14 ms·
I Don’t Care How Well You Code, Understand Your Compensation
- kelukelugames 10y agoComplain time! Before I joined my last company, the recruiter said my shares were worth $1 each. After I joined I found out they were 50 cents per share. I don't think the recruiter intentionally mislead me. Probably lazy and uninformed.
- nibnib 10y agoI don't understand most of the financial terms used in this article. Where do I start?
- jfoutz 10y agoEh, the gist is employees take on very little risk. We get paid every two weeks up to layoff or retirement. It's different when you are looking for investors.
- tluyben2 10y agoI read it as; if you take shares instead of your marketvalue in cash then you need to understand what you are doing. A lot of people do not. Term sheets and contracts by investors usually contain things that benefits only them, especially when the company does not work as expected.
- nibnib 10y agoThis was my take, and I'm pretty sure I belong to the group that does not.
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y agoEmployees take more risk. Each one is putting in an amount of money equal to an angel, often with options that give them far less compensation compared to that angel. You can't work for 10 companies so all your eggs are in one basket. You would be right if the employees were getting market salary and working a market/normal work week of say 50 hours.
- Animats 10y agoThe basic thing to understand is the concept of "dilution". Companies can issue new stock in exchange for new investment funding, driving down the value of existing stock. Sizable dilution is rare in publicly held companies, but common in privately held ones. There are often contractual terms which protect some parties against dilution. Founders and early stage investors may be protected, while other employees are not. Sometimes founders don't have anti-dilution protection. For an overview, see [1]. This is historically unusual. Up to the last decade, companies tended to become profitable and go public much earlier. Now we have round after round of private financing going into money-losing companies to fuel rapid growth, in hopes that, somehow, they'll dominate the industry and make the money back someday. That may not happen. Twitter won on market share and still can't make money. Uber may be next. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2011/10/13/understanding-how-dilution-affects-you-at-a-startup/ https://techcrunch.com/2011/10/13/understanding-how-dilution...
- UK-AL 10y agoI think its rare to have any anti dilution protection for anyone in a high growth company. At most you have then option to buy into further rounds, so you keep your percentage the same.
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y agoI've seen anti-dilution clauses in founder documents, and really you should have one that limits dilution under certain circumstances (so you don't get arbitrarily or selectively diluted out.) They are probably extremely rare for general employees, but they are not rare for people who have negotiating power (eg: C level executives.) ==== Apparently I am blocked from responding too often as a new account, so adding here because I can't add a new comment to the parents parent: It really is quite shocking how often people act like these things are not the business of employees. On one hand they want you to take a lower salary, and they claim that options will make up for it, but on the other hand they think it is somehow unreasonable for you to ask basic questions necessary to value the options? I recently had a CFO act incredulous when I requested a copy of the Stock Option plan. Like I didn't deserve to have a copy of it, even though he was requiring me to sign a contract agreeing to its terms. At that point I basically wrote off the options, and have written off the company and am on my way out. The reason they get away with this kind of obfuscation is, I think, that most engineers just go along to get along and aren't too demanding. Unions would be worse, but we need to start sticking up for ourselves a lot more.
- uiri 10y agoI hope the following is helpful rather than confusing - feel free to ask any clarifying questions. Also, I will preface this with the fact that I am an engineer and not a finance person. I may be subtly wrong on some points and I am happy to be corrected by those with more knowledge on these topics. Liquidity preferences - Also described in the article as "investors escape safely on Preference stacks", investors usually have terms which state that when the company is sold, they get paid first so that they can at least recoup their investment before anyone else gets paid. Usually they get paid again with everyone else, resulting in a "double dip" into the sale proceeds. Reverse-merger IPO - this is a rare (for tech companies) deal structure where private company A merges with public company B. The resulting merged company is now publicly listed because company B has already gone through the IPO process. Dilution - described in the article as "over-dilution" and "dilutive financing", if there are X shares of a company and you own Y shares, then you own Y/X % of the company. If the company then creates Z shares to sell to investors, you own Y/(X + Z) % of the company. The difference between these percentages is dilution. Often, existing investors have anti-dilution provisions. They are able to buy additional shares in the round up to their existing percentage. Founders and employees usually have no such luck. Ratchet in a down round - Admittedly, I don't know what a ratchet is. I would guess that it is a protection of some sort for investors from a down round and thus bad for founders and employees. Non-liquid - (nearly) impossible to sell Highly volatile - a plot of price over time looks like a rollercoaster Anti-dilution provision - see the latter part of "dilution" above IPO protections - Also have no idea what these could be. I would guess at something to protect investors who invest at a high valuation where the public valuation is lower. 409-A pricing - How the shares are assigned a value for tax purposes
- kspaans 10y agoThis showed up on HN last year: https://github.com/jlevy/og-equity-compensation https://github.com/jlevy/og-equity-compensation It's got advice on where to start, common gotchas to look out for (in the US), and definitions of everything.
