7 ms·
SF YIMBY Platform
- gravypod 10y agoSaying "more homes", "more zoning control", and "stop treating homes as investments" are all crazily opposite ideals from my perspective. These demands are not very well scoped.
- tyre 10y agoNot to take a stance one way or the other, but I can provide background on why (in SF at least) these aren't mutually exclusive. More homes means either building on new land or adding density to existing land. There isn't much "new" land available in SF, but knocking down existing buildings is still very risky. Even if your proposed development meets every existing zoning regulation, it can be shot down. So "more zoning control" here means putting more control in the actual zoning regulations, as opposed to allowing anyone to try and stop the process via ballot measure or legal challenge. Increasing supply (building more or denser housing) will naturally decrease prices, which is where the investment bit comes in.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> So "more zoning control" here means putting more control in the actual zoning regulations, as opposed to allowing anyone to try and stop the process via ballot measure or legal challenge. The phrase "more zoning control" sounds like increasing the amount and complexity of zoning regulations, rather than, as you suggest, removing unwritten rules.
- raldi 10y agoThat phrase is not from the submission.
- derefr 10y agoIt sort of does increase the amount and complexity of the (explicit) regulations, though; it's forcing unwritten rules to be written down. (At which point we would then have control over keeping or removing them.) "Make the re-zoning process more predictable" would maybe be a better slogan.
- RickS 10y agoThey can certainly be in opposition in some scenarios, but in the case of SF, they fit together in a way that's coherent, if not well defined by the article. Zoning control != zoning restriction. Control over zoning can mean things like mixed use, autonomy at the lower levels (versus "our hands are tied by group X" situations), and issuing permits on a "default yes barring interrupts" basis, instead of a "default no pending complex approvals". Treating homes as investments is what leads to most NIMBY ways of thinking, which while harmful to the region at large, make perfect sense on a homeowner level. Many SF land owners have bought in at overvalued levels and continue to pay or receive overvalued rents. Motions that would make the city more affordable on the whole threaten the size of their returns, so people who treat homes as investments are often in direct opposition to what would be good for the less rich. TL;DR the 3 pieces you mention can coexist as "more homes, of more varieties, regardless of the fact that will threaten existing homeowners' ROI"
- amluto 10y ago> Treating homes as investments is what leads to most NIMBY ways of thinking, which while harmful to the region at large, make perfect sense on a homeowner level. Many SF land owners have bought in at overvalued levels and continue to pay or receive overvalued rents. This is something that puzzle me. If areas are upzoned and higher-density redevelopment becomes possible, then housing prices will drop. But housing prices aren't the same thing at all as land value. If I owned a small low-density unit on a small plot of land, I wouldn't be able to sell the house as such to someone who wanted to live in it for as much money, but I think the value if the property could redeveloped as-of-right at higher density would increase. So at least some plots of land should increase in value.
- azernik 10y ago> "more zoning control" They're saying almost exactly the opposite of that - establish clear rules that, if followed by developers, lead to automatic approval, rather than the current mess of endless, case-by-case approval processes. > "stop treating homes as investments" This is specifically deaing with government policies that prioritize houses' utility as investments over their utility as consumer goods - eg by restricting supply.
- raldi 10y agoThe linked document doesn't call for more zoning control; it calls for different zoning.
- smallnamespace 10y agoThe more supply is restricted, the higher property prices rise. The higher property prices are, the more homeowners will do to protect their economic interests by voting to restrict supply. It's a vicious cycle. > therefore public policy should be based on viewing homes as places to live, not as investments. This sounds all well and good, but can you really expect people to support diluting their >$1mm property investment?
- derefr 10y agoNaive question: how much would it distort the market if prices were allowed to rise on undeveloped land, but there was a sort of "land-value control" equivalent to rent-control on developed land, preventing its value from rising? (Maybe implemented in terms of a tax at time-of-sale that takes away however much profit was made due to property-price inflation and just hands it to the city instead.)
- pseudonom- 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_land_trust https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_land_trust is certainly relevant.
