20 ms·
Contemplating the possible retirement of Apache OpenOffice
- verbify 10y agoI thought everyone interested in a FOSS office suite was using libreoffice.
- okket 10y agoEverybody is using LibreOffice, except a poor few that get misguided by search services to the Apache OpenOffice website. IMHO there is no sane reason why Apache OpenOffice still exists. Edit: Looks like there are a lot more OpenOffice users out there than I thought, sorry. I really thought the world would have moved on, at least since 2013/14, see https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/fb/StarOffice_major_derivatives.svg/1949px-StarOffice_major_derivatives.svg.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/fb/St...
- nunodonato 10y agopride and ego
- cstross 10y agoThis is not actually true; I am aware of lots of non-technical users who know nothing about Sun, Oracle, or Apache and who haven't heard of LibreOffice but who continue to quietly use the free office package they were recommended at some time in the previous 15 years. (For example: I'm a member of an online community of working novelists and just last week someone was advocating OpenOffice to another irritated Microsoft Word customer -- the OO.o user had never heard of LibreOffice and was very taken aback when I gave them an update on the history of OO.o post-Sun.) While I agree that Apache OOo is effectively dead in the water as an on-going project, its continued existence has caused huge confusion among millions of users and there's now an equally huge public education campaign required to get them moved onto a modern, secure, maintained codebase. The optimum strategy would be to turn openoffice.org into a redirect to LibreOffice, or to reassign the OpenOffice name rights to the LibreOffice project ... but egos are gonna ego.
- josteink 10y ago> The optimum strategy would be to turn openoffice.org into a redirect to LibreOffice, or to reassign the OpenOffice name rights to the LibreOffice project ... but egos are gonna ego. This is so simple. It would solve everyone's problems. So of course that's never going to happen. Welcome to the real world :(
- corbet 10y agoApache is actually considering doing that: https://lwn.net/Articles/699110/ https://lwn.net/Articles/699110/
- davidgerard 10y agoThis is horrifyingly incorrect. AOO still gets a shitload of downloads. It wasn't until last year that LO overtook AOO alone's download total. You would be amazed. Ordinary people know MSO sucks and want a free alternative. "OpenOffice" is the name they've heard as their exit. The project is entirely trading on the goodwill that FLOSS activists built up for the name "OpenOffice" from 2002-2010. That brand is still powerful! So whatever you do, make sure everyone you know uses LO instead of AOO. e.g. I wrote this last year for Tumblr. Target audience was writers and creative people who aren't geeks but just want to do their stuff. Written after I encountered yet another innocent user who'd just got AOO. Please excuse the apocalyptic tone, (1) that's how you write to catch attention on Tumblr, (2) this was during the six months they had a massive hole in the default install and were spending their time defending the product on blogs rather than fixing it: http://reddragdiva.tumblr.com/post/128873352708/urgent-get-the-hell-off-apache-openoffice-its http://reddragdiva.tumblr.com/post/128873352708/urgent-get-t...
- harry-wood 10y agoYou might be interested in my impressions as somebody who hardly ever uses office software, but an open source enthusiast and keeps up with some tech news. I was aware of the OpenOffice/LibreOffice split of course. I knew this would mean some confusion until the dust settles. My vague impression was that LibreOffice might be a better choice for supporting openness versus corporate ownership (and so I'd plumbed for that myself) but at the same time I worried that OpenOffice might end up being better managed and maintained than LibreOffice. I was not aware until I read this, that the dust was settling so comprehensively on the side of LibreOffice. More than just OS idealists buying into it, it's actually being maintained a lot better. This is good news. The situation seems a lot clearer than previously, but yes the message needs to get out. Hopefully apache will shut down, redirect and facilitate re-merging the brand names.
