11 ms·
State of Starfighter
- Alex3917 11y ago"We're going to be stepping up our operational tempo as a recruiting company, rather than sinking back into the dev cave where we're comfortable for weeks at a time." Without respect to whether this is the right move in this situation, which it may be, I'd like to point out that, as 'advice', this is suspiciously trendy lately. I can't count the number of times in the last month where I've had people who have never seen or used our product tell me that our product is already good enough, and we need to spend more time doing growth or sales stuff.
- diziet 11y agoHow many users have you folks gotten to register?
- patio11 11y agoOnly about ~40,000 or so, but I wouldn't pick that as one of the top three metrics I'd be interested in. It's like hits. I don't even know how many hits we've gotten, and frankly no answer to that question matters to me. (Good candidates for metrics that I should be worrying about might be "number of players who hit our internal bar for outreach", "percentage of that population who would like Starfighter to give them options", "count of successful placements", and "revenue." You'll understand if I don't publish a /stats page with those numbers updated in real time, even though the thought certainly crossed my mind a time or three.)
- zeemonkee3 11y agoI was looking for the most important metric in the article - how many jobs have you filled so far? I have limited bandwidth for free-time coding, and anything has to compete with my own side projects and "list of things I need to learn/revise to keep head above water in notoriously mercurial industry". If I were to invest time in Starfighter, I'd need to know that, assuming I do my part and finish the game with a reasonable score, that a) it will land me an interview and b) it will do sufficient pre-vetting of my skills so that the interviewer doesn't need to throw whiteboard curveballs. If I saw some kind of metric on job placement I might think it's worth spending time on. Otherwise my time would be better invested in improving my Github profile and resume and building my network.
- diziet 11y agoTotally reasonable, though a couple of those things are not metrics you mentioned but measures of potential market.
- solutionyogi 11y agoCopying my comment from last time which went unnoticed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11448323 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11448323 Thomas and Patrick: First, I want to thank you for trying to address one of the most frustrating part of a developer's career. As you know very well, after Silicon Valley, it's the finance companies in NYC area who pay top notch developer salaries. Even though I am a competent developer, it was quite a struggle for me to break in to the finance industry (They only wanted to hire people with finance experience). It took me a little while but I was able to break in. Now I am over that hump but I am faced with another problem. I have been working in 'Back office' for hedge funds for several years and would like to transition to 'Front office' and I am faced with the same problem again. I am not able to switch roles because I don't have experience working in the front office. The Stock Fighter CTF is a perfect way to demonstrate the relevant ability to prospective employers. Do you guys have any plan to work with hedge funds/investment banks for your recruiting platform?
- patio11 11y agoYes. Something like 90% of our client roster is software companies; most of the balance is finance firms. (There are some companies that are a bit of column A and a bit of column B.) Some developers are under the impression that we only work with finance due to the theme of our first game, but we care about finance like Blizzard cares about orcs -- it is a convenient backdrop on which to hang fun gameplay, stories, and a few pedagogical goals. (Mostly engineering-oriented rather than market-microstructure oriented, but if we totally change the tenor of HN HFT threads I will be very happy indeed.) Many of our finance industry clients/prospective clients have, shall we say, more process requirements to adopting new vendors than typical software startups have, and rather less reason to trust that we know what we're doing. This makes the sales cycle longer. Medium-term, I'd love for us to be a good place to get developer jobs in the finance industry. If you were hypothetically in a conversation with me today about opportunities constrained to finance (and not FinTech), I would not have as many options as I want to have, but I'd hypothetically recommend keeping in touch and/or waiting for consequential announcements later in the year.
- tehabe 11y agoConfusing, at first I thought this was about the F-104 Starfighter, than I thought it was a new science-fiction computer game but I never thought about a recruiting firm. I hope I'm not alone.
- daveguy 11y agoBlog post is crashing my mobile browser: chrome on galaxy S5. Anyone else having this problem?
- aeorgnoieang 11y agoIt's Discourse (forum webapp) and I suspect it's a rather heavy site for mobile devices.
- codinghorror 11y agoHmm that device is modern enough, latest Chrome version? Any plugins?
