25 ms·
Why California is so expensive: It’s not just the weather, it’s the regulation
- ryanmarsh 10y agoSF et. al. aren't an oil boom town that'll crash in the next cycle. SF is the Manhattan of tech and tech is where most economic growth will come from for the foreseeable future. Regulations don't help. NIMBYism doesn't help. But if you ended both I still don't see how it would ever be as cheap as somewhere like Houston.
- eldavido 10y agoOn the other hand, oil boom towns don't _move_. Anecdotally, a lot of people I know are leaving SF. I imagine the next 20-30 years will look like any other industry, where a clear center emerged, but then it diffused outward into the broader economy as more and more industries assimilated the new tech. Now, you could make the argument that SF's core competence isn't so much a technology as the process of innovation itself, but I'm not sure that's the argument you're making. And I don't see any reason why a cheaper place with a lot of smart people and money (to reference pg) couldn't be the next SV, like say, Pittsburgh, or Seattle. Though I guess the social network, which is really what holds this entire place together, does have some staying power...maybe finance is the best example to prove your point?
- orky56 10y agoWe have yet to see a new SV emerge in another city. The capital from VCs is still here. Unless something drastic changes, SV will remain firmly planted as the world's tech hub.
- uola 10y agoBy definition those leaving SF are those who didn't "make it". The whole point of being a center that you have the most power over something that people need, controlling access to markets. It's already very apparent for successful startups from outside SV that has to sell through app stores etc.
- dionidium 10y ago> In some California cities, the average four-bedroom, two-bathroom home would set you back over $2 million, while a similar home would cost less than $100,000 in many other US cities. This is a little but misleading. You have to scroll way down to get to any city with an average under $100k for the described home and those are in cities with vast, mostly-abandoned areas where (basically uninhabitable versions of) such homes might cost as little as $10k. (Their averages are brought way down by outliers, in other words.)
- replicatorblog 10y agoYou are right, the author was extreme, but not by that much. Look at Houston, or Austin and you'll find lots of perfectly nice, new construction, 4b/2br in the $250K range. I live an hour outside Boston where there is a similar dynamic at play. My frustration is that large cities like Houston are able to build inexpensively, while relatively small ones like Boston/SF are just insane.
- dionidium 10y agoRestrictive zoning laws are good for incumbents
- jonknee 10y ago> My frustration is that large cities like Houston are able to build inexpensively, while relatively small ones like Boston/SF are just insane. Houston is a large city just because it's sprawlville (to a ridiculous degree, city limits is an astounding 627 sq mi). It's not a fair comparison to an urbanized city like Boston or SF (that both have 5+ times the density).
- muzz 10y agoAnd sky-high property taxes in Texas also helps keep prices low.
- kqr2 10y agoAre there any examples of cities or states that have been able to successfully transition from expensive to affordable housing in a non-castastrophic manner? Even at a more local level ( https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ ), the problem is complex with many stakeholders. How do you get everyone to agree and try to reach a better solution?
- hiou 10y agoNope. Brexit style armchair quarterbacks all the way down.
- ktRolster 10y agoGovernor Brown has a bill that will help a lot with thee problems: http://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/blog/real-estate/2016/05/brown-affordable-housing-development-approval-ceqa.html http://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/blog/real-estate/201...
- 1_2__3 10y ago> new projects with 20 percent affordable housing for tenants making no more than 80 percent of the area median income or projects with 10 percent affordable housing near transit would be exempt from most local reviews. That sounds great, but think of it this way: a 200-unit luxury apartment complex that includes a shithole in the back with 40 units that lack parking and a separate access door would be exempt from local oversight. Does that sound like a pattern for success to you?