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoMSO is closed, proprietary, whatever, but it's actually a fine piece of software especially compared to OO and LO. Word, PowerPoint and Excel are so good that people end up overusing them for stuff they're not intended to. Others like OneNote or Visio are extremely useful, too. They might not be the best on each category, but together it's a very powerful suite. Plus, MSO is multiplatoform on Windows, Mac, iOS and Android. I'm unaware of mobile versions of OO or LO. Everyone I know, including myself, that uses OO or LO is because it's free (as in freedom for some, as in beer for others) and can read/write MSO files to an extent.
- david-given 10y agoMy father's been a happy Ubuntu user for years (and a fairly resentful one for a few more years --- he still misses the old GNOME user interface and loathes Unity). He mainly uses it for Gimp and LibreOffice. When he had to switch from OpenOffice to LibreOffice he was pretty close to packing it all in and using something else; his argument was: why should he trust a package produced by an organisation that can't keep their own house in order? That is, from the outside the schism between OpenOffice and LibreOffice is basically invisible; they're both considered to be the same thing, because they produce the same software. It's seen as an internal conflict, and it's a big reputational problem.
- UncleSlacky 10y agoHas he tried Ubuntu MATE to get back the "old GNOME" style interface?
- jnbiche 10y ago> and a fairly resentful one for a few more years --- he still misses the old GNOME user interface and loathes Unity Why doesn't he use Mate? Ubuntu Mate is readily available on the Ubuntu website. Is he aware that it's a continuation of the old Gnome (Gnome 2)? And well-maintained to boot.
- type0 10y agoMATE is really a better GNOME2, some ppl don't want to believe it. There is somehow a parallel to OpenOffice and LibreOffice. Many non techy ppl don't know what forking is (for them it sounds as fornication). It adds to the confusion and we end up with a lot of users hesitating to try a better software.
- int_19h 10y agoI'm not sure MATE can be treated as "Gnome2 under a different name" at this point. While it started as a fork, they're doing some pretty massive refactoring, like gradually moving to Gtk3.
- 10y ago
- imtringued 10y agoI'm using OpenOffice because Libreoffice for some inexplicable reason defaults to PDF for printing even though I constantly set it back to postscript. The PDF feature is broken and swallows umlauts forcing me to print everything at least twice.
- yrro 10y agoOblig: please file a bug about this if you haven't already!
- khaled 10y agoDo you have bug reports about PDF printing issues, I’d like to have a look myself (I have some interest in streamlining LibreOffice text layout code and part of it would be killing PostScript printing support at some point, but if PDF printing is buggy then it has to be fixed first).
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoNot me! I use real Microsoft Office. And it works great.
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoNot me! I use real Microsoft Office. And it works great.
- hannob 10y agoActually for many years we have told people "if you want a free alternative to MS Office use OpenOffice". And we told this to people who are not closely following tech news. It's an established brand and it's not easy to undo. Many people will still google for openoffice. It would be helpful if they'd just get a message "OpenOffice is outdated, you can still download old versions, but you really want to get Libreoffice instead".
- theallan 10y agoOne of my OSS bits of software has an XSLX data export options, so I've been interested in the OpenOffice / LibreOffice split because of a bug in OpenOffice causing the file I was outputting to be read as empty. I've changed the file format now, but even for a tech based audience I got a number of questions about OpenOffice. Just did a Google Trends on the topic [1] and it shows the two surprisingly close, confirming what you say, the openOffice brand still has momentum. 1: https://www.google.co.uk/trends/explore?date=all&q=openoffice,libreoffice https://www.google.co.uk/trends/explore?date=all&q=openoffic...
- yoodenvranx 10y ago> libreoffice I hate that name. As a German I have no idea how to pronounce it and it's even harder for my non-techy friends. The name "Open office" has a very nice flow and everybody knows how to pronounce it, but "libre office"? They should have selected an easier name for that project.
- hasch 10y agoFlossOffice? even stranger, and make sure to use it at least once a day :-)
- bitwize 10y agoFloffice!
- type0 10y agoSounds good to me! What we really need is school teachers that would nag their students to use it at least once a day, maybe then we as a society hopefully get rid of the pesky MS Office someday.
