42 ms·
I am a developer, so I am all for higher developer salaries, but your posts shows a common misunderstanding about economics. The value someone creates has noth
by slg 10y ago
I am a developer, so I am all for higher developer salaries, but your posts shows a common misunderstanding about economics. The value someone creates has nothing to do with their salary. Their salary is dictated by how many people need to hire developers and how many developers exist to fill those jobs or in simple terms, supply and demand. I might create millions of dollars in value with my code, but there might be another developer that will accept $5k less that can still create millions of dollars with their code. Similarly, the job that 95% of us do really isn't that unique. Sure, each development job has its own challenges and there certainly are a handful of 10Xers out there, but the truth is that once you get to the point of "competent developer" and the meaty part of the bell curve, we are all pretty much interchangeable. It then becomes a question of who will do the same work for less.
- ISL 10y agoAgreed. In my field, physics, salaries are low precisely because supply is high. The work is hard, and demands a lot of training/skill, but there are a lot of people who will do almost anything to stay in the field. One of the things they can do is accept a lower-than-tech-market salary.
- kenjackson 10y agoYes... see game programming too.
- zenlikethat 10y agoHave you ever worked on a project where management considered developers as pretty much interchangeable and added folks to the team that did more damage than good? If so, do you want to repeat that experience?
- ktRolster 10y agoI'll say this: if you aren't writing code in a way that someone else can pick up the project when you leave, then you are being an irresponsible coder.
- doki_pen 10y agoThe problem is, that's 98% of coders that you've described.
- crdoconnor 10y agoThis only makes sense if the compensation isn't tied to your replacement value. If it's tied to replacement value... well, too bad - the company shouldn't create an incentive to ramp up technical debt.
- logfromblammo 10y agoIrresponsible coding follows naturally from irresponsible management.
- ktRolster 10y agoTake responsibility for your own code. Be a man, or be a woman. Stop blaming other people. Your life becomes better when you take control.
- logfromblammo 10y agoI take responsibility for my own code. Code that belongs to the company is ultimately the responsibility of the stockholders and their board. As an at will employee with no equity, I will give them exactly what they ask for in their code. At each job, I will go above and beyond the call of duty once, to gauge the reaction. At some jobs, I get a cash bonus. At others, I just get a pat on the back. The last two jobs in a row, I was told to not do that again. So I didn't. Don't be an apologist for bad management. I'm not going to do the right thing if I could get fired for it.
- zenlikethat 10y agoThat's exactly the point. Developers aren't "mostly interchangeable". Some are much better bets than others.
- slg 10y agoMy post had the condition of "competent developer". There are certainly some developers that aren't competent. In my experience those developers get weeded out of the industry relatively quickly. This cuts off the bottom of the bell curve leaving most most developers with something close to an average skill set or above. I also won't discount the frictional costs of changing teams. If you take two identical developers and switch their jobs, each of their teams would see a temporary hit in performance as each one gets acclimated. But they will eventually get to the point were their team is exactly as efficient as it was with the other employee.
- crdoconnor 10y ago"There are certainly some developers that aren't competent. In my experience those developers get weeded out of the industry relatively quickly." That gave me a chuckle.
- eru 10y agoIf you define competence as being able to hold down a job.. (Though, of course, some social intelligence goes a long way. No need to actually know how to code.)
- sheepmullet 10y agoIn my experience even something as simple as effort varies greatly between two equally skilled developers and results in very different outcomes.
- zenlikethat 10y agoThey don't get weeded out. They might even sit in one place for years at a time before management catches on and does something, if they even catch on at all. Or, they will bounce from job to job infecting various roles with their poor work until the immune system of each company slowly wakes up and does something about them. Sadly, this gives them more "experience" and industry credibility, making it even easier to trick future victims.
- cheald 10y agoNail on the head right here. The price of an employee isn't their MPL, it's no greater than their MPL and is set by how little the next guy is willing to take to do the job. Competitive pressures work to drive down labor prices, too! Nobody is stopping engineers from saying "I'm going to contribute $1.5m to your bottom line this next year, I want you to pay me $1.4m", but they'll be shown the door because there's a guy that's willing to contribute the same $1.5m in exchange for $100k in compensation.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> Nobody is stopping engineers from saying "I'm going to contribute $1.5m to your bottom line this next year, I want you to pay me $1.4m", but they'll be shown the door because there's a guy that's willing to contribute the same $1.5m in exchange for $100k in compensation. Which is why you should be an owner/competitor versus an employee if you know the business well enough.
