13 ms·
Intel knows it's no longer inside
- walterbell 10y agoHave there been studies on the relative software utilization of client hardware over the years? If clients are reduced to consumption terminals where special purpose IP blocks (e.g. video decoding) neutralize the difference between x86 and ARM, there is less justification for the price premium of a powerful general purpose CPU. If powerful clients have large local storage and compute-oriented apps that are optimized for low-latency human interaction on large desktop monitors or VR workspaces, then there would be good reason to pay for a general purpose CPU. A powerful desktop can also serve as a cloud to mobile devices, but a cloud server cannot offer the low-latency response of a local desktop. Why discard the one form factor that can serve both roles? Is the problem Moore's Law or the lack of desktop software innovation and business models? If Hollywood can promote business models via PC hardware DRM (e.g. SGX), can the software industry support hardware for client-oriented business models?
- bhouston 10y ago> Why discard the one form factor that can serve both roles? Half way between cloud and mobile means you are not needed for the most part. I think that VR rendering will also be eaten by mobile with high end GPUs. The only reason I need desktop is for compiles, but compiles could easily be done on the cloud.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoIt is almost as if you're telling us that you can code on a phone. "Mobile with high end GPUs" - what sort of battery do you have in mind for that? If you're calling a laptop "mobile" then ah - okay, but that's not the general use of the term.
- nl 10y agoPlenty of people code on tablets with keyboards, especially in environments where the computation is offloaded (eg ssh, Cloud-based IDEs, Jupyter, etc).
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoAre these "tablet" tablets, or something more like a laptop that masquerades as a tablet?
- nl 10y agoMostly iPads, but I use my Nexus 7. Surface Pros too of course, but I agree this is getting close to a laptop.
- freyr 10y agoNow this is just getting silly. Comparing a lightweight laptop to a modern tablet with a peripheral keyboard, the primary difference is a mechanical hinge.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoThe real difference is more about the underlying software ecosystem. And granted - this is slowly converging.
- srcmap 10y agoFew years ago, I setup my android platform to allow chroot into a ubuntu for ARM rootfs directory. With that, there is almost zero different than Linux PC. (Well, except may 16+GB of RAM and few TB of SSD/HDD)
- dredmorbius 10y agoA 10" Android tablet + bluetooth keyboard isn't bad from a hardware perspective. The OS and software stink.
- bhouston 10y agoI need a large high resolution screen (4K 30" or better), a wireless keyboard and a wireless mouse. I need responsiveness to my inputs, so I need a local GPU and some local processing (pretty much where the web browser is headed), but most storage and computation could happen on the cloud and I wouldn't notice if the apps were written properly. My hope setup is already this for the most part: laptop + 4K monitor + wireless keyboard + wireless mouse. And I write applications and do CAD and 3D computer graphics. If I can live this way now, it means that most everyone else can too. Just need to continue to shrink that laptop down until it is just the size of a smart phone.
- pjmlp 10y agoOn the mobile space unless you are targeting C or C++ code on Android and WP, the CPU doesn't matter. So in Android with dex, UWP with .NET Native and iOS with bitcode, compiled at store servers the client systems can have multiple CPU offerings. But that brings some headaches when profiling the applications across devices.
- legulere 10y agoLLVM bitcode already has some architecture-specific things baked in (pointer size, supported data sizes, macros matching to architectures in C are already evaluated, ...). You can target a neutral bitcode ABI that can be further compiled down to different architectures. That's what PNaCl still does, but I think Apple doesn't do that.
- pjmlp 10y agoI also don't know, but since it is done at the store level, can probably replace those parts if needed. Way easier than converting between Assembly languages.
- stephengillie 10y agoThe i7 from 2010 still runs fine in my gaming PC. Unlike a Pentium 3 from 2000, there have been no major speed advances in the past 6 years. True, today's i7 can push 16 threads instead of 8, but even with a full screen game, YouTube, Twitch, Chrome, and 2 game servers, it barely uses 6 threads. The devices aren't necessarily disappearing; we just don't need new ones anymore.
- andyjdavis 10y agoI have been looking around for a replacement laptop. Historically I have primarily looked at 3 numbers. RAM, hard drive size and CPU speed. It is just for running one or more IDEs so I don't have any particularly special requirement. I feel like CPU speeds have plateaued. Not so long ago getting a new machine after a few years meant getting a new CPU that was vastly quicker whereas all of the laptops I am looking at are only marginally faster than my ~3 year old laptop. My hard drive requirements are not huge so it looks like I am essentially buying a new laptop just to get more RAM.
