10 ms·
Wal-Mart Plans to Test Grocery Delivery Through Uber, Lyft
- mathattack 10y agoIt seems like Uber and Lyft are currently doing deals like this as big special one-offs. At what point do real world services like this become plug and play via APIs?
- venomsnake 10y agoWhen we remove the pesky wetware
- mathattack 10y agoCan't you see a world where Lyft or Uber offers themselves as a platform? "You put in the weight and dimensions of the object to be transported, and we'll give you pricing and an ETA for pickup and delivery" People could then choose to do the delivery similar to how they choose to pick people up. Perhaps there's a premium (similar to surge pricing?) based on size.
- jamesmishra 10y agoThere already are APIs for booking rides and package delivery through Uber. See https://developer.uber.com/ https://developer.uber.com/ (Disclosure: I work on the Uber API team.)
- Cherian_Abraham 10y agoWould be interesting to know how and who shoulders the liability here?
- maxerickson 10y agoWalmart has all the reputation risk. Which whatever anyone wants to say about Walmart's reputation, it's pointless to offer the service if they let it suck.
- drglitch 10y agoCall me old fashioned but I still would trust UPS/FedEx more with my packages - as opposed to contracted amateurs. Granted, last mile delivery is always a challenge... How long until you can get a freight van through uber's subprime leasing program?
- awqrre 10y agoI'd be ok with it if the package had a security seal on it...
- lujim 10y agoAgreed, but to be fair that was how I felt about having Uber driving me around when I first heard about it a few years ago.
- pigeons 10y agoAnd that's why I don't use Uber, their drivers are much less professional (smoking, loud music, don't know the area, poor driving skills) than taxi drivers.
- samdb 10y agoIn the UK we have Yodel, which is essentially 'contracted amateurs' delivering in their own vehicles.
- BostonEnginerd 10y agoFedEx used to operate like that - the drivers were private contactors who had to buy their own equipment: https://www.publicintegrity.org/2012/04/02/8565/fedex-fails-deliver-drivers https://www.publicintegrity.org/2012/04/02/8565/fedex-fails-... http://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwood/2015/06/16/fedex-settles-driver-mislabeling-case-for-228-million/#e0b48dd5f5aa http://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwood/2015/06/16/fedex-sett...
- lujim 10y agoThis is going to take a bit of magic to pull off. Groceries are very low margin items and people just opt for pre-made restaurant food when we are feeling lazy. When I'm motivated enough to prepare my own food I'm motivated enough to go to the grocery store. This is the domain of driver-less delivery vehicles of whatever kind.
- rimantas 10y agoThere are also moms (and sometimes dads) at home with a small kids. And they may be highly motivated to avoid journey to a grocery store.
- lujim 10y agoAgreed, and I'm in the boat. However those same people tend to have less disposable income and seem to be less apt to pay monthly fees or premiums for luxuries. When you think families think more bulk generic costco toilet paper and less "convenience fee" of any kind
- jerf 10y agoWhile I agree there's an inevitable correlation there, since children are (reductionistically, financially) an expense and households that have an additional expense will be poorer than their equivalent household without that expense, I think you may still be overstating the poverty-inducing effects of children a wee bit.
- lujim 10y agoI've been Single Income/Single, Dual Income No Kids (DINK), dual income with kids and single income with kids. Kids won't completely destroy your finances but 529 plans/day care alone can put a hurting on your finances. You become much more financially responsible and less likely to pay for luxury services (for yourself) like HBO, Spotify, Netflix, Gym membership, high lease car payment etc after you have kids.
- 10y ago
- nebulous1 10y agoI'm torn between wanting somebody to compete with Amazon and it being Walmart
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eli 10y agoAlso Instacart and Google Express and Peapod.
- ghaff 10y agoYes. This is somewhat newsworthy as it's another example of Uber/Lyft's interest in becoming more broadly-based logistics companies. However, grocery delivery already exists. It's just remained something of a niche. My speculation is that the reason is some combination of "I want to look at the produce," "I don't want to pay $10 for delivery," "I'm just not organized enough to sit down at my computer and input my order," and "I've always just gone to the grocery store." Personally, I find Walmart to be a mediocre grocery store that I only go to because it's convenient. Given the other options that already exist for me, I would have pretty much zero interest in getting delivery from Walmart. I'd be using Peapod if I wanted it.
- imroot 10y agoMy issues with Instacart is that not every shopper knows how to shop for produce. I order avocados from instacart: They're all black on the inside when I cut into them. I order specialty chips or cheeses? They're marked as "Item out of stock," but when I run to the same grocery store that they shopped at after my delivery it's right there in plain sight to me. I order deli meat from Instacart? They ignore my comments about how I would like it to be sliced and deliver it to me shredded. Outside of that? I love instacart -- as long as they're packaged goods (pick and ship) and they're not hot deli items or cold/frozen items (I've had drivers put yogurt in the same bag as a lot of frozen veggies and peas and stuff that shouldn't have been frozen was frozen.)
