant narcissist, Steve just absorbed people's energy and his behavior never improved. Eventually I refused to try to work with him. The tl;dr -- the title's suggestion sometimes backfires spectacularly.
- Nursie 10y agoIt's funny, I remember from some years ago reading similar advice under the heading "How to disagree with Americans", the implication being that American speakers could not take direct disagreement, and required a little ego-massage first. And of course that we British had no such foolish pride. I think probably it's a little more universal than that :)
- jgalt212 10y agoWhy prove to a man he is wrong? Is that going to make him like you? Why not let him save face? He didn't ask for your opinion. He didn't want it. Why argue with him? You can't win an argument, because if you lose, you lose it; and if you win it, you lose it. Why? You will feel fine. But what about him? You have made him feel inferior, you hurt his pride, insult his intelligence, his judgment, and his self-respect, and he'll resent your triumph. That will make him strike back, but it will never make him want to change his mind. A man convinced against his will is of the same opinion still. --Dale Carnegie For the above reasons, in social situations, I avoid every argument that I can.
- GFischer 10y agoGood quote. I should re-read How To Win Friends and Influence People. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Win_Friends_and_Influence_People https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Win_Friends_and_Influen...
- drjesusphd 10y agoA worthwhile goal of arguments is not to convince your opponent that he/she is wrong, but to convince spectators.
- dilemma 10y agoPlot twist: You start off telling someone about the ways in which they're right to then proceed to telling them they're wrong, and realize that they are actually right and you are wrong.
- 1_player 10y agoThat's the best kind of discussion: when one learns something from the other, instead of just exposing different point of views.
- zeeshanm 10y agoThis is a classic technique for influencing people. The rule of thumb is nobody likes to be criticized in any situation whatsoever. The worst thing you can do is to tell them they are wrong. One way to get a difficult message conveyed is to get the other person say "yes" a few times before being told things as they are. Anyone interested in learning more I would recommend reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Win_Friends_and_Influence_People https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Win_Friends_and_Influen...
- ojosilva 10y agoThis is very shallow. Negotiation theory is not helpful when you're plainly or partially wrong, or just in a very weak position to defend. Here's a classic negotiation example that I just can't crack: Her: I've told you, please don't leave your socks on the floor. Him: (mirroring) Leave my socks on the floor? Her: Yes. Please throw them in the laundry bin right after you take them off. Him: (open-ended question) How am I supposed to do this if I'm in a hurry? Her: After you take off your socks, pick them up. Then throw them into the bin. Two seconds and you're are done. Him: (Pascal's empathy) Yes, you're right. Leaving socks on the floor is just annoying. But understand that when I get home sometimes I'm in a hurry or I'm tired and I don't feel like picking up the socks. Her: Please just do it. It annoys the hell out of me. There's just no good way to negotiate your way out of this. Typically negotiation courses and books always focus on how the reader will bargain to win, not to minimize losses or just accept to lose but compromise on an ongoing basis (give-and-take).
- AstralStorm 10y agoSometimes, a game cannot be won. Negotiation cannot be done if the other party is not willing.
- ojosilva 10y agoOne way to break such a stalemate is to increase your empathy to the point you become the psychiatrist and the other party the patient. Here he could debase Her argument as being a manifestation of an obsessive compulsive disorder. If she agrees to that "diagnosis" just a little, he might be able to move to a kill by proposing that the socks remain on the floor as a form of therapy that will help Her treat her overwhelmingly obsessive behavior.
- antisthenes 10y agoSo who's more wrong here? I don't quite follow the argument.
- Natanael_L 10y agoThe argument is that some negotiations have no winning outcome
- sharemywin 10y agoMy favorite was arguing with my brother and I said "logically ...." he replied I don't believe in logic. He won the argument I had nothing to work with.
- overcast 10y agoThis is one of the essential points outlined in Dale Carnegie's seminal "How to win friends and influence people". This should be required reading for EVERYONE before graduating high school, and revisited regularly. I read it at least once a year. Begin with praise and honest appreciation. People will do things begrudgingly for criticism and an iron-fisted leader, but they will work wonders when they are praised and appreciated.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoBuzzfeed-style click bait. We are better than psychological tricks.
- kelukelugames 10y agoAka criticism sandwich aka shit sandwich. http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Shit%20Sandwich&defid=1424344 http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Shit%20Sandwi...