20 ms·
Israel Proves the Desalination Era Is Here
- manachar 10y ago"Water shoots into the cylinders at a pressure of 70 atmospheres and is pushed through the membranes, while the remaining brine is returned to the sea." I've heard this brine can have a pretty negative ecological impact, I wonder how that could be mitigated.
- brianwawok 10y agoExplain why? The ocean is say 99 parts water and 1 part stuff. We take out 1 part water and .01 parts stuff, keep the water, then put the .01 parts stuff back. Doesn't seem to really change the ocean concentration? I guess maybe if dumped too close to shore it could make a brine slick?
- refurb 10y agoHigh local concentrations could certainly be a problem, but it seems pretty easy to solve. Just setup a pump to pull a ton of sea water into the plant and deposit back out off shore. Slowly inject the brine into the stream and it would be instantly diluted.
- abalone 10y agoNot easy. You have to consider the energy cost of pumping tons of sea water around.
- refurb 10y agoStill easy, just expensive. My understanding is that the brine you get from desalination is only slightly more salty than sea water. It might take 20 gals of sea water to prosuce one gallon of desalinated water.
- brianwawok 10y agoGravity? Make a 3 mile pipe with a small angle down.
- dalke 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination#Outflow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination#Outflow gives an overview of the environmental problems in desal outflow: > Desalination processes produce large quantities of brine, possibly at above ambient temperature, and contain residues of pretreatment and cleaning chemicals, their reaction byproducts and heavy metals due to corrosion.[45] Chemical pretreatment and cleaning are a necessity in most desalination plants, which typically includes prevention of biofouling, scaling, foaming and corrosion in thermal plants, and of biofouling, suspended solids and scale deposits in membrane plants.[46] > To limit the environmental impact of returning the brine to the ocean, ... > Brine is denser than seawater and therefore sinks to the ocean bottom and can damage the ecosystem. Careful reintroduction can minimize this problem. Typical ocean conditions allow for rapid dilution, thereby minimizing harm. What's an example of not typical? Here's an article which points out that the Arabian Gulf is shallow, with low circulation rates and high evaporation rates which make it naturally saltier. That, combined with the damming of freshwater and increasing number of desal plants places a limit on to how much it can be use as a water source: http://www.thenational.ae/news/uae-news/environment/desalination-threat-to-the-growing-gulf http://www.thenational.ae/news/uae-news/environment/desalina...
- ethbro 10y agoFrom the article, "chemical-free method." [1] I'm sure the salt concentration isn't great, but it's a lot easier to spread salt around than remove heavy metals and cleaning chemicals. [1] https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ilana_Berman-Frank/publication/236137883_Bioflocculation_Chemical_free_pre-treatment_technology_for_the_desalination_industry/links/00b4951976edf67426000000.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ilana_Berman-Frank/publ...
- dalke 10y agoMore details at http://www.filtsep.com/view/44376/success-behind-advanced-swro-desalination-plant/ http://www.filtsep.com/view/44376/success-behind-advanced-sw... : > Minimizing the plant's environmental impact: Pipe jacking .... Other measures: the potential impacts of the Sorek Plant's operation on the environment were thoroughly assessed, and appropriate measures were taken to prevent, minimize and mitigate these. The following are some highlights of these measures: > – The feed water pumping station is located far (2,400 meters) from the coastline, and feed water flows by gravity to the on-site pumping station. > – Entrainment and impingement effects at the intake system are minimized, thus minimizing the consumption of electricity and chemicals (especially CO2) and reducing the emission of related greenhouse gases, air pollutants and noise. > – Environmentally-friendly antiscalants, and inorganic and treatable cleaning solutions, are used. > – Brine is discharged back to the sea approximately 2 kilometers offshore, and at a depth of 20 meters through a specially designed outfall system (diffusers) that enhances quick brine dilution to the seawater body. The critical parameters of the brine disposal are monitored online, 24/7. > – The plant is equipped with a special sludge treatment system to treat any effluents generated in the process. This system removes all suspended matter and only clear water is discharged to the sea.
