12 ms·
Another successful DAO attack recursive split
- mentos 10y agoHeh feels like we're living in the Eve:Online universe now
- SkyMarshal 10y agoThat's pretty much exactly what it is, just text-based not graphical.
- Snowdax 10y agoI dunno, the trade part of Eve is fairly numbers and text heavy
- Aelinsaar 10y agoI'm struggling to understand how even the most optimistic cryptocurrency fan could think this is going to end well.
- cloudjacker 10y agoLibertalia's self destruction
- jrockway 10y agohttp://www.newyorker.com/humor/daily-shouts/l-p-d-libertarian-police-department http://www.newyorker.com/humor/daily-shouts/l-p-d-libertaria...
- cloudjacker 10y agolol we've come full circle, most of my hackernews karma is from posting that article
- jrockway 10y agoYeah, I think I originally saw it when you posted it. I read it from time to time and it makes me laugh, especially the bit about the sidewalks and intentionally shooting the mailbox. My libertarian-leaning friends were not so amused.
- happyslobro 10y agoAs a cryptocurrency fan who chose to invest nothing more than some time learning an interesting new system, I think that things are going just fine. We ran an experiment, and we are getting really interesting results; the kind of results that make good anecdotes in textbooks, decades later. It's just too bad that the experiment was orders of magnitude larger than it needed to be. But if most of that was speculation and greed, then little value has been lost.
- paavokoya 10y agoIt's incredibly satisfying to watch this unfold after getting downvoted to death and told "bitcoin is inherently flawed, BlockChain Technology is muh future" in other threads. After spending 4 years in bitcoin and having watched all the copy+pastecoins fail similarly to alternative internets I can say that any new blockchain isn't revolutionary or innovative in the way most people shallowly believe in the hopes of finding "the next bitcoin". It's already here just accept it.
- oolongCat 10y ago>incredibly satisfying What an incredibly rude thing to even say. While it is 100% the fault of the people who "invested"(if you can call it that) in this. At the end of the day its someone else's hard earned money, perhaps stupid at spending, but hard earned money. I honestly feel really bad for the people who are loosing so much of their money, it should not happen to anyone. Its a horrible horrible situation for the people involved.
- tromp 10y agoit could be someone else's easy earned money...
- lossolo 10y agoI agree with strong bitcoin position. I can tell you one thing, I've read paper about bitcoin and know it's architecture (I've written software communicating with bitcoin network) and person that wrote it is genius. I encourage you to read about bitcoin architecture (if you did not already), it's beautiful. Every detail was thought about including 51% of hashing power attack, blockchains with different length, inflation, double spending etc. It's battle tested solution and i don't see any other crypto currency to challenge bitcoin anytime soon.
- solotronics 10y agoIt's not a binary win/loose situation. Cryptocurrencies are like neighboring countries who's economies are intertwined. For proof see the 10% fall in BTC when the DAO was hacked. This 'hack' could bring a lot of innovation in creating proper smart contracts so there is a small upside to this.
- squizzel 10y agoHopefully they take it all so we can stop hearing about it.
- paavokoya 10y agoIn some countries it's already made fiat currencies obsolete. Peek outside your bubble every now and then.
- Frondo 10y agoIn which country has Bitcoin made fiat currency obsolete?
- esrauch 10y agoAre you seriously suggesting that Bitcoin has outright replaced traditional currency in several countries? That's a pretty strong claim that will need some supporting evidence, I'm very skeptical there exists a country where the majority of the population has been part of a single Bitcoin transaction, much less use it as their primary currency. When i peak outside the bubble I see people who haven't even heard of Bitcoin and don't have any intrinsic opposition to Fiat currency.
- seibelj 10y agoI think you need to peek outside of your bubble
- dang 10y ago> Peek outside your bubble every now and then. Acerbic personal jabs like this are not allowed on Hacker News. We ban accounts that do this repeatedly, so please don't do it. Instead, please (re-)read the site guidelines and post civilly and substantively, or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11933544 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11933544 and marked it off-topic.
- olh 10y agoWe are watching the killer app for decentralization of governance getting centralized governance because the stakeholders made bad investments. This is hard-tech sitcom.
- mbrock 10y agoThere's no central control of the Ethereum blockchain. Various parties are making various recommendations and arguing forcefully because there is no way for a central authority to simply change the blockchain logic. Whether any proposed fork will survive is unclear because it's a decentralized decision.
- empath75 10y agoI'm struggling to understand why anyone would want to bail the DAO investors out of their stupid investment by forking. They told everyone that the code is the final word, someone used the code to empty their bank accounts. Either you believe in what the ethereum block chain espouses or you don't.
