6 ms·
I always wondered why these are laid out in a grid, and not hexagonally, which is optimal for circle packing. You could fit more in that way.
by LeoPanthera 10y ago
I always wondered why these are laid out in a grid, and not hexagonally, which is optimal for circle packing. You could fit more in that way.
- theophrastus 10y agome too. i finally got to ask a professor at an agricultural college that question. all i can do is give you the non-definitive answer he gave me: "there are access roads between all those circles for planting, harvest, and, maintenance. straight roads are a helluva lot easier to build. land is cheap, gravel isn't."
- mjevans 10y agoThis, and the related square (ish) grid survey pattern in the US explain the parceling. The tilling of soil ruining embedded networks explains why that isn't used (probably also pests). Circular irrigation sprayers; now those I have to wonder about versus a single over-farm arm that can run down a length. Also, if the water is valued as it should be, why aren't 'growing season' tent structures with build in irrigation used instead?
- c22 10y agoA single large arm operating the way you describe would need synchronized drive wheels on both sides, adding cost and complexity over a single-drive anchored system. You'd also need a lot more slack in the hose that feeds it.
- Sean1708 10y ago> Circular irrigation sprayers; now those I have to wonder about versus > a single over-farm arm that can run down a length. > Also, if the water is valued as it should be, why aren't 'growing season' > tent structures with build in irrigation used instead? I suspect that the answers to those are maintenence and materials respectively. If you have a circular arm you essentially just need an engine, a pivot, and a wheel at the end of the arm, whereas if you have an arm that runs linearly you need a lot more moving parts (some sort of mechanism to turn the rotational motion of the engine into a linear motion, some sort of mechanism to keep the two ends of the arm in sync, some sort of mechanism to make the arm travel in the opposite direction, etc.). All that adds up to a bigger initial cost and more maintenence. For the tent on the other hand you would really need a lot of raw materials. If we just make the tent 1 mile (which is the size of the bigger circles) in diameter and 10 feet high, then you would need over 500 acres[1] of plastic/tarp/(whatever you're gonna cover the tents in) per circle. Add on to that the metal needed for the irrigation system and building costs, and I really start to doubt whether it would be cost effective. [1]: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=pi+*+(0.5+miles)%5E2+%2B+(pi+miles+*+10+feet) http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=pi+*+(0.5+miles)%5E2+%2...
- d-sc 10y agoFrom what I've observed, each of the wheels on the center pivot has its own controller to keep the system in line. Some appear to have GPS controllers. The issued with having a large linear arm is re-connecting the water supply every time the arm moves.
- logfromblammo 10y agoIf I'm going to build a giant greenhouse in Oklahoma, it's going to need to be weather resistant. A slack covering over a grid of 10-foot-tall supports won't work. If you consider the cost of structural supports will likely dwarf the tent covering, different architectures probably make more sense. I would suggest a half-torus with major radius 0.25mi and minor radius 0.25 mi. The structural shell would be a tensegrity grid, with the covering affixed over it. That's 790 acres of covering over 502 acres of land. You're going to need a lot of steel cable, and a few truckloads of rigid 50' pipes. You will also need at least two types of pipe-to-cable junction. Sprinklers under the apex ring (0.25mi above the ground) could easily irrigate the covered area from a fixed position, without rotating, and condensers above the apex ring could recycle water out of humid exhaust air and feed it right back into the sprinklers. There would be no moving parts at all, other than in the groundwater pump and sprinkler heads. You have one ring-shaped pipe (a gutter could work, if the sprinkler heads don't require pressure to operate) to supply the sprinklers that is 1.57mi long, and one pipe from ground to apex ring 0.39mi long. But with center-pivot, you only need a well pump, 0.5mi of pipe, A-frame supports, and wheels. But then you lose water to evaporation and transpiration. So I think giant greenhouses could not appear until the aquifer dries up, and water costs skyrocket. Even then, I'm not sure it wouldn't be better to just put a bunch of mirrors and a collector tower up, and transmit the solar energy to a vertical farm that is closer to a cheaper, more reliable water source.
- oasisbob 10y agoBecause land in the US wasn't surveyed with hexagons. In the PLSS system (used in a majority of US states), land was initially surveyed using one-mile sections as the base unit. The next division is into section quarters, a half-mile on the side. The article has an image which I suspect illustrates differing ownership of the SW quarter: https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-k0CA9Q64oOI/V6iHkNVv8EI/AAAAAAAA01g/WlP7zeI7dgYK8hsZZV4V9wRJX2bLSQZtACLcB/s1600/US%2BCPI%2Bquarters.jpg https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-k0CA9Q64oOI/V6iHkNVv8EI/AAAAAAAA0... Why not in Saudi Arabia? Who knows, but they certainly show more creativity in the layout.