- philsnow 10y agoIt sounds like it would dis-incentivize market liquidity even more than Prop 13 already does.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> Maybe implemented in terms of a tax at time-of-sale that takes away however much profit was made due to property-price inflation and just hands it to the city instead. Apart from being unjust, that approach would completely break the market and put people out on the street. You buy a house for $200k; its value increases to $400k; you sell it, and the city takes $200k, leaving you with $200k. You now cannot afford any of the houses currently for sale for $400k, even though the additional $200k you don't have would just go to the city, and the seller just gets the $200k you actually have. Typical price controls affect both sides of the transaction, so the house value can't increase, or doesn't increase faster than a certain limit. That at least doesn't directly prevent people from selling one house and buying another comparable house. To answer your original question, though: to what extent do the areas in most dire need of housing have any undeveloped land? Those areas don't have much undeveloped land; they have underdeveloped land. If you had price controls on undeveloped land but not on developed land, at some point you'd end up with a price inversion where a given property with a house on it has less value than the same property without the house. At which point someone wanting to extract the increased value could demolish the house and then sell the land at market value.
- rspeer 10y agoIs this the same group that was going to call themselves BARF (Bay Area Renters' Federation)? Seems good. This is probably a better name and more generalizable to all the other cities that need it.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoGovernor Brown is trying to move legislation that would allow developments that meet a minimum below-market allocation to bypass local approval completely. If this becomes law, NIMBYs will become extinct quickly as developers will just bite the bullet and include a lower-cost component to get fast-track approval to build directly from the State. And they'll get it. Personally I feel that we are really getting close to killing the golden goose. At some point, companies will leave or grow large satellite offices elsewhere if housing becomes unattainable even to well-paid employees. We need to inform change, not fight it.
- 100k 10y agoI support this change, but it applies to the zoning that exists. If it passes, NIMBY efforts will shift to down zoning. Down zoning has already happened in many cities (including San Francisco), but it could be taken further.
- rsolari 10y agoGenerally speaking, the downzoning already happened decades ago. In CA, various state laws require that cities zone some parcels for new housing. Often, that housing never happens because cities can disapprove even zoning-compliant projects on those parcels. The by-right law is intended to fix that problem. Unfortunately, the by-right law does not seem likely to pass the legislature. If you support it, you should call and email your state reps.
- raldi 10y ago> If it passes, NIMBY efforts will shift to down zoning. For once, CEQA would actually protect the environment: Nowadays, downzoning requires an impact study. There's no way any credible study could conclude that promoting sprawl is good for the planet.
- jcranmer 10y agoUnfortunately, environmental review is often a vehicle for ensuring that people get as many chances to complain and obstruct as possible, even if the environmental impacts are minimal. An example of absurd objections in this vein can be found in the Virginia Avenue Tunnel replacement project, where residents objected because: a) It would lower their home values (note that the railroad tunnel predates the houses by a few decades, and the railroad has talked about doing this project for 2 decades) b) Extra train traffic means more pollution. Seems reasonable, until you realize that the tunnel is almost literally in the shadow (it's on the south side, not north, so not quite literally) of an interstate. Guess who's responsible for most of the air pollution. c) The project calls for railroad to temporarily run in a exposed trench while building the tunnel. Residents are worried about what would happen if an oil tanker car caught fire. Unfortunately, a glance at the map indicates that this is not on the routes between oil supply centers and oil demand centers, and, as Baltimore found out (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howard_Street_Tunnel_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howard_Street_Tunnel_fire ), fires in tunnels are much worse than fires in the open air.
- raldi 10y agoIf you live in the Bay Area and you'd like to get a voter guide emailed to you right before the election detailing which candidates and propositions are best for increasing the housing supply, you can sign up here: http://www.sfbarf.org/pages/vote.html http://www.sfbarf.org/pages/vote.html
- erehweb 10y agoWary of non-https page.
- eridius 10y agoWhy does pressing Escape on this page cause it to switch to a Squarespace login page?
- RyJones 10y agoIt's a feature[0] of Squarespace [0] https://support.squarespace.com/hc/en-us/articles/205815858-Disabling-the-Escape-key-login https://support.squarespace.com/hc/en-us/articles/205815858-...
