21 ms·
Salary Negotiation
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JoshDoody 10y agoHi everyone! That's me you hear talking to Patrick ;) If you have any questions about the episode or salary negotiation in general, ask away! As you can probably tell, I love talking about this stuff!
- toomuchtodo 10y agoHey Josh! Hope you don't mind me tossing the link to your workshop on youtube here. It was super helpful! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sN19aNmjBoU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sN19aNmjBoU
- JoshDoody 10y agoI don't mind one bit. Thanks for posting this!
- ohjeez 10y agoMost discussions about salary negotiation are about postponing the money discussion until we know there's a fit. But what do you do when you-as-applicant need to be sure you're not wasting your time (or theirs)? That is: I'm really senior in my field, with 25 years of experience, and for several years I've been commanding top dollar. (I'm worth it, too!) But often I start discussions with would-be employers (or clients), wherein the work sounds enjoyable, and they clearly are falling in love with me... and then a half hour later (or three days later) we come around to money ranges, only to discover their budget is half what I'd consider accepting. I can end off with, "I hope you do really well, so that you can afford me sometime soon!" but I'm always saddened and frustrated by the process. Because by that point I'm imagining how cool it would be to do that job. How do I signal to a client, "I'm expensive -- and worth it!" without saying, "Hey, can you afford me? Because otherwise let's not even talk."
- illumin8 10y agoThis exactly. I'm senior in my field (and pretty damn good), and many times recruiters will contact me about a position that sounds like a great opportunity - for example, I was recently contacted by a large financial services company who wanted to hire a senior manager to lead a cloud services team. When I told them my salary expectation, they said their range topped out at half that. First, I was a bit shocked to hear that Fortune 500 companies with $USD revenue in the billions would hire senior managers and want to pay them what would be considered an entry level salary for a good programmer right out of university, but honestly, I've defaulted to just telling them my salary because I want to avoid all the time wasting that multiple interviews would require, just to get to the point where they really like me, and would I please consider their great position where I'd have more responsibilities, longer hours, at half the salary...
- 15155 10y ago> many times recruiters will contact me Recruiters are easy: "What is the client's targeted range for this position?" or "What have you placed other people for at this company?" If the top-end of the range is within some arbitrary percentage of your target, pursue, otherwise: "no thanks!"
- cozuya 10y agoYou can turn it around on them a little bit by replying "this sounds like it may be a good fit for me, but I'll need a salary range from you in order to move forward" and then the whole conversation is short circuited.
- 15155 10y agoThird-party recruiters and staffing agencies won't have this conversation or play this game at all: they'll be 100% upfront with you upon demand. "In-house recruiters" would require that kind of short-circuiting, and it will be met with varying results. Asking: "what is the top end of your current employees' salary range for X role/experience?" can be good, too, to preempt the conversation. It's not asking them to make an offer or anchor a price for you specifically, but will save everyone time when you discover that the top-end is 40% lower than you would even interview for. If the prospective team is large and diverse enough, there will exist people that are more experienced and more-compensated than you. At that point you will at least know that they're paying it to someone. If they're not paying anyone what you expect: you do not want to be the most well-compensated or smartest person in a role at a company and should pass on general principles.
- bonobo3000 10y agoHey Josh, i have one question - how do the rules about disclosing salary change when you're talking to an external recruiter (from an agency)? I don't quite understand who's "side" they are on - on one hand, it seems reasonable to tell them the real range i'm looking for upfront so they can narrow the search, on the other hand they might reveal that to the employer..
- nfriedly 10y agoNot Josh, but I would say they're on their own side. They get paid when you accept, so the want both the company to raise it's rates and you to lower yours.
- kelukelugames 10y agoThe original blog post is one of the best reads on the topic. Especially for people who never tried to negotiate before or always failed. http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/01/23/salary-negotiation/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/01/23/salary-negotiation/
- swombat 10y agoWe're really trying to nail a good way to deal with salary negotiations when onboarding people, at GrantTree - one that gets out of this "gotcha" approach to salary. So far the best we've figured out is to be the first ones to name a number, and be super-transparent about how we arrived at that number. The reasoning is that "in a salary negotiation the first person to quote a number loses", so since we (as the employer) are in a naturally stronger position, we deliberately "lose" upfront to avoid forcing the other person into a negotiation dynamic where they're going to try and push it as high as they can, and we end up trying to push it as low as we can. I think everyone loses out from this, and it starts the working relationship with distrust. Instead, we run a pay evaluation process internally, including feedback about the value of the role and the person from all the people who interviewed the candidate. We publish all that feedback, as well as the suggestion/reasoning of our pay trustees (a group of people who use that feedback to try to place the candidate on our pay scale), along with the number this maps to, and the full pay scale, and the list of how much everyone is being paid in the company so they know where they stand (anonymised, because not everyone is comfortable yet with someone who is not yet a team member knowing their salary). So far we've successfully used this process once and it led to a great onboarding experience. It's a recent development. I hope it continues to work, and allows us to avoid the games described in this very helpful podcast. I thought I'd share it in case other employers here are struggling with the same question. This won't work in every company. Have a read through http://danieltenner.com/open-cultures/ http://danieltenner.com/open-cultures/ if you want to understand more about how we run the company - hugely important in making this work.
