25 ms·
SpaceX lands rocket at sea second time after satellite launch
- mulmen 11y agoLooks like the landing was perfectly centered on the barge this time as well. Does anyone know when they plan on reusing one of these recovered first stages?
- haser_au 11y agoThey said at the beginning of the live stream that they plan to do a test fire on the first recovered first stage "sometime soon".
- reportingsjr 11y agoDid they say anything more specific than that? They have already done a static fire of the first one they recovered.
- agildehaus 11y agoThe first recovered stage, F9-021, has already been static fired and will likely end up as a monument outside of SpaceX HQ as they've filed an FAA request to do so. https://oeaaa.faa.gov/oeaaa/external/searchAction.jsp?action=displayOECase&oeCaseID=277099798&row=292 https://oeaaa.faa.gov/oeaaa/external/searchAction.jsp?action... The second recovered rocket, F9-023, will be relaunched. It has already been static fired with no announced problems. Elon said it'd be a few months before a customer was announced, but the general feeling is that it will be an SES satellite as SES has already publicly expressed interest.
- CamperBob2 11y agoAmusing... I was wondering why they needed to get FAA permission to park the rocket, but the application says it'll be 160 feet tall. So they're standing it up, as opposed to the NASA methodology of positioning their monuments horizontally.
- agildehaus 11y agoNormally a 160 foot tall object wouldn't need FAA permission, but SpaceX is located right next to Hawthorne Municipal Airport.
- dba7dba 11y agoAnd fairly close to LAX too. Another stop for star tour buses!
- dba7dba 11y agoThere is no open space to park a 160ft long object horizontally anywhere near spacex HQ.
- SpaceX_Tech 11y agoNot sure why your comment was downvoted but this is true, there really isn't much open space around the SpaceX property. I wish we had a campus like Raytheon or Northrop have in El Segundo/Redondo Beach. The 60's & 70's were certainly the high points in aerospace campus architecture here in SoCal.
- coderdude 11y agoDo you work for SpaceX? You have it in your username and comment like you're part of the company, but also spend your time discussing the merits of the NRA. Do you represent SpaceX or are you just super enthusiastic about them? It's not easy to tell.
- SpaceX_Tech 11y agoI do work for SpaceX although I'm not in engineering or software dev. I work in the technician/skilled labor side of the house. I don't think I've posted anything specifically discussing the merits of the NRA, although I have posted on the subject of gun control and self defense. In any case I'm not sure why discussing that topic and working at SpaceX would be mutually exclusive. Obviously it should be said that I don't represent SpaceX and the views I express here are my own and not the company's.
- SpaceX_Tech 11y agoBased on that FAA application it looks like someone will be losing their prime parking spot. In all seriousness though, I'm not sure how I feel about this monument. It's going to be really crammed next to the main building and I don't think it will have a very strong visual presence with a giant grey wall directly in the background. There isn't really a good vantage point for viewing either. I suppose it will look ok from the opposite corner of Crenshaw.
- Sanddancer 11y agoYou probably know best here, but I'm seeing a first stage height of 135 ft. Perhaps they're thinking of placing it on the roof of the main building? Though I do totally agree that it would look better elsewhere, like over by one of the onramps to the 105. Just a shame that the Western Museum of Flight moved, a nice little rocket garden in that museum would have been a nice touch.
- kchoudhu 11y agoDo customers get a discount for launching on a used rocket?
- lmm 11y agoThe first one definitely will (unless negotiations break down and they decide to launch without a customer, but that seems unlikely). Eventually when it becomes routine maybe not.
- Mchl 11y agoWhen it becomes routeine all clients get a discount as price per launch goes down.
- kchoudhu 11y agoOr not, because the next best alternative is much more expensive than SpaceX's current pricing. We're dealing with a corporation -- I'm not sure we can count of them to "pass on the savings".
- coralreef 11y agoAren't they passing on the savings by bidding lower prices than their competitors?
- Symmetry 11y agoThe thing is they're already able to bid lower than all their competitors.
- lmm 11y agoOnly marginally - if none of their competitors can reuse a rocket then they only need to undercut the cost of a non-reusable rocket. The reward for innovation is that you get a temporary monopoly on that innovation and so can extract something very like a monopoly rent.
- andygates 11y ago023 (Fnord) has been fired? I must have missed that. Got a link?