- adventureartist 10y agoYou are correct. The new plant in San Diego dumps out a ~20% brine IIRC that is supposed to be not as bad as the 50% brine that creates dead spots in the ocean. Not sure about the Israeli brine, but they did help develop the San Diego facility.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoThat's not how desalination works in practice, you don't end up with 100% salt as a result, even so that would be problematic. Typically you end up with about half of the inflow salt water being converted to fresh water and the other half being converted to higher salinity salt water. Note that the salt in seawater is actually about 3.5%. So what happens is you suck up a bunch of seawater, which is pretty easy to mitigate negative effects from, and then you have an outflow of 7% salinity seawater, which you have to be somewhat careful with. Ignoring power usage, the US draws something like ten thousand cubic meters per second of water for its use. So a single plant that is supplying water for, say, only a million people might be expected to discharge a volume of water brine that was on the order of 1 million cubic meters a day. The ocean is big, but it would be extremely costly to discharge that amount of brine into the ocean in a way that wouldn't create a very large persistently briny volume near the discharge point. Also, that discharge point is almost certainly going to be near to the shore, which means that it will impact ocean life.
- matheweis 10y agoThey conveniently have an already briny place to dump it all: "The brine discharge from the plant will be piped 100 miles north through Jordan to replenish the Dead Sea"
- srameshc 10y agoThis technology could be a boon to country like India where huge population relies on rain and some of the reservoirs are at about 40% despite decent rainfall this year. On the other note will desalination and consumption of sea water by humans balance the rising sea level ?
- delecti 10y agoPretty much all the desalinated water that is "consumed" will just flow right back out to sea.
- FreeFull 10y agoEither that, or end up evaporating in the atmosphere, precipitating somewhere, and then flowing into the sea.
- rs999gti 10y agoEventually, according to the water cycle: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/19/Watercyclesummary.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/19/Watercyc...
- douche 10y agoThe amount of water consumed by humans is a literal drop in the ocean, on the global scale, fear-mongering aside. I wouldn't worry about the impact of a handful of desalination plants.
- MichaelGG 10y agohttp://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=50+billion+m%5E3+%2F+(1.3+billion+km%5E3+to+m%5E3) http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=50+billion+m%5E3+%2F+(1... California uses 1/26 millionth's of the ocean's volume per year (50bn m^3 out of 1.3 bn km^3). So a drop is quite right! According to [1], it takes 87 mi^3 (~320km^3) to raise the ocean level by 1mm. You'd need several Cali's worth of water use just to negate to that 1mm rise. And that's assuming you destroy the water after use, which basically does not happen. If you _could_ destroy the water (freeze it all or fuse it all or something) it'd still take a million years to use it up. 1: http://www.sealevel.info/conversion_factors.html http://www.sealevel.info/conversion_factors.html
- abalone 10y ago> Desalination used to be an expensive energy hog, but the kind of advanced technologies being employed at Sorek have been a game changer. Water produced by desalination costs just a third of what it did in the 1990s. How much of that price drop is due to lower energy prices? How sustainable is the power source? Even with significant efficiency improvements (3X), shifting from local freshwater sources to desalination would have a massive energy requirements.[1] For such a bold claim ("the Desalination Era is Here"), this article has a rather lightweight examination of the environmental impacts. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination#Energy_consumption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination#Energy_consumptio...
- einhverfr 10y agoOne of my favorite takes on this topic is Clarke and Dawe's take on the Victoria desalination project[1] (the two are comedians). [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_SrrylkIEc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_SrrylkIEc
- vacri 10y agoIt's a bit sad, though - the Victorian government was in a no-win situation with that one. A nine-year drought with the water reserves to a city of 4M people down to 15%? Something had to be done, and the common refrain of "drought will break next year" had been heard every year for the previous half-decade. The plant was over-expensive and should have been bought in a progressive manner rather than full-capacity-at-once, but Melbourne was actually in danger of running out of water. They joke in the video "why not build a dam where it's actually raining?", but the point was, there'd been barely any rain for a decade. There wasn't anywhere that fit that description (and Melbourne has tons of water reserves outside of long drought conditions). Of course, because Fate is an arsehole, they got the construction underway, and the next year the drought broke. If the drought hadn't broken, people wouldn't be so quick to condemn the desal plant...
- aaron695 10y ago> How sustainable is the power source? Oil (and such and such) will last a 100+ years and obviously won't destroy the planet in that time. I'd call that sustainable. And given it's just a "power source", at any time we could swap it out for X, Y, Z. Plus they specifically talk about efficiencies in the article? Not sure your point at all? I haven't seen huge drops in energy cost across the world? Electricity seems the same or more than the 1990s?
- aphextron 10y agoWhere is the power coming from? Desalination can only be as efficient and sustainable as the power source. It's not surprising if Israel can build massive desalination plants dependent on cheap fossil fuel power. This is just trading water now for more CO2 added to the atmosphere, worsening the underlying problem.