- sillysaurus3 10y agoInstead, we run a pay evaluation process internally, including feedback about the value of the role and the person from all the people who interviewed the candidate. We publish all that feedback, as well as the suggestion/reasoning of our pay trustees (a group of people who use that feedback to try to place the candidate on our pay scale) None of those factors are why someone is worth $X salary. You say I'm worth $X. I go get a job offer for $Y. If $Y > $X, you were mistaken. It's both as easy and as hard as that, for candidates. If you want to get anywhere close to your earning potential, you'll have to have more than one option when job seeking. It doesn't matter what you're paying other employees or whether that information is known to employees. EDIT: To clarify, this is about market value, not intrinsic value.
- vox_mollis 10y agoOne thing Patrick seems to be wholly ignorant of is that engineers, by default, maintain a very high correlation with nonassertiveness and dearth of social skills. Those stereotypes exist for a reason. For most of us, these factors are baked into our essence from childhood, and are virtually impossible to break. In the absence of concrete interaction examples or a corpus of negotiation scripts to analyze, none of his vague advice is useful for many of us.
- jerf 10y ago"One thing Patrick seems to be wholly ignorant of is that engineers..." It seems far more likely to me that Patrick has made it such a focus for him to share this advice is that he is intensely aware of it, rather than what you said.
- vox_mollis 10y agoDon't get me wrong, I understand and appreciate his motivation, but I doubt he fully comprehends the psychology he's up against. Apologies if I come across as too un-appreciatively negative toward his efforts.
- gk1 10y agoAre you aware that he was (is) a developer himself, long before he became an evangelist of charging more?
- vox_mollis 10y agoYes, I'm quite aware of this fact. But he's a socially competent developer, and my point still stands about those of us who are not.
- mason55 10y agoDid you come out of the womb knowing how to program or is it something that you spent some time on, reading, practicing, working your way through uncomfortable situations? Social competency is a skill just like any other and requires practice and learning.
- dshep 10y agoLove these, but patio11 needs a better microphone setup, its so echo-y and robotic! Please take this as helpful feedback rather than hurtful criticism.
- osipovas 10y agoDefinitely found this too. Josh Doody sounded crystal clear though.
- patio11 10y agoIt's actually less the microphone and more that I recorded this at my coworking space, whose only room for recording is literally a glass box. I'm going to try to find another room to do podcasts in -- the audio engineer flagged it, too, but shipped beats perfect.
- SyneRyder 10y agoIf you're stuck with recording in that room, perhaps you could try getting something like an SE Electronics Reflexion Filter? It's like a tiny vocal booth just for your microphone, to block reflected sounds. http://www.seelectronics.com/reflexion-filter-x/ http://www.seelectronics.com/reflexion-filter-x/ http://www.seelectronics.com/reflexion-filter-pro/ http://www.seelectronics.com/reflexion-filter-pro/ Not sure of RRP in Japan, but someone is selling the RF-x on eBay US for $80. (I don't have one myself but I've been meaning to get one for years, didn't even know they had a home-studio model until just now.)
- oafitupa 10y agoAre we still linking to this snake oil salesman?
- dang 10y agoWe asked you before not to do this. Since you didn't stop, we've banned your account. If you don't want it to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com.
- billions 10y agoWhy are developers NOT paid proportional to output? A 5x developer should get paid more than a 2x dev but that doesn't seem to happen
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Why are developers NOT paid proportional to output? Because measuring business value of output of individual developers on a team is not easily done, and other output measures (e.g., SLOC) tend to be things that, if tied to pay, would create obvious adverse incentives.
- wccrawford 10y agoIndeed. I had an employer that told me my output was too low for the first few years. Then we had a security audit (following an event) and my code was the only code that came through squeaky clean. They didn't talk about the amount of my output after that. It's not easy to measure the value of someone's work, even years later, and certainly not immediately.
- etjossem 10y ago10x engineer: a developer who incurs technical debt so fast he appears more productive than the ten developers tasked with cleaning his mess up. [1] [1] http://10x.engineer http://10x.engineer
- maxxxxx 10y agoHow do you measure that? Most hard metrics like number of bugs fixed or lines of code are easily abused.
- FLUX-YOU 10y agoWhat do you do if you find a security exploit down the road that costs the company thousands but you already paid for his output?
