9 ms·
What’s Behind the Ballooning Upper Middle Class? Education
- beastcoast 10y agoI believe that is referring to share of total income, which means the rich are getting a bigger piece of the pie while the middle and lower classes are getting poorer or stagnating. In other words, inequality is increasing. The article doesn't mention anything about How the classes are defined however.
- learc83 10y agoThe article does talk about that but it's primarily addressing the growth in the upper middle class as a percent of the total population. From 13% to 30% in the last 40 years.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoClicking through to the full report, I find: "Between 1979 and 2014 ... there were sizable declines in each of the lower three groups, with the poor and near-poor falling from 24.3 to 19.8 percent, the lower middle class from 23.9 to 17.1 percent, and the middle class from 38.8 to 32.0 percent." My read of that is that since 1979, there has been a shift up for all income groups. There are fewer poor and near-poor, fewer middle class, and substantially more in the upper middle class. Isn't this good news? Doesn't it fly in the face of the 'growing income divide'? Something is not adding up...
- dozzie 10y agoMaybe it's thresholds that are not adding up. Or maybe not.
- lqdc13 10y agoEducation doesn't help fix poverty or move people from lower middle class to upper middle class. http://www.demos.org/blog/12/2/15/why-education-does-not-fix-poverty http://www.demos.org/blog/12/2/15/why-education-does-not-fix... Edit: However, it will increase wages in absolute terms: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/01/upshot/why-more-education-wont-fix-economic-inequality.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/01/upshot/why-more-education-...
- dmix 10y agoI always assumed it was a cross between the newish tech industry, usual finance industry salaries, fracking, and the ever expanding defense contractor industry that has been generating thousands of millionaires [1]. All of these require an education and most importantly living in the right places. These industries while booming are better at generating upper middle class with a lot of low wage jobs in between, rather than the healthy middle classes common in older industries like steel, mining, and other union jobs that fueled the 1950-70s middle class boom. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/dc-enclaves-reap-rewards-of-contracting-boom-as-federal-dollars-fuel-wealth/2011/06/27/gIQAWQC5HJ_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/dc-enclaves-reap-reward...
- merpnderp 10y agoNot all education is the same. If memory serves a recent Chronicle of Higher Ed study had gender studies bachelors making $14/hour with software engineers making $100k/year. So maybe education is the most important factor if you only count in demand fields.
- ddorian43 10y agoWhat job can you get from "Gender Studies" beside teaching it ?
- DominikR 10y agoI guess you can make it your job to relabel boys kissing girls without asking for permission as rapist and you can also create all kinds of new genders. I heard that there's now 50+ new genders that have been created by this science. Edit: I feel it is unfair to downvote ddorian43 just for asking what kind of jobs you can have with a degree in Gender Studies. I'm not aware of a Gender Studies industry where customers pay good money for Gender Studies services and products.
- ddorian43 10y agoAnd then you combine it with your software skills to do: https://blog.pinterest.com/en/more-gender-options-pinterest https://blog.pinterest.com/en/more-gender-options-pinterest
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThere are scores of jobs in areas such as retail management that don't care what your degree was in, only that you have a degree from somewhere in something. In some, you'll get hired in as a fast-tracker to management with training and such, others you'll find opportunity with just a bit of retail experience (having a job through college can be enough). Sometimes the same is true for secretarial positions, and I'm guessing these sorts of qualifiers are everywhere.
- 10y ago
- dbjacobs 10y agoGiven "uses absolute income thresholds adjusted for inflation", the result is not surprising. You would expect this result as long as you had real GDP growth (i.e., growth above inflation). What this doesn't tell you is what percentage of that real GDP growth did the middle class get to participate in. And this is where the growing economic disparity is coming from.
- mwsherman 10y agoThe definitions of middle and rich in the report are pretty close to made up. In the latter case, the study literally uses "people who identify as rich". The study appears to define "middle" as 90% of respondents, which is laughable. Everyone thinks of themselves as middle, no matter how far from the actual middle they are. The obvious definition would be percentiles of income, or wealth, or other measurable advantage. This would put a lot of readers in an upper class, as which people really don’t like to think of themselves.
