11 ms·
The Great Productivity Puzzle
- thedevil 10y agoA few rants (mixed in with a few half-baked ideas): 1) Economic progress from the industrial revolution is about quantity. We learned to make a lot more stuff. The industrial revolution is not quite done, but the impact is less and less every decade. We may never match that quantity growth of stuff because we don't even want more stuff, we only want better stuff. And we're getting better stuff and more variety. 2) Info. tech. IS being mismeasured and it's huge. We're not all imagining it. The economics of info tech are REALLY good except in the official GDP numbers. And arguing that it's not counted in economic measurements doesn't debunk the mismeasurement claim, it supports/explains it. What's more, info tech decimates a lot of industries - music, GPS, newspapers, travel agents, etc. And self-driving cars are probably going to decimate the auto industry and wipe out a lot of logistics related jobs. Everyone(A) will be better off but official GDP will fall. 3) Wages aren't growing largely because the economy needs more skilled and more managerial workers, but we don't seem to be producing a lot of them(B). It's an awesome time to be a skilled worker. Good and growing pay and billboard signs desperately seeking talent. There's no end to work that needs to be done with the right skills. Meanwhile, unskilled workers aren't so useful anymore. They were well off when anybody could sit in an assembly line and produce a lot of stuff. But now unskilled workers don't really produce, they mostly trade their time for other people's time (e.g. by cooking their food) and they do so from a weak negotiating position. I don't see any of this changing anytime soon. (A) Everyone = the vast majority of people (B) Anecdotal, I could be wrong
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> The economics of info tech are REALLY good except in the official GDP numbers. Take Google, for example. The (economic) value that Google provides to me is far more than I pay for, which is zero. It's even far more than what Google makes from the ads it serves me. Google is capturing as revenue only a small fraction of the value it creates. That (and similar cases) are why much of the info tech economic/productivity gain doesn't show up in the official GDP numbers.
- nostromo 10y agoWell, the official GDP numbers also don't count the value of sunshine and rainbows -- because that's not what they're created to measure. If you get a lot of value from something you pay nothing for, and it doesn't increase your job output in dollars and cents, then there's no reason it should increase GDP.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoand to that extent we should reduce the importance we place on policies that increase GDP. GDP increases are nice, but they are by no means the only important thing to consider. many other considerations must be made when creating or changing public policy.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoBy that logic, stuff I buy that doesn't increase my job output (like movies, music, and ice cream) also shouldn't be in GDP. Stuff I consume belongs in GDP, even if it doesn't turn into stuff I produce.
- nostromo 10y agoYou missed where I said: > something you pay nothing for So, obviously, yes, if you buy ice cream GDP will go up.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoOK, now I see how to parse what you said. If I pay nothing, and I produce nothing, than it doesn't add to GDP. True, as GDP is constituted. But what if it is free and still makes me better off? Take Linux + Apache, for example. I can create a business for very little money because those are available to me for free. But are they only economically valuable when they cost money? If I used Windows to create my business instead, that would contribute to GDP, even if my business failed. Two (not perfectly) equivalent products, but one counts as GDP, and the other doesn't. Once you see that "economics" can contain more than dollars, then you see that GDP isn't the correct measure of economic activity.
- Spooky23 10y agoYou're wrong about one thing... The low skill jobs didn't vanish. They moved to places where wages and regulation (safety, environmental, etc) are less. The people who made Fisher Price toys in East Aurora, NY were made redundant by equally low/moderate skill workers in Mexico and later China. Your undershirt was made in North Carolina until the late 80s, and shifted to a variety of places until it hit the bottom -- Bangladesh. The IBM people who assembled Power servers in Minnesota were replaced by Mexicans. The Dell folks in North Carolina and Texas were replaced by Mexicans, Taiwanese and Chinese. What you characterize as low skill work and workers still exists and isn't being automated away to the extent that the average HN commenter would suggest. I question the value to the consumer as well. The shoes on my feet are made in some mega-factory in Guangdong. They cost more than the shoes I bought a decade ago that were made in Maine, and are of similar quality. IMO there's a lot of middlemen or some sort of self dealing going on -- producing shoes in massive bulk should push prices down, not up.
- Qworg 10y agoAre they the same price in 2006's dollars?
