20 ms·
I don't think it's right to equate R&D spending with "losses". Google makes a profit, not a loss, so technically it does not have losses. It has expenses, and a
by zaroth 10y ago
I don't think it's right to equate R&D spending with "losses". Google makes a profit, not a loss, so technically it does not have losses. It has expenses, and among those, investments in future technology.
If all Google could do with their cash flow was pay a dividend, that would be very sad, and it would call for a much lower P/E ratio. This article completely misstates the facts.
Perhaps the way they break out their financial statements is confusing to someone without an accounting degree. Just because "Other Bets" is negative, a growing negative number in this case is a good thing. This is showing Google has more free cash to invest in growth and has good ideas they believe in and want to pursue. I would be worried if instead they were stockpiling cash. You would then have to ask, why can't they put it to work effectively?
Of course, everything they do that is making money is no longer an "Other Bet" by definition.
- brador 10y agoThe question is can these moonshots pay off their expenses in the long run. Given how little Google is known to actually ship I question if they can.
- zaroth 10y agoIf the article was titled, 'Will Google's moonshots pay off'? With a list of the top projects and cumulative spending on each one. Some analysis on each of the markets and what their potential size could be in 2020. Who are the biggest competitors in the space? Now that would have been interesting to read!
- bitL 10y agoMoonshots are called that way because they bear both immense risk of failure as well as a potential to bring in billions. So individual moonshots are almost always failures; the ones that are successful pay the other ones. Google is doing the right thing to remain alive in the future without enforcing lock down on their users (like other companies not producing moonshots do).
- brador 10y agoThey're only good investments if they tap that well someday. If you sit around moonshotting all day and never shipping they're worth $0. So far, no moonshot by a big corp has paid off. Maybe it's too early, or more likely Google is hoarding tech and filing patents like a rational engineer running a business using machine learning would do, and while that's good for Google it's bad for Society to have so much cool tech locked away in a damp basement when it could be changing lives and being iterated on.
- redthrowaway 10y agoSelf-driving cars look poised to pay off in a big way in the next 5-10 years.
- mike_hearn 10y agoNo moonshot by a big corp has paid off? I used to work at Google. I remember the term "moonshot" being thrown around, it started with Larry and Sergey. If there's a definition for what this means, in the Google context, it's in their heads and nowhere else. But the way I interpreted it was "really really ambitious project". One thing I do remember is that several projects that were described at the time as moonshots did pay off. The one that comes to my mind immediately was Street View. The idea of driving a car with a spherical camera down every road in the world seemed completely insane at the time it was first proposed, the idea it might make money even moreso. But Street View worked, and whenever we switched on SV in a new country usage of Maps in that country permanently increased. It really increased the value of the product, and in turn I guess it also raised ad revenues (or it'd be odd if increased usage didn't correlate with increased ad revenue at all). There were others I remember. Rewriting the web search indexing system more or less from scratch was a big one. You don't hear much about that, but it was a big risky effort to rewrite the core of your product from scratch. I think people tend to take past successes of radically ambitious projects for granted. Android was a moonshot at the time. We don't think anything of it now, but it wasn't clear at all it'd be so successful.
- ktRolster 10y ago>I don't think it's right to equate R&D spending with "losses" Especially since they are still working on them. Can't really call them a loss if it turns into billions in the next few years. Better to say "Alphabet spent $859M on...."
- taneq 10y agoMaybe even "Alphabet invested $859M..."
- AnAfrican 10y agoIn some contexts, not all Spending is Investment even if it can be defined as investment in layman terms.
- Mtinie 10y agoCan you provide an example? I would not consider reasonable overhead costs to be "investment" dollars, but you may have something else in mind.
