16 ms·
The US needs a system where victims of malpractice get compensated but the doctors or hospitals are not necessarily held liable (unless it's gross negligence).
by maxxxxx 11y ago
The US needs a system where victims of malpractice get compensated but the doctors or hospitals are not necessarily held liable (unless it's gross negligence). US doctors spend a lot of time, energy and legal maneuvering denying and covering up mistakes instead of being able to admit them and improve procedures if necessary.
In my view there should be a nationwide malpractice insurance pool and the medical associations should push for better quality standards within their ranks.
- wskinner 11y agoThat seems like it would raise a serious issue of moral hazard.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoNot if you pull the license of repeat offenders. F* up once? It happens, medicine is hard (EDIT: Document what went wrong, put a process in place so it doesn't happen again, issue a notice to all other medical facilities offering related procedures). F* up again? You're out of a job. No different then how the FAA and the NTSB operate. EDIT: Medicine can be made safer through the same processes used to ensure air travel is the safest transport method in the world. It can't be as safe, but we can do better.
- rplst8 11y agoI disagree entirely. People are known to be fallible. Processes prevent things from accidentally happening. In areas where the life of someone or a large organizational failure hangs in the balance of an action, that action should be wrapped in process to ensure it's correct execution, with fail-safe mechanisms put in place. Further, these systems should be audited on a regular basis to ensure compliance. Only in the case of purposeful or willful action or absolute gross negligence or being found unfit for duty (mentally or physically) should someone have their life ruined by removing their status/job/career path.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ryanlol 11y ago>Only in the case of purposeful or willful action or absolute gross negligence or being found unfit for duty (mentally or physically) should someone have their life ruined by removing their status/job/career path. Seriously? Losing your job hardly means that your life is ruined.
- jleader 11y agoSo you're advocating forgiving the educational loans of doctors who lose their license? Or do you leave them massively in debt, without the (relatively) lucrative profession they had assumed would allow them to pay off that debt?
- ryanlol 11y agoI'm not advocating anything. I'm just saying that losing your job/career/whatever doesn't equal a ruined life.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> So you're advocating forgiving the educational loans of doctors who lose their license? Yes, although the better solution is to subsidize the education of medical providers directly, instead of burdening them with massive loans that take decades to repay. That's an argument for another thread though.
- thebokehwokeh2 11y agoMore than any other occupation, doctors spend a majority of their young adult lives learning about medicine and everything related to it. By removing them of their license to practice that, you've essentially stripped them of their life's purpose.
- ryanlol 11y ago
- wskinner 11y agoI would describe being fired if you f* up again as being held liable. Liability doesn't have to be monetary.
- maxxxxx 11y agoEverybody makes serious errors from time to time. At least me and everybody I know. You should be able to admit them without losing your career or being ruined. Obviously if somebody makes a lot more errors than others he should lose his job. My point is that the current system encourages denial and cover up. It doesn't encourage improvement.
- lmm 11y agoI don't think anyone wants to kill their patients. So what's the adverse scenario here? Doctors being paid per-operation and skipping safety steps? Doctors wanting to make a name for themselves and taking on ambitious surgeries that shouldn't be done? It seems like you could cover those cases without making individual doctors massively liable for essentially random mistakes.
- cmiles74 11y agoI don't see why the the anesthesiologist should not be held liable in this case (and possibly the hospital). In my opinion, it would be very reasonable for them both to pay a significant penalty. These abnormally low (and capped) penalties make it easier for those who should not be doing this work to keep showing up every day. I understand that we don't want to scare people in health care out of the field, but those who are clearly inept certainly should be afraid to keep working.
- wvenable 11y agoMost of the problems are systemic. Most people are probably not "clearly inept". You probably make dozens of mistakes in a week but, just by the nature of your job, nobody dies. Procedures, policies, and even technology should exist to prevent and mitigate mistakes because humans are deeply flawed. Unfortunately the fact that the situation is life-and-death with huge liabilities that there really isn't significant effort to improve things. It's legally safer to continue practices that mostly work but are already standard than try something new.