- ThomPete 10y agoOutsourcing is the last step before automation. You have to follow your own rationale here trough. What happens when mexicans become richer and also concerned about safety at workplace because now they can afford to worry about it? This is why even china is outsourcing to even cheaper places, robotics or why when production sometimes comes back it's in fully automated factories.
- Spooky23 10y ago> What happens when mexicans become richer and also concerned about safety at workplace because now they can afford to worry about it? They get canned and the work gets shipped out to China.
- adrianN 10y agoPeople are only winning over robots because machines are currently more expensive. Labor tends to get more expensive as economies mature, whereas robots keep getting cheaper.
- sien 10y agoIn Robert Gordon's book he points out that GDP growth was not well measured in the industrial revolution either until things had stabilized and after a lot of the big improvements in life had happened. Look at infant mortality and mortality to 5 years old in 1800 vs 1850 vs 1900 vs 1950 or so. How much is it worth not watching your children die? The addition of water and sewage into housing had a huge impact. Dramatically reducing the labor required to live and dramatically reducing disease. Look at life in 1800 vs 1900 and the percentage working on a farm. It was probably an improvement to live in a town or city and not have to get up at dawn and work in a low productivity farm. Look at how life expectancy shot up. How much is it worth looking at your grandchildren grow up? Sure, since 2000 we have vastly better internet connected phones and social networks and it isn't well measured. But what wasn't well measured in the past was probably worth more and was more important for people's lives.
- taneq 10y ago> We may never match that quantity growth of stuff because we don't even want more stuff, we only want better stuff. This was my thought. This kind of measurement of the economy conflates maximum potential productivity with market demand, in essence assuming a supply-limited scenario. We've reached the point now where most people in first-world countries have as much as they want of most things that aren't super new, super expensive or super high tech. Production is now demand-limited.
- tunesmith 10y agoWhat sorts of constraints in our daily lives feel blindingly obvious, in terms of wishing for a solution? I mean beyond true life-transition concerns like finding new housing or new jobs. In the past, I'm sure a clothes-washing machine must have felt pretty obvious even if people weren't sure what it was. It's always been a pain to do laundry and there had to have been a wish for some sort of contraption to make it drastically easier, even before knowing what that contraption would be. When I think of real constraints in daily life, I can only think of things like - the effort of transition from waking to working, commuting, perhaps the convenience of having nutritious food that improves your health, and... what else? What sorts of things do you think of when you say, "I wish I could just snap my fingers and..."
- maxxxxx 10y agoThere are plenty - Folding laundry - Setting a table - Ironing shirts - Cleaning the house - Doing taxes -.....
- roymurdock 10y agoEating, exercising, sleeping. One day we'll look back on these activities as we look back on hand-washing clothing, drawing water from the town well, burning coal/wood for central heating, etc. The question is: what will "we" be at that point.
- FiatLuxDave 10y agoThink bigger. I truly feel that we won't be considered truly civilized as a species until some child has to ask their mother, "Mommy, what was pooping?". The child would then slowly grow more and more horrified as their mother explains what people had to do in their daily lives in the past. "Mommy, that's disgusting! How did people live like that?" We still have a very long way to go.
- imglorp 10y agoI normally take a dim view of economics and this article is worse than usual. My complaint is the massless, frictionless world of economics does not take real world forces into account. > technological advancement just ain’t what it used to be. We're about to see millions of human roles vaporize when automated driving hits home. This isn't like the dishwasher or desktop calculator. We've already seen self checkout stations. How long until whole stores are automated? Eg: http://newatlas.com/go/5028 http://newatlas.com/go/5028 > Many productivity-enhancing new technologies are capital goods—think back to the moving truck. Bullshit as well. Hardware is rapidly approaching free as services dominate. Plus most of our readers shift capex to opex by cloud hosting, for example. Furthermore, offshoring and free trade means you won't invest in equipment because you're not even making the widgets any more, in house. > Look at what an ideal kitchen looked like in 1955 Mostly irrelevant when "instant gratification isn't fast enough". Our kids can't even be bothered to microwave something in 30 sec, so prepackaged convenience, dominates households. Finally, what does corporate malfeasance (eg VW emissions, banking crisis, LIBOR fraud etc) do to productivity? I think this is a more honest assessment: http://www.businessinsider.com/alan-greenspans-mistake-has-led-to-debt-and-stagnant-wages-2016-8?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=referral http://www.businessinsider.com/alan-greenspans-mistake-has-l...