- 10y ago
- nxzero 10y agoCore issue long-term is that if Amazon doesn't own the "last mile" it will be at the mercy of those that do; clearly, Jeff knows this, though unclear how he's going to address this long-term.
- TorKlingberg 10y agoUK supermarkets are a bit ahead of the curve here. All the large ones have a home delivery service, including Walmart-owned ASDA. It's quite cheap too: £1-6 if you buy £40, for various time slots. They all use their own vehicles and staff, so I suppose Wal-Mart can reduce the risk by using Uber/Lyft. I wonder though, does this mean no active cooling on the way? Can you trust that the ice cream is still frozen when it arrives? I have found home delivery very useful, especially after having a baby. I don't enjoy going to a supermarket after work on weekdays, but receiving a delivery is easy and means the weekend is free. The main psychological barrier is that it takes surprisingly long to choose groceries online, almost as long as walking around the store. They try to make it easier by suggesting things you usually order, but it's still something you have set aside time for.
- wiremine 10y agoWhat is the ordering experience like? Do you have a set order that comes on a regular basis? Or are they one-off orders, or a mix?
- martin-adams 10y agoAs someone who has used Sainsburys, Asda, Tesco and Ocado. There is much room for improvement in the ordering process. Ocado are the best, but they are expensive. Sainsburys pulled their dedicated app and you have to use the crappy mobile web.
- mcintyre1994 10y agoThey remember and pre-load your order for you, but you can modify it freely before making it. I'd agree with the sibling comment though - they're not standout good online experiences, and I haven't tried any of them on mobile.
- KJKingJ 10y agoMine are always one off orders. I'll log on, choose an hourly timeslot for delivery and then browse down a list of products i've purchased before (both online and instore) and chose which ones I want to be delivered. It takes about 10-15 minutes to do and they will deliver everything right to my door. It ends up being a huge timesaver compared to having to go to and from the supermarket and pick everything out. I tend to place an order about once every 2-3 weeks, and supplement it with "top up" shops for fresh items (meat, veg etc) in a mini-supermarket on my way home from work every so often.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoI'm always surprised grocery delivery is still a big deal in the US. All the major supermarkets in the UK do home delivery, next day, for a £3-5 delivery fee. You can go the site, fill your basket, and checkout. You also get a 1-2 hour delivery slot so you don't have to wait at home all day. We also have Amazon Prime Now doing grocery delivery within 1 hour in some cities. I can see how it would be a problem in some less densely populated areas in the US but how it's not done in all cities is beyond me. Any one know?
- PickledJesus 10y agoIf you do it in the evening it's only £1 usually. Hardly any reason to go to the supermarket anymore.
- brianbreslin 10y agoMy guess is that its due to traditionally very sprawled out cities in the US. Huge amounts of the population live miles away from grocery stores. I think in New York you were able to get delivery for years for groceries if you were willing to pay the local grocer extra.
- blackguardx 10y agoWhen I lived in New York 5 years ago, every grocery store I went to had some sort of delivery option.
- TorKlingberg 10y agoCan you order through their website, app, etc? I'm not going to call in a weeks grocery shopping over the phone.
- schrodinger 10y agoPeapod, fresh direct, Google shopping express, max delivery, Amazon fresh, to name a few. We use peapod for almost all of our groceries, ordering about every other week Even a lot of bodegas have their own little websites for ordering.
- jokoon 10y agoPlanning in advance could really save a lot of gas, time and money if customers decided to shop online more. The last mile seems like a tough headache in term of logistics, but I'm sure there are many people who would love to not go shopping if it was convenient enough. Although I don't think it will viable at first, so I doubt that market will really grow, since the economies of scale only happen if enough people shop online in a small region. Ultimately companies like Walmart still want customers to roam in their supermarkets to buy things they did intend to, as a virtual store and online ads seems less appealing than a customer just wandering in an aisle and discovering an article.
- mtgx 10y agoIt would also reduce traffic in cities.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoIsn't this a bit going the wrong way somehow? Growing up, mom went grocery shopping once every 2 weeks. We'd load up 2 or 3 shopping carts that filled 8 or 10 grocery bags. One auto trip every 2 weeks for groceries. With all the delivery services for restaurants, groceries, and more and more sundries, the trips to my house are made for less and less 'stuff' per trip. More trips per household obviously means more gasoline burned. With Amazon or FedEx, at least it's a truck on a route with several dozen deliveries to make. But this Uber/Lyft scheme looks to likely be 1, maybe 2, deliveries per trip.
- agmcleod 10y agoHow did you guys keep vegetables fresh for 2 weeks? That's usually why i go a couple times a week. Usually buy a pack of meat to have for a few nights of dinner, vegetables to use as well. Then get more once it's used up.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoThere was a time when canned and frozen vegetables were more common than fresh. I can't eat them today, but that's what we ate growing up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tomkinstinch 10y agoThere's actually an argument to be made that some frozen or canned vegetables have higher nutrient content than the equivalent "fresh" vegetables at the grocery store, since the frozen ones are harvested closer to peak readiness and packed proximal to farms, versus the "fresh" veggies which may be harvested well in advance of when they're ready to give them adequate time for long transit to stores and a reasonable duration of shelf stability. I believe this is the case for tomatoes—not sure which other crops. Unless you've grown them yourself, canned tomatoes will generally make a tastier pasta sauce than their fresh counterparts.