- eterm 10y agoBecause almost everyone involved in Ethereum also invested in "the DAO", so they're taking a mulligan. "oops, just a practice!"
- mjfl 10y agoIt's really annoying to think that they are going to get this bailout now though, while in the future they are surely going to thumb their noses at anyone who makes similar contract mistakes. The ability to see a contract through to it's full intent should not depend on your social proximity to the Ethereum development team.
- beachstartup 10y ago> The ability to see a contract through to it's full intent should not depend on your social proximity to the Ethereum development team. i don't think it's any coincidence that's how it works in the 'real world' either, with big banks and governments. at the end of the day, it's about people. money isn't real.
- eterm 10y agoWatching Ethereum discover why there are lawyers is similar to watching the Bitcoin community find out why there are (central) banks. The bitcoin world now has "consensus" meetings which from an outsiders' perspective look a lot like the kind of meetings at Davos that bitcoin was supposed to be against, only without regulation, consumer protection and any recourse against bad actors within the upper spheres of influence. In future of ethereum there'll have to be "arbitration committees" which will look a lot like courts. Self-appointed, unregulated courts of course.
- hngiszmo 10y agoYou are very much mistaken on that one. Those consensus meetings can not decide anything against the will of the users. In fact bitcoin core would hard fork bitcoin if miners agreed to mine too big blocks and nobody could dictate the users of either of the chains to switch to the other. The user is in full control which type of bitcoin he wants to use but as such forks cause insecurity in the market, consensus meetings are held, to gauge the overall potential for consensus on the available options going forward. The most recent changes like CSV are only activated if 95% of miners want them, which would not stop the other 5% from going on without that. And you can be damn sure about seriously controversial changes triggering a 5% fork if need be.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> The user is in full control which type of bitcoin he wants to use I am in full control of which currency I use when transacting.
- kang 10y agoIf the govt changes monetary policy, your held dollars change definition; if bitcoin devs do anything my bitcoins remain as per the definition i agreed to. I can choose to move to that new currency or not.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago
- amix 10y agoThe major problem of Solidity (Ethereum’s language) is the Turning completeness. This makes it incredibly hard to reason about any property of the contracts (since everything is undecidable due to Rice’s theorem). I don’t know why they didn’t reduce the computing power, so it becomes much easier to reason and automate the reasoning about contracts. Do they really need Turing completeness? This could be one of the better things about Bitcoin's blockchain: it's simpler and easier to reason about.
- narrator 10y agoTuring incompleteness was a very significant design decision by Satoshi. If it had been designed by more than a single person, I don't think that decision would have been made. I think that's because the balance of paranoia vs flexibility would have favored flexibility in a larger group. People have to trust each other to form groups so they are naturally less paranoid the larger they become.
- wcummings 10y ago>Do they really need Turing completeness? Of course not, this is why Bitcoin only supports a handful of transaction types which closely mimic things you might do w/ paper checks or cash.
- lordnacho 10y agoIt was very ambitious. I guess they could have just hard coded some simple contracts mimicking existing financial instruments: an equity that pays out variable profits from a certain address to owners, a credit that periodically pays out a fixed amount, options, packages such as convertibles, indices, and so forth. About the Turing completeness, is there any limit to what you can calculate? What's to stop me from doing a contract that eats up an unreasonable number of calculations? That could easily be something that works fine when n is small but explodes when a bunch of different people are involved. Something that might be hard to check beforehand.
- halter73 10y agoEthereum uses "gas" to quantify the computational resources a contract consumes. There is a slowly growing limit to the amount of gas a contract is allowed to consume in order to execute. As for being hard to check beforehand, you're absolutely right. You can read about the consequence of this in one case on this reddit thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4ghzhv/governmentals_1100_eth_jackpot_payout_is_stuck/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4ghzhv/government...
- niftich 10y agoNot sure if this is exploiting the same bug as the first split. But commenters on yesterday's thread have noted [1] that the DAO code currently executing seems to be several days older, and out of sync with the newer github repo [2][3]. This is one way to get a free code review /s There was an issue raised on their repo to make exploitable bugs private [4]. So far it doesn't appear to have gained traction but I wonder, what will it say about decentralized communities, and the focus on the sanctity of their code as a contract, if it's accepted. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11928936 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11928936 [2] https://github.com/slockit/DAO https://github.com/slockit/DAO [3] https://github.com/TheDAO/DAO-1.0 https://github.com/TheDAO/DAO-1.0 [4] https://github.com/slockit/DAO/issues/264 https://github.com/slockit/DAO/issues/264
- jsprogrammer 10y agoAre you saying the running code is not open, or even available? How does that work in a decentralized system?