- dredmorbius 10y agoI think you're giving this article shorter shrift than it deserves. While I don't feel it (or Gordon) quite puts its finger on the cause, it does a good job of quantifying the symptoms. Gordon does this at rather more length. In particular, we're seeing challenges, from within the economic establishment, of the prevailing view of the past 60 years or so that economic growth is normal and perpetual. On your first point: Gordon illustrates this in exquisite detail, but the impacts of technological innovation (vs. the rate of innovative change disrupting procedures, devices, companies, etc.) have fallen tremendously over the past 150 years. Gordon looks at the period 1870 - 2015, divide roughly into three (almost) 50 year periods: 1870 - 1920, 1920 - 1970, and 1970 - present. In the first 50 years, you saw virtually all the innovations you will find around you today, in at least some form. Steam power, electrical generation (and light, heat, motion, sound recording & transmission), radio, elevators, cinema, sanitation and sewage (far more responsible for improved life expectency than all the rest of medicine), elevators, skyscrapers, and most of all, petroleum and its consequences: cars, trucks, power tools, plastics, and more. It's almost easier to list what didn't develop: TV, penicillin, DNA, computers, lasers, nuclear power, gas turbines, and satellite launch capabilities. What developed from 1920 - 1970 were the applications and utilisations of those technologies. Gordon notes that the home of 1920 was connected to five networks: water, gas, electricity, sewage, and phone. I'd add two more: the postal and package delivery networks, which whilst not fully end-to-end, provide the foundation of the Amazon of its age, Sears, Roebuck and Company. The fundamentally new technologies from 1970 to present have been far fewer, almost entirely concentrated into communications, information and entertainment, and have had vastly smaller impacts on work, home life, health, and transport than the innovations of 1870-1920 and applications of 1920-1970. (Again: covered in detail by Gordon.) On productivity-enhancement as capital goods: I'm finding your argument unpersuasive. Capital equipment, the energy to drive it, and its organisation are key to productivity. Much now derives from how pieces are organised -- WalMart and Amazon are as much logistical companies as anything else. But yes, capital plays a huge role. Of the kitchen, your third point: again, the contrast is the kitchen of 2015 vs. 1970 vs. 1920 vs. 1870. In 1920 you may well have had a wood-burning stove (gas was being introduced), no refrigerator, in some homes no running water (Gordon highlights the total amount of hauling that was required in the 1870 home: water, wood, and food in, various wastes out, little arriving on its own). The change 1870 - 1920, 1920 - 1950, 1950 - 1970, and 1970 - 2015 of kitchen appointments has shown a tremendous fall in rate. That microwave your kids can't be bothered to use didn't exist in the 1970 kitchen, but that's about it. VW's behavior may well be a consequence of firms pressurised to ever-increasing returns in light of declining rates of growth, or of declining absolute productivity.
- nostromo 10y agoI hear classic economic thinking is that productivity gains lead to higher wages. But could the causation be reversed? Cheap labor tends to disincentivize innovations that can lead to productivity gains. Perhaps we're entering a period where there are simply too many people for too few jobs. This keeps unemployment high, wages flat, and removes the incentive for companies to invest in automation.
- barrkel 10y agoI don't buy it. For labour intensive jobs, the more people you have, the more jobs you create: there is no fixed pool of jobs that gets consumed by labour. The labour itself needs servicing. Jobs that aren't labour-intensive are typically higher and higher skilled. IMO there are too few highly skilled people in many skilled professions, especially in countries like the UK, which no longer have a robust apprenticeship system. Shoddy work is the order of the day. If there were more people competing for the jobs, I'd expect lower prices and higher quality. And tech? It's almost impossible to hire really good people.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThat argument has in fact been made for why, e.g., the Romans didn't exploit coal, which they had (from England) rather than human and muscle power. Slaves were far too cheap. A developing thought: the industrial revolution, writ large -- starting with the Medieval industrial revolution of increased use of wind and water power, was in many was a continuously ramping-up circumstance of living close to (but not immediately at) the thresholds of subsistence, having available opportunities for improvement, and having a gradually increasing degree of technical complexity in tapping into those opportunities, which developed as the challenges and opportunities increased. If you're not testing your limits, you've got no incentive to improve. If you've pursued some improvement, but are then contented with the results, you'll continue in a "fat and happy" existence. This has occurred in several places and times through human history. If you're pushing at limits, and are aware of the concept of technological advance, but the resources aren't available, you'll tend to slide into decline. Arguably this happened to the UK following WWI. England had steamed into modernity on the basis of its coal reserves, but switching to oil, without (then-known) reserves, she stumbled and the United States picked up the slack. (Why the Middle East didn't exploit its own oil reserves earlier is a tremendously interesting question -- whether for want of technology, industrial capacity, or other reasons. I'm planning on looking into this.) Another possibility is that the technological leaps are simply too great. The Middle East question may have been a case of this, and the West (and world at large) may face that conundrum in switching to renewable or sustainable energy options.
