15 ms·
The 19th Century plug that's still being used
- chiph 10y ago> it received complaints that the headphone jack was sunk into the casing. I had forgotten that. I paid $12.99 for an adapter that shouldn't have been necessary. I expect with modern times, the Lightning-to-3.5mm adapter will be twice the price, and just as unnecessary.
- raverbashing 10y ago"Thinner phone" is a stupid requirement. A thinner phone will be mechanically weaker. Yes, Apple retired Floppy disks and DVD readers, because those were replaced by something better. This is not the case here. A Bluetooth headphone will give you an inferior experience. A lightning converter will give you a worse experience because I can bet it doesn't stay plugged as firmly as a headphone in a high vibration situation (e.g. people exercising) and you can't have the charger plugged while you listen to music Just as a reminder it was the EU who ended the BS of every company having a stupid proprietary charger.
- brianwawok 10y ago> Just as a reminder it was the EU who ended the BS of every company having a stupid proprietary charger. Did they? How did Apple get away with it?
- entee 10y agoThey ship the phones with a small adapter that goes from micro USB to lightning. You're allowed a proprietary port into the phone as long as you provide the adapter for free.
- crishoj 10y agoThey do? Not in Denmark.
- ricksplat 10y agoI've never seen this ... I thought it was just the case that they paid whatever fine it was ...
- brianwawok 10y agoNice. http://www.apple.com/shop/product/MD820AM/A/lightning-to-micro-usb-adapter http://www.apple.com/shop/product/MD820AM/A/lightning-to-mic... $20 to buy in the US. Sure it cost $.10 to make.
- stouset 10y agoExcept for the fact that people have torn down their electronics accessories and found them to be significantly higher quality than the crappy ones you can buy for $5. http://www.righto.com/2014/05/a-look-inside-ipad-chargers-pricey.html http://www.righto.com/2014/05/a-look-inside-ipad-chargers-pr... Better components, better design, better safety, and better assembly. Plus then you have to package and ship the things. People complain about Apple selling $20 accessories, then turn around and complain about working conditions in Apple's suppliers like Foxconn (despite Apple doing far better on that front than their competitors).
- Sanddancer 10y agoThat link's about power supplies, where there actually is a significant difference in component quality. A lightning to microusb adapter doesn't involve voltage shifting or anything else that's super problematic. About all the lightning connector does is introduce lock-in.
- tombrossman 10y agoThe EU did, here's some background[0]. As for Apple, they didn't 'get away' with anything as far as I can tell. While iPhones are very popular, they make up well under 20% of the global smartphone market. It's a bit early to say standard headphone jacks are obsolete, but the notion sure does generate clicks and catchy headlines. [0]http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-24726077 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-24726077
- rayiner 10y agoI just got a pair of Bose noise-canceling bluetooth headphones. They work great. I'm looking forward to doing away with the headphone jack.
- raverbashing 10y agoGood. However: - You have to recharge it - If you forget them at home you can't get a replacement for cheap - Setting up bluetooth is an extra hassle as opposed to just plugging the thing
- rogerbinns 10y ago- Bluetooth audio codecs do lossy real-time re-encoding of the audio, affecting the quality
- nalllar 10y agoand usually introducing quite a bit of latency
- thaumasiotes 10y agoAssuming you want to listen to music, latency really doesn't matter much.
- dredmorbius 10y agoI mean, nobody would ever want to use a phone to talk to someone, amirite?
- thaumasiotes 10y agoI certainly wouldn't.