- funkysquid 11y agoGood question - Elon tweeted this https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/728459808270000128 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/728459808270000128 - sounds like they could end up with a backlog ;)
- aerovistae 11y agoA few months ago Elon said they were at least initially looking at June or July for a re-fly.
- gozur88 11y agoAt the presser following the first barge recovery Musk said they would probably re-launch it in June. It sounds like they aren't planning to do much with it beyond test firing.
- iamcreasy 11y agoA white ball of fire. And then there it is...resting! Beautiful!
- russdill 11y agoLove how the autobalance on the cameras cut almost everything to black so you could not see the rocket at first, until it emerged from the darkness.
- glaberficken 11y agoMoon landing deniers will have a field day with that camera's footage.
- adventured 11y agoMuch like with the moon landings, then SpaceX will do it another dozen times, and the deniers will pretend there was only one landing so as to fit the narrative better.
- andygates 11y agoSpaceX already have their little cadre of deniers - an offshoot of the "space isn't real" and "moon hologram" berks.
- fixermark 11y agoThat was an unexpected and delicious bit of Hollywood drama. My first assumption with the flash followed by darkness is that it had impacted too hard and exploded or wrecked the camera. The autobalance stabilizing was a great big-reveal moment.
- gozur88 11y agoThe stream I was watching had the video delayed a couple seconds from the audio. Based on the initial crowd reaction I assumed the landing was a failure.
- kirrent 11y agoFor those wondering, this isn't a simple repeat of CRS8 which landed on a drone ship about a month ago. CRS8 was a mission to low earth orbit which left the first stage with plenty of fuel to effect a landing. The landing was made as slow as possible and limited only by how low a single engine could be throttled. The re-entry burn which slows the rocket down before the landing burn was also more agressive. This mission was to launch JCSAT-14 to geosynchronous orbit which requires the falcon 9 to move the already heavy satellite into a geosynchronous transfer orbit. That meant the first stage had to do a lot more work and was left with a lot less fuel as a result. Therefore, the re-entry burn was less aggressive, the first stage came in with twice the speed, and SpaceX needed to do a far harder landing with three engines lit in the quicker and riskier suicide burn. Somehow, despite playing down expectations, they managed an even more precise landing than last time.
- gpm 11y agoTo expand on this slightly the CRS8 (and OG2, the land landing) landing was done using only 1 engine, which even then was presumably throttled. This landing burn was done using 3 engines so they spend less time below terminal velocity, and thus use less fuel. The total deceleration should be ~40 m/s during the burn.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dsfuoi 11y agoSo only about 4Gs? I somehow though it would be more and unsurvivable for humans.
- mikeyouse 11y agoCheck out the flight profile on Flightclub.io -- I'm not sure how accurate their instantaneous data is but they're showing ~12g acceleration upon landing the booster. Seems more like what I'd expect.
- js2 11y agoWebcast - https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig First stage landing is just after 38 minutes - https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig?t=38m https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig?t=38m
- neals 11y agoI always try to watch the webcasts and I can't help but cringe so hard when they start chanting 'USA USA USA', every single time. What is up with that?
- JumpCrisscross 11y agoIt's an American company, hiring American engineers, and successfully competing with the interests of entire nation-states?
- Luc 11y agoNo, it's something else, a cultural quirk among Americans.
- adventured 11y agoNo it's not. The French, British and Italians for example all have extreme amounts of nationalistic pride and show it throughout their economies, the pride they hold regarding their history and culture. Scandinavia is very proud of its broadly tremendous standard of living and their well run welfare states, etc. - and Scandinavians are never shy about bragging about it online in my observation, you can hardly get away from it. The Chinese and Japanese are extremely nationalistic, and that's downplaying how nationalistic they are, extremely doesn't do it justice. I also find any time India has an accomplishment that gets global attention, Indians take a massive amount of pride in it, and you can see that pour out on HN or Reddit for example (and I don't think there is anything wrong with that). The chant may be a quirk of the US, the nationalism it represents is absolutely not.
- DanBC 11y agoWhen someone flies the England flag the assumption most people make is that the person is far right racist football yob. I have to constantly guard against this bit of bias - "no, DanBC, they might not be a drunken lout". It's a bit different during soccer world cup or european cup. Very few people fly the Union flag. And chanting: no-one chants unless they're at a sports match. Chants just feel weird.
- smegel 11y agoThis is one of those turning points in human history.