- aruggirello 10y agoWould be popular among dentists :-)
- luibelgo 10y agoDepends on the language, it's very easy to pronounce in Spanish
- ekianjo 10y agoIn French too.
- Doctor_Fegg 10y agoBut not the same way! I've never known whether the Spanish or French version is the canonical pronunciation for LibreOffice.
- SyneRyder 10y agoAnyone know if this would impact on NeoOffice, the Mac native port? They seem to draw code from both LibreOffice and OpenOffice. [Side note: the way NeoOffice asks for yearly donations in order to access binary updates is very smart. Synergy also uses this method, and NeoOffice & Synergy are the first GPL projects I've regularly contributed to as a result.]
- davidgerard 10y agoNot at all. As I understand it (I looked into this when I was doing a big fix-up on the OpenOffice cluster of articles on Wikipedia), NeoOffice tracked OOo (and then ooo-build/Go-oo) until 3.1.1, when it stopped doing that and just maintained that codebase. Though they pull in fixes from LO and AOO, but I don't know how substantial that is - NeoOffice is only two guys.
- bsharitt 10y agoI used NeoOffice a long time ago when OpenOffice required X11 on OS X. Now that LibreOffice works natively on OS X, what does NeoOffice offer now? Is it like Camino was to Firefox?
- SyneRyder 10y agoWhile I've not tried LibreOffice (downloading now!), I think the Camino / Firefox comparison is a good one. My reason for choosing NeoOffice was because I wanted the most Mac-like experience and without a dependency on Java. It looks like the main difference/advantage right now is integration with the native Mac font rendering & grammar/spellcheck engines, according to the front page of the NeoOffice website.
- chris_wot 10y agoHave OpenOffice actually done anything.
- the_mitsuhiko 10y agoThis image would suggest it got some code from StarOffice and alter some releases: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/fb/StarOffice_major_derivatives.svg/1949px-StarOffice_major_derivatives.svg.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/fb/St...
- xigency 10y agoWell, here it looks like Apache OpenOffice made a couple of releases.
- chris_wot 10y agoBarely.
- rectang 10y agoThere was substantial development energy for a while. Notably, there was a large donation from IBM of code that had been in Symfony.
- chris_wot 10y agoAnd yet their build system is still the same as it pretty much has always been. There is no easy way to sustain any sort of development energy with a developer unfriendly system like that one. LibreOffice realised this early on and did the hard yards to fix fundamental issues like the crappy build system, and to put into place developer friendly infrastructure like gerrit. The OpenOffice team didn't see this as important or even necessary, and now they are withering on the vine, but complaining about it quite a lot. That Symphony code can only take you so far. That was integrated several years ago. What have they done since then?
- creshal 10y agoAbout damn time.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoApache should never have accepted this hot potato from Oracle in the first place.
- jonathanstrange 10y agoNothing against hot potatoes, though. With butter.
- chris_wot 10y agoThe LibreOffice hot potatoes are hot, buttered and have melted cheese. I personally chose the more delicious offering, because not only did OpenOffice.org have no butter, they definitely had no melted cheese. Chef Meeks runs a hatted restaurant. One so great the kitchen hands work for free and the sous-chefs are many, and work well together. And unlike a kitchen, there is really minimal amounts of swearing, and their customers love them and even try to help the kitchen by nicely reporting cooking errors and help in fixing their own meals.
- rincebrain 10y agoWhy do you think so? It's not clear that they could have known this would not be sustainable at the time, and I don't see how the hot potato staying with Oracle would have been a better option.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoIt was immediately obvious at the time, I remember it as such. The devs jumped ship to LibreOffice. All Oracle was left with was a brand and a moribund codebase, and for some reason Apache accepted it. Why didn't Oracle give it to LibreOffice? Because they were sore at being bypassed, it looked like. The correct thing for Apache to do would have been to say, nope mate, we don't want to be part of your childish feud, keep it, trash it, or give it to the people who are actually doing the work.
- rincebrain 10y ago
- akerro 10y agoThanks Oracle!
