17 ms·
What If There Just Aren’t Enough Jobs to Go Around?
- arcanus 10y agoThe TL;DR: "A new paper says the problem is not supply. It’s that firms just don’t have enough demand for labor." Here is a press release from the folks who authored the study: http://rooseveltinstitute.org/demand_side_dynamism/ http://rooseveltinstitute.org/demand_side_dynamism/ And here is the paper (warning: pdf): http://rooseveltinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Declining-Entrepreneurship-Labor-Mobility-and-Business-Dynamism-A-Demand-Side-Approach.pdf http://rooseveltinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Dec...
- tylerkahn 10y agoThank you!
- criley2 10y agoIs the "infinite work hypothesis" finally ending?? The answer to "what happens to workers being replaced" has always been "they'll find jobs elsewhere, every time you make a job redundant you create other new jobs", what I've seen called the "infinite work hypothesis" where there will always be new work and the problem is agility, job training, not demand.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoNo, the problem is misallocation of labor. There's a huge to-do list of jobs that need to be done at almost every level, from design and build of significant infrastructure in most countries around the world, to community-level support work. It would be perfectly possible to retrain the long term unemployed for all but the most difficult design and management elements. They're not done because the metrics of Wall St deem them "not profitable" - which means traders can't make quick gains out of them. Allocating labor on the basis of whether or not traders and stock owners can profit in the short to medium term turns out to be an unintelligent way to strategise an economy.
- forgotpwtomain 10y ago> Allocating labor on the basis of whether or not traders and stock owners can profit in the short to medium term turns out to be an unintelligent way to strategise an economy. And yet, this turns out to be the most succesful strategy civilization has used so far.
- mordocai 10y agoI don't know if the data is there to make that claim.
- merpnderp 10y agoJust the Chinese and Indian cases seem more than enough data to make this case. Both economies stagnate behind the world trend until they open up free markets, at which point their economies explode and a billion people are lifted out of abject poverty nearly overnight. There is an arguable case for strong welfare states, but true socialism has literal mountains of evidence against it.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoChina and India are heavily state-managed and in no sense are they genuine laissez-faire free markets. China still thinks of itself as Communist. True socialism - on the soft European model - has literally mountains of evidence for it. The basic problem is maximising productive - i.e. innovative and practical - activity, and not allowing the economy to financialise, which replaces actual activity with meaningless proxy casino activity. Capitalism on its own concentrates wealth and chokes off its own air supply. Government management on its own ossifies into bureaucracy and oligarchy. There's a sweet spot between the two where government provides stable markets, seeds R&D, and prevents excessive concentration of wealth and power, but talented and inventive individuals are still rewarded for talent and invention, and the cost of entry for new business ideas is as low as possible.
- nostrademons 10y ago
- phkahler 10y ago>> every time you make a job redundant you create other new jobs That is false on its face. If you buy a robot to replace a welder, you indirectly employ the people who design, build, and maintain that robot. True, and those are higher paid jobs than the welder. But at the end of the day, the person running the factory where said robot is used did an analysis and concluded that it was cheaper to buy the robot than to employ the guy it replaced. That means fewer total man-hours in the workforce, since those man hours are billed at a higher rate and are still lower TCO. TL;DR - if your TCO goes down by employing higher paid people you have caused a net-loss in jobs. TCO ~= rate*man_hours so if TCO goes down while rate goes up...
- csbrooks 10y agoAnecdote: My brother-in-law has worked at the same factory for 20 years now. Their efficiency has probably increased 10x in that time. They are producing more than they used to, with a lot less workers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- savanaly 10y agoI don't think anyone claimed that the new jobs would be replaced one to one with jobs maintaining the new technology, just that some of the new jobs would be in maintaining the new technology and some would be in new industries that we haven't even thought of. For a big historical example of this, look at the decrease in labor usage for farming over the last couple centuries. Where did all the people who used to work in agriculture go to? Like 1% of them now remain on the farms, maintaining the technology that displaced the other 99%, who are now dispersed across whatever other modern industry that we didn't used to have (and, we'll note, the pundits at the time highly doubted that most of the 99% being displaced on farms would find be able to find alternative positions).