- marssaxman 10y agoIt's really quite simple: you assume it's all worthless, because that's how it starts and that's how it generally ends. Even if it were going to be worth something, you'd have been better off taking the money up front and investing it however you wanted in the meantime. But it doesn't really matter, because you have no control over this anyway. All you have to do is decide whether the salary is high enough; the rest is irrelevant. Some people really enjoy playing the lottery. If that's you, well, knock yourself out getting into the details of the options package! Just don't kid yourself or make any serious life plans based on your hopes about that stuff.
- cloudjacker 10y ago> All you have to do is decide whether the salary is high enough; the rest is irrelevant. You mean feign interest in the company for two years longer than every VC that passed them over? I'm being cynical, but I am baffled how Silicon Valley companies think they are going to be privileged enough to hire engineers that are actually interested in their company's ambiguous mission, amongst the subset of engineers randomly on the market at any given time How many VCs weren't interested again?
- YuriNiyazov 10y agoThis is really wrong. You can very well assume that it's worthless. If you do, chances are you will not do your research on things like early exercise and 83(b) filing (whether, for example, you work at a company that even allows things like that). Then, in the very small chance that your equity is actually worth something, you will be kicking yourself really hard because if you'd only prepared, you could've been paying LTCG on the whole spread, rather than dealing with AMT and trying to find a private buyer for your illiquid stock to pay off the IRS and the CA FTB.
- vacri 10y agoThat all sounds like a fancy way of saying "playing the lottery".
- 10y ago
- cloudjacker 10y ago> So talk to the CFO about the numbers — when you’re hired, when it’s fundraising time, and any time in between. Hahahaha, oh man so here's the part where I just dump all my emails about the answers I have gotten back from CFOs over the last decade: - "common stock shareholders aren't privy to financial details" - "we don't share that information" - "I discussed it with the board [consisting of myself] and they decided not to release valuation information" - "The stock options are just to retain employees!" and other awkward non-sequiturs that are distinctly not a financial statement. So do ya'll want to unionize or nah, I have a feeling Peter Thiel and Andreesen would totally support it and we already make enough to make union dues negligible.
- guelo 10y agoOne time I had the privilege of getting the CEO's assistant to read me over the phone a prepared high level summary of company financials. She read very quickly and refused to pause or repeat anything.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> common stock shareholders aren't privy to financial details Delaware law lets you make a Section 220 request [1] to inspect a corporation's books and records for a proper purpose, e.g. to identify potential buyers and sellers or for investment valuation purposes. [1] http://www.pepperlaw.com/publications/what-every-corporate-counsel-should-know-about-stockholder-inspection-rights-2009-11-17/ http://www.pepperlaw.com/publications/what-every-corporate-c...
- cloudjacker 10y agoThanks! Now is there any trendy company that streamlines this service?
- icebraining 10y ago(Noob here) Don't most startups offer stock options and not actual stock nowadays? Is the owner of options classified as a stockholder under the law?
- justinlardinois 10y ago> one of the reasons I chose to work on Wall Street prior to joining a start-up was to fully grasp the financing terms of the companies for which I would later work. And this is also the reason why I'm very wary about equity. I'd certainly want to work for a company that's going to do well financially, regardless of how I'm being compensated, but I have only a layman's understanding of business and finance. I'm simply not equipped to judge the financial health of a potential employer and how much its equity is really worth.
- zatkin 10y agoThen you should educate yourself. Take a class or two at your local community college or do some research online. It's extremely vital that you have a good understanding of the financial world we live in. Knowing a thing or two about some of the basics will help you in the long run, regardless of whether it's related to compensation or equity.
- justinlardinois 10y agoIs that really enough? When I accept equity as compensation, I'm essentially investing in the company I work for. People who invest for a living typically have more education on the subject than a handful of community college courses.
- tn13 10y agoForget about equity, at least get the salary part right. Keep interviewing to check how much the market is willing to pay you and you will be surprised to know that "loyalty" does not pay much in America unless the employer is willing to offer you substantial amount of money to spend like 4 years at the company.