- jacquesm 10y agoSimplest instant solution: 301 every page about openoffice to a page about libreoffice.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoaaaaauuuurrrrgh that's sound in principle but placing 301 on a domain like that is really, really bad.
- jacquesm 10y agoAgreed, but in this case those reasons actually make it more valid, because there will be no way for someone else to reverse the decision once it is made. It closes the door on some zombie resurrection of openoffice and essentially cedes the identifier to libreoffice.
- vog 10y agoIndeed, it should be 307 instead, just to keep the decision revertible.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAs 'jacquesm points out, you may want to explicitly make the decision non-revertible in cases like this.
- StavrosK 10y agoWhy is that? What if you want to change your domain name?
- fiatjaf 10y agoGitHub Pages sends 301 redirects when you put a CNAME file on the repo. That's insane.
- ohthehugemanate 10y ago301 redirects are the herpes of the Internet. You make one mistake, and it's with you for the rest of eternity.
- Aardwolf 10y agoCould they drop openoffice, then rename libreoffice to openoffice? That would be fantastic
- ptero 10y agoThis. Name natters. IME 90% of people I know who want to quickly look through a PowerPoint on Linux will install OpenOffice. Even when they hear that libre is the better version 80% of them would stay with oo as it is the "real" oo.
- ajdlinux 10y agoI agree in the case of the Windows/OS X environment, where brand awareness of LibreOffice is low, but in the Linux world... my distribution (Debian) doesn't even package OpenOffice, and I don't know any Linux user who uses OOo.
- chengiz 10y agoHere's one. Never thought it necessary to change. OO works just fine.
- fosco 10y agoditto
- dorfsmay 10y agoWasn't OpenOffice own by Sunacle at some point? I think that's when a lot of users moves to LibreOffice.
- umanwizard 10y agoLibreOffice is original OO, in terms of continuity of development, more so than AOO is.
- keithpeter 10y agoAnd another one to some extent: oOo uses its own font rendering, the LO team (I gather) moved over to using libraries (harfbuzz) available in host OS for font rendering. I seem to have better results on former under some circumstances. I have not had any round-trip editing problems flitting between the two under Linuxen of various kinds.
- 1ris 10y agoI think the document foundation should get the brand, instant of Apache squatting. It's still far better known that libreoffice.
- type0 10y agoMaybe Libre Office could take over the branding, making "0pen Libre Office" (OLO for short, not to be confused with LOL). That way even ppl searching for Open Office would find a good free Office suite.
- tener 10y agoIt made a sense few years ago, now Libre Office has a brand of its own. I don't think having the ownership would be useful now.
- dagw 10y agoOpenOffice still a much stronger brand outside of the Linux community. Basically all the non-technical people I know (including some very non-technical people like my father-in-law) know that OpenOffice is the free alternative for MS Office. I'll bet not one of them have heard of Libre Office.
- pmontra 10y ago
- k__ 10y agoHow did the whole Oracle buys Sun thing work out for the OSS projets in general? Did LibreOffice and MariaDB get all the core devs?
- morgo 10y agoYou are comparing apples to oranges here. MySQL had a different (and more successful) business model. No MariaDB did not get all the core devs.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoOracle killed OpenSolaris. They literally moved Solaris back to being closed-source. With no justification, even, beyond Oracle not liking open-source. Undoing the massive amount of work the Solaris team made in order to open-source it in the first place. There's no more source code releases for Solaris now. Unsurprisingly, almost all the core Solaris team walked. This talk is informative: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc&t=33m https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc&t=33m
- jimjag 10y agoFollow the actual (open and public) discussion: https://lists.apache.org/thread.html/6d3bb86f8abc1ae88f3aa3aa08c65721f71a951c07a967b8d288ee3a@%3Cdev.openoffice.apache.org%3E https://lists.apache.org/thread.html/6d3bb86f8abc1ae88f3aa3a...