- niftich 10y agoNo, I'm saying the running code is older. The repo has been updated since, so there are updates/fixes/pull requests in the repo that haven't been deployed to the running code yet. The most recent bugs that appear to have been fixed are still present in the running instance of the DAO. (Prompted by your post, I have since edited my previous post to clarify the intended wording.)
- xorcist 10y agoHow do you deploy new code in a decentralized system? Could such a possibility not be used to change smart contracts post-facto?
- gcr 10y agoThat's a great question: how is new code deployed on a smart contract? If this is even possible, what prevents the holders of The DAO's account keys from deploying a new "Send all outstanding balance to this wizard" version of the code? If it's not possible to change the running version of a smart contract, how does the community plan to deal with these sorts of problems?
- Animats 10y agoWell, this is a mess. Remember, there's a clock ticking - there are, what, 25 more days before the funds from the first exploit become liquid. With more exploits being found, the original proposed patch, which just blocks a specific destination address, won't work. The price of Etherium has fallen about 35% since this started. The Etherium market cap has dropped from $1.5bn to under $1bn. Volume hit an all time high, and the price is still in a screaming dive as people try to get out.[1] I wouldn't be surprised if the person behind the exploit turns out to be an insider. That would be in keeping with cryptocurrency tradition. In the Bitcoin world, most of the major "hacks" turned out to be insider theft. [1] http://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/ethereum/ http://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/ethereum/
- cjbprime 10y agoThe patch does not block a destination address; it blocks all transfers from the DAO's source address, as a stopgap towards better solutions. (It actually works on all instances of the DAO's code address, not just the famous ~$150M instance.) https://github.com/ethereum/go-ethereum/pull/2715 https://github.com/ethereum/go-ethereum/pull/2715 > There's simply the notion of --illegal-code-hashes that takes a list of hashes that are placed in "ignore-mode".
- vegabook 10y agoI am not convinced that this is actually theft. The "exploit" was simply code. And code rules, in the "The DAO"/ethereum world. Indeed, isn't it arguable that said insider(s) (and I agree it's probably an inseder) should identify themselves and challenge the leadership who are damaging their own credibility and that of ethereum generally? All these rollbacks -> they are the ones which are arguably illegal as they override the code. In my view, the so-called thieves have a legitimate claim on the ETH they have made and the investors in the DAO should respect the old caveat-emptor idea which is axiomatic to all investments, both inside and outside the blockchain world. They invested in a dog, and they should lose all their money. This is efficient markets at work.
- jsmeaton 10y agoIt's more like they invested in a VC firm which then siphoned off all the money into a Swiss account. You'd have recourse through the court system.
- Animats 10y agoThe "attacker" has been heard from.[1] "I am disappointed by those who are characterizing the use of this intentional feature as "theft". I am making use of this explicitly coded feature as per the smart contract terms and my law firm has advised me that my action is fully compliant with United States criminal and tort law." There's much argument over whether this is a hoax. There's a good writeup in American Banker.[2] They question whether the rules should be changed. Patrick Murck, a lawyer and researcher at Harvard University's Berkman Center: "The contract is the code, it's unstoppable code, it's unbreakable, it's self-executing and autonomous — right up until everything goes wrong. And then, 'No no no no, that's theft!' Which is some social norm that we've attached to it that's not based in the code, and then we're going to stop the whole system and basically bail it out," he said. "Is this something we're going to do every time a smart contract fails? Or is this just because there are a lot of [Ethereum] insiders in the DAO?" [1] http://pastebin.com/CcGUBgDG http://pastebin.com/CcGUBgDG [2] http://www.americanbanker.com/news/bank-technology/what-the-attack-on-the-dao-means-for-banks-1081575-1.html?zkPrintable=1&nopagination=1 http://www.americanbanker.com/news/bank-technology/what-the-...
- zenogais 10y agoThe word from the attacker is absolutely a hoax [1] [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4oo1io/an_open_letter_from_the_hacker/d4e7efq https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4oo1io/an_open_le...
- kovek 10y agoThere is an incentive to exploit contracts. Contracts that stand unexploited mean that they probably cannot be exploited. More complex contracts should re-use smaller, proven contracts. This model should work in the long term. Just make sure not to invest too much on too complicated contracts that do not re-use smaller proven contracts.
- naasking 10y ago> More complex contracts should re-use smaller, proven contracts. This assumes that compositions of unexploitable contracts are themselves not exploitable, which isn't true in general.
- kovek 10y agoOnly composed contracts which stood unexploited for longer amounts of time should have a lot of money involved. I'm not saying that there will not be flaws, but this dynamic where there is an incentive to exploit the contracts (be it composed or not) makes contracts which stood longer more interesting.