- daveguy 11y agoMost recent chrome. No mobile plugins (that I know of). Coming back a day later (after a reset) the site is slow to load and scroll, but is not crashing every time. Maybe just the forum webapp (Discourse) that is just too heavy for mobile like aeorg mentioned.
- codinghorror 10y agoWeird, the Galaxy s5 should have enough power to run modern JavaScript apps. Have not seen this reported elsewhere in the network.
- daveguy 11y agoBlog post is crashing my mobile browser chrome on galaxy S5. Anyone else having this problem?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoInteresting. I must have misread something early on because I thought Startfighter was launched to improve recruiting of coders and stuff. I didn't know about games and such. Does that factor into recruiting or is there a nice post showing exactly what it's about? Tptacek?
- patio11 11y agoThis is our perpetual messaging conundrum: are we a game company or a recruiting company? Yes. When we talk to our clients, we're a recruiting company which uses online challenges to a) source and b) pre-qualify very good engineering candidates. When we talk to engineers, we're a company which makes fun engineering-y things you can do on the Internet. (Hack a stock exchange through it's REST API! Code a market maker! Buffer overrun a C program running on an AVR microprocessor to corrupt a FIX message to steal a billion dollars!) And we can also, potentially, introduce you to a job if that is interesting to you. Our estimation is approximately 95% of our users are not in the market for a job at this exact moment in time. You can see the two-sided messaging on our website: For companies: https://www.starfighters.io/approach https://www.starfighters.io/approach For engineers: https://www.starfighters.io/players https://www.starfighters.io/players
- nickpsecurity 11y agoOk, so I wasn't crazy thinking there were two companies with the name haha. That's a very interesting approach to talent selection. Sounds like an evolution over the programming puzzle's in interviews except not a waste of time or stressful. I like that you make it fun and extremely relevant to security skills at same time. Extra props for the Bobby Tables reference. Thanks for the answer!
- davidw 11y ago> Yes Which one pays the bills - or will pay them? Given this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11692083 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11692083 I'm kind of curious how you guys - who have a boatload of startup/bootstrap smarts - managed to go off "into the weeds" of geeking out on the tech and ignoring the company's business. If you want to talk about it, of course. Good luck in any case!
- the_rosentotter 11y agoYour biggest problem is that I have read several quite long blog posts about Starfighter, and I still don't understand what it is. I am a developer, I like to believe of above average intelligence, I'm your captive audience. If I don't get it, what are the chances the rest of the world will?
- amitutk 11y agoDevelopers play games on this platform. The games are testing their technical competence. This info is passed/sold to recruiters. Hypothesis: If you are good at these games, you will be good at your technical job.
- solutionyogi 11y agoHave you seen their homepage? https://starfighters.io/ https://starfighters.io/ "Starfighter is a recruiting firm that detects and introduces the best programmers on the market." And to learn how they achieve it, see: https://starfighters.io/approach https://starfighters.io/approach And to provide some context as to why Patrick and Thomas are in this venture, http://sockpuppet.org/blog/2015/03/06/the-hiring-post/ http://sockpuppet.org/blog/2015/03/06/the-hiring-post/ (my all time favorite article by Thomas) Hope this helps.
- schmichael 11y agoI'm confused as well. The description on their home page that you cite doesn't match the description they provide on the linked : > Starfighter, if you're new here, is a company which makes fun engineering challenges that you can play online for free. I can see how the two things would be related, but it's still confusing brand messaging.
- rargulati 11y agoOut of curiosity, would something like "play games, get hired" convey the message better?