- guelo 10y agoYes, things like Google Search must be increasing productivity. But at the same time the amount of time dedicated to infotech entertainment addiction is going through the roof. I wonder how much productivity the hours of Facebooking at work is costing us.
- iofj 10y ago> infotech entertainment addiction Those are things being sold, that people want. How is this anything but a large positive for the economy ?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoForgetting for a while the non-linear costs of distraction in cognitively intensive jobs, I wonder if Facebooking at work is really costing us anything at all? I'm having a hard time imagining that office workers of 20+ years ago were that more job-focused than they're now. But then again, the problem may be Internet in general - I can't imagine people being able to do so many non-work errands while in the office if it weren't for e-mail in particular.
- cableshaft 10y agoI did data entry in an office with no internet connectivity (well it did, but they didn't allow browser usage, we connected to mainframes to do our work) before about 12 or 13 years ago. When people wanted to zone out they read books, usually. Audiobooks were also common. I brought the entire series of Discworld novels in on pdf, and managed to read the entire series while I worked there. I also wrote a bunch of notes down on paper. Hell, when I was working in warehouses away from computers entirely I'd still zone out during it and mentally work out some ideas for personal projects once I was done with work. Sometimes I actually miss that, since I seemed to have a lot more ideas then. Point being, you don't need computers or internet for people to find ways not to be 100% productivity machines.
- darawk 10y agoAm I missing something or did the 'debunking' of theory #1 not hold any water? > First, they said, mismeasurement has always been an issue in the information-technology sector, and it was just as big an issue in the period from 1995 to 2005, when productivity was growing rapidly. If your hypothesis is that non-technological productivity growth has reached its peak but technological productivity growth is accelerating, then this is exactly what you'd expect. And you'd expect the mis-measurement issue to take you much further from the mark then you do now. Saying that mismeasurement has always been an issue completely ignores the fact that how big of an issue it is relative to other factors may have changed. > Second, the productivity slowdown hasn’t been confined to sectors in which output is tough to measure: it has been broadly based This is just stating the contradiction of the original hypothesis. If mis-measurement is an issue, how do you know that it's broadly based? > And, finally, many of the benefits that we’ve reaped from things like smartphones and Google searches have been confined to non-market activities While true, it's hard to imagine that things like access to Wikipedia, Stack overflow, instant global messaging, etc..Haven't significantly enhanced productivity for a variety of office workers as well. Not to mention automation technologies a la Amazon's Kiva robots and other factory automation tech.
- Animats 10y agoSomething that's puzzled me for a while: why haven't we hit "peak office" yet? Why are there still so many people working in offices? By now, we should have many abandoned office blocks, much as we have abandoned factories in the Rust Belt. But that's not happening. We have all this office automation, but too many people in offices. Are marketing cost and G&A (general and administrative) increasing as a fraction of cost of goods/services sold? Perhaps it's the overhead of capitalism. Advertising just moves demand around; where the savings rate is low, it can't create it. There are a surprising number of products, from movies to telephone service, where the marketing cost exceeds the cost of providing the product or service. One problem with a winner-take-all economy is that the cost of competition goes up, because being slightly better at the margin becomes more expensive. It's like sports; the additional input required for 1% more performance is a lot more than 1%, once you're close to the record.