- vladimirralev 10y agoThis just seems like a walkthrough how to educate a shitty manager who got their "business-degree" from dilbert comic strips. The last thing a manager wants to do is to lowball a guy who's performance depends on his own good faith. If I have to explain to the manager why this is a bad idea and why he is putting me at disadvantage while keeping key information from me and using sleazy tactics he saw in the "boiler room" against me then how can I trust this guy to have my back in the future? I got to say this almost never happens in the big5 companies nowadays. There are countless internal trainings for recruiters specifically not to do stuff like that and especially anything remotely similar to what you see in pop-culture. I mean what are the chances none of your candidates would have seen "Suits" or "The Wolf from Wall Str." after all? Even if you manage to hire somebody below their market rate it will be just a few months hanging out with peers and he will find out and be resentful.
- jonknee 10y agoIt turns out there are a lot more than 5 companies out there in the marketplace... And if you think you got a fair initial offer you almost certainly did not.
- vladimirralev 10y agoI referred to top5 just as an example of professionalism, possibly backed by tons of data and analytics internally too. Which to me means it's the best methodology currently known. Well if I didn't get a fair initial offer then the manager must think the risk of me finding out will not affect his goals. I accept that, as long as they accept it too. But I don't want to find out I was lied to and then expect me to be loyal.
- ffn 10y agoHe doesn't even have to hang out with peers, one simple search across some popular job site nowadays (e.g. glassdoor) will immediately land you with a decent salary amount for your desired position. We've already entered the brave new world where the concept "salary is private information" is dead, and, if one is a developer active on Github (or other OSS platform), then the concept "my work portfolio is private" is also dead. So you're absolutely right, the worst thing for a hiring manager and a potential employee to do is set themselves up into adversarial positions of who can best manipulate and "break" the other person first. Because a company built with employees and management who can't trust each other, and are in constant underground wars to gouge the most out of each other, is bound to get trounced by competitor companies in the open market
- jknz 10y agoWhat follows is an honest salary determination process, where no party has incentive to lie. It is also very fast. The rules are as follows. (Can't remember where I read about this.) The company and the candidate write on a piece of paper a salary. The company should write the number above which it is not willing to pay the candidate. The candidate writes the number under which she/he is not willing to work for that company. The numbers are disclosed. If there is an overlap, they sign a contract and the salary is the average of the two numbers. Otherwise, there is no hiring. Edit: the parties can play this game only once
- pillowkusis 10y agoyou still have a strong incentive to lie, do you not? Since the final salary is the average of the two numbers, employers want to go as low as they can and prospects want to go as high as they can. in fact, this system punishes honesty even more than the current one -- if I am honest and the other person is dishonest, the dishonest person wins because they will pull the average in the direction they want and I get a worse deal than if we were both honest.
- jknz 10y agoSay the candidate is honest, wants 120k and writes down 120k. Say the company honestly wants candidate ufo 130k or less. Company plays is dishonest card and writes down 110k. Then the candidate leaves and there is no hire. If company had been honest she would have hired a fitting candidate for 125k, less than the most that company was willing to offer (130k).
- pillowkusis 10y agosay the candidate wants 150 but would take as low as 120. so she writes down 120. she's actually worth 150. the company is willing to hire her at up to 150. But instead, they say 130. She gets hired at 125 as a result. If they had negotiated, they certainly would have settled closer to 150. Her honesty cost her 12k/yr. The company profits immensely from its dishonesty as long as they say a number just above the candidate's lowest.
- arielweisberg 10y agoMy observation is that salary negotiation has little to do with negotiation. The management side of the table is never thinking in terms of economics and has no idea what their BATNA is. I think this comes from HR and leadership which can't quantify what the right balance is for comp vs their BATNA. For engineers this is especially challenging because metrics are hard to come by and correlate with the $$$ going out the door.
- TrickzOnU 10y agoI've been working for over a decade. There is ONE and ONLY ONE rule i've seen universally followed by HR -- your pay rises with the # of people reporting to you. Regardless of whatever managers say about running a lean shop or budget or whatever -- the more people you hire and manager, the more money you make. If you can do the work in six months, tell them 18 and hire two others. If you can do the work with 4 FTEs, tell them 12 FTEs and get a nice promotion. Increase employment, get great documentation and unit tests, and play to the foolish HR policies HR has cooked up. When people get paid for productivity, then switch to lean. Until then, play to the metric they set.
- 15155 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- OhHeyItsE 10y agoI've had multiple situations where I did answer (honestly, too - before I knew any better) the "dreaded" question up front and had the recruiter tell me: "Wow. You must work for a really great company! We can't even come close to matching that." Process ended right there, countless time saved. So, as with all things, YMMV.
- ThomaszKrueger 10y agoSame here. As soon as I say what I make recruiters usually congratulate me on making what I make and won't call me back. So recruiters are only good for run of the mill, entry level folks, not really for highly skilled or specialized developers.
