20 ms·
The Untold Story Behind Saudi Arabia’s U.S. Treasury Holdings
- chiph 10y agoI think we always knew that they were buying a lot of government debt, this just makes it official and puts some numbers to it.
- lr4444lr 10y agoLook at that gas station photo during the embargo: "Limit: $300 per customer". $300 in 1974? Wow!
- Luc 10y agoThat's $3.00 :)
- lr4444lr 10y agoThanks - makes much more sense. I haven't had my coffee yet. According to the Dept. of Energy that'd be about 7 gallons. (http://energy.gov/eere/vehicles/fact-915-march-7-2016-average-historical-annual-gasoline-pump-price-1929-2015 http://energy.gov/eere/vehicles/fact-915-march-7-2016-averag...) Not sure what typical passenger car engine efficiency was in those days, though.
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoI remember the '73 embargo vividly. Rationing was based on license plate, even or odd. My parent's two autos were one of each. Of course, a station wagon and pickup truck. So my dad would get up about 4:30, put the snub-nosed .38 under the seat, and go get in line. Those who waited until the station opened were too late. Stations had big signs up if they had no gas. Gas was always pumped by the attendant. When you got to the pump, he would tell you how much gas you could have. Five gallons was common. My parents were small business owners. The embargo put their business at the edge.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoWow I never knew that. I lived through it too - but on a farm. We were exempt from any sort of rationing. So I didn't get any notion that things were that tight. I thought the lines (on TV) were just panicky folks rushing to fill up, like they empty the grocery store every time a storm is coming.
- apaprocki 10y agoMore recently, the even/odd license plate scheme was put in place in NYC in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy.[1] Local refineries were shut down and every station ran out of gas eventually. There were far away deliveries being trucked in but they were gobbled up almost immediately. People were waiting in multi-hour lines to get gas from the handful of stations that got a shipment in. [1]: http://www.nyc.gov/html/om/html/2012b/pr406-12-static.html http://www.nyc.gov/html/om/html/2012b/pr406-12-static.html
- xenophonf 10y agoI don't understand why Nixon and subsequent administrations didn't push _hard_ for total energy independence after that, as in moonshot-levels of investment into alternative energy (whether alternative sources of oil or research into nuclear/renewables).
- vox_mollis 10y agoCarter tried, and he learned the very valuable lesson that you NEVER level with your electorate. Always feed them happy, optimistic fantasies or your career is over.
- ZoF 10y agoThat's $3.00
- eternalban 10y agoBitter Lake [1] connects the Saudi windfall with the rise of global bankers as a power. Showdown at Doha [2] looks into the growing discomfort of US with rise of Iran and the subsequent strategic deal with SA which has lead us directly to the current mess. The role of the Brits (always busy busy in the shadows) is well worth looking into. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitter_Lake_%28film%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitter_Lake_%28film%29 [2]: http://masoudbehnoud.com/weblog/s2.pdf http://masoudbehnoud.com/weblog/s2.pdf
- Cyph0n 10y agoThanks for the links. I've added Bitter Lake to my watchlist.
- arethuza 10y agoFYI Bitter Lake is probably the best thing I've watched in the last couple of years - not sure I completely agree with all of it, but the format and approach is breathtaking.
- digi_owl 10y agoCheck out the rest of Curtis' documentaries as well. One eyeopener was part of his Pandora's Box series, A is for Atom, where he looks into the buildup of nuclear reactors on both sides of the cold war. In particular how said reactors, at least in the US, were basically (massively) scaled up submarine reactors.
- s_q_b 10y agothe Brits (always busy busy in the shadows) is well worth looking into. Sigh, the British are constantly furthering their own agenda in the Middle East. Their HUMINT network is just much better than anyone else's in the region, and their active intelligence work is informed by a much more nuanced view of that portion of the world. Americans like to do things from a distance, if they possibly can. Airstrikes, cyberattacks, drones, all involve minimal risk of casualties. The Brits have been on the ground, building their network, for far longer than the Americans. If only they'd share more of the fruits of their labor. It's been a quarter millennium, and British intelligence still looks down their nose at the Americans, treating them like a rebellious problem child.
