5 ms·
> The documents have revealed the hidden assets of hundreds of politicians, officials, current and former national leaders, celebrities and sports stars. I fee
by jedberg 11y ago
> The documents have revealed the hidden assets of hundreds of politicians, officials, current and former national leaders, celebrities and sports stars.
I feel bad for the celebrities and sports stars. In all likelihood, most of them probably have no idea that their money is in a tax haven. Some of them probably do, but most of them probably outsourced their money management.
The politicians I'm thinking probably had an idea of what was going on with their money, but maybe they outsource just as much.
I'm just saying a lot of the people in this database are probably just rich people who made a bad (or good depending on your point of view) choice in accountant.
- return0 11y agoI don't believe that at all. That said, i 'm OK with people finding legal ways to avoid taxes.
- a3n 11y ago"I'm rich. Here Mr Congressman, write me a law that makes this practice legal. Here's a campaign contribution."
- pc86 11y agoThat's ridiculous. Nobody says "I'm rich."
- kafkaesq 11y agoThey don't need to. The donations (and other things the wealthy and connected to get the attention of lawmakers) speak much louder than words.
- dpark 11y agoWell, almost no one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjTmUhcRX3I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjTmUhcRX3I
- a3n 11y agoCaricature to shorten the example.
- uola 11y agoLegality as such isn't really relvant when it comes to tax planning. Not only that, but most people don't actually care about illegal tax planning even if they say they do, because in that case you would ask for a receipt ever time at your corner store. What you instead should ask yourself is if you are okay with people paying less tax then they would if the tax agency had all the information and resources to find out the truth.
- belorn 11y agoAre you OK with people using other kind of loopholes/bugs in the legal system, or is it just the tax system? We have for example involuntary manslaughter, which was a fix to a legal system which before only considered a crime if someone had an intention to kill someone. As the story goes, the law came as a result from train companies in the early days went ahead and drove with no warning horn or cross overs, and as a result people got run over. The train companies did not have an intention to kill anyone, and their action was legal, but people kept dying from train accidents and society did not deem that OK. Thus the law was changed.
- return0 11y agoThese laws are the result of expanded free international trade. We're not entitled to the one without the other. So if these double taxation and trade agreements were gone, then also tariffs should be increased, and suddenly, the iphone becomes unaffordable.
- roel_v 11y agoThere were varying degrees of guilt when killing someone in Roman law already. Suggesting that involuntary manslaughter was 'invented' because of trains is preposterous. You might be thinking of corporate manslaughter but that's an entirely different matter. You also seem to suggest that people were killed in droves because of trains not using a horn, and that the only was that was stopped was by introducing some new form of manslaughter. I hope you see for yourself how that falls under the category of 'extraordinary claims', which as we know requires extraordinary evidence.
- belorn 11y agoSince you are talking about proofs, will you now provide evidence that it was criminal in roman law to unintentionally cause someones death? They had mines and work accidents, so it should be easy for you to find. I mean, I only recited what I heard from a professor of law and legal history, but I am sure that as a random person on the INTERNET as yourself has more validity. That extraordinary evidence you provided is all I needed.
- kasey_junk 11y agoI think its important to remember that when people talk about "tax havens" what they are really talking about are places with strict privacy laws. The most common reason people want those privacy laws is tax mitigation, but for certain people, celebrities and sports stars especially, the privacy could be the entire motivation.
- uola 11y agoMostly not. When talking about privacy in terms of tax havens it's rather wheter or not they have signed and comply with information sharing agreements i.e. privacy from the government.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agouh... delware corporations have the strict privacy laws... only difference is taxes. you're an idiot.
- mabbo 11y agoJimmy Carr had this happen to him[0] and basically handled it pretty well. He stayed in public, took the ridicule and admitted his wrongdoing. He had an accountant take things too far, and he went along with it because hey, more money. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carr#2012_tax_avoidance_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carr#2012_tax_avoidance_...
- TillE 11y agoI was surprised how much vitriol was directed towards Jimmy Carr. He even got a scolding from David Cameron. Despite (apparently) doing nothing illegal. It's certainly a dishonest thing to do, but you've got to fix the laws; a moderately popular comedian is very far from the biggest offender.