- nissimk 10y agoYes, they're frequently just looking for butts to put in chairs. Getting the numbers out of the way first helps to avoid wastes of time. But the other side is true also for more junior or underpaid developers. They need to use tactics like these to get themselves to the right side of the bell curve. Once you've developed the experience and skills and had the good luck necessary to move you into the upper range of compensation, it helps to tell them right away to avoid wasting time with employers who aren't interested in paying up for senior talent. Again, though, if you know the potential employer has paid rates / compensation in the range you are looking for in the past, it is also safe to delay because you may get a better offer even coming from an already high compensation.
- fourneau 10y agoIt depends what kind of recruiters you use. At the end of the day, the company that hires the recruiters (whether they're in-house or an external company) should be fine tuning the recruiter's filtering system. With enough patience and direction they can be excellent to find high skilled individuals who are looking for a new job.
- bitwize 10y agoIf they're just looking for butts in seats, why do crooters stop talking to you unless you have at least n years experience (n often quite large) in the client's exact tech stack? "They're looking for a candidate who's ready to hit the ground running..."
- TrickzOnU 10y agoLet me share my horror story -- I fell for a company that offered me the same salary (no raise despite big promotion.) Then, he (Division CTO of Fortune 500 medical company) started subtracting salary from this baseline for all my "benefits" like free shuttles, 401k matching, etc. I was supposed to take the lower wage in exchange for amazing work, 3 fully paid conferences a year, yada yadda. Two months into joining, the shuttle went from free to paid. Ouch. Then, the manager expected me to stay late 3x a week, which meant i could not even take the shuttle 3x a week, and instead have to take a taxi. Still not enough salary to buy a car + insurance + parking. Then policy changed and 401k match disappeared. Finally, policy changed and all conference reimbursements ended. Final blow -- my PDP is tied to 3 conference posters a year, so i pay out of pocket for travel/registration/hotel. By the way, the work is great, but i'm paying so much out of pocket that i'm getting the hell out of there. Sucks for me. Sucks for the manager too -- I spend half the day now doing eLance projects.
- ceejayoz 10y agoYowch. When you say "subtracting salary", do you mean in the offer, or after you were hired?
- TrickzOnU 10y agoI was given a salary figure, until I got on-site for the final round, at which i got a very hard sell and the reveal -- some of the salary was "in kind" -- free shuttle bus, 401k match, etc (all in policy, not in offer letter.) Policy changed shortly after I joined, and I learned the policy change was being discussed months before I joined -- so the hiring manager extracted these concessions knowing full well they perks may be reduced or removed.
- igorgue 10y ago>> the manager expected me to stay late 3x a week I'd argue the job isn't that great.
- erikb 10y agoYou are probably trying to show us how bad your employer is. What I'm reading though, is how you should have walked away at least 5 times in the process. What part of the work is actually "great" btw. I would guess you don't have any other job yet. Because everything sounds very horrible.
- jboggan 10y agoThe main thing that I liked about using Hired.com during a previous job search was that they made the salary offers very transparent during the bidding phase and it completely avoided sticking me, the candidate, with the salary question. By the time I started interviewing at companies their initial salary offer was more than what I would have been able to negotiate myself, mostly because I didn't even know to ask for that much.
- codegeek 10y agoWhenever I am negotiating a salary, even if I have to reveal what I make now, I will end that statement with "But based on my experience and value that I bring to the table, I am expecting at least xyz for my new role otherwise it is not worth it for me to quit my current job". This way, you make the whole "current salary" irrelevant. The point is that any good employer will NEVER let go of a candidate who is an excellent fit for their role but they had a huge gap in current vs desired. They only let go of candidates who either are not a good fit OR are asking for a very very high number that is literally out of the budget assigned (more applicable to larger corps.). But then again, it has nothing to do with current salary crap.
- rm999 10y agoCompletely agreed on negotiating without the "current salary" perspective. I've always requested to keep my current salary secret, but I've never met a hiring manager/HR recruiter that's ok with this. I suppose knowing what I make comforts them that their offer isn't completely crazy, but I think it's also evidence of a disturbing bias against the unemployed/underemployed.
- 15155 10y ago> I've never met a hiring manager/HR recruiter that's ok with this There's a very simple position to take here: "My compensation is a function of the value I will be providing to your company, not the value I provide to my current employer." Be assertive. At least in the United States, short of a backchannel reference check, a prospective employer has absolutely no way of confirming anything you say - a fact that can be brought to light if this kind of question ever comes up. At the moment, for good talent, it's a seller's market. > evidence of a disturbing bias against the unemployed/underemployed There is a definite bias against un(der)employed. This has been well studied. Furthermore: your BATNA while employed is infinitely better (for most people).
- tyre 10y agoTwo things we have done to fix the waste of time, human energy, and shenanigans around salaries: 1) Post salaries with job descriptions. (e.g. seneca.systems/careers/growth/go-to-market-strategist-product-marketer) 2) Pin salaries to job position[1]. We do not allow individuals to negotiate their salary separately from their position. If you have the same position, you make the same salary. [1]: https://github.com/SenecaSystems/employee_handbook/blob/master/compensation/salary.markdown https://github.com/SenecaSystems/employee_handbook/blob/mast...