- Jaruzel 10y agoAs this is Apple we're talking about - most iPhone users stick with those nasty in-ear buds that come with the phone - it's not like they are going to notice the lossy codec comparatively over the rubbish quality of those buds (or the equally rubbish m4a low bit-rate that iTunes dumps onto the phone). I'll just bet they'll start evangelising about how 'improved' the sound is now that it's no longer over a legacy/obsolete jack. ;)
- entee 10y agoI agree with the bluetooth being inferior, I hate that the standard headphone jack is going away. If it isn't broken, don't fix it. That said I've been told that the 3.5mm jack takes up a surprising amount of internal space, and that between freeing up that space and a few other tweaks, getting rid of the jack substantially boosts battery life. Still, I think it's not a great trade-off, now you have to babysit a new battery in your headphones, which probably won't last a full day of use. On a personal note, anticipated lack of a standard headphone jack is one of the reasons I upgraded to a 6S recently, this way I'll have the best 3.5-mm phone Apple made for a while. If I do have to upgrade later on, I'll be strongly tempted to get an SE instead of a higher end phone, as long as it has a 3.5mm jack.
- semi-extrinsic 10y ago> getting rid of the jack substantially boosts battery life Yes, as you say, by moving the power draw for the DAC to another device, which must be charged separately. This isn't a real gain in battery life in any way.
- entee 10y agoYeah, I recognize that. It's also extra space to shove battery into. Like I said, I don't think it's a real worthwhile trade-off.
- 1anh2kqowg 10y agoAt least for most headphones with some kind of band, there is a lot of room for a battery.
- jschwartzi 10y agoThere's also a lot of additional weight.
- grive 10y agoIt's always possible to add a battery. That's not the problem. The problem is that we have a passive device, headphones, that works well and are a stable and mature tech, that will become crap. I dont want to charger yet another device in my daily routine. I won't, actually, and will steer away from any phone that requires active headphones to work.
- Spooky23 10y agoIt's just a way to differ estimate a flagship device. Apple is pushing volume to enterprises, etc and will make the iPhone line more diverse.
- x2398dh1 10y agoWhy will a thinner phone be mechanically weaker? What about if everything on the phone is flexible?
- msandford 10y agoCan everything on the phone be rolled up into a taquito shape? Oh, 99% of all silicon chips are rigid, not flexible? Oh, bummer. I guess that'll take some serious semiconductor fab breakthroughs before it happens.
- e12e 10y agoI'd say bluetooth is good enough for using the device(s) as a phone - but a jack might be better for connecting a high-end stereo system. On the other hand, even for that, you would probably be even better off with a digital output, and a good DAC (either in the amplifier, or as a separate unit). FWIW I recently got one of these: http://us.creative.com/p/sound-blaster/sound-blaster-e3 http://us.creative.com/p/sound-blaster/sound-blaster-e3 and I'm very happy (not for use with an Apple device though, I use it with a Sony Xpedia Z3+, my laptop and my desktop via a recent generation usb bluetooth dongle (for AptX support).
- Tobold 10y agoI'm going to assume the sound is fine on the Soundblaster, but How is the battery on that thing? Does it last the full day and them some, like my phone does?
- Camillo 10y ago> "Thinner phone" is a stupid requirement. You may think that the current iPhones are thin enough, but almost nobody actually uses the phone on its own. You need to take into account the thickness of the case, and now that people are playing Pokemon Go, it really needs to be a battery case, which is even thicker. So the base phone needs to be thinner. (They can't just make the phone a little thicker and put the extra battery inside it because reasons.)
- x1798DE 10y agoDoesn't need to be a battery case if they design a phone with a replaceable battery, like every phone I've ever owned (after iPhone 3G, which was more or less the only option at the time).
- xkcd-sucks 10y agoOh oh and the battery case can have a built-in bluetooth audio module with a headphone jack on it!
- pvdebbe 10y agoOther manufacturers seem to be able to design devices that have the sturdiness and the battery such that extra cases aren't required in everyday use.
- tonmoy 10y agoTo use a 3.5mm jack headset you need to add power amplifiers inside the phone, do proper impedance matching and hope that noise in the path does not corrupt the data. But sending power and digital data solves all these problems, the wires don't need to be as well made either!
- dredmorbius 10y agoYou've simply moved all those pieces outside the phone, increased headphone cost, and decreased modularity via dedicated Bluetooth pairing.
- tonmoy 10y agoBut the noise susceptible analog signal does not have to travel a long path, digital signal does. As such the power amplifiers do not have to be as power consuming/over designed. Moreover, you can do other stuff with the headset like taking multiple button inputs without additional wires.