- Alphasite_ 10y agoSolar is now significantly more economical than it once was and in the long term would be rather appropriate for these regions.
- pstuart 10y agojinx! you owe me a glass of water.
- pstuart 10y agoSeems like solar power would be a perfect fit.
- unchocked 10y agoPhotovoltaics, in the long run.
- drewm1980 10y agoThis story is hopeful but also worrying... I am so glad I am not living in a region where my drinking water depends completely on non-renewables. I hope energy hogs like desalination can be used as a buffer to reduce storage needs... I.e. build over capacity and run them when energy is plentiful.
- avita1 10y agoOf the three plants mentioned in the article, it looks like at least the smallest (Ashkelon) is powered by natural gas. http://www.delek-group.com/Holdings/EnergyInfrastructure/DelekInfrastructure.aspx http://www.delek-group.com/Holdings/EnergyInfrastructure/Del...
- azernik 10y agoIn Israel, it's mostly a triumph of politics over economics - Jordan, Israel, and the PA have cooperated in developing desalination plants [1] in part in order to defuse conflicts over water. Water allocations have historically been a zero-sum competition in the region, so when there's a chance (however expensive) to just throw money at the problem to make it go away, everyone's willing to play along. [1] http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2013/12/09/senior-israel-jordanian-palestinian-representatives-water-sharing-agreement http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2013/12/09/se...
- unchocked 10y agoI think it's quite a mistake to dismiss public infrastructure that efficiently provides a vital resource in needed quantities as somehow triumphing over economics. Economic theory seems to be supported here, in that infrastructure now exists to meet record demand, at a higher marginal price than earlier supplies. Did you mean to say that it's simply expensive?
- Spooky23 10y agoYou miss the point. It's cheaper to screw your neighbor than to build infrastructure.
- mabbo 10y agoI've heard that just as big as their desalination efforts are their water reuse efforts. All that sewage we work so hard to get rid of? Turns out that's still fresh water. Sort of. It's just got some other stuff in it is all.
- maxerickson 10y agoLA has a big water reuse program. http://www.lacsd.org/waterreuse/ http://www.lacsd.org/waterreuse/ I guess in many areas it is less urgent so it doesn't get done.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoOrange County's water reuse system is far bigger: http://www.ocwd.com/what-we-do/water-reuse/ http://www.ocwd.com/what-we-do/water-reuse/ The Groundwater Replenishment System (GWRS) is the world's largest system for indirect potable reuse. The system takes highly treated wastewater that would have previously been discharged into the Pacific Ocean and purifies it using a three-step advanced treatment process.
- dghughes 10y agoIsrael recycles 86% of water from the sewers compared to the second most efficient recovery in the world is Spain at 19%.
- ksec 10y agoThat is the 2nd most interesting point i want to hear more about. And yet the article does not go into any details.
- Xyz9292929 10y agoEverything you wanted to know and VERY interesting :) http://www.smartpeoplepodcast.com/2015/10/26/episode-214-seth-siegel/ http://www.smartpeoplepodcast.com/2015/10/26/episode-214-set... tldr; water was used as an excuse by the British to limit immigration to Israel, so from the earliest onset of the formation of Israel, Israel has been trying to tackle the problem of water use inefficiency.
- HillaryBriss 10y ago> Sorek can produce a thousand liters of drinking water for 58 cents. In Los Angeles, the DWP tier 1 retail price for a cubic foot is very, very roughly 5 cents or roughly $1.75 for 1000 liters. And DWP's prices are going up (for a host of reasons).
- gozur88 10y agoThere's no point in comparing retail to wholesale, though.
- Dylan16807 10y agoWhen the retail price is large enough, it's worth showing that you could add this new wholesale price on top without greatly affecting it.
- jpollock 10y agoDoesn't the DWP price include procurement, treatment, delivery to a house and sewage treatment, whereas the Sorek price is only procurement. To compare them, it would have to be the price someone pays to obtain a kilolitre of untreated water at source. California seems to have some water transfers, and I found a report listing prices from $50-$550/acre-foot, or ~1.25 million L (2012 [1]) That would give an upper bound of (550/1250) $0.44/kilolitre at source. [1] http://www.ppic.org/content/pubs/report/R_1112EHR.pdf http://www.ppic.org/content/pubs/report/R_1112EHR.pdf
- HillaryBriss 10y agoI do not think the sewage treatment is included in that price. But the rest is, as you say.