- fixermark 11y agoNot quite "The polio vaccine," but certainly higher up than "laser-based Christmas decorations." ;)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- EA 11y agoDoing it one time is a technological leap. Doing it twice in such a small window of time is a logistical/programmatic leap.
- ygra 11y agoIn a way this time was a first as well, considering that they only recovered boosters for LEO missions so far. GTO is much less fuel to work with for landing and higher velocities.
- xadhominemx 11y agoWere they different rockets? If so I don't see the logistical leap.
- hoorayimhelping 11y agoDifferent use cases. This was a GTO launch which means the first stage had way more energy and therefore way tighter margins than the last attempt. This attempt used three engines to land and had a more difficult landing trajectory.
- geerlingguy 11y agoWhat's notable about this attempt (as opposed to the last) is that the first stage rocket was traveling twice as fast (4x the energy to overcome on landing), and didn't have enough propellant to do a 'boostback' burn. Instead, coming in very hot, the rocket had to use three engines (instead of one) to slow for landing. The last time this was attempted, the first stage put a nice hole in the deck of the drone ship. Seeing the rocket dead-center on the barge was quite a sight!
- mabbo 11y agoI suppose this is why people say "it's not rocket science".
- throwaway2016a 11y agoSlightly off topic but I was watching a television show the other day and someone said they worked at NASA. The host then said "So you're literally a rocket scientist?" And the guy said emphatically "Rocket engineer, there is a big difference" I'm sure this particular task probably was a little bit of both. After all, they had to run several real world experiments to prove their calculations.
- taneq 11y agoIt's important to know the difference: https://i.imgur.com/r6oEhvS.jpg?1 https://i.imgur.com/r6oEhvS.jpg?1 The most interesting work is right in the intersection of the two disciplines, though. :)
- ck2 11y agoxkcd needs to make one for that too https://xkcd.com/435/ https://xkcd.com/435/ I guess "purity" is just another word for "lack of immediately applied practicality"
- LanguageGamer 11y ago
- SagelyGuru 11y agoGood work! I still think that they should have some grippers on the barge, or a net, ready to spring and grasp the rocket on landing, instead of carrying flimsy legs all the way to space and back.
- olivier_martel 11y agoThey are trying to nail it every time without those grippers because they won't be there on Mars.
- ohitsdom 11y agoThe current legs aren't flimsy, and they seem way less complicated than a gripper system would have to be. How would a gripper system handle off-centered landings? It would have to catch the falling rocket very quickly because there's not much fuel left in the tank to hover. Your proposed system would add a lot of complexity, all for the small decrease in launch mass.
- rco8786 11y ago> Your proposed system would add a lot of complexity, all for the small decrease in launch mass. While I agree with your overall sentiment, I imagine that people building rockets make complexity tradeoffs to save tiny amounts of weight all the time.
- JshWright 11y agoSpaceX, on the other hand, has been willing to sacrifice some weight in order to reduce complexity and improve reliability and reusability.
- SagelyGuru 11y agoPermanent decrease in launch mass is big money, whereas complications on the barge do not really matter. Like all good engineering problems, it only looks problematic at first sight and I am sure that SpaceX could rise up to the challenge. Use a big funnel mesh? However, I accept the comment that perhaps they are really practising for landings on Mars, where fair number of probes have overturned on landing.
- brianwawok 11y agoHere is the video http://www.space.com/32811-spacex-rocket-landing-jcsat-14-launch.html http://www.space.com/32811-spacex-rocket-landing-jcsat-14-la... Hopefully we won't have the typical hacker news discussion about why the employees chant USA.
- shiven 11y agoYoo.Ess.Ae! Yoo.Ess.Ae! Yoo.Ess.Aeh! There. See. No harm, no foul. Anyways, as a non-American living in the US since 2001, I fail to see an issue with chanting USA, one way or another. It is an American company, with majority US employees, running this project (mainly) for an American entity (NASA), on US sovereign territory (or ocean?), using a significant chunk of US resources. So, it is their company and their country. I say, let them do what they want with it. And if chanting USA is what they wish to do, I have no problem with that.
- MacsHeadroom 11y agoAny proud chant is problematic only to the degree of pride it conveys for the wrong thing(s). Landing a space ship in 2016 surely warrants significant pride. Whether the USA is worth praising for this particular success, I'm not as sure. But damn, congrats to everyone involved. You just landed a fucking space ship. Good job.