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- partisan 11y agoThank you for being so open and honest. A lot of people look up to you and I think it is a good thing for them to understand that one does not spontaneously become a patio11 and that the struggles continue on even after success (however that is measured). I have some questions below, though I understand if you prefer not to address the topics therein. > The components to this include an emulated AVR microcontroller, an emulated hardware device built out of three of those microcontrollers, a scratch-built C compiler, a scratch-built fully-functional debugger, and an in-browser UI to tie everything together. I'd say you guys jumped into the deep end of the pool and your goals from a technology standpoint were ambitious, to put it politely. Do you think that you would have taken a different approach if you could do it over again? Did you have to invent these wheels or where there other options you could have leveraged to accomplish the same goal? Is the technology you are building part of your competitive advantage? Having seen in-browser consoles and programming environments, I just have to wonder what the advantage is of coming at the recruiting problem from a hard computing perspective. As a programmer, that is the way I would approach it as well, since that is where I would feel I am making the most impact, but that would simply be to make me feel useful and not to move the company along, necessarily. Also, I detected a hint of discord in yours and tptacek's posts during and after your release. Would you say that the process has put a strain on relationships, even if temporarily?
- patio11 11y agoDo you think that you would have taken a different approach if you could do it over again? Oh goodness yes. If I had a do-over, I'd run a straight-up recruiting company with ~0 lines of code written for 2~3 months on the strength of our personal networks, figure out how that works, launch a single tech tree far closer in scope to e.g. Stripe CTF 3 than what we launched, fold candidates developed from that into the recruiting stream, then scale engineering and recruiting in parallel. Instead we went into hard-core dev mode for ~10 months to do something which derisked the business a lot less than being recruiters for a month would have. Co-founder relationships are co-founder relationships. It's been a stressful year getting a totally new thing off the ground. I think thats a comes-with-the-territory sort of thing based on the reports of literally every founder I know; it is new territory to me. Maybe someday I'll write more about that, but for the moment, still have to figure out recruiting first.
- oafitupa 11y agoYet another failure for patio11, the "how to be successful" blog posts guy.
- Grue3 11y agoI remember this thing from back when it was launched. I only solved like 3 levels, but I did it entirely in Lisp. Which brings me to the following observation: since there's no way to see the source code, it's not possible to check if the person legitimately solved the task or just used somebody else's code.
- linuxfan2718 11y agoyour source code is checked on the last level
- aresant 11y agoIn my experience with marketing two-sided marketplaces you need to focus your messaging / outreach around the more scarce asset, the "catalyst asset", let's call it. The catalyst asset in this case is developers. If Starfighter's system / gamification can actually identify incredible developers, that are also amenable to looking at job offers, the recruiters will be banging down your door. Right now the Starfighter landing page is recruiter centric, the "For Engineers" and "Play Now" are low contrast menu items at the top. Further confusing the issue for your catalyst audience is that your player-centric funnel is called Stockfighter.io and yet most of the mentions (including this one) are of Starfighter. I think you'd get a lot of engineer's attention if you kept it as simple as "Play engineering games developed by experts. Winners get a better job." PS - Considering how many times you guys have been / will be at the top of HN why don't you consider adding a "Try Starfighter. Get a better job." button to the right side of the blog as a call to action so all these lovely clicks aren't wasted?
- patio11 11y agoThe day we can credibly promise "Winners get a better job." we will have that exact sentence on our website, tended to by a team of people whose only responsibility is finding more players, paid salaries out of the stupefyingly large rivers of money that sentence implies. A pre-requisite to being able to truthfully say it is figuring out how to run a quirky take on a recruiting company. Until we feel comfortable on that, we don't have to maximize for reach, and certainly don't want to overpromise. ("Come use our fake stock exchange. It may not crash! Some people find it intellectually interesting! There exists a non-zero possibility that you might have a fun conversation with a geek in which that stock exchange and your career goals will feature prominently." is about what we can promise right now.)
- davidw 11y ago"This site can’t be reached" right now. Interesting - I can ssh to a server of mine and read it. So maybe it's getting blocked by the firewall here. If that's happening here, perhaps it's happening elsewhere too.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gist 11y agoMeanwhile starfighter.io points a job search page which shows jobs from indeed.com...
- galistoca 11y agoAny competent developer I would like to hire would be spending time building stuff with their skills instead of playing games with it. No disrespect to the players, but just saying if you're good at something you should use your gift to produce something useful instead of using it to consume what someone else built.
