20 ms·
Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight
- greenwalls 11y agoI guess it's just a coincidence that most athletes aren't overweight. It doesn't have anything to do with them exercising?
- blakesterz 11y agoI thought the same thing at first, but then I read this. We're talking us regular folks getting maybe an hour of exercise. If you're an athlete you're getting WAY WAY more so it makes sense that you're burning off calories like mad.
- s0rce 11y agoI also thought the same thing. The article didn't really address the point specifically, if you are highly active most of the day you will burn a substantial amount of calories. Some people maintain weight while consuming 4000+ calories per day, for example on long hiking trips or long distance running. I'm not sure about the hunter gatherer example. That was interesting. Maybe they are in much better shape and can be active a large portion of the day without expending much more energy. Or simply, the activity isn't extremely high-level.
- hyperpape 11y agoUnder one heading, the do specifically call out elite athletes, "whose job is exercising" as a potential exception. It's also true that many endurance athletes are pretty careful about what they eat. My brother, who was a pretty good high school and college runner (5ks and 10ks especially), used to say he had a high body fat for a runner because he ate ice cream. His BMI? Maybe 20, 21 at most, and he was lifting weights back then.
- imgabe 11y agoIf you can dedicate 8-12 hours a day to exercising, sure. It takes years of training to even be fit enough to do that, though. You can't be 100lbs overweight and out of shape and expect to be able to do that without injuring yourself.
- tzs 11y agoAmusingly, if you go by BMI, quite a few pro athletes are overweight, or even obese. (This is a good illustration of how idiotic BMI can be...). For instance, Michael Jordan was slightlu overweight according to BMI. Shaquille O'Neal was past overweight and into obese. Wilt Chamberlin was overweight. Leaving basketball for boxing, Muhammad Ali was well into overweight. Mike Tyson was obese. How about American Football? I'm going to exclude line positions since a large part of their job is to be a wall and so we'd expect them to go for mass. Quarterbacks Dan Marino and Joe Montana: overweight. In fact, five of the last six Heisman Trophy winners (who were all quarterbacks) are overweight, and one is obese. The last four non-quarterback Heisman winners were running backs, and two were overweight and two were obese.
- vskarine 11y agoso true, I've never been in better shape in my life, I recently ran ultra-marathon and can easily bench press my own weight 10 times but my physician told me I am overweight and should loose 15 pounds because my BMI is over 25. I wanted to take his head off.
- gaberpt 11y agoa
- adrianN 11y agoCycling an hour each day is also hard for most people.
- titzer 11y ago400 calories is about half an hour at vigorous effort for most people, or maybe 40 mins at moderate effort.
- hyperchase 11y agoIgnoring the fact that moderate exercise will most likely increase your appetite and disturb your body's constant strive to keep homeostasis.
- gaberpt 11y agoThis a harmful, eye-catching, title. Whereas exercise is not required to lose weight, you still can use exercise to optimize the process.
- takno 11y agoAbout half of the article deals with why attempting to use exercise to optimize the process probably won't help much with it and for some people will completely derail it. The title is exactly aligned with the article
- WalterSear 11y agoNone of the article looks at weight training.
- mholmes680 11y agoBut, wait.... #10 - eat less fat? That runs counter to science too... http://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/apr/07/the-sugar-conspiracy-robert-lustig-john-yudkin http://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/apr/07/the-sugar-con...
- samfisher83 11y agoIt you a eat a lot of fat you will get fat too. Its all about moderation. If you eat 4000 calories of FAT everyday you will get fat.
- adrianN 11y agoEating 4000 calories of anything will make you fat.
- lrei 11y agoEat (drink) 4000 calories of gasoline. wont make you fat. point is: only calories you can convert into "human fat" will make you fatter. that process can not happen without certain chemicals (hormones) in your body, like insulin mentioned above. it's not as straightforward as that which was op's point.
- koluft 11y agoAre your confusing nutritional calories with physics calories? When people talk about diet, of course they are talking about calories obtained from digestion, not combustion engines.
- lrei 11y agoEnergy is energy, a calorie is a calorie in gasoline, food or electricity. However when talking about nutrition labels, those are generally an estimate of calories potentially extracted by humans (which I think is what you mean with nutritional calories). I'm not confusing anything. But some people seem convinced that the car analogy is exactly how the human body works - you put food into your mouth and it gets "burned" by exercise or stored (calories in, calories out) and no amount of evidence or science seems to convince them otherwise.
- krisdol 11y agoYou should exercise to prevent diabetes and a swath of other health problems, though.
- blktiger 11y agoTLDR; Exercise alone won't help you lose weight, you need to combine exercise and diet changes.
- rarec 11y agoTrue enough. You can't outrun a poor diet.
- beachstartup 11y agoi would say that it's just extremely, extremely difficult to exercise away a bad diet. not impossible, but a strategy that is basically guaranteed to fail if you're a normal person with a normal job and life.
- blakesterz 11y agoSo that's an interesting long read, I guess all the details end up making sense. Some physical activity in addition to calorie counting and other behavioral changes is the best way to go. The most important thing a person can do is to limit calories in a way they like and can sustain, and focus on eating more healthfully. Don't expect to be able to exercise enough to lose much weight.
- upofadown 11y agoDoes anyone actually still think that the extra energy consumption caused by exercise will cause you to lose weight and not just eat more? A more contemporary discussion would include the idea that the different state of being caused by exercise causes less food intake ... which incidentally is true for me personally. It is entirely possible that people that exercise regularly never have any trouble with their weight and thus never show up in these studies.
- DanBC 11y ago> Does anyone actually still think that the extra energy consumption caused by exercise will cause you to lose weight and not just eat more? Plenty of people on HN strongly think this. The nutrition discussion on HN is normally fucking terrible. (See this thread where someone talks about "the science" and links to the Guardian as a reference).
- thesis 11y agoOne of my trainers once said... I'm helping you for 1 hour a day, you have 23 other hours to ruin it all. Healthy eating is super super important.
- taiboku 11y agoThis article misses a key point: increased muscle mass correlates with increased calorie burn. Not all exercise is created equal. Exercise that doesn't build muscle is indeed ineffective at burning fat. But exercise that DOES build muscle has a compounding effect on burning fat. Your muscles require more energy to maintain, so they will burn more calories just by existing.
- maxerickson 11y agoThis effect is pretty small. Like 10 calories a day for a pound of muscle (which is quite a bit of muscle to add). It still matters, a few calories a day for a year ends up being pounds of weight, but adjusting calories out of the diet is going to be a better first strategy.