- MicroBerto 11y agoSpaceX is a company full of highly-dedicated, ridiculously hard-working patriotic Americans who went to prestigious American universities - both private and public - and is run by a extremely ambitious and innovative legal immigrant. The company embodies everything that makes America great. Chant away.
- fit2rule 11y agoI think its offensive to have nationalistic robot-like-chanting being defended as an okay thing. Its the sort of thing you expect people to do at rallies or cult gatherings, and from an outsider perspective it always tarnishes what is otherwise a very rational event, because its an implied irrational, collective mindset. As a non-American, I wish it'd stop - its a major turnoff for these events, and I switch away when it starts up. I know, I know - Americans have a right to be proud, and they do. But expressing it with a cult-like mechanism that is, essentially "our group is great, nobody else can/has done this" is just .. revolting. I say this, knowing full well I'm going to get down voted for it, but I really do wish you Americans would think about it from the other side of your dark mirror. Can't we come up with a chant that includes all of humanity? After all, America wouldn't be the nation it is today without all other nations on Earth, including the ones that America has invaded, and destroyed completely, wantonly, for decades. EDIT: Feel how this post detracts from the main article, and is a distraction from the feel-goodness of SpaceX's accomplishments? For us non-Americans, thats how the USA-cult chant feels - a total distraction. I wish I could down vote the chanting when I see it on TV, too.
- manaskarekar 11y agoHosted webcast: https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig Landing at 38:18mins https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig#t=38m18s https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig#t=38m18s Great info on the thrusters on the first stage at 19:37. https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig#t=19m37s https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig#t=19m37s Edit: Thank you and sorry about the time stamp link, I posted quickly from my phone. Hopefully it works on shortlinks.
- robbiemitchell 11y agoYou link directly a specific place by adding this to the URL: #t=38m18s
- chipaca 11y agoyou can also make it a query parameter, which often works better. E.g. https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig?t=38m18s https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig?t=38m18s
- tlrobinson 11y agoSeems like the landing is now around 29min: https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig?t=28m58s https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig?t=28m58s
- thrownear 11y agoOk. Can we have less of Tesla/SpaceX posts. There is already one discussion about this in the front page...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- castis 11y agoBe the change you wish to see in the world.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zupreme 11y agoI remain confused about why SpaceX is getting so much fanfare and praise. What have they accomplished that NASA didn't already accomplish during the Apollo missions? I know SpaceX is doing it all more cost effectively, because we have better technology, but have they actually accomplished anything tangible that NASA didn't a generation ago?
- jacquesm 11y agoNASA landed a first stage on a barge to be re-used?
- lmm 11y agoNASA reused every engine (not just the first stage) of an orbital payload delivery system, many times, 30 years ago. Runway rather than barge but that's not really an important difference. (The exciting part will be much cheaper refurbishment than the STS. But SpaceX haven't actually delivered on that component yet)
- justifier 11y ago> Runway rather than barge but that's not really an important difference. it is an important difference when you look beyond earth the moon, mars, and any future site that has yet to send robots to pave a runaway that is: 4,500 meters long, 91 meters wide, and 40 centimeters thick(o); will necessarily be vertical take off and landing (o) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shuttle_Landing_Facility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shuttle_Landing_Facility
- lmm 11y agoIf and when SpaceX land rockets beyond Earth, that will very much be something to get excited about.
- odonnellryan 11y agoThis argument makes no sense.
- Gravityloss 11y agoIt could be argued that flying to orbit with a first stage that's being reused will be as historical when SpaceX will do it. The Space Shuttle did reuse SRB casings and the orbiter, it was a bit different but a great achievement too. However this time there is more potential for cost savings. It can still happen that they can't be realized because of some details or even fundamentals we don't understand from the outside.
- ino 11y agoHow are non-US space agencies and companies (like ESA, Russia, Japan, China, etc) reacting to the SpaceX and Blue Origin achievements? Are they also testing similar things but we aren't hearing? Or they aren't threatened by the advances?
- mikeash 11y agoAirbus is working on Adeline, which would fly back and recover the first-stage engines and avionics (but not the fuel tanks) on an Ariane rocket. The Chinese have mentioned an effort to recover and reuse first stages by landing them with parachutes. So far, the Russians seem to think the effort isn't worthwhile. Closer to home, ULA's new Vulcan rocket is supposed to recover the first stage engines (but again, not the fuel tanks) using a parachute and helicopter. It remains to be seen whether any of these schemes will work or how long they'll take. They have a lot of catching up to do in any case.
