3 ms·
If I created a business sending unsolicited snail mail to your address, and you asked me to stop using a cease and desist letter, should I comply, and allow you
by chii 10y ago
If I created a business sending unsolicited snail mail to your address, and you asked me to stop using a cease and desist letter, should I comply, and allow you to destroy my business model?
- 1123581321 10y agoI don't understand this analogy. Do most people have the legal ability to prevent letter-sending without working with the Post Office? Did the company have many other sources of revenue besides Facebook?
- DanBC 10y agoIn Europe you can't send me unsolicited marketing mail if I've withdrawn permission. (In most cases you need my explicit opt-in confirmation that I want your junk mail before you send it to me).
- adventured 10y ago> In Europe Is there some kind of Europe-wide agreement on unsolicited marketing mail that covers every country?
- lmm 10y agoThere are EU data protection directives that have that effect. (Saying "Europe" to mean "the EU" is technically "wrong" in the same sense as saying "America" to mean "the USA", but it's common enough to be widely understood. Language is a tool for communication)
- grkvlt 10y agoYes, if your business model revolves only and completely around sending these unsolicited pieces of mail to my address, I think there would be no problem in getting a court to uphold the cease-and-desist letter, thus destroying your business. Quite how your business was going to produce revenue just sending mail to one person is a mystery though, anyway...
- DanielDent 10y agoIn the US, people have the right to decide a sender may no longer send them snail mail if the sender has sent them obscene materials. It's my understanding that case laws has led to obscenity in this context being 100% as defined by the recipient. If you believe content type X is obscene, and someone sends you content type X, you can follow the procedure for reporting obscenity. They are obligated to stop sending you anything.
- dudifordMann 10y agobut in this case, the users, through the Power website, did give permission to receive, or send, the "snail mail". From the article "Power users also authorized the software to send Facebook messages to other Facebook users for them" So in your analogy. I created a business of sending snail mail to addresses I already had in my possession on my list of contacts. My contacts might not appreciate my snail mail, but I am not sending snail mail to the Facebook corporate Office -Or- if I am sending to the Facebook Corporate Office, then only though its mail routing department, which was set up to handle these very packages. The C&D, I think, is equivalent to preventing contacts from communicating with each other, or, Postal Censorship[1], which I suppose is more a policy issue than a legal one. Which I suppose extends FB to be a governing body, which I guess leads us to CFAA... [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postal_censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postal_censorship