- henrikschroder 10y agoNo, if you belong to the working class or the upper class, you most definitely don't think of yourself as middle class. Wealth and income aren't very good markers for class, there are plenty of working class members who make more money than many middle class members.
- ceras 10y agoAre you from outside the US? I've never heard this attitude in the US, but have heard it multiple times from people from other countries (often the UK). Here in the US I've heard families earning from $30k to $200k, working jobs from manual labor to white collar, call themselves "middle class."
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Here in the US I've heard families earning from $30k to $200k, working jobs from manual labor to white collar, call themselves "middle class." $200K is definitely considered middle class in the US, especially by the left. For example, both Clinton and Sanders use $250K as their upper limit[0]. As for manual labor vs. white collar - it depends on what context you're talking about, but in terms of sheer economic purchasing power, that doesn't really matter that much. (Incidentally, a lot of white-collar office jobs pay a lot less than many blue-collar positions). There's definitely a class and status aspect to the term 'middle class', but that's much harder to quantify (and is also only loosely correlated with income - hence the existence of the term nouveau riche. As an aside, $200K isn't necessarily as much as people think it is, which is (one of the reasons) why people like Clinton and Sanders consider $250K to be middle class[1]. A lot of people who "make" $200K in gross income are often working jobs which require them to cover a lot of large expenses (such as vehicles/equipment) out-of-pocket, or are running their own businesses[2]. While they might seem rich if you just look at the $200K figure, that doesn't mean they're really rich in any meaningful sense of the word - even if they're frugal, they could still be living quite hand-to-mouth on that amount. [0] http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/18/news/economy/clinton-sanders-middle-class/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/18/news/economy/clinton-sanders... [1] There are more cynical, political reasons for doing it as well, but there is a factual justification for it as well. [2] I'm not talking about startups, but genuine 'small businesses', for which they're often the sole proprietor or one of very few partners.
- LiweiZ 10y agoThe interesting point about measuring anything in many reports is less associated but more practical dimensions are often picked for writers to tell more engaging stories. Well, someone is able to have one model and different report APIs targeting different audience then.
- akhilcacharya 10y ago> Even with the degree, students from low-income backgrounds get less of an income bump throughout their lives than those from wealthier backgrounds Could this be because of the university attended?
- ageek123 10y agoAn arguably better treatment of this topic from the WSJ a few weeks ago: http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2016/06/21/not-just-the-1-the-upper-middle-class-is-larger-and-richer-than-ever/ http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2016/06/21/not-just-the-1-the... (The key finding is that most of the people who have "left" the middle class have gone up, not down.)
- DominikR 10y agoI see this a little bit different. There are always booming industries precisely because they aren't regulated a lot by the government which open up a venue for all kinds of people with all kinds of backgrounds to make their way to the top without a college education. Then after some time governments start regulating that industry until only the ones with connections and degrees from good colleges have the chance to enter the industry. This is the moment when this industry ceases to enable people based on merit (smart, working hard) to move up the social ladder. Eventually this industry dies because of this process, because now it is not the strong willed, smartest and hardest working that make it to the top but instead it's a bunch of drones from colleges that all have the same thinking, manners and world views. I believe this has already happened in the financial industry and I feel that in the next 1 or 2 decades this will also happen in the IT industry, which currently isn't heavily regulated. I myself (immigrating from a Socialist country) made it in one of the richer EU countries to the top 0,5% of society without a college education (I dropped out) in the IT sector and I'm quite sure that I wouldn't have made it if this industry was heavily regulated. I equate regulation to an entry cost to do business in some area. While regulation in itself isn't bad too many regulations can over time create an environment where only the ones that already have money can enter the playing field. It's kind of like the rich and powerful see that there's an industry where a lot of profit can be made and the first thing they do is to immediately create entry barriers with regulations so only their own offspring can claim future profits in this industry.
