21 ms·
Apps made for one OS shouldn't insist on aping the design elements of another
- mlvljr 10y agoTLDR, HN, who'll be the Google of 2020s? P.S. Speaking of UI and UX, HANGOUTS SUCK!! (I and a colleague were not able to see (and then listen) each other in a call for about 15 minutes yesterday, with avatars popping in and out, everybody seeing himself only and such, until one of the machines in my LAN was able to both be seen on the other side and heard, too)
- fenomas 10y agoThis seems like a trivially silly article. In essence it argues: "OSes are special sauce and apps are commodities - Google should recognize this and stop trying to differentiate their app designs." That's certainly a valid opinion, but its reverse is just as defensible - if one considers services to be special sauce and OSes to be commodities, then it directly follows that app UIs should first be consistent across platforms. And considering that Google's entire business model is based on the latter view, why on earth would they take the author's view?
- simonh 10y agoWhile in general I'd agree with Jason, in this case I can't. There's a big difference between the case of Word on the Mac back in the 90s and Google apps on iOS. I use Gmail, Google Maps and Google Docs, but I use them equally on iOS and on the web. What I want from these apps is a consistent UI on the web and in the iOS apps. I couldn't give two craps about what it looks like on Android. No disrespect to Android, but that's just not an issue for me. Jason's position is reasonable. Making the UI on iOS more like iOS conventions would have advantages and for some people this would be a better option, but there's an extra issue here he's not acknowledging.
- pan69 10y agoThree words for the author of this post: iTunes for Windows
- drunken-serval 10y agoIt's mentioned explicitly as an example of what not to do.
- JackPoach 10y agoAnd Microsoft is 'unmaking' many of the mistakes it made in the past two decades
- pervycreeper 10y agotl;dr--- Google is the equivalent of 90s-era Microsoft because it is angrily disliked by some Apple fans, and it incorporates Material Design in its iOS apps.
- cjfjdjcjfjd 10y agoUh oh, dang is going to throw another tantrum... He hates TL;DR's.
- PuffinBlue 10y agoI know that 'tl;dr' is frowned upon here but this particular tl;dr is better written and just as in depth as the article itself.
- abraae 10y agoWry tl;dr's like this should be exempted.
- aexaey 10y agoThat was a suprisingly accurate summary. The whole thing, including the incoherent rant about material design
- rmvt 10y agocouldn't agree more. this article is nothing more than an ignorant rant. i wanted to give it the benefit of the doubt, even though it's from macworld but oh well... just take a look at the two app comparisons. you have to be an idiot to write stuff like that and actually believe it. on material: google has, from the start, said it's a design style and philosophy that it has chose to adapt on android (and on the web too), so it's only natural they try to do it on ios.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoBut it's okay for Apple to inflict their design on Android because it's Apple.
- 10y ago
- johnloeber 10y agoMaking analogies between Microsoft in the 90s and X without mentioning the huge antitrust lawsuit[0] always seems dubious to me. The evolution of Microsoft as a business is not purely due to its product strategy. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....
- frgewut 10y agoActually Google currently is facing some serious anti-trust cases as well.
- tluyben2 10y agoMaybe Google is better at hiding it or just being 'less evil', but MS was pretty open with their 'destroy everything that comes in our path'. I think it is important to mention that when mentioning the antitrust case. Edit: I was against the antitrust case at the time even though I did not like nor used MS /products/ and did not approve of their practices. I believed they got that power because they managed to get enough people drink the coolaid and that's a part of what a business does; kudos to them basically. Still don't like most software they make, but as a company it seems a lot better now. Why restrict that? I have another opinion (I would be for the antitrust case now) now as I grow older.
- serge2k 10y agoI don't really see capturing browser market by shoving it in your face at every opportunity and taking advantage of shady opt-out bundle installers as that much different than bundling with the OS. Google is really the same as any other big company. They will do what they can get away with to further their goals.
- kmiroslav 10y agoThe author should launch iTunes on Windows and realize that Apple is pulling the same kind of crap on Windows. Large companies have large egos.
- JonCox 10y agoTo be fair, iTunes on Mac is also a buggy, confusing, slow and generally terrible application.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Udo_Schmitz 10y agoThe author addresses this in the article: “Good Mac apps should feel like Mac apps, and good Windows apps should do likewise. If iTunes for Windows feels like a Mac app, Apple’s doing it wrong. (One could argue Apple’s doing it wrong with iTunes everywhere, of course…)”
- ysavir 10y agoThat's not addressing it. That's making a hollow, unqualified claim, using authoritative tone to make it sound like a proper, true absolute.