- Zigurd 10y agoIt's not quite 19th c. technology. It was .25 inches, but it had only two conductors, the tip, and the ring, separated by an insulator. Hence the "tip" and "ring" nomenclature for analog telephone wiring. Analog phone technology is remarkably back-compatible. You can use an 80 year old phone today. Not many, if any technology products could claim that level of compatibility. But, so what? Analog phones are going away. They just lasted longer than most other technologies. So should codecs and amps inside of mobile devices. Those things belong with the transducer, so they can be tuned to the characteristics of the transducer.
- Animats 10y agoThe original 1/4" phone plug for switchboard use had a ball tip, rather than a pointed one. It's almost compatible with modern 1/4" jacks, but the proper jack is a "long frame telephone jack". I use those with antique Teletype machines. Unlike 1/4" audio jacks, the ring is not a ground, and the shell is always insulated.
- c22 10y ago> You can use an 80 year old phone today. I think it depends on where you are. A lot of lecs only take dtmf signalling these days.
- iliis 10y agoOne of the most backwards compatible technology I know of is railway signaling infrastructure - altough it's not a consumer product like a telephone: There are still fully mechanical control centres where you have to switch the switches by hand and turn a crank (to generate a bit of AC) to signal another control centre the current state of your tracks. Doesn't matter if the next station uses relais-logic or computers, it works.
- Sanddancer 10y agoSpeaking of railways, and connectors, the railway couplings in the US are another thing that's withstood the dest of time. The Janney railway coupler is compatible with couplers built 100+ years ago, and of a design dating back to the 1860s, with the refinements pretty much all been making individual components more and more standardized.
- hackaflocka 10y agoAnd it works beautifully. When for some reason, my bluetooth headphone's connectivity is acting up (happens often), I can take my wired headphone and plug it in without even looking, knowing that it WILL work. One of my car's electric windows has stopped working. For my next car, I want something where there's a fallback to a mechanical crank (the way car windows used to be).
- onion2k 10y agoI'm just old enough to remember cars with mechanical hand cranks to open the windows. You couldn't open the passenger side window if you were driving. It was dangerous to open the driver's side window if there was a lot going on. The rear passenger windows often didn't open at all in cheaper cars. The number of times you'd leave a window open by mistake was far higher because cars didn't alert you about it. I'd much rather have electric windows that are cheap and easy to repair than reintroduce hand cranked windows, even just as a back up.
- c22 10y agoI drive a car with hand-cranked windows and I don't have any of those problems, maybe just cause I'm used to it? Did you know you could go out today and buy a 2016 model car with manual window cranks? It's still an option on a lot of vehicles.
- hackaflocka 10y agoGood to hear! Elon Musk: if you're reading this: if you put a manual window crank option in your cars (especially as a fallback in case the electric window fails), that's what I'll buy.
- modfodder 10y agoMaybe the hand crank could charge the battery as well. On long road trips just have your passengers crank through the night....
- Animats 10y agoHow is USB-C working out as a connector, from the ruggedness standpoint? It has a huge number of pins (24) in a small space. How many insertion cycles can it survive in the real world? Is connector wearout going to limit phone life?
- tombrossman 10y agoLooks like the spec is 10,000 cycles: http://www.anandtech.com/show/8377/usb-typec-connector-specifications-finalized http://www.anandtech.com/show/8377/usb-typec-connector-speci... That's over 13 cycles/day for two years. Probably fine for most users. Edit: The official spec is only available via a zipped folder of PDFs, here's the particulars to save readers the effort. 5.7.1.3 Durability or Insertion/Extraction Cycles (EIA 364-09) The durability ratings listed in Table 5-16 are specified for the USB 3.1 connectors. Table 5-16. Durability Ratings Connector Standard Durability Class High Durability Class USB 3.1 Standard-A connector 1500 cycles min 5000 cycles min USB 3.1 Standard-B connector 1500 cycles min 5000 cycles min USB 3.1 Micro connector family 10000 cycles min The durability test shall be done at a maximum rate of 200 cycles per hour and no physical damage to any part of the connector or cable assembly shall occur.