- green_lunch 10y ago"We do not allow individuals to negotiate their salary separately from their position. If you have the same position, you make the same salary." This is great from a company perspective, but it essentially allows a company to get an employee at a much cheaper rate. Employees with more experience will get the same pay rate for the same job as someone with potentially much less. Since all companies don't do this, I probably wouldn't ever work for your company knowing this is your policy. I bring much more value to a company with all of the experience and knowledge that I've gained. At my last 9-5 job, I was able to get paid almost 20% more than many of my co-workers because of my negotiating skills and experience. I just have to shake my head when I see so many people fighting for less power, rights, and inevitably less money and calling it a 'win'. But, this doesn't really matter to me anymore. I've owned my own company for the last 5 years and don't need to negotiate my own salary.
- hyperpape 10y agoDon't companies that try that sort of thing usually have well defined bands? Software Engineer I, II, III, etc?
- marssaxman 10y agoI can't make any sense out of your argument. How on earth does this drive away people with experience? I know what I can do and I know how much money I want to make. A company advertising a job with a salary attached would get some bonus points in my evaluation just because of their honesty and willingness to step out of the bullshit negotiation game, but I'd also know up front whether their expectations corresponded with mine. I'd only apply if it sounded like a reasonable offer, and if it sounded like a reasonable offer, why should I hesitate to apply? Your perspective must be very different from mine, because I am totally failing to see this from a point of view where I can make your words make sense.
- jldugger 10y ago> How to avoid the “What is your desired salary?” question Already off to a bad start. Just like we assume that advertisements without a salary range will be shitty salaries, employers assume applicants who dodge this question have a shitty BATNA. A good answer to this question is "x% more than I'm making now, and high enough to outbid competing offers from companies A, B and C." But if you want to avoid answering the question, a good response is "you advertised at 80k-100k, and that is admissable, but you will need to beat offers from companies A, B and C."
- Mendenhall 10y agoIt was always pretty simple for me personally, If you don't want to pay me what I want, you are free to hire someone else. I find the most important part is being able to walk away, If you negotiate from a position of weakness or need you are behind already. If I am hiring I know what I can afford to pay, what I think the position is "worth" and what I want out of it and make an offer according. I like ideally to pay for work not for hours etc, if you give me what I want I don't care if I am paying you $3000 dollars and you worked a half hour and slept for a week out of town, I would consider that smart and efficient. I find its the person who is applying that has the power not the company and I think that's an important lesson for people who are applying to learn. If "they" are not willing to pay me what I want, that puts us on a bad start already.
- JoblessWonder 10y ago> I find its the person who is applying that has the power not the company I think you are assuming the person applying has some sort of safety net (a current job, savings, alternate income.) That is where the BATNA comes into play. Sure, if you are already making an acceptable amount of money to meet your needs, aren't overworked/over-stressed, and relatively satisfied then you are indeed in a position of power. If you need to get hired some place within 2 months and have been having trouble getting a job then you very well might not be in a position of power. Not all people have the ability to walk away.
- Mendenhall 10y agoThen the person applying will be in a position of weakness. That to me is letting "worry" even if real drag you down. I think when you really need something it is even more important to negotiate from a position of strength, if not they will sense it and pick it apart. In some ways its much like dating, does anyone really want the desperate type ?
- vertex-four 10y ago"Always be able to walk away" is not very good advice to people who don't have the option to walk away, whether people should always have that option or not in a perfect world. "Pretend you're able to walk away" possibly is, but not everyone's good at playing games like that. The alternative to not working is, eventually, losing almost everything you have. The alternative to not having a romantic partner is, well, not having a romantic partner. You're not going to die from lack of love.
- igonvalue 10y agoPatrick, it seems like this latest episode isn't available on iTunes. Maybe it's related to the error message I see when I load the feed in my browser [0] > This page contains the following errors: > error on line 3559 at column 476: Input is not proper UTF-8, indicate encoding ! Bytes: 0xE3 0x81 0xA8 0xE3 [0] http://www.kalzumeus.com/category/podcasts/feed/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/category/podcasts/feed/
- patio11 10y agoIt's in iTunes. Sometimes there is a delay for them to crawl the feed. Another issue might be that, if you haven't listened to me recently, your client might not grab updates. (Totally reasonable since nothing was published in several months.)
- calcsam 10y agoRe: stock options: I built http://optionvalue.io http://optionvalue.io as a tool to help engineers at startups understand what their options are worth. Even if you don't know anything about stock options, it will walk you step-by-step through the numbers you need, give you a value, and show you the math behind that number.