- Rapzid 10y agoI wonder how many new houses would need to be built to reduce prices to what I would consider affordable. I wonder why developers would want to sell houses at that rate when new townhomes in Dublin are going for 700k and your looking at 1m+ for a new home. I wonder how people with high home values, especially those who bought in high, will feel about losing so much of their home's value. I suspect homes in SF won't become "affordable" again until another economic crash of some sort.
- jvm 10y agoI agree with the pessimism that we are unlikely to completely solve the problem with these measures, although I believe that is for political economy reasons and not because it's impossible. However I also don't think we should let the perfect be the enemy of the good. > I wonder how many new houses would need to be built to reduce prices to what I would consider affordable. A single new unit permits one additional family to live in the Bay Area. Even if we don't build enough to let everyone live here who wants to, each one we do build counts. And if we built enough it would actually bring prices down. > I wonder why developers would want to sell houses at that rate when new townhomes in Dublin are going for 700k and your looking at 1m+ for a new home Developers just need to earn a spread between development cost and purchase price. Developers will happily build units as long as that spread is sufficient compensation. We are a long way from bringing that spread down to zero (and if we ever got there houses would be much cheaper!!). > I wonder how people with high home values, especially those who bought in high, will feel about losing so much of their home's value Increased as of right property rights actually increases land value and probably ends up being net positive for homeowners. > suspect homes in SF won't become "affordable" again until another economic crash of some sort This is probably true, but increased supply can at least alleviate the problem.
- pessimizer 10y agoPrices won't lower at all. This is a movement by large SF landowners to raise the worth of the land they already own, using credulous tech kids as patsies. They will use new units as tax writeoffs and collateral for loans to scarf up land in gentrifying neighborhoods in other cities and other countries, so they'd rather let them sit vacant than let rents or prices drop by a penny. This is the same as when pharmaceutical companies set up and fund patient advocacy organizations.
- swang 10y agoI got this in my email box and don't know who gave it to them. I'm not sure if I agree or not with the entirety of their platform but I'm too annoyed right now to care.
- InternetGerbil 10y agoScroll down to the bottom of the email. The bottom of all mailchimp emails tell you how the sender got your email. At the bottom of the email it reads: "Copyright © 2016 YIMBY Party, All rights reserved. You are receiving this email because you included your email address with your voter registration."
- swang 10y agoThanks. thought someone else who was running just gave it away.
- hiphipjorge 10y agoAny insights into what the YIMBY position is on rent-control? They don't even mention it in their platform, which seems like a big omission (and obviously not accidental). While I fully support this movement, I do believe rent control has been an effective way of slowing down gentrification and forcing residents out of the area (although there are exceptions to this, of course). As an engineer who should not have rent control but still does I do recognize the system does have its limitations.
- juyvova 10y agothis is such an important subject and I'm happy it's finally getting attention in larger tech community. while housing is a regional issue, it also all starts at home with each city committing to housing policy changes. in Palo Alto Adrian Fine is leading that change - he works for nextdoor.com, he was born and raised in Palo Alto, he is a young, urban planner, govtechy and cyclist. let's start paying attention and start small - if you live in Palo Alto or know someone who does - check out www.votefine.com and support him any way. housing is a social equality issue
- CalRobert 10y agoRemember that a lot of the issue isn't zoning, it's parking minimums. Forcing every studio apartment to have at least two parking spots is an effective (albeit horrific) way to force low density.
- muzz 10y agoYour example is theoretical, this particular constraint does not appear in San Francisco. New buildings (even huge ones) are being built with little to no parking.
- CalRobert 10y agoFair point. I actually was thinking more of the bay as a whole (its own basket case with regards to getting housing built) than SF, which was an error considering that the article is focused on SF.
- muzz 10y agoThe largest distortion to the housing market in California is Prop 13, and its effect is statewide not just confined to SF. This is a large reason why escaping SF's rules by going to bordering/nearby cities doesn't result in significantly lower housing costs. More new supply is great, but doubt it would be enough to significantly offset the much larger effect of Prop 13.
- swagv 10y ago163,696 square miles in California and it can only be these 49...