- ktRolster 10y agoIf you have a better idea, I'm really interested in hearing it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- mabbo 10y agoI don't get why this is surprising. The goal of nearly all of these regulations is, effectively, to prevent housing from being built. They reduce supply, while demand is increasing. This is basic economics. Compare this to Toronto. Housing is getting more expensive here, yes, but not at nearly the same rate. Demand is increasing because of high immigration, but supply is being allowed to increase as well- and mostly in the up direction. There's a condo over on College street that just opened, 60 floors or more I believe. An 80+ twin tower condo is I think now approved by the city over on King. The main strip of North York must be averaging 25-30 stories tall, and it's 15km from downtown! If California wants to lower their housing prices, they need to have supply match demand. To do that, they need 50 story buildings. A lot of them. And they need to start soon, because they take years to build.
- dmix 10y agoToronto had a massive building boom [1] over the last 5-7 years that far outpaced Chicago, NYC, and Huston (something like #1 Toronto had 150 buildings v the closest #2 was 40 in Chicago being built). The construction on the hundreds of condos are just starting to be completed and condo prices actually went down for the first time in forever while housing prices continue to rise. SF housing crisis is entirely self-created. If it wasn't for zoning limitations they'd be one of the top 5 fastest growing city in North America no doubt. [1] http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/130-highrise-building-projects-in-toronto-lead-north-america-1.2504776 http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/130-highrise-building-projec...
- tostitos1979 10y agoI recall reading somewhere that the downtown core actually has less condos than needed. TO should have built more apparently. They built a lot of condos further away and those condos are the ones that are decreasing/not going up. Also, since there are a lot of Toronto folks on this thread ... what are you folks doing if you don't own anything already? Prices are at an all time high but there is a general fear that if you don't buy now, you will be locked out forever. A data point there are condos in Gibson Square in North York for north of 650K. Seems insane but that is what the market is I suppose.
- grecy 10y agoI think this is true of everything in the Developed world, not just housing. Healthcare, education, taxis, hotels, small engines. They're all insanely expensive because of the massive amount of regulation that's been added to them in the last 50 or so years. Of course, those regulations add safety and control and structure, so I'm not saying they're all bad. Just look at the houses or air quality or safety record in undeveloped countries to see what happens without all those regulations. I find it fascinating that apps like uber and air bnb are basically just getting around all of the regulations and are in a sense going back in time to the way things were (and still are in the undeveloped world.) i.e. if you want to sleep somewhere, you just pay someone for a room in their house - never mind if they have a "permit" - same goes for an informal taxi in most of the world. It will be interesting to see what happens when people make apps/websites for all the other areas of our world that have an enormous markup because of regulations.
- bubbleRefuge 10y agoIn Latin America, there is lots of regulation. Just try opening a business. Hiring an employee.
- grecy 10y agoIt depends if you do those things legally. There are also tons of things you can do without regulation like picking people up in your car/van or letting people sleep in a room in your house or cooking them a meal.
- option 10y agoPeople who own houses in CA and Bay Area in particular, especially those who bought recently, why would they want housing prices to go down?
- groby_b 10y agoBecause we understand the problems of monoculture and non-diverse communities? Because we know where income inequality leads? Because we'd rather see fellow humans have a place to live in, instead of seeing our bank account grow? Because for some of us, social responsibilities matter too, not just money?
- st3v3r 10y agoBut this isn't a little bit of money we're talking about. This is a lot of money. This is levels of money that a family likely can't bear. Now, if, as prices went down, the loans went down as well, that'd be another story.
- 1_2__3 10y agoFor a teeny tiny fraction of you this is true - and it has no bearing on anything. Nobody's asking the minority anything.
- xienze 10y ago> Because for some of us, social responsibilities matter too, not just money? You'd be changing your tune if the $1M+ house you bought suddenly went underwater to the tune of several hundred thousand dollars.
- groby_b 10y agoI lost 50% on my house, and I'm still saying this, so no, I probably wouldn't. I get that this is a huge burden. I don't suggest that's the magic fix, or that this should happen across the board at such staggering numbers. I'd prefer if it didn't happen to such an extent again to me, either. I was merely answering the OPs question why anybody owning a house would want them to go down at all. We are currently on an unsustainable trajectory. They need to come down, and they will, sooner or later. The only question is if we want to handle this in a controlled way, or as a collapse, like last time 'round.