- ZoF 11y agoWhere are you getting 10 calories per day per pound? I find that surprisingly low, and that's even if we're talking 100% sedentary here.
- maxerickson 11y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=muscle+mass+rest+calories https://www.google.com/search?q=muscle+mass+rest+calories
- seanalltogether 11y agoThis blog post cites 2 sources on the 6-10 calories per pound, haven't read through it myself though. http://www.builtlean.com/2013/04/16/muscle-burn-calories/ http://www.builtlean.com/2013/04/16/muscle-burn-calories/
- vanderZwan 11y agoNot only that, but aerobic exercise also works better because your cells will burn energy for longer after working out - so I guess building muscle and getting it to burn more energy by running is the most efficient combination
- revelation 11y agoThe title says "you shouldn't exercise to lose weight", which seems to suggest that exercise will negatively affect your ability to lose weight. There isn't a single study here that proves this rather lofty hypothesis.
- tzs 11y agoYou are taking the title as meaning lose weight => ! exercise or equivalently exercise => ! lose weight That's not what the title is saying. What it is saying is ! (exercise => lose weight)
- revelation 11y agoWell, the title was changed, which makes this somewhat silly.
- vanderZwan 11y agoI'd like to see that last graph split out into "fat loss/gain" and "muscle loss/gain" - because reducing food intake can also make your body break down muscles, which is equally bad. Doing exercise to stimulate the body to make more muscles can counter that effect.
- yuzi 11y agoI went from 190 lbs. to 138 lbs. over 6 or 7 months. The only exercise I did was jogging for 45 min a day. What I noticed was that jogging made me feel better, which somehow got me to consistently eat better. After a days jogging I didn't want to put crap food in me and ruin what I had accomplished and by doing it everyday I felt good enough, often enough to stick with it. So, based on my experience, I simply can not agree.
- Retric 11y agoExercise is harder to keep up long term and gaining back the same weight after 5 years is not that useful.
- yuzi 11y agoNot for me. I may have stopped working out for long periods, since then, but the 6-7 months of diet change stuck which was enough to maintain the weight loss (approximatley). 14 years now.
- maxerickson 11y agoI see stories like yours and I wonder if the key factor is that you decided in a meaningful way to not be overweight anymore. The exercise and better diet follow pretty easily from that.
- koluft 11y agoExercising every 5 years isn't so bad.
- specialp 11y agoThis is very true. Exercise has more of an effect than the calories burned. It improves your health and you feel much better than when you had a sedentary life. As always the answer is that decreasing calorie consumption with moderate exercise is key to maintaining weight loss. Just as exercising cannot offset massive overconsumption of food, massive underconsumption of food will make one that is dieting feel terrible, and thus not as likely to continue. In addition the amount of exercise done is never going to really offset a sedentary job. Someone walking on their feet all day vs me being at a desk is going to consume much more energy than me even if I workout after work intensely for an hour. So I am still going to need to consume less than them. But if I did not do the hour of exercise, my body would break down from not being used, and my overall feeling of health would decline.
- ChemicalWarfare 11y agoAnecdotal evidence from being a gym rat for 20 years, although I'm sure there are studies out there to prove this. Maybe :) No doubt that diet+exercise is the way to go when it comes to long-term weight management. The thing is, "weight loss" in and of itself is a misleading metric. You're losing weight! Great! But hold on a minute - your gut is the same size but your biceps is smaller and your strength is way down. What happened? You lost weight alright but its muscle you're losing, not fat. So where I'm going with this is exercise is very important to make sure you don't negatively impact your body composition by losing muscle weight when dieting.
- paulsutter 11y agoExactly - percent bodyfat is a much better target metric than weight.
- misterspaceman 11y agoAgreed. The problem is that weighing yourself is easy, but measuring body fat is way harder. Most of the at-home measurement tools are wildly inaccurate; the accurate ones are either expensive or inconvenient.
- joshvm 11y agoI don't trust the absolute numbers, but the data from my FitBit Aria has a pretty low variance over time: http://imgur.com/5AgKU9F http://imgur.com/5AgKU9F It does seem to be tracking reasonably well - I've lost a bit of fat, but not a significant amount since then. Given what I see in the mirror, I think 16-17% is about right. There are some weird fluctuations, but we're talking 1-2% day to day. The range of the graph is about 4-5%. The trick is to measure several times a day if you get the chance (or at the very least when you get up and when you go to bed) to smooth out any fluctuations.
- crpatino 11y agoThe gut-to-hip ratio is a rough, but effective, alternative. At least if you start from an overweight/obese body type.
- vannevar 11y agoThis article, including the title, is a bit of a mess. Nothing in it refutes the commonly accepted principle that if you burn as many daily calories in exercise as you consume in food, you will not get fatter. The point of the article seems to be simply that the modern Western diet is so high in calories that it's difficult to do enough exercise to make up the difference. The survey study they cite talks about exercise in the range of only a couple of hundred calories a day, and even then, contrary to what the article implies, the study's conclusion clearly states that weight loss was proportional to the amount of exercise. So, sure, if you're eating 1000 calories/day more than you're burning, throwing in an extra 30-minute walk on the treadmill isn't going to do much. But try a real exercise regimen like P90X where you are burning an extra 800 calories or so a day, and you absolutely will see results even if your diet remains unchanged.
- pjlegato 11y agoThe point of the article is that the relationship between "amount of exercise you do" and "calories you burn" is probably not linear, as has traditionally been believed. According to the scientist's theory, you get diminishing returns, where you have to do ever more and more exercise to burn the same number of calories.
- vannevar 11y agoBut the study they cite to support that view talks about very low levels of exercise (1100 calories a week) in the long term studies. If the diet calorie surplus was comparable in both long and short term, it's not surprising that the results were disproportionately low in the long term compared to the short-term studies: with such a low level of exercise, it wouldn't be surprising if the measurement error was significant. In a longer term study, it's tough to control for what people do the rest of the time. And in their discussion of the Hadza tribe, they admit that the Hadza could be resting enough at other times of the day to offset the increased calories they expend for food gathering. All that does is tell us that given two populations that exercise about the same amount, the one that eats less will be leaner. That says nothing about whether the Hadza could remain lean on a Western diet if they also exercised more, which is the real question. Nowhere in the article is that question actually directly addressed. The study of marathoners they cite points out that the subjects increased their intake while they trained, which unsurprisingly limited their weight loss. If you eat the same amount but exercise significantly more, you will lose weight. If you eat significantly less with no increase in exercise, you will lose weight. Nothing in this article supports with data the conclusion that the latter approach is better than the former.