- stupidcar 11y agoWikipedia says Ariane 6's first test flight is scheduled for 2020, and Adeline will arrive between 2025 and 2030. Meanwhile, SpaceX plans to launch a Mars mission in 2018.
- grondilu 11y agoSay what you want about SpaceX's plans for re-usability, nobody can deny they are making progress at an incredible pace. I've just checked on Wikipedia and apparently the first flight of the Falcon was in 2010. That's six years ago. Compared to that, Arianeespace's target of 2025 (in nine years!) for Adeline is almost ridiculous. Just checked: Stephane Israël just raised concerned after SpaceX's latest success: http://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2016/05/05/face-a-spacex-le-pdg-d-arianespace-se-fait-lanceur-d-alerte_4914148_3234.html http://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2016/05/05/face-a-spa...
- jessriedel 11y agoCould you copy-paste his comments? Google translate worked OK, but the site has a paywall.
- hoorayimhelping 11y ago>P.S. Downvotes for this question? Really? There are always people on HN who love being contrarian and trying to diminish amazing things. It's like they hate seeing people excited for something and want to point out that this isn't that big of a deal. We're literally watching things happen for the first time ever, and this person's response is "what's so great about this?" while implying that people who are excited about this are fanboys. I can understand the downvotes honestly.
- thrownear 11y ago>diminish amazing things.. Sorry. We are living in a period where mediocrity and even complete fraudulent stuff is hailed as profound and "amazing". People with differing opinions matter, and I would say they matter more than ever. And I don't think people love being a contrarian". It is quite easy being a fanboy, but it is hard to go against popular opinion, and be a "contrarian". There is no love in being a contrarian, there is only hate and ridicule.
- odonnellryan 11y ago> Sorry. We are living in a period where mediocrity and even complete fraudulent stuff is hailed as profound and "amazing". Like what? Even the transistor is pretty damn amazing. It's fine to be critical, but let yourself get excited sometimes too.
- thrownear 11y ago>Like what? Look around. If you don't see it already, I won't be able to make you see. And what does the transistor has to do with the period we live in? I mean, right now, not 50 years earlier. >It's fine to be critical, but let yourself get excited sometimes too. Do you know why landing a rocket in salt water is bad. I mean, do you really, really know? From Spacex subreddit.. https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/219sow/how_significant_is_the_damage_cause_by_salt_water/cgb801o https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/219sow/how_signific...
- leecarraher 11y agoAm i missing something, is the need to land vertically a requirement of a fragile fuselage? Seems wasteful to carry extra anything (in this case rocket propellant) to space, just to avoid having to re-right the rocket when you get it back on earth for a subsequent launch. Is extra fuel payload < landing gear or parachutes?
- Davesjoshin 11y agoI'm guessing they want a single solution like vector thrusting because it can be used on planets with and without atmospheres.
- ehnto 11y agoIt is partly because they are trying to develop a system which can be used regardless of atmospheric conditions, so reusable in another sense. Parachutes don't do so well on the moon, for example. But also because a parachute landing actually does a lot more damage than you might expect, and sea water is the last thing you want in your million dollar rocket engine.
- jonknee 11y agoIIRC it's the most stable position because it's a big empty tube with some really heavy rocket engines at the base. It's also precise so they can land on a tiny barge in the ocean.
- mikeash 11y agoParachutes aren't massless. The parachutes you'd need to land a rocket like this are actually comparable in mass to the extra fuel and landing legs needed for the vertical landing approach. You also can't land on a ship with parachutes. You don't have enough control. You can still land at sea, but then you have to actually land in the water, which means getting seawater on all your rocket hardware. That causes lots of problems when you want to use that hardware again. SpaceX did experiment with this approach. Here's a picture of the second Falcon 9's interstage with parachutes packed inside: http://i.imgur.com/PGXIqKX.jpg http://i.imgur.com/PGXIqKX.jpg But it turned out not to work so well. NASA had some success with this approach on the Shuttle SRBs. It's easier with solid fuel rockets, because they're less efficient and built tougher. Even then, the cost of recovery and refurbishment ended up roughly breaking even compared to just building new ones each time. As far as "wasteful" goes, that depends on what you're looking at. Saving fuel for the landing subtracts from payload capacity, which is wasteful in theory... but in practice, many payloads are smaller than the maximum anyway. If you suffer a 30% payload penalty, but you're launching a satellite which is 40% smaller than your maximum, then who cares? The only waste is some extra fuel, which is super cheap. The full fuel load for a Falcon 9 launch is something like $200,000, compare to the total mission price of around $60 million.