- jpollock 10y agoYou are correct, in LA, it's broken out into a separate line item. From the DWP FAQ: "The Sewer Service Charge (SSC) is based on metered water use" https://www.ladwp.com/ladwp/faces/wcnav_externalId/c-cs-sewer-charg;jsessionid=jtpbXczQjvtM6njrczJxY9LGF0Jvjn4q1zGTHBwBP6l5rTPj1ZyD!747476876?_adf.ctrl-state=j2xbb4sk6_4&ladwp/cms/ladwp000399.jsp&_afrLoop=603635808483886&_afrWindowMode=0&_afrWindowId=null#%40%3Fladwp%252Fcms%252Fladwp000399.jsp%3D%26_afrWindowId%3Dnull%26_afrLoop%3D603635808483886%26_afrWindowMode%3D0%26_adf.ctrl-state%3D18bpvkygwi_4 https://www.ladwp.com/ladwp/faces/wcnav_externalId/c-cs-sewe...
- adventureartist 10y agoFor some perspective: LA county uses about ~50 Million cubic meters of water per year. The largest Israeli desalinization plant is ~225 Million cubic meters per year. The entire state of California uses ~50 Billion cubic meters of water per year. Very rough numbers
- MichaelGG 10y agoBut only a few percent is for residential use, right? So ignoring agriculture, a few large plants should provide enough water for humans to be happy in Cali solely off of desal?
- abalone 10y agoI'm guessing people in Cali would not be very happy living without agriculture, so no.
- btilly 10y agoCalifornia's GDP is estimated at 1,800 billion. Economic activity coming from agriculture is estimated at about 100 billion. Given an average economic growth rate of 2.5% per year for California, losing all agriculture would set California's growth back about 2 years. Nobody wants to do that, and there are all sorts of complex legal issues around water rights. But push come to shove, California could survive just fine without its agricultural sector.
- andrewjl 10y agoCalifornia can do that, but the demand for fruits and veggies will still be there. California grows the vast majority (in the US) of quite a few of those: peaches, carrots, strawberries, and others. Instead these will need to be shipped from overseas by marine transport which is an intense source of pollution.
- wmil 10y ago
- jmspring 10y agoThe article states -- "Desalination used to be an expensive energy hog, but the kind of advanced technologies being employed at Sorek have been a game changer. Water produced by desalination costs just a third of what it did in the 1990s. Sorek can produce a thousand liters of drinking water for 58 cents. Israeli households pay about US$30 a month for their water — similar to households in most U.S. cities, and far less than Las Vegas (US$47) or Los Angeles (US$58)." But I saw nothing about where the energy comes from, the type of source, the scale. I'd like to compare this with local proposals, etc. One of the biggest DeSal issues is cost of conversion and source, proximity of source, etc. play a huge factor.
- unchocked 10y agoThe energy comes from the grid. The nice thing about the grid is that it lets you abstract out power, kinda like bandwidth on the Internet. Do you care which data center a new app lives in? But if we must, I suspect the supply side (of electricity) I suspect most new supplies in Israel are solar PV located in the Negev, since peak demand there correlates with sun. And what sort of local proposals are you imagining as alternatives to desalination?
- nickff 10y agoIt looks like almost all 'grid' power in Israel comes from hydrocarbon sources, with the largest part being coal, followed closely by natural gas, and distantly by diesel.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Israel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Israel
- jmspring 10y agoSo cost of local energy generation is a big part of it. "The Grid" here in CA, is highly variable in cost depending on where you live. In the Monterey Bay Area, one proposal by a local oceanographer/hydro geologist was at Moss Landing where there is a power plant and could provide (with pumping/piping, etc) for both Monterey and Santa Cruz county. Santa Cruz, being ... polite ... unable to play well with others, was pushing their own thing which would disrupt a good part of the town, had no local power generation, and would require extra pumps, storage, and what not all over town. Something in the $100s of millions for a county of < 250k. The regional approach makes way more sense, but local politics and all.
- sandworm101 10y agoHonestly, I had always assumed Israel was much more advanced than this article points out. In the 90s I was a kid in the middle east. We had a "sweet water" tap in the kitchen for drinking. Everything else was recycled. We didn;t flush our toilets with drinkable water. And low-flow appliances were the norm. I find it shocking that Israel hadn't started such measures until 2007.