- cheald 10y agoAssuming that you can tolerate the commensurate risk, absolutely. Many people forget that the rank-and-file employee isn't exposed to the financial and legal risk that their employers were/are.
- jazzyk 10y agoBut they are exposed! In case of financial trouble (very common at startups), who gets to be laid off first, the CEO or the developer? Also, rank-and-file employees are typically scape-goated in legal proceedings, example: finance people going to jail for rogue/insider trading, even though upper management at least encouraged such behavior.
- cheald 10y agoEvery employment position comes with some degree of risk exposure. But, the risk of "I might lose my job" is quite a lot less scary than "I might lose all my invested capital and/or be stuck with crippling debts after the company crumbles". Early-stage startup employees are given greater compensation packages than later-stage employees specifically because of the greater risk of going to work for an early-stage startup. This isn't a very difficult thought exercise - if you believe the risk profile is greater for employees than CEOs, then why not quit your job and become a CEO of your own company?
- hiou 10y agoThey have you trained well.
- revelation 10y agoAssuming perfect information, yes, "supply and demand". Since you are so eager to offhand dismiss people, you can now research that one condition you conveniently left out.
- marcoperaza 10y ago>Assuming perfect information, yes, "supply and demand". Since you are so eager to offhand dismiss people, you can now research that one condition you conveniently left out. There's plenty of information about salaries at software companies floating around. Everyone knows (or could know with a quick search) what the salary for each level at the big tech firms are, as well as what the typical pay at startups is.
- eru 10y agoIt's a bit harder to do for a fresh grad in the middle of nowhere that's not already in Silicon Valley or even the same continent. However the information problem for employees isn't actually all that bad, as you say. The problem for employers trying to figure out whether people can actually perform is much, much harder. (But luckily they can usually diversify their bets amongst more than one employee.)
- markonthewall 10y agoI tend to ignore any comment that starts with "you misunderstand basic economics". That's not so much the arrogant tone but rather the crass dogmatism that pervade those comments. Change the set of axioms and the initial parameters and you end-up with invalid definition and properties of market dynamics. I guess OP probably believes that markets reach equilibrium by themselves.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- samsonradu 10y agoBut is it ok for competition to kill the value of developers work (in the benefit of managers/founders and whomever else)? The actual point I think is to get developers to understand they need to lift the bar higher because it's now set too far from the value they actually create.
- hnal943 10y agoCompetition drives down prices. Everyone likes that fact except for when it is applied to their own price.
- samsonradu 10y agoCompetition means no profits for anybody, no meaningful differentiation, and a struggle for survival. So why do people believe that competition is healthy? The answer is that competition is not just an economic concept or a simple inconvenience that individuals and companies must deal with in the marketplace. More than anything else, competition is an ideology—the ideology—that pervades our society and distorts our thinking. We preach competition, internalize its necessity, and enact its commandments; and as a result, we trap ourselves within it—even though the more we compete, the less we gain. - Zero To One, The ideology of competition
- athenot 10y agoAn illustation of that is found in high-end hotels. Beyond the building, it's the value that the cleaning and groundskeeping staff provide which makes the stay great. And yet their pay is not that much higher than their counterparts working for a budget hotel. (As a side-note, that's why I always smile and engage with the staff whenever I can: it's a thankless job, despite being one of the most important.)
- Frondo 10y agoThat's great! I dig how you treat them with respect and human dignity, that they're not beneath you but working hard, too. I hope you also support their right to unionize wherever that is possible.
- eru 10y agoHow does one follow from the other? I appreciate that grocers are selling me cheap goods, and that it took hard work to create and supply them. Yet, I don't want them to form a cartel.
- infinotize 10y ago"Whoa, whoa, whoa. I like to be nice enough to the Help so that I can pat myself on the back. But let's not get ahead of ourselves and let these people fight for higher wages, which might impact my costs!"
- eru 10y agoThey can raise their asking price, or exit that particular labour market. I did something similar, and became an economic migrant. Cartelization is not good for the economy, no matter who tries to pull it off.
- cloudjacker 10y agoI disagree, there was a time when the finance community similarly valued themselves with the broader market until some people realized the numeric dollar value they could create. And the rest is history. Its time for software engineers to collectively realize their expanding relevance to value creation in actual numeric value.
- eru 10y agoWhy collectively? Did the finance people need anything collective?