- Swizec 10y agoIf nothing else, it's because people like to separate their living space from their working space. For reasons ranging from Easier To Get Into Work Mode, to No Screaming Toddlers. It turns out renting office space or a big enough apartment/house to have an extra office is expensive. Wouldn't it be nice if somebody else paid for that? Perhaps somebody who also pays you and can then recuperate this cost with scale by putting multiple people together in the same area. If everyone had their own home office, how much would salary have to increase? Take San Francisco for example. Renting a 2-bedroom apartment instead of a 1-bedroom would increase my and my girlfriend's rent by about $1,000 per month. This would give one of us a good home office. The startup I work for pays about $10,000 to rent a big-ish office space. There are 15 of us working in it pretty comfortably. That's a lot cheaper than everyone paying an extra $1,000.
- aidos 10y agoI might be misunderstanding your parent's comment but I think the question wasn't, "why are people still doing their work from offices?" and more, "what are all those people in offices still working on?" There's a lot of work that feels like it should have been automated out of existence and yet there are still lots of people working on it.
- greenmountin 10y agoOne approach to understanding low productivity that I find interesting is covered in Jason Furman's very readable "Is This Time Different? The Opportunities and Challenges of Artificial Intelligence" report [1] -- he's one of Obama's lead economists. In short, productivity growth may be lagging because of AI etc; it's because people have to spend time retraining for jobs not obsoleted by new technologies. He briefly states his rejection of Gordon. [1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/page/files/20160707_cea_ai_furman.pdf https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/page/files/20...
- jackcosgrove 10y agoI'll modify Gordon's hypothesis. New technology is no less productive than it used to be. The difference is that new technology requires fewer humans in the loop. That's why productivity is rising but wages are not.
- mcguire 10y agoThere is something radically wrong with how they measure productivity. I don't know what it is, but the details matter. I remember the first verse of this song, back in the '90s when economists were wondering if information technology was a productivity sink. All of this new fun stuff was everywhere, but productivity measurements were going down. At the same time, just-in-time inventory management was acknowledged as the greatest innovation since sliced bread---and you can't do that without information technology. And the changes since then have only made IT more central and that has reduced the friction to do essentially everything else.
- throw_away_777 10y agoProductivity increases are going to the top earners, as wages stagnate for most of the population. http://inequality.org/income-inequality/ http://inequality.org/income-inequality/ This has many reasons behind it, including political factors such as the decline of unions and increase of free trade.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThis is yet another review of Robert Gordon's The Rise and Fall of American Growth. Incidentally, William Nordhaus also just published one.[1] Of the good: Gordon's book is a tour-de-force of the past 150 years (nearly) of economic progress in the US, and documents impacts on everyday life meticulously and engagingly. I and numerous reviewers, several of whom I strongly suspected to disagree, find the case he makes for a hump-shaped growth curve -- that is an increasing accelleration from 1870 - 1950, followed by a slowing accelleration, though continued growth, from 1950 to present -- compelling. Gordon also makes a good case for several of the factors contributing to the exceptionally vibrant growth from 1920 - 1950, including especially the stimulus of World War II and the post-war recovery. But also the very fundamental nature of many of the innovations brought online at the time. His treatments especially of transportation, communications, healthcare, and household life are spectacular. I recommend them highly. There are some missing elements though. Gordon never uses the phrase "Maslow's Hierarchy" -- the pyramid of needs that humans must have met, starting with food, clothing, and housing, and extending through safety and security, social engagement, and self-fulfillment. He does address many of these individually, and notes that early innovations tended strongly to address the base elements, and of the importance of security and predictability (a tremendously under-acknowledged failing of post-1970 economic experience) among individuals. A possible defense of ongoing growth might be made by seeing the present period as one of a consolidation and development of technologies -- say, very large datacenters and broadband backplanes, as well as increasingly capable mobile devices and programming tools for developing them -- which may see some future breakout. Gordon seems in this, and several other areas, particularly incurious. Gordon's life work is largely focused on GDP measurement, and