- hcrisp 11y ago"One if by land, two if by sea..."
- gist 11y agoThe big difference between landing at sea and on land seems to be the PR value. Otherwise a target is a target, taking any differences in weather into consideration. In fact it seems that landing at sea is actually less pressure since you don't have the same safety concerns and crash pictures (which are bad for publicity) the rocket simply disappears.
- iandanforth 11y agoThis is incorrect, it's about fuel. By the time the rocket has completed first stage separation it's traveled a long way "horizontally" and is no longer near the launch site. They are trying to create a landing spot as close to the rocket as possible so it can't make it back. The only orbits that can reasonable get all the way back to land are fairly low and from specific launch sites.
- aerovistae 11y agoCompletely incorrect. The question to ask is, why are they bothering to land at sea? And, if you had done any cursory research instead of just announcing that SpaceX is making a PR grab because it sounded good to you, you would have read in the abundantly available explanations that this launch was to geostationary transfer orbit, rather than low earth orbit. GEO is a lot, lot higher than LEO, which means the rocket has to be going a LOT faster to get there. This uses up a lot of fuel, leaving them very little to slow down from an even higher speed than the normal mission. Decelerating from a much higher speed takes MORE fuel than decelerating from a low speed, and they have less fuel available because so much got used up in getting to that speed. So it's not plausible to get all the way back to the launch site. Instead they position a droneship way downrange so the rocket doesn't have to go as far back to land. But it's still going EXTREMELY fast, and managing to slow down all the way and land is an incredible accomplishment.
- gist 11y ago> So it's not plausible to get all the way back to the launch site. I never said return to the launch site. I said return to land. > if you had done any cursory research instead of just announcing that Unnecessary to speak that way in order to make your point unless you are trying to specifically make someone feel bad for voicing their thoughts.
- ck2 11y agoThe long-term plan is to put humans on these right? How many years out is that?
- lfuller 11y agoOne. They're planning on testing manned missions with their Dragon 2 and Falcon Heavy in mid-2017.
- ck2 11y agoWow are they really ready for human life onboard in a year? Unmanned failure doesn't bring much press. Kill a few people and it will set back the whole program years.
- mikeash 11y agoThey think they will be ready. Note that the manned Dragon has an abort capability. If the launcher blows up that doesn't necessarily spell doom for the astronauts.
- mikeyouse 11y agoSince they don't have to deal with the insulation issues like the shuttle did, the most dangerous phase of flight for a crew is during launch. Last Spring, SpaceX demo'ed their launch abort system which in theory should be able to protect the astronauts against any launch problems; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_FXVjf46T8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_FXVjf46T8
- Kinnard 11y agoI wonder if there's coordinate potential with seasteading? Astronauts are gonna want all sorts of goods and services upon landing I imagine. Having someone stationed nearby will mean swifter pickup of equipment and astronauts. And if there's someone stationed nearby they'll want goods and services as well.
- mattbeckman 11y agoI don't think astronauts would land on the droneship, as that's just for the first stage. When the Crew Dragon lands, it would be coming in from orbit, so I imagine they would just target the landing platform at the Cape as part of their de-orbiting plan. That being said, would you want to be in the nearby path of the rockets if they were going to be ditched?
- jklinger410 11y agoI find the level of criticism for SpaceX on this site to be incredible. I understand this is a place for intelligent discussion, but sometimes I feel like I can't find a single thread on this site without someone in the comments presuming they are smarter than someone else.
- typon 11y agoWhat is it about software development that brings out these kinds of people?
- odonnellryan 11y agoIt's perfectly healthy to be critical. Depends how you do it.
- ekun 11y agoIve noticed it in any technical field. People love to hear themselves talk and miss out on a lot by not listening to others.
- thrownear 11y ago>I find the level of criticism for SpaceX on this site to be incredible. This has to be the funniest comment I have seen today. There are more than one post regarding this event with 300+ votes. Still the level of criticism for Spacex on this site is "incredible", Really?