- pm215 10y agoSo something I'd like to get advice on is: what do you do negotiation-wise if actually salary is not the thing you care most about? Suppose you (for health reasons or just because you don't need the extra money and like the reduced stress) want or need to work less than the usual five-day week -- at what point do you bring up the "hey, how about a four-day week" question, when the typical employer is looking for a five-day-a-week full time employee? If you raise it early then it seems like they're just going to file your application in the bin, but bringing it up only at the end seems kind of awkwardly blindsiding them... (I can see how it would work negotiating this as an already-established employee where you're a known quantity to the employer and they'd rather not lose you altogether, but not how to get that kind of setup from the start with a new employer.)
- eastbayjake 10y agoIt seems like the same principle is in play: demonstrate your value first, then talk about terms after they're sold on you and want to make an offer. I can't imagine any company that would flat-out refuse a talented candidate over a 4-day week request, but I think most would sideline you if it was brought up before you'd demonstrated the value you can add to their business. In fact, I'll bet many companies would view a 10% paycut for a 10% reduction in hours (4 days @ 9 hrs/day) as a no-brainer win to get a talented hire.
- zenlikethat 10y agoI don't think so. 4 day work week would be a deal breaker for most companies. If Joe gets hired in and never works Fridays pretty soon everyone else will want Fridays off too. Salary is irrelevant, it's human nature.
- eastbayjake 10y agoI previously had a colleague reduce days in exchange for a pay cut, it was clearly messaged to us (a small startup) that there was a tradeoff happening, and the rest of us were happy to make more money working 5 days/week. I think the human nature part is wanting to be treated fairly -- it's unfair if you get paid the same and work less, but it feels fair if you make more money for working more.
- blazespin 10y agoThe problem with more salary is more responsibility. More likely to be cut if you don't perform at the level commensurate with the salary.
- logicalmind 10y agoYep, and this really becomes a problem has you advance in years. I'm a programmer and have been for almost 20 years. When you're younger, you are always negotiating upwards. When you're at a job making 70k and you leave, you go to a new job and ask for 80k. But then you're 40 and making a lot more. Now the question as to what you are offered is different. If they're paying you to be a "programmer", can they really justify that huge salary? They can hire multiple college grads for what they're paying you. So it's not so much about your direct programming skill, but your experience/knowledge/wisdom that they are paying for. And each company is going to value that differently. Your options really come down to whether you want to truly remain a "programmer" in which you may have to make some concessions to compete with the other programmers in the market. Your responsibilities remain that of a programmer. Or you have to take on a manager/director/architect role which is less programming skill and more people management skill with a lot more responsibility.
- 15155 10y agoArguably, with that much experience, you would make more money consulting. Instead of being seen as a curmudgeon who could be replaced by four college grads, you're an external, automatically-trusted authority who commands a healthy day rate. It's just a matter of optics. Though that life isn't for everyone.
- whack 10y agoI've heard this "don't name a number first" advice so many times, but personally, it never seems to work. My current comp is significantly higher compared to others with my level of experience. So when I refuse to give a number, the recruiter ends up guessing a number that is significantly lower, and making a lowball offer. I've also had many other experiences where after many hours of interviews, I find out that the company is unable to make me a competitive offer, because my current comp is too high. I'm seriously considering abandoning this advice in future, and simply just naming my comp expectations right at the start.
- SapphireSun 10y agoThe point of the advice seems to be that you might get lucky and they'll name a higher price, so if you happen to know that they won't you have more information than they do and can set the anchor point appropriately I suppose. I'm not going to claim I'm some kind of master negotiator though.
- daxfohl 10y agoPerhaps try turning it on its head. Ask the interviewer what their salary range is, before they ask you.
- linkregister 10y agoThis sounds like some naive advice. Almost always salary range is discussed through a recruiter. This likely will be fruitless and will make you look like an amateur.
- withdavidli 10y agoAdding to linkregister's reply. Unless it's the hiring manager, the interviewer likely doesn't have access to that information. The interviews are to judge skill and if everyone wants to work with one another. There are also different leveling with the title, so they won't know the range until all the interviews are finished. And while money is important, it comes off as you're only interested in the money to the interviewer. Your statement also says interviewer instead of recruiter, was that a mistake? I have never had an interviewer discussing salary range, maybe cost of living in the area, but not salary range for the role.
- daxfohl 10y agoHas anyone tried to beat the interviewer to the punch on the salary question? Put them on the spot by asking their range before they hit you with it?
- basseq 10y agoYes, but it's typically a factor of a bad HR department. Don't let the recruiter hang up on that first phone screen without satisfying yourself that they could make a competitive offer. Otherwise, you're just wasting time. They should have the same desire, hence this is only an issue with bad HR departments. It's not worth it to jump to salary immediately. You come off as either selfish or naive. So yes, I've done it. You get to the end of that call, and you realize you haven't talked compensation. So you tie in with interest and next steps: "Sounds like I could be a great fit for this position, and I look forward to talking further with the team to confirm that. I do want to make sure we're on the same page in terms of compensation..." Then you go from there.