- dang 11y agoHN threads on this topic tend to be repetitive and superficial, but this article appears to be so much more substantive than the usual media pieces that we've provisionally turned off user flags on the post.
- yarou 11y agoIn certain Vedic traditions, physical exertion is seen as a form of meditation. The concept there is if you can discipline your body, you can discipline your mind. That being said, I think the author of this article tries way too hard to be counterfactual. If you put an obese male or female on the treadmill with modest caloric restriction, over time they will lose weight on a log scale.
- sokoloff 11y agoYou can't out-run the fork.
- thenadamgoes 11y agoYou diet to lose weight. You exercise to get in shape.
- Scramblejams 11y agoFWIW, my experience disagrees with this. I was overweight, started running (starting around 9mi/wk, when I got bored and stopped I was up around 24mi/wk), and started losing weight quickly, lost a ton of it over a year, after which I was at a very good weight for me. Now, as the piece touches on, that exercise did change my eating, but the outcome of that isn't clear to me -- I stopped eating/snacking for a few hours before a run so I wouldn't cramp. But I also started eating a lot more outside of those exercise windows, as running so much made me quite ravenous at times. Ate anything and everything I wanted and I just kept dropping weight as long as I kept running. Haven't looked at the data cited in the article, but my guess is that these studies are looking mostly at what's often defined as "moderate" exercisers, that is, people who walk an hour every day or something similarly unintensive. Which is vastly better than nothing, but it isn't exactly a hard workout like what I was engaging in, and I wouldn't expect to drop much weight if that's all I was doing.
- jacorreia 11y agoIt's literally just calories in vs. calories out. If 400 calories/day meets your weight loss goals, all you have to do is make sure that the calories you expend + the calories you no longer intake = 400. The ratio of those two factors completely varies from person to person on what their motivation levels are going to be, but as long as it works for you it will result in the same amount of weight loss as any other ratio
- pjlegato 11y agoThe whole point of the article is that the traditional "calories in/calories out" model is wrong. "Based on the research, Pontzer has proposed a new model that upends the the old "calories in, calories out" approach to exercise... He calls this the "constrained model" of energy expenditure, which shows that the effect of more physical activity on the human body is not linear."
- fattylite 11y agoThe conclusion is: "10) So what actually works for weight loss? At the individual level, some very good research on what works for weight loss comes from the National Weight Control Registry, a study that has parsed the traits, habits, and behaviors of adults who have lost at least 30 pounds and kept it off for a minimum of one year. They currently have more than 10,000 members enrolled in the study, and these folks respond to annual questionnaires about how they've managed to keep their weight down. The researchers behind the study found that people who have had success losing weight share a few things in common: They weigh themselves at least once a week. They restrict their calorie intake, stay away from high-fat foods, and watch their portion sizes. They also exercise regularly. But note: These folks use physical activity in addition to calorie counting and other behavioral changes. Every reliable expert I've ever spoken to on weight loss says the most important thing a person can do is to limit calories in a way they like and can sustain, and focus on eating more healthfully. In general, diet with exercise can work better than calorie cutting alone, but with only marginal additional weight-loss benefits. " It doesn't upend it, it basically just says "Don't count calorie expenditures as part of your caloric deficit", which has been standard advice for every resource I've used for quite some time.
- pascalxus 11y agoOur body's software is so hopelessly out of date. It's programmed to preserve fat at all cost: something quite useful, say 2 million years ago when famines were happening almost every day. Medical and nutritional science needs to advance more quickly in this regard. Currently, it's going at a snail's pace. I mean, we understand the entire creation of the universe, but the most advanced nutritionists in the world are barely aware of the basic mechanisms which govern our fat production, not even understanding how it works. So far, all we have is theories, hypothesis, correlations and some compelling experimentations. Personally, I'm waiting for the iBody app to come out. iBody, will allow us to control our metabolism at a cellular level, dialing it up or down at will. We'll be able to control our appetites and hungers at the push of a button too. But, at this rate, who knows how long it will take to get this off the ground: 100s of years, thousands? Come on investors, this is a multi-trillion dollar market.
- dota_fanatic 11y agoIt's utterly easier to just make and advertise addictive food, completely throwing nutritional quality out the window. What if you could even claim your addictive, mostly empty junk is healthy? Therefore funding and studies with the intention of obfuscation and the control of the progress of understanding. The world would have to look very, very different than today's for something like an iBody app to come into being. Where's the money to be made in people having that much control over themselves? The goal is to sell more (eg) donuts, not less. To defect is the norm.
- pascalxus 11y agoYes. Consumers are mainly to blame for this. As long as consumers keep buying the garbage (solutions that don't work/never had any chance of working) they're pumping out, businesses don't have much incentive to create anything that works. It's appalling to me, how people can continue to spend so much money on gimmicks and appetite suppressants that clearly don't work.
- edraferi 11y agoThere is some very interesting work happening in this area. Specifically: how can we make money by preserving & building health? This is the foundation of the whole pay-for-outcome revolution pushed by the ACA. They want to pay doctors for keeping people healthy, not for the lengths they go to fix you when you're sick. Doing this requires more data than we have now and new market structures.
- ghshephard 11y agoDepends on how quickly you want to lose weight, and whether that's your only goal. If, as a 150 pound male, your RMR is about 1500 kcal/day, and you eat at least 1000 kcal/day (anything less probably isn't healthy - you do need to supply your body with nutrition, and also avoid going into starvation mode) - then you are running a 500kcal/day deficit - about 3500 kcal/week, or 1 pound of weight loss. If you want to lose any more than that, eating less, outside of a metabolic lab environment, is probably not going to be effective (you either have your RMR drop as your body goes into starvation mode, or you end up binge eating as your body reacts to the massive deficit of calories). This only allows for increased caloric output - and it's relatively simple to do 500 kcal/additional aerobic exercise/day - an hour of brisk walking, with maybe 30 minutes of stair climbing does the trick. This gets you from 1 pound of weight loss a week, to 2 pounds, and has the additional benefit of increasing your VO2 Max. This doesn't even touch on the importance of resistance strength training exercise, and how key that is to maintaining a healthy body while dropping weight - it's all to easy to turn into a lightweight flabby weak person by just not eating/exercising.
