17 ms·
What Marissa Mayer Brought to Yahoo That Can’t Be Bought or Sold
- dudul 10y agoDo Yahoo employees really call themselves "Yahoos"?
- a_small_island 10y agoNo different than calling yourself a Googler.
- anonymfus 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yahoo_(Gulliver%27s_Travels) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yahoo_(Gulliver%27s_Travels)
- bitwize 10y agoWhich itself has silly variants, like Noogler gor new employees or Doogler for dogs. (Google is, explicitly, a dog company. Dogs are welcome at Google facilities. Cats are officially strongly deprecated.)
- Practicality 10y agoInteresting given the number of cat videos this "dog" company distributes. ;)
- RileyKyeden 10y agoThey're cats. They have to feel they're unwelcome before they want to be there.
- Practicality 10y agoAt one point they were yahooligans. I suppose that term fell out of favor at some point.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI remember Yahoo having a kids' section, and the members being called Yahooligans.
- Practicality 10y agoThat probably put off the adults from wanting to be called that :)
- toast0 10y agoYes, when I was there (2004-2011), my job title was Technical Yahoo!, but nowadays they've lost the punctuation. The security team was called the Paranoids. Lots of little goofy names.
- racl101 10y agoAt Apple Steve just called everybody except for his key people 'idiot'.
- boterock 10y agoI have to admit that when she started in Yahoo, they tried to do their best to not suck that much, but I think it was too late. In a time where internet and word of mouth can punish very hard bad PR/bad UX, they tried with Tumblr showing they weren't going to screw up anymore, but still they couldn't go back to what they were before.
- soperj 10y agoand yet, Craigslist.
- mgkimsal 10y agodo you mean the UX on craigslist is bad? i find it to be fantastic. could be better on mobile screens, i'll grant, but it all still works, and is fast enough for what I need.
- burkaman 10y agoYeah, Marissa Mayer is how I was first introduced to the concept of the glass cliff: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass_cliff https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass_cliff. I don't think she ever had a chance.
- jazzyk 10y agoShe was consoled with ~$200M for not having had a chance.
- seanalltogether 10y agoThis explains the seemingly easy path Theresa May had to becoming Prime Minister following the Brexit vote.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- burkaman 10y ago
- wehadfun 10y agoOff topic but what would the selling price for Yahoo have to be for MM to be considered a success? 20B, 100B,..
- dudul 10y ago[ignore: Didn't they get an offer from Microsoft a few years ago for 125B or something?] I think what makes it a huge failure is that 5B is basically what they spent just to acquire one company. Edit: Based on the replies the first part of my comment is inaccurate.
- yesplorer 10y agoNo. The $125b was the valuation during the 1990s. Microsoft offered way less - $44b.
- dudul 10y agoOK, my bad, I got confused with the numbers :)
- akkartik 10y agoThe Microsoft offer was for $45B: http://news.microsoft.com/2008/02/01/microsoft-proposes-acquisition-of-yahoo-for-31-per-share http://news.microsoft.com/2008/02/01/microsoft-proposes-acqu... The market cap of Yahoo was still around half that when Mayer was appointed. But that was all from their stake in Alibaba, which has already been spun off. The rest of Yahoo had a negative value, I think. So it's gone from 0 (conservatively) to $5B.
- scholia 10y agoSuccess would have been growing revenues, instead of watching them decline. Success would have been at least one really successful mobile app. Success would have been not selling Yahoo....
- stinkytaco 10y ago
- pboutros 10y agoThat's a good read. Just goes to show that it's important to remember people's humanity, especially when all the cards are stacked against them. People have said some really ugly stuff about MM.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mankash666 10y agoYes- it's important to stay human while thousands of employees get laid off and the CEO makes a few hundred million for the valiant effort of letting good employees go
- pboutros 10y agoThat's exactly the sort of situation I'm referring to.
- scient 10y ago"Good" tends to be very subjective. Actually good people rarely get let go, unless there is a very good reason. At the same time almost everyone who gets laid off thinks they are a very good employee, which obviously is not the case. And execs get paid for the expectations and responsibility. You are just being salty right now.