- wodenokoto 10y agoI actually think it's a pretty okay marketing strategy. If you truly believe your own interface is a selling point,then you need to show it off to people who aren't familiar with it. If iTunes truly has a superior user experience (ha!) people will think, hey wouldn't it be nice if all my apps were like that.
- tkubacki 10y ago"If iTunes truly has a superior user experience " It has not
- 10y ago
- Dylan16807 10y agoJust some icons and menu colors? If that's their biggest problem then they're doing well.
- runholm 10y agoWhat you are describing is the entire field of interaction design. It's not "just some icons and menu colors".
- Dylan16807 10y agoNo I'm not. The two different UI styles are extremely similar. Look at how little changes on the screenshot of apple music, the good example. Complaining about the direction of the three dots that make up the menu button is the ultimate in bikeshedding.
- Zelmor 10y ago"and the target of dislike and rage from many people who love Apple products." He managed to lose me in the first paragraph. Not a record, but really close.
- tn13 10y agoHonestly as a user I think Apple and Google can fry frogs with their design guidelines. I want app makers to make apps that are fun to use and enjoyable and more importantly useful. I could not care less if they are following company X's design guidelines or company Y's design guidelines. There is nothing earth shattering or innovative or useful about Apple or Material design guidelines. It is just an attempt to establish their brand.
- cloudjacker 10y agoRemember when Facebook and Google had strict styling "guidelines" for their login buttons that were completely different and didn't fit aesthetically on anybody's login screen together? That was big ego
- tluyben2 10y agoI must be a very weird person I feel lately (this theme is recurrent on HN); I don't actually notice the difference. I use iOS & Android and if the app works well I don't notice if it doesn't behave 'like it is supposed to do' on the respective OS. It is far more noticeable on desktops. However, if copy/cut/paste (Firefox on Linux notably which is unusable because I cannot copy to/from it), file dialog and drag & drop works with the rest of the applications and the application is solid otherwise as well I don't care about that either and probably won't notice it. I notice it with software that presents me a hard to use custom file open/save dialog only. And I tend to just not use that anymore. But on mobile; if the app is good (I for one like Google docs) I don't believe many people actually notice this difference.
- zxcvcxz 10y ago>copy/cut/paste (Firefox on Linux notably which is unusable because I cannot copy to/from it) You just highlight text and press ctrl+c, ctrl+v, etc. You could also use the right click menu. I've never had a problem like that before. This works for me on firefox 46.0.1 on Fedora 23.
- tluyben2 10y agoMust be something with my environment; i'll remove it as apparently it's just me. There are more instances I ran into that, but my example of the non standard file explorer is more annoying usually anyway.
- hollander 10y agoHave you tried to remove your Firefox profile on Linux? Just rename it so you can move it back later if needed. Then try to copy/paste. Then disable all addons and try again. It should work of course.
- tluyben2 10y agoI tried a few things and then gave up; I will revisit. It is a known problem as there are a lot of posts all over the web from people with the same issue.
- PSeitz 10y agoan apple fanboy dislikes android, quelle surprise
- simula67 10y agoGoogle is acting more like Microsoft. They are building huge moats around their business ( Android, Chrome etc ) so it becomes harder to use some Google products without using others. Google discontinued 'Google Sync' ( https://support.google.com/a/answer/2716936?hl=en https://support.google.com/a/answer/2716936?hl=en ). It favors Google Finance and Youtube over its rivals in search results page. They 'have not figured out' how to allow extensions in Chrome mobile. They had no-poaching agreements with rival companies. I am almost a Google fanboy, but I suspect they will be no different to Microsoft in a few years. Letting products stagnate, pushing the tech industry backwards but making a pretty profit for investors.
- erikb 10y ago> so it becomes harder to use some Google products without using others. This was a phase around the boss of Google+. Google found that people don't like it and stopped doing it, like 2-4 years ago. Now it's perfectly possible to use things separately I would argue.
- CaptSpify 10y agoreally? I still can't unlink my gmail account from my youtube account. Voice is still falling to the wayside, and hangouts is being pushed instead. I'm going to have to respectfully disagree with you
- beisner 10y agoTo be fair, Chrome for iOS won't ever have extensions because Apple requires all HTML rendering to be done with their web viewer (which can be embedded in other apps), meaning that Google simply can't control the rendering of the page (and thus implement the majority of chrome extensions). The app is basically just a wrapper for the same browser that Safari uses.