- british_india 10y agoRegulation does not come out of thin air--it comes in response to abuses. It's intellectual twaddle to complain about the resulting regulation without acknowledging its source--which is abuse of the commons.
- x3n0ph3n3 10y agoIt also comes about as a form of abuse by vested interests engaging in regulatory capture. Don't mistake politicians for do-gooders.
- cylinder 10y agoWhat if Californians just decided they want their communities to look the way they do now? Switzerland could make everything less expensive if they imported cheap labor and cut the minimum wage. But they elect not to. I guarantee that if you made California cheaper you'd attract more people and then it'd just become more expensive again. There's not enough space there to accommodate all the people in the country that would live there if they could afford it.
- tostitos1979 10y agoWell .. maybe the CS industry needs to all agree to jointly move away to a state that has a better attitude to the problems faced by young people. As someone in their mid-30s, I'll never be able to afford a house in Mountain View (despite earning an income there, spending money there, renting there, etc.).
- cylinder 10y agoIt starts with employees demanding higher wages. That'll get their attention and they'll move offices to cheaper cities. My partner just rejected a job offer because housing is too expensive. This is a six figure salary and management level but after taxes and rent on a one bedroom apartment there's not much left over to make working worth it.
- 10y ago
- british_india 10y agoRegulation does not come out of thin air--it comes in response to abuses. It's intellectual twaddle to complain about the resulting regulation without acknowledging its source--which is abuse of the commons.
- muzz 10y agoFigure 1 uses data that ends over 20 years ago?
- BurningFrog 10y agoIf this is ever to be solved, it has to be on the state level. Individual cities or counties are not going to nobly go against their interests and start building more than they have to. But a lot of people have gotten very rich off of this, so I don't know if there is any political strength behind this. What happens to the Jerry Brown proposal will be a good indicator.
- thescriptkiddie 10y agoBut building more housing isn't against any city's interests, more housing means more tax revenue. The people who are likely to block this are the people who have made "fortunes" by seeing the value of their homes rise. I would argue that those people have more power statewide than they do in the denser cities where few people own their own homes.
- BurningFrog 10y agoAfter Prop 13, housing is a net loss. Or so I'm told. I think it's more of a NIMBY thing. People can agree that California needs more housing, but fight to the death against it near their house.
- muzz 10y agoNo mention of Prop 13. A statewide market distortion that likely overshadows the city-level regulations.
- iceManChild 10y agoI completely agree that there is way too much regulation. But, the other part of the equation is people are still willing to pay the resulting price in the end. In the more "prime" communities like Palo Alto, Menlo Park, and Mountain View they still seem happy to pay the extra cost to get permits to tear down a 60 year ranch style home and then petition a city council to put a custom build in its place. Contractors advertise that they know the regulations and how to work with officials to get their permits through and charge a premium. The funny part is once construction is complete the new residence want to prevent new construction in order to "preserve the neighborhood" they moved into.
- bunkydoo 10y agoVery true in NYC also, everything is so tightly regulated that the spending power of your dollar bottlenecks compared to other parts of the country
- mmanfrin 10y agoUsing 'California' as a unit, and then selecting housing prices from the Bay Area to illustrate. Okay. Because houses in Stockton are $2mil? I don't dispute that there are some really stupid land-use regulations in certain cities, but to hand-wave all of California as suffering from the yoke of regulation is to show a biased and superficial hand.
- muzz 10y agoTrue, but cities have borders and if one constrains building, the builders can just go outside that city's limits. This is why I think that statewide factors are the dominant force here.
- Spooky23 10y agoHousing prices are driven by average income, interest rates and population growth. Period. In a stable metro, the minimum price is a floor driven by the prevailing rent as defined by social services for section 8. The median is driven by the median two earner income. You can validate this by looking at small cities with dominant employers like a state Capitol. Everything else just changes the size, form and fitting of the housing unit.