- merpnderp 10y agoIt is not false on its face. The goods produced by the now robot welder reduce their cost; freeing up capital to flow to some other industry either as profits or lower prices. That factory isn't a closed system.
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoThe Economist had some decent articles on this recently. http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21701119-what-history-tells-us-about-future-artificial-intelligenceand-how-society-should http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21701119-what-history-...
- bduerst 10y agoWell centuries of automation and employment have supported that claim, maybe not to the the full hyperbole by which you repeat it. In fact, the inverse is considered a fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy
- clock_tower 10y agoThere hasn't been infinite work for quite a while now; I've heard the theory that Japan invaded Manchuria in 1931 so that they'd have something to absorb their industrial productivity -- because they were running low on domestic stuff for factory hands to manufacture. Of course, it didn't help that wealth was very heavily centralized in Japan -- the eight zaibatsu families, the Cho:shu and Satsuma fiefdoms (the army and navy respectively), and the imperial family owned probably a majority of the country's wealth, and the common people were too poor to buy very much or stimulate the economy...
- Futurebot 10y agoGwern has written a good piece on this idea here: http://www.gwern.net/Mistakes?cx=009114923999563836576%3Adv0a4ndtmly&cof=FORID%3A11&q=chunking#neo-luddism http://www.gwern.net/Mistakes?cx=009114923999563836576%3Adv0... "The Luddite Fallacy Fallacy"
- ben_jones 10y agoI feel like the "infinite jobs" idea is too foundational to American culture to be completely removed. The very definition of "prosperity" includes having a job. The definition of "success" includes having a job.
- bbctol 10y agoCultures change. It can be painful, but eventually, it will become inevitable.
- fucking_tragedy 10y agoFor the "The End of History" hypothesis to work, the basis for capitalism supposes infinite growth to provide opportunity and prosperity for people. But capital has decided growth is too risky in many markets. It's a shame we've structured our society and economy to be dependent on the whims of capital.
- WorldMaker 10y agoI've described it before about how deeply American culture has a "work problem" and that it is as much a religion as anything. We don't call it a "Protestant Work Ethic" without reason, and lot of what you hear people say about jobs and work these days wouldn't sound much different from what the Puritans (who get credit as some of the earliest American colonists) preached as core to their way of life. To some extent as the culture has gotten less dogmatic in some areas, the dogma of work has only entrenched further. (To many people the big corporate passive aggressive notes from belly of HR about the "good of the company" are the closest to people's weekly and/or daily sermons that they'll see.) There are a lot of people, pundits especially, that see work as a moral obligation and the lack of work as a sin. I think it will take as much as anything else a new wave of religious thinking to move American culture past some hangups into a future with fewer "jobs" available. Or a redefinition of a lot more hobbies and crafts as "jobs" and "work". (I'm not sure which would be easier. There are stigmas in both directions.)
- keyboardhitter 10y ago> To many people the big corporate passive aggressive notes from belly of HR about the "good of the company" are the closest to people's weekly and/or daily sermons that they'll see. Oh wow. I've not thought about that culture in such a light. Perhaps that's why I have always found those "sermons" a bit creepy? I think you have a great point here. > Or a redefinition of a lot more hobbies and crafts as "jobs" and "work". (I'm not sure which would be easier. There are stigmas in both directions.) 100% agreed. I know quite a few artists who are branching off into freelance, using the internet to their disposal (patreon, gofundme, etsy, etc.) who have been chided for not "having a real job" or looked down upon for choosing to have a part time "real job" to make time for their craft / art. Yet, they make respectable income. This phenomenon for artists in general may not be new, of course. I just like to imagine how the internet may help change or eradicate the stigma of it not being "good enough". When my own brother decided to go down this path, I was a bit concerned, and the truth is most of my positions as a sysadmin until recently were very corporate. I was appalled at myself for even thinking things like, "But this isn't going to build a career for him. Why is he even taking this chance? This seems stupid of him." I'm now wondering if my exposure to this 'corporate dogma' may be related.