- pm90 10y agoThis is actually too broad a generalization to be useful at all. Regulations do hamper and get in the way of business by usually increasing costs. But there is usually a good reason for those regulations (e.g. we have mandatory airbags because they were deemed necessary for people's safety, despite adding to the cost of the vehicle). I can see why you would have such a viewpoint though. What you describe is exactly what happens in many countries where corruption is more prevalent (e.g. India, Russia etc) with regulations being created precisely to keep out others.
- DominikR 10y ago
- HappyFunGuy 10y agoExpanding the definition of what is Upper Middle Class is ballooning the Upper Middle Class.
- dexterdog 10y agoSo it's like autism epidemic?
- paulpauper 10y agoIf everyone becomes 'upper middle' then it's no longer middle. Statistically, there will always be a lower, a middle, and an upper quartile.
- onion2k 10y agoOnly if the class system is based on statistics. It isn't. What class someone is in is defined by their values, beliefs, assets, etc. It's possible for everyone to be in one class. Note that "lower class" isn't a thing. It's called "working class". That doesn't fit in your model.
- douche 10y agoThere's also a sub-working class, that is lower class, but doesn't or isn't able to work.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoIt mostly just sounds like the income-to-population curve is shifting from a Gaussian to a power-law curve. The power-law curve is gonna have a longer tail, with the "upper-middle class" making up more of the population (integral of the probability density function), even while the density at any given point along that tail is much lower than the density used to be for the right one-to-two sigmas of the Gaussian.
- Futurebot 10y agoAlso worth read is the Economist's article "An hereditary meritocracy": http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21640316-children-rich-and-powerful-are-increasingly-well-suited-earning-wealth-and-power http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21640316-children-ric... "Not only do graduate couples tend to value education; they also tend to have money to spend on it. And though the best predictor of an American child’s success in school has long been the parents’ educational level—a factor which graduates are already ahead on, by definition—money is an increasingly important factor. According to Sean Reardon of Stanford the past decades have seen a growing correlation between parental income and children’s test scores. Sort the students who took the SAT, a test for college applicants, in 2014 by parental income and the results get steadily better the further up the ladder you climb." "And on top of spending on school, there is spending outside it: the gap between what rich and poor parents shell out for museum trips, music lessons, books and so on has been widening (see chart 2). In a world where lots of people do well on SATs, cultivating extra skills matters. The opportunities for parental investment continue in higher education, which is ever more costly (see chart 3) but offers ever greater returns. Between 1979 and 2012 the income gap between the median family with college-educated parents and one with high-school educated parents grew four times greater than the headline-grabbing income gap between the top 1% of earners and the rest, according to David Autor of MIT, rising from $30,000 to $58,000."
- white-flame 10y agoEducation is not "behind" it, as in causation. It's correlated. If you're "upper middle class", you can afford to send your kids to your/their pick of school, get them the right connections, raise them with financial and social sensibilities that will serve them well, distance yourself from negative influences, etc etc etc. That special piece of paper is simply one of the common trinkets of that lifestyle. Stop assigning magic powers to it.
- morgante 10y agoIt goes beyond money though. My parents technically earn below the federal poverty level. They definitely could not have afforded the expensive private education I received. Yet from a young age it was always expected that I would attend college and a huge emphasis was put on education. Educational values endure across generations more effectively than wealth.
- dschiptsov 10y agoYeah, if your parents are able to invest nearly a half-mil so you would have that paper which tells HR guys that your parents have invested neay a half-mil in you... It is about pay-walled system of elite degrees - a status symbol brought by family money in the most cases. BTW, there are many great teachers and courses in these elite schools (I personally love MIT and Yale online courses), so yes, there is also knowledge component in elite education.) But it is paper which makes the difference.
- morgante 10y agoThis definitely matches my experience. My great grandparents were solidly upper class (they owned a large paper company). Since then, there has of course been wide variation in outcomes, from my mother making $10k/year to my aunt who owns a highly successful architecture firm. Yet absolutely everyone in my extended family went to college. Values and norms persist longer than money.
- known 10y agoA job in WallStreet?