- dboreham 10y agoOne of the cases where jwz is spot on : it's a lottery ticket, nothing more.
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y agoExcept that you can pay $1 for a lottery ticket with long odds of a $100M return, here you are paying $70k for a $1M lottery ticket with equally long odds of return.
- signa11 10y ago> ... here you are paying $70k for a $1M lottery ticket ... care to elaborate a bit on how you got that ? thanks !
- ryandrake 10y agoIf the difference between what you can make in total compensation at BigCompany and your salary at Startup is $70K, then you're essentially buying a lottery ticket for $70K... PER YEAR.
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y ago...and if your options are for %0.1 of the company, they have to be a unicorn for you to make a million bucks (assuming that $1M is "lottery ticket" paying off.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y agoSo, I've been working for startups for a long time. Finally I've reached two "rules"- - Be a founder - Restricted Stock Units or Preferred Shares are the only way to go. Options are way slanted against employees. If you have a market value of $150k and you take $80k in salary, you're giving up $70k of real money each year. The value of your options in most situations that work out well (Eg: base hits) are going to be less than that (when accounting for risk). If you get fired in the 11th month, you've lost about $70k and get nothing. IF you get fired in the 13th month, you have 1 year and one month vested, and 90 days (most likely) to spend real money to turn those options -- which you've already paid for by giving up market salary-- into something valuable. Options are basically a raw deal, and I'm not even getting into liquidation preferences. IF you give up real salary of $70k a year, that is the same, literally, as the angel who puts $70k into your A round. You should be getting the same terms as the A round in that case. That you don't is part of how the game is rigged. You should vest almost from the beginning. I think 90 days of trial period with a cliff (Eg: you vest 90 days on your 91st day then every 30 days after that you vest another 30 days) is ok. You don't want the cap table to be too complex. Yes, Venture Capitalists wouldn't like this. Of course, because it's fair rather than tilted towards them. I know this won't become popular because engineers are too easy to manipulate. They read some self serving VC blog about why liquidation preferences are perfectly acceptable and they buy it. But if you're there the year before the VC you took a lot more risk than they did. You're investing your real salary that you're not getting and could be getting by working for a fully developed company, while they are investing other people's money. I've heard of programs called Slicing Pie and the like that make this easy. Why you want to be a founder? Well, after over 20 years working for startups, I have spent al to of time asking CEOs and CFOs specific pointed financial questions. I have gotten the runaround from them, and that's a flag that makes it easy to pass on the company. But when I haven't gotten the run around, way too often what they have told me was false. Many times the CFO when asked for the number of authorized shares or the total shares on a fully diluted basis would give me some BS number. I don't know if he didn't actually know. (Many times the startup doesn't even have a CFO at that point.) Many times I've been told that options accelerate, on acquisition, only to find out that the founders deal was that way but they wrote a new option plan for later employees that didn't have as nice of terms. Just recently I saw a plan that gave the "compensation committee" the ability to do anything they wanted including cancelling all outstanding options grants, in the event of an acquisition. I really don't know who wrote that document but I think it was one of the investors, and the "executive management" of the company never actually read it. They didn't believe it said that when I pointed it out. (Who am I, I'm just an engineer (this time, been a founder in the past, but I thought this company had reduced a lot of risk and so the tradeoff was worth it.) So, another piece of advice- work for a company where the founders are hard asses when it comes to investment and terms. These people didn't even read the stock option plan (and weren't going to give it to me, despite requiring all of us employees to sign an agreement agreeing to its terms, because our CFO didn't realize that there was a separate plan document- he kept saying (or thought) that the agreements were the plan!) This kind of lack of attention to detail is very common, in my experience in startups. Working for a startup that fails is pretty lame, but working for a startup that succeeds and you get screwed out of the upside is much, much worse.
- romanovcode 10y agoI don't like the tone that equity is a "compensation". In no means it's a compensation, it's not even a bonus. It's just something on top.
- brianwawok 10y agoLook up the definition of compensation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- victor9000 10y agoIt's a lottery ticket. You say thanks when you're given one, but you don't use it to justify a lack of real compensation. Because in the end, you can't pay bills with lottery tickets.
- z1mm32m4n 10y agoFor those wishing to take up the author's claim of understanding their compensation, Brian Krausz gave a great talk about this subject, titled "Demystifying Startup Job Offers" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y13tqllSros https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y13tqllSros Worth watching if you're looking for a nice starting off point for some of these areas.