- meira 10y agoWhat if? You create them, of course. The f..king main reason that exists something called economy and polítics is to solve people's living problems, not to create stupid zillionaries.
- pixie_ 10y agoI feel like ancient civilizations a lot of times turned to art once their societies leveled off. Large structures, pots, roads, figures, clothing, etc.. I believe art is unlimited resource and we could have an economy running purely on art. Isn't a large portion of the economy already running off of art? Movies, games, tv, media, events. I actually feel there even a lack of art right now in terms of food, furniture, products in general. I'd pay for objects with more thought put into them, but there isn't enough people today to dedicate their time to art. With all these menial jobs taken up, maybe even more people will turn to custom crafts and trades. Where what I'm paying for is the creativity and uniqueness of the objects I'm buying.
- visarga 10y agoCreativity and uniqueness might not be the sole domain of people. Our digital children are learning fast, and they are pretty creative from what I have seen so far.
- kiba 10y agoI doubt that's sustainable, especially given that you have people like 'starving artists', 'starving writers', and of course game programmers who throw themselves at projects working eighty hours per week. Anything that people likes to do tended to be oversupplied.
- shams93 10y agoThat's so right, if you look at income numbers for SAG its scary, starving artists is right!
- chris_va 10y agoAt the moment. In a world with no demand for labor, there is an implication that the cost of goods would be dominated only by supply scarcity. For commodity goods, they would essentially be free. 200 years ago a real shirt would cost you ~$2000 in today's currency (land -> sheep -> farmers -> spinsters -> dyers -> weavers -> tailors). Now a decent shirt costs $40. Eventually artsists won't starve, even with minimal income. Ideally, hopefully.
- wrong_variable 10y agoPeople forget History. The two times where labor was more valuable than capital. 1 | After the black death in Europe 2 | After the second world war Most of history's default was the gilded age, the roman empire survived for 600[1] years with having worse inequality than in the modern times. Usually the only way to reverse the trend is by a large scale elimination of significant portion of young people. [1] EDIT : correction
- krapht 10y agoOr, we simply wait out the next few centuries. Reproduction rates in many developed countries have dipped below replacement. Maybe the total world population will decrease in our time.
- mc32 10y agoExcept now people expect retirement and pensions... Not something people back then counted on when populations of people working declined...
- nostrademons 10y agoPerfect! There are not enough jobs to go around, and so we have more people not working. Sounds like mission accomplished. ...we might need to work on wealth distribution, though.