- userbinator 10y agoThat's what the spec says. It remains to be seen how connectors perform in the real world, with all its dust and dirt.
- Animats 10y agoTrue. That thing has more pins in less space than anything previously exposed to consumer handling.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoDust and dirt are a bitch. The original 30 pin Apple connector wasn't bad, but when I looked at the new lightning connector I thought it would be a clear improvement. But now I'm not sure. Lightning pins are quite small. I find my devices don't always make good contact. I find black stuff (oxidation?) building up on both pins and sockets. Compared to lightning, USB-C just "feels" like it will be much worse. I predict it will be a disappointment in the real world (as most connectors turn out to be).
- lips 10y ago"If you look at the previous generation of phones, things like Nokia phones, you had to have an adapter," he reasons. "If you want to connect headphones to professional equipment, you also need a professional adapter." No, this was (for the most part) an anomaly. (Sony loved this crap.) And the "adapter" you need for professional gear costs all of .25, unless you want to plug your headphones into BNC, then it's maybe 1$ in parts and 15 minutes at your bench.
- e12e 10y agoFunny thing. My old sony-ericcson phone was the first that came with a hands-free that had a separate minijack above the mic, so you could use any headset with the (wired) handsfree (and it also had a standard "long" minijack for control+mic+output). Sony made a couple of brilliant mp3 players with proper line out for a while - until Sony Music got upset about "piracy", and apparently the ensuing battle within Sony killed a lot of great products. Which turned out to be a net loss, as was obvious to anyone - it happened that Apple took the marked with the iPod, but it was obvious someone would).
- swang 10y agoI think Apple did this too late. If they had done this with an earlier release where smartphones were still "advancing" I think they would have gotten better conversion. Now what can they possibly offer in the next iPhone that offsets the loss of the headphone jack? Wireless headphones are just not all the way there and I don't really want to have to think about charging another device and then get mad if I forget to charge it then have nothing to listen to for the day. Unless they offer something substantial with the next iPhone and assuming the headphone thing is true, I probably won't buy another iPhone.
- gcb0 10y agoNokia did it before the iPhone. everyone hated them. Apple is smarter. they first get the monopoly, then they screw the users
- zaroth 10y agoFor me the only thing that would make eliminating the headphone jack worth it is if they put a lightning jack on both ends and made the phone perfectly symmetrical. With literally no top or bottom, no right or wrong way to hold it, and finally a way for my phone to sit in the cup holder with a charge cable coming out the top and maps showing in the right orientation! The trick in making all this work of course is what you do with the rest of the buttons. If Apple could come up with something truly better than what we have had all along for lock, volume, silent, and home, that would be really neat. In other words, I can see justifying removal of the jack as part of a holistic redesign which really evolves how we interface with the device. Removing it to make the phone just a bit thinner would be disappointing.
- 1anh2kqowg 10y agoI agree that two ports would make me a lot less annoyed by the change, especially when you can keep an adapter around for one of the ports. But from experience, designs where the charging and audio ports are on opposing ends are pretty annoying in practice, because the two cords restrict how you can move the phone when it is charging and headphones are in use. Apple stopped doing it that way several years ago.
- zaroth 10y agoYour only other choice is a single port on one side. There's no way you get two ports side-by-side on one side. So your point is well taken, but the existing setup of charge and audio together on the same side would be gone no matter what. I think the choice is eliminate the port and don't allow simple charging while listening without a weird adapter, or else you need two lightning ports. What will be funny is the power cords which have a 3.5mm jack embedded in them. Take the jack off the phone, move it a couple inches away. It can be made very streamlined, doesn't have to be bulky. The possibility of a good power/jack cable makes me think they won't actually pull off a radical redesign, but I'd be so glad to be proven wrong, just to see something different from Apple.