- alexc05 11y agoBased on all the other comments in the thread, I wonder if we updated to language we used if our goals would be clearer. Why not replace the phrase "lose weight" with "become slimmer"? We're not actually concerned with losing weight, but in fact with losing a specific TYPE of weight. It makes it a lot easier to come to terms with instructions like: "keep your insulin down and your fat cells will empty" The scale is an imperfect measure for slimness and lose weight is the wrong phrase to describe what we're generally trying for. Obviously these are sweeping generalizations, if you feel the need to poke holes, you're probably right. I'm going for brevity as opposed to a "think piece" - please feel free to take the comment with a grain of salt.
- thedz 11y agoI've found online reaction to this article quite interesting. Normally data and study minded folks bring out the "anecdotally, this doesn't seem true" responses, and people seem think the article is attacking exercise as a concept. It's not. It's saying that if a person's goal is to lose weight, then adjusting to a good diet is far more important than (a reasonable amount of) exercise. The article does not claim that exercise is harmful. In fact, it explicitly states that there are very many health reasons why exercise is important, and that exercise+diet is still better than diet alone. It also goes into the culture surrounding exercise, and how it tends to be misleading. The education in popular culture around exercising presents it as a magic pill, as being a major driving force behind weight loss. You see this on magazine covers and on tv, "belly fat exercises", "toning exercises", all sorts of exercises that serve to reinforce the idea that weight is primarily a result of physical activity rather than (for most people) food consumption. Ultimately though, I think the studies referenced back up the conclusion pretty well: weight loss effectiveness goes diet+exercise > diet > exercise, given standard amounts of each.
- hvoiiita 11y agoI think to accurately display the relative effectiveness of diet and exercise for weight loss is something like this: diet & exercise >> diet >>>>>>>> exercise I like this quote: "You work hard on that machine for an hour, and that work can be erased with five minutes of eating afterward"
- x0x0 11y agoeven easier (as weightlifters, powerlifters, bodybuilders all know): weight comes from your mouth, not from the gym abs are made in the kitchen 80% diet, 20% training
- 3pt14159 11y agoAbs are made in the kitchen, but as someone who went from 22% bodyfat to 11% they are pretty puny abs if you don't pair it with some pretty frequent exercise.
- slfnflctd 11y agoI've noticed in some cases that exercise can actually stave off hunger pangs - both while doing it and afterward for a while (you want water more than food) - and in this manner it can act as an appetite suppressant. As long as you ignore the body's impulse to eat more than usual when you finally do sit down for a meal, it can very much work in your favor. There's also a phenomenon people refer to as "shrinking stomach" (that I've observed first hand) where your body adapts to feeling more full on less food. I don't know if your stomach actually shrinks, but it feels like it. If you don't sufficiently often resist the urge to eat more than you need, your body will adapt to that intake level and there will most likely be a rough patch when you try to change the trend. I believe most people can push past this uncomfortable period and stop feeling deprived after a while.
- loxs 11y agoI have seen exactly the opposite effect on myself. After exercise I can (and really want) to eat the world.
- slfnflctd 11y agoCertainly both responses happen. I've noticed I tend to have a delayed reaction and get hungrier later, then eat a whole day's calories in a sitting without even trying. Regardless, there are all kinds of ways to help suppress appetite, and if exercise is having this affect for you, alternating with other methods can allow you to delay and/or reduce eating.
- EpicEng 11y ago>The spinning instructor was echoing a message we've been getting for years: As long as you get on that bike or treadmill, you can keep indulging — and still lose weight Who is saying this? Anyone who has spent an hour educating themselves on the subject knows that it's all about calories in v calories out. That can be accomplished via the gym and the kitchen, or the kitchen alone. Exercise provides additional benefits; higher caloric deficit assuming the same diet, muscle tone (appearance and burns more calories when you're doing nothing), and general cardiovascular health.
- minikites 11y ago>Surely I had earned an extra margarita. You can stop reading right there, that's the problem. You have to both eat well and exercise to lose weight. You don't get to eat extra things just because you exercised. Focus on two things: First, portion control. I know it's wasteful for the environment but I get the single serving versions of (healthy) things (e.g. pre-sliced cheese, single cups of greek yogurt instead of the big tub, etc) so you know exactly how much you're eating. Get a kitchen scale and some measuring cups for everything else, the odds are excellent that you're a crappy estimator. And bring your lunch to work. Second, blocking out time in your day for exercise, even if you don't work that hard. It's important to put on your workout clothes and at least go through the motions until it's an ingrained habit (1-3 months in my case but ymmv). Once it's an ingrained habit it's much easier to keep going. I start to feel gross and unclean if I go more than three or four days without some kind of strenuous exercise. It's a lot of work and it's very difficult, but it's not complicated. With these two things I have lost 70 pounds and kept it off for seven years.
- xyzzy4 11y agoExercise makes your face and overall aesthetics look better even if you don't lose weight.
- amorphid 11y agoWhen I started exercising, it made me hungrier. But my crappy eating habits made me sanna stuff my face with more crap. Developing better eating habits, then adding exercising, works better for me.
- cphoover 11y agoI guess people go to the gym for different reasons. Me personally I don't care about losing weight. I want to convert my body fat into muscle. If I don't eat a lot I can lose tons of weight, but I also look and feel weaker. So for me, exercise is very important.
- orky56 11y agoYou can't convert body fat into muscle. You can choose to cut (lose fat), bulk (gain muscle), or lean gain (gain muscle without gaining any/little fat). Unfortunately, it is frustrating and futile to do any of the above 3 at once.
- beloch 11y agoWhat other people see when they look at you is determined almost entirely by your diet. Nobody can see your muscles if they're buried under blubber. How you feel, on the other hand, is hugely impacted by your physical activities. Not only does exercise give you energy and focus, it has a huge impact on mood. Exercise is more effective at fighting depression than most medications. There's more to being healthy than being a healthy weight. It's probably better to be active and a little bit overweight than it is to be skinny and inactive. Note: I said a litle bit overweight, not obese. Health risks add up quickly if you're obese. Being cut and defined like a fitness magazine model is not realistic for most people and confers few benefits beyond aesthetics. Getting out of the obese range is realistic for most people and does confer statistically significant health benefits.