- cloudjacker 10y agoNot sure how to answer that It's routine to get bonuses larger than your annual salary in finance, specially in investment banking roles, this is not routine in software engineering
- cloudjacker 10y agobut many forms of greater liquidity could be possible for potential value producing software engineering roles
- eru 10y agoOnly the total compensation is important for me. If anything, I'd rather get a stable one than a variable one. (Variable is only better, if the expected value is higher.) In any case, in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12212180 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12212180 you said something like - finance people used to get normal amounts of money, now they get more - hence, software people need to do something as a collective. I don't see how the first implies the second. Especially since the finance people didn't do anything as a collective, did they?
- ghurlman 10y agoOnce I stop reading article after article here and elsewhere about how there just aren't enough developers in the world to fill all the jobs he have now and coming, then I'll buy that we're on a pure supply & demand curve.
- cheald 10y ago"There aren't enough developers" is explicitly why devs can make six figures rather than $10/hour.
- dbingham 10y agoThis reality provides one of the best arguments for a switch from a capitalist economy, in which it is shareholders who have little to do with the creation of value in the economy who ultimately benefit the most from it, to a free market socialist economy (one based on democratically owned worker cooperatives). In an economy based on worker cooperatives, the distinction between "employee" and "owner" is eliminated. Instead of there being competition in the labor market which drives salaries well below the value created by individual laborers, labor simply receives the value it creates.
- cheald 10y agoConsider that practically every company begins as a democratic worker-owned cooperative, and those worker-owners generally can't wait to diversify themselves out of that position. Risk exposure is a lot higher when you're a worker-owner, and most people are horribly risk-adverse. Ignoring the risk factor in the equation leads to some rather wrong conclusions.
- vasilipupkin 10y agoexactly. The point of shareholders is so that you can spread risk and reward. Instead of contributing all the capital yourself, you sell shares in your business to others, giving up some reward, but also a lot of the risk. Without this, the economy would collapse
- hx87 10y ago> most people are horribly risk-adverse Free market socialism (i.e. a large UBI + single payer healthcare + low regulation) would largely mitigate that risk aversion, especially when combined with low levels of personal debt, since if you fail you can always count on decent healthcare and the UBI check.
- walshemj 10y agoOne advantage of the NHS serious medical conditions wont bankrupt you.
- 10y ago
- johnward 10y agoIt should be noted that several tech employers were found to be illegally colluding to artificially lower wages.
- mancerayder 10y agoThis, slightly adjusted, would make a killer Onion headline.
- jonknee 10y agoIn Silicon Valley it seems popular to just start your own company and capture the value that way, but other fields have solved this issue by unionizing.
- hnal943 10y agoUnions do not have a good history of preserving value, at least not in the USA.
- hiou 10y agoThen why are developers outside of the higher pay tiers paid about the same as a unionized UPS driver?
- jonknee 10y agoThere are certainly problems with unions, but they have definitely succeeded in raising pay for their members.
- hnal943 10y agoThose that still have jobs. Employers commonly reduce the number of jobs available when those jobs become more expensive.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hx87 10y agoHigh level executives at large corporations are a small enough group with enough common interests that they might as well constitute a union, and they have an exemplary record of preserving value for themselves.
- jonknee 10y agoSame for athletes, the MLB Players Union has been extraordinary in preserving value for its members (guaranteed contracts!).
- tacostakohashi 10y agoAll of these things are true. However, there is another input into supply side, and that's alternatives to employment like starting a company. Any employees that really create much more value than their salary can and will just leave and start their own company, where they get to set their own salary. By doing so, they'll also be leaving the pool of employees, and potentially hiring others too (reducing supply, increasing supply, driving salaries up). Of course, every employee creates more value than their salary, to cover overheads, some profit for shareholders, etc. Employees that claim to be creating far more value than their salary, but not leaving to start a company, are probably deluding themselves, and vastly underestimating the value of the capital employed in their company, goodwill with customers, the sales and management functions, etc.
- Kliment 10y agoThe latter is not necessarily true - you might be creating tremendous value, but have barriers to market entry that are enormous such that you can only really create that value from within one of the existing players on the market. See aerospace, telecommunications, medicine, government contracting for examples of such industries. If I'm making a huge amount of added value for a large telecom, it's unlikely I can start a startup to compete with it, and given the state of the market I'm unlikely to make much more at their direct competitors. Thus, as long as my value is industry-specific, and the industries have large barriers to entry, I might be creating much more value than my salary but unable to leave and compete against my employer.