- 15155 10y ago> You come off as either selfish or naive. Or, if framed appropriately, expensive and valuable. Your time is money. You do not want to waste it on a role that has compensatory packages beneath what you'd be willing to take. You are a professional doing another professional a favor. Framing this correctly is a bit more nuanced, however. If you're talking to an external recruiting or staffing agency, however: immediately jump to salary. They will not hesitate and have no opinion on you as a candidate. You're saving their time and they're not emotionally staked in the possible negotiations to come.
- jadengore 10y agoJosh Doody has been doing great talks on this for a while. Haven't read the article, but I've heard some of his other work. Should be a good read.
- paulsutter 10y agoTwo ways to answer the "current salary" question - say that your salary expectations depend on the work, the people, the work hours, vacation policy, etc, so it's too early to discuss salary, or - ask what the company pays people in the same position. They won't tell you, but that establishes concretely that it's private information. If they do share the information with you, you can respond with "my expectations are higher", or "that's within my expectations". And then if they persist in asking yours, you can choose to answer or to stonewall. You got the data, so now the mystery is over and you have control of the conversation. This comes across weak, phony, and panderish: > I think the best way to answer the current salary part is to say something, like that you’re not comfortable sharing that information, and you prefer to focus on the value that you can add to the company, and not what you’re paid at your current job This sounds clownish, like playing a game: > “Well, if you’re trying to qualify me for a range, why don’t you tell me the range, and I’ll tell you if I’m in the ballpark?” This sounds wonky and comes across as an insincere: > “I’ve been entrusted with a variety of information by my current firm. I intend to keep their confidences on that sort of thing. They consider their salary compensation private.
- shostack 10y agoAgree with most of this. However I'd say that asking "can you share your range" when appended to your first recommended response can be very powerful. By making clear that you don't have enough info about the opportunity to properly value it, but recognizing that they need to qualify you based on their range, you're putting the ball firmly in their court to bring more data to the table. Companies who remain firm about not giving out any info but demanding a salary from you are probably not places you want to work.
- marssaxman 10y agoWhat a gross, unpleasant world this article describes.
- floodyberry- 10y ago"How to trick everyone in to over-paying and over-compensating you, which you can then use to become even more over-paid and over-compensated as you hop jobs" I guess "How to break the cycle of greed" probably wouldn't go over too well with them or their target audience.
- jboydyhacker 10y agoI disagree with the advice on avoiding the "what is your target comp" in current market conditions. Unless the market gets a lot worse- give the number that would make you happy and expect to get it. Generally, in a startup the last thing I want to spend time on is replacing good engineers because their salary was below market. In short- If I want to hire the person - I just give them the number they ask for. Recruiting is the worst time sink and better to spend time on retaining the folks you have and improving your business.
- nunez 10y agoI think the most important bit about negotiation that I've learned and read is this: if you're not willing to walk away, your attempts to negotiate will fail. If you're not willing to say "sorry we can't come to a middle ground here" and leave the conversation with no regrets, you'll eventually cave in and lose. (This has been my biggest problem wrt salary negotiations. When I get an offer from a company that I like, I'm almost always unwilling to give it up. Having multiple offers on the table is the best alternative to this.)
- matrix 10y agoHaving been on both sides of the hiring process many times, there's some useful tactical ideas in this podcast, but in my experience tactics should only play a small role. As a candidate for a job, before you go to any interview (even a phone screen) you need to know what the local market salary range is for the type of job in you are applying for. If you don't know that, you're in a position of weakness and any amount of verbal judo isn't going to be useful. A good hiring manager will not try to cheat you - they will make you a fair and reasonable offer. It might be at the low end of reasonable, but nevertheless it will be reasonable. If they give you a ridiculous lowball, they're not a good hiring manager, and at that point you should just walk away. Even if they come back with a reasonable offer. You don't want to work for a company or a boss that thinks that's ok to do to people. A good hiring manager will not ask you your current salary. They might ask you early in the process: "what are your salary expectations?". It is acceptable to not name a number and just say something to the effect of "competitive market salary" which should signal to the hiring manager that you know what that range is, as does he, and you're good with that. If you need to give a number, just state range near the top of the local market salary range and move on. Yes, there's a theoretical risk that you've anchored yourself lower than they might pay, but you've anchored yourself at the top of the market range - not exactly a terrible outcome. Caveat: this advice might not apply when dealing with a recruiter.