- Gibbon1 11y agoAn idea that carries some weight (heh) with me is that your weight consists of four 'compartments' Skeletal: Hard to argue that more skeletal mass is 'bad' Muscle: Also hard to argue more is bad Subcutaneous Fat: This is what people don't like. Visceral Fat: This is the stuff that kills you. If you're judging the progress of your cunning diet and exercise plan using a bathroom scale, you're going to be disappointed because muscle/skeletal mass increases.
- beloch 11y agoPeople who build up a lot of muscle sometimes fall into odd BMI classificiations. e.g. Phil Heath, Mr. Olympia winner of 2015, is 5'9" and 250 lbs at competition weight, which would classify him as severely obese (BMI 36.9), even though at that weight his body fat is probably close to the minimum a human can tolerate. For most people, there's simply no way to build up that amount of muscle without some form of chemical assistance (e.g. steroids). If your BMI falls into the obese range, it's exceedingly unlikely that you're just big-boned and muscular.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- marrington 11y agoAt the beginning of this year I was easily 100 lbs overweight. Decided it was all coming off this year. Started counting every calorie with myfitnesspal, later started looking at macros as well. Weight started coming off but it really accelerated when I got serious about exercising. Swimming a mile 3x per week. Weight training 3x per week, and I've been on the treadmill a lot in the evenings, probably another 15 miles per week fast walking. Down 60 lbs as of now and consistently losing around 3-4 pounds per week. It's hard to keep calories at less than 1800 per day with all the exercise, but it's just a hard psychological limit I've set for myself and the myfitnesspal app (and a kitchen scale) make it doable. It seems to me that the exercise has made me lose about 1-2 pounds per week more than just diet, but who knows. I miss pizza.
- narendra 11y agoNice job Mike!
- andreasklinger 11y agore pizza: try making pizza with shredded cauliflower as base. depending how much cheese you add it's should have controllable calories. it's nothing close to real pizza but maybe it works as placebo effect ;)
- marrington 11y agoYeah we do that about once a week and it helps.It's not really pizza but whatever it is is pretty good.
- heisnotanalien 11y agoYou can find 600 calorie pizzas easily enough, which fit into a 1800 calorie a day diet just fine.
- louismg 11y agoExcellent progress, Mike. My dad (an MD) always simplified weight loss as calories in minus calories out. Exercise accelerates the calorie burn (which you know) and moderating the intake is key. A couple years ago, I started using Fitbit and increased my exercise significantly. I lost 5 pounds a month for 6 straight months.
- jkljkljkljjj 11y agoOften ignored aspects to exercising as an obese person are that it plain sucks, is difficult, and likely to result in injury; it's harmful. Whenever I see obese people out running in public, obviously attempting to lose weight, these thoughts come to mind: 1. Impressive; that's a lot of hard work, not to mention embarrassing. Nobody fit I know could do the same carrying the equivalent weight in a backpack full of sand. 2. Doomed; you're killing yourself, imagine the long-term effects of such stress on your lower joints. 3. Futile; you're probably just going to eat too much of the wrong stuff now with all the appetite stimulated by the hard work, combined with the comfort sought in the immobilized and depressed days of joint and muscle pain. Lose the extra baggage before you start exercising! Your body will thank you. I used to weigh ~225# in my mid 20s. That weight was dropped to ~170# in under a year by simply removing sugars and refined/processed carbohydrates from my diet, which is a good weight for my build and height of 5'9". My experience was the desire to be active and exercise simply emerged once my weight was down, because doing physical things became fun and easy again, which also meant it was perfectly safe. In my mid 30s now and ever since that initial drop I've stayed around ~165#, but with more muscle now that I'm more physically active. I continue to diligently avoid sugars and processed carbs, processed foods in general really, and exercise every day for the fun and fitness, because it's easy and seems to combat many of the negative effects of aging. Exercise seems optional to me. If you eat correctly, without even exercising you'll have a normal weight, and preserve the ability to be physically active. If you eat poorly, you trap yourself, and the only way out of the trap is a slow process of eating correctly, the duration being proportional to how far you've let yourself go. It frustrates me how we've structured the food environment such that all the convenient/affordable options surrounding us are bad for us. It takes constant discipline to not eat poorly as a result. Good luck.
- tdyen 11y agoYou've hit the nail on the head with the exercise theories. Injuries can stop any program dead in its tracks. Avoiding injury is the key.
- rsp1984 11y ago> The calorie restriction groups lost more weight than the group the dieted and exercised. Yes, and anything else would have surprised me. Exercise leads to muscle build-up. Muscle is heavier than fat. The right metric to use here would have been body fat, not body weight. Similarly, the fitness goal should not be to "lose weight" but to get into good shape overall and feel healthy.
- agrona 11y agoThe article claims that >We have no control over our basal metabolic rate and then links to a page[1] that explains >Muscle cells require more energy to maintain than fat cells, so people with a higher muscle to fat ratio tend to have a higher BMR. and >Muscle tissue burns more calories than fat tissue, so increasing your muscle mass will help you lose weight. It doesn't seem to address this discrepancy, though (that by exercising to build muscle mass one can affect their BMR and thus the lion's share of the calories burned). [1] http://www.nhs.uk/Livewell/loseweight/Pages/how-can-I-speed-up-my-metabolism.aspx http://www.nhs.uk/Livewell/loseweight/Pages/how-can-I-speed-...
- Axsuul 11y agoI'm surprised the ketogenic diet is not mentioned at all. It's becoming clearer and clearer that obese people are likely much more insulin resistant than the rest of the population and as a result much more carbohydrate intolerant than the rest of the population. The insulin response these people are experiencing is causing them to store much more of the energy that they consume, especially if it contains fat. However, if you get rid of the carbs but still consume the fat, your body instead becomes adapted to burning ketones for fuel instead of glucose. So as a result, any fat that you may ingest while in ketosis gets burned for fuel instead of becoming plasma. Just saunder over to reddit.com/r/keto and you can already see the amazing transformations taking place.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- reddytowns 11y agoThe best way to lose weight is to fast. People are so accustomed to not going without food for a few hours it becomes a phobia. Our ancestors did not live like this. If you practice fasting long enough, you'll eventually get used to your stomach being empty, and it won't bother you anymore. Then it becomes trivial to lose weight. I eat only one meal a day, and I don't even notice it when its been over 24 hours I have gone without food. As an added benefit, I can have an absolute feast everyday, including a large dessert, without gaining any weight.