- ZoeZoeBee 10y agoThis is the problem with our current first world financial system, it is predicated on constant growth. Even the slightest hiccup in growth leads to serious consequences for the over leveraged and make no mistake most of our safety nets are over leveraged and dependent upon unrealistic gains when faced with a stagnant to declining population. The Great Aging is underway, the EU last year had more deaths than births and will for the foreseable future, Japan has been there for a little while and China's working age population is already in decline. Africa, the Middle East/India and parts of South America are the only places experiencing actual population growth, when immigration is not taken into the equation. With Demographics and Automation deflation is the likely outcome. The Central Banks are trying all they can to prevent this from happening in the near term by spending Trillions of dollars to prop up economies and drive interest rates lower to eek out some inflation. They seem not to care whether growth is actual demand growth or simply a mirage in terms of inflation. The central banks are doubling down their efforts and will be even more accomodative in the next few years when the growth they continue to state is right around the corner never materializes. Unfortunately I do not see a way out of this without the developing nations taking care of themselves.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mathattack 10y agoIt seems like there are 2 things that can be done: 1) Make it easier for new firms of all kinds to open and create job. (Less occupational licensing requirements, etc) 2) Reduce the cost/burden of employment. (If someone has the choice to hire an employee in SF and Texas, they'll choose Texas since the laws are more business-friendly)
- emodendroket 10y ago#2 seems more like a way to shift jobs around from one place to another than to create them
- mathattack 10y agoSomewhat. But there's friction from moving jobs around. An oversimplified way to view it... Let's say I can get $100/hour of value out of an employee. As long as I can get $100/hour of value from them, I'll hire them. Now let's say that there is $10 of regulatory burden. (Hard to fire, etc) Then I'd need $110/value to hire someone. Now let's say it costs me $5/hour in communications overhead for people out of town. Then we have 3 scenarios: 1) $110+ in value - I can hire in either place. I prefer the HQ if the resource in CA is $5/hour cheaper. (Or measurably better) 2) $100-$105 in value - I hire in the other place. 3) Up to $105 in value - No hiring. Lowering the regulatory burden to less than $5/hour adds to the amount of jobs people have. Note - it's never really this simple, but it illustrates the idea that someone has to bear additional costs. When the employer and employee split it, relationships that used to net out with higher employment can end with higher unemployment.
- worldsayshi 10y agoHow is this?
- emodendroket 10y agoIf Texas offers me some really sweet incentives so I go and establish my business there (or move an existing one there) instead of California I haven't exactly created twice as many jobs as I would have otherwise, have I?
- emodendroket 10y agoThen the government should either directly employ people or else provide them with an income, or some combination of these.
- noarchy 10y ago>Then the government should either directly employ people or else provide them with an income, or some combination of these. It is interesting to see that, in the early 21st century, communism is becoming palatable again. Could this be due to all of the old communist states either ceasing to exist or (for instance, the case of China) changing into something quite unlike their former sleves? In short, did we forget about those states?
- emodendroket 10y agoUnless the US went communist in the 1930s, government employment, even for the express purpose of creating jobs, wouldn't constitute communism. Besides that, if there is really not enough demand for workers, and there is never going to be, the alternative would seem to be a permanently unemployed underclass.
- sedachv 10y ago> Unless the US went communist in the 1930s, government employment, even for the express purpose of creating jobs, wouldn't constitute communism. I came across this interview recently: HG Wells: > My visit to the United States excited my mind. The old financial world is collapsing; the economic life of the country is being reorganised on new lines. > Lenin said: “We must learn to do business,” learn this from the capitalists. Today the capitalists have to learn from you, to grasp the spirit of Socialism. It seems to me that what is taking place in the United States is a profound reorganisation, the creation of planned, that is, Socialist, economy. You and Roosevelt begin from two different starting points. But is there not a relation in ideas, a kinship of ideas, between Moscow and Washington? > In Washington I was struck by the same thing I see going on here; they are building offices, they are creating a number of state regulation bodies, they are organising a long-needed civil service. Their need, like yours, is directive ability. Stalin: > The United States is pursuing a different aim from that which we are pursuing in the USSR. The aim which the Americans are pursuing arose out of the economic troubles, out of the economic crisis. The Americans want to rid themselves of the crisis on the basis of private capitalist activity, without changing the economic basis. They are trying to reduce to a minimum the ruin, the losses caused by the existing economic system. > Here, however, as you know, in place of the old, destroyed economic basis, an entirely different, a new economic basis has been created. Even if the Americans you mention partly achieve their aim, ie, reduce these losses to a minimum, they will not destroy the roots of the anarchy which is inherent in the existing capitalist system. They are preserving the economic system which must inevitably lead, and cannot but lead, to anarchy in production. Thus, at best, it will be a matter, not of the reorganisation of society, not of abolishing the old social system which gives rise to anarchy and crises, but of restricting certain of its excesses. Subjectively, perhaps, these Americans think they are reorganising society; objectively, however, they are preserving the present basis of society. That is why, objectively, there will be no reorganisation of society. > Nor will there be planned economy. What is planned economy? What are some of its attributes? Planned economy tries to abolish unemployment. Let us suppose it is possible, while preserving the capitalist system, to reduce unemployment to a certain minimum. But surely, no capitalist would ever agree to the complete abolition of unemployment, to the abolition of the reserve army of unemployed, the purpose of which is to bring pressure on the labour market, to ensure a supply of cheap labour. You will never compel a capitalist to incur loss to himself and agree to a lower rate of profit for the sake of satisfying the needs of the people. http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2014/04/h-g-wells-it-seems-me-i-am-more-left-you-mr-stalin http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2014/04/h-g-wells-it-se...