- bisby 10y agoSometimes the reason doesn't need to be "good" in the sense that it's a great reason, but in the sense that it was the right decision. I worked as a engineer at a huge billion dollar company in a newly created slot. There was 2 on the team and I was the third. Then massive layoffs. Thousands of people let go. I was one of them. Was I "good people" ? I don't know. I like to think I was, that's why I got the position. Of the 3 people on the team, I was the right choice though, least experience with the company's infrastructure, etc. The real issue at hand was the disconnect between the team manager (who found out he had to let me go the morning it happened and was quite upset about it) and upper executives. Why was adding my position approved by upper executives in the first place if they knew that a month later they would be laying off so many, you would think they would have had a massive layoff of that size in the works for more than just a few days. So there was no "good reason" other than "cutting cost" but if someone had to be let go, the 2 others on the team deserved the job more than me.
- bitL 10y agoSorry, so she raised comfort of some employees (which developer "on a mission to save a company" really needs free food instead of interesting challenges?) and decreased the ability to hire top talent by introducing other employee-unfriendly policies like banning remote work, i.e. working while living on Hawaii, giving superb motivation to stay at Yahoo and see it prosper. The rest seems more like a COO would do and not a strategic CEO. It is still fact that a little team of 5 can accomplish huge things, yet they weren't able to recruit any, while blowing insane money on useless acquihires. And also looking at technical decisions like replacing Netty with node.js in their infrastructure and resulting 4x slowdown and probably increasing operating costs reeks of following useless fads and really useless management.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoI may get downvoted for saying this since it's not fashionable to say things like this but I will anyway: When a company is going down, the type of people you need is people who are enthusiastic and team players. The last type of people you need are competent yet not so much of a team player. It's because: 1. Pampering these people will only result in lowering rest of the team's morale. 2. When a company is going down, a 10x or 100x or even 1000x developer (whatever that means) won't be able to save the company alone. In a sense I think she was trying to filter out people who were not "all-in", because that's what it takes for a sinking ship to have even 1% chance of coming back up.
- bitL 10y agoI believe what you actually need is to hire 2-3 teams of 10x developers/artists including a few visionaires and let them figure out projects that might one day become cash cows keeping company afloat (and give them massive stake in success). You need to both expose them to problems of the company so that they feel pressure as well as completely isolate them from toxic culture that brought down your company, so that they can give an all-out effort. Imagine if that lone guy at Microsoft didn't figure out trick with 286 protected mode that allowed Windows to survive and wasn't heard by top management - we would all be running OS/2 10 now.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>the company was also stacked with some of the least motivated. Every company has unmotivated people for the CEO to deal with. Yahoo is not unique in this regard.
- zekevermillion 10y agoFrom a non-insider perspective, it certainly looks as if MM accomplished the mission. Stock price went up, and she locked it in with a well-timed sale. Her compensation package appears to have been designed to produce exactly this outcome. It's not Steve Jobs' return to Apple. But she did help the investors salvage a respectable outcome.
- gaius 10y agoIt would have anyway - its the management at BABA you can thank for that...
- frozenport 10y agoHad they sold earlier during her tenure the company could have easily gone for twice as much.
- collyw 10y agoWas it down to luck more than anything else? She made a few bets. Most failed. One did spectacularly , yet seems to have very little to do with Yahoo as a company.
- zekevermillion 10y agoShe inherited a depreciating asset in core yahoo, managed to hold the line on further losses. She is also managing a "strategic transaction" that could go very wrong if done poorly. I would guess that (if successful) this deal will be thought of as a success, and probably comes as a relief to the board and officers. But again, I only know what I read on the Internet which surely is missing some important facts.