- astrodust 10y agoPlus speculation. If it was driven by just those factors Ireland wouldn't have happened.
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's more about cheap rates and access to capital. Very little speculative activity is financed by cash.
- astrodust 10y agoIt depends on your market. We're seeing a lot of Chinese capital (cash) being dumped into real-estate since it's seen as a cheap investment that produces good returns. In this bubble that house is appreciating at 17% per year or more. If you're leveraged you can get higher returns, but finding someone to loan you the money may be difficult. If you've got cash, just dump it on properties and let it appreciate.
- Animats 10y agoThe last California housing crash was in 2008. The next one may be starting. There were lots of empty houses only 6 years ago. Outside the coastal zone, there's not much state level regulation. The coastal zone is regulated because there's a general consensus that California doesn't want a wall of high-rises at the coast like Honolulu or Singapore. San Francisco has substantial opposition to "Manhattanization", even though things are going that way. Different communities on the SF peninsula are going in different directions. Redwood City is building vertically - 8 to 15 stories, not skyscrapers, but many buildings are going up. It's not clear that the Silicon Valley boom will continue much longer. Web has been done. Apps have been done. IoT, if it happens, will come from places where "things" are made. The Next Big Thing hasn't appeared yet.
- hardtke 10y agoHousing is also expensive because of the California building codes. These include things like double pane windows, copper pipes and energy efficient appliances. These raise the cost of new construction compared to other states, but lead to long term lower home ownership costs and reduced energy consumption. If we are serious about climate change we need to create such regulations. Buyers will chose cheaper houses if given the choice.
- clarkmoody 10y agoReally interesting EconTalk from 2011 about cities, regulation, and growth: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2011/10/avent_on_cities.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2011/10/avent_on_cities.htm...
- danhak 10y agoThere are plenty of places in California where you could buy a home for $100K. The article does a very poor job of demonstrating a causal relationship between "regulation"--he doesn't even cite any specific ones--and basic supply/demand dynamics that are common to major metro areas throughout the world. All he's got is a very hand-wavy argument and a chart that abruptly cuts off circa 1994.
- maxharris 10y agoThis post made me think of a little history. There were plenty of problems in the 19th century, but the ideas of the era did not lead them to suppose that the first answer to any problems was red tape. The effects of this difference are huge. I know this isn't quite apples-to-apples, but a rather stark comparison comes to mind: Using the comparatively primitive technology of the 1880s, James J. Hill was able to build a transcontinental railroad in a decade (using private finance). Here in Seattle, the public transit authority says it's going to take two or three decades to build a train that goes just six miles.
- eldavido 10y agoMy friends and I talk about this a lot. We aren't living in the 1880s anymore. For one, we value life, health, and safety much more than they did back then, with things like OSHA, much more stringent labor laws (overtime, child labor), more types of insurance required for employers including unemployment and various disability coverage, environmental laws like CEQA/Clean Air Act, and tons of other stuff. But I think the biggest change is ultimately cultural. We just don't value growth today like we did back then. We want safe workplaces, and a clean environment. I also think there's a much greater tolerance for government bureaucracy today then there was in the 1880s, including all kinds of permits that take weeks to issue, multiple agencies overseeing everything at the state, local, and federal level, and just in general a huge expansion in the size of government. If you told someone from the 1880s that US government spending would rise to some 40% of GDP over 120 years, they'd think you were totally insane. I go back and forth on whether it's good or bad. It's a complicated question. It takes forever to get anything done, and yet, young Chinese nationals are coming to the US because their parents have utterly ruined their environment, they don't trust the safety of their food supply, and factories with hundreds of people in them burn down, killing everyone inside. I used to think the US and Europe were radically different places, but I'm coming to see they're more alike vs. different. It's really the US and China that are worlds apart.
- maxharris 10y agoI think (but am not completely certain) that we needed a high-growth environment to be rich enough to invent the technologies that give us safe workplaces and a clean environment. If that's true, I also wonder what safety and and living standard improvements we might be giving up because we don't have high growth today.