- mosselman 10y agoMisleading title and premise: The author makes it seem as if something will be explained for people who are not 'financially-savvy', but nothing is explained. In fact it is made more complex. Which is fine, but still it was kind of misleading. Solid advice to get financial advice nonetheless. Can someone explain this part to my/some-of-us like I am five?: "Which muppets advised them to spend hard-earned cash to exercise a non-liquid, highly volatile financial instrument? There is no world where the (relatively) small tax breaks involved justify the expected value equation, given that Good Technology was nowhere near exit." I have no idea what it says here.
- javier2 10y agoI thought the same. The post does not explain anything at all, just dumps a lot of jargon. I think it says employees are convinced to spend their money on options/equity in the startup they work for, but a startup is a gamble, most don't work out. Specifically, in the Good Technology the author feels the valuation given in the buy was nowhere near the point at which the investors/founders had hoped to exit?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Noseshine 10y ago"advised to exercise their stock options" The option is free. Exercising them is not. You won't get from having the option to jump into the water, you only get wet if you actually do it.
- signa11 10y ago> I have no idea what it says here. i would _guess_ it means that (in this specific scenario): folks miscalculated the perceived tax-break benefits offered (due to option exercise at the time of vesting) vis-a-vis using their money more profitably somewhere else.
- senko 10y ago> exercise a non-liquid, highly volatile financial instrument? Buy something that can't be converted quickly and easily back into cash (non-liquid), and whose value changes a lot (highly volatile). This means if it starts to go down, you can't get rid of it fast enough and you stand to lose a lot. > the expected value equation, given that Good Technology was nowhere near exit The value equation would be, the outcome ($) times the likelihood of that outcome. So the outcome might be big, but the chance for it is perceived to be small (given that they were nowhere near exit), so the expected value is not very high. Boils down to they spent their hard-earned cash buying something that might lose a lot of value, is unlikely to be a big win, and that they, once they buy it, are basically stuck with it. No wonder he disses the advisors (note all of this is just explanation of what is said, without judging if his premises are correct).
- jondubois 10y agoFinance is evil. Day trading, investment banking, venture capital; they don't produce anything for society, they just sit at the intersection of various people, companies and industries and they capture big chunks of the money that flows between them - They rely on information asymmetry and market manipulation to do so; but 'information asymmetry' is just a euphemism for 'deception'. Even startups which are doing well and generate profit tend to go on to raise money from VCs - This sounds ridiculous; they don't need the VC money but they raise money from the VC anyway because: 1. They need the connections and 2. They need the tech 'media' to promote them with a headline like "W raises $X millions from Y to disrupt/democratize Z!". This highlights the fact that VCs have an oligolopy when it comes to economic connections and the media and they leverage it for their own needs. Also the fact that crowdfunding was essentially illegal for so long is also scandalous - Not only do they hoard all important social connections and the media but they also have a stranglehold on politics.
- grinnbearit 10y agoFinance isn't evil; day trading, investment banking, venture capital are all sharing information with the world and trying to move money to places where its more valuable. There is a case to be made about "negative externalities"[1] but talking about the whole of finance as unnecessary is throwing out the baby with the bath water. [1] costs that aren't borne by the producer
- wott 10y agoValuable for what?
- grinnbearit 10y agoValuable for satisfying human desires The theory is that people spend money on what they desire, and so companies that generate more money satisfy more human values. You will always find outliers and exceptions (caused by negative externalities usually), but this is true in general.
- pjc50 10y ago
- sharmi 10y agoIf anyone is interested in learning more about compensations and about salary negotiations, here are some previous discussions on Hacker News. Open Guide to Equity Compensation (github.com)[1] Salary Negotiation (kalzumeus.com)[2] Ten Rules for Negotiating a Job Offer (freecodecamp.com)[3] An interesting anecdote about negotiation [4] [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10880726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10880726 [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11830598 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11830598 [3]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12197795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12197795 [4]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11552780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11552780
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- flexie 10y agoI think it's mostly supply and demand, timing and where you live. But those are the factors we rarely talk about. Instead, people complain they are not compensated enough relative to the importance of their work, their intelligence, the hours put in, their title or the length of their education or the risk they take. If people were paid according to the importance of their jobs, I would argue that plumbers, sewage workers and farmers should be paid higher than programmers. If it were about intelligence, most physicists I know are underpaid and programmers are generally compensated fairly. If it were about hours put in, many of the people producing our clothes should be paid better than us. If it were about titles, programming should be behind almost any other engineering field. If it were about length of education, programmers would generally rank much lower than they do because so many don't have any or much formal training. If it were about risk, in just about any other profession people have taken larger risks than a programmer joining a startup. So you "risk" only making $40,000 for a couple of years? Yeah, well, that's the calculated risk your English high school teacher knowingly took on for life when she decided to take a bachelor in arts. And yes, she could have become a developer or lawyer instead. What about the risk of work injuries faced by construction workers every day. That's real risk. Our financial risks are modest worries. Programmers in 2016 are generally very well compensated for a low risk, indoor job with a very low barrier to entry.