- GuiA 10y ago"if I’m ever in a position like Marissa’s, I want to be the kind of CEO who answers emails from strangers six or seven levels down from herself at 1 AM on a Sunday morning, even when she has a new baby in the house." I'm grateful for this article reminding me why I never really will fit in with the techie fanatics. Yesterday I went home at 5p, after a very productive day, and trimmed plants in my garden, not checking my work email until the next day. (Well maybe for $200M over 5 years you could convince me to do that. But then it's back to books and gardening and developing pictures) Also oddly reminiscent of this post from yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12168718 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12168718
- deelowe 10y agoIt really sucks when your manager thinks this kind of work ethic is healthy.
- GuiA 10y agoYes. I am very lucky to have a manager that will frequently tell me to just leave if I stay too long after 6p, and actively encourages me to do less work (which I find quite frustrating - I feel like I'm already not doing that much!). I work at a very profitable, well known company FWIW, in a fairly core role with plenty of people depending on my productivity.
- exelius 10y agoIn general, people aren't productive working more than 10 hours a day. Unfortunately, some people are -- and those people very often find themselves in executive positions, surrounded by other people with exceptional stamina who wonder why everyone below them is so lazy. Fortunately, a lot of companies have realized this and started making employee retention a metric (because recruiting is expensive, especially for tech positions.) Keeping people happy is still important.
- Kluny 10y agoCoding is different from normal work though, isn't it? I mean, if I have 3 hours of data entry ahead of me, I get in the zone almost instantly and crack through it at high speed with little difficulty, take lunch, then go on to the next thing. I've never had 3 hours worth of emails or administrative work to do, but I imagine it to be the same. 3 hours of solid code, on the other hand, takes a special day of the office being unusually quiet, at least half an hour to get in the zone, and at the end of it, I'm done for the day. It's not just my own arrogance, is it, to say that "code" work and "admin" work are two completely different categories that ought to be evaluated differently?
- bastijn 10y agoGreat story, thanks for the different perspective on things. I did giggle at the title here on HN though. "... That cannot be bought." I guess MM, being an acquired CEO could be considered bought. It just didn't give the result they wanted..
- ucaetano 10y agoI remember that is was usually claimed that Yahoo's valuation (net of Alibaba's stake) was either zero or negative. She was able to sell it for $5B. That sounds like an amazing success story.
- CptJamesCook 10y agoIt turned out that after taxes and other factors, Yahoo's core value was worth more. I doubt she had a significant effect on it, other than the ~700 mil loss they took on Tumblr.
- 1024core 10y agoHeh, I remember Jelena from discussion on devel-random. I would like to correct (mildly) a couple of anecdotes in her article, because I was there and closer. > A friend relayed this story: The Sunnyvale campus had a building with redundant turnstiles, which required a badge scan seconds after employees had scanned their badges to open the main doors. People complained about it when the building was remodeled years before, and kept complaining through several CEOs. After Marissa read an email griping about the turnstiles, they were gone the next day. I remember it a little differently. This was Building D, where the executives sit. Before Marissa got there, there were plans to put an additional set of card-activated turnstiles inside the door. (This building is also where the Yahoo store is, and the main reception desk). Yahoo was plagued with leaks, and some people thought that adding an additional turnstile will keep people from tailgating in. When Marissa got there, she took one look at the turnstiles and said, "this is stupid", and ordered them removed. Not only that: there were card-activated gates in the parking lots, and those were gone too immediately. She didn't want barriers to coming in to work. And about devel-random, or "d-r": I was pretty active on that. No one told Marissa about d-r, but just a couple of days after she got there, on a Saturday IIRC, she responded to someone on d-r. This sent shockwaves throughout the upper echelons, and soon senior management were clamoring to get on d-r. Most of them dropped out, exhausted by the volume; but she stuck around. Also: she used to use pine(1) to read her emails. That increased her stature in my eyes, and those of quite a few other engineers. It's the small things that mattered a lot to the battered egos at Yahoo; and Marissa did a lot of good. She was the best CEO of all the ones Yahoo had seen, bar none (OK, I wasn't around during Koogle's tenure).
- robertcorey 10y agoWere you able to post to d-r anonymously?