- webnrrd2k 11y agoThe best way to put this idea that I've heard is this: "you can't out run your fork"
- throwaway_xx9 11y agoNice to see an article that explains common-sense ideas with some effort to collect data. My theory about how the Biggest Loser contestants lose weight - get this - they're not allowed to snack during their all-day workouts.
- throwaway22342 11y agoI just got a new girlfriend who is vastly overweight. I forbid her to "diet" but she's still going to lose the weight, because we'll start lifting heavy weights together. The only thing she has to do is make sure she eats enough protein. She can eat whatever the fuck she wants. This is why this works. Here is what happens if you eat 10 donuts under scenario A (the author's) and scenario B (mine). So, the author's scenario (and by the way, from the author's lead[1] it totally sounds like she/they are people who have not figured it out. It's like following a Howto on how to compile your kernel, from someone who has spent years failing to compile a kernel.) So the author's scenario is restrict intake. [A] Okay, here's A. A is you restrict your intake to 1200 Calories per day. That's tough. We'll assume you succeed at following A. First of all you DEFINITELY will not squeeze enough protein in there. So your muscles atrophy. You will also be extremey lethargic. You'll feel like you're starving yourself: because you are. As a result, I guarantee your basal metabolism after all your muscles atrophy away will drop to like 1350 calories. You'll hardly move. But let's say you chug along at 1350 calories. That's a net loss of 150 calories per day. Now what happens if you cheat ONCE and eat ten donuts. Let's say you put on 452 calories * 10 = 4520 calories. Divide that by the net loss of 150 calories per day while you were stuffing yourself with salad and the very very occasional fun-sized Milky way bar! Okay, ready? 4520 / 150 = 30.13 days. In a SINGLE meal, or a single day, by buying a dozen donuts ONE TIME -- YOU CAN RUIN AN ENTIRE MONTH DIETING!!! You can make up for a whole month of dieting. But remember, you've lost all your muscles cuz' you've been starving yourself, and totally demotivated and not eating enough protein, your muscles are all but gone. So when you fall off the track just a tiny bit, watch out. Cuz you're still only burning that 1350-1500 calories per day from your slowed down metabolism. POOOF!! Can you hear our [A] subject puffing up!! IT'S LIKE AN AIRBAG INFLATING. And you've seen it happen to lots, and lots, of people. It just doesn't work. What the authors advocate is stupid and wrong, and even when it works, even when the subjects never, ever, cheat, they end up looking 'skinny fat'. Not attractive at all. Even if you win against all odds, you still lose and look like shit and feel like shit!!! Which is why I forbid my vastly overweight girlfriend (she weighs 22 pounds more than me despite being 5.2 inches shorter, and where I am well-built for my height) from dieting. She's not allowed to. It's the last thing I want her to do. Instead let's look at B. [B] lifts heavy weights and makes sure they eat enough protein. So subject B starts to work out. A lot. And still eat a lot, but specifically make sure they're eating enough protein. I'm not going to give you exact numbers because all I know is what works. Here's a typical daily plan for a muscle builder [2]. In my experience, if someone is going and lifting heavy weights, and building muscle, that just consumes so many calories. And it doesn't just consume calories - whereas in [A] the basal metabolism dropped to 1500 or lower calories, for the subjects in [B] every day just by existing and moving around living their life they're also burning 2200-2800+ Calories, or if they're a man, 2500-3000+ Calories. Then you have the actual work that you're putting INTO the lifting at the gym. I forbid people to do any cardio or yoga or stupid crap like that. Only lift heavy weights. No, they're not going to start looking like bodybuilders. They'll just start looking great. All the celebrities do it, via personal trainers. Okay, so to finish our mental exercise, now the subject in [B] is trying desperately to come up with 3500 Calories per day. They're working hard to get enough protein every day. Let's say they're eating, oh, I don't know, let's FUCKING DOUBLE the dieter's intake. We gave the dieter 1200 calories. We'll give B 2400 Calories. And then for shits and giggles they can eat a big mac every single day. Wait, no, let's give them 2. So we take 2400 calories, add 2 big macs[3] which is 257 calories * 2 = 514. They can eat two big macs every single day, or something else instead like chocolate or whatever the fuck they want to cheat every single day, day in, day out. I'm just using that as an example. So we add that to 2400, so 2400 + 514 = 2914. If they're lifting properly, that still comes 500 calories short of 3500. So they're STILL at a 500 calorie defecit, or, EVEN IF THEY'RE NOT THEY'RE RAISING THEIR BASAL METABOLISM. They can cut the two big macs out and some of the cereal and crap and lose the extra bulked-up weight (using all the muscles they now have) in short order. Okay, now we give [B] ten fucking donuts. What happens? Jack shit! They'll use that extra 4520 calories we calculated above in like 5 days. If they aren't having two big macs and a bunch of crap every day, then they could cheat and have ten extra donuts TWICE A FUCKING WEEK. You jealous, A-team? And what's more, if they succeed, they won't look like fucking shit! They'll look awesome. So, yeah, the author is completely mistaken. Oh, and in case you guys think this is theory - it's not. I've gotten my friends off of fat-logic, and into a fucking gym a few times a week, and in a couple of months saw all of their fat totally drop away and see them become a highly attractive person. I think my girlfriend is pretty attractive now, but she's overweight. She's not going to be in six months, and she doesn't have to give up shit to do it, just take half a fucking hour to exercise a few times a week and track her protein in her head to make sure she's getting enough. Articles like this are part of the problem, not the solution. Take it for me, because people following my advice have actually done it (I was never very overweight but enjoy working out.) Don't listen to people who don't know what works. Eat whatever you want, as long as you're getting enough protein, first, then maybe cut SOME of the crap (like 2-liter sodas that aren't diet and stuff like that) out. And go to the gym and get strong. You'll thank me later. (Well, unless I'm hellbanned for going against fatlogic. But the numbers and actual experience of tens of thousands of people who have gotten strong don't lie. The article does, by telling you not to exercise to lose weight.) [1] which I'll quote, you can judge for yourself: >"I'm going to make you work hard," a blonde and perfectly muscled fitness instructor screamed at me in a recent spinning class, "so you can have that >second drink at happy hour!" > >At the end of the 45-minute workout, my body was dripping with sweat. I felt like I had worked really, really hard. And according to my bike, I had >burned more than 700 calories. Surely I had earned an extra margarita. > >The spinning instructor was echoing a message we've been getting for years:" [2] http://dietcomedians.tumblr.com/post/86088489890/eat-massive-to-get-massive http://dietcomedians.tumblr.com/post/86088489890/eat-massive... [3] https://www.google.com/search?q=big+mac+calories https://www.google.com/search?q=big+mac+calories
- mixmastamyk 11y agotl;dr: Why you shouldn't use exercise as an excuse to overeat, it doesn't burn enough calories.