- crasp 10y agoThere are always jobs that are worse in some way. If a plumber screws up you might get a wet floor or sewage in the street. If some banking software makes a flaw, you can't just pick up a mop and clean it up. There are always jobs that come out worse in some category compared to programming. The problem here specifically is that given you have written 50% of the software people are using and investors are making some millions out of it while you make $40K a year, because they sort of lured you into a deal that apparently is not working out too great for you because you were so focussed on getting the lines of code rolling out they sort of took advantage of the situation?
- paublyrne 10y agoInvestors may be taking advantage of your labour but this is the nature of every business. The business owners take advantage of employee labour to make a lot more money than the employees. I find the entitlement to better terms than people inother fields that frequently crops up here incredibly pretentious and self righteous.
- wccrawford 10y ago>I find this lack of diligence infuriating. These intellectuals — much smarter than me — imagine block chain technology for cryptocurrencies and how to cure diseases, but don’t put in the effort to comprehend ownership percentages or what a ratchet means in a down round. Why? Nice victim-blaming here. Why don't people spend tons of effort on a lot more things? They haven't got the time and don't want the stress. Don't blame them for being trusting, loving souls. Blame the company for screwing them over with over-complicated rewards schemes designed to screw them from the start.
- lllllll 10y agoThis.
- discordianfish 10y agoI don't get why everyone is criticizing this article. I think the main point is simply: Understand your compensation. And this is important. For instance, it makes a huge difference if you're allowed to sell your shares on the secondary market or not. That way a friend-of-a-friend made a bunch of money while other employees who joined a few month later can't and probably won't ever be able to sell those shares at a good price.
- Xyik 10y agoLet's be honest, the only reason companies aren't transparent about these things is because of investor/founder greed. Whether or not the numbers are 'fair' isn't even relevant until employees fully understand their compensation. It's basically like how landlords in SF take advantage of the housing market by unnecessarily raising rent to absurd levels just because they can - it's the same with investors. They have the money so they try and scalp those who need it under the guise of taking on risk. In reality, if an investor lost the 10M he/she invested in a company, it probably wouldn't change their life at all.
- samsamuels 10y agoFar too many people out there are looking to make a buck on someone else's hard work than their own.
- dnh44 10y agoYou can't make lots of bucks solely on the basis of your own hard work. The whole point of being an entrepreneur is to make a buck off of someone else's hard work in addition to your own.
- avindroth 10y agoI don't feel like going to Wall Street to learn about all this. I am sure there is an element of experiential component, but which books or resources can I peruse to get myself acquainted?
- j_jochem 10y agoHaving seen these types of articles crop up a number of times now, I've started wondering if the issue of preferred stock vs. regular stock vs. options is something that is specific to how stock ownership works in the US or if this also applies to other countries. In particular, I would be interested in information on stock ownership in British ltds and how things work in the EU in general. Can anybody with experience in those markets clue me in?
- westoque 10y agoNot all people are motivated my money. Some people really just don't care about their compensations. They are just motivated either by the idea, the people, the leader, the industry, etc.
- dnh44 10y agoEven if one is not motivated by money, one should at least still have the self-respect to make sure they are being fairly compensated for their time.
- k__ 10y agoThis bad and good. Bad because people who don't think about this will probably get less money than they deserve. Good because everyone can try to get as much as possible without being a 10x engineer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- koonsolo 10y ago"In business, you don't get what you deserve, you get what you negotiate" - Chester L. Karrass
- hiram112 10y agoThis is a good article, and the same thing could be said with regard to offshoring, H1Bs, etc. Very profitable companies have gotten away for years with the tired argument of not enough talent. It is easy for engineers to fall for the line, since it pushes our egos in the right way: only really talented people can do what we do. The truth is, tech companies are spoiled. They all want the top 5%, but don't want to pay the premium. And they've found that since they can't always get these 5% for cheap, they might as well get the bottom 50% for a discount via H1B indentured servants. I like software engineering a lot. But the older I get, the more I know that it is a dead end, and I'm preparing my pivot. Not because there isn't a demand for software, but simply because the tech field is full of naive and professionally weak workers that allow the whole industry to be exploited far more than other professions. Globalization, offshoring, etc. is not something that can be easily countered. Even lawyers, journalists, and nurses - typically very politically savvy professionals - have not been able to counter it 100%. But tech workers are really at the bottom of the barrel as we not only lose to offshoring, but also allow ourselves to be arbitraged and later replaced by foreign workers in our own countries (from what I've seen, Western Europe is catching up with the US with its 'blau karte' and other schemes).