- Kliment 10y agoThe 3 numbers for me are battery life, linux compatibility, cost (in that order)
- robocat 10y agoThe most important speed up you can currently get is changing to an NVMe SSD running at 3 times the speed of a SATA SSD. However, for many devices it difficult to wade through specs working out if you are actually getting NVMe (or whether you are just getting M2 SATA at the slower speed instead).
- kazinator 10y agoThat is an important speedup if you access a lot of data compared to what your DRAM can cache, or often do a full reboot (which means cold re-reading a lot of executable images from storage). Max out the RAM first.
- 10y ago
- projectramo 10y agoThere is one important additional fact one ought to keep in mind when reading something like this: Intel derives much of its competitive advantage from its ability to manufacture. This means that a lot of Intel's advantage will only express itself when the market grows really large. There have been a number of times when other companies beat Intel to a new technology (introducing, say, the 64 Bit chip several months ahead), but when the market took off and the cycle began, only Intel was able to deliver in sufficient quantity. I don't know what the total market for a particular chip is likely to be, or how fast it will get there.
- vonmoltke 10y agoIMO, Intel's greatest weakness is that they got so large on such a relatively narrow set of product lines. Their fabs are all optimized for massive runs of dies, unlike their competitors in the fab space. It makes them far less agile.
- RI_Swamp_Yankee 10y agoARM is a very compeitive field of a number of manufacturers, building chips for billions of devices. The advantage is no longer Intel's. More, the Great Old Ones - IBM with their zSeries and Power8 and now Oracle with SPARC of all things, are making a play for the server racks again. They're trapped between the massive economies of scale ARM is enjoying at the low end, and improvements in lowering cost and increasing yield for small batches of fancy and performant chips by the big R&D houses at the fat-margined high end. The middle of the road is shrinking fast.
- shortsightedsid 10y agoSun didn't fab the Sparc themselves and therefore it's unlikey that Oracle will. AFAIK they were fabbed in companies like TI. Source: TI's annual report from 2007 http://investor.ti.com/secfiling.cfm?filingID=1193125-07-42451&CIK=97476 http://investor.ti.com/secfiling.cfm?filingID=1193125-07-424... Therefore, Intel's competitive advantage of running their own fabs could keep them ahead in the server space as well.
- leaveyou 10y ago>Brian Krzanich said the company's focus was on moving to the cloud, with data centers and the Internet of Things considered primary growth drivers Cloud, servers.. I get it, Intel is well established there, but IoT ? Do they have a foothold in this area ? When I look on their page I don't see anything promising.. and when I think of IoT, I imagine some low power ARM SOCs like Raspbery Pis combined with Arduinos rather then anything Intel sells today. http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/internet-of-things/products-and-solutions.html http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/internet-of-things/pr...
- lmz 10y agoIoT = more clients = more servers, no?
- petra 10y agoNot really. A typical IOT client sends a few bytes every few minutes or hours. that's not much. But the "internet of watching things", a world full of connected cameras is a different story. But it ain't a great slogan :)
- shortsightedsid 10y ago> A typical IOT client sends a few bytes every few minutes or hours That's the SigFox definition of IOT but not necessarily typical for all cases. There are several usecases out there which require slightly higher bandwidth and data rate, but not quite broadband. One quick example is over the air firmware updates. Take MSP430. If we were to build a smart meter using a MSP430, our firmware probably be couple of kilobytes. Likewise, the size of the data can vary upstream as well.
- petra 10y agoI agree that there are some other usecases, and they might impact wireless standards and chips at the client, for example. But do you think those usecases have a big impact when coming to evaluate how big of cloud the IOT will require ? if so, please share a bit, so we could grasp the scale of things.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoI wonder if there will soon be room for a non-x86 PC due to the rise of mobile devices. Don't think there's been one available since the demise of the Power Mac.
- Frenchgeek 10y agoWell, the raspberry pi ( and others like it ) could be argued to be it, to an extend...
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoApple have smoothly changed processor architecture twice before, they could do it again. Maybe they'll go ARM everywhere at some point.
- philippnagel 10y agoIs ARM objectively better than x86?
- redial 10y agoIt is objectively cheaper.
- old-gregg 10y agoARM is better for <5W applications when performance is secondary to power consumption, but Intel is beating them at performance/watt ratio everywhere else.
- esturk 10y agoSo why not use both? Just like iPhones use a M9 processor for some dedicated computations, why can't MacBooks offload some less intensive computations to an energy efficient ARM processor. This in no way eats the x86 market but in fact grows the ARM market.