- hnal943 10y agoYou're a component in a value creating engine which includes the ability to hurdle those barriers to entry, which means you don't get credit (on your own) for the total value that you are able to produce within that system.
- Kliment 10y agoMore likely, you're a resource being extracted by a monopolist that set up those barriers to entry.
- eldavido 10y agoI agree with your explanation but I'd suggest a slightly different way of explaining it. Labor's price is set in a competitive factor market, just like land or capital. It gets bid up and down by supply and demand. Let's call this "the labor market force". How much value a person can provide in a given setting depends on a whole range of things including what the employer does (scaled product company vs. body shop), overall management effectiveness, how motivated they are (both themselves and by their employer), their skill level, etc. Let's call this "the company force" The reason people aren't paid as much as California devs elsewhere has a lot more to do with the "company force" than the "market force". The fact is, most companies who employ developer just don't need great devs. They need people who can develop websites of moderate complexity, keep things going, write line-of-business software, etc., not people who can do original, innovate algorithmic work. Related, there is no "Developer shortage". There is only a technical talent shortage insofar as dev salaries are getting bid up and the buyers who are getting outbid (mostly smaller startups) are complaining. The good companies are getting exactly who they want.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>The fact is, most companies who employ developer just don't need great devs. They need people who can develop websites of moderate complexity They actually do they're just unable to recognize great devs, unable to recognize that they don't recognize them and refuse to pay for them. But they certainly need them. >Related, there is no "Developer shortage". There's always a shortage of labor in every industry. That's one of the iron rules of business lobbying - if you whinge about it enough the government will go and do something (training, bring in immigrants, teach code in school) that will let you pay employees less. => higher profit.
- BurningFrog 10y ago> the truth is that once you get to the point of "competent developer" and the meaty part of the bell curve, we are all pretty much interchangeable That is not my experience at all. I see big skill differences in my coworkers. But as an employer, it's real hard to know which candidate is 200% of the average and who is 50% (or -10%), so you end up having to offer everyone an average salary with small variations.
- devishard 10y agoI don't think the poster of your parent comment would disagree with your explanation of the how things are; they're only saying that's not how it should be. If we lived in a just meritocracy, people who created millions of dollars in value with their code would be compensated with millions of dollars, but this is rarely, if ever, the case.
- GFischer 10y agoAs a counterpoint: people don't create millions of dollars in value in a vacuum. Somebody (usually several somebodies) took the chance to create a support structure to enable said person to create the millions of dollars in value. How much of the value should go to the value creator and how much to the enabler with the capital (and the vision to use it in that way instead of spending it on something else) is a very interesting question that has been tackled for a long time, particularly from Marx onwards. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_theory_of_value https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_theory_of_value
- devishard 10y ago> Somebody (usually several somebodies) took the chance to create a support structure to enable said person to create the millions of dollars in value. A tech company contains a lot of structure, and very little of that is actually geared toward enabling anyone to create millions of dollars of value. A large portion of that structure exists to enable the management of a company to justify taking in large profits. It's should surprise no one that those creating the structure would create it in a way that benefits them. I know a few people who work at a tech cooperative, which has mostly developers with 1 secretary who manages benefits/taxes/etc. and 1 "business liaison" who manages customer communication. They've created millions of dollars of value without most of the structure, and it's no coincidence that they're all set to retire in their late 30s.
- GFischer 10y agoA tech cooperative is a kind of structure that should be more popular, I agree.
- devishard 10y agoI don't think the poster of your parent comment would disagree with your explanation of the how things are; they're only saying that's not how it should be. If we lived in a just meritocracy, people who created millions of dollars in value with their code would be compensated with millions of dollars, but this is rarely, if ever, the case. It's this fact which makes libertarian arguments about the unfairness of tax and social welfare programs offensive.