- okket 10y agoParallel universe: http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg28200.html http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg282... If we look at LibreOffice and compare: LibreOffice, that is *good* (not more) software and *excellent* public relations. OpenOffice, that is *excellent* software and *pretty bad* public relations. Proof: http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg28203.html http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg282... Secondly, as alluded to above, we should prepare ourselves for the FUD, the "AOO is dead" victory chants, the numerous anti-AOO and anti-Apache spewings, etc... There are some who will use this as a self-serving soapboxing opportunity, and warp the facts into some Bizarro alternate universe history. We should be there to set the facts straight but also resign ourselves to the fact that their voices will likely be louder than ours. [...] But the main reason why, imo, was because we were also end-user. End users needed to make a *choice* between AOO and SomethingElse. Don't say the word. By no longer being an end-user application, that goes away. End users play no role any more? Good luck with that.
- jimjag 10y ago"End users play no role any more? Good luck with that." In what parallel universe do you get that conclusion from that thread?
- okket 10y agoMy last remark was too snarky and out of context, I am sorry. You want both projects to merge again with OO being the 'core' and LO the 'user interface'? Sounds intriguing, but are both code bases still compatible enough for that? Would this not be more effort than gain? What is obvious is that the AOO project cannot support, at the present time, being an end-user focused effort. I would suggest we focus on not being one, but instead being a framework or library that can be consumed by actual end-user implementations. (Quote from your email)
- jimjag 10y agoI didn't say "merge". Being a library or framework which can be consumed, either in whole or in part, by another entity is in no way a "merge".
- EdSharkey 10y agoHere's an idea. If OpenOffice has no contributors. How about all the libreoffice folks start committing to both code bases or mirror them, whatever? Maybe the only thing that differs between the code bases is some splash screen and text resource bundles, ultimately. Why not bury the hatchet, devs?
- PeterisP 10y agoWhat's the point of that wasted effort? What you're asking is "if X has no contributors, why don't Y people become contributors and start contributing?" Currently there are differences between code bases. If the OpenOffice team wants to abandon OO codebase and distribute a version of LibreOffice with some splash screen and text resource changes, then they're free to do so, it's open source.
- EdSharkey 10y agoI was thinking more like a takeover of the Open Office codebase since its organization has collapsed. Take over the administration, steering committee, etc. I can see that the codebases have diverged, but will a lot be lost if Open Office's codebase was clobbered with the LibreOffice sources?
- JohnTHaller 10y agoApache wouldn't permit that due to their distaste for LibreOffice's licensing (read: copyleft).
- rectang 10y agoLibreOffice doesn't like Apache's licensing, but AOO is happy to share the code with them and they are happy to consume it. Both sides have strong beliefs, but the licensing situation benefits the copyleft faction.
- sveredov 10y agoCommitting on both repositories is not practical, because the source code has diverged too much between the two. It's now too much effort and requires brain power to do. I have not seen blame from LibreOffice developers and I do not understand what is being said in the AOO discussion. Instead, the Apache OpenOpenOffice people took advantage of the openoffice.org domain. They should have put on openoffice.org that the old OOo has been forked into AOO, LibreOffice and NeoOffice. However, what they did is not mention at all that LibreOffice is one of the options out of the defunct OpenOffice.org.
- tombert 10y agoI honestly didn't know that AOO was still updated, as I've really not seen anyone use it in the last three years. Upon re-trying it out right now, it actually seems perfectly fine...I kind of wonder why no one uses it.
- cs702 10y agoOpenOffice's website design, marketing efforts, and documentation are less friendly to non-technical people that those of LibreOffice, the most prominent fork of OpenOffice. Subtle "superficial" details matter a lot to non-technical people -- for example, LibreOffice's web page has a "Get Help" link, instead of a "Support" page. In addition, LibreOffice has been the default office suite in key GNU/Linux distributions like Ubuntu for many years. As a result, the LibreOffice fork has been more widely adopted than OpenOffice, leading to the present situation. One possible path for the OpenOffice folks would be to copy the Linux kernel and become an "upstream project" that others use to create a range of office-suite distributions like LibreOffice. In other words, stop packaging and marketing OpenOffice to end-users. Stop competing for end-users with downstream projects.
