6 ms·
India is set to launch a scale model of a reusable spacecraft on Monday
- hackaflocka 11y agoMy suggestion to India: focus on encouraging the would-be Elon Musks in your population. Give them permission to do it. Remove the barriers to them doing it. You'll get there much faster if the private sector were doing it.
- hackaflocka 11y agoWow -- people are downvoting such basic commonsense.
- piyushpr134 11y agobecause it is a pathetic comment. Thank you
- dang 10y agoYour comments have repeatedly broken the site guidelines. We ban accounts that do this, so please follow them from now on. That means posting civilly and substantively, or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- generj 11y agoThe fact of the matter is, space has only really become feasible for the private sector in the last few decades in the US and a few other countries. The overriding reason for this has been large government funded research programs funding the sunk cost initial R&D for the private sector. A secondary reason is the now widespread usage of commercial satellites. Countries with private space companies also have long-standing aeronautical engineering companies. India lacks all of these things. Shifting all of the space program to private companies would be a disaster there. Companies rarely finance scientific endeavors because the payout on them is too long - and many pure science efforts like landing on Europa offer no possible payback plan. Science in space cannot exist without government largess. Also, one of the primary reasons for space research has historically been weapons deployment (ICBM). Private firms are not going to fund that sort of development - unless the government pays them to do so. I am tired of people applying a free market rant to everything they run into. Any economist will tell you that the "free market" only really applies in very particular markets (perfect competition), and even those have a common trade/law/infrastructure system established by a government. Space is actually better suited to oligopolies, which are almost as far away from a free market as possible and practically dictate a need for regulation.
- anonymousab 11y agoIs there evidence of ISRO doing a bad or inefficient job?
- negamax 10y agoThe reason you are getting downvoted is because you come across as fault pointer at a successful event. Yes, India needs more private sector participation. It has been divesting like crazy but more the better. There's lots of groundwork, infra and social norms need to be challenged and changed for US like entrepreneurship scenario. India has it's own strength and weaknesses. In last few years, it has done a good job of recognising those weaknesses and enhancing strengths.
- balakk 11y agoIt's launched already, deemed successful. http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/science/india-successfully-launches-reusable-launch-vehicle/article8635448.ece?homepage=true http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/science/india-successfully-...
- hackaflocka 11y agoSuch a poorly worded article, replete with grammatical errors. No close-up pictures of the "shuttle." Strange. (And I'm not talking about a generic long range picture of a rocket taking off either.) The episode has the smell of government propaganda.
- slaxman 11y ago'No pictures of the "shuttle." Strange.' The picture clearly shows a 'winged' rocket as described in the article. "The episode has the smell of government propaganda." Not sure from where you get the smell of government propaganda. ISRO has been credited for some of the most successful launches. They sent a probe to mars in the first attempt. There seem to be smart folks working there.
- mangamadaiyan 11y agoI don't understand the downvotes. There's always a place for contrasting opinions, and /especially/ when they're expressed politely, they deserve a polite response. I have the same doubts. I'd love to see a picture of the real thing.
- Allamaprabhu 11y agokudos
- dingo_bat 11y agoSome news outlets have been calling it a "space shuttle", which is highly inaccurate considering that this has no plans of being for human use. I'm happy with the progress ISRO has made but lying/deception will not help anybody.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- trhway 11y agohttp://indianexpress.com/article/technology/science/isro-rlv-science-india-takes-baby-step-towards-reusable-space-shuttle-today-2814507/ http://indianexpress.com/article/technology/science/isro-rlv... "The hypersonic flight experiment (HEX) will be followed by the landing experiment (LEX), return flight experiment (REX) and scramjet propulsion experiment (SPEX)." Notice - scramjet. I think it isn't reusable space program like SpaceX's. It is more of an advanced tech development program with "spaceplane" being a goal. Dovetails nicely with the current active development of 7Mach Russian-Indian scramjet missile BraMos 2.
- dgaaaaaaaaaa 11y agoIt could be just ignorance. I would bet that the journalist thought that space shuttle is a fancy word for rocket.
- dingo_bat 10y agoIt is a mix of ignorance and trying to exaggerate/sensationalize everything.
- piyush_soni 11y agoUnfortunately, ISRO can't control what news outlets write about them.
- grkvlt 10y agoThis isn't 'lying' or 'deception' in any sense of the words. News outlets are calling it a space shuttle because they are either misinformed, confused, or just trying to find a form of words that will be familiar to a layman and confer a general sense of what is being attempted while not striving for, or caring too much about, technical accuracy. Off topic - It's a little sad when people's first reaction to a mistake or inaccuracy is to immediately claim it as a deliberate attempt to mislead or other malicious act, and I see this a lot. Generally in Internet arguments the response to someone making an incorrect statement seems to be to call them a liar, as though they are deliberately misstating things, rather than simply being wrong...
- deanstag 11y ago'Everything went according to the projectory, he said adding that the winged space plane will not be recovered from the sea.' - Is that okay? Do a lot of missions around the world consider sea a dumping ground?