- aerovistae 11y agoI see little or none, <5% of discussion on this page.
- dang 11y agoI'm pretty sure there's literally no other topic on which the HN community is so overwhelmingly positive. There are a lot of commenters here, so there will a bell curve (or some distribution) on any topic at all. Picking negative comments from a tail is always possible, but it misrepresents the community, in this case completely. Posting indignant comments about it just adds to the problem and takes the thread off topic.
- grondilu 11y agoThis success was unexpected. That means that they can recover a stage from a higher speed than previously thought. Does that mean that the recovery of the second stage from LEO may actually be feasible?
- mikeash 11y agoSecond stage recovery is a whole different beast. Recovering the first stage on a flight like this is a delicate dance because margins are so small, so everything has to go exactly right. The previous attempt (SES-9) didn't quite go exactly right, and made a big boom, perhaps because the engine burns were slightly mistimed. Recovering the second stage is difficult because it's coming in from a much higher speed. The first stage came in doing about 2km/s. The second stage would come in doing 8km/s or more. That means 16x more kinetic energy to deal with and 64x more heating. You need a proper heat shield, not just clever engine burns. There's much less extra margin to play with as well. The second stage does most of the work but is much lighter, and one pound on the second stage is worth ten pounds on the first stage. SpaceX definitely believes second stage recovery to be feasible at some point, but not on the current Falcon 9.
- ctthill 11y agoKE = 0.5mv^2, so the second stage would only have 16x the kinetic energy if the two stages had the same mass. The dry mass of the first stage is approximately 25,600kg. At 2km/s, its kinetic energy is 51.2 terajoules. The dry mass of the second stage is approximately 3,900kg. At 8km/s, its kinetic energy is 125 terajoules. So the KE of the second stage is actually about ~2.4x that of the first stage. Here is were I found the masses of the stages: http://spaceflight101.com/spacerockets/falcon-9-v1-1-f9r/ http://spaceflight101.com/spacerockets/falcon-9-v1-1-f9r/
- mikeash 11y agoI meant relative to the mass of the stage, since that's what's relevant to the challenge.
- 11y ago
- tdrd 11y agoHere's the landing from the webcast video on youtube https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig?t=2300 https://youtu.be/L0bMeDj76ig?t=2300
- Ferver777 11y agoSimply incredible. Elon Musk is the New Thomas Edison
- bryanlarsen 11y agoMusk would probably be offended by that comment -- Nikola Tesla and Thomas Edison were bitter rivals and enemies.
- mathgenius 11y agoI get the impression that Edison was more of a showman than a business man. Musk is at a whole other level.
- j1vms 11y agoTesla is really great, but there exists a "take" on Edison that makes him also not so bad. Here, listen to Linus talk about him a bit: https://youtu.be/o8NPllzkFhE?t=17m24s https://youtu.be/o8NPllzkFhE?t=17m24s Linus: "I'm more of an Edison..." (TED2016, Feb. 2016)
- samstave 11y agoCan someone please explain to me how the falcon orients itself during this total process?? Does it use fins, or simply engines and whatever those little jets are that, say, the space shuttle had around its nose... How does the falcon manage to physically orient its body? Also, is that process completely autonomous? Is there a remote flight engineer steering this to the barge - or is it completely self-guided
- cloudwalking 11y agoIn space it uses nitrogen thrusters to orient. Once in the atmosphere it uses grid fins to orient. The entire liftoff and return is piloted by Falcon's flight computers -- no humans involved.
- samstave 11y agoThank you - how does the barge communicate with the falcon? And what types of comminucations are they having. I assume the barge is stating its GPS location, but does it also communicate things like sea conditions - and its elevation (what is it called to describe the condition of the sea), as well as wind, north-south orientation, etc... I am impressed - but I want to know how this works.
- cletusw 11y agoRumor is (https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/3b0stk/falcon_9_what_technology_is_used_to_have_it_land/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/3b0stk/falcon_9_wha...) that the barge does not communicate any information to the booster. Instead, it uses GPS and some ingenious motors to maintain position and orientation, and the Falcon booster uses a radar altimeter to judge accurate vertical distance.
- samstave 11y agoThats just fucking awesome if true. Its like "how can we maximize the use of some 'cheaper' technology and a shit-ton of math to accomplish this in the technologically simplest way?" Wow.
- solitaryb 11y agoFor the second month in a row... Wow!