- bluedino 10y agoI would pay a small premium for a 'pick up at store' service like I can at some retailers. Buy the item online, go to the store, go to the customer service counter and pickup the your purchases. Imagine just going to the grocery store drive-through and picking up your groceries that you've chosen beforehand.
- dvcc 10y agoI am not sure where you live but this is pretty common in the north east (ShopRite etc.). To me though, I feel like there are misaligned incentives when employees pick food vs. the customer picks the food. Why should the employee care if the bread is going bad tomorrow instead of a week? The added time-savings just don't offset that concern for me.
- ghaff 10y agoI can't say that concerns with expiration dates are high on my list of issues when I'm grocery shopping. That said, if I'm going to order online anyway, I'm not sure why I wouldn't just have it delivered--maybe for a few bucks more--than driving to the store. Maybe if I'm not very mobile but can still drive, but then I still need to unload the car. I don't really understand the use case.
- icebraining 10y agoSometimes you can't be sure when you'll be at home to receive them.
- ghaff 10y agoThere's still a time window for pickup though. So you have to schedule in any case.
- ghaff 10y agoAt least in the Northeast US, Hannaford has started offering this. Personally, I'm not interested but I see the benefit for some people.
- martin-adams 10y agoJustin King (former CEO of Sainsburys in the UK) said that their data showed that people start ordering groceries for home delivery is when they start a family. After a few weeks, when (usually) the mother of the new baby is willing to venture out, she will visit the grocery store to buy extra things. Turns out that the spending level of online groceries doesn't drop, but the spending level of ad-hoc in-store purchases does, resulting in an overall increase in spending. This is true for my family. The UK also has seen an increase of convenience stores which carry a 5% price premium. People like to by a little often, than to buy a lot every week. The behaviour of grocery shopping has shifted a lot in the past 5 years in the UK. Edit: Spelling and clarity
- mankyd 10y ago> people start ordering groceries for home delivery is when they start a family. This certainly matches our experience. We've been using Google Express a ton to get the regular necessities that come with having children: diapers, cheerios, food for lunches, etc. We have a grocery store within walking distance that we still visit regularly for produce, perishables, and the odd ingredients that dinner sometimes requires.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mmilano 10y agoI can't say I'd want my family's food traveling in a car used to haul the public around when it's not delivering food.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoWhy not?
- Tistel 10y agoThis could be huge if they can keep the prices near Walmart levels. This could be a way to get around the negative stigma of shopping at Walmart amongst the hipster / bourgeois / middle class. If they pull this off it will put real pressure on the other grocery providers. On the downside, grocery delivery services have been tried many times in the past 15 years.
- ghaff 10y agoEh. I can't say I've done formal comparison shopping but Walmart groceries don't strike me as being systematically a lot cheaper than other grocery chains on an, ahem, apples to apples basis. Personally, given other options, I'm not sure why I would use Walmart for grocery delivery given that I'd be paying for delivery in some form and their selection and, often, quality are inferior to other stores.
- dsl 10y agoHave a look at Walmart SavingsCatcher. As you walk out of the store, you snap a QR code on your receipt. They check every other store in your area for the stuff you bought and refund the difference on a gift card if they weren't the cheapest. I've used it a few times with grocery delivery.
- kilroy123 10y agoI've used Safeway's home delivery service before. Wal-mart's as well. The whole, get your groceries delivered, it isn't such a great experience to be honest. First of all, pretty much every single time, I was missing items! Secondly, navigating the online store is a horrible experience. Finding things, thinking of what you need. The whole thing stinks. The experience of walking down an isle and picking out what you need, is strangely more efficient.
- alagappanr 10y agoStrangely, the small merchants in India are doing a great job when it comes to door delivery of groceries. Even over 15-20 years back, my mom used to get door delivery of the month's groceries by just making a phone call. One of the reason's for the success of this model was that most customers did not have a car to transport all of their groceries and phone-order was the easiest option available to them. (I'm talking about the late 90s when Internet was not that common). Of course, it works on the assumption that the customer exactly knows what they want - rather than making them buying arbitrary items at the store. Most of the merchants circulate their menu/deals along with newspapers and have a phone number that customers can reach them at. All you do is decide on what you want to order and then call the merchant at the given number. They deliver all the items at your house within a couple of hours. It uses the idea of "Cash on Delivery" i.e., you make your payment in-person to the delivery person. This method has been in practice for so many years that customers are quite used to the entire process and the merchants make sure that the delivery is processed as comfortably as possible.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoOnce again I wonder about the notion of an "independent contractor" class of worker, one where they save up and buy the standard "util-i-car" a vehicle which has a driving/motive unit, and attachable rear units, delivery pod, cargo pod, livery (tax) pod, transport (ambulance) pod, Etc. Along with a supply of lenders/repairs/resellers who lend you the money for your first utili-car, trade you used car or pod, repair your car/pod, sell new pods etc.