- jseliger 10y agoThe rise of automated looms and spinning jennies clearly mean that the farms aren't going to be sufficient to provide employment for people, who are in turn going to turn to vice and sloth. And, as we know, when the old way is exhausted there is no new way forward. I propose that we be suspicious of the looms and especially of the people who make the looms.
- clock_tower 10y agoThe Luddites weren't wrong, but they were about 200 years too early. Technological unemployment is a thing now...
- Mz 10y agoWhat if The Future is what we choose to create rather than some inevitable road we cannot get off of because of REASONS?
- adamnemecek 10y agoNot an economist but my thoughts on the topic are that society can make changes to accommodate this. This isn't a catastrophe, we just need to prepare. I think this needs to/will happen: * labour will change from people having only one main skill to having multiple skills ("jack of all trades, master of none" will become "jack of all trades, master of fewer") * this will be made possible by the fact that technology makes is easier to (re)educate yourself and also to tailor education exactly for your needs (c.f. university course unbundling, what if you could take different courses at different school based on which fits your needs (kinda like, mooc, yeah, I know mooc aren't the runaway success we'd hope for but give it time)) * we probably will not get rid of the issue that you have to pick a skill(s) when you are fairly young and you don't know if those skill will still be useful when you have to leave the workforce * basically, people will have to learn a couple of skills pretty well and hope that the future jobs will require a particular combination of your skills (and if you are lacking some skills, you should be able to pick up new skills easily) * it will become standard for people to keep learning * i also think that the "default" unemployment rate might rise but unemployment will be more temporary for the single unemployed people My view as someone who strongly believes in technological progress, I would guess I would summarize my advice as "you have to know how to leverage technology not to be outpaced by technology" but this isn't exactly anything novel.
- bduerst 10y agoThe trend here is that humans will become ubiquitous learning machines, valued for their ability to fulfill variable demand. Automation works well through economies of scale to fulfill large, steady amounts of demand. A.I. works well when there is a lot of existing data or logged activity to train on. For new, variable, or niche demand markets, Humans will be unique in that they can fill the demand faster than A.I. or robotics.
- adamnemecek 10y agoYeah, and your argument is a lot more concise. Have you read anything on the topic?
- doorty 10y agoSide note: If college education was "free," it might encourage faster re-skilling and more "profitable" to society.
- zanny 10y agoExcept the actual cost of college is not free, and for a lot of material covered in colleges it is an extremely inefficient way to convey that information, in both time and monetary cost. A large part of the problem is that, in a glut of labor, employers use degrees as litmus tests of commitment rather than ability. If you can just ignore anyone who doesn't have a bachelors, you will, because why not? But that doesn't mean the bachelors is, at the macroeconomic level, worth it to society to push everyone to get.
- topspin 10y agoThe operative word there is "might." Greece has free education. Their educated youth are fleeing as fast as they can. Not very profitable. All that free education also somehow failed to prevent their chronic debt crisis and general decline. It's almost as if economic prosperity is more involved than just distributing free stuff........
- rhino369 10y agoCollege is not really a job training program and to the extent it is, it's a poor one.