- dogma1138 10y agoIsrael has been recycling most of its wastewater since the 60's, today it reclaims over 86% of its wastewater this is a huge margin over the next closest contender which is spain at 17%. The water in the toilet is drinkable, that doesn't mean it's wasted there is no need to overcomplicate your water management systems if you can reclaim most of the water back and reuse it, including as drinking water. Countries with "dual feed" water systems don't do it for efficiency or water preservation, they do it because the main feed water quality is below drinking levels, so larger municipalities can supplement the main water system by providing a "drinking" tap into homes, in some places the drinking tap is communal for the building, block, or even the entire village while the rest of the water should not be drank without boiling or treatment if at all.
- sandworm101 10y agoThat isn't the system we had. The drinking water line supplied the "sweet water" taps and and dishwashers. Interestingly, the hot water tanks also got 'sweet' water as dishwashers often use hot water. The non-drinking water in homes was recycled water and was more heavily chlorinated, making it safe for bathing but not great for drinking. It wouldn't make you sick, but drinking a large amount could be uncomfortable. Then we had a third standard for irrigation of lawns and such. That water wasn't as heavily chlorinated.
- dogma1138 10y agoThat's pretty standard in emerging water markets, the chlorinated water was actually most likely not the recycled one (you do not chlorinate water that is not near drinking quality, if you do it to unfiltered reclaimed water you create really nasty chemical reactions), it's most likely water that has been collected or transported at least partially in open air systems and the chlorine is used as a antiseptic. The drinking water is the higher quality water that has been treated and is transferred in a closed system with higher quality control, while the water used for lawns is most likely the reclaimed water. When you can reclaim most of you water and ensure quality control throughout the system you simplify it, have one water feed for residential use, and usually another for agriculture and industry. Reclaimed water even drinking quality is usually not put back into the tap because the cost of ensuring water quality make it unfavourable, it's used for agriculture and industrial uses, when it ends up again as drinking water it's often as filtered bottle water simply because you can then transfer the cost of the additional water quality control to the industrial users.
- ZoeZoeBee 10y agoCape Coral, Florida has been using a RO desalination plant to provide drinking water since the 1970s, currently they produce 18 Million Gallons a day http://fwrj.com/techarticles/0909%20FWRJ_tech2.pdf http://fwrj.com/techarticles/0909%20FWRJ_tech2.pdf
- lyonlim 10y agoI wanted to understand how Singapore's desalination capacity (which is known as our fourth tap for water sources), compares with this. The numbers are quite mind blowing, at the scale Israel is doing desalination. Our current desalination capacity, with 2 plants, amount to only 100 million gallons per day which currently meets 25% of our needs [1]. [1] https://www.pub.gov.sg/watersupply/fournationaltaps/desalinatedwater https://www.pub.gov.sg/watersupply/fournationaltaps/desalina...
- CydeWeys 10y agoI've never been as afraid of fresh water shortage as a lot of other people seem to be precisely because it is exactly the kind of shortage that is solved by market forces. Freshwater getting scarce? OK, so the price goes up. Now there's more incentive to conserve water by replacing fixtures for low-flow variants, letting your lawn die (why do you really need one in a desert anyway), and using more efficient irrigation methods in agriculture. The price of water still keeps going up? Then the price of meat goes up because growing crops to feed animals become more expensive, and people eat less meat. Meanwhile, increased price makes desalination more profitable, and more plants come online. I don't see it as anything rising close to a civilization-ending threat. Seawater is abundant. Freshwater can be made cheaply enough. We are extravagantly wasteful with water as it is, and that can be fixed easily enough as it becomes more expensive.
- ph0rque 10y agoYup. The fresh-water problem is an energy problem, and it's getting solved.
- WalterBright 10y agoIt's also a pricing problem. Shortages happen when the price is not allowed to rise.
- gunnihinn 10y agoWell I'm glad you guys nailed the problem in three tweets or so.
- orionblastar 10y agoAs we know when a water source dries up in a Middle Eastern nation, the people who need it move to a different location and some get desperate. This leads to more refugees for other nations to take on, and a small fraction join a terrorist organization to survive. If this technology can bring fresh water to Middle Eastern nations, it can help fight terrorism, and end the refugee problem as they'd have no reason to flee if plenty of water and food are available as well as jobs.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoWhat if war breaks out and the desal plants are targeted?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wmil 10y agoMiddle eastern birthrates massive. They are outstripping any possible growth in jobs, water, or food. The refugee problem is permanent.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ronjitg 10y agoWhat about the environmental costs of desalination though? The article doesn't mention them, but they are significant.
- dredmorbius 10y agoAny specifics on that?
- lucb1e 10y agoI assume it's about the salt that is dumped back into the ocean after removing the water from it.