- joe_fishfish 10y agoChrome on Android is a different story though. Firefox on Android allows you to use add-ons for the web version of Firefox with no fuss. Why can't Chrome do the same?
- throwaway13337 10y agoGoogle is also resembling Microsoft in the sortof-broken-but-usable cross-product features. For example, when I browse to google maps, and try to look at the reviews list of a point of interest on the map, it takes me to a google search - completely out of the context I was in - and opens as modal dialog in that search area. There are lots of examples of similar functionality. Individually, its harmless, but as a whole, it feels sluggish and clunky. This kind of behavior seems to be common in large software companies that have separate divisions with communication issues between them. It's sad to see Google go down that road.
- vmateixeira 10y agoThey're just looking after they're business. By having the same applications layout/behaviour, it will help users to switch to Android easily in the future.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- proyb2 10y agoThat's why we all have different furniture.
- mlvljr 10y agoMine is from IKEA mostly :/
- ericdykstra 10y agoUser interfaces should be designed for the user, not for the operating system. I feel like more apps should embrace their uniqueness rather than aping whatever Apple/Google/whatever puts out as the "new standard" every time their design team decides to go in a new direction. A lot of user interface design is managing user expectation (things people have gotten used to, like where a "create" button is or what a "share" icon looks like) versus optimizing for long-term usability of an app (something like Snapchat, with its seemingly-esoteric UI that is actually efficient once one is used to using it). The only reason the author gives for taking this position is that "Participating on someone else’s operating system means you’re on their turf. The author even admits that "I’m not saying either design is superior." So app companies should forego optimizing for user experience to pay respect to the platform that they're on? This is a totally backwards position; apps should respect their users. If that means following all the OS guidelines for a sparingly used app, that's fine. But if that means creating a unique UI and app flow for long-term user happiness, then the app company owes no respect to the "local conventions" of the OS. edit: clarity
- tomn 10y agoI'm not sure I agree. I use one phone, with many apps, so it's helpful if the common parts of all the apps I use behave in the same way. For example, how do I get to the preferences for this app? Via a hamburger menu on the left, or an ellipsis menu on the right? Almost all the apps on my phone that have the concept of making a new item (SMS/instant message/email/calendar event) have the button for doing so in exactly the same place on the screen; this is great as it means only have to learn that action once, and it works for all the apps I use. That is optimised user interface design. Of course designers still need to put in effort to make their apps usable, but making having the common subset of actions work the same across apps is great for users. It's unfortunate that platforms seem to change their interface guidelines all the time (no just the look and feel), as it seems to be having the opposite of the intended effect. The cost benefits of having a single style for an app across platforms is also a significant factor; I'd rather have an app available on my platform than not.
- k__ 10y ago
- jetskindo 10y agoIf Google docs had a mac like ui on ios, the author would be writing about how inconsistent Google docs is. "They should unify their design"
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAnd by "unify" the author would most likely mean "change all the other apps to have Mac-like UI".
- grawlinson 10y agoMicrosoft now aren't that great with the following examples: * Constant starting/shuttering of their mobile OS offerings. * Disregarding user privacy in Windows 10 (and extending that to Windows 7/8 via updates) * Forcing users of Windows 7/8 to update to 10. It's basically malware at this stage. * Removing admin abilities in Enterprise offerings of Windows 10.
- vt240 10y agoWhat admin abilities were removed in Windows 10 Enterprise?
- grawlinson 10y agoYou can't disable users from accessing the Windows Store, from what I've heard.
- vt240 10y agoThat is for Windows 10 Pro, which as far as I can tell they are not even pushing on small business like us. I am seriously concerned though. It was hard enough transitioning to 7.
- tremon 10y agoFor one, you can no longer completely disable certain (feature) updates. The most you can do is delay the feature by a year.
- vt240 10y agoThat doesn't seem to be what they claim in [1] for a managed environment. We are still using 2008 R2 and Windows 7, but it is getting to the point where we need to at least upgrade Windows Server. What a headache. [1] https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/itpro/windows/manage/introduction-to-windows-10-servicing https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/itpro/windows/manage/int...
- vixen99 10y agoHe says "Truth be told, just as I used Word 5.1 back in the day, I use many Google services today." Just as? No, he paid good money for the Microsoft software.
- vblord 10y agoDo you think MS Word should have been free? Or that google should have charged for it?