- iLoch 11y agoYeah. My mission of taking the garbage out, amongst others.
- abhishekash 11y agoAs per point 6 and 7 on http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/india-all-set-to-launch-its-own-space-shuttle-today-1408943 http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/india-all-set-to-launch-its-o... , it seems that India does not intend to dump unwanted stuff in the sea
- hackaflocka 11y agoIf I were a competing space agency, I'd get my hands on the wreckage ASAP (if India doesn't plan to recover it).
- lmm 10y agoThe ocean, for spacecraft first stages, yes. Rocket launches are so infrequent and the ocean so large that it seems irrelevant, and in any case there's no practical alternative for a nation that's just getting started with spaceflight.
- pravula 10y agoIndia has been launching from 1960s. It is not "a nation that's just getting started with spaceflight"
- piyushpr134 11y agoUncle, this is not north korea or some bullshit US company. ISRO has sent missions to mars and moon. NASA works with them. Moreover, please open you eyes and check the first picture on the article.
- yyyuuu 11y agoChill dude ..
- hackaflocka 11y agoIt's a generic picture of a rocket. I want close up pictures of this so-called shuttle.
- piyushpr134 10y agoIt is not. It has wings and is much smaller than a regular rocket
- pjc50 10y agohttp://www.isro.gov.in/sites/default/files/galleries/Reusable%20Launch%20Vehicle-Technology%20Demonstrator%20%28RLV-TD%29%20Images/5c330.jpg http://www.isro.gov.in/sites/default/files/galleries/Reusabl...
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11751948 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11751948 and marked it off-topic.
- dmode 11y ago"The final version will take at least 10-15 years to get ready." This was at the bottom of the Hindu article. How does this compare with SpaceX and Blue Origin's timelines ?
- pm90 11y agoThey're probably not trying to compete in the global market for space launches as much as simply reduce costs for the Indian national space program. Most people often forget that SpaceX is a US company, and hence the services it supplies are subject to US laws, specifically, export restrictions and sanctions.
- pravula 10y agoActually, they have a commercial launch arm and do compete in global market. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antrix_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antrix_Corporation).
- generj 11y agoSpaceX is within 1-2 years of the Falcon Heavy; same timeline for the Dragon 2 capsule (reusable) for carrying humans into and out of space. Blue Origin's timeline to orbit is a quite a bit longer and filled with a lot more question marks. With that said, there is value for India in having their own cheap space launch system which can't be blocked off by the US on a whim.
- adventured 11y agoI agree. Even if the launch vehicle were to fail, there's a large amount of value for India in building up the significant infrastructure (both technological and intellectual) involved in having broad space capabilities. In the next five or so years India will pass France to become the fifth largest economy in nominal terms; in the next 15-20 years they'll probably overtake the UK, Germany and Japan to move into third place. It definitely makes sense for them to keep investing in space regardless of the outcome on something like this vehicle.
- nautical 11y agoOfficial Link : http://www.isro.gov.in/technology-development-programmes/reusable-launch-vehicle-technology-demonstration-program-rlv-td http://www.isro.gov.in/technology-development-programmes/reu... (Posted here before : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11751458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11751458)
- rahuldeshpande 10y agoA direct link to images : http://www.isro.gov.in/rlv-td/reusable-launch-vehicle-technology-demonstrator-rlv-td-images http://www.isro.gov.in/rlv-td/reusable-launch-vehicle-techno...
- yoda2 11y agoRather than focusing on competition between different organizations we should focus on development happening in space science in recent years.
- linux_devil 11y agoIndian Space Research Organization or ISRO plans to test two more such prototypes before the final version which will be about six times larger at around 40 metres and will take off around 2030. src :http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/india-all-set-to-launch-its-own-space-shuttle-today-1408943 http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/india-all-set-to-launch-its-o...
- arjie 10y agoVideo would be cool. Something I really like is being able to watch all these launches, famous or otherwise. On Youtube, you can go all the way to the Saturn SA-1 launch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-0-8Pd7fK9w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-0-8Pd7fK9w. Fantastic stuff.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- runewell 10y agoCool! The more common reusable rockets become, the more we can assume their cost benefits and apply them to even more ambitious space projects.
- ramgorur 10y agosome people in india are saying this might be a lousy propaganda, no one knows what, you can never be 100% sure of what modi government says (or does). But, let's say I have enough money and man-power to build a nintendo-ds and a hygienic toilet, moreover assume, I don't have either. Also assume, I go outside my home to take a dump on the street (or behind a bush), but I also want to play super-mario-bros on the nintendo-ds at the same time. which one should I build first? obviously the toilet, right? before making a reusable spacecraft, we should spend some rupees on making some good toilets -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixJgY2VSct0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixJgY2VSct0 we should be more serious about prioritizing the issues that we want to spend the tax-payers' money on.
- sriram_malhar 10y agoEvery country -- even the poorest -- can afford to do multiple things well at the same time. Both sanitation and space exploration have their own benefits. As a Nigerian economist once said, "we are not a poor country; we are a poorly managed country".