- jimjag 10y ago"One possible solution would be for the OpenOffice folks to copy the Linux kernel and become an "upstream project" that others use to create a range of office-suite distributions like LibreOffice." ... which were exactly the thoughts and reasons behind Apache accepting OO in the 1st place. For various reasons this obviously never happened. But it WAS the idea from the start.
- cesarb 10y agoInterestingly, that could have happened. Not only did LO make the effort of rebasing all their changes on top of a particular AOO release, they also were set up to incorporate all the new work from AOO into their branch. For instance, they quickly incorporated the sidebar code. Even today, one of the LO developers still goes over each AOO change, merging any worthwhile ones. What actually happened? For some reason, development on AOO stalled. What little work still happens on it, is almost always replicating work LO already did two, three, sometimes five years ago. See it for yourself at https://cgit.freedesktop.org/libreoffice/core/log/?h=aoo/trunk https://cgit.freedesktop.org/libreoffice/core/log/?h=aoo/tru... : pick a commit, and look for the "Notes" field. For instance, picking "Port main/fileaccess to gbuild" I see the note "prefer: 1f9bc2b2aa8168f9c164044058b117d2a17d83ad"; that git hash is for a LO commit from 2011 (https://cgit.freedesktop.org/libreoffice/core/commit/?h=aoo/trunk&id=1f9bc2b2aa8168f9c164044058b117d2a17d83ad https://cgit.freedesktop.org/libreoffice/core/commit/?h=aoo/...). In the meantime, LO did a lot of cleanup work. Finishing the build system move to gbuild, cleaning warnings across all the code base, removing plenty of obsolete or unused code, running several static checkers, and more. As I noted at https://lwn.net/Articles/699108/ https://lwn.net/Articles/699108/, the recent AOO CVE was probably found and fixed on LO two years ago, as a result of running a fuzzer together with valgrind. If you wanted to pick an "upstream project" to base an office suite on today, it makes more sense to pick LO instead of AOO.
- puppetmaster3 10y agoi think what is growing is markdown types and such. i like.
- thrillgore 10y agoThis was all but expected once Oracle sent OOo to the open source retirement home. LibreOffice continues to thrive and has replaced all the OOo installs at my workplace.
- mindcrime 10y agoWell, my prediction[1] came true even faster than I anticipated. I don't understand why so many people seem so desperate to see AOO fail and go away. Hey look, if you prefer LO, fine. Some of us prefer AOO for our own reasons. There's no reason to take glee in seeing a project struggle. Anyway, none of this means the project is actually going to be retired. It's just a discussion around something that might happen. [1]: http://www.mail-archive.com/dev%40openoffice.apache.org/msg28192.html http://www.mail-archive.com/dev%40openoffice.apache.org/msg2...
- d33 10y agoWhat could be any of the reasons to cheer for AOO anymore? From my perspective, it seems that it only creates confusion.
- wjoe 10y agoWhat reasons are there to prefer OpenOffice? From my perspective, I hear about LibreOffice updates often, and OpenOffice doesn't sound like it's being maintained as much. I don't know if this is actually correct, but I never understood what the need was for keeping them separate after Oracle gave up OO to Apache. LibreOffice seems to have 'won' popular attention if nothing else, and is the one included in distros now. Having two forks competing just seems confusing and a waste of effort on maintaining two forks. Initially it made sense to have a fully open fork when OpenOffice was under Oracle's control, but I don't understand what the purpose the two forks serve now that OO is under Apache's control.
- mindcrime 10y agoThe two forks represent two different ideologies to a large extent - "permissive" licensing vs "copyleft". Some of us think it's important to have a full-featured, world-class office suite that's under a permissive license. Others think it's important to have a full-featured, world class office suite that's copyleft. Who's to say either is wrong? Feature wise, there may not be a lot of reasons to prefer AOO right now. I don't know, as I spend very little time looking at / using, LibreOffice. AOO does everything I need, so what differences exist aren't ones that concern me a lot. YMMV.