- st3v3r 10y agoExcept while I'm getting that education, I still have bills to pay. I still have a mortgage, and I still have a family to feed.
- chrisbennet 10y agoFor anyone who has a theory that involves making new jobs and retraining people, consider these cases: A) 50 something factory worker whos job along with the other 100 folks he works with, have been eliminated by automation or some other sort of efficiency. B) 30 something software engineer who's field (except for research) has been eliminated by AI. "A" is something most of us have the luxury of had waving away with "retrain them to be surgeons and leave their homes behind and move to someplace else for work". "B" hasn't happened (yet) but what would you do if it does? It's not so easy easy to dismiss is it? Lack of work is a structural problem. The landed gentry of our time don't even need the surfs anymore so it's even worse in some ways.
- bduerst 10y agoConsidering the amount of data it takes to train an A.I., there isn't much threat to it taking human related jobs quickly, even less so in emerging industries. You could hand wave about 10 years from now all the software jobs are replaced by A.I., but there will be entirely new industries in place that we can't really conceive of right now. Case in point: Imagine if someone told you in 2006, that there would be a $70 Billion mobile app industry consumed by over a billion people worldwide, using some fantastic new device that's only vaguely similar to the flip phone in your hand.
- gscott 10y agoIt is also a location problem. If you have bought a house but can't sell easily or don't want to move then you can't go to a place in the United States that has more jobs. For example right now in Grand Forks ND there are walmart jobs $14-$18 an hour and apartments for super cheap (with electricity included) for $450 and up.
- falcolas 10y agoAs someone who lived in Grand Forks... I would rather do the same job for $7 an hour just about anywhere else. The weather, floods, wind, and lack of anything to do around there make it a very un-desirable place to live.
- 10y ago
- chrisbennet 10y agoFor anyone who has a theory that involves making new jobs and retraining people, consider these cases: A) 50 something factory worker whos job along with the other 100 folks he works with, have been eliminated by automation or some other sort of efficiency. B) 30 something software engineer who's field (except for research) has been eliminated by AI.
- merpnderp 10y agoIn the mid-west we have programmers 2 years out of school making $100k in places where the CPI is 90. What if we just have a massive misallocation of resources and people should be learning how to program, nurse, become doctors, plumbers, HVAC, or all the other jobs that pay incredibly well?
- st3v3r 10y agoTraining for those jobs takes time and resources. Not everyone who has lost their existing job will be able to invest those things at possibly getting another one. Also, if you send a bunch of people into those fields, the cost of labor will drop, and they won't pay incredibly well for long.
- zghst 10y agoSoftware engineers provide immense value, I highly doubt there is any misallocation, however with other jobs, what if their wages are suppressed because of the lack of a strong market presence and intense competition prevents wages from rising.
- Gravityloss 10y agoAre there lots of jobs that produce value above minimum wage? It's a tough question... There are ways to solve some issues in a low barrier for entry style. Finland has mandatory return payment on all bottles and cans sold. This has resulted in a cottage industry of bottle collectors who target public outdoor events and places where people hang out. So those people perform a valuable service and nobody needs to really coordinate anything. But it would be a very bad way to depend on for livelihood. Somehow these worlds need to meet...
- maxharris 10y agoFirst, there are plenty of jobs, but not enough people that have decided to develop themselves enough to have the skills to do them. For example (a real life one, unfortunately for me): I need a biopsy of a mass near my heart, but the current waiting time for this procedure here in Seattle (at both major hospitals) is two months. What we do have is plenty of regulations that constrain the supply of physicians, services, medical supplies, insurance, and everything else needed to perform operations. It is one of the most un-free markets in America, with predictably disastrous results. Sure, those laws prevent a few people from being duped by charlatans, but they also prevent people like me - who are willing to sit on the phone for hours and days, and willing to do research for weeks on end - the possibility of a longer life. -- There are also plenty of regulations that are limiting career mobility, both in medicine and in other fields. An example of this is that anything that makes it hard for employers to fire people also makes it more costly for them to hire different people (because that new person is an unknown, and therefore risky, as the employer has to hold onto them longer, even if they aren't willing/able to produce.) -- EDIT: I'd like to add that the idea that some people are destined to be doctors (and some aren't) is completely wrong. I was a premed in college (molecular biology degree, worked in a research lab on campus full-time for two years after graduating), and I gave up on the MD track after talking to a few younger doctors. They all told me to quit while I could because they were all in 200k+ in debt, and couldn't switch out of their careers because of it, and they were miserable (tons of useless paperwork, not a lot of progress either in research or with patients). So I went into software, where you don't have to convince a committee to give you permission to make a new app.