- GFischer 10y agoI take offense with " the bottom 50% for a discount via H1B indentured servants." There's probably a mix of talent in H1B visa workers, but I know several and they're among the top talent in the U.S. Some H1B visa holders have gone on to found multibillion-dollar companies. I don't live in the U.S. and don't face H1B visa competition (we do have Venezuelan and Cuban and Spanish engineers coming here to Uruguay so something similar), but it shouldn't be seen as so black-and-white. They can help grow the pie, they're not out to take a slice of the pie from native-born engineers. Maybe you should help them negotiate better rates, or a better visa that allows them to do so.
- sisk 10y agoI've seen bite-sized blog posts and conference talks on the subject, yet I've never found a truly thorough resource. Can anyone recommend a book or two?
- ihsw 10y agoHonestly what's wrong with just paying people a lot of cash? Why the swindling with securities? Because that's all it is -- look at a 10 year timespan between two developers, one making cash and one making cash+options, and you will see a difference in how much they take home. Stock options are all smoke and mirrors, nine times out of ten. I'm all for giving people more financial opportunities that integrate with their lifestyle and risk tolerance but come on, people are being ripped off on the promise of "options" and gauging how much "faith" someone has in a company. Screw faith, just give me cold hard cash!
- jasode 10y ago>Honestly what's wrong with just paying people a lot of cash? The context of the blog post is "startups". Startups without significant revenue don't have a lot of cash to pay high salaries. Another reason for stock compensation is to tap into the power of incentives. Hopefully, the potential equity upside attracts employees who think their work contributions can boost the value of the company (and hence their stock options) rather than mercenaries who just want a paycheck. Paying with 100% cash doesn't easily differentiate those 2 groups.
- ihsw 10y agoSo what if there is a lack of cash? Keep demanding more. If and when the cash comes, will your real salary increase? No! Of course not! You will be the last to know and this information asymmetry is the reason the rules are stacked against you, which is why you should never stop asking for more money. If the company tanks then so what? Not your problem, you're a developer. The premise of my argument is that the separation between the two groups you mentioned is so temporary that it doesn't even matter -- and not only that but whether you're a mercenary is not up to you, it's up to your employer. You might as well get paid fairly to reduce your risk surface.
- jasode 10y ago>So what if there is a lack of cash? Keep demanding more. That's fine, but you're changing the subtopic of your text that I was specifically responding to. You asked, "what's wrong with paying a lot of cash?" What's wrong with it is that the fledgling startups do not have "lots of cash" to pay so playing dumb about why they aren't paying it is a non-productive conversation. Sure, as a future potential employee, demand all you want -- and renegotiate for higher salary next year -- or quit for a better job -- or start your own damn company -- or don't take the job at all. All that empowerment cheerleading is fine but it's from the perspective of the "employEE" so it's changing the subject. My answer was specifically explaining the perspective of the "startup employER" -- and that's who you had asked about. >The premise of my argument is that the separation between the two groups you mentioned is so temporary that it doesn't even matter It can take several years for startups to receive revenue and profitability and therefore, the recruiting mindset will favor one group vs the other over a long ramp up period. This hiring strategy is unavoidable when the startup does not have a lot of cash. >whether you're a mercenary is not up to you, it's up to your employer. Btw, I wasn't using "mercenary" in a derogatory manner. It's a label I often proudly wear and being fabulously compensated with cash never flipped a switch in my head from mercenary to loyal employee. I was mercenary to the bone. Anyway, I make the distinction about mercenaries to highlight that some employees' incentives may not be aligned optimally for a cash-strapped startup. Therefore, perhaps the mercenary should restrict his criteria for employers to be the more mature companies who pay high market-rate salaries and very little in stock. That strategy seems more productive than wondering why Microsoft pays "lots of cash" but startup XYZ does not. The blog was about startups and not companies like Microsoft/IBM.