- s_q_b 10y agoYou can see from their reported figures that their U.S. treasury holdings are far too low for a sensible national portfolio. It's a pretty glaring hole, and you know that the money is going somewhere off the balance sheets. The question has always been how much U.S. debt exactly the Saudi's hold. This is an interesting historical anecdote, but it doesn't provide any information about the size of the debt, other than "much larger" than official figures, which isn't terribly informative. At this point, Saudi Arabia needs the United States more than the United States needs Saudi Arabia. The OPEC cartel is broken, Saudi Arabia is running a massive deficit, both China and Europe have economies mired in the aftershocks of 2008 which cannot absorb the additional supply, and the United States is energy independent. If the Saudis are even willing to suggest selling off their dollar-denominated debts, they must be either unfathomably arrogant or extremely desperate. My read is the latter. They really must want to keep those documents secret. There is no way that a country gobbling up it's meager monetary reserves could afford the hit to the value of those assets as they unwound them, even if they sold them off very slowly and predictably. Something potentially very bad for world security is in those documents. Something that would force us into confrontation with the Saudis. Something that could cause a run on the dollar. There must be some extremely senior officials involved in that report. Whoever they are, they're senior enough that they can't be made to disappear quietly into the night. If those pages do contain information specifically identifying financiers of 9/11, the United States might be war-weary, but you can bet that a massive majority of Americans would demand their heads on pikes. As much as I support the public's right to know, that's a very nightmarish scenario.
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoPerhaps we should be demanding heads on pikes. This has very real implications for Hillary Clinton's election chances as well. The Clintons have been supporters of the Saudis for some time now and have accepted Saudi government money through the Clinton Foundation. https://www.clintonfoundation.org/contributors?category=%2410%2C000%2C001+to+%2425%2C000%2C000 https://www.clintonfoundation.org/contributors?category=%241... http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/05/hillary-clinton-foundation-state-arms-deals http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/05/hillary-clinton-... There is no reason the U.S. should be allies with the House of Saud. We have almost no aligned interests and very different views on human rights and Wahhabism. My hope is that the report is published.
- sailfast 10y agoHow is it possible to sell U.S. Treasuries in secret or in a dark market while still providing an ostensibly transparent market for Treasuries? Those two things seems counter to each other. A deal with this structure as a preference seem extremely misguided, and I'm not sure if the secrecy was requested by the Saudis or by the Nixon / Kissinger NSC / Cabinet which was prone to secrecy for no reason. Either way, one more crazed "feather" in their cap that greatly influenced the future of the country for better or worse.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoHow is it possible to sell U.S. Treasuries in secret or in a dark market while still providing an ostensibly transparent market for Treasuries? Those two things seems counter to each other. Let's consider equities first. A huge amount of invested money is indexed, which basically means not doing active investing but simply tagging along with the price discovery done by more active market participants. That seems to work out pretty well. Not perfect, but good enough. Why can't treasuries be the same? There's such a thing as a "noncompetitive bid"[1], which means you agree to purchase Treasuries at the same price that the smarter money chose to purchase at. Right now there are low limits on how much can be bought by noncompetitive bids. But perhaps the Saudi's just get that price for however much they want to buy? The treasury market is huge huge huge. It probably remains reasonably "transparent" regardless of what the Saudis buy. [1] https://www.treasurydirect.gov/instit/auctfund/work/work.htm https://www.treasurydirect.gov/instit/auctfund/work/work.htm
- aedron 10y agoThe most surprising thing is the backdoor arrangements the Treasury and Federal Reserve handily created to keep Saudi bonds purchases off the books - through forty years! I'm sure most people would not believe something like this could be done - that actual governing and federal dealing is so hidden, through changing administrations, in spite of apparent transparency, like annual reports, budgets, hearings, and so on. It really puts a big question mark on the U.S. democratic system, as if that wasn't tenuous enough already. Oh, and if anyone was in doubt about the shift to Iran, this suddenly being publicized as much as anything tells you all you need to know. It's a big middle finger to Saudi Arabia.
- mark_l_watson 10y ago+1 Couldn't agree more. This story would have really surprised me 10 years ago but now I accept that the Economic Royalty (or Deep Government, or whatever you want to call them) use a lack of transparency to do what profits them.
- aedron 10y agoThe massive issuance of U.S. Dollar debt to Saudi Arabia, as a result of the deal mentioned in the OP, coincided perfectly with the abolition of the gold standard (the dollar being linked to physical gold reserves) [1]. So right from the start, the U.S. was purchasing oil with pieces of paper with no guaranteed value of any sort. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_shock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_shock
- rwmj 10y agoI'd rather have fiat currency than gold, because that would save me the time and hassle of selling the gold and getting something I can actually spend.
- ericHosick 10y ago> I'd rather have fiat currency than gold, because that would save me the time and hassle of selling the gold and getting something I can actually spend. Isn't currency backed by commodities considered something other than fiat currency?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIt's called the "gold standard".