- GlennCSmith 10y agoThe are great advantages to individuals and society to paying less than the value of goods and services. If my daughter is ill, and a simple shot of antibiotics will cure her, should I pay $20 for that, or should I pay what saving her life is actually worth to me? I've enjoyed ever faster internet connection speed at my home (coming in two weeks -- gigabit!) I assure you I'm not paying the full value of what that speed is worth to me. The same for food, clothes, transportation, everything. If I really did have to pay the full value to me for each of those I would, by definition, be indifferent to buying any of them. Market economics has some serious downsides, but it has vastly increased the welfare of humanity. More people have been coming out of poverty in China in the past few decades that ever before in human history. If you feel it is unfair that as a developer you can create millions of dollars in value that you aren't being compensated for, then I recommend you consider ways that you could be compensated for this value. Perhaps instead of being an employee, maybe get involved in a start-up with equity (or found a company.) Having done so, I can assure you it's more nerve wracking than ever I would have expected, and harder to unleash the millions in value than one might expect, but it's still fun, challenging, rewarding, and worth giving a go! :-)
- devishard 10y ago> The are great advantages to individuals and society to paying less than the value of goods and services. If my daughter is ill, and a simple shot of antibiotics will cure her, should I pay $20 for that, or should I pay what saving her life is actually worth to me? I've enjoyed ever faster internet connection speed at my home (coming in two weeks -- gigabit!) I assure you I'm not paying the full value of what that speed is worth to me. The same for food, clothes, transportation, everything. If I really did have to pay the full value to me for each of those I would, by definition, be indifferent to buying any of them. Okay, so what's the society of my boss getting paid twice as much as me while actively impeding my ability to create value? Also, antibiotics and internet are poor examples of market economics; both are heavily subsidized and regulated. So it's disingenuous to hold these up and then in your following paragraph claim that market economics is helping humanity. > Market economics has some serious downsides, but it has vastly increased the welfare of humanity. More people have been coming out of poverty in China in the past few decades that ever before in human history. How do you justify attributing this to free market economics? > If you feel it is unfair that as a developer you can create millions of dollars in value that you aren't being compensated for, then I recommend you consider ways that you could be compensated for this value. Perhaps instead of being an employee, maybe get involved in a start-up with equity (or found a company.) Having done so, I can assure you it's more nerve wracking than ever I would have expected, and harder to unleash the millions in value than one might expect, but it's still fun, challenging, rewarding, and worth giving a go! :-) I do think it's unfair, but I actually don't care, because I'm self-aware enough to realize that the way in which our economy hurts me is nothing compared to how it hurts most people. I'm incredibly lucky to have landed in a career where things are only as unfair as they are, and I'd much rather work toward helping people in worse situations than me than in fixing the minor injustice of getting paid less than management.
- ubernostrum 10y agoSo, this supply and demand thing. We keep hearing from large tech companies that there's a crisis -- a massive shortage of qualified software engineers, to such a degree that they won't be able to operate at all if they can't raise the H1-B quotas and import more people to fill all the jobs currently going unfilled. If that truly is the case, then supply and demand would tell us that currently engineers are underpaid; if there are companies so desperate to hire engineers that they're turning to immigration law to try to increase the supply, why aren't they simply offering large enough compensation packages to attract the existing pool? Pondering the answer to that may enlighten you.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoExactly. If a company were to announce they were going to bump dev salaries up by 75K/year, they'd be flooded with people wanting to interview.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hx87 10y agoA similar issue exists with respect to illegal immigration and low-pay, low-status jobs such as crop picking, meat-packing, and janitorial services: if there aren't enough Americans willing to do the job at prevailing wages, then aren't prevailing wages too low? Sure, my tomatoes would cost more and cleaning services might be 200% more expensive, but that's just the cost of doing business.
- ubernostrum 10y agoOr for another "white-collar" example: the alleged "pilot shortage" in the US. There's no shortage of trained, qualified pilots; there is a shortage of trained, qualified pilots willing to accept the wages and working conditions that are typical when starting out with a US-based airline. That one ends up draining in the opposite direction: instead of working for airlines in the US, those pilots go overseas where the offered pay and working conditions are better, and end up flying for Asian or Middle Eastern airlines.
- sbov 10y agoThis isn't exactly correct either. It's a combination of barriers to entry (e.g. startup costs) and how much value the developer can make vs what they're paid. If a developer makes $100k/year and can create $1 million in value, then certainly I can poach them by offering them $200k/year and still make a profit on top of that. In many fields what prevents this is startup capital. It's expensive to get a supply chain for physical goods up and running. But if you have the business acumen and connections there is not nearly as much of a barrier to entry in the software world.
- riboflava 10y agoYou don't even need much startup capital if you're starting up not in an expensive location like SV. The reason so many of us 100kers don't up and leave when we realize we're generating millions in value is because we're only generating that value as part of a larger organism telling us what to focus on. Given individual autonomy most of us couldn't produce the same value, maybe not even our salary value. Ability to autonomously produce value seems independent from coding ability, business acumen, and connections and I would argue is far more important in building a lasting business.