- ihaveahadron 10y agoIt has nothing to do with the fucking weather. In fact for many, maybe even most people, the weather in california is SHIT. I like rain and snow, so -- by definition -- california has BAD weather -- for me.
- bsder 10y agoIt also hasn't helped that the Fed has held the interest rate so low for so long in order to prop up the property bubble. If the interest rate went up a couple of points, nobody could afford the mortgage on a million dollar home. At that point, the market would start moving in a different direction.
- orky56 10y agoThose interest rates would also affect developers who are looking to build. The net effect could be a lower supply that keeps demand constant.
- kevindong 10y agoHousing is expensive because demand is high while supply is low. Perhaps a portion of the the difference in housing costs between certain areas in California and certain areas in other states (i.e., the 4 br/2 bathroom example) can be attributed to regulation, but the the vast majority of the difference is attributed to the fact that there is high demand for that $2 million home whileas that $100k home is in Podunk, Fly-Over State, USA where no wants to live. In addition, at $100k, there has to be something wrong with that home. My old house's insurance bill claimed that it would cost in the mid-$200k range to rebuild that exact same, 4 bedroom, 3.5 bathroom, ~4,000 sq. ft. home.
- Empact 10y agoThe natural way that markets behave is when prices are high, the price is an incentive to create more supply, which then reduces the supply/demand mismatch. With reduced regulation, there would be much more housing supply in SF. E.g. the city's footprint is slightly larger than Paris proper, which has 2.5x the population thanks to a consistent building height of ~6 floors. Paris is hardly a free-market bastion, or a place known for low quality of life, but SF out-regulates Paris with its tyranny of the vocal minority and regulation by bodies driven by perverse incentives. Apart from directly adding supply, building up increases tax revenues and local population which enables / justifies transit expansion, which then increases the practically accessible pool of housing for anyone desiring to live in the city. So, in trying to understand your point: do you not believe that housing costs would be lower if there was 3x the supply of housing, ala Paris, and a faster, more comprehensive farther-reaching transit system?
- ww520 10y agoCase in point. I've a remodel project last year. The city has a regulation to require home owner to plant tree in front of the house for any permit based remodel work. When asked how to the tree planted, they said asked the state park service to get the permit and ttee requirement. But, but, I can pay a fee to substitute the tree planting. wtf.
- williesleg 10y agoIsn't it illegal to store rainwater in California? They're just so progressive there. Maybe that's why everybody's moving to Austin.
- bcheung 10y agoRegulations, at least well intentioned regulations, exist to reduce risk to society. However, risk tolerance is rather subjective. It would be nice to allow people to pay more for less risk and have things cheaper if they are comfortable with more risk. Forcing everyone to the same lowest common denominator forces people who can tolerate the extra risk to pay for more than they need. Let people have more of a choice. Maybe it can be rated to a certain level of safety with regards to different aspects (wind, fire, flood, accessibility, etc). When I was poor, I built my own place in a friend's warehouse for $3,600 (mostly lumber and drywall from Home Depot) and about 2 months of my own labor with 1 other person helping. It was a small 2 story structure with 4 rooms. It had electrical, Internet, and plumbing. It obviously wasn't to code but it was completely functional and comfortable to live in. I read up on the different codes and why they existed and chose to follow the ones that make sense from a structural engineering / human safety standpoint, while ignoring other ones that I thought wouldn't have any significant impact on me (handicap accessibility, etc). I also wasn't concerned with how it looked. Exposed drywall. Used melamine sheets as giant whiteboards for the interior walls because they were more functional to me than traditional walls. If I had to live according to the regulations, permits, etc, I would have been homeless. But since I was willing to skirt the law and tolerate more risk I was able to get by for dramatically cheaper. I also had to spend time learning how to do framing and construction but that's not really a big deal if you know how to read and can use the Internet. Then there are those regulations that only exist to satisfy the wants of some politician or their cronies. But that's a completely different issue.