- 10y ago
- whazor 10y agoSince the transistors in chips are becoming smaller and smaller, heat is an increasing issue. This is why ARM chips for smartphones and IoT are booming, because their requirements of small chips are compatible with the shrinking size of the transistor. Now Intel tries to get a cut of the market, but they are too late. Anyway, I think they should keep focussing on making the computer chips and focus on the temperature problem.
- mtgx 10y agoIndeed. Intel's thinking right now (or rather in the past couple of years) seems to be that "hey, we missed the smartphone market, but at least we're early for the IoT market, right?" Except there are two things wrong with that theory: 1) "IoT" is mainly a new name for something that has already existed - a market that has already been dominated by ARM: the embedded/microcontroller market. ARM has much better expertise in this market, better relationships, and better ecosystem, as well as a full range of products. 2) If Intel's chips weren't competitive in the mobile market (especially when you compare all three metrics of performance, power, and price), then why would they be in the embedded IoT market, which plays even more to ARM's strengths?
- roymurdock 10y ago1) "IoT" is mainly a new name for something that has already existed - a market that has already been dominated by ARM: the embedded/microcontroller market. The IoT is much more than just the embedded hardware. It's the potential that lies within connecting embedded hardware. Extracting and refining data from embedded machines/sensors/nodes. The whole ecosystem of apps/services that can potentially be created on top of these new data streams.
- phkahler 10y ago>> The whole ecosystem of apps/services that can potentially be created on top of these new data streams. I haven't seen any of that yet, just hype. Of course every company wants to collect more data on consumers and is hoping IoT will enable them. None has provided a compelling reason for a "consumer" to buy an IoT device. Look at how Nest was all hype and then had a thermostat fail at its primary function when it lost the net connection. That's a huge step backward, and it's not going to get any better when the data collection remains the priority.
- frik 10y ago@Intel: how about thinking about 10GHz single core CPUs? And where is Atom? Why are we stuck in 2006 era CPU singe core performance? @nVidia: how about thinking about affordable high end GPUs? The GPUs got 400% more expensive since 2011. It's a pitty that AMD bought ATI, and now they can't compete with Intel and nVidia. And we all have to suffer and pay higher prices and get less performance - because no real competition exists any more.
- raverbashing 10y agoMHz/GHz are overrated. Not to mention today's 3GHz Intel and AMD offerings are much faster (per core) than let's say, the 3GHz offerings of 10y (?) ago nVidia got their bets right with investing on uses other than gaming for their GPUs now they're eating AMD/ATI in the deep learning field Affordable and High End are rarely on the same phrase, so there's your answer to when nVidia is going to do that
- protomyth 10y agoMHz/GHz is basically RPM in a car, not the greatest determinate of speed.
- raverbashing 10y agoCorrect Example: https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu_lookup.php?cpu=Intel+Pentium+4+1500MHz https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu_lookup.php?cpu=Intel+Pentiu... Other examples: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/intel,264-18.html http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/intel,264-18.html
- squeaky-clean 10y agoWhat a perfect analogy! Next time I'm having this discussion with people, I'll have to remember this.
- hvidgaard 10y agoExcept that the absolute pinnacle of motorsport go as high as they can because it is what produces the most power. Not that this matter for normal cars.
- astazangasta 10y agoAnyone else think this VR stuff is going to crash and burn hard? I'm really not sure why there is so much optimism around this area, it seems way too niche to drive general trends in computing.
- bduerst 10y agoI'm on the fence because I'm biased against something that requires changing user behavior, like wearing headgear. With rehashing of 3D tv in the last few years, it was obvious that it was more of a product gimmick with manufacturers than real value. With VR, you're seeing big companies pushing into the space from a spectrum of angles, ranging from re-imagining the workspace to 3D gaming. The bigger question is whether or not VR will become commonplace before augmented reality advances enough to replace it.
- criddell 10y agoOther than for gaming and watching certain kinds of videos, I can't see VR (or AR) being a huge deal. I can think of all kinds of neat things that could be done with it, but the production costs are just too high and the equipment is too clunky. Even in gaming, I expect VR games will be only moderately successful.
- bduerst 10y agoI can see AR taking over the workspace, where you put on an ergo headset and see a digital overlay of multiple screens.
- criddell 10y agoI'd be surprised if that became a thing outside of specialized cases like doctors seeing a patients vital signs and AI advice while they operate. One thing I've expected to see more of is Second Life. I thought for sure all the VR hype would reinvigorate Second Life for things like online classes and virtual meetings.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y ago> if Intel's vision comes to pass then that device — the smartphone — will constantly be communicating with Intel-powered data centers So Intel and Microsoft want to go where IBM and Oracle are withering?