- nibs 10y agoSpent: verb, to spend, you could spend money settling a lawsuit but it would be a stretch to call that investment. Investment: to allocate money in the expectation of future benefit, so that could mean administrative expenses, which would cover and include a lot (but not all) spending. My vote would be on invested.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoIt's all about the perspective. A manager might consider test-driven development or security-driven development a matter of "spending" - in that it costs time and money and doesn't provide an immediate tangible benefit compared to making the thing that makes the money - but the engineers see it as an investment. Both sides are right. If the company is never hacked, then it could both validate the security model as well as give a reason why not to bother in the first place. If the software runs smoothly throughout development (give or take a bug here and there), then all that testing was indeed a waste of time. The difference between investment and cost is the ability to look into the future and analyze the past. So there really isn't a straight answer. EDIT: it also matters to the perspective of those outside of the organization. A bullish analyst might call Alphabet's moonshot projects an investment, while a bear would likely label them a cost.
- jahnu 10y agoPlaying devil's advocate here (a little) but imagine they took a few dozen million of that and, say, improved their development tool chains for Android (which are disappointingly flaky). Or another few dozen millions and extended the security updates for Nexus phones by a couple of years. That could grow their market share of both developer mind-share and consumers. Moonshots maybe should come once you've mastered all your core products?
- Normal_gaussian 10y ago> Moonshots maybe should come once you've mastered all your core products? Then they'll never come.
- bachback 10y agoyes, absolutely. they do have 75B$ in cash and another 60B$ in short-term investments. So they have 135B$ to spend. judged by that number Google is too conservative.
- adventured 10y agoThat's incorrect. They have $75 billion in total 'cash.' $15 billion is listed as cash and $60 billion is listed as short-term investments (as of Q1 2016). http://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GOOGL/financials?p=GOOGL http://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GOOGL/financials?p=GOOGL
- bachback 10y agoright, thanks. 90B$ in current assets and 150B$ in total book value.
- maxerickson 10y agoThere's a long history of using terms like loss to describe such segmented financial results. It's also typical to talk about them on an operating basis. A vaguely topical example would be Xbox. Microsoft (and the press) reported losses on it for years, years were it would be reasonable to say they were investing in building up the division.
- drawkbox 10y agoI agree the market has a hard time justifying R&D and that is a problem. That is why small companies/startups can disrupt and innovate faster. Another way is like Amazon, they just spend all the profit back on R&D and prevent much of this profit/growth talk, it stays focused on competition and future goals. They are in a constant state of R&D by reinvesting profit. Spending on R&D should be seen as good in a tech world where you must stay ahead, not as losses. If you are a big tech company and not spending on R&D, expect that to be short-lived.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoSpending on R&D should be seen as good if it generates useful results and eventually turns into a revenue stream - no matter how indirectly. Amazon is great at this kind of R&D, because Bezos seems to spend all of his free cycles asking himself if there's something else Amazon can do to make money. So Amazon R&D is primarily return-led. No one else works quite like that. Google seems to have thrown a lot of money at R&D, but it's not obvious how much of a return it's going to generate. Apple and MS are in the same boat. MS does very cool research, but mostly lacks the management to turn the research into viable products. There's a huge disconnect between the products MS could be shipping, and the products MS is shipping. Apple has been spending more on R&D, but seems to be marketing and image-led - possibly based on the assumption that's how Jobs worked. (He didn't.) Alphabet R&D seems engineering-led - which is great for engineers, but isn't a famously effective way to find new customers and generate more income.
- melling 10y agoCompany X invests billions into the "future". This continues for 5-10 years without results turning into profitable products or direct improvements. Shareholders begin to question the value of those investments. "Is the R&D being well spent?" Google hasn't turned any moonshot into a profitable product yet, right? They're going to need a winner or two to convince investors. Apple will be in the same position in a few years because they are ramping up R&D.
- eru 10y agoDoesn't matter too much what Google/Alphabet shareholders think. The controlling majority is with the founders, and the company is not going to the markets anytime soon to ask for more capital.
- melling 10y ago"any time soon" What exactly does that mean? The next two years? If people start dumping your stock, I'm sure there will be repercussions.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoWell, to be fair, people probably won't be dumping their stock over this news.