- dingleberry 10y agoI've used reverse osmosis unit for years. new unit is less than $100usd it paid itself in months. maintenance is cheap. my RO has kinda low efficiency. 4 units of water in, i get 1 unit of clean drinkable water. 3 units are 'waste' (don't believe what socmed says, it's not dirty). the waste water is used for laundry, aquarium and gardening. my fishes and vegs are thriving. to test purity, just plunge the ohm meter probes into a cup of ro water. if the resistence is in 1MOhm, it's pretty pure. mountain/mineral water bought from store is about 150kOhm. after drinking ro water for a while, store-bought water tastes slightly salty. my house pumps water from ground (well-pump). for a family of 6, i need 1m3 of water. that's about half hour of 500W pump. an ro unit (40W) runs about 3 hours for 5gal bottle. so give or take, 1/2kWH or about 15KW per month. that's about $1 or $2 for my water need per month. if i must buy raw water (such as living in an apartment), it's about $1 per m3, so about $30 per month; however, i get drinkable water too. ro units are portable. i saved $28/mo in water expense after moving from apartment. flashing back from memory, i used to lug around 3 5gal water-cooler bottle from stores to my apartment every 3 days (i had 3 bottles). it was not pleasant and wasted time (go to store, queue, lug heavy bottles back) ro unit has relay so you don't have to sit and wait for it to fill. it automatically cuts power to the pump when its internal clean-water-tank is full.
- elliotec 10y agoWow, that's really interesting. Do you have other tricks you use for efficient homesteading? Using solar and whatnot?
- chrissnell 10y agoThat's really cool. Do you face any regulatory issues for your pumping? Do you have to own water rights on your land to pump from the ground? Have you ever had your groundwater tested to ensure that there are no contaminants that might not be filtered by RO?
- dingleberry 10y agowater from well is okay for home use; however, for hotel, you need permit. i'm not overly concerned about contaminants because my water source is at the back of my house which has big trees, not some deserted mines. likewise, i never really question the safety of spring water bought from store. my crude experiment say that it's purer than spring water. that's should be sufficient. as far as i know, spring water is just that, water from spring, untreated.
- ksec 10y agoOn the Subject of Water. > Sorek can produce a thousand litres of drinking water for 58 cents. I am guessing this is the cost to produce and not the final cost to Homeowners. How much further down can we reduce this cost? I am guessing this is close to the limit of efficiency, any more reduction will have to come from cheaper energy source? Since Nuclear Power requires lots of water, would the both makes sense working together? Most countries have leaky water around pipes. UK lose around 20%, US is a little above 10%. Are the any innovation that we can shrink this number? I dont see why this cant be within 98%+ region. What is stopping it?
- baybal2 10y agoGoogle polypropylene piping. A standard in continental Europe since eighties, added to building codes across NA just few years ago.
- regularfry 10y agoThe age and number of the pipes. It's easy to underestimate the scale of the problem. There's been a replacement process going on in London to replace ancient cast iron and wooden box piping on the mains supply for the past few years. That's mostly Victorian and earlier installations, but there isn't anything like a full inventory of where they are, and sometimes what they find is that the original pipe has completely disintegrated: the water is just flowing through the void in the clay. I do know of one case (not in London) where complaints about the quality of a house's water led to the discovery that it was, via a somewhat convoluted plumbing route, still drawing water from the nearby river via Roman pipework. If you can find a leak, stopping it is usually straightforward, but on a colossal, heterogeneous and patchily documented pipe network like the UK's, the best you can do is patch it up as you go along.
- andrewclunn 10y agoAnd here Sim City had me thinking this was common place when I was a kid.
- sathishvj 10y ago"water can be a bridge" - :-) Nicely worded.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoI've said this for years here in Australia, when people talk about a "water shortage" - there's no such thing. What there is, here at least, is a cheap power shortage and a water infrastructure shortage.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sriram_malhar 10y agoI wonder what the downside of desalination is. What does one do with the huge quantities of leftover brine (when operating at country levels) -- surely dumping it back into the sea can't be good for the surrounding marine environment. In nature, there is no free lunch.
- Reason077 10y agoTheir counterparts in Syria fared much worse ... the wells ran dry and Syria’s farmland collapsed in an epic dust storm. More than a million farmers joined massive shantytowns on the outskirts of Aleppo, Homs, Damascus and other cities in a futile attempt to find work and purpose. To what extent the current situation in Syria influenced by environmental changes, I wonder? Unemployed farmers -> Social instability -> Civil Unrest -> War?