- danielvf 11y agoHey now! :) Tinkering with things is a fantastic way to learn. And a desire to tinker for the sake of understanding is a really good tell for a smart problem solver. Every job I've had has been because I played around with some technology for fun, and then ran into people who had a need for it. Playing with code can also be relaxing. In my normal work, the code that I write needs to be reliable, maintainable, and performant. Buy playing stockfighter is a way to have fun without the burden of any that. I can do really stupid stuff, just for the joy of it. Heck, I hooked up a spam filter to one of the levels and won. Or built a minecraft stockfighter hologram visualizer.
- lordnacho 11y agoI'm genuinely excited about a recruitment firm where the people can actually code. It's an industry that needs some skills, even just basic ones like calling back people that you said you'd call. So often you get guys who have no clue talking about things they don't understand, deciding who gets to apply where. This is terrible for both employees and firms. They also charge way too much money as a middleman. No way it's worth 1/4 of a salary to filter a list of candidates. Especially when you just do it by the staircase method. That's the one where you throw the pile off a staircase and choose the ones on one step. I really hope recruitment doesn't turn you into douchebags. Here's some choice tactics I've come across: - They call you, the employer, with the perfect candidate. Guy checks all the boxes, top degree, top employment history, looking to move for more interesting work. Half an hour before the interview, he cancels. But luckily the recruiter has some other guys available, and why not talk to them since that time is booked anyway? - They call you, the employee, saying one of your colleagues is leaving and mentioned you. He's got a top job lined up, just send your CV. (Why bother harvesting CVs though, if you're gonna do like in tactic one?) - They bomb your LinkedIn with an employee's CV. Your LinkedIn say nothing about you wanting to hire, or what technologies you use. - They put out generic ads to get CVs. Not real jobs, just imaginary jobs. Anyway, I'm hoping there's going to be some real value added from you guys.
- patio11 11y agoThe last few months have been an interesting mix of learning empathy for some of the pathologies of the recruiting industry and being absolutely slackjawed amazed at how bad some players [edit in response to reply: meaning, actors in the recruiting industry] are. An example of the former: I now totally understand why recruiters frequently forget elementary facts about individual candidates or jobs. They're often juggling multiples of both at once, at numbers which overwhelm the working memory of almost any human, for weeks at a time. I had a very nice conversation with (making up facts) Cindy the Pythonist and Sandy the front-end engineer one Tuesday, minutes from each other, and three weeks later had about twenty minutes of the conversation with Sandy go by before realizing that I was giving her advice for Cindy's situation, to her amazement. I do know that React is not made of Python, and I've recently shipped a retail stock trading site built in it, but from Sandy's view of the conversation it probably sounded like I was scatterbrained, incompetent, or scatterbrained and incompetent. I thought I could fix this with better notes or a database, but I think it has to be fixed with process improvements, because the amount of task-switching I was doing was making it impossible for me to keep each of the X0 stories I was telling straight. I don't anticipate us adopting lying as a business tactic. Telling the truth seems so much more straightforward.
- educar 11y agoI am wondering why you are not selling your product for what it is. You have made a game/CTF engine/whatever. This is your expertise and what you have spent the most time on. Sell the game. I don't quite get the recruiting angle. How is this related to the above other than the assumption that your game helps identify smart people? Leave it to other companies to approach you rather than you approaching companies.
- weinzierl 11y ago> Incidentally: should you ever go in to get a bank account at a Japanese bank, remember to edit your company's website to take the words I rob banks because that is where the money is. off your homepage prior to the initial customer interview. Irony doesn't translate well. ("NO NO NO, we're not bank robbers; we're a video game company! Honest!" "What, like Nintendo?" "... In a manner of speaking, almost exactly like Nintendo.") This is hilarious. BTW the quote is really there - https://www.starfighters.io/ctfs https://www.starfighters.io/ctfs.
- no_wave 11y agoI have two takeaways from this article: 1.) Your organization is in a rough state right now (for any number of reasons, some outside of your control), and you're likely to have more difficulties going forwards. 2.) You haven't successfully placed a single developer into a job yet even though forty thousand people have signed up. Both of these statements might be inaccurate, but those were the main things communicated. I'm much less likely to open an account having read this, and I don't understand why new levels are being released when the recruiting pipeline currently seems like the bottleneck of the business.