- 1024core 10y agoNo. It's an internal list. But you were free to express yourself without almost any restrictions, modulo the usual workplace norms.
- 0xmohit 10y ago
- Lagged2Death 10y agoI'm no biz-geek, I probably can't name a dozen CEOs. But for years, MM's name was called put in every critical mainstream headline about Yahoo, of which there were many. I do not believe that's an accident. I do not believe a man would have been treated the same way.
- 1024core 10y ago> I do not believe a man would have been treated the same way. This. Larry Ellison fucks around on a sailboat. Larry is busy with "X" for years. And no one bats an eye.
- smacktoward 10y agoOracle and Google both make astonishing amounts of money. Nobody (least of all shareholders) is marching on their headquarters with torches and pitchforks. So nobody cares what the leaders of those companies do with their time -- so long as their companies continue to make astonishing amounts of money. If the money dries up, rest assured that the line of people demanding that the leaders start paying attention to the business would rapidly become quite long.
- dexterdog 10y agoExactly. Ellison seen on a mega boat tells you how well he is doing and thus the company. MM answering low-level employee emails in the middle of the night says she doesn't know what's going on.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> This. Larry Ellison fucks around on a sailboat. Larry is busy with "X" for years. And no one bats an eye. If Oracle's valuation was less than the combined valuation of holdings it owned in other companies such that its core business had an apparent negative valuation, there'd probably be more negative attention to Larry's extracurricular activities. When you are seen to be succeeding, no one questions your methods -- success implicitly validates them. That's not about sex or gender, its about apparent success.
- colmvp 10y agoWhile her great experiences illustrate a caring and hard-working person, I still can't forget writeups describing someone who was unable to develop a product strategy / roadmap in a timely manner, resulting in a lot of miscommunication and execs left in limbo (see the Forbes article written in early 2015). There's no doubt that it was extremely hard to turn that ship around, so I'm not at all attributing the company's failure to her. But as a product person, at the end of the day, my best experiences with CEOs has never been about whether they've rejuvenated a certain company culture but rather their ability to help provide vision and strategy (among other things). Furthermore: > But I know that, if I’m ever in a position like Marissa’s, I want to be the kind of CEO who answers emails from strangers six or seven levels down from herself at 1 AM on a Sunday morning, even when she has a new baby in the house. I want to be the kind of person who has time to hear people out, even when they’re saying things that hurt me. Honestly, I'm happy when my CEO answers e-mails at reasonable hours and has work/life balance (as much as a CEO can get).
- tlogan 10y ago> Yahoo is a Failure, but Marissa is a Success I have to be living in some alternate universe. Because in my universe, if you do not accomplish the goal (revenue grow) you failed. It could that the goal was too hard to achieve, maybe the goal was impossible to achieve, etc. But, at end of the day, she failed. And as result of her failure people will lose their jobs :(
- mkagenius 10y ago> And as result of her failure people will lose their jobs They will most probably get jobs again like they did earlier. Life is full of ups and down, you can blame one person for that..but try not to.
- pfarnsworth 10y agoShe gets paid $50M/yr for the sole purpose of being held to blame and credit for everything that happens.
- bdavisx 10y agoHer performance ranking program was so badly implemented by Yahoo’s ugly layers of middle management that it deserved every bit of the mocking and criticism it got, both on devel-random and in the tech press. I think one thing that could possibly "save" Yahoo would be to fire every single middle manager and above immediately (and probably most of the 1st line management as well), and then rebuild the management from the ground up. Yes, Yahoo would be a mess for a year or more, but it already is a mess and has been for years - and it seems like a common thread is the entrenched management that isn't willing to change and has a lot of incompetency. Time to throw out the baby with the bath water.
- jessaustin 10y agoHaha it would be great to see a troubled company try that. One suspects that we'd hear it more than see it however, as the great wailing and gnashing of teeth by PHBs would be audible on other continents. It would have to be a completely vendor-driven company, however... er, excuse me, "a company that concentrated on its core competencies". After all, the paychecks still have to go out, for the peons left after the great firing, and you can't just give the bank accounts to some random person.