- sriram_malhar 10y agoThis SciAm article lays it out exactly as you do. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-change-hastened-the-syrian-war/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-change-has...
- lucb1e 10y agoIsn't that exactly what the article says, one paragraph further than your quote?
- vmateixeira 10y agoWhat about climate changes and any other possible drawbacks? Shouldn't this be considered having in mind that we're bringing water to.. where it's not supposed to exist, hence influencing a micro climate and making climate changes?
- yiyus 10y agoAnother example worth checking is Isla de Hierro, in the Canary Islands (Spain). Not only they are using desalination to produce most of the fresh water they need, but the desalination plants and the whole island run 100% with renewable energy.
- known 10y agoThank you, Israel; Please also amend https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_in_Israel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_in_Israel
- GirlsCanCode 10y ago@dang this is off topic
- bluejekyll 10y agoI don't see a lot of discussion around the brine. In previous reading brine will eventually create areas in seas where fish and other life starts dying off because of the extreme salt content. This article mentions the brine "is just pumped back into the Mediterranean", but don't they need to be concerned about killing fisheries?
- clsec 10y agoHere are a couple of reports on the marine impacts of desalination. Documents are in PDF form Key Issues in Seawater Desalination in California: Marine Impacts http://pacinst.org/app/uploads/2013/12/desal-marine-imapcts-full-report.pdf http://pacinst.org/app/uploads/2013/12/desal-marine-imapcts-... Desalination Plants: Potential impacts of brine discharge on marine life ftp://ftp.pcouncil.org/pub/Salmon%20EFH/338-Danoun_2007.pdf
- vessenes 10y agoThe article mentioned one installation was going to channel brine back to the dead sea, so if you've got a super salty body of water nearby, brine problem = solved!
- rshaban 10y agoFalse. The Dead Sea is already rapidly drying up due to climate change; pumping even more salt in will only hurt. http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-dying-of-the-dead-sea-70079351/?no-ist http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-dying-of-th...
- vessenes 10y agoThis is only true if the brine content being offloaded is greater than that of the Dead Sea now.
- dvirsky 10y ago> One of the driest countries on earth Average rainfall in Tel Aviv - 528mm/year, that's about 50mm less than Jerusalem - and London. Now, a lot of the country is a desert, but even Beersheba gets an average of 400mm. Only the far south is really dry. Not that Israel didn't need its desalination system, it might be the only good and/or competent thing our government has done in recent years, but it's not a very dry country in its inhabited areas.
- SixSigma 10y agoBut ... The Tampa Bay Desalination Plant produces 25 million gallons per day of drinking water to provide 10% of the region's needs. [1] Americas’ largest seawater desalination plant provides 50 million gallons (189 million liters) of drinking water for the San Diego area each day - 8% of needs [1] http://www.tampabaywater.org/tampa-bay-seawater-desalination-plant.aspx http://www.tampabaywater.org/tampa-bay-seawater-desalination... [2] http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2015/11/02/world/florida-flop-new-california-seawater-desalination-plant-seeks-slake-san-diegos-thirst/ http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2015/11/02/world/florida-fl...
- pauldprice 10y agoThis is a fantastic development. Tying the climate change and water shortage to civil unrest, regional war, immigration disaster, and world security problems is something the US presidential candidates are failing to understand or at least communicate effectively. This article was a hard read due to lack of editing. I hope they update it with fewer typos and cut and paste errors. Peer review people, at least.
- davidf18 10y agoWhile Israel does grow and export fruits and vegetables, it imports "water" in the form of grains and beef and other "red" meats. At least some of the beef is imported from Argentina. According to one source 1 ton of wheat is 216,000 gallons of water. Beef requires considerably more water per pound, at least 10 times as much and the documented source says much more. Beef and other red meats are also imported as a rule. Turkey and chicken, which require less water, are grown domestically. http://www.vegsource.com/articles/pimentel_water.htm http://www.vegsource.com/articles/pimentel_water.htm For many of the Middle Eastern countries with water shortages, importing grains and red meats to conserve on water seems like a good strategy. Also, technology from carbon nano-tubules may make the desalination if much cheaper. Couple this technology with ever-improving solar technology which is likely to be efficient in Israel's Negev Desert and this promises to be a water technology with no consumables.
- elcritch 10y agoIntriguing point. Though it'd seem very likely that the other comparison cities list (LA, Vegas) would also import pretty much all their grain and beef. Also, never saw many cattle grazing in Jordan or Israel. But there is a fair amount of grains grown in Eshcalon and by Lake of Galilee.