- noonespecial 11y agoAnother industry faced systemic life-and-death problems like this. Air travel. They use extensive checklists that they run like human computers before every flight, from the smallest cessna to the largest airbus. My mom, the NP, says doctors, as a group are too proud to ever use lists like that. She asked me how the "pride issue" was dealt with among pilots. I suggested that when it comes to airplanes, prideful pilots have a way of sorting themselves out one way or another. Source: I'm a timid GA pilot who actually shouted "I'm a leaf on the wind" at my plane during my first solo...
- wvenable 11y agoI'd argue that there so many differences between air travel and medicine that it's not a useful comparison. A single passenger doesn't even interact with a Pilot, as just one example.
- tn13 11y agoI think the above example illustrates why a malpractice insurance pool might be a bad idea. The one who makes the mistake must pay up. This will ensure those who make less mistakes will succeed at faster rate.
- Maarten88 11y agoDo you also think the doctor who brilliantly saves someone's life should be rewarded the lifetime earnings of the person saved? Introduce "Value Based Pricing" in healthcare? I think medical errors should be (financially and professionally) punished, but only up to some reasonable amount, aimed at the future and on damage to society, not on compensating the victim (which you can't really anyway). If you want to be compensated in full for everything that might happen to you, then get personal insurance. Getting insurance against i.e. disability is a better approach anyway, as this also covers cases where it is caused by no-one, by yourself or just by bad luck. It seems strange that personal insurance is rarely mentioned as a (partial) solution for these situations in the US. Maybe because collective/social solutions have a bad reputation?
- maxerickson 11y agoSocial Security actually has some provision for disability. So we have a collective social system in place (I guess the payments aren't necessarily high enough to call it a solution). I think people don't carry additional private policies mostly because they are spending most of their budget on other things and are somewhat short sighted. https://www.ssa.gov/disability/ https://www.ssa.gov/disability/
- tn13 11y agoValue of something does not depend on the what the provider is providing but what are the alternatives for the consumers. A brilliant doctor who saves someone's life should be awarded lifetime earnings of the person if the alternative is dying. Clearly people already spend a fortune getting state of art medical care for the same reason. Value depends on alternatives and not on what a doctor is doing. Also a lot of medical errors are because doctors can get away with it or they have simply too high egos to go through a checklist. Penalizing doctors is important for their mistakes. But I do agree to your point that there is no clear way of determining what is good compensation. Sometimes death destroys one life, disability destroys many lives. I think the jury must determine what the compensation is.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- forgetsusername 11y ago>In my view there should be a nationwide malpractice insurance pool and the medical associations should push for better quality standards within their ranks. It's an interesting idea, but who pays for it? Taxpayers? Have fun with that politically. The doctors? You'll drive out those on the margins of "doctor or other career". We here in Canada already have a massive doctor shortage everywhere but major cities, so that's a problem.
- shimon 11y agoI agree this would be politically problematic, but not for the reason you provide. Doctors already spend tons of money on private malpractice insurance; this national pool would just be a different administration of the same insurance payments. In fact, the pool could be effected with different regulation of the existing private insurers and changes to malpractice law. And if done right, it could plausibly lower overall insurance fee burden on doctors.
- Scoundreller 11y ago> Doctors already spend tons of money on private malpractice insurance In Ontario Canada, the government reimburses most of their malpractice insurance fees. As a result, they're currently paying 1986 rates: http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/pro/programs/ohip/mlp/announcements.aspx http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/pro/programs/ohip/mlp/announc...
- forgetsusername 11y agoAnd how is Ontario doing, generally, with regards to the number of doctors: patients? I lived there, and know doctors personally. The answer is terrible.
- 794CD01 11y agoIn the US, at least, "doctor shortages" are caused by insufficient capacity upstream. Some combination of not enough medical schools and not enough licenses issued. Which happens because existing doctors are not incentivized to flood their field with more doctors who will then compete with them and lower prices.
- Artistry121 11y agoCan you provide evidence for this claim? I worked in doctors offices as a consultant for 18 months and never noticed doctors spending time "covering up mistakes". They did spend lots of time documenting their analysis and work though.
- maxxxxx 11y agoMy girlfriend had a nerve cut during knee surgery. The doctor did not acknowledge that error but waffled around. Only after consultation with two more surgeons it became clear that this was clearly an avoidable mistake.
- jpadkins 11y agohow does the pool get funded? You can have some really perverse incentives depending on how its funded...