he leans very heavily on this. His argument is that GDP underaccounts for true improvements in lifestyle, an argument with some merits, though others argue that it overaccounts by failing to take into consideration diseconomies. It's curious that Gordon doesn't explore alternative quality-of-life measures suggested by many contemporary critics of economic orthodoxy. More fundamentally, in not addressing them, Gordon raises some very profound questions over the fundamental basis of economics. What is wealth? What is value? How is value associated with cost and price? How should costs of renewable vs. nonrenewable resources be considered? Is energy a fundamentally different economic input? What is the relationship of energy to economic growth? What is technology? What is the mechanism, or mechanisms, by which technology does, and doesn't, promote increased productivity? What are the market-mediated impacts of improved productity, particularly as expressed through the Jevons Paradox, Giffen, and Veblen goods? How does one measure quality? How does one measure the total capacity or capability of an economy? These aren't easy questions. They are, I'm finding as I research economic theory and its history, less ridiculous, and rather more explored, than I'd have thought. There are some exceptionally notable departures and paths taken in economic theory over time, often poorly addressed in the current curriculum. As with some of the infrastructure issues above, Gordon's marked disinclination to pick up stones, particularly ones on which sacred cows seem perched, strikes me as a singular weakness of his book. There are other authors, mostly neglected, who've explored this space. Eric D. Beinhocker's 2006 book The Origin of Wealth, Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen's Entropy and the Economic Process, W. Brian Arthur's work on the economy as an evolving complex system, and others. I see the questions and explorations as deeply related. ________________________________ Notes: 1. http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2016/08/18/why-economic-growth-will-fall/ http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2016/08/18/why-economic-grow... Nordhaus is cited in Gordon for his work on economics of both computers and lighting, and addresses advances of lighting (and underaccounting of these in GDP) in his review. It's an interesting exploration of limitations of economic measurement.
- joeyo 10y ago. If Gordon is right, sagging productivity figures simply reflect . the fact that scientific progress doesn’t have as much impact on . the economy as it once did. Rather than waiting for productivity . growth and wages to rebound of their own accord, Gordon supports . policies designed to expand the size and quality of the labor . force, such as raising the retirement age, letting more . immigrants into the country, and expanding access to higher . education. Assuming for the moment that Gordon is right about the diagnosis, isn't this remedy exactly backwards? If productivity (per worker?) is down, than surely increasing the size of the labor pool is exactly the wrong medicine and will result productivity per worker to decrease further. Increasing the quality of the labor force through higher education, etc, makes sense. But how can increasing the size of the pool lead to wage increases in the absence of other productivity gains?
- georganos 10y agoI read that as in increasing the number of highly qualified immigrants, thus increasing the quality of the workforce.
- joeyo 10y agoWhat's your read on increasing the retirement age, then?
- douche 10y agoAwesome, keep the boomers around even longer, clogging up the jobs and lanes of advancement. My generation is never going to be able to retire anyway, since Social Security will be kaput long before we see a dime, so whatever...
- vasilipupkin 10y ago1) more people means more demand for stuff, means more incentive to produce stuff, more competition to sell them stuff and higher economic growth 2) if people want to come here, it's because they think they are not being as productive as they could be where they are now.
- drusenko 10y agoProductivity increases when you save people time. When a job used to take 2 hours and now it only takes 1, productivity has gone up. I wonder if the reason productivity is going down is that the current cohort of 2010s technology companies may actually have the opposite aim: consuming people's attention and time. Things like social networking, advertising supported businesses, mobile gaming, &c., aren't saving people time at all.
- iofj 10y agoThat's just part of the story. Productivity = value(p.output) / value(p.input) for all p in the economy. So essentially how do you raise productivity ? Make ridiculous profits. Reducing the time it takes to do something, IF it results in more being done, certainly raises productivity but it isn't the whole story. Currently the problem seems to be overcapacity pushing down on margins, with the situation being confused by central banks non-printing ("loaning") between scare quotes because the prospect of those loans getting paid back are certainly not what they should be.
- djyaz1200 10y agoIt's social media.