- inputjoker 10y ago2 most common phone companies before the iphone era were nokia and sony ericsson. Before making 3.5 jack mandatory by the GSM association, sony ericsson used proprietary connector for their headphone jack and nokia used 1.5mm jack. We weren't using 3.5mm jack all the way from the first smartphone and we shouldn't stick to it for the future smartphones.
- jurassic 10y agoIf they are moving to a paradigm where I can't listen and charge at the same time, the 6 will be my last iPhone. I wish they would stop trying to shave millimeters off my phone thickness and address actual user needs like battery life. When was the last time any of you said, "Damn, I wish this phone was thinner!"? Probably never. But many of us regularly bemoan the battery life of our devices.
- vidarh 10y agoIn fact recent phone models have gotten less comfortable to hold for me because of thinness.
- Daneel_ 10y agoThis. I drop my 6S all the time, whereas my previous 5S was a dream and never slipped. I shouldn't have up^H^Hdowngraded..
- sliverstorm 10y ago"Damn, I wish this phone was as thin & durable as a graham cracker, so that I can put it in my pocket all day"
- 1anh2kqowg 10y agoI think users would be happier day-to-day with a larger battery, but in the ATT showroom they are more likely to go for the thinner phone with a small battery and no headphone jack.
- stouset 10y agoNobody seems to consider that the extra space can be used for a bigger battery instead of a smaller phone.
- jacobsladder 10y agoCriticizing Apple for deciding to remove another port, is really shallow and superficial way to spread FUD (Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt) against this large corporation. Just so we are on this page, you will _still_ be able to connect 3.5mm headphones to your iPhone. You will just have to use an adapter. There are benefits for removing this port: 1. It frees up internal space. 2. It makes outer design more robust, simpler and cheaper for production. 3. It makes the phone lighter. 4. It allows you to make iPhone thinner. 5. You have one less limitation to account for when designing new iPhone. 6. You waste less materials on cables and oversized jacks made out of metal. I really like how article says that there will be lots of cables wasted from this. Well, so what? Should we stop all innovation and keep all standards forever the same so there is no waste? Ideally we should move on to smallest possible ports and most efficient standards. We can get there with tiny steps, and that will include throwing away legacy things. 7. It's easier to make phone waterproof when you have less openings. In addition to that, lightning jack is superior to microUSB and other jacks, because you can insert it either way. It also has magnetic functionality that the other jacks lack. Finally, for me as a customer, this change does not bring any problems either. I may have to spend $20 more for adapter. But if the phone costs $500, this change is insignificant. Companies in the audio industry might have bigger problems from this, but it's their problems, not mine. I am seriously surprised that BBC would be posting useless crap like this. Could it be because there is a lot of money to be made from shorting Apple stock and then releasing anti-Apple propaganda?
- userbinator 10y agoNote that there is a 2.5mm variant of the connector, which I'm surprised hasn't gotten more common as a result of the whole thinness trend.
- dublinben 10y agoThe reason why this obvious option isn't part of the discussion is because thinness is just the smokescreen. The real reason Apple et. al. want to move towards digital connections for headphones is DRM. They want to control the entire signal chain of their valuable (Beats = $3b) music content.
- zwily 10y agoI'll believe you if they don't provide a simple analog adapter.
- achairapart 10y agoAlso, no more IR remote control: https://www.amazon.com/M-Way-Universal-Appliances-Controller-Dust-proof/dp/B01HGNFQQG/ https://www.amazon.com/M-Way-Universal-Appliances-Controller...
- callesgg 10y agoI like that the 3.5 mm connector is fairly simple and is does not break easily. I have seen many broken micro-usb connectors, and a couple of broken lightning connectors. I cant remember ever seeing a broken 3.5mm connector, the cables break before the connector. Do i want a thinner phone? No, i want a phone with better battery life. Like phones had back in the day(2005) a week or two was not uncommon.
- sxcurry 10y agoI don't understand the angst. Have an existing iPhone - keep it! Apple isn't going to send the earbud police to your house to confiscate it. Buying a new phone - buy an Android phone! Am I missing something here?