- lmm 10y agoFor an individual that makes sense. For a nation the cost/hassle of selling gold is comparatively low, and the risk of the fiat backer's interests being averse to one's own is much higher.
- dpc59 10y agoThe ability the US has to assure people that you'll be able to buy oil with USD through military bullying of OPEC countries is a pretty good guaranteed value.
- wahsd 10y agoWe really should simply cancel all debt and confiscate all assets owned by Saudi Arabia and any other muslim country as consequence for 9/11 and all the other terrorist attacks against the west hat muslims are organizing, supporting, and funding in order to undermine, fracture, and weaken the west with the help of self-loathing and self-destructive liberals. What are they going to do about it. Will Europeans all the sudden withdraw their investments and stop exporting to the USA? Will the Chinese all the sudden worry that the same may happen to them even though they are not part of the cancerous muslim scourge upon all of humanity that is attacking and undermining the west and they will simply stop exporting to the single larges market out of fear? No. None of that will happen and muslims will have learned a valuable lesson that cancer received chemotherapy and turmor removal; not chanting, meditating, and juicing until it's too late to treat a highly curable muslim cancer. Remember, muslims are voluntarily part of a vile organization founded by vile savages whose legacy is mass murder and mass rape and pedophilia.
- knodi123 10y ago> muslims are voluntarily part of a vile organization founded by vile savages I was on board with your rant until this point, but I refuse to wave a pitchfork around and scream for blood with someone who doesn't even own a thesaurus.
- wahsd 10y agoWhat, because I reinforced the fact that islam is a vile organization founded by vile savages? Are you so feeble minded that you dismiss reality simply because a concept is repeated. Islam was founded by people who slaughtered people who surrendered, and then mass raped their wives in the blood soaked soil and then enslaved them. What other word does your thesaurus suggest could be used besides vile? Islam is a cancer on all of humanity. It constantly and persistently proves it, yet for some reason the morons cannot see the blatant reality right in front of their faces that will cut off their head the second they gain control. Fools think that muslims are innocuous because they know them personally as I have known them all my life, but reality is that islam is just like a cancer or virus, if you have a few abnormal cells or even early stage cancerous cells, you can avert the inevitable, but you will rue the day you do a Steve Jobs and try to meditate and juice away your highly treatable cancer until it is too late. Islam is an infection on all of humanity, all other cultures, all other religions, all other humans. Once muslim is fine, a few muslims can't affect much; but that's why they continuously and insatiably reproduce and infiltrate and undermine and will never and relentlessly hammer away until they have dominated. It is precisely and exactly how Islam grew and spread throughout the middle east and it is precisely how they will dominate Europe after centuries of blood, sweat, and tears spilled to keep the caner at bay. You are supporting the cancer that will eat away at every single thing you claim to believe in. There will be not stopping it, it is not just a cute little mole that give you character, it is a cancer that is eating away at you and will only lead to one thing. It is precisely like a virus, precisely a trojan horse.
- marcusgarvey 10y agoMentioned is the GAO's finding -- all the way back in 1979 -- that the secrecy had no legal basis. Reports from the GAO, the Government Accountability Office, are a great way to keep an eye on all sorts of wonky, provocative investigations that are often left in the shadows.
- coldcode 10y agoI wonder how many other secrets we know nothing about in the US like this.
- advertising 10y agoThere's a book called confessions of an economic hit man - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confessions_of_an_Economic_Hit_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confessions_of_an_Economic_Hit... Essentially U.S. helps impoverished nations with infrastructure and other aid, but saddles them with debt in order to control them politically or otherwise. The interesting part was when it came to Saudi Arabia, which had so much money it didn't need to take on debt to develop their infrastructure. So instead they bought America's debt as this article explains. I lived in the kingdom from '82 - '04 which was quite an interesting time span to have lived there. Things have definitely changed as a younger, mostly western educated generation, returns home and social unrest cannot be quelled with unlimited social programs anymore. Most of the Saudi's I know now simply take american concepts/franchises and spin them out over there. From hamburger chains to house cleaning services. Works pretty well for them. The most annoying thing was the weekends were on Thursday and Friday, so if you wanted to do anything international with a bank you could only do it Mon - Wed as their banks were closed on their weekends and then U.S. banks were closed Sat / Sun. I believe you can still simply walk to a certain part of town and watch an execution, along with a couple of hands once a week there. Just you know, if you wanted something to do on a weekend.
- zeeshanm 10y agoThere is a new edition of the book mentioned above if anyone's interested: "The New Confessions of an Economic Hit Man."