- tommynicholas 11y agoOf course this article focuses on cardio. It's almost become conventional fitness wisdom that cardio will not help you lose weight. Weight lifting will also not help you lose "weight" but it will help you lose fat. Diet #1, lifestyle #2, weight lifting #3 (optional), cardio #infinity
- ape4 11y agoI like the iterative method. Everyday look at a scale. If your weight has gone up, you did something bad the day before... don't do that again.
- amckenna 11y agoAs someone who has tracked their weight on a daily basis for the better part of 8 months, I wouldn't suggest doing that alone. Your weight will fluctuate by a few pounds day to day and sometimes will trend up for a few days, then down for a few. What time of day you weight yourself and factors like your hydration level will play a part. What I did was weigh myself every morning and record my weight and body fat %. Then calculate a rolling 10 day average. That was nice because if my weight went up for a day or two but overall was trending downwards it was visible. Graphing it and watching the graph go downwards was very motivating.
- kazinator 11y agoExercise didn't work for me until I stuck with it consistently, and progressively. The problem is that what doesn't work is "strawman exercise": for instance, the kind of exercise that a sedentary volunteer test subject is able to handle in some study. Before exercise works for fat loss, you have to train up to the intensity and volume that is required. That takes months. Consistent months during which you not only don't give up, but pile on the challenges. If you quit, you lose your progress and slide back to the start. You can't measure exercise just by the time put in and the theoretical calories, by the way. There is a quality component to it. Another thing is that once you have a decently low body fat, the remaining areas where fat accumulates on your body will show to be "exercise resistant". It's very hard to get rid of that centimeter of fat from the back of your thigh, calves, upper back and arms, or central abs. Or that pesky "love handle" area. That, I can attest, either can't be done with exercise, or requires exercise to be a full time job. But that's not what this article is about; the claim is that exercise isn't effective against obesity.
- spinlock 11y agoThe other thing that the article doesn't address is how much weight you gain in muscle when you exercise. When I go from out-of-shape to back-in-shape, I know that I've increased my muscle mass as well as loosing fat. That doesn't show on the scale but it definitely is what I'm going for. Also, increasing your muscle is going to increase your resting metabolic rate. So, as you exercise and get stronger, you'll burn more calories while resting. (this probably only holds for men who build muscle when they work out. if you're a marathon runner who's rail thin, I don't think you'll burn much fat at all while resting.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- CryoLogic 11y agoThe title to this article is very manipulative and misleading. Weight loss seems to be a mysterious science to the everyday man and woman, but is well known by most top athletes and has been for many years. It is simple chemistry. The calories you eat are stored in fat, which is comprised of O, H and C. Roughly ~3500 calories will become one pound of bodyfat. By this logic, yes you can eat less calories and lose weight. If you are burning 2500 calories per day, and you opt to eat only 2000 calories per day you should lose aprox. 1 lb of body fat per week (500 * 7 = 3500). On the other hand, exercise is very important in weight loss. Muscle mass is expensive to maintain, and every lb of muscle mass can take 30-50 cals per day just to maintain. This increases your daily calories burned, allowing you to eat more food w/o weight gain or keep the same food and lose weight. Additionally, when you exercise and convert the fat to energy the fat is released in various forms of O, H and C. Most of it is breathed out, and some comes out in liquid form. This is literally weight you are losing. Each atom has a molecular weight, be it O, H or C. And if you want to do the math you can figure out how much weight you are losing per exercise per hour. The reason some people believe low carb diets are the best for weight loss, is directly tied to exercise. Quickly avail. energy known as glycogen is stored in your muscles and used up before fat. It is created from carbohydrates. Without glycogen in your muscles, you will burn fat first.
- eloff 11y agoWhile I appreciate the logic behind this, and agree in principle, it's an overly simplistic picture. If you decrease your calorie intake your body compensates by lowering your metabolism. Between this and the decreased metabolic burden of carrying less fat and muscle, this is why many dieters find that their weight loss plateaus after a while of making progress. As far as low-carb diets in particular, there are also additional factors. If you get the carbs down under about 20 carbs a day you can go into ketosis, which is a wasteful metabolism. You literally piss away some 10-20% of your calories. But the biggest benefit of low-carb is you don't have those blasted carbs (and especially sugar!) adding calories to your diet without triggering the satiated response in your brain - you just eat less on a low-carb diet, without feeling hungry.
- jdminhbg 11y ago> It is simple chemistry. The calories you eat are stored in fat This is where you made a huge, unsupported-by-science leap.
- dragonwriter 11y agoYou shouldn't exercise to lose weight, because for most people you shouldn't be aiming primarily to lose weight; weight loss should be a component of the broader goal of improving overall health. For which you probably should exercise, regardless of whether it's optimal for the narrower goal of weight loss.
- boulos 11y agoAnytime this comes up in conversation, I enjoy pointing people to John Walker's Hacker's Diet (https://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/ https://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/). I enjoy the bits of Autodesk trivia he tossed in as well (he was a co-founder and wrote much of AutoCAD, as he then thinks "So if I can do that, why can't I learn to lose weight?"). The most accurate critique of any of these "calories in minus calories out" arguments is that those vary from person to person and from food to food. So if you do have a particularly hard time losing (or gaining!) weight, it might be a bit of genetic variation.
- formula_ninguna 11y agoPeople get fat not because they eat too much. But because they eat junk food. That's it. The amount of calories is irrelavant here. If you want to be a good shape, eat fruit. Without GMO and hemicals. That's simple. Yet most people go to McDonalds, drink Coca-Cola, eat different kinds of shit and wonder "What should I do to lose weight? Hmmmm, maybe I should work out more?"