- velox_io 10y agoThe BBC failed to mention that there is also a 2.5mm jack available. Quite a bit smaller, but I haven't seen one for a while (~5 years). After replacing so many headphones because of cables breaking, I'm really happy Bluetooth headphones. Although when I want to enjoy music, you can't beat decent headphones with a half decent soundcard/ DAC.
- ajnin 10y ago> "Studying Moore's Law and the history of technology, it's clear we're not going to stick around with something analogue for long," he says. The real world is still analogue, and as long as we have biological brains there will need to be a digital to analogue conversion somewhere to interface with it. Phone manufacturers might want to move that conversion out of their devices, which is understandable because analogue electronics is expensive and good quality even more so, and that change would make it someone else's responsibility. In the end if this does go through it might not be totally a bad thing if the new digital connector is also a standard (and provides power, I might add). That way it would be possible to get a good quality DAC and reuse it everywhere.
- niccaluim 10y agoThis is a lot of fuss over nothing. Of course there will be an adapter. Maybe not the most elegant thing in the world, but it's not as though millions of headphones are suddenly going to become useless.
- jmspring 10y agoWhen I use my iPhones for music (currently have a 6), I use one of two headphones: - Plantronic BackBeat Pros - Westone UM4r The BackBeat's are great wireless, noise reducing over the ear headphones. I need to remember to charge them. The Westone's are in ear monitors that, depending on type of bud you put on them, have noise reducing capabilities. They are wired. They are also some of the most amazing monitors I've owned over the years. (It hurts the time I lost a pair). Sitting in a quiet space, the Westones will blow the Plantronics out of the water. In a plane, if I am not trying to comfortably sleep, the Plantronics are great. If I want to lay my head to the side -- IEMs rule the day. Apple has yet to produce a set of headphones that feel comfortable for me or deliver decent quality. I can't bike/run w/ Apple's headphones, they fall out (or hurt). If they go the route of no 3.5mm jack, I'll likely insist on one of those stupid converters. I've yet to see anything from Apple or Beats that compares to upper end IEMs for quality, or upper end over the ear phones for noise reduction.
- dingo_bat 10y agoThis is the sort of thing the market will sort out anyways. If there is enough of a market for people who don't care about the 3.5mm port, apple will be fine. People like me will buy something else. Just because apple doesn't have expandable storage hasn't made samsung discontinue it either. Same deal with the headphone jack.
- mdip 10y agoWhile I'm with you and won't be buying one for reasons beyond the 3.5mm jack (but that would be a deal breaker if I was on the fence), I'll be more surprised if the removal of that feature stops scores of people lining up to get the latest phone (along with a new set of over-priced headphones). At the end of the day, it's "give up the 3.5mm jack" or "don't get the latest iPhone" and I'll wager that they'll have no problem generating lines filled with people that just have to have the iPhone 7 because...Apple! Apple has a near-religious following. I got a kick out of a friend of mine who upgraded on release when they ditched the 30-pin connector. He'd recently purchased an alarm clock, an add-on for his home stereo and had already owned several other 30-pin reliant bits. They were on eBay the following week. Out of the non-techies I know that purchased the iPhone 6, none of them could tell what, specifically, they were getting over their existing iPhone 5S (that's a grand-anecdotal-total of 3 folks, though). If there is resistance on this release due to there not being enough compelling features, that resistance will eventually give way. Many people are so wired in to Apple's products that lock-in will win. Maybe they'll wait until the 8. But eventually Apple will be making money on sales of ear buds with Apple-only connections and will benefit from yet another component that locks them into their platform. And the folks who spend $200 on supposedly high-end ear phones[0] will now feel even more compelled to stick with Apple's product line. I'm biased and this is a little overly cynical. I've never owned an iPhone and the two Apple devices I've ever owned: an iPad that belongs to my wife and an iMac that I use as a display (target display mode) because, at the time, it was a little less than a comparable "screen only" device with similar specifications (and it was physically prettier, to boot). I've not logged into it, directly, in two years and don't really get the appeal of OSX. [0] I've never understood this. I have a pair of 25 year old studio headphones (AKG, 1/4" jack, big, over-the-ear with a very long cord). I needed them due to equipment and was sicked that they ran 10 times the price of a pair of solid headphones, but I was amazed by the quality they produced. I didn't want to buy these, but after 25 years of heavy use (and the manufacturer still makes the model I purchased), I can't say I feel bad about the price. The Beats/Bose headphones? I can't tell the difference between them and a pair of $30 active noise cancelling headphones I purchased from Big Lots. Granted, I can't plug my AKGs into a phone even with an adapter -- they're too quiet.