- Loughla 11y agoWhy is 'because it's legal' a valid argument for nearly everything? Whatever happened to civic duty and moral obligation?
- pc86 11y agoDo you donate additional money to the treasury every year when you file your tax return?
- krapp 11y agoIt's a perfectly valid argument when someone is implying you've committed a crime.
- AndrewGaspar 11y agoThey did their civic duty and moral obligation by paying the exact obligation asked of them by society. If they don't use the number they got by following the tax law as written, which number do your propose is the ethical one? Rule by moral indignation of upper-middle class software developers is not a scalable system. If the tax law is written unsatisfyingly, try to fix the tax law. Don't claim immorality on the part of those who are working within it. Or colloquially, don't hate the player, hate the game.
- dredmorbius 11y agoQuoting John Doe (the Panama Papers leaker): The prevailing media narrative thus far has focused on the scandal of what is legal and allowed in this system. What is allowed is indeed scandalous and must be changed. But we must not lose sight of another important fact: the law firm, its founders, and employees actually did knowingly violate myriad laws worldwide, repeatedly. Publicly they plead ignorance, but the documents show detailed knowledge and deliberate wrongdoing. At the very least we already know that Mossack personally perjured himself before a federal court in Nevada, and we also know that his information technology staff attempted to cover up the underlying lies. They should all be prosecuted accordingly with no special treatment. https://panamapapers.icij.org/20160506-john-doe-statement.html https://panamapapers.icij.org/20160506-john-doe-statement.ht...
- jedberg 11y agoI'm not sure what your point was quoting that. This quote says that the lawyers knew what they were doing was wrong, but it says nothing about their clients being involved.
- dredmorbius 11y agoIs that leap really so great?
- wernercd 11y agoGuilty until proven innocent after all...
- dredmorbius 11y agoUnder Napoleonic law, yes, actually.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThe question is whether lawyers and clients should be accused the same. Whether we assume guilt or innocence while accusing them is a completely different topic.
- Randgalt 11y agoYes. Also, there is nothing wrong (legally or morally) with avoiding taxation.
- jedberg 11y agoLegally there is nothing wrong with it. Morality depends on who you ask. Maybe for you it isn't wrong, and that's fine, but to others it is. That's why it is hard to judge morality -- because it is based in opinion, not fact.
- DanBC 11y ago> legally Tax laws are so complex that we don't know if some tax avoidance schemes are legal or not. The accountants selling them claim they are legal. The tax authorities sometimes claim they're not legal. Ideally they'd go to court and get a ruling, but that's expensive and regulators tend to avoid court if possible (at least, in England they do) and so we have "agreements" where a scheme is deemed abusive and some amount of tax is repaid. There's no prosecution; no sentences; no convictions. These repayments are not fines. So it's hard to call that illegal.
- bpodgursky 11y ago> Tax laws are so complex that we don't know if some tax avoidance schemes are legal or not. That's the wrong way to phrase it. If you don't know if actions are legal or not, you are simply not living under the rule of law. There is no law, if you cannot reasonably figure out what the law is.
- uola 11y agoIt's probably not that hard to figure out what's going on if you live in a european welfare country and suddenly are asked to sign nominee contracts and have passport copies sent to Panama.
- awqrre 11y ago> ... probably have no idea .... You could also say "they probably knew about it" and you would be just as correct. But either way, it's their money, so they should have known about it.
- jedberg 11y agoWhen you hire a mechanic, do you make them tell you everything they did step by step? It's your car, shouldn't you know about what changes were made to it and how it is maintained? Maybe, but you probably don't. You probably trust your mechanic do to a good and legal job. It's the same here, they trusted the lawyers to do a good job.
- jude- 11y agoIn the US at least, you are responsible for ensuring your vehicle is street-legal when you drive it on public roads. You, not your mechanic, get the citation if it's not.
- zzleeper 11y agoThats BS. See the FC Barcelona case for instance. One player told another of a 'trick' to pay less taxes, and so on, and now half of their stars are on trial for tax evasion on multiple countries. Also, there is no way an acct will go out of his way for no return, they were likely hiring them for promises of super great deals, kinda like Madoff's investors.
- Mandatum 11y agoIf they were to on-shore all of their funds, would all be forgiven?