- davidf18 10y agoA metric ton (1.1 tons) of #1 Winter Wheat ranges from $140 to $160. Israeli desal water is about $0.52 cubic meter or 260 gallons. Using the 1 ton wheat is 216,000 gallons of water, it comes to about $430 per ton using the desalinated water. Thus, wheat imports water at $0.15 cents per cubic meter.
- baybal2 10y agoWe need nuclear desalination and district heating
- amluto 10y agoI used to think that desalination was very expensive, but: > Sorek can produce a thousand liters of drinking water for 58 cents. For comparison, the lowest marginal rate for water in a single-family residential unit in San Francisco costs $4.86/ccf or ~$1.72 per thousand liters. San Francisco has an excellent water supply, and they nonetheless charge about three times the cost of desalinated water in Israel. This obviously glosses over a bunch of things (cost of maintenance of the SF water system, the fact that SF charges quite a lot of money for the privilege of having a water meter, the capital cost of the desalination plant (I don't know whether that's amortized in the 58 cent figure)), but still, desalination isn't terribly expensive. I suspect the main issues blocking large-scale desalination in the US are: - Lead time. Desalination looks great during a drought, but it looks useless in wet years, and it takes longer than a typical drought to get it up and running. - Environmental impacts. You have to build the intake and brine discharge systems, and getting that through environmental review might be complicated. The first point could be addressed to some extent by running the plant even in surplus years and using it for groundwater recharge.
- radicaldreamer 10y agoMost water is used for agriculture, where the cost is much lower. Also, desalinated water isn't very good quality, in the mid-east, it's often not used for drinking or shampooing your hair.
- kragen 10y agoThere are some crucial details here I'm not understanding. The article says Israel needs (or needed?) 1.9Gm³/year (60 kiloliters per second, 60kℓ/s) of water, of which it got 1.5Gm³/year (48kℓ/s) from natural sources; but now (or when the plants opened?) it gets 127Mm³/year from the 2005 Ashkelon desal plant, 140Mm³/year from the 2009 Hadera desal plant, and 150Mm³/year from the new Sorek plant. These total 417Mm³/year (13kℓ/s), but the article says Israel's current total is 600Mm³/year (19kℓ/s) from desalination plants, which is more than 417. Also, it says, Israel now gets 55% of its domestic water from desalination. But 55% of 60kℓ/s is 33kℓ/s, which is 14kℓ/s more than the 19kℓ/s it says Israel gets from desalination. I suspect there's some confusing mixing of categories here leading to these numbers not adding up properly. The other really crucial questions are about capex and opex. How much do these plants cost to build, and how much do they cost to run? How much of that is the energy cost? They give the figure that the Sorek plant's reverse osmosis runs at 70 atmospheres (7.1 MPa; fucking Christ on a stick, why do people keep inventing new non-SI units?) which means that each liter of output water requires 7.1kJ of mechanical energy to force it through the membrane. There are presumably some other energy costs, but that may be the bulk of it. At US$100/MWh (US$28/GJ; fucking non-SI units again), which is a reasonable ballpark for the levelized cost of electrical energy, that's about 200 μUS$/ℓ or 200 US$/Mℓ. Irrigation water is commonly quoted in US$ per acre foot in the US; this is US$240 per acre foot, which would be a very competitive cost. But it says the cost is US$0.58/kℓ, which is 580 US$/Mℓ or US$715/acre foot, about three times the cost of the mechanical energy and high enough that many crops are uneconomical. It is crucial to understand where that extra cost is coming from. One of the comments on the Ensia version of the story claims that the new Carlsbad desal plant is selling its water for US$2000/acre foot. I don't know if that's true, but it's about 150% higher than the projected costs. Links, in case the Scientific American web site is lost: Original article: http://ensia.com/features/how-a-new-source-of-water-is-helping-reduce-conflict-in-the-middle-east http://ensia.com/features/how-a-new-source-of-water-is-helpi... Bar-Zeev et al.'s article about their bioflocculation anti-biofouling prefiltering apparatus: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/236137883_Bioflocculation_Chemical_free_pre-treatment_technology_for_the_desalination_industry https://www.researchgate.net/publication/236137883_Biofloccu... DOI: 10.1016/j.watres.2013.03.013 "Climate change in the Fertile Crescent and implications of the recent Syrian drought": http://www.pnas.org/content/112/11/3241.abstract http://www.pnas.org/content/112/11/3241.abstract doi: 10.1073/pnas.1421533112
- ShinySnivy91 10y agoDubai can't be making this situation any better.