- david927 10y agoThat's like saying there's plenty of room for musicians if you're Mozart. The amount of investment required to develop yourself for a target field has grown astronomically, but that's been coupled with a push down in wages. I know lawyers who spent a fortune for their degree, passed the Bar, and make barely more than minimum wage. Regulation isn't causing this; automation is causing this.
- maxharris 10y ago
- njharman 10y agoHonest question: Is it not widely accepted that 1) Eventually, and probably pretty soon (within 100years), that there obviously won't be jobs for everyone. Automation, progress(efficiency gains) and increasing population makes it inevitable. 2) That a general "goal" of society is do away with jobs. In any traditional sense. To me we've been approaching that ever since agriculture provided ability to support specialists (those who don't spend time gathering/producing the food/resources they need). Such as scientists, artists and soldiers. The jobs keep moving "up" the ladder (away from production). Previous low-rung jobs get reduced in number by efficiency or replaced via automation. The end of this trend is that all basic needs are met by 0 to a tiny fraction of a percent of human labor and rest are all free to pursue specialist activities such as science, art, and killing each other.
- beatpanda 10y agoIf 2 is true our politics (at least in the U.S.) haven't caught up. We have to be comfortable with the idea of simply giving money away to people who are not earning it, or giving them more than the market would otherwise bear. One of the ways we could do that is by making university tuition free, to say "well, if you can't get a job, you can always spend your time thinking instead." Instead we're restricting access to univerisities more and more based on the idea that a university education is only about getting a job and you should have to have "skin in the game". We've been making it harder, not easier, for people who aren't working to access the collective product of society, and we're all poorer for that.
- sixothree 10y agoI feel like the US by design is poised to fail in competing against other countries when workforce becomes automated.
- lastyearman 10y ago1) The problem is between now and then. I don't see many willing to cut back on their lifestyle to help those whose skills are no longer valuable.
- 10y ago
- Mendenhall 10y agoI think many of these articles about jobs or lack there of and solving the problem dont take into account human nature. It is much more complex than just "economy".
- Apocryphon 10y agoHas anyone read Player Piano by Vonnegut recently?
- epa 10y agoThe United States has a very skewed view towards work and individual employee production. At some point in time, cultures must shift to realize that two individuals at 40 hours per week can do the work that one individual at 70 hours per week is performing. The key here is incremental corporate profits must shift from shareholders to employees through aggregate increases in employee costs (2x the employees, half the hours for each). Realistically - this problem is a matter of greed at the business owner level.
- dsylexicus 10y agojobs are the cost of satisfying human economic desires. we want to minimise costs, not increase them.since nobody knows what sort of jobs will exist even 5 years from today, there is no point in speculating and wringing hands. who saw the rise of zumba dance teachers? theres atleast a million of them today and they dont need high education or be employed in silicon valley. did president clinton with all the information available at his disposal have the foresight to plan for an app economy for his citizens or imagine how internet search would be something different than what lycos offered?