- matrix 10y agoHaving been on both sides of the hiring process many times, I think there's some useful tactical ideas in this podcast, but I think they're missing the forest for the trees. As a candidate for a job, before you go to any interview (even a phone screen) you need to know what the local market salary range is for the type of job in you are applying for. If you don't know that, you're in a position of weakness and any amount of verbal judo isn't going to be useful. A good hiring manager will not try to cheat you - they will make you a fair and reasonable offer. It might be at the low end of reasonable, but nevertheless it will be reasonable. If they give you a ridiculous lowball, they're not a good hiring manager, and at that point you should just walk away. Even if they come back with a reasonable offer. You don't want to work for a company or a boss that thinks that's ok to do to people. A good hiring manager will not ask you your current salary. They might ask you early in the process: "what are your salary expectations?". It is acceptable to not name a number and just say something to the effect of "competitive market salary" which should signal to the hiring manager that you know what that range is, as does he, and you're good with that. If you need to give a number, just state range near the top of the local market salary range and move on. Yes, there's a theoretical risk that you've anchored yourself lower than they might pay, but you've anchored yourself at the top of the market range - not exactly a terrible outcome. Caveat: this advice might not apply when dealing with a recruiter.
- matrix 10y agoHaving been on both sides of the hiring process many times, I think there's some useful tactical ideas in this podcast, but I think they're missing the forest for the trees. As a candidate for a job, before you go to any interview (even a phone screen) you need to know what the local market salary range is for the type of job in you are applying for. If you don't know that, you're in a position of weakness and any amount of verbal judo isn't going to be useful. A good hiring manager will not try to cheat you - they will make you a fair and reasonable offer. It might be at the low end of reasonable, but nevertheless it will be reasonable. If they give you a ridiculous lowball, they're not a good hiring manager, and at that point you should just walk away. Even if they come back with a reasonable offer. You don't want to work for a company or a boss that thinks that's ok to do to people. A good hiring manager will not ask you your current salary. They might ask you early in the process: "what are your salary expectations?". It is acceptable to not name a number and just say something to the effect of "competitive market salary" which should signal to the hiring manager that you know what that range is, as does he, and you're good with that. If you need to give a number, just state range near the top of the local market salary range and move on. Yes, there's a theoretical risk that you've anchored yourself lower than they might pay, but you've anchored yourself at the top of the market range - not exactly a terrible outcome. Caveat: this advice might not apply when dealing with a recruiter.
- OpenDrapery 10y agoHas anyone had much success with negotiating the health care benefits out of the equation? For example, if your spouse carries the benefits, then you don't need them. I'm guessing most employers don't have the luxury of substituting $20k in salary in lieu of healthcare.
- Radle 10y agoAnyone an idea what I can reasonable expect as a student in Germany? I am working for a company in the Metal industry as a software Developer. I am working very independently.
- nunez 10y agoI've heard that negotiating a higher salary at companies decreases what you can get for bonuses/profit-sharing. Is that true?
- sokoloff 10y agoIt's unlikely to be -EV for you to do so. Technically, the higher the salary they pay you, the less profit there is to share, so absolutely, a higher salary will reduce the profit sharing. (you can immediately see how this is massively beneficial to you, of course). Also, your future raises might (or might not) be smaller if you come in on the high end of the range. Some companies have a formulaic "X%" type of system, which means you want to start as high as possible. Others target a ratio to some fictitious "market reference" where a higher initial salary will result in lower future raises, which STILL means you want to start as high as possible. Some company somewhere no doubt has a policy that works as you describe/fear. The overwhelming majority do not.
- 15155 10y agoEven if it were, it can anchor your next role at a much higher place. Compare job hopping and seeing 15+% base salary bumps each hop to possible, but not definite (often meager) raises + possible bonuses: rarely is the prospect (gamble) of a bonus worth the career trajectory + salary hit.
- analognoise 10y agoGo on 2 interviews a year no matter what. Always ask for more than you think you'll be able to get. Ignore talk about culture if they think that makes up for salary - it doesn't.
- mathgenius 10y agoMy fantasy negotiation scenario: ME: "Ok so you are willing to pay me 200k to work 8-9 hours a day, how about paying me 100k to work 4-5 hours a day?" THEM: "sounds awesome"
- jeremysalwen 10y agoWhat would be a realistic path to negotiating part time when full time work is expected?
- mathgenius 10y agoYeah, I don't know, hence the "fantasy" adjective. But, somewhat realistically, the cream of my day lasts on average about 4 hours (longer when i'm hot, shorter when i'm not). So this really would be a bargain for an employer.
- oaf357 10y agoI have always been honest with what I'm being compensated. In six years I've nearly doubled my salary.
- dvcrn 10y agoI hate salary negotiations. I'm just not good at them. Especially when I'm forced to do it on the phone. Right now I'm earning a good chunk less than my coworkers with same or lower working experience and it's slightly annoying. On the other side I know of a really good coworker that earns even less than me. I'm a strong supporter of open salaries. Don't give people who can negotiate better more but implement a system that applies to everyone the same. Take seniority into account, work experience, a base and calculate the salary of every engineer based on that. Fair and open.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoJust throw out the number you want, after giving them the clear picture that you think they're more or less making a mistake. Go high. All they can do is counter. I've seen a salary number printed in the initial job ad. If that number doesn't work for me, I don't pursue the ad. If they ask me for a number, that's the number they get - with the observation that it was printed on the ad.