- ryao 11y agoI feel that those who think that exercise is a solution for weightloss either have an absurdly good metabolic rate or have an unrealistic view of how much time people can devote to exercise. I had tried to lose some weight a few years ago and everything O tried had failed, including exercise. At one point, I purchased a digital scale and performed multiple measurements a day of my weight. They confirmed that additional exercise (e.g. walking a few miles) had negligible impact on my weight. Afterward, I decided to redesign my diet for weight loss. I was able to lose 50 lbs in roughly 3 months by that alone. The idea was that my body had an abundance of energy such that all I needed were nutrients to keep my body going and a certain volume in my stomach to trick it into signaling my brain that I was eating sufficiently. I ended up consuming a multivitamin pill, egg whites, tofu, brocolli and fruits each day for the better part of those 3 months. I calculated that doing that lowered my daily caloric intake 800 calories a day. Sadly, I ended up regaining about 30 of them after pressure from certain relatives to eat more got to the point where being fatter was preferable to having to deal with it. The entire time, I had been considered overweight to obese by my BMI so the pressure to eat was in no way because I had gone overboard, although I had come within 5 lbs of attaining a "healthy" BMI before I regained some of the weight. My mistake was switching to Soylent after deciding that I did not want to lose weight so quickly. The idea that I was not eating food triggered my relatives' "lets try to feed him" reaction. Lately, I have started to try doing this again by consuming a daily multivitamin pill, water, spinach, "beyond meat" fruits and a daily bag or two of popcorn (to clear the pantry). The popcorn will be eliminated as soon as I have finished the remaining supply, but even eating the popcorn, I am losing weight by doing this, although it is definitely not as fast as it would be had I not decided to finish off that popcorn. The first time that I lost weight, I had a relative who attended weight watchers. The people at weight watchers were horrified when told how quickly I managed to do it and talked about studies about the dangers of rapid weight loss. My feeling was that they did not want to lose a source of revenue and that being as fat was worse for me. In hindsight, I think that they would have been right had I been anywhere close to a healthy weight at the time as what should matter is the percentage of weight lost rather than the raw numbers. The closer that I approached a "healthy" weight, the slower my weight loss became and when I was within 5 pounds of it, I had started to feel somewhat light headed, which is when I decided to try lose by weight more slowly rather than force it through a large deficit in my daily caloric intake.
- jsonmez 11y agoBiggest flaw in article: assuming all "weight" is fat.
- lkiernan 11y agoActually you'll lose muscle weight by cutting calories just fine
- fortyseven 11y agoAs a fatass who walks 2 to 3 miles a day for exercise, and is seeing little in the way of progress, I know this to be true. I know what must be done, but man, it's hard to break bad food habits.
- garyrob 11y agoFrom the article: "If a hypothetical 200-pound man added 60 minutes of medium intensity running four days per week while keeping his calorie intake the same, and he did this for 30 days, he'd lose five pounds. 'If this person decided to increase food intake or relax more to recover from the added exercise, then even less weight would be lost,' Hall added. (More on these 'compensatory mechanisms' later.) So if one is overweight or obese, and presumably trying to lose dozens of pounds, it would take an incredible amount of time, will, and effort to make a real impact through exercise.” OK. I exercise more than that every month and have for years. It's painless to do because it's the only time I spend watching TV shows like Game Of Thrones--I look forward to my exercise sessions. So, this article is telling me that (unless I exhibit compensatory mechanisms' such as eating more than I do), and if I started at 200 lbs, I'd lose 5 lbs a month, just doing what I actually want to do (because I enjoy watching entertaining TV shows like GoT). I'd go from 200 lbs to not being overweight in less than a year. The article's take on this is "it would take an incredible amount of time , will, and effort to make a real impact through exercise". That seems like an incredible amount of negative spin the authors are trying to put on it. To me, it sounds like a fantastic deal. And one I've taken advantage of. My own weight loss path is pretty complicated, but I was at 225 and now my weight stays between 173 and 183, generally up and down depending on life events and whether I have temporarily keep more sodas in the fridge than I normally do. EDIT: I just want to emphasize that the key for me is that I enjoy my exercise sessions, because I look forward to watching the most entertaining TV produced in the English language. So it takes almost no will power or effort. It's a matter of choosing not to watch that TV when not exercising, which gets to be a habit--similar to not picking up an apple pie every time I go to the grocery store so there's no such pie sitting around the house. If if DID take willpower and effort to do that exercise, I probably wouldn't do it! It helps enormously that I have an elliptical trainer in the house. But that's a small investment compared to the health benefits--not just weight loss and maintenance, but the fact that exercising is great for the brain, and many other benefits as well, including a reduction in cancer risk. EDIT 2: I don't even know if I'd find that TV all that enjoyable if I wasn't exercising. I can imagining thinking "why am I wasting this time watching this crap when I could be doing something useful??" But when exercising, there are so many benefits that I give myself total permission to watch it, and I do enjoy it!
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 11y agoI started working out heavily to lose weight, but also to "feel better." I succeeded at both points, but it took an extremely long time to hit my goal weight. Looking back, it's clear I was eating too much to compensate for the additional work I was doing. I gained half of that weight that I lost back pretty quick because I couldn't keep up the strenuous exercise routine. So, the next time I instead focused on my eating habits and skipped formal exercise entirely (mostly just went for walks instead). I had much more consistent and predictable weight loss week-over-week and now I'm about to surpass the goal I had the first time I tried in 1/3 of the time. It really came down to small portions -- I didn't have to give up many types of food, I just didn't eat nearly as much of it as I would have in the past. This echoes experiences from people I know. They start out with a strenuous exercise routine and it's fun in the beginning to push yourself, but most people can't sustain it. Or they get injured and that sets them down a path of being lazy and gaining the weight back.
- ryanpardieck 11y agoI've lost over 130 pounds in the last two years and I deliberately avoided high intensity exercise during that time. I find it very hard to moderate my hunger when doing regular high-intensity exercise. I would take long, slow walks a few times a week, and would rarely feel hungry while maintaining a very high daily caloric deficit. (In fact, I often felt quite full. I drank beer frequently, indulged in a pint of Ben and Jerrys a few times a month, ate out a lot, etc.) In my experience it's most important to find a way to eat at a caloric deficit that feels natural, do-able, and fun. Even rapid weight loss takes a very long time, so you need to build it into your lifestyle. If you're like me and you like beer, ice cream, and dining out, then it's mainly a matter of portion control. I ate what I liked, but I learned to moderate portions and listen to my body. I ate until I was no longer hungry, and then no more.
- BioMeditate 11y ago"Despite going from being mostly sedentary to spending a couple of hours exercising almost every day, the participants only lost about 11 pounds on average" I would love to lose 11 lbs
- BioMeditate 11y ago"Despite going from being mostly sedentary to spending a couple of hours exercising almost every day, the participants only lost about 11 pounds on average" I would love to lose 11 lbs