- usefulcat 10y ago"If you're using £1,000 headphones with your iPhone at the moment, you're going to be slightly cross." So.. maybe just don't buy this hypothetical new iPhone?
- cm2187 10y agoWhat would be funny is if the audience started booing Tim Cook when he announces this new "feature" when presenting the iPhone 7...
- jeffbush 10y agoWhile working on mobile phones, I've found a number of problems with the TRS style jack. One is they trap lint internally, which can often result in the internal switch that detects insertion permanently thinking there is a headphone in it (Google "phone thinks headphones are in"). The external speaker is usually muted when a jack is inserted, so when this happens, the phone doesn't make any sounds. Lint is very difficult to remove from the outside the connector. The other problem--which the original inventors couldn't have anticipated--involves the hook switch (hangup button) on wired phone earbuds. The switch usually works by shorting the microphone to ground. The problem is that, because of the geometry of the plug, the microphone is also shorted to ground while the plug is inserted or removed. To avoid erroneously interpreting insertion/removal as a hangup, the software must wait for the button to be held for around a second. This precludes doing other interesting things with the button, like having double clicks, or clicks with different durations perform other functions. It also feels a bit awkward to have to hold it for so long.
- deathanatos 10y ago> One is they trap lint internally, I've owned my current phone for ~4 years, and the first port to stop working — due to lint — was the USB port, not the audio port. > Lint is very difficult to remove from the outside the connector. Removing lint from a 3.5mm audio port is going to be vastly easier than removing it from a USB port (which is completely possible). The entrance is much wider, and you don't have to worry about damaging the connector thing that USB has in the middle, as it doesn't exist. I've even removed a silica gel ball (which are apparently about 3.5mm wide …) from an audio port (and needed a paper clip to crush it first). I'd not want to try the same thing on a digital USB or lightning port …
- stouset 10y agoLightning wouldn't be any more difficult than an audio jack — I'm not sure why you think it would be. Agreed that USB would be a nightmare, but thankfully that's not really a plausible scenario for an iPhone.
- 10y ago
- perilunar 10y agoIf they want thinner, just go from 3.5 mm audio to 2.5 mm audio. Already an existing standard. If thinness is just a cover for wanting digital, then go TOSLINK and have digital with analog fall-back. They already have it in the MacBook Pros.
- xkcd-sucks 10y agoBut the 2.5mm jack was used on TI graphing calculators and flipphones from the 90s... It doesn't seem very innovative.
- copperx 10y ago"Studying Moore's Law and the history of technology, it's clear we're not going to stick around with something analogue for long" Dediu didn't study the basics of sound reproduction, which are all analogue. All the fancy ones and zeros end up in a stupidly innacurate shaking paper cone. Ignoring a few esoteric exceptions, that's the best that we've got.
- kristopolous 10y agoIn 1997 they had a proprietary Apple plaintak 3.5mm connector that was longer. In 2009 they moved controls from the shuffle to the headphone to force their thing again. And this is just on one plug. They are the company of proprietary hardware and this is how they play.
- kagamine 10y agothat gen of Shuffle was a disaster and then they redesigned the little square one to make it better. Imo the Shuffle as it is now is one of the best devices ever designed.
- touristtam 10y agoWhat I've read: Apple, Apple, Apple. What it should have read: Phone manufacturer (among which Apple with its popular iPhone) are starting to bring mobile devices without the omnipresent 3.5mm audio jack.