- erikb 10y agoThe funny thing is: I understand his argument, but the Android like Google apps where what finally made the iPhone a little usable for me. I have it for nearly a year now and still every day wish myself back to the times I had a Nexus 4. It is just way more efficient. I don't what the goal of a normal iPhone user is. But my goal is to get things done as fast as possible. I need to work. But for that iPhones are really painful to use. And I don't know but if you have seen the Gmail App, can you ever go back to the Mail app from iOS? It's like a Porsche vs a rikshaw. Why would anybody want to use the latter one?
- samwestdev 10y agoAnother crappy Jason Snell's Original
- ja27 10y ago"Boo hoo" - every Android user with an app drawer full of iOS rounded rect, flat, gradient-shaded icons.
- MBCook 10y agoSo you recognize that it is a problem. I've heard that kind of complaint from Android users before and they're correct. So shouldn't Google fix it on iOS? Apple, of all people, did it right when they brought Apple Music over to Android. I'm still amazed at that. They don't have a good history (i.e. everything they released on Windows).
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoWhat a sad and click bait-y article. So, there's not a million other examples of apps that also don't follow the iOS style? This article was written just to beat the Android vs iOS war drums.
- davidcollantes 10y agoI don't think it is click-bait, nor to incite wars. I think it expresses clearly something I noticed long ago: Google apps's--under iOS--UX/UI is completely different from the rest. They look odd, they do not behave as an iOS user would expect an iOS app to behave. Same as the Microsoft applications he mentions. I love that Google has picked a unique UI/UX for Android, that's great. Yet, when providing apps for iOS, they should behave, and conform like the rest of iOS apps do.
- torgoguys 10y agoReading the headline, I was half expecting the article to say that Google's just-announced Instant Apps initiative is the resurrection of ActiveX in IE, a comparison I'm just waiting for some journalist to make. (To this point, I've mostly read nothing but praise for the idea (instant apps). I see instant apps as another sad retreat from the promise of the open web.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Arnt 10y agoI'm going to go out on a limb and assume that most users of google apps also use google-as-a-website. So what's google to do, provide consistency between the app and other apps or between the app and the corresponding web UI? That isn't a simple question with a simple answer...
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoParticularly irritatingly: Google disables “shake to undo”, which I've actually needed, instead making it “shake to give feedback”, which is never something I've needed. Presumably just to upset iOS users?
- whack 10y agoIt's worth pointing out one major difference between Word 93 and Google apps in 2016. Back in 1993, we were pretty much living in a 1-device-per-user world. People had one computer, and they used all their apps on that one computer. Hence, if consistency is the goal, the only thing to be consistent with is other apps on that computer. However, in 2016, we're living in a multi-device world. A single person can easily own a smartphone, a tablet, a laptop as well as a desktop. Some of them may be iOS, others may be Windows, and others may be Android. And they are likely to use the same apps (eg, google Maps) on all of those different devices. Hence, I would argue that consistency across devices today, is more important than consistency across different apps. As someone who owns a mix of both Mac and Android products, I would like for Google docs to look and behave similarly no matter which device I'm on, even if it means that Google Maps ends up looking differently from Apple-Music.
- maxxxxx 10y agoOf the apps I use most of them I use on only one device. So it's better to stick to the platform guidelines.
- no_gravity 10y agoAccording to the author, they made that mistake in 1993. In 1993, Microsoft's market cap was under $30 billion. Today it is over $400 billion.
- werber 10y agoThe only google app I regularly use on my iPhone is their Photos app, and I like that it's cohesive across platforms. The subtle switch to being material design land on iOS gives me reassurance that my pictures will be safe in google's cloud. This feels worlds away from the design wars 20 years ago, when all you got was frustration and no real user benefit.
- TelAviv_1 10y agoGoogle Bob!?
- d0m 10y agoTL&DR: Author doesn't like material design
- ysavir 10y agoI think the author misses the point. Using a native-looking interface will only encourage users to stay on their iTems, and Google (not so) secretly wants to convert those users to their own native platforms+.
- digi_owl 10y agoI for one miss the 3.x-4.x Holo UI.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoHolo was the best UI Google ever did. It felt like the future. Now I feel like Android is living in some wannabe iOS thing with paper-based skeu.
- deprave 10y agoWebKit and Blink: Embrace, Extend, Extinguish.