- brownbat 11y ago> the doctors or hospitals are not necessarily held liable (unless it's gross negligence) I've had friends who have worked retained surgical instruments cases. Meet one or two of those victims and you will never support tort reform again. If this were a problem of gross negligence, then I would agree with you that we should focus there. But the problem isn't gross negligence, it's a problem of "business as usual." It's a thousand doctors following procedures with a 0.1% error rate and 999 thinking, "nothing bad's happened to me so I must be doing everything fine," even though they could each reduce that to a 0.001% error rate with a simple checklist or by actually washing their hands. Put another way, if you put someone's life in your hands and you're not focusing a significant percentage of your efforts on procedures designed to radically reduce risk, then you're engaged in gross negligence. There's another area where we all have that philosophy. We send a million people hurtling through the air each day in incredibly complex machines. Airlines focus on safety because (a) they are actually responsible for their passengers and can't just call a mulligan because, hey, people make mistakes; and additionally, (b) they suffer massive reputational costs for safety errors. So my medical malpractice reform would make medicine more like other industries with far better safety records. It would include a requirement that hospitals post their mistakes on their front door as people walk in.
- eru 11y ago> It's a thousand doctors following procedures with a 0.1% error rate and 999 thinking, "nothing bad's happened to me so I must be doing everything fine," even though they could each reduce that to a 0.001% error rate with a simple checklist or by actually washing their hands. Seems like that's an argument for a very discerning insurance company. Following the checklist should reduce their insurance premiums 10 times. And that's noticeable. (Of course, the ideal insurance company in question needs to collect the information how doctors behave, and needs to be legally able to act on it.)
- studentrob 11y ago> Seems like that's an argument for a very discerning insurance company. It's an argument based on a made up or uncited statistic.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The US needs a system where victims of malpractice get compensated but the doctors or hospitals are not necessarily held liable (unless it's gross negligence). Malpractice, by definition, is action falling below the standard of care set by the profession. If malpractice occurs, "improving procedures" is not necessary, because the harm results from failing to meet the the procedural norms of the profession. Improving procedures is called for when adverse outcomes result from problems that are not malpractice.
- neurotech1 11y agoThe problem is that most people don't realize that its relatively easy to for a patient (or their lawyer) to formally notify the state medical board of a complaint. Even billing issues are sometimes investigated by the state board. For smaller claims, the doctor may settle the case for less than the threshold for listing in the public provider record. The National Practitioner Data Bank [0] is more strict in what gets recorded and doctors can't cover it up as easily. Doctors and hospitals might try and deny the issue but in some states, if the complaint is substantiated (but the doctor is not formally reprimanded) it still gets noted in the National Practitioner Data Bank. This will be checked by any prospective employers in the future. In aviation, there is a philosophy that its better to admit a mistake, and learn from it. This is known as the "Asoh Defense" [1]. Doctors could learn a lot from Capt. Asoh. The NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System [2] is for aviators to self-report a safety issue without fear of being violated by the FAA for their admission. There is even an immunity policy for non-deliberate pilot errors. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Practitioner_Data_Bank https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Practitioner_Data_Ban... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japan_Airlines_Flight_2#The_.22Asoh_defense.22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japan_Airlines_Flight_2#The_.2... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_Safety_Reporting_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_Safety_Reporting_Syst...
- adrianratnapala 11y agoNot sure if there is a need for a national insurance pool or not -- but you are quite right. If the issue is getting procedures right, then insurers should have to pay up so they have an incentive to crack down on procedures. However, I think the tort caps exist because when big bad insurance companies are involved, courts decide to play Santa and inflate damages to huge amounts. Caps are a crude way of getting around the problem though.
- WalterBright 11y agoPunishing doctors for making human errors will not result in perfection. It will result in doctors hiding and denying their mistakes. A better approach is to acknowledge that people will make mistakes, and work with doctors to identify why the mistakes are made and how procedures can be altered to prevent those mistakes in the future. This is how it is done in the aviation business. Punishment will not work.
- MertsA 11y ago>Punishing doctors for making human errors will not result in perfection. Yeah but it's not just about punishment. A small portion of medical professionals account for a disproportionately large amount of all medical malpractice claims. The worst 1% accounted for a third of all malpractice claims according to a recent study. I agree that we shouldn't be cracking down on individual mistakes, but we certainly do need to crack down on doctors who are significantly more likely to harm patients in the future. http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/857885 http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/857885