- jelenaw 10y agoI've actually said exactly this several times including in a convo with an exec-level ex-Yahoo last night. I don't think it's ever really been possible even for Marissa - the company is public and if you fire thousands of people you are likely to scare the board and shareholders. But I can't think of a middle manager I knew at Yahoo who deserved to stay.
- smacktoward 10y agoThere's a simple reason why you'll never see this strategy attempted: who decides which people get fired? Middle management and above.
- lintiness 10y ago$200M for handing out free lunch, a self-esteem boost, a poorly implemented personnel ranking scheme, and a few emails at weird hours ... sounds like a pretty sweet deal. sign me up!
- scient 10y agoSalty about never making a management role, eh?
- lintiness 10y agodidn't read the article, eh?
- bbcbasic 10y agoYou could use this same argument for any CEO. Pick 3 things then say $X m for a b and c that's a pretty sweet deal. Sign me up.
- lintiness 10y agoanother non-reader. i picked out the main points the writer specified.
- bbcbasic 10y agoI read it. My point is you can make the same class of argument - pick one or two trivial achievements and a fuckup for almost any CEO or indeed professional and make it sound like their job is easy.
- 1024core 10y agoIt makes me angry and sad to see all the sniping about her $200M (or thereabouts) earnings over 4 years. The spotlight has always been on her, and her failings are magnified beyond reason. Is it because she's young woman and pretty? I was at Yahoo from 2004 through 2015. I saw some seriously stupid CEOs. One of them being Terry Semel. He made more than $200M in just one year (and even more, according to rumors). Here's an article from around that time; I wish I had time to dig up more: https://3qdigital.com/analytics/terry-semel-you-owe-1000-yahoo-employees-200-million/ https://3qdigital.com/analytics/terry-semel-you-owe-1000-yah... But you never hear his name ever brought up. Because he was a white, male CEO?
- Spooky23 10y agoHe also didn't invest a lot of time and energy on self-promoting PR. You knew who he was, but nobody else did. Meyer did and has for years. She wants this attention as part of a broader personal branding effort. Everyone knows that Yahoo was a dead man walking, and the details of her tenure will be forgotten quickly -- but lots of people know who she is. Anyone who watches CNBC knows who she is, and many other people do as well with the corporate nursery stories, stories about her being a woman, etc. Good for her.
- rhizome 10y agoWasn't Yahoo essentially unsellable when she took over? Tying the company's future to her personally may have been pretty much the only way they could disturb investor sentiment and inertia.
- _yosefk 10y agoBallmer is white & male (well, like Semel, probably not white enough for white supremacists, but apparently white enough for the purposes of this discussion), MS market cap didn't shrink under his tenure, but he gets a lot of criticism for missing growth opportunities that others capitalized on. Why is he criticized more than Terry Semel? I dunno, probably 'cause nobody cares about Semel any more?
- 10y ago
- the_improbable 10y agoI was a Yahoo for a couple of years before getting caught up in the recent layoffs. When I talk about my time there, I use the term "organizational inertia". It's amazing how people will fight for products, methodologies, and workflows that are clearly not going to be feasible if the company is going to survive. A company that's been around for as long as Yahoo has, and has locked in to a certain way of doing things, is hard to turn around no matter how good the CEO is.
- ecmermaid 10y agoAlways several sides to any story - super appreciated this one. Whether Marissa failed or not - this piece was well written and worth the read.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- urmish 10y ago> Yahoo may be a failure but Marissa was a success This is low tier bait. I am convinced the author is trying to ruse anyone who reads his garbage post.