- melling 10y agoTo be really fair, I didn't say they would. I was addressing the long-term impact of spending large sums of money without any clear benefit. People are usually content while a company is growing fast enough.
- eru 10y agoWhat kind of repercussions? Please elaborate. The only result of a lower stock price that I can see is that Google employees might demand cash instead of stock for compensation. (But Google still does make enough in cash.) And by 'demand' I mean: get unhappy, be more likely to leave, and for new hires, be more likely to take up alternative offers instead.
- whack 10y agoGenuine question: Has Google ever achieved financial success with a moonshot project? Google Glass seems to have come closest to becoming an actual product, but it eventually crashed and burned as well. The self-driving car was a great technological success, but I really wonder how Google plans to monetize it. Years ago, when Google was the only major company doing self-driving-cars, there was a lot of buzz and potential. But they didn't seem to capitalize on that in any way. Now that Tesla and every other major car company has achieved near-parity, I really wonder what Google's end-game is for self-driving cars. In general, a lot of these moonshot projects sound so zany, that I wonder if the division will ever recoup its investment.
- Retric 10y agoIn terms of internal projects gmail, and local maps comes to mind. If your going to call everything that did not work a moonshot then by definition no. However, it's only a failure when they give up so self driving cars are rather undecided at this point, and theses projects help recruiting which has non obvious benefit.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoThe important question is whether something was designated a "moonshot" before it succeeded or failed, thus giving us an unbiased sample.
- zaroth 10y agoI think moonshot, by definition, means 15+ year timeframe to full realization. Google is a very young company, they just haven't had piles of cash to invest in moonshots for long enough for us to have seen the results. X was founded just 6 years ago, Alphabet was founded just last year! To be asking 6 years in where are all the moonshot successes already? I think this demonstrates exactly how problematic and pervasive short-term thinking is. The question to ask is in 50 years, how many different $10B+ revenue streams will Alphabet have? If we really think this R&D isn't going to pay off, at the scale Alphabet operates, that's almost like losing faith in humanity.
- t3f 10y agoI agree with where you're going. If you're not familiar with the DoD/Govt Lab TRL Model [1], that is how I mental model this type of "Other Bets" and similar group work. Catapulting a TRL1-3 concept to product is certainly a moonshot, _but_ they cant afford to take a long comfortable stance to incubate all ideas over an indefinite period of time. The beauty of trying to fund/productize TRL1-3 Moonshots is so many great bits and nuggets fall out of it during the course of maturation that you get to reiterate on. In my view you are right that they are thinking long term, that they have a positive P/E and still are funding Moonshots along with the safer higher TRL items is encouraging for their investors, that's good long term planning. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technology_readiness_level https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technology_readiness_level :edit: Formatting
- jeffreyrogers 10y agoCapital can still be poorly allocated even if it goes to R&D. If investors think that that capital would be better allocated by being returned to them through dividends then it should be. This may or may not be the case, but just saying that it's R&D so more spending is good is the wrong way to look at it.
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoGoogle's core business (search-powered ads) is at this point a cash cow that does not require R&D investment at a $1B/pa level, so it's not fair to label these as investments either. That was the whole reason behind the creation of Alphabet - now investors can see that Google is acting as a VC that's being powered by its ad earnings, and they can judge how successful Google is as a VC. (So far, not very successful.)
- anjc 10y agoIt's an accounting loss. Their revenue is less than their costs. Nobody gauges the state of a company by just looking at one line on an income statement though.
- outworlder 10y ago> I don't think it's right to equate R&D spending with "losses". I was baffled by that. Is this just because they called it "Other Bets" instead of plain old boring R&D? If anything, that would make me want to buy Alphabet stock. We need more companies willing to invest on "moonshots", as the article calls it. We need to get back to the Xerox PARC times.
- Amygaz 10y agoThat story was written by someone at AP covering the tech industry. He has consistently showed terrible analytical acumen and reporting of major and minor events. http://bigstory.ap.org/content/michael-liedtke http://bigstory.ap.org/content/michael-liedtke