- hristov 10y agoThe reason for this is deflation. Deflation in our economy is massive and far under-reported. Deflation is especially great in areas where productivity is rising. The way economists measure productivity is by the monetary value of the thing produced. Thus, productivity gets tied in with inflation and deflation. Suppose you make widgets, and can make 10 of them per hour. Suppose you sell each of them for $10 bucks. Now suppose inflation hits and the price of the same widgets is all of a sudden $20 per hour. You still only make 10 widgets per hour. But all of a sudden you are twice as productive according to the way the government and economists measure productivity. The opposite happens when deflation occurs. If your widgets all of a sudden start selling for $5 per hour instead of $10, you will be considered by the official economic analysis to be twice as lazy even if you work just as hard and make just as many widgets per hour. And there you have your problem. Deflation is hitting everything, but it is hitting industries that benefit from productivity of new technology the hardest. Take a serer cpu made today that can perform 100 times as much work as a server cpu made about 10-15 years ago. Is intel considered a hundred times more productive when they make this cpu that does 100 times more work? Of course not. Their productivity is based on how much the cpu sells for and since per cpu prices have held stable to slightly decreasing over that time, intel's productivity for that particular cpu is deemed to have decreased as well. Or take pictures. Twenty to thirty years ago there were probably over a hundred thousand people working in photo development shops making pictures for people. Now about a 100-200 programmers (estimated) among Google, Apple, Facebook and yahoo probably provide the vast majority of picture viewing services in America. Is that a great increase of productivity? It should be, because a hundred people are doing the same stuff a hundred thousand were doing twenty years ago. But officially it isn't because picture viewing is considered to be free, so no revenue is assigned to it. So productivity growth is happening, but unfortunately it is accompanied by large drops in pricing, which make the official measure of productivity look bad. Why are prices dropping? This has to do with something journalists do not like to talk about -- wage stagnation, income inequality, etc.
- buzzybee 10y agoI thought about this for a moment and then remembered something important. The big driver of our economy today is to add a layer of customization and modularity to existing processes via IT: Now you can get ala carte information, or summon a cab from anywhere, plan and present social arrangements with a minimum of formal overhead, or manufacture goods in smaller runs than before. Physical processes like transportation increasingly fit into a packet switching analogy - not driven by a particular modality of capital and energy(bike, car, train, plane), but by protocols driving end-to-end connectivity, like shipping containers. This is not a process that creates value in the same way that using energy more intensively, to spin wheels, lift objects, melt iron, or process chemicals, grows value. In past iterations, we've always had a link between energy intensity and industrial growth. But now we have a huge demand for new designs that reconsider the same processes, using a similar amount or less energy than before. The amount of labor that can go into designing that stuff is similarly huge. But it's a superstar situation - a few people make big breakthroughs by chance. We are "less" productive on average, routine work doesn't reap the benefits, and capital allocation doesn't have the guarantee of power it used to, in a world where tiny software startups are constantly scanning for a new platform lock-in opportunity. The economy stumbles from one speculative bubble to the next, trying to resume a paradigm of the past. It's a very chaotic, disruption-heavy, what-have-you-done-for-me-lately future that we've built for ourselves, and it's made everyone a little more insecure even as it produces its share of new wonders.
- gumby 10y agoWhat frustrates me about articles like this (even professional ones -- this simplifies for a general audience) is that they only look at one side of the equation. Low inflation is the opposite side, and it's interesting. Yes, GDP$ per unit hour has not gone up much, but the flip side is that the economic value of the output has gone down. If you look in terms of PPP, workers are doing better: fewer labor hours go into buying dinner. The corollary is that fewer hours are required to produce PPP equivalent product (e.g. a car) so fewer workers are needed (since the $ are not going up at the same rate it looks like productivity is not). That's why the LFPR is sinking. A victorian era "smokestack" model isn't useful when looking at this world. This is why automation really is likely to cut employment this time (in fact it already is) and that's the real economic problem to be worrying about. Which some are (e.g. the small UBI experiments under way) but it's still not mainstream.
- eridius 10y agoWhat is PPP?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- arnavroy 10y agoPurchasing power parity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity
- wodenokoto 10y agobut aren't the US experiencing very high inflation?
- redwood 10y agoNo.
- botterworkshop 10y ago
- chmike 10y agoThe theories presented in this article consider USA economy as adiabatic. They ignore the growth occurring in Russia and China, and how this has affected the growth in Europe and USA.
- mlvljr 10y agoHow about Brazil ands India, too, then?
- wazoox 10y agoProblem: how is productivity measured? The example given is pretty transparent, however, if a doctor sees 20 patients a day instead of 15, his productivity is up, but does he do a better job overall? Productivity can enhance up to some point; you can't indefinitely build more cars every day for instance. Final stance: there is no such thing as infinite growth on a finite planet.