- hawkice 11y agoThanks for pushing the human element of recruiting forward. Instantiating the Recruiting post by Mr. Ptacek is perhaps the best good any small group of people can do for tech at this point. That being said, I lost a lot of interest when it started seeming like finishing the game had a low chance of leading to anything. If your retrospective says, when we started, we should have only done recruitment and gotten that at 100% before writing any code, why is your near term plan to launch the low level tech tree environment, followed by the challenges? Shouldn't the plan be, oh, hey, let's put that completely on the back burner, and get like ten stories of employees who are comfortable with us telling where and how they got an awesome job?
- armitron 11y agoI totally do not understand the reason for starfighters existing. Who is it aimed at? Mediocre engineers? Those targeting hedge funds? First of all, as a boss, I would never hire someone from starfighters without an additional interview. Too many ways for one(s) to game the system. The current interview process may have faults, but it works out OK for the vast majority of the field. Are Ptacek & co trying to fix a problem that's simply not there? As a software engineer, why would I even consider wasting my time with starfighters.io when I can simply go do as many traditional interviews as I want, with the top 10 companies in my field (that are also not using starfighters.io), get multiple job offers that I can use for leverage/negotiation, without having middlemen parasitize off of me. And this is exactly what starfighters.io is, a middleman. Historically, middlemen have been tolerated (yet always seen as parasites) whenever they ABSOLUTELY HAD to be there. Ptacek's background is in computer security (Matasano). Rumor has it that whatever success they had came from consulting (penetration testing). The single product that they released that I am aware of, a firewall rule manager, didn't seem to go anywhere. One has to wonder what he's doing with starfighters.io.
- ryanSrich 11y ago> I would never hire someone from starfighters without an additional interview This is the crux of my issue with the product as well. I'm entirely uncertain what a Starfighter candidate gets me as a hiring manager. I'm not going to blindly hire someone because they passed a few levels in an online programming game. The fact that the candidate is technically competent accounts for only 10% of what I test a candidate for in an interview.
- hawkice 11y agoA very reasonable and predictable attitude. Which raises the question: what does this get engineers, if it takes a lot of time and doesn't save any in the interviewing phase? Personally, I hate resumes with the fury of a thousand winds. They say nothing important and decontextualize every important thing I've done in my career. But this won't help unless the Starfighter crew has managed to negotiate _something not so small_ with hiring managers who are skeptical of everything (it is kind of their job to be skeptical, sort of?).
- mattste 11y agoJust a heads up to the Starfighter team browsing this thread: going to starfighter.io with uBlock Origin results in the job listings being blocked. EDIT: it appears starfighter.io is different than starfighters.io.
- pfarnsworth 11y agoIf this doesn't allow successful candidates to skip the onsite interview, then what value does this add? I had the exact same criticism for TripleByte. If I spend the time going through a non-direct link to a company, there has to be some value along the lines of skipping onsites which are the bane of our existence as programmers these days. If going through starfighter doesn't help us with this, then there's no value, I can just email the company and get a phone interview pretty quickly.
- elliotec 11y agoI'm with you. This really just seems like another annoying step in the broken process that will add more pain.
- dragonwriter 11y agoI think the engineers that it is aimed at are the ones for which it will not add more pain: specifically, I gather that the entire idea is to have something that provides a useful input to a recruiting process (even if it doesn't completely replace, e.g., interviews, it ideally at least replaces coding tests in interviews with something simultaneously less tedious and more real-world) while actually being something interesting enough on its own to engineers that many of them, if it existed and wasn't tied to recruiting, would engage with it anyway for personal development and/or entertainment. (The name being a reference to The Last Starfighter sort of implies this: you play the game for fun, win, and someone drops out of the sky with a job offer doing what you were doing in the game, but in a non-game environment.) Obviously, making this work requires both convincing hiring managers that it can replace at least some of the annoying technical parts of the hiring process, and developing engaging games that can engage, collectively, a sufficient pool of engineering talent. Sounds like the concern is that, to date, they may have focused too much on the latter and not enough on the former, but while that's a challenge, I don't think it has to be an insurmountable one.