- mdip 10y agoInteresting discussion and I wanted to call out a particular part: The CEO's willingness and constancy in responding to employees. I worked at Global Crossing during the entire time that John Legere (of T-Mobile fame) was CEO and he had a very similar policy, though I can't say for sure he didn't fire folks for writing him things he didn't like[0]. He swore up and down that he reads every message sent to him and that employees are always welcome to write him. I did so in the later evening on Christmas Eve (I'll admit I had a few beers in me) about some finishing touches I was putting on an application we were deploying to production the following week. I received a reply just after midnight on Christmas, clearly sent from a Blackberry. I can't remember the contents (it was something along the lines of "nice work") but I remember feeling quite good that the CEO was willing to take some time to reply to me on a holiday at a very odd hour. As "employee engagement" goes, this certainly improved mine. [0] I honestly don't know. Global Crossing had a total of "zero" good years in that every six months or so another 10% of the staff would be let go. Did some of that originate from a bad message sent to the CEO? No idea, but they were looking for reasons to get rid of anyone they could throughout my tenure. Though I'd written him a few times, I'd written him a few times but never in a manner that would have had cause to get me fired.
- fragola 10y agoIMO Yahoo was just unfortunately not salvageable and MM gets a lot of criticism from a lot of directions (I've seen a lot of articles by women criticizing her for not taking "enough" maternity leave, for example). I feel like she's just a favorite target. http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/09/03/marissa-mayer-s-two-week-maternity-leave-is-bullsh-t.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/09/03/marissa-may...
- jelenaw 10y agoThanks for all the great discussion here & thank you Jess for submitting my article to HN. (In case anyone is curious, Medium currently credits this post with 13,362 views on my Medium post.) I have another HN account--sadly underutilized, I have to admit--but didn't want to tie it to my real name, so here's a brand new baby account for this thread... I'm glad to see a few comments here from other ex-Yahoos who felt the same thrill I did when Marissa came to Yahoo. It really was like night and day. I've seen a lot of discussion here, on Twitter and on Medium critiquing the way I responded to Marissa's late-night email habits. For a lot of people it seems late emails from an executive are a negative and demonstrates an expectation that others also be on email at 1 AM. I was surprised by that because I've always really enjoyed working for workaholic/fanatic CEOs, but I understand because I've also encountered some toxic personalities who do use late night email runs to demonstrate that they're "working harder" than everyone else (when in reality they're only putting more work into playing the game, not into deliverables). Because that was never remotely the case with Marissa, I didn't even think about it while writing. With Marissa, hearing from her late at night sent the message "I'm always thinking about what you need from me," not, "I'm always thinking about what you should be doing FOR me." Of course, I'm a little bit of an unhealthy fanatic workaholic type myself, which is definitely part of why Marissa is such a powerful role model for me. She doesn't pretend that her sleeplessness or fanaticism is the most healthy or balanced way to live, and she doesn't advise others to be exactly like her. She just demonstrates that being naturally that sort of person is survivable and is compatible with having love and happiness in your life. That alone was huge for me. If I can be who I authentically am and survive it and have people around me who love me anyway, even if I shorten my life and don't necessarily have human relationships that are AS fulfilling as a Type B personality might be able to have, I'm ok with that outcome.
- draw_down 10y agoI guess I don't think it's particularly good that she was an email junkie, to the point of being on email a couple hours after giving birth? But beside that I can understand why some took her as an inspirational figure.
- uvince 10y ago"on a Saturday IIRC, she responded to someone on d-r. This sent shockwaves throughout the upper echelons, and soon senior management were clamoring to get on d-r." So, basically Marissa ruined devel-random, too? Nice. Is there anything Marissa can't do?
- caycep 10y agoThe problem with this is: this means MM is a very good executive regarding technical details, daily operations and the like. However, she wasn't hired to be HR or COO. She was hired to be CEO, in a company that faced deep existential challenges in a market that was rapidly making its products irrelevant. When she took over, I wasn't sure what value Yahoo really provided other than a "yet another portal and email provider" type of thing, far from being a peer of FB and Google that it aspired to be. The company needed to execute a pivot of epic proportions and in this, we have heard very little. And maybe there were some projects in their skunk works that may yet get written about, which never saw the light of day. Morale of the troops? great. Making employees' lives better? great. But it doesn't mean squat if your company still doesn't have a viable product at the end of the day...