- jamesrom 10y agoIf that is owned by a different person, that brings an interesting opportunity cost problem. If the owner of the smaller area shared it with the owner of the bigger area. An agreement could be struck to pay for 1 quarter of the operating costs and receive one quarter of the harvest. Both parties would save on operating costs, yet receive the same harvest.
- crikli 10y agoGood question. That would be fairly (ok, wildly) impractical. Most of the roads are gravel, which means that maintenance would be a nightmare. Road graders aren't great at keeping the blade level on turns. So you'd get buildup/digout at every turn. When it rained you'd get run-off and erasion. Which makes me think of drainage, wow, with the water making 120 degree turns roughly every half mile you'd get some serious washout on those occasions when we get 2" dumped on us in what feels like 10 minutes. Zig-zagging across the country with a 24-row planter in tow would be a giant pain in the ass (you plan your route minimize the number of turns you're making). Would be a pain driving a combine fitted with a 12 row head. And at harvest the trucks taking grain to the elevator or silos would be doing the same zig-zagging. It's not like the grain that's outside the obvious circle doesn't yield. It get irrigated via runoff as well as powerful sprinkler guns at the end of the pivot arm. Credentials: grew up farming in central Nebraska, married into a 5th generation farming family. Thousands of acres, all centrally irrigated via pivot. Edit: Didn't want opening tone to sound argumentative/condescending. Edit 2: Just thought about power lines. They'd have to zig-zag too. Which means the pole on the zag would have lateral force vectors acting on it, so it would have to be reinforced/anchored. When the afore-mentioned washouts happened, down goes pole and powerline.
- jamesrom 10y agoYour points are totally valid. But you wouldn't need to make sharp 120 turns. You could just have very slight waves with a frequency of 1 mile. http://i.imgur.com/vJq0Q3i.png http://i.imgur.com/vJq0Q3i.png Of course, driving on roads like these would be annoying.
- tuna-piano 10y agoAlmost bed time, so I can't do the math right now, but based on the following papers, how much additional money could be earned if they transitioned from rectangles to hexagons? http://www.aces.edu/timelyinfo/BioSysEng/2008/October/BSEN-IRR-08-01.pdf http://www.aces.edu/timelyinfo/BioSysEng/2008/October/BSEN-I... http://www.k-state.edu/irrigate/oow/p07/OBrien.pdf http://www.k-state.edu/irrigate/oow/p07/OBrien.pdf The 2nd paper quotes a land cost of $139 / acre? / time.
- robbiep 10y agoPrime agricultural land in Australia sells for $1500-2000/acre. Pumping costs can run to a quarter million dollars a year. Actual centre pivot installation (for a square kilometre like that) is approx 500,000 as well. Source: my parents are farmers and we have centre pivots
- bluejellybean 10y agoI never understood why they haven't built them to overlap. Is it just a cost/complexity thing? Something with varying heights at the end and a little auto-shutoff to avoid the overlap is all I'm picturing.
- vacri 10y agoLand in these areas is cheap. Maintaining hex roads is more expensive than straight ones, and also makes travelling slow if the hexes are small.
- lordnacho 10y agoOr add a little one in the corners to fill out most of the star shaped remainder? Probably farm land is cheap, and it's easier to expand by adding more of the same than optimising usage. Maybe there's alternative needs on the farm that provide more benefit than cramming in as many of these things as possible. After all, it wouldn't be the most complicated thing in the world to just have a thing that isn't fixed in the middle.
- taejo 10y ago> Probably farm land is cheap In particular, arid farm land is cheap. And that's clearly what we're working with here.
- avian 10y agoWikipedia has some photos of hexagonally arranged fields, so apparently it is used in some places: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center_pivot_irrigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center_pivot_irrigation
- usrusr 10y agoAdding to the previous answers: Central pivot irrigation tends to be built in regions where agriculture is limited by water supply, not by land area. Where the farmer on humid lands ask "how do I work efficiently with my land area", his peer on arid lands asks "how do I work efficiently with my annual water volume". (Edit: and it always ends in tears when the actual question being asked is "how do I get most out of our shared water supply") Where land is the main limitation, you'd most likely not go from square circle packing to hexagonal circle packing, you would get rid of circles altogether. (Wikipedia does have pictures of hexagonally packed, so apparently there exists a level of intermediate land scarcity where the trade-offs work out in favor of hex-packed circles)