- myblake 11y agoThis really hits the nail on the head. The problem with onsites is really the "quick prove to me you're smart" type of tests that both are time intensive and also very frustrating to a lot of people in that they're often calibrated with a heavy bias towards avoiding false positives with nothing to even track the amount of false negatives. Success with something like start fighter provides a reasonable benchmark for the latter which is in itself pretty valuable. The thing to consider though is that it would be crazy to take a job without going in to meet your potential future coworkers. It's also a quicker and less unpleasant process (and more of a two way street) to try and make sure it's a good cultural match. Thus, solving a bunch of the problems with technical interviews shouldn't actually eliminate onsites, it should rather make them more effective and less awful.
- loeg 11y agoI finished all of the Microcorruption challenges relatively quickly (I'm on the first page of the "Hall of Fame"). Yet I have no idea how to approach the 2nd level of Stockfighter ("Choc a Block"). It's frustrating and I don't enjoy that game. Given that, I don't see how Starfighters could possibly place me in a reasonable role.
- WA 11y agoI felt similar. Especially since Patrick said that something like "the first levels of Stockfighters are so easy, most devs should be able to beat them in 5 minutes with cURL only". It actually took me three days to beat chop a block, because I couldn't wrap my brain around it. Then I beat it, but more due to luck I guess, because my bot couldn't reliably beat it again. Edit: What I want to say is: Don't get discouraged too quickly. If you enjoy it somewhat, it's kind of nice to figure out how to win :)
- SyneRyder 11y agoDitto on the "don't get discouraged". I've gone through a few levels now and part of it has been perserverance (and sometimes a lot of thinking & sketching ideas over coffee). The "5 minutes with cURL" comment is definitely offputting if you get stuck. Ignore it. Consider it a convenient lie that helped motivate you to start, but don't kick yourself over it. As for the unreliable bot - many of my first solutions were something unreliable. Then I went back and improved the code's reliability / performance. Having a stroke of "luck" is usually just a first insight into what's going on.
- disgruntledphd2 11y agoRead the level instructions. They tell you specifically how to do it. Seriously, I barely knew what a POST request was and I can beat that level reliably.
- nilkn 11y agoI think the #1 issue this is going to encounter is that companies aren't going to trust it enough to hire top players blindly or with only a culture-fit interview, and most top developers aren't going to want to invest in finishing all the Starfighter exercises if it just means they're going to be put through the gauntlet again for each individual company they're put into contact with. (Certainly some top developers will still participate, just for the fun of it, but probably not enough to make it into a really sustainable high-impact business.) I really love the idea, though, and I want to believe that with enough perseverance this issue could be solved. I think it mostly centers around trust. Starfighter just has to establish itself as an extremely reliable recruiting platform.
- partisan 11y ago@patio11 Do you play starfighters? How do you ensure that the product is fun for the end user?
- daxorid 11y agoQuestion to the proprietors: How would you prevent proliferation of solutions to levels on github, etc, as has happened with Thomas's cryptopals challenges?
- lawnchair_larry 11y agoIt seems like there are 2 very simple metrics that make everything else pretty irrelevant. For applicants - how many who "pass" get jobs? For employers - how many positions did you fill? I found it odd that the blog post intentionally left that out. Getting someone an interview is not a good metric! And as someone who has spent a fair bit of time on both sides (it sounds like the founders have minimal experience actually applying for jobs) it is a huge mistake to interview serially. Companies take their sweet time getting back to you (weeks is not uncommon), and their initial offer is not as good as it could be. When they know that they are competing for a candidate, they are very quick to move on a candidate. This helps the whole "follow up" problem solve itself. While it might seem like it requires more mental bandwidth, it probably requires less. And customer satisfaction goes way up. For someone job hunting, every passing hour waiting for an outcome can be brutal. Also, I am simultaneously impressed and confused by the technical investment. It's fantastic work, but doesn't seem like it is helping to increment #1 or #2.
- cm2187 11y agoAnother website that can't just display some html without javascript...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]