- Artlav 10y agoIn simple words, you should work for money/salary, not for promises/equity. This way you'll always get a fair compensation, regardless of what happens to the company.
- qudat 10y agoLow risk, low reward. If everyone thought this way then entrepreneurs wouldn't exist
- merandacurtis 10y agohttps://www.glu7.com/blog/5-outrageously-commanding-facebook-advertising-strategies/ https://www.glu7.com/blog/5-outrageously-commanding-facebook...
- riskneural 10y agoAdam Smith's five reasons to get paid more: 1. Skill. Over the long run, jobs that require higher skill will attract higher wages, or else people won't bother to spend the costs acquire the skills for the job. 2. Accountability. All equal, you'll take the job without personal consequences when things go bad. 3. Wholesomeness. Undertakers get paid more. Butchers get paid more than bakers. If it sounds cool at a party, expect to get paid less. Supply and demand. 4. Job security. Essentially, you need a higher wage for an unstable job than a stable job. Risk premium. 5. Physical danger. Yes, a lumberjack will get more danger money than a programmer. However, you'll demand a higher wage for a programming job with crazy hours and the only food in the building is a snack machine with cinnamon buns which have no expiry dates.
- ausjke 10y ago"Please talk to a financially savvy individual to avoid missteps that could impact your long-term wealth." -- this strikes me, everything said makes common sense, and most engineers will agree, but the difficult lies in this sentence, how/where to find this resource _easily_ while working 7*24 on startups? It is extremely difficult to find a real person, or a nice website, to make the ownership/stock-options/shares/etc straightforward and easy to follow, those jargon/terms are made to confuse any ordinary typical person. I wish there is a website providing such service, say, charge $100 a hour to analyze my financial situation thoroughly or something like that. And no, I'm not saying a financial professional from Fidelity that is trying to sell me some funds.
- scandox 10y agoPeople who care about money will always have trouble understanding people that don't care about money - and vice-versa. (Obviously, the context here is a milieu in which everybody has enough for basic needs.) It's all about head space. Caring about money is quite a binary thing: once you engage with it, it's a huge commitment - intellectually and emotionally. People who don't care about money understand that they're only inches away from caring - and that the moment they cross that line their whole attitude is going to have to change. That's why they're wilfully disengaged from these issues. They don't want to set that process in motion. Money has a gravity all its own - it sucks you in. People who do care about money don't have a problem. Money proves its own importance in a very material way. So the commitment always seems justified.
- jfdk 10y agoI think this largely depends on how much money you are chasing and your aspirations. I care about money not because I want to have lots of things but because I want the freedom to work on my own ideas (without selling my soul to a VC). A certain amount of money early in life can greatly change your trajectory, for better or for worse. It just takes discipline.
- codingdave 10y agoThat still needs to be balanced, though. As you get older, you'll lose time to other things. You may get sick, injured, or die. There is no guarantee that you will have a "later". So find the balance - live enough to be happy with today, but work enough to be prepared for tomorrow.
- shimon 10y agoI don't see why it should be so polarized. You can care enough about money to understand the components of your compensation. You can also care about quality of life enough to make decisions that trade money earned for other goals. There's an attitude of "money is unpure" that is destructive. Even if you are not motivated mainly by money, you will need to understand it so that you aren't taken advantage of by people who are motivated and fluent. Thinking you are above this is just an excuse for laziness - it's about as realistic as saying you're above eating healthy and exercising.
- codingdave 10y agoThere is a bigger picture than money. I know I could have more wealth. But I'm pretty happy with my life, despite not having maximized my income and investments. I have enough money to pay my bills, enjoy my life, and still have enough extra to have the first-world problem of where to invest it. Would having focused my energies on making even more make me a happier person? Or a better father to my kids? Doubtful.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- totally 10y agoI understand that a thing is worth what someone will pay for it, but to balance that out a bit, no conversation about compensation is complete without consideration of actual needs. When colleagues, whose compensation is as wildly out of proportion to their needs as mine is, complain that they're entitled to more, it's at best a negotiating stance and at worst a black hole of insatiable greed. Obviously this is some game theory mojo, and we'll never get everyone on board with it, but imagine for a second a world where everyone isn't vying for "more", but for "enough". In the zero sum game we have here, compensation becomes a moral issue.