- the_duke 10y agoSee also this discussion on the mailing list, where I asked (recently, August 3rd) if it is a viable idea to somehow combine efforts with LibreOffice again: http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg27754.html http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg277...
- mindcrime 10y agoThere's effectively a one-way merge already. LO can - and do - consume patches contributed to AOO. But, for a variety of reasons, that are mostly historical as far as I can tell, the LO developers have generally been unwilling to contribute code in the other direction. An outright "merger" of the two projects seems unlikely due to the licensing differences and the associated thinking. Some people prefer permissive licenses like the ALv2, others prefer the GPL/LGPL world. So getting everybody to agree on that is probably a non-starter.
- the_duke 10y agoAs I pointed out in the mailing list, there has been practically no development on OO this year though.
- mindcrime 10y agoAs I pointed out in the mailing list, there has been practically no development on OO this year though. And? I mean, yeah, it would be nice to have more cool new stuff coming out, but it's not like AOO owes the world anything. It's open source, it's volunteer driven. If people want more new features, more development, etc, then more people need to volunteer. If they don't, well... the world gets what it gets from the folks who are contributing.
- davidgerard 10y ago> it's not like AOO owes the world anything. It arguably owes its users not distributing security holes to them. Sitting on the vulnerability since October 2015, only revealing it in July because the reporter said they were going public with it ... there is no way that is responsible stewardship of end user software. In fact, I just checked - I went to www.openoffice.org, went all the way through to download, and it still gives me the vulnerable version and doesn't give me information that there's a vulnerability or a fix. You're an AOO dev. What do you see as your responsibility in this regard?
- slajax 10y agoI literally downloaded this for the first time in years the yesterday. This is really sad news.
- blockednbcads 10y agoLibreOffice should go back to its Java roots. It was a dumb decision to move away from an excellent language and platform.
- ryanmarsh 10y agoWhy does Open/LibreOffice matter anymore? This is a sincere question. I'm well aware of why OO was a big deal circa 2000 when I was using it (if I'm getting the dates right). I cannot figure out why it matters anymore, or why it will matter in 10 years. Back when every year was going to be the year of "Linux on the desktop" the linchpin was MS Office. That's because we didn't have the million different SaaS products we have today, products tailor made for jobs only Office would be considered for. Basically MS Office was a hammer and everything was a nail. This is not the world today. Today there are a number of viable alternatives and there continues to be innovation around the jobs MS Office was traditionally used for. Someone is going to bring up: vendor lock in, Freedom, etc... I don't get those arguments any more.
- WilliamDhalgren 10y agoIt'd be a very interesting argument, if you could provide statistics to back up the notion that Office products today are really as marginal as you make it out to be. I'd expect them to be comparably central to corporate and civil service jobs in the economy in total as ever, just because economy in bulk is a very sluggish thing and they do the job, but I'd be thrilled to be wrong.
- jamroom 10y agoIt matters if you have years of documents that you still need to be able to view/edit. Not everyone wants to upload these documents to an online service (i.e. google docs), so having a free option that is not tied into any monthly subscriptions is nice. Sometimes it's just nice to keep things local and not have to rely on the "cloud".
- okket 10y agoArs Technica: "OpenOffice, after years of neglect, could shut down" http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/09/openoffice-after-years-of-neglect-could-shut-down/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/09/openof...
- kasabali 10y agoIt is really depressing reading the thread to see that how some members just can't let it go. I'm totally pro-diversity and support different projects and forks with different priorities but AOO's track record and sitting on top of a valuable brand has been a net loss for the open source in office area. I wouldn't mind it at all had they continue to develop their own thing named SolidOffice or whatnot, but I know companies which still use Openoffice on Windows, because that is what they have had always used, nevermind it doesn't even get prompt security updates.