- Natsu 10y ago> the truth is that once you get to the point of "competent developer" and the meaty part of the bell curve, we are all pretty much interchangeable. It then becomes a question of who will do the same work for less. This under-values domain knowledge and especially company-specific knowledge. Yes, someone can ramp up on a code base over time, but I don't know if you've seen how ugly the limiting case is where they utterly replace all the devs with a new set who know nothing about the codebase and drop all the organizational knowledge. The rate at which things get done suddenly becomes a fraction of what it was before and the defects multiply quickly.
- stale2002 10y agoSupply and demand absolutely determine programmer salaries. And what you neglected to mention is that there is currently a massive developer shortage of supply, and lots of developers are being suckered into low salaries when they could be making much more somewhere else.
- matthewowen 10y agoYour answer also shows a common misunderstanding about economics, because it takes too narrow a focus. If there exist jobs that produce $1MM in value but that have a going rate of 200k, then there should be more of those jobs: either the company doing the work should expand, or it should have competitors. This will lead to increased competition to hire, which means higher wages. The increased number of jobs might generate downward pressure on the value produced by those jobs (since the output is now less scarce), and the increase in salary should increase the number of people who want to work in the field (which would dampen the salary increase), but we should ultimately reach some sort of equilibrium. The fact that tech companies bemoan how hard it is to find employees suggests that we aren't at this equilibrium. To give an analogy, your explanation is akin to when people observe that the price of a good is based on the competitive market, and that the cost to produce merely provides (in most cases) a floor to that price. However, that's only part of the story: in a well functioning market large spreads between cost to produce and price encourages competitors to enter the space, which leads to lower prices. There may be delays, and there may be exceptions, but generally the function of competition is to reduce these spreads. Likewise, we should expect competition to reduce the spreads between job value and job salary, generally by increasing salaries and lowering values.
- arvinds 10y agoUnfortunately we have network effect monopolists who can get away with huge margins. See Google, Facebook
- jack9 10y ago> either the company doing the work should expand, or it should have competitors. That's not how technology works. The most evident example is where data feeds data, creating a market without compare. You can't compete with google for map data or AWS for hosting. > we should ultimately reach some sort of equilibrium The equilibrium is not based on the metrics you have proposed except in the slightest degree.
- matthewowen 10y agoDoesn't the fact that people are trying to compete with those services suggest that you can? Bing maps, Apple maps, Azure, Google Cloud Platform, Digital Ocean, Joyent. I don't think technology is that different. Incumbents have always had advantages. That doesn't totally preclude the possibility of competition. It might be that they compete by providing less value for less cost (eg the maps might not be as good, but they might be good enough for some users), or by servicing users that the incumbent doesn't care about (side note: isn't this what The Innovator's Dilemma is about?). But it's rare that a competitor is so dominant as to totally preclude any possibility of competition. You certainly haven't provided an example of one yet.
- jondubois 10y agoCEOs and top executives are highly replaceable too (they sure change companies a lot), and yet they command massive salaries. What happened to the laws of supply and demand there? Why do CEOs have to die or retire before the board decides to replace them with someone more competent? How was Steve Ballmer able to stay in charge at Microsoft for so long?? I remember the day Ballmer announced his resignation, MSFT stock went up by like 10%! So the market definitely wanted him out! The main difference is that executives have leverage (and they have friends in high places) while average employees have almost no leverage. It's the government's job to make sure that employees have some sort of leverage over their employers.
- eru 10y agoThere's supply and demand, and then there's also principal agent problems. In practice, shareholder capitalism is a lie: companies are run for the benefits of upper management. (You see some more examples of stories like the Ballmer resignation, when you look at the "Effects of untimely CEO death", eg http://www.cnbc.com/2016/04/28/the-effects-of-a-ceos-death-on-stock-performance.html http://www.cnbc.com/2016/04/28/the-effects-of-a-ceos-death-o...) It's not only rank-and-file employees that have little leverage, average shareholders aren't much better off. The government can try and make sure to keep barriers to entry low for competitors, and barriers to switching to competitors for employees. Competition keeps companies in line, even when it's executives running the show.
- st3v3r 10y agoI can't agree with that. For most people, the salary is dictated by how good they are at negotiating, and how strong their ability is to walk away. Two things that are completely unrelated to their ability to do the job, and as such, should have nothing to do with the employment process.
- eru 10y agoThose factors are hugely important. But you'd be hard pressed to get more out of a company than you provide in value to them, even with the best negotiation. (Unless you are going to work for fools..)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- patrickthebold 10y agoI think his point may be: Don't be that guy who accepts $5k less.