- arca_vorago 10y agoI think the main thing that most IT workers fail to understand is employment contracts or agreements. Far too often a person needs a job, so too quickly agrees to terms that end up biting them later or causing resentment. I'm reminded of the guy who outsourced his job to china and just surfed reddit all day. The problem is indicated of a larger issue not really talked about though, and thats the destruction of the middle class and increasing income inequality. I have started heavily referencing cost of living statistics when trying to understand macroeconomics, and when, in one of the most insulated areas from the 08 crash in Texas, with some of the lowest cost of living, and 49k is the living wage, which is almost impossible to get, I see a large storm brewing over the country that hardly anyone else seems to notice. The true bottom line is that employers have far too much power, and employees need to start expanding theirs, before the neofuedal state kicks in fully and shit gets really fucked. To give a quick example of bad compensation, I used to contract for some of the best law firms in town, and I got to know the secretaries and paralegals pretty well. well, come to find out, apparently the office managers from the various firms call each other to price fix salaries and compensation for them so they dont want to leave etc. Its blatantly illegal, but what are they gonna do, sue the best lawyers in town who are "good christian men" and "paragons of the community"? So most of them just grin and bear it. Not to mention the fact that some of them bring in well over 4,5,6 times their salary in client billing themselves (eg not their attorneys) yet they still get a measly 1k christmas bonus. Econimic warfare is real, and as W Buffett said, the rich are winning.
- Androider 10y agoStartups give stock options because they feel they have to in order to attract talent. The startups can't compete with Google/Apple/Microsoft when it comes to the base salary, they simply don't have the cash or revenues to do so yet. But what if the startups offered something else that most of the big companies can't or won't? How about 100% remote work, real work life balance (less than 40h weeks), 4+ weeks of vacation out the gate, 4 day weeks during summer (like Basecamp) etc. Basically, given conflicting choices, always optimize towards what makes a great place to work. Would that attract top talent (not necessarily only the SV talent)? What if there were no stock options involved at all, would that make you less psychologically invested in the company?
- wiz21 10y agoI think it's fair for a programmer to evaluate himself (and, surevaluate himself) just like start up founders, investors, evaluate their start ups when they try to sell them... I think I'm worth millions right now. Hire me, I'm such a huge opportunity !
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- exelius 10y agoIn a capitalist system, you actually have an obligation to get as much of the pie as you can. Fuck being seen as greedy; greed is the entire basis of capitalism. This doesn't mean resorting to illegal / unethical measures; but it does mean always negotiating to get a better deal. This goes from the top of the economy all the way down to the bottom. I'll admit it can be hard when you don't have leverage; but you also have a stronger incentive to fight than some VC or PE who is really just playing for points. More companies should really encourage this with their employees and arm them with the information they need to negotiate effectively. True; compensation would probably rise, but so would job satisfaction (and its attendant effect on employee turnover -- important in knowledge work where recruiting costs run upwards of $60,000-100,000 per hire). It's probably a wash in the end dollars-wise, but it makes it a lot easier to keep high-performing teams together. If you don't want to be greedy, give all your money away to whatever charities you want after you earn it and live a modest lifestyle. But the whole system functions better when everyone has the ability -- and the expectation -- to fight for the best deal they can get.
- gtycomb 10y ago> I would argue that plumbers, sewage workers and farmers should be paid higher than programmers. Then, of course, the plumber et. al. should consider moving into programming. No one is stopping them from training themselves and learning what it takes to make the switch. The programmer getting $80,000, who developed a key technology to start a multi-million organisation, if she finds she is not compensated appropriately, should consider teaming up and starting something on her own probably.
- clifanatic 10y agoI think of stock options and the like as lottery tickets. And I never win the lottery. If I'm offered stock options, I'll gladly take them, but I want real money, too.
- anupshinde 10y agoCouple of interesting quotes that resonate with this. 1. "Company doesn't care about you (employee), and you shouldn't care about the company" For few years this resonated in my head and I disbelieved it for obvious reasons. Its just demotivating. But after more than a decade I know this is completely true. 2. "Customers don't care how good the code is" True. As far as the functionality is reliable and acceptable quality. Good code is only a value-enabler.
- warfangle 10y agoOn the other hand, how many companies stonewall potential new hires that try to perform due diligence on the options package offered?
- swiftisthebest 10y agoIs there a MOOC or other similar teaching system that I can learn this type of information? Thanks!
- kriro 10y agoTo provide a counterpoint...do I really have to care all that much. I know many people that obsess over money but quite frankly I feel like it's mostly a hygiene factor. As long as grave injustices are avoided interesting work trumps interesting compensation (imo)