- Falkon1313 10y ago>jobs are the cost of satisfying human economic desires. we want to minimise costs That's an excellent perspective. There's a major barrier though. Even if we produce enough that everyone could satisfy their desires and then some with a cost of only 34 minutes work per week (<2% of a 40 hour work week - parallel to the fact that less than 2% of the population now works in agriculture to produce more than twice enough to feed everyone), we would still demand that everyone must work at least a bare minimum of 40 hours or else they don't deserve to live. That's our culture. But there would be no demand for that work. So what would the people do? And more importantly, why do we demand that they do it? That becomes a philosophical question, not an economic one.
- Animats 10y agoBoth the article and the paper aren't very good; they're trying to infer too much from macroeconomic data. They implicitly assume that labor is more fungible than it is. Reality is that we just don't need that many people to make all the stuff. US manufacturing output is at an all-time high (output has recovered completely from the 2008 recession). US manufacturing employment peaked in 1979. Imports are 26% of US consumer good consumption. What are people doing? Here's US employment by sector.[1] It's worth spending some time with this table. Incidentally, "information services" dropped from 2.2% in 2010 to 1.8% in 2014, and is still dropping. No, going into computing isn't a good move. The only area with big growth is "health and social assistance", which reflects an aging population. (Mining was up from 2010-2014, but that reflects the oil and gas boom. That's already collapsed.) That's the reality. [1] http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_201.htm http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_201.htm
- ryanmarsh 10y agoWhite collar jobs get a little harder to find and people start freaking out. Meanwhile my clients import skilled workers by the plane load. We're a long way from autonomous strawberry pickers and housekeepers. I don't doubt that eventually much of the economy will have no need of human labor but we're quite a ways from that. I mean I get it. I'm replacing some good white collar jobs with software right now. But "jobs"? Nah. There's lots of those.
- jwatte 10y agoIt's impossible that there is simply nothing in the world that needs doing. Exactly how to make sure that things that need doing, are done, is what economics and politics are about, but any "job shortage" is because of inefficiencies along some spectrum, not actually ever a natural state.
- saintgimp 10y agoThe word "job" as used here is a technical term. It doesn't mean "anything that needs doing". It doesn't mean "anything I find enjoyable or worthwhile". It actually means "activities that someone will pay me money to do because I can do it better, faster, or cheaper than anyone or anything else, including machines." (For the purpose of this discussion there's also an implied meaning of "someone will pay me enough money for those activities that I can purchase adequate food, shelter, and discretionary items so as to have a reasonably comfortable existence.") That set of activities appears to have peaked in per-capita terms and is probably on a decline which will accelerate rapidly in the future. So yeah, you're right that this problem is inherently an economic problem, not an "I don't know what to do with all my free time" problem. That doesn't make the problem any less urgent or less difficult to solve. It's actually incredibly difficult to solve because it'll involve rejiggering our social contracts, which will probably take several generations to complete.
- emblem21 10y agoAt Emblem 21, we analyze not just the time, material, and energy costs for economic activity, but also the complexity components as well. Every economic activity consumes and yields complexity. This complexity is difficult to measure given its contextual nature, but it is encoded into the pricing of the transaction itself. Currently working on very advanced neural networks to detect the edges of this contextual complexity. Autonomous labor doesn't destroy jobs because the autonomous labor is also a consumer of complexity, energy, and time. https://s32.postimg.org/pjzgj39wz/Labor.png https://s32.postimg.org/pjzgj39wz/Labor.png
- zghst 10y agoYour site is down. I find it a bit worrisome, looking through your repos that many files are blank. I would like to learn more about your company.
- emblem21 10y agoGreetings. Our corporate structure is undergoing a fundamental transition (from a software contractor to a holding company) and we're still deciding on presentation and community outreach. ...which is to say we have plenty of researchers but no social team. :) Our primary goal is the formation of autonomous labor by helping put the institutional periphery into place: legal review, trade agreements, economic policy study, political and memetic steering, and financial innovation. Robots just won't automatically take all of the jobs. Humans are very good at cutting their own throats collectively and we very much account for this. We have three private tech projects at this time that cover the UAV and theoretical mathematics space.