- MOARDONGZPLZ 10y agoThanks for the heads up. I read the original in college and it was very interesting, although I thought it was a bit embellished. http://www.amazon.com/New-Confessions-Economic-Hit-Man/dp/1626566747 http://www.amazon.com/New-Confessions-Economic-Hit-Man/dp/16...
- arethuza 10y agoI read it a good few years back and found it interesting although I was slightly skeptical about to what degree the conspiracies described existed outside of the author's head. However, being older and somewhat more cynical (particularly after binge reading about the UK involvement in the Iraq and Afghan Wars) I do wonder if I should read this again - are there any materials out there that support his claims?
- SCAQTony 10y agoWe pretty much put a price on our morality. Looking at the bond holders graph, it appears we owe about a 1/2-trillion dollars to oil producing nations. It's no wonder we tolerate tolerate gross human rights violations therein. Sort of like that J. Paul Getty Quote: "If you owe the bank $100 that's your problem. If you owe the bank $100 million, that's the bank's problem." Makes me wonder if we have a similar deal with China: we sacrifice our industrial sector (no other nation allowed that to happen) in exchange for bond buying?
- strictnein 10y agoWe haven't sacrificed our industrial sector: https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/INDPRO https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/INDPRO
- milcron 10y agoI think this chart helps explain why someone might think so: http://blogs-images.forbes.com/timworstall/files/2015/10/mfg1-e1443798818201.jpg http://blogs-images.forbes.com/timworstall/files/2015/10/mfg... The US manufactures more than ever before, it just takes fewer jobs to do so.
- mikeash 10y agoWouldn't the Getty quote imply that it's China and Saudi Arabia who have the problem, not the US? I don't know about "sacrifice our industrial sector" thing, either. The US is the world's second largest exporter. Those exports just happen to be somewhat less visible since they include a lot of things outside of consumer goods. You can walk around the US and see all the Chinese-made phones and think, "China sure makes a lot of stuff." But most people won't walk around China and see all the US-made airliners and think, "The US sure makes a lot of stuff too."
- tsunamifury 10y agoThe Kingdom Opening [1] will give you a fast historical overview. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9bHlO057DyY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9bHlO057DyY
- FrojoS 10y agoI have a stupid question that is a bit more general than the Saudi case. What's the advantage of selling oil and the using the dollars to buy treasuries or other conservative investment assets? Wouldn't it make much more sense for a country like Saudi Arabia to limit their oil production and finance their deficit of the sales directly instead of using royalties? This assumes that the value of oil will rather rise over time . In addition, for a producer as large as the Saudi's, this strategy should even raise oil prices.
- digi_owl 10y agoTo some degree they have the big dog of international politics by the balls...
- jeffcoat 10y agoNot so stupid: Start with the phrase "Hoteling's rule" for a century of academic analysis of that question. If you own an oil field, you have to balance a number of factors: * How is the price of oil changing, relative to overall inflation? You mentioned this one. But also, * Are technological improvements (either increasing the total amount of extractable oil in the world, or outright oil replacements) going to dramatically lower the price if I wait too long? * Is it still going to be my oil next year, or am I going to be first against the wall when the next revolution comes? My (unsophisticated, outsider) opinion is that if you see oil-producing countries selling as quickly as they can, that's weak evidence that they're worried about the last two bullets.
- randomname2 10y agoIt's interesting how for decades, the story of Saudi Arabia recycling US petrodollars, i.e., funding the US deficit by buying US Treasuries with proceeds of its crude oil sales (mostly to the US), while the US sweetened the deal by providing the Saudis with military equipment and supplies, remained entirely in the conspiracy realm, and how with this fascinating Bloomberg story this "theory" now becomes fact.
- 77ko 10y agoIt seems to be that this story has been out there for decades now, and this Bloomberg story just adds a few details.
- emblem21 10y agoWhat is petrocurrency mercantilism? http://i0.wp.com/cultstate.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Yep.png http://i0.wp.com/cultstate.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Ye...
- known 10y agoAnd believe me this deal/collusion has created friction between 1.8 billion Muslims and the West;
- ohashi 10y agoBloomberg site is godawful. It reloaded the article on me 3 times while reading it. Great way to rip off advertisers with more pageviews and piss off readers.
- known 10y agoSince 1971 OPEC is bullied to sell Oil exclusively in US dollars resulting in friction between 1.8 billion Muslims and the West; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_Shock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_Shock http://qz.com/562128/isil-is-a-revolt-by-young-disaffected-muslims-against-their-parents-generation/ http://qz.com/562128/isil-is-a-revolt-by-young-disaffected-m...