- bikamonki 10y agoI agree with the point being made: I would be really pissed if a desktop app had the window management buttons on a different corner, even the same corner but different icons would feel bad. However, mobile apps are more like websites rather than desktop apps. The 'shell' has to be consistent with UI design and behaviour whereas the 'content' can have a UI relevant to function and maybe a different brand. For example, if you open gmail on Chromium and Safari, you'd expect it to behave and look the same on both.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Tyler-Durden 10y agoMaterial design is not android design. It is googles design concept. Being surprised that the company uses it for their applications, is like an American traveling to a far off country called Great Britain and be surprised they speak English there
- ajoy39 10y agoMaterial Design isn't just about Android Apps though. They make libraries for websites too, and have guidelines for all types of devices built into the spec. Google isn't using MD in their iOS apps to bring Android design to iOS they're using MD in their iOS apps because they believe MD should be a universal design paradigm for applications and web apps. You can argue that it shouldn't be, you can not like it as a design framework in general, but it's not about Android vs iOS it's about Google's vision of application design regardless of platform.
- imissmyjuno 10y agoThe article's point still stands though: sticking to a platform's design == jarring user experience. Not to say that I agree that it's necessarily bad: his example of Word on Mac vs. Windows is actually interesting bc, given sufficient differences, users would have a hard time switching between the two if they own both platforms and the applications look completely different. I think it should be possible to retain certain UI paradigms (e.g. back buttons, toolbars) while staying uniform across all platforms in other respects.
- Zombieball 10y agoIs it a jarring experience though? I imagine many Google product users use more than just one app, be it Gmail on iOS and the web browser, or docs, etc. Material design creates a consistent experience across devices and platforms for Google apps. I think the result is not jarring but a feeling of familiarity.
- MBCook 10y agoIt's jarring, because basically EVERY OTHER iOS APP behaves similarly. If you spend all your time on Android and the Web, an for some reason occasionally use a Google app on an iPhone it may feel familiar to you. But if you have an iPhone chances are you spend a lot of time using other iOS apps (including the system ones) and are used to that design language. It's nice that it's consistent with other Google products, the problem is that's the wrong thing to do on iOS because it feels so out of place. You can still use your colors and many of your other schemes, but basic platform conventions like share buttons and menu locations should be respected.
- isidoreSeville 10y agoI've never really used iOS so can someone tell me if this is even a real problem? The apps shown in the linked piece seem totally fine to me, so maybe there are better examples out there?
- MBCook 10y agoThey seem fine to you because you don't use iOS. I'm guessing you're an Android person. Have you run across apps that don't feel like Android apps? They feel like someone made a least-effort attempt to port an iOS app over to "the other platform" and the result is just sort of jarring and weird? That's the issue. It's not necessarily that they look bad, your app can look like what you want. The issue is that they don't follow lots of little platform conventions that you get used to and so they feel foreign and slightly annoy you every time you try to use them.
- Zigurd 10y agoThe article has some good points. Material Design is a fine convention for Android and for Google's Web apps, and is well-supported for those if you use Google's libraries and frameworks. But I would not recommend that app developers should take MD to iOS. iOS has it's own conventions. Observe them. On top of all that, Web UI design lacks universal conventions. There isn't much to be gained by aping Google's style on the Web, unless you really like it. Every developer needs distinctive design elements in the areas that are not covered by platform conventions, and their Web UI is a good place to develop distinctive elements. BUT that doesn't mean Google is making a mistake, except possibly on iOS. If Google's iOS apps are not close enough to iOS conventions, Google is, at least potentially, confusing their iOS users.
- edko 10y agoApple has strict rules for allowing apps into the iOS AppStore, and they are enforced for every developer, including Google. While I disagree with the contents of the article, the rant should not be against Google only. If material design apps are accepted then it is not only Google's "fault".
- makecheck 10y agoWhile I prefer adherence to the OS’ conventions, I can handle variations as long as they solve some problem. For example, one could argue in favor of something like a non-standard icon if that makes gestures easier to discover than they are by default on iOS. Gratuitous redesigns are silly though, and by nature have to consume engineering effort that otherwise would’ve been spent elsewhere. And when engineering effort has clearly gone into a new veneer while there are still broken app features, I become really angry. Too many apps on iOS alone have been “updated” with redesigns and mysteriously lost functionality in the process (or effectively lost functionality, by hiding previously-known features somewhere new).
- DeadReckoning 10y agoTotally disagree. I love the iOS material design apps like Inbox and Google Photos
- jasonm23 10y agoThe more you understand product design and usability, the more you value consistency with the platform. The problem is, no one starts out with this knowledge or value system.
- rdiddly 10y agoUI "conventions" (i.e. fashions) wouldn't be such a big deal if people adhered more closely to first principles like discoverability, etc.